Regarding mounted assistant, it might be better to use Washington (Prime). He has more HP and the lower attack can be compensated by using the attack book, something that Cheng Yaojin cannot do. Thanks for these amazing videos mate.
Great video, thanks for the effort !! 🎉🎉 Could add an example of T1 defense composition? Like 400M T1 mounted, 100M T1 siege, 10M T1 ranged. Going all the way up to the top tiers.
@@rodrigoyoshida535 the composition would depend on your specific buffs and what the enemy is attacking with. To make it simple, you need enough T1 mounted and siege so that they never get wiped out, and for ranged the more you have the better.
@@Maath_Faseli This is interesting: a ranged defense with a T1 Mounted/Seige Wall. I was thinking of a higher T1 siege because of the range, but since the actual attack is the range, the shorter, less expensive T1 siege protects. Hmm. But what about their attack long range. Will this just be a numbers game of having more than they can kill depending on their march size?
When did Isaac Brock come out? Seems like about a year ago. I suspect we will see a new wall general early in 2025. Marshall and Shigeharu are still serving me well.
Questions: what's the point of counted ground defense general in? They usually are the last troops engaged in battle. should mounted plus siege buff more usefull than others?
if you face a majority ground or mounted march then they would be the first to be engaged, but if you want to check for just siege + mounted you could download the spreadsheet and tweak the formula to get those numbers
great video thank you!! im going with zach taylor t1 defense build, aiming at 300M t1 mounted, but also having t14 mounted/archer/ground marches. planning flat refine on taylor's gears for mounted, and % refine for archer. does that work?
absolutely, for the gear I would try for only flat refines on mounted, but I know that can be expensive, so if you get a ranged % atk and want to keep it then go for it
So if I'm following correctly, in your opinion, for a T1 mounted defense w/high tier ranged, the best combo would be Taylor and Sigurd? I need to find a way to get a copy of Sigurd...
Very informative! I have a question - I have quite a lot of t12-14 troops (Ghost my cavs). Currently, I run Marshall as my main (4 red stars, 5 specialties, and skin) and Brock as my assistant. Would I be better served running Brock and Leo (I can make either main) together compared to using Marshall?
Marshall works fine, if you could get Brock to 4 or 5 red stars you could use him, but it really depends on what troop type you have the most focus on at the moment. For the assistant though, jump to the part of the video where I cover the assistants 32:47
I was curious where Edward Teach would fall into assistant. I've got Taylor main and Leo assistant and was thinking Teach replacing him. Takenaka might also be an option.
@Maath_Faseli sadly I don't have Takenaka. I'll test out Teach, but probably better on Senate fully ascended and staying with Leo. Runestones and BoA too valuable for marginal increase.
@@TheReebokjoe yeah if he's fully ascended then I would keep him in the senate, maybe when they release a new siege general they would be a good assistant
CAN YOU RE EXPLAIN HOW A T1 SEIGE WITH LOWER RANGE IS GOING TO BENEIFT YOU MORE THAN A T11 SEIHE WHICH HAS HIGHER RANGE. SO ARE ASKING THE ENEMY COME CLOSSER TO YOU? OR IS IT ABOUT THE SHEAR VOLUME AND THE ENEMY TIME IT WILL TAKE TO CLEAR A THICK WALL. IN THAT CASE WHY NOT 100M t11 seige as counter?
T1 siege has shorter range than T11, your T1 siege will come closer to the front line and will be available for their siege to shoot before your T11 are available to shoot
@cameldaddybactrian9979 @allsport4071 there are lots of generals that can be used as the assistant. Any general with the "D" in the spreadsheet can be used on defense
@@carnalknowledge9721 the % buff is really low, that's why I prefer Zachary over Boudicca. I see why people use debuff mayors, but you should be able to get more than enough debuff action from your sub cities alone.
depends on what is attacking you. If you get hit with a siege rally then you would need more than you would from just a single player. The goal is to never have all your T1 siege or mounted die, so if they all die then you need to build more.
So many generals missed! Trajan probably best defensive general you can get in tavern. So many that can be used on wall that aren't specifically wall generals. Omg
if you skip ahead to the assistant section I talk about a few other non wall general options, it would be to much to mention all the generals that could be used on the wall, but there area others that can work
@Maath_Faseli I agree, but I would look at the best generals for wall. For example, Washington Prime all though a mounted wall general for a cav t1 trap is a huge mistake. Is much better than boutica with just 1 red star.
