Seohyun was singing her part of "my heart" with Taeyeon's vocals. That is what they do for the actual song itself. "My heart" part is actually harmonized with a higher key from Taeyeon and a lower key from Seohyun, and this is why Seohyun sang the note with Taeyeon for their US show performance.
nope, this hapenned because they didnt have time to change the choreo and this is a "lipsync" performance Seohyun can do all Taeyeon lines if they give to her a mic
LOL.. They just danced at the played CD. Maybe that's why Jess looked so bored dancing. Seems they are just invited to danced or any just to be there. And while Hyo slipped, Sooyoong saw it then looked at Yuri. Yuri saw it then looked at Soo. They laughed and look down. Hahaha. Funny. All in all they enjoyed. But I really miss Taeng. Power of 9!
I used to think that nine as a group is a large number..But after seeing two missing members it looks so odd and empty..I really hope Girls' Generation will stay together forever!!!..They are the best!!!:))
@xrawrstephanix they lipsynced for all of the songs and for Taeyeon and Yoona's parts. Just saying :p Tiffany could have easily done Yoona's part like last time and I'm pretty sure Jessica or Seohyun can hit Taeyeon's high notes. It's just easier if they lipsync when 2 people are missing so yeah.
A bit late on this, but you can find a few videos where Taeyeon was missing and Jessica covered her part. Most of those were from early in their career. Neither one is missing from shows a lot.
Aww... I still remember when I discuss what'll happend if Taeyeon absent n I suprised that it happened! 2 mmber absent so d'line was very not complete, I very sad about that, they tried hard to do the best but~(speechless) I hope they'll be complete in every live perform, n what I imagined before come true, no one can replaced Taeyeon part coz it is very hard even Jessica couldn't replace it, Seohyun just lypsinc-ed Taeyeon part SNSD, HWAITING !!! We always support u :D
You guys should understand that there are 9 of them, minus 2, there are 7. The sound systems in that venue probably can't support them all so only selective few can sing live and the rest needs to lip sync. And it also depends on the performance fee that the organizer is paying, they sometimes just paying for the artistes to be present and do a simple show so it will come to an agreement that they just need to lipsync. Understand the situation before complaining please.
I hate it when there are missing members and they don't put them live... Cause anyone who knows them will see those were not Tiffany and Seobaby singing...=/
its awkward without the 2 members present, but then again the girls always make do and manage to put on a great show. Yoona was probably filming love rain, but where's Taeyeon, does anybody know? Was it because of her toe?
when did they subsitute for Taeyeon in The Boys? never right? but they did in Mr. Taxi because the note is easier to reach. not in The Boys because it's too high for the other members.
@girlsgeneration91 Its always a mess when there are members missing because SNSD has formations and are synchronized in their dance. Every time a member is missing, they have had to practice slightly different formations and movements than before compared with all 9. Makes them a bit more sloppy since they have to learn it quickly and also because they know The Boys movement by repetition now, even that slight change is hard to unlearn, especially when it's a temporary change.
when hyo slipped....i am pretty sure yuri also had a tiny mistake....well it was not her fault at all...it was because of those tiles i gess....i love how yuri and hyo are totally in sync
@tentenyoung There are many problem if they cant sing live at some stage. May be they get cold or something. SM will never them sing live if they are sick and Sone will agree with SM,too :)
so the best option for them to do is to lip sync since taeyeon was not present and nobody can hit her high notes.. it's awkward to hear taeyeon and yoona's voice sung by seohyun and fany. lol. :)
lol it's always a clusterfuck when two or more members are missing. it's never this bad when only one is missing. many mistakes are made but it's nice that they're able to laugh at themselves. they know it's a mess.
I'm pretty sure they were lonely that two of their members wasn't able to perform with them. And the reason that stage is so empty and messy because the dance is meant for nine. SNSD Forever9
Their performance look so poor because of their dance is for 9 members. I think singing part is not so effect. But when they are dancing. That is a really problem. They cannot dance so well. They got a lot of mistake during their performance. That is my idea !
What were they doing? It's just the worst performance ever! I know Taeyeon's parts are always difficult, but she's not the only vocalist of this group. The others were there, weren't they? Why didn't they try to cover her parts? And Yoona's parts weren't difficult at all. They didn't even change the dance, but just leave Taeyeon and Yoona's positions empty. Could they respect the audiences a bit more? I don't understand why they can be called the national girl group when they are too unprofessional like that!
You act like they have control over who gets to sing? It’s definitely the company who decided to do this. They have covered both Taeyeon and Yoona before. Don’t act like idols have his type of freedom. They are professionals and they have absolutely earned the title of nations girl group.
