Lol I probably should havemade myself more clear. I meant, because of the non lip sync rule on Music Core, it is making companies/artists want to actually perform more without lip syncing. Before i would find maybe find one performance where they would actually sing and now I am finding more after that rule. I mean every performance i watched from Inkigayo, the performers have been singing live.
Strangely the song isn't a difficult song and the dance isn't difficult either but when you put them together... Applause. Damn jumping and dancing, rapping and singing. Especially its pretty fast and they use the stage well. Not some slow movements or just hand movement. Also I'm not sure if its the mic for this stage or they were just having an off performance. Irene did better in this one then in the music core live. Joy did good also. I know seulgi and Wendy has the more powerful vocals and are really amazing singer but one point seulgi was shaky (still love her tho) and in Wendy note her voice sort of strained but its not that noticeable cause the music louder then the mic sort of. But still red velvet hwaiting! I'm such a fan of SM groups. Loool
Well, EXO and SNSD can do well as well. Maybe not every single member, but they have pretty good singers as well. They just hardly show it for whatever reason.
I was just really mesmerized by Wendy's high notes.. She really hit it hard and solid! I had a feeling that she'll be my bias.. But now is for sure! Irene and Seulgi made it hard for me to choose though..
In my opinion, seulgi is the real deal for RV. I mean, awesome vocals(even in live performances), awesome dancer, killer eye smile, not to mention she really is gorgeous? *dies* Pretty or not, for me she's the best in RV (talent wise). to which is why she's my bias.
exactly! and I'm pretty sure she's going to be in some variety show soon with joy(resident choding for RV) ^^. she knows how to talk and react in shows just like what she did in the radio program they a few days ago.
a one of a kind group, to follow Red Velvet's journey as a fan has had it's up and downs but seeing how far each member has come had make it worth it. Happiness!
I usually don't like the maknaes as much because I feel like they're way too overplayed just because they're the youngest but Joy has absolutely captured my heart. Everything from her smile to her voice to her natural bounce with every dance move. Perfect maknae! Joy you're my bias! Love Seulgi as well, she's got a lot of talent!♥ Red Velvet Fighting!
ACCURATE ~~ Honestly, Irene unnie is genuinely beautiful and deserves all the recognition she gets, but Joy is something else. Her face itself radiates joy (pun intended) and I just feel like she'd be great as the visual of RV. Her beauty is natural as well as it is her aegyo. She's just beautiful.
ThisKpopGuy I didn't think they pulled off anything in 'Be Natural'. I honestly, quit halfway through that video... :/ Not that they didn't pull off the look, but it was around the time Mr Mr came out - so I was bored with the whole "I can be sexy with a suit on" deal. Automatic was really good though - I'll give them cred for that one lmfao :)
セーラーグール / Sailor Ghoul I don't think they were trying to be sexy with their looks, more like the choreo was trying to be sexy. Lmao. Be Natural is way more calmer than Happiness so I mean..
Joy is probably the most popular member according to the fanchants omg her screams are so much louder than the other girls! And she wasn't even promoted haha.
I really believe that Joy is the most visual of all, Irene has Korean standards and she is very beautiful! but for me, in my perspective, Joy is the visual one.
Come on you guys lets be real here. There is no such thing as a "Bias" when it comes to Red Velvet. Thats why I barely choose biases now everyone of them slays my life equally 😂😱💕
I love that part at 0:22 soo much! And I fell in love with Joy the first time I saw her. How can someone be so angelic???!!!! I would seriously do anything to marry someone like her:)
It seems like the smaller groups in SM like TVXQ, SHINee, and F(x) are better live than the bigger groups and RV are already good, once time passes they will be just as good.
