Congratulations to Mahua Moitraji for making the Indian Parliament Proud, by her outstanding arguments! Thank you so much for your demonstrations that will awaken the ignorant minds of some of our narrow minded law makers. God bless you for loving India.
Bro when manmohan sing was there global growth was high every country was growing fast Now global growth is 2percent Manufacturing needs global support also
Compare that situation with the world growth rate. If India was doing so well in UPA, then why did India never exceed China's growth rate even once during 2004-2014. In fact, China was growing at roughly about 13% and more during UPA's term. When UPA took over in 2004, trade deficit with China was USD 1.5 Billion. At 2014, when UPA left, it was close to USD 36.2 Billion. Now, it has only increased to $72 Billion. UPA was able to show growth rate by incurring 30x trade deficit with China. What good came out of it? I would have been happy if UPA cut down its growth to improve local manufacturing.
Brilliantly explained Sujit Nair Ji 🙏🏼🙏🏼👌👌 Thanks for being so simplistic while talking in layman’s language, but surely on a highly serious topic 👍🏼👍🏼
On the contrary, she knows a lot.... especially how to please those who will keep her in power. mind you, she does not need to help the common man, she only needs to make her rich clients richer and richest.
Absolutely clear the current Indian economy is in distress. Demand has slumped leading to a viscous cycle. 12 lakh high net worth individuals gave up Indian citizenship in the last 8 years. Hope India FM is able to turn around this situation 😞
FM Nirmala Sitharaman is not inclined to give straight answers to the questions put to her on economic affairs. She rather devotes her energy to put counter questions , and relishes in deflecting the focus to other innuendos and whataboutery. Her loud claims on rapid growth of economy under the current regime fail to inspire confidence of the members of the opposition parties in Parliament. The track records in the management of economy are not at all inspiring and convincing.
Mr.Nair, in reality these are all blunder of inflation come down. Yes as far as vegetables as growth is more price down. Few months back Tomato was Rs.125.00 because of damage by rain. Now vegetables prices are a bit down. But I tell you all the pulses increase of 12% over the earlier price. Potato chips was Rs.88.00 now they put Rs.98.00. I buy chole channa half a kilo Rs.70.00 now I was charged Rs.80.00. GST 18% on Insurance Premium. Is it justified? With out any thing of service GST charged. It should have been 5% standard for all service. Proudly saying GST increase is laughing thing. Shameless.
Correct Regarding Textiles the prices increased by 30% last 2 years, the sale volume decreased by 25%.so gst increased due to price rise.not only that many items gst rates increased and many goods came to tax net. The govt is fooling the people.
How mismanagement of not so bad Indian economics status leading to avoidable unemployment, devastating inflation, shrink foreign investment, disturbing rise in people straining below poverty line is explained using common man's vocabulary ...common people can now understand that they suffer not because they are mismanaging their meager fund but government is not efficiently managing their fiscal sources. Thanks to Surjit Nayar
The speech by Ms. Moitra threw lot of questions and at least now the govt should understand they have to understand the requirement as rulers and not slinging mud on others.
Speciality of this Govt , is no record , unemployment no record , disaster of Covid , no record , economy good or bad , no record , all good , goody goody is India
Many don't realize the issue of taking citizenship by the rich in other countries? We are in our own dreamland as the governments create wonderful dreams everyday, hiding facts. Nice episode.
Keep it Simple Dikra! No Cash 💰 inflow - No FDI and wealthy Indians running 🏃♂️ away and renouncing Indian citizenships 😱 Reduced foreign remittances by Indian workers in Gulf countries - hence cannot offset cost of “Crude” Oil imports plus + plus + plus + 😬😭🥵🤬😴
One of the 12,43,000 people who took up foreign citizenship since 2014 has interviewed PM and asked him "Kya aap aam khaate hain?" - proving to India that he may have Red Dil but he definitely has Zubaan kesari
Excellent analysis full truth of the facts and reality of sickening Indian Economy and all time high inflation rate and mass migration of Wealth Creators. God only should save India.
