I think Ludovic Tezier and Jonas Kaufmann's voices blend so well together they could be opera twins! This is a truly gorgeous rendition of this beautiful duet. ❤
Bravo: heard equally enjoyable version with Dmitri Hvorostovshy in 2008-another unique powerful voice. sung slightly different, but voices and vibratos were equally coordinated. The common singer in both was Jonas Kaufmann
Siempre regreso para escuchar este fantástico dueto ..Y la increíble fuerza interpretativa de las maravillosas voces de Kaufmann y Tezier ..Siempre es un placer recordar tanta bella música..👏👏👏👏👏💖💖🌹🌹
@@armenak20962 I am laughing so hard at this comment? Do you mean both of them? Don't you know that Ludovic Tezier IS French? As for Jonas Kaufmann, I reckon his French is damn near perfect. Oh Lord 😅😅😅😅
Jonas Kaufman (as Giuseppe Giacomini and Jose Cura) is a good example of the Italian term "Voce Ingolata". Which means a swallowed or squeaky voice, a voice fault. The voice "ingolata" is an obvious constriction problem. Most of the problems associated with this defect come directly from the tongue. The tongue pushes down on the hyoid bone, then it lowers and contracts the entire sound production mechanism. Even if the tongue does not interfere, the voice is too tight and the sound is thick. This dark artificial sound, typically woofy and thick, does not reveal the real "scuro", the voice loses body and clarity. Singers who do not sing with an "ingolata" voice are for example Mario Del Monaco, Enrico Caruso, Beniamino Gigli, Franco Corelli, Jussi Björling ... ecc
Oh what the heck are you whinging on about? Jonas Kaufmann sounds exquisite in this. I think his tongue is perfectly alright where it is if it produces such a wonderful sound! 😂
Yo creo que la lengua de Jonas Kaufmann está colocada en su perfecto lugar ..La voz más bella , Un sonido timbrico glorioso , pianisimos increíbles una fuerza interpretativa única , maravillosa , dolcissima voce...No podemos pedir más a una voz , no sería humano ...La voz perfecta no existe pero la de Jonas Kaufmann le pisa los talones ..❤
Jose Cura, Jonas Kaufman,Giuseppe Giacomini are good examples of the Italian term Voce Ingolata.Which means swallowed,or throaty voice.This video isn't about who is better, it is focussing on a vocal fault. Voce ingolata is an obvious constrictive problem.Most of the issues relating to this comes directly from the tongue.The tongue is pushing down onto the hyoid bone, then it is depressing and constricting the whole mechanism.Even when the tongue isn't interfering, the voice is overly tensed and the sound is thick.The artificial dark sound which is characteristically woofy and thick is not indicative of true scuro,the voice loses core and clarity. Singers who don't sing with ingolata.Mario Del Monaco, Enrico Caruso, Beniamino Gigli are used as side by side examples.Notice the fine line when singing correctly and incorrectly. Other negative conditions can also amplify the ingolata, such as a wobble or inverted vibrato. Jonas Kaufmann doesn't sound as bad as Cura because his vibrato is more normalised. Many comments have suggested some of these singers could not be ingolata because they have squillo.This is untrue. Many think squillo is achieved by placing the sound forward in the mask, (a place that many think of as a resonator) this is one of the most wide spread misnomers of singing, even great singers in master classes will always suggest "placing" the sound in the mask. Singing forward is a constrictive action that raises the larynx and closes the throat. It produces a hard metallic sound which people interpret as squillo.It is not. Squillo, core, ring, clarity etc. comes about through thyro-arytenoid function,i.e. Chest voice function. The increased use of chest voice in the sound increases the squillo, providing those overtones which give the voice core, (demonstrated by the lack of overtones in pure falsetto. Falsetto being