This is where the time they were still called rookies but their stability on live perfs were on point even when you removed the MR. Then there's this group called TWICE which is very popular but they are a group of visuals and their stability is so not good. I've listened to their MR Removed (twice's) but its really not good
Yeah :/ I'm guessing its because of SIXTEEN that they were introduced to the audience before hand and the members are the ones chosen by the audience. Not hating on Twice or anything (cause I'm an once) their choreography is easier than RV where they had to jump and they never even stopped moving when they were singing their lines where as Twice is standing in one place while singing yet their voices are still not stable. JYP should've trained them more even Chaeyoung the rapper sings better than many of the members.. If I were to pick the most stablest it would be Jeongyeon, Jihyo and Nayeon could barely reach the notes in Cheer Up. Its like why did they give them those parts if they cannot reach it?...
Развлечения
![Felix "Unfair" | [Stray Kids : SKZ-PLAYER]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/Oswujxm2Ag0/mqdefault.jpg)
who miss this era where all the girls are loved by their stylists?
We seriously need to bring the stylist for this era back. lmao.
Ikr
Right
Bless this non lipsync rule, because i'm actually getting some performances worth watching
Inkigayo hasn't that rule...is Music Core.
Inkigayo doesn't have a no lip-sync rule, only Music Core has it.
Actually on inkigayo the agency/promotion manager is in charge of if they lipsynch or not. So they chose to sing cause they know they can :D
Lol I probably should havemade myself more clear. I meant, because of the non lip sync rule on Music Core, it is making companies/artists want to actually perform more without lip syncing. Before i would find maybe find one performance where they would actually sing and now I am finding more after that rule. I mean every performance i watched from Inkigayo, the performers have been singing live.
Actually Red Velvet never done a lipsync live performances but sure putting playback are always.
Who miss the happiness era?
ME! T_T
Me 😭
me !!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
Meeeee! I miss this eraaaaa 😭💖💖💖 The reason why i love red velvet and this song of rv (since it's their debut song. Lol) is my first love.
잔인할 정도로 쌩라이브인데 이걸 저춤에 소화하네 ㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋ미친거아니냐고
I keep forgetting this is a rookie group.. Damn, so much potential.
compare this rookie group to MAMAMOO who is also a rookie group and you will see the difference.
lichee32 maybe mamamooo is also great as a rookie and so is Red Velvet too, what's the point of comparing each group?
lichee32 What are you trying to say? Mama moo are bad? They are great just like Red Velvet.
Raymond Liang yep look where they are now
@@lichee32 I dare you to say that now xD
OMG! Joy owned the stage!!! How can she be cute at the same time beautiful?!! I really like her!!!
Wendy and that high note... Oh my god O.O I freaking love this group
Ikr! She awesome, Wendy is like my fave
her high note is good or ? haah to me its prefect
she is my bias haha
+yehet trashaf if you like her high note in this...you should see her singing halo pre debut, her notes are perfect
Joy looks like Kim Yoojung the child actress! She's so pretty!
IKR. i thought the exact same thing. She's like an older version of her. Since KIm Yoojung looks like sulli, she looks like sulli too :')
Jessica Wu IKNOWW omg so jealous haha they're all so pretty
omg! i thought the same when i saw her, i was like, where did i see you? lmao. Finally, i read that someone thought like i did!~
Hahaha kim yoo jung is my favorite chil actress she so similar to joy
And joy is also similar to Suzy :))
Agreed
Joy is so popular. A lot of fan girls.
The more I see Seulgi, the more I like her.
i like camera angle + switching + lighting = so fun
HAPPINESS!
Joy got so many screams
Joy's so pretty today
Agree.
Joy is gorgeous on the daily basis though.
kaille seo i second that.
Her killer eye smile.. Too good to be missed!
Joy ♥♥ and she dances and sing very well also live singing se is great!!
Omg my video adjusted itself to HD when Wendy started singing "let it shine on me"
Feels hahahahaha 😂😂
XD
LOL! Wendy is in the house 😎😎
Lol mine buffered. Maybe it's because of my horrible internet connection or it just couldn't handle Wendy's vocals
Joy and Wendy they always catch my eye joy seems so cheerful and Wendy her voice
My bias is Seulgi, she's so pretty and her vocals are so stable and pretty too lol
Me too! I love the sound of her voice and she is so stable on stage. I always wonder why she wasn't given more lines in this song
Me too she is amazing
She is amazing!
