i already told you my feedback in another comment so i won't say it again but i really appreciate your hard work, and you explained things really properly and since i am here i might as well subscribe hoping to see more good content from your side good luck
hello i agree with the poor Management there is clear evidence that Harry has Asthma is a condition in which the airways narrow and swell and may produce extra mucus. This can make breathing difficult and trigger coughing, wheezing when breathing out and shortness of breath that affects 1 in 12 people of all ages.Whilst the severity of the symptoms vary and can heavily impact a person’s life Management would withhold meds that would help him breath or have him preform with ill knowing it would lead to an Asthma attack. i would recomend the channel My Mind My Mood for more details
I think this video will educate many people about what the music industry is, that they stop believing everything that comes out in a newspaper or in an interview. The industry is controlling and there are still many shady things that need to be brought to light.
Very well made. It’s horrible what these guys went through. We just didn’t know it at the time. It’s a miracle they all turned out as well as they have. I can’t imagine the intense pressures they felt.
@@debrasnipes7431YOU JUST DON'T GET IT!!!! FAME AND MONEY DOESN'T MAKE PEOPLE HAPPY. I KNOW LOTS OF RICH PEOPLE WHO ENDED UP DYING ALONE!!! THEY USUALLY DON'T HAVE REAL FRIENDS. JUST A BUNCH OF LOSERS AND USERS WHO ARE WITH THEM FOR THEIR MONEY.
I'm not surprised at any of what you mentioned occurring. The problem is they were just young kids going through it. Your brain doesn't have the maturity to deal with the complexities of being an image verses who you really are. What a shame. RIP Liam. I heard everyone else is going to keep in touch now and they're worried about Zayn. I hope whatever issues any of them have they can work them out. It is just unacceptable what happened to Liam and so sad that he couldn't be helped. I wonder if Simon has any guilt.
This is so prevalent in the entire entertainment industry. Many (I would say a majority) of minor stars grow up to have issues with addiction, mental health and gender identity and sexuality preference. Twenty years later we are no further than we were back then. I recently watched a video about "Glee" and was sickened by how they were treated. And today three of them have passed away. It makes me wonder if all the money is worth the price of fame.
Poor Liam Payne. He told Fans in Argentina that being in a boy band messed him up. This was right before he died. Liam had been struggling for years with drugs and Alcohol. He would be clean for a while, then relaspe. Unfortunately, this became a pattern in his life. It's so heartbreaking and sad the way Liam died all alone in a Foreign Country, without his girlfriend there to help him. Liam had no real friends with him to help him, at the end. Liam deserved so much better. RIP BEAUTIFUL SWEET LIAM PAYNE 😢 💔 ❤️
Great video! I was watching a gossip video (can't remember which one) and it stated that the fans made up Larry Stylinson. When I made a comment saying " that's incorrect, I am 52 and I clearly remember a interview with Louis and Harry and they stated they came up with the name". My comment was deleted and than I was blocked 🚫
thank you for this video! we need to raise awareness! this happened to them, but this happened to many other celebrities aswell! and I’m sure it still happens to this day to some of them
And yet celebrities are completely irrelevant, if they disappeared nothing would change. It would be very different if doctors, teachers, firefighters disappeared… then we would be in trouble.
Very well done! These talented lads became of age in the public eye - but now that they are all grown men, they seem to have remain grounded and grateful for the lifestyle that fame has brought them. And, they haven’t forgotten where they came from. Love their solo efforts❤.
What a great and informative video. I love the last bit about treating others with kindness. Sadly that is something that many on social media to follow and now we find ourselves here with Liam gone. I would definitely watch if you did a well balanced intake of what was going on in regards to the social media platforms that were going at Liam for various reasons. Although I'd understand that you may feel you don't want to at this time of those who are mourning him.