void of chest voice function, it only has crico-thyroid participation). Franco Corelli clearly states in the Stefan Zucker radio interviews, that he didn't sing in the mask and it is wrong to do so.95% of singing is resonated in the pharynx. Below is a quote taken from Joseph Shores website. The full article; (www.josephshore.com/a_right_to... the original experiment conducted in the early 50s by Warren Wooldridge. Shore also quotes another vocal scientist who conducted the same experiment, William Vennard (The mechanism and the technic 1967). Singers Joseph shore, and Jerome Hines (The Four Voices of Man 1997) also conducted the same experiment. "In 1954, Wooldridge attempted to Isolate the contribution of the nasal passages to the singing voice by comparing the vowels produced by six professional singers under two conditions: - normal, and with the nasal passages filled with cotton gauze. He was unable to find significant differences between the spectra of the vowels produced under the two conditions, and a jury of expert listeners was unable to distinguish the two conditions by hearing tape recordings. Wooldridge concluded, "The term 'nasal resonance' is without validity in describing voice quality in the singing voice," (p. 39). A repetition of this experiment by five male singers, including myself, confirmed the original findings, (Vennard). "In the experiment on nasality to which I have referred (Par. 343) we not only filled our nasal passages with gauze but also had our maxillary sinuses more than half filled with water, (Fig.41). These are the largest of the sinuses, and putting water in them would change their resonant properties noticeably if they were of any importance. Our singing under these conditions was compared with our normal singing by 86 vocal authorities from the United States and 25 from Holland. The Dutch judges were included because Europeans frequently judge American speech to be nasal but they were no more able to detect the difference between the normal and the abnormal singing than were the American listeners. Our conclusion was that neither "nasal resonance" nor "sinus resonance"
Oh do belt up! I don't care where from or how Jonas Kaufmann produces his voice, I just know it's absolutely gorgeous and wonderful to listen to. Go and swallow your own tongue you absolute heathen! 😂
Et alors ? Oui la version Bjoerling/Merril est magnifique... Pas de place pour d'autres ? J'aime les deux ! Pas toutes les autres interprétations bien sûr mais ça ne me dérange pas que J Kaufmann ait une voix de ténor assez basse. A mon sens, le mariage avec L Tezier est réussi et différent. Pourquoi pas ?
Thanks bacquier was a magnificent baritone one who didnt just identify as french but sang in italian and very well indeed a beautiful warm voice a great actor a man who sang to a wide audience and never pigeonholed himself
I think Ludovic Tezier and Jonas Kaufmann's voices blend so well together they could be opera twins! This is a truly gorgeous rendition of this beautiful duet. ❤
On ferme les yeux, il n'y a plus qu'à se laisser embarquer C'est une merveille
Magnifique. Contente de trouver cela enregistre.
❤❤🇩🇪🎼🎵🎼🎶🎼🎵♏🙏🙏🙏 "Die Perlentaucher" von Bizet.....
Wunderschön....🤩🤩🤩😍😍😍😍
Oui, 2 voces maravillosas.
Perfection , the best of their talents , combined ..
It is gorgeous. Would have been even better if we could have seen them
c'est magnifique!! Grazie!!! verdaderamente un regalo!! gracias !!!
Very vivid presentation! Great combination of voices.
The best ....
Meravigliosi, incomparabili! E chi rosica, ci resti ❤👏👏💓
Wunderbare Stimmen kann man nicht genug hören.😂❤
Deux interprètes dont les voix s'unissent parfaitement ! Merveilleux !!!
Diction parfaite en Français de Jonas Kaufmann. Still amazing, velvet voice and Tezier stunning with a dark timbre👏🎶🙏
Fermez les yeux, écoutez, c'est beau ❤
Bravissimi. Sono dei grandi interpreti.
Wunderbar!
So beautiful - quite stunning!
