Footnote. This song WON the Oscar for Best Original Song for a Motion Picture. Lady Gaga won the BAFTA, Golden Globe, Grammy AND Oscar. The first time anyone has won all of those for the same song! I think Cooper came a LONG way. Two years ago he couldn’t sing. He took more than a year of voice, and guitar. (His guitar teacher was Lukas Nelson, son of ...Willie Nelson! Lukas Nelson and his band play Jackson Maine’s backup band in “A Star Is Born.”) Lady Gaga refused to work with him unless he sang LIVE. So he did!
They respect each other and the performance is so fantastic that they genuinely have the audience believing they are lovers driving home the talent and passion for their art
Hi Carl, I really enjoyed your reaction and critique on so many levels and nuances. Loved your comment on her tan😁 Yes they sure have a chemistry. Going to try to catch your live feed. Thank you! Blessings, Pam
I've just discovered your channel and been breezing through your videos and think your commentary and the way you breakdown the technicalities of what the singers are doing is brilliant! I don't think I've seen that you've done any Harry Styles reactions and I'd love to see your thoughts. If you happen to decide to watch some videos a few I'd recommend for you to see some of his vocal abilities are: Sweet Creature at BBC the One, Sign of the Times at Graham Norton, and any of his performances/carpool karaoke on Late Late and Live Lounge! Anyway I love your channel and look forward to more.
She is like Jordan, Kobe etc...very clutch in any performance, 100% all the the time. TRUE TRUE TRUE GOD GIVEN TALENT. If she practiced I think GaGa could tackle oprah.
I thought this performance highlights the fact that Bradley is not a natural singer, but I thought that Lady GaGa might have done better - but as you said, they went into this with no warm up
These two are rendering us all speechless.. so there's 'that'.. Something in the way Gg and Bc are blending is almost supernatural. Hate to use that word but, wth !!
I love hearing a male vocal coach, giving opinion of this. Even you seem to have felt her emotional reaction to His approach to the piano bench. In another video (Las Vegas) she begged him to sit by her. I love how you stayed technical in your comments...but well, you're a man. As a woman and a musician, the emotion here is overwhelming., my bad :)
re: the way the looked at each other - how long did they have to rehearse the scene in the movie? How long did they rehearse and ACT the song in the movie? It would be hard to do a good job with that song withOUT acting thru it. :o)
They were replicating their characters. They said intentional teasing chemistry. Bradley has gorgeous model/ actor girlfriend. Gaga just broke off engagement. Your analysis was interesting n helpful. Thanks. Please react to Corey Taylor w Stone Sour Song #3 acoustic version. Also love to hear reaction to Beth Hart n Bonnamassa live Amsterdam I’d Rather Go Blind
carl john you need to react to katrina velarde whitney houston medley. it is insane. i am a fan of the great divas of the 80's and 90's but this katrina is out of this world. one of the best singers in the world. you should not miss this.
I’m gonna go with Joy Beha and say bs. They practiced the performance for a week with strict directions in every detail. Watch Jimmy Kimmels interview with her. She explained it better then I can.
That’s not true. He’s happy w his beautiful model actor girlfriend n she just broke off engagement. They played up chemistry on purpose they said to show characters.
They developed a natural intimacy that comes from being vulnerable with someone who supports and nurtures you through it. He had to help her learn his craft, she had to help him learn hers and in the end they created something beautiful.
Symphonic metal singer Floor Jansen sang this song on a Dutch TV show Beste Zanger (Best Singers, where 7 singers sing each others songs or songs that mean a lot to them). You should check out her version: ruclips.net/video/M68pe4a_9zk/видео.html
Have you ever done a reaction to Dana Winner? The song I was specifically thinking of is this "One moment in time" rendition: ruclips.net/video/pDo4kvip-cQ/видео.html
their skin probably looked orange because of their self-tanners or spray tanning...….but the lighting, Stephanie said in an interview, was Brad wanting and her getting her lighting guys to get him Honeycomb lighting for the ambiance and mood he wanted to create.
I love them. But this performance was very disappointing. Bradley is no singer and that sucks because he has an honest voice.now,lady gaga is no stranger to performing in concerts and different occasions,that's what she does basically...singing and performing live like she always does.the no rehearsal before hand is not an excuse for this less than ordinary performance. She is the live queen but not here.I don't think you told us up front that they both were out of time because of the difficulty of the song.come on,she performs song tens of times.this performance reminds of Eddie's performance in which she apologized and asked to repeat the song.I know criticizing lady GaGa at this point is very hard because people won't allow it for she is a goddess now.I love her and it his romance between Bradley and her is like a fairy tale.But the truth should be told, they both sucked here but melted our heart at the same time and I was waiting for a kiss.
![OsamaSon - ik what you did last summer [Official Music Video]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/4DIQDnu3mr4/mqdefault.jpg)
Footnote. This song WON the Oscar for Best Original Song for a Motion Picture. Lady Gaga won the BAFTA, Golden Globe, Grammy AND Oscar. The first time anyone has won all of those for the same song! I think Cooper came a LONG way. Two years ago he couldn’t sing. He took more than a year of voice, and guitar. (His guitar teacher was Lukas Nelson, son of ...Willie Nelson! Lukas Nelson and his band play Jackson Maine’s backup band in “A Star Is Born.”) Lady Gaga refused to work with him unless he sang LIVE. So he did!