Lacs of Indians in USA in the queue for citizenship of USA i e they have virtually left India and is only a matter of time to leave Indian citizenship.
Not ambani or adnani its thr people of India who voted the idiots in power and not just gave the the matchbox but also the gasoline to burn our country and economy to the ground
18 rupees in my hand is productive, but in the hand of the government is commodity of consumption. A government that gloats over high tax collection is eating up the seed for the next crop
Problem is we say economy is growing, GDP raising but none of prices are coming down. I see the increase of remittances is the biggest issue, and these remittances are not getting taxed. The remittance only add to GDP of country. If a family stays here and their children send them per month 1 lakh, isn't it their income why is there no cap of tax on such remittances. I see lot of youth moving to other countries sending money and buying assests here. What about people who stay here contribute to people by paying income tax here. Why is goverment not thinking about taxation of remittance ?
U hit the nail on the head with GST increasing and Fuel increasing despite economy shrinking. Some might say that it is a large part of why economy is shrinking and the other major reason would be that the economy had slipped into recession just 4 months before Covid lock downs. There has been no economic initiative from Govt since then apart from raising all taxes on Fuel and Govt utilities to achieve their own income requirements. This leaves less money in everyone's pocket and not much hope to increase salary or income.
As long as correct data does not come out ,it is not possible to analyse or plan for future. We started meddling with macro indicators also ,reasons known to some. Dr Subrahmanian swamy once said the figures were inflated by 4.8 percent and no official source contradicted the statement.
Government, instead of boasting its so called good economy, must make policies conducive for foreign investors, since many investors are leaving China and looking elsewhere for investment. Unless we grab the opportunity, our economy continues to lag behind China...
Raw Macro economic Data 2004 to 2014 : GDP increase by 190% 2014 to 2021 : GDP increase by 55% GDP Per Capita Bangladesh beat India , both were affected by COVID Only Adani is growing and rest of Indians are becoming poor
No relief given in Income Tax .Minimum tax level kept at Rs 2.5 lakhs for several years despite inflation and depreciation in value in rupee l. We are really suffering due to high cost of living and at the same time various tax rates are kept high'
People that are buying Portugal Greece citizen they spend close to 4.5 crore each depend on the family you multiply it....Anyone that has a purchasing power he must have close to 100 crore or even more..... if close to 2 lakh people left multiply 2 lakh by 100 crore.... my calculator surrendered couldn't showed figure
Every construction site on a small plot of land starts with Temporary Watchman Shed ( 80 sqft) . First thing installed = Dish Antenna followed by cooking gas
I remember, in year 2008 all the developed countries and gulf countries were all most became poor. Closed banks, lost everyone job, companies closed and etc. That time most of the people in India were well settled. That financial crash didn't effect only one country in the world that was India.
For common man, economy is .. there's big hole in our pockets and our money is going away in the form of costly groceries, GSTs, fuel purchase etc . Who are or is Pappus doesn't matter for us that's for politicians. Control the cost .. we praise you .. if not, we curse you and change you in the next election
For the last three months ,I have my monthly family budjet inreased by 50%.We are finding it difficult to meet both ends.Every thing is costly.There is abundance but we have no money to buyas the cost is escalted beyond our capacity
Mahua Moitra knows very well because she is a representative of the area whose economy depends on 80% businesses as they were on 350 years ago - I mean before the British rule.
When FM herself saying that Government spends 33 billion dollars to curb Rupee volatility that means our economy in distress.
Congratulations to Mahua Moitraji for making the Indian Parliament Proud, by her outstanding arguments! Thank you so much for your demonstrations that will awaken the ignorant minds of some of our narrow minded law makers. God bless you for loving India.
After Manmohan Singh Indian Economy
Couldn’t Touch 10% Growth Rate even
One Year. Who is the Pappu now ? 😊
The biggest Papus are entire gang of Modi.
Bro when manmohan sing was there global growth was high every country was growing fast
Now global growth is 2percent
Manufacturing needs global support also
@@justchill2928 Don't forget 2008 crisis.
