The Totem of Undying applied to this theory is even more fascinating. 'Totem like biome' happenstantially leads me towards the thought aswell. The totem of undying may not have been an attempt to cheat death, but to instead, harness the life force of others to restore that of the Illagers, once stolen by the Creaking Heart.
I bet it's a combination of gold and resin and soul Magic illegar have been tapping into soul Magic experiments like this guy said the pale Garden was originally a dark oak forest it's probably Dumping Ground for the failed experiment creaking heart in a way the illager followed the ancient builders too dam well since the ancient Builders were messing around with soul Magic and soul sand research and end up making the Wither
I do like that the Creaking has tendrils on its head like the Warden. You know a mob is intimidating when a weeping-angel-wood-spirit version of it is tame by comparison. It also might be a coincidence but when I found the pale garden, because of the altitude at which it generated, there turned out to be an ancient city beneath it. It felt very fitting to find them together.
So this is what Wifies has been up to in his spare time while parrot was off amalgamating factions to unite an army in the farlands, what an exciting revelation 😂💀
The explanation of the illagers skin being gray because their life force is being drained also could tie into the official minecraft video where they say the they are called Ill-agers for a reason (they basically implied that they are ill/sick and this is the reason why they are gray)
@@kvp2249 i was about to comment this lmao RetroGamingNow has way better lore imo Game Theory's lore is very sensationalist, it doesnt sound as serious as RGN's lore theories
SUPER interesting stuff for SURE!! Thanks for the vid @ Wifies! P.s. My jaw DROPPED whenever you made the villager and paleness comparison and stealing the life force and turning them pale WOULD make sooooo much sense tho really! Loved ur thoughts on the creaking!! Thanks again!
I love these theory videos! I used to watch them all the time and I hadn't realized until recently how much of it I've just accepted as what happened in the games lore, the stuff about the endermen especially. I really like how they tie back to each other
I want to point out a crucial fact: -The Creaking doesn't attack ANY MOB but the player. I could make the case that the sheeps made the creaking because they aren't attacked by them and doesn't fear them.
I think it only attacks those that it thinks of as a threat, so it doesn't attack the Illagers because just creating the Creaking is enough to scare them, so why waste energy chasing them
1:pigglins have fear of campfires because gases produced by the pigglinsl is what made nether into this hell 2: the ancient humans do not created directly the warden, they created its portal to try to escape from the wither and released the warden 3: pillagers lore are explained in minecraft legends, so I do believe in your teory that the pillagers created the creaking, but they where not villagers back there
The only Pale Garden I've found was after around 4~5 hours of exploring and it was literally close to a mansion, thought it was cool and sparked the same idea in my mind
What's really terrifying is that all music and sounds(Except walking if I'm not mistaken) stop when in the pale garden, which adds to the creepiness of the whole thing
I don't know how accurate the game theory minecraft lore is but in the latest video on minecraft they said the illagers were working with the ancient builder to train to defeat the wither. So there could be a chance that if after the warden that they created had gone rouge they made a simular mob aka The creaking. A mob with infinite resistence but if you break the heart it disappiers. The warden is a mob with a lot of health and it also is spawned by a skulk catalist that need to be broken if they want to stop the skulk from spreding. Also the reason for the pale garten could be that there was either a traiter or another illager who brought the creacing heart to the dark oak forest to extract resin and it spreed to the surrounding trees or they had put so many hearts in one spot that the power of the creaking heart consumed the trees in an attempt to make the trees its puppets.The motivation could change from being to copy the ancient builders to help them and become a part of their history or something like that. I believe that this theory most likely isn't true but I would love to get some feedback and also great video and I hope you will make great videos like this one.
why do illagers attack villagers then in raids. And if the illagers were able to harness life its self wouldn't they have created more technology's like trying to find the missing builders or exploring world.I think something is missing in the story, like why would the now illagers copy the players that went missing. and if the ancient builders had to run from the wither[ made of soul sand where did that come from] how did the villagers survive i have more questions then answers why do creepers run from cats.
there is a thing that proves the villagers got pale because of the pale garden, when mojang was creating the illagers they tought of "SICK villagers" that makes the story how they become pale with more sense, they got sick because of the pale garden
Great video, your conclusions are super similar to ones I came up with on my own, with some extra details that really strengthen your theory, very well done as always
I think the pale garden and warped forest were made by the End influances, and the illagers learned not to mess with the Broken God after they failed to conquer the End in Minecraft Dungons.
YES this is what we need for those of us that aren't the biggest fan of the creaking. it compensates for LOOOOOOORRRRRRRRRREEEEEEEE, and if you already like the creaking its like a double win.