She didn't seem to get much screen time though :(
Yaaay Seulgi bias ^.^ I think she's an all rounder , vocals , visual and good at dancing ^.^
Strangely the song isn't a difficult song and the dance isn't difficult either but when you put them together... Applause. Damn jumping and dancing, rapping and singing. Especially its pretty fast and they use the stage well. Not some slow movements or just hand movement. Also I'm not sure if its the mic for this stage or they were just having an off performance. Irene did better in this one then in the music core live. Joy did good also. I know seulgi and Wendy has the more powerful vocals and are really amazing singer but one point seulgi was shaky (still love her tho) and in Wendy note her voice sort of strained but its not that noticeable cause the music louder then the mic sort of. But still red velvet hwaiting! I'm such a fan of SM groups. Loool
(Y)
Wendy kills it every time
Joy is so cuutttteee ah ♥
The only thing that I gotta say is
Joy is so cute!!Her smile is so fascinating🙈
행복 들을 때마다 기분이 좋아지네요😊
Finally another group from SM who can do well live. First was DBSK, then SHINee, now RV.
Well, EXO and SNSD can do well as well. Maybe not every single member, but they have pretty good singers as well. They just hardly show it for whatever reason.
lol funny not mentioning SJ !!!!
Sorry but did you ever hear about a group called GirlsGeneration? -_-
also f(x) :)
sr but u should say all SM group did well, they have all the best artists n they all famous
Wendy and Seulgi though. So pretty and such nice voices!
Joy is really cute! I like Wendy's voice.
Joy' smile bring me life ^^
JOY really has a bright smile :)
Seulgi and Joy
I was just really mesmerized by Wendy's high notes.. She really hit it hard and solid! I had a feeling that she'll be my bias.. But now is for sure! Irene and Seulgi made it hard for me to choose though..
Be like me then. There is no such word as a "Bias" when it comes to Red Velvet 😂😉💕
Still Wendy biased here.
the cheers for joy here tho😋😋
I don't see that many comments for Irene. I love Irene, am I the only one?
Really bro, she is the second most popular
+Kawaii Igloo Yeah then Joy, Seulgi, Yeri
+Lucky One Red velvet popularity ranking is
Joy
Irene
Seulgi/Yeri
Wendy
Meli ARMY Really? I looked at a poll
+Meli ARMY I think that's wrong, but I dunno.
baby Joy 🐥🐥🐥🐥
I like Joy she looks so nice
Thank fuck for them, singing live that's what I like to see. Not shitty EXO after 2 years and they ain't singing live
OMG! HAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHA
Obviously you don't know that exo sang live before more than once xD. But since this is a RV video ill leave you alone.
Miller M good behavior!~
Just stfu. You don't know anything about Exo
yeah, exo are lipsync till D.O's voice cracked lol.
Joy look very cute she is adorable and pretty :3
The fans scream's when it's Joy's part. Saranghae!
Who also thinks that they were more happy than now..?
Nadeen Mohammed maybe because happiness its supposed to BE a happy performance ? Please, DONT try to BE negative about yeri
joy performs more happily in this era there's a reason why I just forgot but it's not because of yeri
ice queen aw. I wonder why
maybe its because she was the maknae in this era and tried to be more cute than the others...
In my opinion, seulgi is the real deal for RV. I mean, awesome vocals(even in live performances), awesome dancer, killer eye smile, not to mention she really is gorgeous? *dies* Pretty or not, for me she's the best in RV (talent wise). to which is why she's my bias.
I really love her low-deep voice. Really contrast to her loveable face :)
exactly! and I'm pretty sure she's going to be in some variety show soon with joy(resident choding for RV) ^^. she knows how to talk and react in shows just like what she did in the radio program they a few days ago.
I really don't know if Seulgi is the main dancer but i hope so, because she dances very well :)
something about this new group that makes me like them so damn much. I just cant quite figure out what it is lol
Honestly, Seulgi can be a main dancer and vocal too. I never regretted picking her as my bias.