Even after changing the equation 😂😂😂
Compare that situation with the world growth rate. If India was doing so well in UPA, then why did India never exceed China's growth rate even once during 2004-2014. In fact, China was growing at roughly about 13% and more during UPA's term. When UPA took over in 2004, trade deficit with China was USD 1.5 Billion. At 2014, when UPA left, it was close to USD 36.2 Billion. Now, it has only increased to $72 Billion. UPA was able to show growth rate by incurring 30x trade deficit with China. What good came out of it? I would have been happy if UPA cut down its growth to improve local manufacturing.
Brilliantly explained Sujit Nair Ji 🙏🏼🙏🏼👌👌 Thanks for being so simplistic while talking in layman’s language, but surely on a highly serious topic 👍🏼👍🏼
Our FM is a floating Minister.😡😡🙏
😀
The real Pappu is Nirmala Sitaraman. Knows nothing of finance
On the contrary, she knows a lot.... especially how to please those who will keep her in power. mind you, she does not need to help the common man, she only needs to make her rich clients richer and richest.
You are right?
Absolutely clear the current Indian economy is in distress. Demand has slumped leading to a viscous cycle. 12 lakh high net worth individuals gave up Indian citizenship in the last 8 years. Hope India FM is able to turn around this situation 😞
All I know is that. Nirmala had black hair before demonetization and GST. Then the onions hit the fan.
Always Mr Nair analysis is Cristal clear to audience to understand. 👏👏👏
Wow!! Such a beautiful explanation and most importantly unbiased. Very few we get to see like these. Cheers Mate!
A storm is coming...
Unfortunately GST on necessary products is very high like medicine , insurance, hospital bill milk, curd etc...good editorial.You are the best Mr Nair
Our FM know 🔔about economy
As usual it was informative/interesting editorial.
I remember aggressive Nirmala before 2014...but now she looks completely confused,with zero confidence...Is she competent 2b FM of India?
The days are coming when this.Govt will find this poor India too hot to handle..
That is very comprehensive. Thank you.
Thank you Nair ji for explaining and simplifying the issues hardly faced the people of India.
FM Nirmala Sitharaman is not inclined to give straight answers to the questions put to her on economic affairs. She rather devotes her energy to put counter questions , and relishes in deflecting the focus to other innuendos and whataboutery. Her loud claims on rapid growth of economy under the current regime fail to inspire confidence of the members of the opposition parties in Parliament. The track records in the management of economy are not at all inspiring and convincing.
Adani assett @ 2014 was 57000 crore,,,,,in 2022 he's worth 200000 lakh crore,,,hmmmm somebody is having acche-din
He may be No 1 soon 😖
Soon he will own India. Busy off everything.
India is heading towards a North Korea model and not a US model
Great editorial!
Mr.Nair, in reality these are all blunder of inflation come down. Yes as far as vegetables as growth is more price down. Few months back Tomato was Rs.125.00 because of damage by rain. Now vegetables prices are a bit down. But I tell you all the pulses increase of 12% over the earlier price. Potato chips was Rs.88.00 now they put Rs.98.00. I buy chole channa half a kilo Rs.70.00 now I was charged Rs.80.00.
GST 18% on Insurance Premium. Is it justified? With out any thing of service GST charged. It should have been 5% standard for all service. Proudly saying GST increase is laughing thing. Shameless.
Correct Regarding Textiles the prices increased by 30% last 2 years, the sale volume decreased by 25%.so gst increased due to price rise.not only that many items gst rates increased and many goods came to tax net. The govt is fooling the people.
No one in the BJP speak the truth
BOTTOM LINE: 130 CRORE population becoming POOR 😢 and POORER and Cash 💵 less POCKETS 😭
Superrrrrrrrr dealing by smt MM & Mr. Nair.
Great explanation.. Vsir
Who is Papu?
Our FM occupying a responsible post in Indian government did not know why Indian Ruppe is falling, let alone the price of Onion.
Congrats to Sujit Nair of HW news channel for highlighting about Indian Economy and he also explains well as to what is Economy and how it works.