I'm older and late in becoming obsessed with this fandom so I've binged videos about the band and each member/couple theory trying to learn everything I can about them. Reading between the lines, I had pieces together everything you said in this video so don't really need you to provide proof of any of it, but if I hadn't seen proof elsewhere or already been convinced these things were true, I would be asking you to prove what you said. I'm a skeptical person and need to know the what, when, where, how, and why to satisfy my curiosity and draw my conclusions. That would be my constructive criticism about the video. Otherwise, you had an interesting topic, the formatting was good, and I really enjoyed watching, even if it broke my heart thinking about all the boys went through. They are remarkable people and deserve the world.
This is Totally Awesome, Seems You've got this and it is good for You to Share with us!! Educational and Say's Alot!! Subscribed 6-3-24 12:03 am in US!🦋
At the end of the video, you added sections for each topic you talked about, but not number 5: pressure. Just the small details in videos can make a big difference. Other than that, the video was really good, keep up the great work!
I think this is quite well made and I'm glad you made it. Never could stand Simon 'Cowel from day one of the show. Always thought he was an a hole. He was outright nasty more often then not and enjoyed it. Total Narcissist. Just really disgusting. It's terrible what they did to these kids. I'm old enough to be their mom and if they were my kids and I found out I would be bringing charges against Cowel and company and sueing big time. This is sickening. I hope eventually they all heal emotionally. Makes me sad and angry.🥺😡
oh shut it, they brought in millions and millions of dollars for themselves and had a blast with popularity, awards, girls. Can't imagine any teenage boy saying no to that.
@@LeonGallagher-j1p and you think they would love to get their lives reunined for that trust me ifv they could go back they would just to be normal humans
They are ordinary people with an extraordinary gift to share with the world, and yet no one has the right to treat them as if they are machines or robots. I'm appalled by how management has handled them. If someone is driven to undergo plastic surgery or hair implants because of the relentless pressure, it should make everyone reconsider the intensity of their schedules. This young boy band was formed with such potential, and surely their time could have been managed more flexibly to support a balanced lifestyle, allowing them to maintain a sense of self. It’s disheartening that the industry lacks stricter regulations for talent management. Many of those in positions of authority seem more focused on shaping these young artists to fit a certain mold-without concern for their well-being. This is nothing less than a form of abuse, control, and manipulation that could have a lasting negative impact on their future. It's truly disturbing to see how some misuse their power and evade accountability when their actions have harmful consequences. If one imposes such a grueling lifestyle on others, they should also bear the responsibility. Acknowledging these issues is essential to realizing the need for change and finding ways to prevent similar mistreatment in the future.
“Extraordinary gift”? People who spend their lives helping ones are the ones with an extraordinary gift. These boys were average but the marketing was great.
Seriously...One Direction may have started as "ordinary" boys, but their talent and impeccable marketing and branding transformed them into global superstars. Their success shows how the right strategy can amplify talent into something extraordinary..agree to disagree......
I feel so sorry & sad for what they had gone through from their management. I think their parents should also interfere & protect these young men from overexposure etc😢😢😢
Que vídeo mais esclarecedor. Que triste ver adolescentes extraordinários serem tão manipulados desse jeito. Que eles possam se libertar de todos os fantasmas do passado. Nem tudo o dinheiro pode comprar. a paz, por exemplo.
hello i agree with the poor Management there is clear evidence that Harry has Asthma is a condition in which the airways narrow and swell and may produce extra mucus. This can make breathing difficult and trigger coughing, wheezing when breathing out and shortness of breath that affects 1 in 12 people of all ages.Whilst the severity of the symptoms vary and can heavily impact a person’s life Management would withhold meds that would help him breath or have him preform with ill knowing it would lead to an Asthma attack. i would recomend the channel My Mind My Mood for more details
Simon has a lot to answer to how he treated them when they were younger he took there teenage life away from them and completely over worked them then had the cheek to lock them up at night they must have missed there family's TERRIBLY He also had to be there for them all and look after them god rest Liam sole R.I.P YOUNG MAN what a great man you were and your singing was absolutely Beautiful xx
well all this comes with fam the parents should’ve been on tour too but simon was told something cause he straighten up a lot and now we see liam was already an user of drugs so now he is gone i wonder if anyone else took em in the group
one direction were not a band , a band can play musical instruments , they were a pop vocal group who were controlled by the record company to the point of destroying the mental health of the boys and the eventual death of one of the members of said vocal group. I'm not a fan of the boys music , but I see the corruption in the music industry and the destruction that happens , and its not good
Simon is pure evil. Sadly, with boy bands, there’s a lot of abuse. The horror stories of N’Sync and Backstreet Boys, aweful! The Beatles rebelled and did their own thing, but originally they were put in little suits and cut their hair the same way. The Monkees resented the control their creators had over them and their music. Rip Liam. Show biz sucks!