Seohyun was singing her part of "my heart" with Taeyeon's vocals. That is what they do for the actual song itself. "My heart" part is actually harmonized with a higher key from Taeyeon and a lower key from Seohyun, and this is why Seohyun sang the note with Taeyeon for their US show performance.
This video show me Taeyeon is very important..
All
duh, she's the main vocalist
after watching this, i find that no one can replace TaeYeon
This show makes me know that no one can replace Taeyeon.
nope, this hapenned because they didnt have time to change the choreo and this is a "lipsync" performance
Seohyun can do all Taeyeon lines if they give to her a mic
It just ...-.-
I just really want to hear Seohyun sing's Taeyeon's part ..
Seohyun's Immitate For Taeyeon Is Good :)
LOL.. They just danced at the played CD. Maybe that's why Jess looked so bored dancing. Seems they are just invited to danced or any just to be there. And while Hyo slipped, Sooyoong saw it then looked at Yuri. Yuri saw it then looked at Soo. They laughed and look down. Hahaha. Funny. All in all they enjoyed. But I really miss Taeng. Power of 9!
they can't sing live because nobody can't sing taeyeon part.BUT I STILL LOVE SNSD AND LOVE TAEYEON
Was Seohyun singing at 3:18 like how she sang with Taeyeon in their performances in US?
Haha , Seohyun sing with Taeyeon's vocal :)) and Tiffany is Yoona's vocal :)) 2:51 My dance queen :))
I used to think that nine as a group is a large number..But after seeing two missing members it looks so odd and empty..I really hope Girls' Generation will stay together forever!!!..They are the best!!!:))
@xrawrstephanix they lipsynced for all of the songs and for Taeyeon and Yoona's parts. Just saying :p Tiffany could have easily done Yoona's part like last time and I'm pretty sure Jessica or Seohyun can hit Taeyeon's high notes. It's just easier if they lipsync when 2 people are missing so yeah.
yoona coming back from japan and taeyeon hurt her feet ;) i guess
yoona was busy while Taeyeon's toe was injured.
I want to see jessica try taeyeon part 😁 hmm i thought she can do it by her style 😍
No, in this song jessica has many part and also has high note
A bit late on this, but you can find a few videos where Taeyeon was missing and Jessica covered her part. Most of those were from early in their career. Neither one is missing from shows a lot.
lol hyoyeon nearly slipped so cute..yuri and sooyoung were laughing.
i love the performances that just fall apart, it reminds me that they're human.
Aww...
I still remember when I discuss what'll happend if Taeyeon absent n I suprised that it happened! 2 mmber absent so d'line was very not complete, I very sad about that, they tried hard to do the best but~(speechless) I hope they'll be complete in every live perform, n what I imagined before come true, no one can replaced Taeyeon part coz it is very hard even Jessica couldn't replace it, Seohyun just lypsinc-ed Taeyeon part
SNSD, HWAITING !!!
We always support u :D
You guys should understand that there are 9 of them, minus 2, there are 7. The sound systems in that venue probably can't support them all so only selective few can sing live and the rest needs to lip sync. And it also depends on the performance fee that the organizer is paying, they sometimes just paying for the artistes to be present and do a simple show so it will come to an agreement that they just need to lipsync.
Understand the situation before complaining please.
I Think they do best
everytime when they played cd for the performance, i felt that they were embarrassed and feeling sorry to fans who cheered them... poor SNSD
WTF HK newspapers reported Hyo's slip at 2:52 as if it was some real serious mistake... O.o
"Its so empty without 9 ><
LOL @ SooRi laughing at Hyo's slip ..
and Sooyoung's mistake at the end of the video . LOL ..
I want to see Taeyeon😔
Where is she...????
She almost SLIPPED! *O*
I think in 'my heart' part seohyun did it. but not high as taeyeon did. Seohyun jjang!!
Taruna Kusuma nope actually she didn't do it, watch the seo fancam you can hear clearly, she was just cutely imitating.
Although they did very well with just 7 of them, But, It won't reach perfect without the other 2. The power of 9. *PERFECT*
OMG , when Hyo slip that time she looks so cute ^^ Sooyoung, yul and Sunny were laughing at her. Aigoo ~ ;D
@taeyeonlove09 Taeyeon hurt her toe while MCing the 1st Gaon Chart KPop Awards so she will be unable to perform for a while.
WHERE MY TAE???I MISS HER SO MUCH
Oh good lord, 7 members? it looks all wrong, I feel all weird and stuff watching it. I thought 8 was bad, damn ...
the best part is that they really enjoyed hahahaha
aaaccckkk hyo slipped! SooRi laughs and Jess is a lazy girl at the back :)) ccccccuuuuuttteeee!!! thanks for all the efforts girls! OT9!
@kimpaabo yeah. its because of her injury. still recovering. she was present though on the j.estina fansign event
it's so lonely when they lack two members.