She’s so trained and it shows.
She knows how to sing in any situation. Distractions and all
And make it feel real.
So true.
Lol you are totally crushing on gaga..she is amazing though
That chemistry is crazy good !
Gaga is incredible, and their chemistry together is palpable. Great review!
This is the best live of both yet ...singing shallow
"Are these guys in love....they look at each other a little bit too long."
❤
They respect each other and the performance is so fantastic that they genuinely have the audience believing they are lovers driving home the talent and passion for their art
First reaction that actually teaches something without being harsh. Definitely subbing.
The way they look at each other 🔥
You know sir...those consonants and nuances which are in the songs are the reason why we love music...because its not plastic as you would like.
The way you were biting your lips while u were watching Gaga priceless!!! ... obviously big crush !
Hi Carl, I really enjoyed your reaction and critique on so many levels and nuances. Loved your comment on her tan😁
Yes they sure have a chemistry. Going to try to catch your live feed. Thank you! Blessings, Pam
Your critique of this performance is the most measured and realistic of the ones I have seen so far. Good job.
Cooper was obviously nervous and all over the place. Gaga, easily the most talented main pop girl of her generation, was on point as usual.
It’s “Meet” 💕
M!C thank you! I was wracking my brain trying to find the “b”
Me too. If you are going to review how someone sings something look up the lyrics and know the song. LOL
Lauren Gasbarini Leave him alone haha
@@MC-fm4ei pardon? I was agreeing with you, but okay?
LADY GAGA ♥️
It's not Be. .it's MEET
Your criticism is on spot your a great Valhalla critique. Excellent
Valhalla?
I've just discovered your channel and been breezing through your videos and think your commentary and the way you breakdown the technicalities of what the singers are doing is brilliant! I don't think I've seen that you've done any Harry Styles reactions and I'd love to see your thoughts. If you happen to decide to watch some videos a few I'd recommend for you to see some of his vocal abilities are: Sweet Creature at BBC the One, Sign of the Times at Graham Norton, and any of his performances/carpool karaoke on Late Late and Live Lounge! Anyway I love your channel and look forward to more.
She is like Jordan, Kobe etc...very clutch in any performance, 100% all the the time. TRUE TRUE TRUE GOD GIVEN TALENT. If she practiced I think GaGa could tackle oprah.
I don't think it would be very nice to tackle Oprah. What's she ever done to you?
Found a new vocal coach reaction channel. Great stuff mate! 🖖🏻🎈
I thought this performance highlights the fact that Bradley is not a natural singer, but I thought that Lady GaGa might have done better - but as you said, they went into this with no warm up
6 seconds and I was like: OMH THAT CUTE ACCENT
It's more natural when a reaction comes from a real live performance on TV instead of a video on RUclips.
These two are rendering us all speechless.. so there's 'that'.. Something in the way Gg and Bc are blending is almost supernatural. Hate to use that word but, wth !!
I love hearing a male vocal coach, giving opinion of this. Even you seem to have felt her emotional reaction to His approach to the piano bench. In another video (Las Vegas) she begged him to sit by her.
I love how you stayed technical in your comments...but well, you're a man. As a woman and a musician, the emotion here is overwhelming., my bad :)
re: the way the looked at each other - how long did they have to rehearse the scene in the movie? How long did they rehearse and ACT the song in the movie? It would be hard to do a good job with that song withOUT acting thru it. :o)
You drop when you say "girl" in "Tell me something, girl." when that's not how it is.
Please react to more Gaga ! Till it happens to you live
Yes the Oscars performance
I just love when Sasha Baron Cohen does this Bruno character
Love his analysis
Listening to Carl sing on his live stream and his voice sorta reminded me off David Bowie
i love the creepy smile on the thumbnail. :3 great vid as usual
Hey Carl, you should definitely react to wicked game by Chris Isaak, he's got such a great technique
I think they are in love ❤️
Please please do Pentatonix version of Shallow. It's amazing!
Would you react to her acoustic performance of perfect illusion on sukkiri please ? It is really good
They were replicating their characters. They said intentional teasing chemistry. Bradley has gorgeous model/ actor girlfriend. Gaga just broke off engagement. Your analysis was interesting n helpful. Thanks. Please react to Corey Taylor w Stone Sour Song #3 acoustic version. Also love to hear reaction to
Beth Hart n Bonnamassa live Amsterdam I’d Rather Go Blind
Mariah Carey vanishing audition please!
*Don't bother; he's a Mariah hater...*
You must listen to the Pentatonix version. They blow it out of the water.
carl john you need to react to katrina velarde whitney houston medley. it is insane. i am a fan of the great divas of the 80's and 90's but this katrina is out of this world. one of the best singers in the world. you should not miss this.
let them sing!