there is a lot of complaining about their not being able to choose their hair, their clothes, etc... but it is a job. it is called work. If you work for a bank, you can't have green hair. if you work for a corporation, you have to wear a suit. if you want to be a pop star, you have to be cute, look trendy and sign autographs. I mean, these guys had a job and that job was to be pop singers and a boy band and they got paid very, very well. Also, pop stars have a short shelf life - the singers get older and lose their baby face cuteness, the teen fans grow up and forget about them. Five years is a good run and five years to make the money before you either retire to a mansion in the country or branch out into a different phase of your music or different career like producing, acting, writing, directing, etc etc...
SORRY, BUT SIMON COWELL IS AN ABUSIVE, MEAN PSYCHOPATH. WAS IT REALLY NECESSARY TO LOCK THE BOYS IN THEIR HOTEL ROOMS AND ISOLATE THEM FROM FRIENDS AND FAMILY MEMBERS??? THAT'S HOW LIAM STARTING DRINKING ALCOHOL 🍸 IN HIS HOTEL ROOM BECAUSE THERE WAS NOTHING ELSE TO DO!! THEN I SEE SIMON COWELL CRYING AT LIAM'S FUNERAL. SIMON WAS LITERALLY CRYING ON LIAM'S DAD'S SHOULDER!!! SIMON SHOULD BE ASHAMED OF HOW HE TREATED LIAM AND THE OTHER BOYS.
a great video you explained things properly every section of your video was covered properly but i think you could have explained the last section in a little more detail especially that shipping thing i know how much that fucked harry and louis over aside from that you covered everything properly thanks for that, i miss them and hope they'll come back one day not as the old band one direction but as friends where all of them will be free and will create and enjoy music together
they LOVE performing (*except Z, though...) so it is irrelevant to portry them as prisoners. I was in the business myself and to work a lot equals happiness, when I do what I love. Their success shows the managment were right - the result proves. Having said that - your end sentence was sopt on.
Agree just think it's the young fandom and it sounds like a dickens novel and they were the golden egg and would have been treated very carefully also closetting is just part and parcel of it to appear straight and that's why fake girlfriends come into it and they would have signed and double signed clauses in contracts not to reveal stuff which is probably normal practice but lou and Harry are still veiwed the same way now when they are so much more than that.
But they could change the management, no? Or they are just THAT traumatised from the being-in-a-band experience that they don't really want to be back again as one? But Liam, Louis and Niall has always said that they wanna come back one day.
@Emīlija Anna Lagzdiņa they can changed record label but the only problem would be that they can't keep the name one directions but if they somehow managed to get all the right of one directions they can moved to better label as group while doing solo at the same time balance solo work and band work similar to how got7 leave jyp.
The boys were minors, and the contracts were signed by their parents. In any case, it was written in the contracts what would be done and in what way. So? Parents should protect their children and should not sign such contracts that abuse minors. Finally, the music industry is always so busy. To all who are involved in this and are successful and not just 1 D. In the end, they were richly repaid for their work both with money and accolades and so everyone can continue as independent contractors. Trust me, none of them would have been successful if they weren't a member of 1D. (except Zayn because he can really sing). Make no mistake: I love 1D and I love their songs, but the truth, in my opinion, is this…
@helenabrglez9234~ That’s just your opinion about Zayn! All of 1D could sing and Harry Styles has proven how important it is to be able to interact with the audience! I love Zayn’s music and I desperately wish he could tour … but even Zayn said how Harry was born to be an entertainer and I agree with Zayn! Have a great weekend! TPWK😽💚🌻💛
I think louis has the best singing voice of 1D only because it is so distinctive compared to the others but I believe all of them have extremely great voices as well their songs as a group are my favorites to listen to apart from louis solo songs since the end of 1D hits talent as a singer songwriter is beyond anything I have ever seen and heard keep the faith louis❤❤❤❤❤❤
@@justwhatilike...234 I love Harry. You are right - he is indeed a good performer, but a good performance is not enough to make him a great singer like Zayn.