"Happiness" is a tough song to sing. The "Shine on me" part is really high but Wendy does a great job every live performance!
Seulgi is amazing. She's gorgeous and her voice is too. My bias for sure!
And Joy is so cute, I didn't notice at first but she's very pretty.
Joy is so pretty
a one of a kind group, to follow Red Velvet's journey as a fan has had it's up and downs but seeing how far each member has come had make it worth it. Happiness!
I usually don't like the maknaes as much because I feel like they're way too overplayed just because they're the youngest but Joy has absolutely captured my heart. Everything from her smile to her voice to her natural bounce with every dance move. Perfect maknae! Joy you're my bias! Love Seulgi as well, she's got a lot of talent!♥ Red Velvet Fighting!
Wendy's visual in this era will forever remain iconic.
joy got the loudest screams, my bias
다들 미쳣다 진짜
I honestly want Joy to be the Visual of RV. Her beauty is something rare. Mixed with Cuteness and Beauty.
ACCURATE ~~ Honestly, Irene unnie is genuinely beautiful and deserves all the recognition she gets, but Joy is something else. Her face itself radiates joy (pun intended) and I just feel like she'd be great as the visual of RV. Her beauty is natural as well as it is her aegyo. She's just beautiful.
well she can be your version of a visual :) irene's visual is more suited for korean standards.
+suhojoysul Joy and Irene, are the visual.
+Lucia mejia goche i don't think soooo? check red velvet's profile.
***** for the Kfans Joy, Yeri and Irene are the visual
Joyy
Love this outfit
Joy is the only one wearing a red socks and her hair is tied up, she is always different and would be my bias forever😍😍😍😍💞💞
Please SM, never give them a sexy concept. LIKE EVER :3
I like them live, thank GOD they have talent.
Joy shall be my main bias now.
God bless your comment lol i feel the same way too!
セーラーグール / Sailor Ghoul they can pull off sexy and classy though, like in be natural
ThisKpopGuy I didn't think they pulled off anything in 'Be Natural'. I honestly, quit halfway through that video... :/ Not that they didn't pull off the look, but it was around the time Mr Mr came out - so I was bored with the whole "I can be sexy with a suit on" deal.
Automatic was really good though - I'll give them cred for that one lmfao :)
セーラーグール / Sailor Ghoul I don't think they were trying to be sexy with their looks, more like the choreo was trying to be sexy. Lmao.
Be Natural is way more calmer than Happiness so I mean..
Lmfao now we have Bad Boy.
Seulgi damn pretty!
I like how Seulgi say 'power'
Seulgi is my baby and my bias
Everyone's "Books" match their hair colors. Only Joy's book is covered on both sides and you can't see her name. Such is the life of the Maknae.
Joy is probably the most popular member according to the fanchants omg her screams are so much louder than the other girls! And she wasn't even promoted haha.
I really believe that Joy is the most visual of all, Irene has Korean standards and she is very beautiful! but for me, in my perspective, Joy is the visual one.
Seulgi is sooo gorgeous Oo....and Joy is such a good performer !!
I can't pick a bias, it's so hard :/
me too xX
Pink! Wendy I think...? She's my bias
nellbellkim Pink is Irene. Blue is Wendy.
Samantha Chacon thanks!
same! even now...
joy so prettest. ♥
오 레드벨벳 그렇게 관심갖고 보진않았었는데 진짜 잘한다 라이브에서도 잘 틀리지도 않고 춤을 추면서 열심히 노래부르는거 보니까 진짜 팬 될 듯ㅋㅋㅋㅋ멋있네
다들 이쁘고 저 핑크머리아이린인가?하고 초록머리하고 안을때 자동 미소ㅋㅋㅋㅋ
At last their live actual voice can be clearly heard ! The Best Live from them so far ! Love Joy
여돌그룹의 데뷔무대 정석!!
Every time I see joy I cant help but smile xD Joy brings joy
i like Joy
지금봐도 패션이!!