There’s two bits missing: why do hostile mobs spawn in the pale garden? Skulk can use their essence to grow, so it says there’s something different about hostile and passive/player mob energy. The other is related: why don’t “good” mobs cause resin to generate? For example, an iron golem. Iron golems are associated with peaceful mobs, whose energy the heart sucked out of the garden. One final question, and I think this is a big one: why aren’t ravagers afraid of the creaking when all other Illagers are? There’s a stronger relationship between the ravager and the creaking than this video implies.
Wifies what if the creaking resin acts like spores from mushrooms and can spread too far away dark oak forests? Which is why there are different pale gardens all around your world.
I have an idea but it might not make sense. What if the creaking hearts the heart of herobrine or the essence of his power to control mobs like puppets? Since herobrine is a all powerful being, he could have put some of his mind controlling powers into a dark oak log and the power corrupts it making the creaking heart
2:00 Actually the bloom but no spread is also triggered by the *any* mob or entity that dosn't drop XP on death, i.e. villagers. ... The bloom is powered by souls, but the spread is powered by exp. ... BTW, Exp has nothing to do with the dead, because it isn't unique to the dead!
SPOILER WARNING! I absolutely love this theory. It connects the dots so well! And the little detail, about illagers' skin color losing life... melted me
260 Comments and only 2 likes...? Either YT fuckin up, or people aren't stepping up and showing enough support. Come on guys, give the man some likes for all his effort he put in for all of us.
a few questions I got Why are there multiple hearts if illagers created it? why would they repeat their mistake time after time? Couldn't have their smart and curious minds figure out Creakings don't move if looked at?
I have an even better theory, more grounded: -Illagers need wood for their conquest, and live in Dark Forest. -They try to grab wood from Pale Garden, and get their ass kicked to fright. That's about it.
"the creaking is a scrapped walmart version of the warden"/"there has always been one group of mobs dead set on making walmart versions of ancient builder inventions"
What Secret is the Wifies Hiding...
:3 ello
Fix Wembu comment like count
What secret is the Wemmbu content hiding…
@@Cartoon079 hewwo :3
Wemmbuuuu!!!!
The Totem of Undying applied to this theory is even more fascinating. 'Totem like biome' happenstantially leads me towards the thought aswell.
The totem of undying may not have been an attempt to cheat death, but to instead, harness the life force of others to restore that of the Illagers, once stolen by the Creaking Heart.
What if then totem of undying isn't made out of gold but instead...resin
@pie662 Wow, that'd be crazy
and that's why they're hostile to villagers, they want to take their life away from them to replenish their own
I bet it's a combination of gold and resin and soul Magic illegar have been tapping into soul Magic experiments like this guy said the pale Garden was originally a dark oak forest it's probably Dumping Ground for the failed experiment creaking heart in a way the illager followed the ancient builders too dam well since the ancient Builders were messing around with soul Magic and soul sand research and end up making the Wither
@J0hnzie in a way it's a consequence of their own soul research
I do like that the Creaking has tendrils on its head like the Warden. You know a mob is intimidating when a weeping-angel-wood-spirit version of it is tame by comparison.
It also might be a coincidence but when I found the pale garden, because of the altitude at which it generated, there turned out to be an ancient city beneath it. It felt very fitting to find them together.
MATPAT:Retires
Evrybody: Losses intrest in Minecraft Lore
Wifes: But I'm still standing
everybody: starts to favor unstable universe
this comment was not it dawg 😭
Retrogamingnow is still standing too
Nobody lost interest, matpat had ass theorys
what about tom...
My spine is creaking
That doesn’t seem good
@@kookikidsfamily3347 if you liked the old mincraft just go play it
Mine too 😞💔 also my knees 💔
I was increasingly getting excited at the end, and when u mentioned the pillager grey skin link I just FREAked oUt
Plot twist the creaking is haunted by Deanthebean9
noooooooo
bro😭😭😭
greenbean13
DUN DUN DUUUUN
Who is that?
So this is what Wifies has been up to in his spare time while parrot was off amalgamating factions to unite an army in the farlands, what an exciting revelation 😂💀
The explanation of the illagers skin being gray because their life force is being drained also could tie into the official minecraft video where they say the they are called Ill-agers for a reason (they basically implied that they are ill/sick and this is the reason why they are gray)
This is my go-to Minecraft lore theorist channel. Ever since Mat Pat left, so did the interesting lore. Thanks for continuing his legacy.
FR not to be mean but Tom really doesn't cut it
check retrogaming
@@kvp2249 i was about to comment this lmao RetroGamingNow has way better lore imo
Game Theory's lore is very sensationalist, it doesnt sound as serious as RGN's lore theories
Mine is RetroGamingNow.
@grandmasteryoda6717 oh he's super cool too, he takes an eerier spin on the lore
SUPER interesting stuff for SURE!! Thanks for the vid @ Wifies!