I think it was absolutely ridiculous and appalling to label a teenage Harry Styles, as a Womanizer. Simon treated all of the 1D boys like slaves. It's just horrible to abuse teenagers like this. Simon definitely took advantage of them.
This is too negative to listen to Again!! Look, 🌟 Harry 🌟 is Ledgendary!! His Kindness, and so Loving, and Humble! Loving Everyone Unconditionally!! As We Love Him, Unconditionally!! Just My Opinion but there never should have been 5 in 1D. Zayn stated his word's" I never wanted to be in a boy band from the very beginning" He could have bailed then! And never got involved from the very beginning! So why did He? JS maybe He needed some recognizing to be on His Own?! I L.O.V.E. 1D as the 4 of Them! No offense meant, just My Opinion!🦋🌻
The five members auditioned as soloists and were chosen for the band for various reasons. Each of them helped build that band into a global sensation. From Liam's interviews it was clear that what the fans saw was far removed from the reality the boys lived. The foursome, you prefer, chose not continue although they could have carried on if the situation was ideal. Losing a member of a five-piece band is nothing new. It was actually your Harry that pushed for the final hiatus/break which he first brought up in 2014. It was a very toxic work environment that could have been managed differently, and was not sustainable longterm. Please show some compassion for all of the boys, they too are human beings, and it was very courageous of Zayn to walk away from that toxicity no matter how attractive the rewards were.
Alright, this is my first video like that, so leave me some feedback if u want, so I can learn from it for the next time :)
I really like the editing and you went into thorough detail, super helpful!! keep up the good work :))
i already told you my feedback in another comment so i won't say it again but i really appreciate your hard work, and you explained things really properly
and since i am here i might as well subscribe
hoping to see more good content from your side
good luck
Thank you very much, i made some other videos like this, you can find them in my "scripted videos" playlist :)
hello i agree with the poor Management there is clear evidence that Harry has Asthma is a condition in which the airways narrow and swell and may produce extra mucus. This can make breathing difficult and trigger coughing, wheezing when breathing out and shortness of breath that affects 1 in 12 people of all ages.Whilst the severity of the symptoms vary and can heavily impact a person’s life Management would withhold meds that would help him breath or have him preform with ill knowing it would lead to an Asthma attack. i would recomend the channel My Mind My Mood for more details
I think this video will educate many people about what the music industry is, that they stop believing everything that comes out in a newspaper or in an interview. The industry is controlling and there are still many shady things that need to be brought to light.
Very well made. It’s horrible what these guys went through. We just didn’t know it at the time. It’s a miracle they all turned out as well as they have. I can’t imagine the intense pressures they felt.
Since when is becoming a multimillionaire and a global sensation horrible? That doesn’t happen working 9 to 5 Monday through Friday. lol
@@debrasnipes7431 how ignorant of you to not see the full big picture, your only seeing the money💰💰💰💰
@@debrasnipes7431YOU JUST DON'T GET IT!!!! FAME AND MONEY DOESN'T MAKE PEOPLE HAPPY. I KNOW LOTS OF RICH PEOPLE WHO ENDED UP DYING ALONE!!! THEY USUALLY DON'T HAVE REAL FRIENDS. JUST A BUNCH OF LOSERS AND USERS WHO ARE WITH THEM FOR THEIR MONEY.