GG + F(X) = Red Velvet... this group is like the cuteness and sweetness of GG + the cuteness and the fierceness of F(X) :3
Perfect live singing as asual
I'm starting to love them especially Joy
Come on you guys lets be real here. There is no such thing as a "Bias" when it comes to Red Velvet. Thats why I barely choose biases now everyone of them slays my life equally 😂😱💕
wendy's visuals and vocals tho 😩💙💙💙
Joy sooo cute! My bias
Omg they sing live or what? and Joy she looks like Sulli so much I think there is another Sulli in SM 😁😄
I love their voices&how they are able to control their breathing but somehow in this performance their voices sound strained and unstable.
yeah they were like to tired ,but still try their best
I love that part at 0:22 soo much! And I fell in love with Joy the first time I saw her. How can someone be so angelic???!!!! I would seriously do anything to marry someone like her:)
a perfect week for red velvet.....all the performances were nothing short of great :)
Joy is such a cutie. All the girls seem very likeable tbh
Irene is still my bias
Joy sounds great! Stable! ❤
It seems like the smaller groups in SM like TVXQ, SHINee, and F(x) are better live than the bigger groups and RV are already good, once time passes they will be just as good.
Seulgi slaying live performances since debut! Lead vocals and main dancer indeed!
ya'll needa stop on yeri shes literally a bae
Joy is so young
Btw that girl with white top is good. :)
Joy 💚
Joy is jealous of Irene? The whole world is jealous of her. I LOVE JOY !!! my next favorite kpop girl.
THE WAY THE CROWDS SCREAM WHEN ITS JOYS PARTS 😍
신인인데 라이브하네;;
irene and wendy are really pretty.
Joy is so cute ;_;
I must be the only person who thinks Joy is just whatev in looks and singing. I mean... she aiite.
Really like Seulgi, I hope Red Velvet can have a long career, they seem like a good group :D
Joy so cute ,Irene so pretty and wendy too and seulgi so unique face
can't decide who is my bias
Joy cute! Joy beautiful! I love her! ♥♥♥♥♥
This is where the time they were still called rookies but their stability on live perfs were on point even when you removed the MR. Then there's this group called TWICE which is very popular but they are a group of visuals and their stability is so not good. I've listened to their MR Removed (twice's) but its really not good
yes
Yeah :/ I'm guessing its because of SIXTEEN that they were introduced to the audience before hand and the members are the ones chosen by the audience. Not hating on Twice or anything (cause I'm an once) their choreography is easier than RV where they had to jump and they never even stopped moving when they were singing their lines where as Twice is standing in one place while singing yet their voices are still not stable. JYP should've trained them more even Chaeyoung the rapper sings better than many of the members.. If I were to pick the most stablest it would be Jeongyeon, Jihyo and Nayeon could barely reach the notes in Cheer Up. Its like why did they give them those parts if they cannot reach it?...
+Jungkook “x” Lamb Skewers Only Tzuyu was chosen by the audience... JYP eliminated all the good vocalists...
Alyanna But I saw one part where everyone was voting, and I saw the girls who were chosen as the girls in Twice now.
CAN WE PLEASE SAY GOOD THINGS ABOUT GROUPS WITHOUT BASHING SOME OTHER GROUP?!
I am a fan of the group RED VELVET and SNSD .
I like JOY ,she há a sunny smile ,internal was very cute and beautiful .
JOY ,I love you
I love Wendy ♡
Irene
Seulgi
Wendy
Joy
Don’t forget Yeri
I’m a OT5 stan!
Joooooooooooooooooy
0:42 ARGHHH JOY SO CUTEEEE
Best live in SM since BoA and DBSK. Every member steals the spotlight with their vocals.
Great performance! Now I just need them to go on variety shows and my life would be perfect
I'm starting to accept this song for what it is.. What are they wearing tho?
clothes :P
I think one of the Happiness concept is cheerleader look so they wore cheer "uniforms" haha (:
Meh. Ive seen worse.
I'll take this "cheerleader" concept over the usual (f)x stylings that make those girls look like they were in a thrift store explosion.
It's things that call "droptop" and "Korea Style" okay?It's really popular in Korea and another Asia countries~