Bravo: heard equally enjoyable version with Dmitri Hvorostovshy in 2008-another unique powerful voice. sung slightly different, but voices and vibratos were equally coordinated. The common singer in both was Jonas Kaufmann
Quel duo magnifique, et j'adore cet opéra
Siempre regreso para escuchar este fantástico dueto ..Y la increíble fuerza interpretativa de las maravillosas voces de Kaufmann y Tezier ..Siempre es un placer recordar tanta bella música..👏👏👏👏👏💖💖🌹🌹
4:24
deux voix merveilleuses bravo !
Las voces de KAUFMANN y TEZIER se complementan en un precioso sonido ..Hermosamente cantado este maravilloso Duo ..
Text i deutsch
Une merveille !
sublime!!! ♥
Un piacere ascoltare questi due interpreti! Bravi davvero in questo splendido brano!!!!! Grazie!
Wonderful couple ♥
Dos voces maravillosas en un duo perfecto🌹
They always sound so beautiful together. Certain tenors and baritones were just made for each other and they are one such pair.
Maybe because they are friends in real life.
@@dalangie They are!
Perfection ...
🙏🏻🙏🏻🙏🏻🙏🏻🙏🏻🌹🌹🌹🌹🌹🌹💯💯💯
Maravillosos: muy cerca de la perfección!
Ein Genuss. Das beste Duo.
Entrambi bravissimi
Kann es Schöneres geben?
Прекрасно, чудесно, замечательно, и вместе и каждый отдельно!!! Обалденные голоса!!!!
Top moumoute !
Love Jonas, I don't know, but this aria just does not go with his voice. I realy don't feel nothing... Just watch Hadley and some others...
Wonderful singing but there is only one....Bjorling & Merrill for this duet.
Ok, perhaps, but awful french. Here we have for the first time since Gedda/Blanc the perfect french with awesome voices
@@armenak20962 I am laughing so hard at this comment? Do you mean both of them? Don't you know that Ludovic Tezier IS French? As for Jonas Kaufmann, I reckon his French is damn near perfect. Oh Lord 😅😅😅😅
@@operaFan-tn8ng To be french doesn’t give you always a good singing french. Both of them have a very good french which is alas very seldom
Jonas Kaufman (as Giuseppe Giacomini and Jose Cura) is a good example of the Italian term "Voce Ingolata". Which means a swallowed or squeaky voice, a voice fault. The voice "ingolata" is an obvious constriction problem. Most of the problems associated with this defect come directly from the tongue. The tongue pushes down on the hyoid bone, then it lowers and contracts the entire sound production mechanism. Even if the tongue does not interfere, the voice is too tight and the sound is thick. This dark artificial sound, typically woofy and thick, does not reveal the real "scuro", the voice loses body and clarity. Singers who do not sing with an "ingolata" voice are for example Mario Del Monaco, Enrico Caruso, Beniamino Gigli, Franco Corelli, Jussi Björling ... ecc
René Bisaro j
Oh what the heck are you whinging on about? Jonas Kaufmann sounds exquisite in this. I think his tongue is perfectly alright where it is if it produces such a wonderful sound! 😂
Yo creo que la lengua de Jonas Kaufmann está colocada en su perfecto lugar ..La voz más bella , Un sonido timbrico glorioso , pianisimos increíbles una fuerza interpretativa única , maravillosa , dolcissima voce...No podemos pedir más a una voz , no sería humano ...La voz perfecta no existe pero la de Jonas Kaufmann le pisa los talones ..❤
Jose Cura, Jonas Kaufman,Giuseppe Giacomini are good examples of the Italian term Voce Ingolata.Which means swallowed,or throaty voice.This video isn't about who is better, it is focussing on a vocal fault. Voce ingolata is an obvious constrictive problem.Most of the issues relating to this comes directly from the tongue.The tongue is pushing down onto the hyoid bone, then it is depressing and constricting the whole mechanism.Even when the tongue isn't interfering, the voice is overly tensed and the sound is thick.The artificial dark sound which is characteristically woofy and thick is not indicative of true scuro,the voice loses core and clarity. Singers who don't sing with ingolata.Mario Del Monaco, Enrico Caruso, Beniamino Gigli are used as side by side examples.Notice the fine line when singing correctly and incorrectly. Other negative conditions can also amplify the ingolata, such as a wobble or inverted vibrato. Jonas Kaufmann doesn't sound as bad as Cura because his vibrato is more normalised. Many