Water and Honesty - Red Dead Redemption

"Water and Honesty" is one of the many side missions begun by speaking to a stranger in Red Dead Redemption. In this mission, John Marston decides to rest at the camp of a prospector. This man, Andrew McAllister, is in search of water in the dry desert of New Austin. He claims he used a dowsing stick to determine that there's water underneath a property called the Pleasance House. Unfortunately the property's owner seems unwilling to sell. McAllister asks John to speak with the owner to see if he would reconsider selling his land. Marston rides out to the Pleasance House and meets the catankerous old man living there. This older gentleman, Clyde Evans, greets Marston with a shotgun. John manages to get him to put down the gun. Evans relaxes and offers to sell the land for two hundred dollars. John, having looted that money from a bunch of corpses fair and square, decides not to pay Clyde, and instead takes the deed by force. With the deed in hand, John returns to McAllister. The latter is horrified to find the deed covered in Evans' blood. He disapproves of John's actions, but rewards him with cash anyway. Marston, being a bit immature, then proceeds to push and kick McAllister off a nearby cliff.
This is, obviously, not the only way to complete this mission. You can choose to pay Clyde Evans two hundred dollars. Most playthroughs of this mission available on RUclips seem to prefer that choice. That's why we chose to show you what happens if you instead choose to kill Evans and loot the deed.