For any subtitles other than the RUclips auto I would have to manually encode them into the video which would double my production time per language per video, unfortunately it's just not possible for me at the moment
@@Ridewise704 depends on what's attacking you. You want enough so that they never get reduced to 0, so just keep building until you get to the point where they don't all die against a strong siege attack
@marcelmbahia9746 Dewey takes a looong time to get to five stars. He is good but takes forever to get him to five stars. Close to 2 years depending how lucky you are.
Your comment about siege hp and defense not being important on the wall... you might want to spend a bit of time digging into the math behind defending siege rallies...
Top notch vid. however, i think that you got your troop attacking order wrong. you don't take into account the troop speed. starting maxT to lowT, cavs go first ahead of ground. ground falls between range and cavs, otherwise, you got some pretty speedy ground that can outrun cavs. if range don't kill the waves of cavs while shooting over their own cav and ground , the cavs will fight cavs until there are no cavs left. what is left of cavs will then go ahead to fight off the ground troops.
The speed mechanic in game is completely broken, watch this video from Derrick Defies to get the whole picture, he does a more accurate job explaining it than me ruclips.net/video/zaM5ajYqudE/видео.html
I HAVE TO SAY. I DIDNT UNDERSTAND ANYTHING ABOUT TROOP ATTACKING ORDER. YOU WERE NOT CONSISTENT IN EXPLAINING WHICH TROOP IS COMING AT YOU AND WHAT YOUR TROOPS ARE DOING... YOU START OFF BY EXPLAINING WITHOUT WHAT TYPES OF TROOPS ARE COMING AT YOU AND THEN SWITCH COMPLETY TO WHAT YOUR TROOPS ARE DOING HALF WAY THROUGH THE FIGHT YOU SWITCH THE FIGHT AGAIN. That was an exteemely was an extremely confusing part of your video to someone who does understand troop attacking order a littile bit better than average
yet you are tossing these non F2p generals 10* stats and listing them, I am not going to go through your whole video and spell it out for everyone because this is what you should have did to begin with; ground general best Main is James Bowie(not the generals you speak of when they are sooooooo expensive is what you are saying unless your going to spend over 20000 dollars on the game
I've waited for a video like this for months (from anyone!). Thanks for taking the time to put it together.
Thank you so much for all your efforts to enlighten the community!
Maybe as a follow up a best combination for common builds video
Thanks for the spreadsheet! People laugh at me when they see ranged general on my wall and my t1's mounted lol,
@@sevastiancholakov2476 😂 my alliance all laughed at me when I said I’m going to use Taylor and Sigurd. Now there all eating shit 😂
Pay attention on Tachibana regarding big t1 hybrid defenses. Nice video, thanks for your effort!
Btw, I'm using Richard with Godfrey atm...
Regarding mounted assistant, it might be better to use Washington (Prime). He has more HP and the lower attack can be compensated by using the attack book, something that Cheng Yaojin cannot do. Thanks for these amazing videos mate.
Thank you as always! I'll be pointing several alliance members to this video.
Great video, thanks for the effort !! 🎉🎉
Could add an example of T1 defense composition? Like 400M T1 mounted, 100M T1 siege, 10M T1 ranged. Going all the way up to the top tiers.
@@rodrigoyoshida535 the composition would depend on your specific buffs and what the enemy is attacking with. To make it simple, you need enough T1 mounted and siege so that they never get wiped out, and for ranged the more you have the better.
@@Maath_Faseli This is interesting: a ranged defense with a T1 Mounted/Seige Wall. I was thinking of a higher T1 siege because of the range, but since the actual attack is the range, the shorter, less expensive T1 siege protects. Hmm. But what about their attack long range. Will this just be a numbers game of having more than they can kill depending on their march size?
Woohoo! I have my coffee ... going to enjoy the vid
Great content!
Just saying "Boo dee car" thanks for this :)
When did Isaac Brock come out? Seems like about a year ago. I suspect we will see a new wall general early in 2025. Marshall and Shigeharu are still serving me well.