comments have suggested some of these singers could not be ingolata because they have squillo.This is untrue. Many think squillo is achieved by placing the sound forward in the mask, (a place that many think of as a resonator) this is one of the most wide spread misnomers of singing, even great singers in master classes will always suggest "placing" the sound in the mask. Singing forward is a constrictive action that raises the larynx and closes the throat. It produces a hard metallic sound which people interpret as squillo.It is not. Squillo, core, ring, clarity etc. comes about through thyro-arytenoid function,i.e. Chest voice function. The increased use of chest voice in the sound increases the squillo, providing those overtones which give the voice core, (demonstrated by the lack of overtones in pure falsetto. Falsetto being void of chest voice function, it only has crico-thyroid participation). Franco Corelli clearly states in the Stefan Zucker radio interviews, that he didn't sing in the mask and it is wrong to do so.95% of singing is resonated in the pharynx. Below is a quote taken from Joseph Shores website. The full article; (www.josephshore.com/a_right_to... the original experiment conducted in the early 50s by Warren Wooldridge. Shore also quotes another vocal scientist who conducted the same experiment, William Vennard (The mechanism and the technic 1967). Singers Joseph shore, and Jerome Hines (The Four Voices of Man 1997) also conducted the same experiment. "In 1954, Wooldridge attempted to Isolate the contribution of the nasal passages to the singing voice by comparing the vowels produced by six professional singers under two conditions: - normal, and with the nasal passages filled with cotton gauze. He was unable to find significant differences between the spectra of the vowels produced under the two conditions, and a jury of expert listeners was unable to distinguish the two conditions by hearing tape recordings. Wooldridge concluded, "The term 'nasal resonance' is without validity in describing voice quality in the singing voice," (p. 39). A repetition of this experiment by five male singers, including myself, confirmed the original findings, (Vennard). "In the experiment on nasality to which I have referred (Par. 343) we not only filled our nasal passages with gauze but also had our maxillary sinuses more than half filled with water, (Fig.41). These are the largest of the sinuses, and putting water in them would change their resonant properties noticeably if they were of any importance. Our singing under these conditions was compared with our normal singing by 86 vocal authorities from the United States and 25 from Holland. The Dutch judges were included because Europeans frequently judge American speech to be nasal but they were no more able to detect the difference between the normal and the abnormal singing than were the American listeners. Our conclusion was that neither "nasal resonance" nor "sinus resonance"
Oh do belt up! I don't care where from or how Jonas Kaufmann produces his voice, I just know it's absolutely gorgeous and wonderful to listen to. Go and swallow your own tongue you absolute heathen! 😂
This is one of the worst interpretations of this song.
This is not good sounds like 2 baritones,kaufman sounds like he has a cold if you really want to hear this sung properly try bjoerling and merrill
Et alors ? Oui la version Bjoerling/Merril est magnifique... Pas de place pour d'autres ? J'aime les deux ! Pas toutes les autres interprétations bien sûr mais ça ne me dérange pas que J Kaufmann ait une voix de ténor assez basse. A mon sens, le mariage avec L Tezier est réussi et différent. Pourquoi pas ?
@@anneboissel gabriel bacquier and vanzo is another magnificent recording of pearl fishers both were excellent singers top class
@@amantedellopera1681 Thanks David ! another different one from old times... beautiful too.
@@anneboissel try also same duet alfredo kraus and barry mc daniel its pretty good too. ....enjoy
Thanks bacquier was a magnificent baritone one who didnt just identify as french but sang in italian and very well indeed a beautiful warm voice a great actor a man who sang to a wide audience and never pigeonholed himself
Jonas knödelt ein bisschen
Wunderbar!