P.s.
My jaw DROPPED whenever you made the villager and paleness comparison and stealing the life force and turning them pale WOULD make sooooo much sense tho really! Loved ur thoughts on the creaking!! Thanks again!
I think it’s weird that they just form nowhere ads a mob that is like horror themed🤔
i think the creaking not attacking the illagers is kind of a plot hole in the final story tho
Wifies can make lore out of thin air
Fr tho
The "scrapped Walmart Version of the warden" got me laughing 😂
Came here to say this too, what a great line 😂
The secret of the Creaking is almost as secret as Mojang's eula changes
14:58 YOOOO THIS IS GENIUS
VIRGIN creaking vs CHAD warden
16:31 Pure Wifies nostalgia.
Let’s just hope that 1.23 finally gives the Illagers a redemption.
Man this was fire it just makes so much sense thanks wifies i appreciate you
14:41 Actually blew my mind off
I love these theory videos! I used to watch them all the time and I hadn't realized until recently how much of it I've just accepted as what happened in the games lore, the stuff about the endermen especially. I really like how they tie back to each other
I want to point out a crucial fact:
-The Creaking doesn't attack ANY MOB but the player.
I could make the case that the sheeps made the creaking because they aren't attacked by them and doesn't fear them.
I think it only attacks those that it thinks of as a threat, so it doesn't attack the Illagers because just creating the Creaking is enough to scare them, so why waste energy chasing them
1:pigglins have fear of campfires because gases produced by the pigglinsl is what made nether into this hell
2: the ancient humans do not created directly the warden, they created its portal to try to escape from the wither and released the warden
3: pillagers lore are explained in minecraft legends, so I do believe in your teory that the pillagers created the creaking, but they where not villagers back there
Minecraft is now a horror game, and I love it
🧑🚀 Always was
always was
OH SHIT THAT'S WHY THE ILLAGERS ARE GREY! wow great theory!
The Creaking Heart is Herobrine's Heart put in a tree and the creaking is his puppet...
ngl, i did not expect wifies to COOK this hard.
how tf did he manage to connect the pale garden to the illagers so eloquently 😭
wifies i watch these all the way through! Love your vids! Keep up the good work!
When truth behind youtuber "wifies"😂
The only Pale Garden I've found was after around 4~5 hours of exploring and it was literally close to a mansion, thought it was cool and sparked the same idea in my mind
Which is better? LIKE for Creaking! Comment for Creeper!
wake up wifies uploaded a new video lets go !!!
Thats actually an awesome theory
Yo Babe wake up, Wifies uploaded!
Frfr but not what I was expecting. I was expecting a arg vid😂❤
What's really terrifying is that all music and sounds(Except walking if I'm not mistaken) stop when in the pale garden, which adds to the creepiness of the whole thing
Wifeory is back baby
HELLO INTERNET, welcome to WIFEORY
@@Ins3rtia very good one
Hello internet welcome to wifeory. The show where matpat goes undercover as Wifies to solve the lore of Minecraft
I don't know how accurate the game theory minecraft lore is but in the latest video on minecraft they said the illagers were working with the ancient builder to train to defeat the wither. So there could be a chance that if after the warden that they created had gone rouge they made a simular mob aka The creaking. A mob with infinite resistence but if you break the heart it disappiers. The warden is a mob with a lot of health and it also is spawned by a skulk catalist that need to be broken if they want to stop the skulk from spreding. Also the reason for the pale garten could be that there was either a traiter or another illager who brought the creacing heart to the dark oak forest to extract resin and it spreed to the surrounding trees or they had put so many hearts in one spot that the power of the creaking heart consumed the trees in an attempt to make the trees its puppets.The motivation could change from being to copy the ancient builders to help them and become a part of their history or something like that. I believe that this theory most likely isn't true but I would love to get some feedback and also great video and I hope you will make great videos like this one.
This was an epic video! Keep up the good content :)
Wifies is the new game theory for minecraft, quite literaly
Great vid
The creaking heart turning what would be illagers pale from villagers was something I did not expect to happen.
14:41 Mind blown
In the Mojang Office Party event, one of the mini games mentions that the Pale Garden is corrupting other biomes
why do illagers attack villagers then in raids. And if the illagers were able to harness life its self wouldn't they have created more technology's like trying to find the missing builders or exploring world.I think something is missing in the story, like why would the now illagers copy the players that went missing. and if the ancient builders had to run from the wither[ made of soul sand where did that come from] how did the villagers survive i have more questions then answers why do creepers run from cats.
Do you consider official minecraft lore?
Wifies has filled the matpat shaped whole in my heart
Dude can I just say how much I love these videos???