Questions: what's the point of counted ground defense general in? They usually are the last troops engaged in battle. should mounted plus siege buff more usefull than others?
if you face a majority ground or mounted march then they would be the first to be engaged, but if you want to check for just siege + mounted you could download the spreadsheet and tweak the formula to get those numbers
When will you add that spreadsheet that you are using in the video to your google docs?
I just uploaded it. Sorry forgot to do that before I published haha
great video thank you!!
im going with zach taylor t1 defense build, aiming at 300M t1 mounted, but also having t14 mounted/archer/ground marches.
planning flat refine on taylor's gears for mounted, and % refine for archer.
does that work?
absolutely, for the gear I would try for only flat refines on mounted, but I know that can be expensive, so if you get a ranged % atk and want to keep it then go for it
So if I'm following correctly, in your opinion, for a T1 mounted defense w/high tier ranged, the best combo would be Taylor and Sigurd? I need to find a way to get a copy of Sigurd...
yes that's correct. You don't necessarily need sigurd, you could use another ranged general with the leading clause
@@Maath_Faseli do Siege and range defenses work? Ex Zack and Leo or Zack and Takanaka
Very informative! I have a question - I have quite a lot of t12-14 troops (Ghost my cavs). Currently, I run Marshall as my main (4 red stars, 5 specialties, and skin) and Brock as my assistant. Would I be better served running Brock and Leo (I can make either main) together compared to using Marshall?
Marshall works fine, if you could get Brock to 4 or 5 red stars you could use him, but it really depends on what troop type you have the most focus on at the moment. For the assistant though, jump to the part of the video where I cover the assistants 32:47
Great vid! Love the new way you presented the content. Did making the vid change your mind on gens you are using?
@@Kapsouro not a whole lot to be honest, I think Zachary Taylor went from #2 to #1 in my ranking for F2P players, but that's about it
@Maath_Faseli who is No 1 for f2p? Richard?
Sorry meant who is No 2 for f2p
Sorry. I meant who is No 2 for f2p players?
@@Kapsouro Yeah Richard would be my #2, and maybe Boudica for #3
What about Mu Guying and Tachibana? Or even Frigg/Miltiades? Good job!!!
They would all work very good as well
I was curious where Edward Teach would fall into assistant. I've got Taylor main and Leo assistant and was thinking Teach replacing him. Takenaka might also be an option.
Takenaka would be the best option of the three
@Maath_Faseli sadly I don't have Takenaka. I'll test out Teach, but probably better on Senate fully ascended and staying with Leo. Runestones and BoA too valuable for marginal increase.
@@TheReebokjoe yeah if he's fully ascended then I would keep him in the senate, maybe when they release a new siege general they would be a good assistant
CAN YOU RE EXPLAIN HOW A T1 SEIGE WITH LOWER RANGE IS GOING TO BENEIFT YOU MORE THAN A T11 SEIHE WHICH HAS HIGHER RANGE. SO ARE ASKING THE ENEMY COME CLOSSER TO YOU? OR IS IT ABOUT THE SHEAR VOLUME AND THE ENEMY TIME IT WILL TAKE TO CLEAR A THICK WALL. IN THAT CASE WHY NOT 100M t11 seige as counter?
T1 siege has shorter range than T11, your T1 siege will come closer to the front line and will be available for their siege to shoot before your T11 are available to shoot
I’ve Boudica and Zach with 300 mil t1 they do the job unless rallied by 4 or 5 folks
So good video i like it but you forget TACHIBANA like assistant she do well for arch and siege
Also consider Miltiades as assistant ground defense general if you don't have Lucilla
@cameldaddybactrian9979 @allsport4071 there are lots of generals that can be used as the assistant. Any general with the "D" in the spreadsheet can be used on defense
Why t1 trap uses sub mayor? The logic is about that they would rather debuff opponents which benefita more than giving percentage buff on your t1. 🤔
@@carnalknowledge9721 the % buff is really low, that's why I prefer Zachary over Boudicca. I see why people use debuff mayors, but you should be able to get more than enough debuff action from your sub cities alone.
Can you tell me best two defense genrals for wall while server war period... In traven available... Thanks
Queen Boudicca and li naomasa@@vijaykatari4520
100m t1 siege enough for a 600m cav wall ?
depends on what is attacking you. If you get hit with a siege rally then you would need more than you would from just a single player. The goal is to never have all your T1 siege or mounted die, so if they all die then you need to build more.