Simple to follow explanation of some aspects of a complex subject. Thanks Sujit.
Fantastic editorial
Paper vote is the only solution Evm should be for citizens out of India
How mismanagement of not so bad Indian economics status leading to avoidable unemployment, devastating inflation, shrink foreign investment, disturbing rise in people straining below poverty line is explained using common man's vocabulary ...common people can now understand that they suffer not because they are mismanaging their meager fund but government is not efficiently managing their fiscal sources.
Thanks to Surjit Nayar
That is exactly what this govt wants!!! 5 rich Indians to fund electoral bonds and remain crores of people atbtheir mercy
Canada attracting immigrants from India who move with 20 to 25 lakhs. These Indians are spending money in Canada and paying Tax to Canada
The speech by Ms. Moitra threw lot of questions and at least now the govt should understand they have to understand the requirement as rulers and not slinging mud on others.
Excellent explanation. Thank you.
Speciality of this Govt , is no record , unemployment no record , disaster of Covid , no record , economy good or bad , no record , all good , goody goody is India
That's why they call themselves *"NDA = NO DATA AVAILABLE"*
Thank you sir. You explained our situation clearly our economic position very clearly.
Excellent, Excellent, Excellent 💕👌🙏
Many don't realize the issue of taking citizenship by the rich in other countries? We are in our own dreamland as the governments create wonderful dreams everyday, hiding facts. Nice episode.
Saab pardesh ab 10 saal me hi gaye hey kya?
The numbers have gone up and the rich are moving out . Earlier people used to go for better earnings and settle their once become rich.
Great Sujit.
Keep it Simple Dikra! No Cash 💰 inflow - No FDI and wealthy Indians running 🏃♂️ away and renouncing Indian citizenships 😱
Reduced foreign remittances by Indian workers in Gulf countries - hence cannot offset cost of “Crude” Oil imports plus + plus + plus + 😬😭🥵🤬😴
Why dont you do an editorial about the Mundra port scandal???
Excellent Sir your connect is very genuine one, hope we get one when everything is on positive
One of the 12,43,000 people who took up foreign citizenship since 2014 has interviewed PM and asked him "Kya aap aam khaate hain?" - proving to India that he may have Red Dil but he definitely has Zubaan kesari
Good communication skills !!!
Excellent analysis full truth of the facts and reality of sickening Indian Economy and all time high inflation rate and mass migration of Wealth Creators.
God only should save India.
Thank you
Only Yours respected…….!!
Mr N Modi is the real “PAPPU”
Now Parliament also acknowledged.
Wonderful Spectacles & IceCream example sir, now it brings more clarity. Because of this only more Indian citizens go to other countries citizenship.
Lacs of Indians in USA in the queue for citizenship of USA i e they have virtually left India and is only a matter of time to leave Indian citizenship.
Very well explained by Sujit Nair!
Very well explained. 👌👏
Wow...such a simple explanation which I can dreamnt off....
Nation wants to know
Who's asli pappu??
Who gave maachis to the paagal to burn the basti??
Hope the people will understand before it's too late 🙏
Thats Ambani & Adani who gave the maachis to the paagal to burn down the basthi. Its not the people who gave the maachis.
Not ambani or adnani its thr people of India who voted the idiots in power and not just gave the the matchbox but also the gasoline to burn our country and economy to the ground
Best Editorial presentation
....
18 rupees in my hand is productive, but in the hand of the government is commodity of consumption. A government that gloats over high tax collection is eating up the seed for the next crop
Very good & simple explaination.
Problem is we say economy is growing, GDP raising but none of prices are coming down. I see the increase of remittances is the biggest issue, and these remittances are not getting taxed. The remittance only add to GDP of country.
If a family stays here and their children send them per month 1 lakh, isn't it their income why is there no cap of tax on such remittances.
I see lot of youth moving to other countries sending money and buying assests here. What about people who stay here contribute to people by paying income tax here. Why is goverment not thinking about taxation of remittance ?
