Watercolor Comparison Potter's Pink: Schmincke, Daniel Smith, Maimeri, Roman Szmal, Winsor & Newton

Поделиться
HTML-код
  • Опубликовано: 4 дек 2024

Комментарии • 46

  • @marlbboro8091
    @marlbboro8091 Год назад +3

    2 years later and my first potters pink (Roman Szmal ) is on its way from Jackson’s. And here is your relevant video . sometimes you just gotta love your listening devices and the algorithm 💃❤️

  • @michaelklein5242
    @michaelklein5242 Год назад +4

    Thanks for the demo! I got a tube of the Cotman's Potters Pink because I get a discount through school. I love this stuff! Finally, I was able to get just the right hue and texture for the sand on my beach project, mixing the pink and burnt sienna. It came out just how I wanted it. I see this will be a go to color for me!

    • @LowKey_izildura
      @LowKey_izildura Год назад +1

      Cotman has Potter`s pink? I never knew that

  • @ligaskirbauska8652
    @ligaskirbauska8652 2 года назад +7

    Schmincke is like a bit more concentrated version of W&N,goes bit darker..it’s also very pretty in mixes..I have Schminke and Roman Szmal,tempted to get W&N next to try when these will be over

  • @happymv5350
    @happymv5350 3 года назад +6

    Love your comparison approach. More please!!

  • @everartokelli
    @everartokelli 4 года назад +10

    I have the DS Potter's Pink, which I love using and I enjoy how it's fairly neutral and it works beautifully in landscapes. I'd probably get the WN version in the future because of how much cooler it is, but they all look delicious :) Thanks for comparing these Potter's Pinks!

  • @lindsayjayne2169
    @lindsayjayne2169 3 года назад +3

    This was super helpful, thankyou!! I was debating on the Roman Szmal and seeing it here.. I love it!💖

  • @morgenmachen2400
    @morgenmachen2400 3 года назад +6

    That Schmincke is beautiful!

  • @angiewright-artist8246
    @angiewright-artist8246 3 года назад +5

    I currently own the daniel smith version, I love the winsor and Newton. The roman schmall is beautiful too!

  • @mariram
    @mariram 4 года назад +4

    Thanks for the video! I have a Maimeri Blu one. And always wanted to compare it to Winsor and Newton. But now can't justify getting it. They look so similar here!

  • @INCWorks
    @INCWorks 4 года назад +5

    It's so cool to see all of these side by side. I just recently got my first 'Potter's Pink' (Schmincke) and was curious how it compares to others. Really interesting to see how Roman Szmal's is quite a bit different. If I were to pick one from this sampling, I'd choose Winsor & Newton's - very pretty.

  • @firecloud6503
    @firecloud6503 3 года назад +6

    The Roman Szmal looks interesting. I‘ve got the W&N and the DS one at home. Potters Pink is a great colour.

    • @jaimeanderson9238
      @jaimeanderson9238  3 года назад +2

      It really is versatile. I think you chose good ones.

  • @glorioskiola
    @glorioskiola 3 года назад

    Very helpful, thanks. I’ve wanted to add this to my collection. Nice to see the differences.

  • @ajc2268
    @ajc2268 2 года назад +1

    Nice comparison. Thank you. Which paper pad are you using?

  • @natford8271
    @natford8271 3 года назад +2

    I think I prefer the W&N. It seems to go down more smoothly.

  • @nadeaner.cowley513
    @nadeaner.cowley513 4 года назад +1

    Great comparison. Thanks for sharing❤

  • @flyinghaggertys9362
    @flyinghaggertys9362 4 года назад +2

    Wonderful comparison! Which one do you prefer?

    • @jaimeanderson9238
      @jaimeanderson9238  4 года назад +5

      Thank you! That is such a hard question. Probably Winsor & Newton because it's nearly as granulating as Daniel Smith but it's cooler, which I prefer.

    • @flyinghaggertys9362
      @flyinghaggertys9362 4 года назад +1

      @@jaimeanderson9238 whew! Lol I have that one. I know it’s so impossible to pick one when they’re all a bit different.

    • @jaimeanderson9238
      @jaimeanderson9238  4 года назад

      @@flyinghaggertys9362 It really is a great one and I know what you mean :)

  • @FaerieDust
    @FaerieDust 4 года назад +4

    I've only got the Schmincke version, but I think the W&N would be my perfect middle ground if I was getting just one of them - I like that it's rosier than Schmincke and DS (DS looks especially brown compared to the others), but still darker than the RS. The RS looks like a really lovely pink, but I kind of expect potter's pink to have a touch more brown to it - I'd love to have it, but not as my only potter's pink.

  • @ArtWorkOfDR
    @ArtWorkOfDR 4 года назад +3

    Never used potters pink but it looks lovely

    • @jaimeanderson9238
      @jaimeanderson9238  4 года назад +2

      It's a lovely dusty rose color that is highly granulating but it's power is in mixes:)

  • @suzanneproulx8768
    @suzanneproulx8768 4 года назад +3

    My favorite is Windsor Newton

  • @PaintinHiding
    @PaintinHiding 4 года назад +1

    i was recently looking get a potter's pink, this was so helpful! thank you so much!! is the roman szmal one hard to rewet? from your metal palette clanking a lot, it seems like it's difficult..?

    • @jaimeanderson9238
      @jaimeanderson9238  4 года назад +2

      I'm so glad:) No it rewets fairly easily. I have some pans in the middle of my palette that aren't snapped in because I ran out of space.

    • @PaintinHiding
      @PaintinHiding 4 года назад

      @@jaimeanderson9238 ahhhh i see, i have that issue too. thank you so much for your reply! i think i'll go with the roman szmal one since it looks so pretty being the 'pinkest' of them all.

  • @giespel68
    @giespel68 Год назад

    Nice comparison:) Tip: tape your paper down so you have your hands free and the paper won't move

  • @marjoriejohnson6535
    @marjoriejohnson6535 Год назад

    How about granulation with W & N

  • @bilgeizgin
    @bilgeizgin 3 года назад +1

    Great video, thanks! Although I'd love to see the close-ups more slowly :)

    • @jaimeanderson9238
      @jaimeanderson9238  3 года назад +1

      Thank you! I'll try to do that on my future videos, thank you for the feedback :)

    • @bilgeizgin
      @bilgeizgin 3 года назад

      @@jaimeanderson9238 You're welcome! I'm looking forward to seeing more content from you. Take care!

    • @CobraDove1111
      @CobraDove1111 3 года назад +1

      Me too....less camera moving

  • @aykatman
    @aykatman 3 года назад

    Hi! May I ask what size is the Roman Szmal pan? I'm wondering how many particles would fit in my palette :^)