So many generals missed! Trajan probably best defensive general you can get in tavern. So many that can be used on wall that aren't specifically wall generals. Omg
if you skip ahead to the assistant section I talk about a few other non wall general options, it would be to much to mention all the generals that could be used on the wall, but there area others that can work
@Maath_Faseli I agree, but I would look at the best generals for wall. For example, Washington Prime all though a mounted wall general for a cav t1 trap is a huge mistake. Is much better than boutica with just 1 red star.
Selam. Altyapı Cc Türkçe çeviri ayar ekle lütfen. Teşekkürler
For any subtitles other than the RUclips auto I would have to manually encode them into the video which would double my production time per language per video, unfortunately it's just not possible for me at the moment
I have leonidas two red stars and boudica
If using Taylor on the wall.... How many T1 siege should accompany the Ti Cavs? Thanks
Really enjoy your breakdowns...
@@Ridewise704 depends on what's attacking you. You want enough so that they never get reduced to 0, so just keep building until you get to the point where they don't all die against a strong siege attack
@@Maath_Faseli I'm only 1.4 billion with 300 mill - T1... 50- T2 and 10 T3.... was thinking start with 100? I guess a trial and error approach
@@Ridewise704 yes it would be trial and error unfortunately, I think 100 would be a good starting point though
Dewey is not good ?
@marcelmbahia9746 Dewey takes a looong time to get to five stars. He is good but takes forever to get him to five stars. Close to 2 years depending how lucky you are.
He is good, he just isn't the best in any one category. If you are already working on him and are close to 5 stars I would keep working on him.
Thanks I have himbto 5 red star. Was lucky lol
@@marcelmbahia9746 How long did it take you?
Your comment about siege hp and defense not being important on the wall... you might want to spend a bit of time digging into the math behind defending siege rallies...
Yeah you're right it is more important than I made it sound in hindsight, but I still think it is more important for a ground or mounted defense
@@Maath_Faseli
Top notch vid. however, i think that you got your troop attacking order wrong. you don't take into account the troop speed. starting maxT to lowT, cavs go first ahead of ground. ground falls between range and cavs, otherwise, you got some pretty speedy ground that can outrun cavs. if range don't kill the waves of cavs while shooting over their own cav and ground , the cavs will fight cavs until there are no cavs left. what is left of cavs will then go ahead to fight off the ground troops.
The speed mechanic in game is completely broken, watch this video from Derrick Defies to get the whole picture, he does a more accurate job explaining it than me ruclips.net/video/zaM5ajYqudE/видео.html
I HAVE TO SAY. I DIDNT UNDERSTAND ANYTHING ABOUT TROOP ATTACKING ORDER. YOU WERE NOT CONSISTENT IN EXPLAINING WHICH TROOP IS COMING AT YOU AND WHAT YOUR TROOPS ARE DOING... YOU START OFF BY EXPLAINING WITHOUT WHAT TYPES OF TROOPS ARE COMING AT YOU AND THEN SWITCH COMPLETY TO WHAT YOUR TROOPS ARE DOING HALF WAY THROUGH THE FIGHT YOU SWITCH THE FIGHT AGAIN. That was an exteemely was an extremely confusing part of your video to someone who does understand troop attacking order a littile bit better than average
ruclips.net/video/zaM5ajYqudE/видео.html watch this video then, Derrick does a better job explaining it
@@Maath_Faseli wow Derrick is a genius. It changed my way of biulding defense layers
I AM VERY CONFUSED BY YOUR ALL-CAPS RANT.
yet you are tossing these non F2p generals 10* stats and listing them, I am not going to go through your whole video and spell it out for everyone because this is what you should have did to begin with; ground general best Main is James Bowie(not the generals you speak of when they are sooooooo expensive is what you are saying unless your going to spend over 20000 dollars on the game
He didn’t say FTP defense guide. It’s a guide including all the generals in the game. It’s for you to decide what to do with the info he provided.
@mega7075 yes and we all know people are not capable of doing that, they will just be like x is bis
Richard is by far better and ftp.
@@openmythirdeyerichard is not ground but yes overall I would say is best overall based off his data
Except people do spend this much money. I don't agree with it but people do what they want with their cash.