I'm not surprised at any of what you mentioned occurring. The problem is they were just young kids going through it. Your brain doesn't have the maturity to deal with the complexities of being an image verses who you really are. What a shame. RIP Liam. I heard everyone else is going to keep in touch now and they're worried about Zayn. I hope whatever issues any of them have they can work them out. It is just unacceptable what happened to Liam and so sad that he couldn't be helped. I wonder if Simon has any guilt.
I think the form of the band just awful.The connection between bandmate is real,no wonder liam want the reunion cuz they are true friend...
This is so prevalent in the entire entertainment industry. Many (I would say a majority) of minor stars grow up to have issues with addiction, mental health and gender identity and sexuality preference. Twenty years later we are no further than we were back then.
I recently watched a video about "Glee" and was sickened by how they were treated. And today three of them have passed away.
It makes me wonder if all the money is worth the price of fame.
Absolutely the price of fame
Great job! I enjoyed your final message. This should have more views
Poor Liam Payne. He told Fans in Argentina that being in a boy band messed him up. This was right before he died. Liam had been struggling for years with drugs and Alcohol. He would be clean for a while, then relaspe. Unfortunately, this became a pattern in his life. It's so heartbreaking and sad the way Liam died all alone in a Foreign Country, without his girlfriend there to help him. Liam had no real friends with him to help him, at the end. Liam deserved so much better. RIP BEAUTIFUL SWEET LIAM PAYNE 😢 💔 ❤️
where was his family?
I feel bad for the other boys because ppl think they are better but they are struggling too
You did a very good job making this video
Great video! I was watching a gossip video (can't remember which one) and it stated that the fans made up Larry Stylinson. When I made a comment saying " that's incorrect, I am 52 and I clearly remember a interview with Louis and Harry and they stated they came up with the name". My comment was deleted and than I was blocked 🚫
Great important work you did here 🙌🙏
Thank you 🙌
I'm a Directioner since 2012 and while the band was "alive", I had no idea what was actually going on into the band 😢😢😢
thank you for this video! we need to raise awareness! this happened to them, but this happened to many other celebrities aswell! and I’m sure it still happens to this day to some of them
And yet celebrities are completely irrelevant, if they disappeared nothing would change. It would be very different if doctors, teachers, firefighters disappeared… then we would be in trouble.
Very well done! These talented lads became of age in the public eye - but now that they are all grown men, they seem to have remain grounded and grateful for the lifestyle that fame has brought them. And, they haven’t forgotten where they came from. Love their solo efforts❤.
All grown men who are still being controlled 😢
What a great and informative video.
I love the last bit about treating others with kindness. Sadly that is something that many on social media to follow and now we find ourselves here with Liam gone.
I would definitely watch if you did a well balanced intake of what was going on in regards to the social media platforms that were going at Liam for various reasons. Although I'd understand that you may feel you don't want to at this time of those who are mourning him.
Thank you for making this video and acknowledging the struggles that the boys had to go through for our entertainment.🫶🏼
hope you'll like it :)
I'm older and late in becoming obsessed with this fandom so I've binged videos about the band and each member/couple theory trying to learn everything I can about them. Reading between the lines, I had pieces together everything you said in this video so don't really need you to provide proof of any of it, but if I hadn't seen proof elsewhere or already been convinced these things were true, I would be asking you to prove what you said. I'm a skeptical person and need to know the what, when, where, how, and why to satisfy my curiosity and draw my conclusions. That would be my constructive criticism about the video. Otherwise, you had an interesting topic, the formatting was good, and I really enjoyed watching, even if it broke my heart thinking about all the boys went through. They are remarkable people and deserve the world.
Thank uuuu, yeah, and i try to Mention a few more sources next time and then link them too :)
This is Totally Awesome, Seems You've got this and it is good for You to Share with us!! Educational and Say's Alot!! Subscribed 6-3-24 12:03 am in US!🦋
At the end of the video, you added sections for each topic you talked about, but not number 5: pressure. Just the small details in videos can make a big difference. Other than that, the video was really good, keep up the great work!