Also the audio at the beginning of the vid with headphones on made ma’ brain tickle.
Wifies is literally the best Minecraft RUclipsr tbh
there is a thing that proves the villagers got pale because of the pale garden, when mojang was creating the illagers they tought of "SICK villagers" that makes the story how they become pale with more sense, they got sick because of the pale garden
Back with another banger
Great video, your conclusions are super similar to ones I came up with on my own, with some extra details that really strengthen your theory, very well done as always
I think the pale garden and warped forest were made by the End influances, and the illagers learned not to mess with the Broken God after they failed to conquer the End in Minecraft Dungons.
YES this is what we need for those of us that aren't the biggest fan of the creaking. it compensates for LOOOOOOORRRRRRRRRREEEEEEEE, and if you already like the creaking its like a double win.
Love ur role in the unstable universe series with parrot :)
7:04 it's racisim dark to pale
The fact fact that the Illagers wield AXES now, the tool used against trees makes a lot of sense in this theory.
There’s two bits missing: why do hostile mobs spawn in the pale garden? Skulk can use their essence to grow, so it says there’s something different about hostile and passive/player mob energy. The other is related: why don’t “good” mobs cause resin to generate? For example, an iron golem. Iron golems are associated with peaceful mobs, whose energy the heart sucked out of the garden.
One final question, and I think this is a big one: why aren’t ravagers afraid of the creaking when all other Illagers are? There’s a stronger relationship between the ravager and the creaking than this video implies.
“A weeping angel of sorts…” wow, very subtle.
my favorite part was when he creaked all over the place
I absolutely love these theory analysis vidios
Great original Story for Illagers, but minecraft legends exists
Wifies what if the creaking resin acts like spores from mushrooms and can spread too far away dark oak forests? Which is why there are different pale gardens all around your world.
I have an idea but it might not make sense. What if the creaking hearts the heart of herobrine or the essence of his power to control mobs like puppets? Since herobrine is a all powerful being, he could have put some of his mind controlling powers into a dark oak log and the power corrupts it making the creaking heart
5:36 It's always the rich people, who are the villains
2:00 Actually the bloom but no spread is also triggered by the *any* mob or entity that dosn't drop XP on death, i.e. villagers.
...
The bloom is powered by souls, but the spread is powered by exp.
...
BTW,
Exp has nothing to do with the dead, because it isn't unique to the dead!
But why doesn't the pale garden continue to expand?
Another thing to note is that the creaking his tendrils that look suspiciously like the wardens
What the chances of both him and Retrogamingnow posted lore theorys in the same week bro.
This also explains where the Illagers came from.
SPOILER WARNING!
I absolutely love this theory. It connects the dots so well! And the little detail, about illagers' skin color losing life... melted me
Next Year: Five Nights at Garden's - Secret of the Creaking
There isn't any comments for the first 17 mins after the video is released because everyone is locked in watching wifes
260 Comments and only 2 likes...?
Either YT fuckin up, or people aren't stepping up and showing enough support. Come on guys, give the man some likes for all his effort he put in for all of us.
yes, wifies posted about the new snapshot!!
I have a companion Creaking named "Douglas Fir". He's a living tree.
0:36 The game theoriests: hmm i think the name look very familiar
Wow this is awesome thanks wifies!
a few questions I got
Why are there multiple hearts if illagers created it? why would they repeat their mistake time after time?
Couldn't have their smart and curious minds figure out Creakings don't move if looked at?
wifies description of creaking: "Walmart version of the warden" lol
WAFFLE HOUSE
WIFFLE HOUSE!
I have an even better theory, more grounded:
-Illagers need wood for their conquest, and live in Dark Forest.
-They try to grab wood from Pale Garden, and get their ass kicked to fright.
That's about it.
Nah, you and Tom gotta do a collab on Game Theory.
wifies' the matpat for minecraft now
2:34 like Dark Remembrance, from creepypasta!
WIFTHEORY HAS RETURNED
The rest of the video 🤔
The last 5 minutes 💀
Thank for making this you made my day A bit better Cause I got Hurt
Ah yes, Reverse Enderman
YES! Another wifies video!
Alright fellow zombies, let’s try to recreate what these illagers did because that looks awesome, just gotta study this creaking thing
I'll be honest, if your Ender Dragon video was anything to go by, I'm a little hesitant to take your theory videos at face value.
Wifies is slowly turning into RetroGamingNow 🤔
"the creaking is a scrapped walmart version of the warden"/"there has always been one group of mobs dead set on making walmart versions of ancient builder inventions"
I wouldn’t destroy the heart if the creaking wasn’t attacking though…
some would call it... Dark Wood
Hello internet. Welcome to wifeory!
And thats how totems are made ladies and gentlemen.
Ah yes, the reverse enderman