What word is she singing that starts with B.
She sings "i'll never meet the ground" its an 'm'
"Meet" not "be"
Ill never be the ground 😂
Would love to see what you think of Marc Broussard!!!
What b are you speaking of? I’ll never Leave the ground is what I think you’re referring.
It's "meet the ground." She's diving...
My 14 year old niece loves Gaga and Bradley’s voices and want ‘em to be together 😆
Please can you do Maruv song Siren!! Mind-blowing!!! She's been killing it!
Background music at end be like ????
You've got to do a reaction on Shikwa Jawab e Shikwa by Coke Studio.
Please react to Queen and Adam Lambert’s Oscar performance too! Love your reactions!
"Be" hehehehehe
You picked up on their relationship. They love but can't be together because of the nature of things..
I’m gonna go with Joy Beha and say bs. They practiced the performance for a week with strict directions in every detail. Watch Jimmy Kimmels interview with her. She explained it better then I can.
That’s not true. He’s happy w his beautiful model actor girlfriend n she just broke off engagement. They played up chemistry on purpose they said to show characters.
Jacki Jean mmmm what about now??? They broke up!!! 😬😏
They developed a natural intimacy that comes from being vulnerable with someone who supports and nurtures you through it.
He had to help her learn his craft, she had to help him learn hers and in the end they created something beautiful.
She’s saying “meet the ground” not beat.
He's referring to the note she's hitting, 'B' (or 'H') in music.
Hot Potato ah ok. Thank you. Makes much more sense. I was like, “ wait he’s got the subtitles on how is he missing this?!?” 😂
@2:00 just say he's pitchy!
Symphonic metal singer Floor Jansen sang this song on a Dutch TV show Beste Zanger (Best Singers, where 7 singers sing each others songs or songs that mean a lot to them). You should check out her version: ruclips.net/video/M68pe4a_9zk/видео.html
I am an alto or contralto. But more alto. I think.
I think it’s an L not a B
I can only understand some words that you're saying 😥 maybe you can pute subtitles in spanish ps: great reaction!!!
Kevin Tamayo she referring to english doesnt prove your point. You literally mentioned it and implied/said it was the universal language. Dickhead.
They are the same colour.
There is NO "B" !!!!! I'll never REACH the ground - REACH not be or "B" anything......
Leopard it is not "reach" either. It is: I'll never MEET the ground. It is not "Be" nor "Rea-" (in reach) it is "Mee"
he means the tone B omg y'all
@@mireyachichelnitzkyanderha5442 He's talking about the consonant.. not the note.. and yeah it's an M, for "meet"
haha my video is broken 😂
Carl John Franz Never hurts to review the lyrics ; especially when dissecting. Otherwise how the heck would we know what singers are singing 😂😂😂.
Aaqa by ali sethii and abida perveen coke studio
Can you do reaction to any of one direction songs..pls :)
tucker carlson tonight
Kindly React on Ith Naheen By Cokestudio plzzzzzz
Meekal hassan band kinary coke studio
Please please please. React on call band song title jilawatan. Thanks ✌️
My niece says she hates Gaga’s voice and that “shes not very attractive” amazing how different people can perceive differently
she's obviously a hater
Is she blind and deaf?
Lady Gaga is a great singer. She’s not that pretty. She touched her face already with fillers and collagen on her lips. Don’t look natural anymore.
ARCEE BEE and you are obviously stupid. Everybody has a different opinion.
Beauty is in the eyes of the beholder. To me she is very pretty. But more importantly, a great talent.
Have you ever done a reaction to Dana Winner?
The song I was specifically thinking of is this "One moment in time" rendition: ruclips.net/video/pDo4kvip-cQ/видео.html
React to Lana Del Rey
Its not a B though, i'll never Meet the ground she sings
Bradley Cooper has a girlfriend
Alex Metzger not any more
The lighting is so orange it makes them look a bit ridiculous.
their skin probably looked orange because of their self-tanners or spray tanning...….but the lighting, Stephanie said in an interview, was Brad wanting and her getting her lighting guys to get him Honeycomb lighting for the ambiance and mood he wanted to create.
I love them. But this performance was very disappointing. Bradley is no singer and that sucks because he has an honest voice.now,lady gaga is no stranger to performing in concerts and different occasions,that's what she does basically...singing and performing live like she always does.the no rehearsal before hand is not an excuse for this less than ordinary performance. She is the live queen but not here.I don't think you told us up front that they both were out of time because of the difficulty of the song.come on,she performs song tens of times.this performance reminds of Eddie's performance in which she apologized and asked to repeat the song.I know criticizing lady GaGa at this point is very hard because people won't allow it for she is a goddess now.I love her and it his romance between Bradley and her is like a fairy tale.But the truth should be told, they both sucked here but melted our heart at the same time and I was waiting for a kiss.
Zain Zain I don’t know where you got the idea there was no rehearsal. There definitely was and Bradley directed this moment.
They were both off key at points in this rendition. That's honest. The performance was good but don't over egg the pudding.
He is so boring and awful 😑😑