These are actually auto generated time stamps from youtube, just noticed it, i will correct it, thank u :)
Well done ❤
Bay City Rollers in the 70’s were treated the same way, but it is alleged that BCR’s money went “missing”. So they ended up with nothing.
My goodness
Thank you 💕
Kindness is Contagious!! Start an Epidemic!🦋
I think this is quite well made and I'm glad you made it. Never could stand Simon 'Cowel from day one of the show. Always thought he was an a hole. He was outright nasty more often then not and enjoyed it. Total Narcissist. Just really disgusting. It's terrible what they did to these kids. I'm old enough to be their mom and if they were my kids and I found out I would be bringing charges against Cowel and company and sueing big time. This is sickening. I hope eventually they all heal emotionally. Makes me sad and angry.🥺😡
The fact that one direction is literally biggest money maker for syoc record label but yet they mistreated them so bad.
Lolololololol 🙄🤦♀️
Liam is now dead .The music industry is satanic. Imo.
Wish so badly the boys could speak freely of the abuse.
oh shut it, they brought in millions and millions of dollars for themselves and had a blast with popularity, awards, girls. Can't imagine any teenage boy saying no to that.
@@LeonGallagher-j1p and you think they would love to get their lives reunined for that trust me ifv they could go back they would just to be normal humans
They are ordinary people with an extraordinary gift to share with the world, and yet no one has the right to treat them as if they are machines or robots. I'm appalled by how management has handled them. If someone is driven to undergo plastic surgery or hair implants because of the relentless pressure, it should make everyone reconsider the intensity of their schedules. This young boy band was formed with such potential, and surely their time could have been managed more flexibly to support a balanced lifestyle, allowing them to maintain a sense of self.
It’s disheartening that the industry lacks stricter regulations for talent management. Many of those in positions of authority seem more focused on shaping these young artists to fit a certain mold-without concern for their well-being. This is nothing less than a form of abuse, control, and manipulation that could have a lasting negative impact on their future. It's truly disturbing to see how some misuse their power and evade accountability when their actions have harmful consequences. If one imposes such a grueling lifestyle on others, they should also bear the responsibility. Acknowledging these issues is essential to realizing the need for change and finding ways to prevent similar mistreatment in the future.
“Extraordinary gift”? People who spend their lives helping ones are the ones with an extraordinary gift. These boys were average but the marketing was great.
Seriously...One Direction may have started as "ordinary" boys, but their talent and impeccable marketing and branding transformed them into global superstars. Their success shows how the right strategy can amplify talent into something extraordinary..agree to disagree......
Now Liam's gone forever..😞💔
RIP Liam Payne
Born 29 Aug 1993
Died 16 Oct 2024
How seriously rude to point out someone's weight?
there's nothing rude about that.
That’s horrible management made them hide their true selves just for some stupid stereotypes
I feel so sorry & sad for what they had gone through from their management. I think their parents should also interfere & protect these young men from overexposure etc😢😢😢
Parents were more than happy to put money and fame before their children.
@@ojj3340 they cpouldnt do anythin g one contracts were signedd they had npo choice
Thank you ZAYN , because YOU LEFT 1D 💞💯💯💯💯💯💯💯👍💞
Can you make a similar video on roadtrip tv?
Que vídeo mais esclarecedor. Que triste ver adolescentes extraordinários serem tão manipulados desse jeito. Que eles possam se libertar de todos os fantasmas do passado. Nem tudo o dinheiro pode comprar. a paz, por exemplo.