Wahh so this happens when yoona the center and tayeon the leader is not here
I think taeyeon hurt her toe or something about her foot so she can't perform this stage
im just wondering if taeyeon wasnt there and theyre singing live who's taking her part?
I hate it when there are missing members and they don't put them live... Cause anyone who knows them will see those were not Tiffany and Seobaby singing...=/
My dancing queen has a unique adlibs
The stage is so empty without 2 members :((
tetap keren? gak kelihatan kosong...
its awkward without the 2 members present, but then again the girls always make do and manage to put on a great show. Yoona was probably filming love rain, but where's Taeyeon, does anybody know? Was it because of her toe?
Hyo slipped! :O They did so well, even with just seven girls :P
when did they subsitute for Taeyeon in The Boys? never right? but they did in Mr. Taxi because the note is easier to reach. not in The Boys because it's too high for the other members.
@TaeNyJeTi I know that taeyeon is there but maybe she's at the back and sing her part . but seohyun and tiffany is lip syncing it.
It's incomplete with only 7 of them.
Hyoyeon almost fall down when her main part
so cute haha lol
Watch the Actual Performance. :) Taeyeon's there.
I just love Lazy Sica :D
r they sing live? it like they r lipsuyn
@girlsgeneration91 Its always a mess when there are members missing because SNSD has formations and are synchronized in their dance. Every time a member is missing, they have had to practice slightly different formations and movements than before compared with all 9. Makes them a bit more sloppy since they have to learn it quickly and also because they know The Boys movement by repetition now, even that slight change is hard to unlearn, especially when it's a temporary change.
when hyo slipped....i am pretty sure yuri also had a tiny mistake....well it was not her fault at all...it was because of those tiles i gess....i love how yuri and hyo are totally in sync
you can see two members bump at left of the video im not a big snsd fan but it sure does look empty ):
why taeyeon and yoona not perform??
@eggshapedcarrot The funny part is the immediate reaction from SY and yuri xD
@tentenyoung There are many problem if they cant sing live at some stage. May be they get cold or something. SM will never them sing live if they are sick and Sone will agree with SM,too :)
i think this is just a dress rehersal..
huhu,where my tae???
YURI ^^
so the best option for them to do is to lip sync since taeyeon was not present and nobody can hit her high notes.. it's awkward to hear taeyeon and yoona's voice sung by seohyun and fany. lol. :)
i miss the two members without SNSD members are lost
LOL Hyoyeon @ 2:52 :))
they look funny ^^
@omg11118 were*
lol it's always a clusterfuck when two or more members are missing. it's never this bad when only one is missing. many mistakes are made but it's nice that they're able to laugh at themselves. they know it's a mess.
lol i love it when the girls hav fun during stage performances...at 01:20 Hyoyeon and Sunny r just jokin around =)
Jessica's not even trying.
why ?
I'm pretty sure they were lonely that two of their members wasn't able to perform with them.
And the reason that stage is so empty and messy because the dance is meant for nine.
SNSD Forever9
They look like a missing puzzle .
they lip synced because none of them could do Taeyeon's "my heaaaart" :p it's true. or else they would've subsituted for her.
it just aint that powerful without taeyeon :(
they was like no mood to dance... pity snsd without taeyeon... T.T
the end.. sooyoung mistake xD
3:09 ñelsññsñeñeñ
i am a sone. but this performance is disappointing. the girls are gorgeous but somethings are missing
livesyn
lipsycn?? not a poblem..still same
hyoyeon slipped
they must've be very tired from all works they've done and you still want to them to sing live? silly!
Dios! what happend with them! :( I love them but i have to admit that this is the worst perfomance ever :''(
they look very "DOWN"..... T.T
Their performance look so poor because of their dance is for 9 members. I think singing part is not so effect. But when they are dancing. That is a really problem. They cannot dance so well. They got a lot of mistake during their performance. That is my idea !
con ganas de llorar por no ver a taeyeon
lipsync ....
Bego
Djd
that looks and sounds awful :(
What were they doing? It's just the worst performance ever!
I know Taeyeon's parts are always difficult, but she's not the only vocalist of this group. The others were there, weren't they? Why didn't they try to cover her parts? And Yoona's parts weren't difficult at all. They didn't even change the dance, but just leave Taeyeon and Yoona's positions empty. Could they respect the audiences a bit more?
I don't understand why they can be called the national girl group when they are too unprofessional like that!
You act like they have control over who gets to sing? It’s definitely the company who decided to do this. They have covered both Taeyeon and Yoona before. Don’t act like idols have his type of freedom. They are professionals and they have absolutely earned the title of nations girl group.
I think in 'my heart' part seohyun did it. but not high as taeyeon did. Seohyun jjang!!