Good explanation.sir
U hit the nail on the head with GST increasing and Fuel increasing despite economy shrinking. Some might say that it is a large part of why economy is shrinking and the other major reason would be that the economy had slipped into recession just 4 months before Covid lock downs. There has been no economic initiative from Govt since then apart from raising all taxes on Fuel and Govt utilities to achieve their own income requirements. This leaves less money in everyone's pocket and not much hope to increase salary or income.
Excellent
Very informative coverage and worthy eye opening discussions. Thanks.
Thank you for such unbiased simplistic information.
Very good presentation
Excellent edition 👌
Excellent way of explaining
Sir thanks good explanation but pm have ordered for his dress for presenting g 20 not delivering in time who is to question idiotic government
Thank you for this news
Thank you sujit sir stay safe
sujit ji fine job
Achor good speach ,he has talking everithing indian politics ,big salute
As long as correct data does not come out ,it is not possible to analyse or plan for future. We started meddling with macro indicators also ,reasons known to some. Dr Subrahmanian swamy once said the figures were inflated by 4.8 percent and no official source contradicted the statement.
Sir salute you .
Yes, power 💪💪💪💪of economy comes🌍🌍 from you are me.... Good quotes....
Hit the nail on the head
This central government make Indians barbad
❤❤India requires an educated PRIME minister.
Very well explained
Government, instead of boasting its so called good economy, must make policies conducive for foreign investors, since many investors are leaving China and looking elsewhere for investment. Unless we grab the opportunity, our economy continues to lag behind China...
Raw Macro economic Data
2004 to 2014 : GDP increase by 190%
2014 to 2021 : GDP increase by 55%
GDP Per Capita Bangladesh beat India , both were affected by COVID
Only Adani is growing and rest of Indians are becoming poor
Sailaji, when the GDP was introduced? Which year?
Good explanation
Enthusiastic edition.Why the present Politicians not understanding.
Create wealth in right way and be safe in India
No relief given in Income Tax .Minimum tax level kept at Rs 2.5 lakhs for several years despite inflation and depreciation in value in rupee l. We are really suffering due to high cost of living and at the same time various tax rates are kept high'
gooood analysis...
People that are buying Portugal Greece citizen they spend close to 4.5 crore each depend on the family you multiply it....Anyone that has a purchasing power he must have close to 100 crore or even more..... if close to 2 lakh people left multiply 2 lakh by 100 crore.... my calculator surrendered couldn't showed figure
They are happy living in another country than living among andh bhakts
Every construction site on a small plot of land starts with Temporary Watchman Shed ( 80 sqft) . First thing installed = Dish Antenna followed by cooking gas
I remember, in year 2008 all the developed countries and gulf countries were all most became poor. Closed banks, lost everyone job, companies closed and etc. That time most of the people in India were well settled. That financial crash didn't effect only one country in the world that was India.
Educated MPs in BJP must hear the details of economy status and act accordingly with their conscious at least for Indian values.
Nice
For common man, economy is .. there's big hole in our pockets and our money is going away in the form of costly groceries, GSTs, fuel purchase etc . Who are or is Pappus doesn't matter for us that's for politicians. Control the cost .. we praise you .. if not, we curse you and change you in the next election
Hi Sujit Nair - thanks for explaining in layman's language.
Public is the culprit, for deficit : let us take more time to realise😅
By the time we all realise, we already b a beggars 😀
Finance Minister is weak in economics, accountability..
Indians who are working out of India are very happy because conversion rate is very high. Value of rupee is reduced a lot. One US dollar =82 rupees.
GOOD ANALYSIS.INDUSTRIAL PRODUCTION DROPPED SO ECONOMY IS DOWN ALL OVER WORLD.INDIA IS IN DENIAL.
For the last three months ,I have my monthly family budjet inreased by 50%.We are finding it difficult to meet both ends.Every thing is costly.There is abundance but we have no money to buyas the cost is escalted beyond our capacity
Mahua Moitra knows very well because she is a representative of the area whose economy depends on 80% businesses as they were on 350 years ago - I mean before the British rule.