hello i agree with the poor Management there is clear evidence that Harry has Asthma is a condition in which the airways narrow and swell and may produce extra mucus. This can make breathing difficult and trigger coughing, wheezing when breathing out and shortness of breath that affects 1 in 12 people of all ages.Whilst the severity of the symptoms vary and can heavily impact a person’s life Management would withhold meds that would help him breath or have him preform with ill knowing it would lead to an Asthma attack. i would recomend the channel My Mind My Mood for more details
Simon has a lot to answer to how he treated them when they were younger he took there teenage life away from them and completely over worked them then had the cheek to lock them up at night they must have missed there family's TERRIBLY He also had to be there for them all and look after them god rest Liam sole R.I.P YOUNG MAN what a great man you were and your singing was absolutely Beautiful xx
Directioners, please keep str3aming SOML...tnx! 💚💙🇮🇹❤️💛
Management killed Liam
Fact💯
This🙌🏻👏🏻
well all this comes with fam the parents should’ve been on tour too but simon was told something cause he straighten up a lot and now we see liam was already an user of drugs so now he is gone i wonder if anyone else took em in the group
N NOW WE LOST LIAM THIS IS SICKENING 🤦♀️🤦♀️🤦♀️🤦♀️🤦♀️these odiots did more than mistreatment to these beautiful boys
one direction were not a band , a band can play musical instruments , they were a pop vocal group who were controlled by the record company to the point of destroying the mental health of the boys and the eventual death of one of the members of said vocal group. I'm not a fan of the boys music , but I see the corruption in the music industry and the destruction that happens , and its not good
Simon is pure evil. Sadly, with boy bands, there’s a lot of abuse. The horror stories of N’Sync and Backstreet Boys, aweful! The Beatles rebelled and did their own thing, but originally they were put in little suits and cut their hair the same way. The Monkees resented the control their creators had over them and their music.
Rip Liam. Show biz sucks!
What about the parents? Where were they?
@@ojj3340 they couldnt do anythimg ones contract were signed
there is a lot of complaining about their not being able to choose their hair, their clothes, etc... but it is a job. it is called work. If you work for a bank, you can't have green hair. if you work for a corporation, you have to wear a suit. if you want to be a pop star, you have to be cute, look trendy and sign autographs. I mean, these guys had a job and that job was to be pop singers and a boy band and they got paid very, very well. Also, pop stars have a short shelf life - the singers get older and lose their baby face cuteness, the teen fans grow up and forget about them. Five years is a good run and five years to make the money before you either retire to a mansion in the country or branch out into a different phase of your music or different career like producing, acting, writing, directing, etc etc...
so true!
SORRY, BUT SIMON COWELL IS AN ABUSIVE, MEAN PSYCHOPATH. WAS IT REALLY NECESSARY TO LOCK THE BOYS IN THEIR HOTEL ROOMS AND ISOLATE THEM FROM FRIENDS AND FAMILY MEMBERS??? THAT'S HOW LIAM STARTING DRINKING ALCOHOL 🍸 IN HIS HOTEL ROOM BECAUSE THERE WAS NOTHING ELSE TO DO!! THEN I SEE SIMON COWELL CRYING AT LIAM'S FUNERAL. SIMON WAS LITERALLY CRYING ON LIAM'S DAD'S SHOULDER!!! SIMON SHOULD BE ASHAMED OF HOW HE TREATED LIAM AND THE OTHER BOYS.
They've made over $50 million each. However, they were certainly involved in a Faustian Pact.
What's a Faustian pact
a great video you explained things properly
every section of your video was covered properly but i think you could have explained the last section in a little more detail especially that shipping thing i know how much that fucked harry and louis over aside from that you covered everything properly thanks for that, i miss them and hope they'll come back one day not as the old band one direction but as friends where all of them will be free and will create and enjoy music together
I'm very disappointed in Simon seeing him that stuff about that overweight girl I'll continue the video now but that's just awful
Simon is a Richard Cranium!
The management and s×mon is the reason 💀😡
dont be naive the management wants to earn money
Hello :)
Hello
@@Banana_Boi_5086 Heyyyy, how r u??
@@louistpwkharry Im good thanks for asking
This is sooo important, louder for the people in the back
they LOVE performing (*except Z, though...) so it is irrelevant to portry them as prisoners. I was in the business myself and to work a lot equals happiness, when I do what I love. Their success shows the managment were right - the result proves. Having said that - your end sentence was sopt on.
Agree just think it's the young fandom and it sounds like a dickens novel and they were the golden egg and would have been treated very carefully also closetting is just part and parcel of it to appear straight and that's why fake girlfriends come into it and they would have signed and double signed clauses in contracts not to reveal stuff which is probably normal practice but lou and Harry are still veiwed the same way now when they are so much more than that.
EXACTLY! Thank you! All these whiners about how they were “mistreated” because they had to actually work for what they got drive me crazy.
@@aprilfisher4947 Stop with the “fake girlfriend” BS. Louis and Harry are not, and never have been, a “couple”. 🙄
This may be a huge reason why they won't or can't record together?
But they could change the management, no? Or they are just THAT traumatised from the being-in-a-band experience that they don't really want to be back again as one? But Liam, Louis and Niall has always said that they wanna come back one day.
@Emīlija Anna Lagzdiņa they can changed record label but the only problem would be that they can't keep the name one directions but if they somehow managed to get all the right of one directions they can moved to better label as group while doing solo at the same time balance solo work and band work similar to how got7 leave jyp.
The boys were minors, and the contracts were signed by their parents. In any case, it was written in the contracts what would be done and in what way. So? Parents should protect their children and should not sign such contracts that abuse minors. Finally, the music industry is always so busy. To all who are involved in this and are successful and not just 1 D. In the end, they were richly repaid for their work both with money and accolades and so everyone can continue as independent contractors. Trust me, none of them would have been successful if they weren't a member of 1D. (except Zayn because he can really sing). Make no mistake: I love 1D and I love their songs, but the truth, in my opinion, is this…
@helenabrglez9234~ That’s just your opinion about Zayn! All of 1D could sing and Harry Styles has proven how important it is to be able to interact with the audience! I love Zayn’s music and I desperately wish he could tour … but even Zayn said how Harry was born to be an entertainer and I agree with Zayn! Have a great weekend! TPWK😽💚🌻💛
Zayn can sing, but he’s no stage performer unfortunately.
I think louis has the best singing voice of 1D only because it is so distinctive compared to the others but I believe all of them have extremely great voices as well their songs as a group are my favorites to listen to apart from louis solo songs since the end of 1D hits talent as a singer songwriter is beyond anything I have ever seen and heard keep the faith louis❤❤❤❤❤❤
@@shonakeil2688 You're not serious. You're kidding, right?
@@justwhatilike...234 I love Harry. You are right - he is indeed a good performer, but a good performance is not enough to make him a great singer like Zayn.
This video should be longer. Simon is a snake.
Cowell should be charged with exploitation
I think it was absolutely ridiculous and appalling to label a teenage Harry Styles, as a Womanizer. Simon treated all of the 1D boys like slaves. It's just horrible to abuse teenagers like this. Simon definitely took advantage of them.
Omg, how awful is Simon😳
Harry likes to look like mickjagger
And they hid larry from us
This is too negative to listen to Again!! Look, 🌟 Harry 🌟 is Ledgendary!! His Kindness, and so Loving, and Humble! Loving Everyone Unconditionally!! As We Love Him, Unconditionally!! Just My Opinion but there never should have been 5 in 1D. Zayn stated his word's" I never wanted to be in a boy band from the very beginning" He could have bailed then! And never got involved from the very beginning! So why did He? JS maybe He needed some recognizing to be on His Own?! I L.O.V.E. 1D as the 4 of Them! No offense meant, just My Opinion!🦋🌻
The five members auditioned as soloists and were chosen for the band for various reasons. Each of them helped build that band into a global sensation. From Liam's interviews it was clear that what the fans saw was far removed from the reality the boys lived. The foursome, you prefer, chose not continue although they could have carried on if the situation was ideal. Losing a member of a five-piece band is nothing new. It was actually your Harry that pushed for the final hiatus/break which he first brought up in 2014. It was a very toxic work environment that could have been managed differently, and was not sustainable longterm. Please show some compassion for all of the boys, they too are human beings, and it was very courageous of Zayn to walk away from that toxicity no matter how attractive the rewards were.
Simon is a narcissist. Period!!
Do u think anyone would notice if simon accidentally died, definitely not from me 😳😳🤣
Complete BS. lol