I think this is not FAIR. Because Mariah said in an interview this 2017 that she's suffering from bronchitis, but she still slayed tho. BTW love your channel and your vids.
Lol I didn't want to make this showdown video because I know this is not her full potential best... but the 2005 BET vibes from that Jimmey Kimmel performance was so evident 😍😍 (the arrangement, some vocals, movements, etc.) which inspired me to make this. Thanks for watching btw ❤️
Honestly am I the only one noticed is almost exactly the same as 12 years ago yet somehow people swear up and down that she can't sing. The only difference is that she's lost some of the ease with the notes after D5 and has lost some agility but other than that it's almost the same to me and trust I love her to death! ❤️
Zamier1212 Mariah was not confident. She definately could go further with her vocal condition, but avoided some high notes. I loved her tone in "I don't"
Victor Hugo this is very true she hit a couple of live F5's in 2016 because she was confident, she just needs to get used to performing on live TV again honestly, but I lbelieve in her. Her tone on I don't was great I wish there was a way to bring back the TEOM tone she had it was amazing, raw and honest to her voice at that time
Zamier1212 Tbh, I only liked the tone of televisioned performances. I didn't like the vocal from tour. Anyway, I'm very excited with her tour with Lionel
MrRaccoon92 omg i know its been 12 years she looks the same, its just 2017 has higher definition camera so you can see everything, but still she has the same face abd everything
They do sound very similiar and I believe she cut down on some of the drinking and got some rest :) If she'd continue doing that she could probably sound even better than 2005 :) go mariah!!
tbh, I cried cause I could see the courage of this strong woman had made through this industry for so long despite the haters had tried to put her down so many times. I respect and love Mariah till death. What a strong woman and forever my one and only butterfly! love you so much for making this A+MAZING video !!
That is so true.... That's why i really love her because she never stop doing her passion.... As long as you have "peace" in yourself, everything is possible no matter what 🙏
My honest opinion: her 2017 was an incredible performance, that ending iconic run had more soul than anything ive ever heard, how she bent down and did a closing run after such a long sustained belt was just incredible
Tbh i prefer 2017's run at the end(remove the whistles ofc) Idk why i think her voice is more powerful there even if its quite short and due to mariah has bronchitis and nodules. It proves that her voice is still there and she can still snatch ur wigs. Btw this video is legendary omg
Sean Soler I agree she looks defeated. she kind looks scared to fuck up. poor MC I hate when people praise and build the celebrities to super stardom. and then try to tear them down
MrThrob411 True! She's so careful here that she played safe. I went to her vegas show and she killed it! I recorded the whole show lol and it's in my channel
That only proves who is better than Mariah? Mariah singing with Mariah! lol. I love both performances! The 2005's one is very special because of the Era! I love it! And 2017 is almost better because once again she needed to Prove herself... after they tried to bring her down again! I can't wait to see her this summer!
2005 mariah wanted it more she fought through with that song and belted the heck out if it. her run attempts and growls were way superior and the whistle at the end was on point. i think that 2005 performance of VOL was the best ive heard so far even compared to earlier performances. 2017 version is ok but i wonder if she would get those vocal abilities back
She still has the ability, but she's 47 now so it takes a little more energy. She still hits that high note live when she feels like it. Plus, 2005 was her biggest comeback to date. People were saying she can't sing and should retire, and she hit 'em with Emancipation. 2017 got off to a rough start, last album didn't do well, so she's playing it safe.
Honestly the best comparison video of her I have seen to date. Not too bad. Almost the same. Proud of her strength and courage after all thats been goin on
This was awesome the only singing that compares to her is HERSELF Lol.. Luv Mariah!!! She sings whenever she really feels like it, yup we can do this again in 2027 Still Her sound hun.
Omg let her live I get it she's a public figure and people want to judge her on every performance. She has an angelic voice and is a living legend. I don't like thinking negatively but when she passes away all y'all judging her will be like she was so talented she was a legend blah blah blah enjoy her and her music while she is in the present it's so great you can watch her live this living legend in one of her concerts right now so appreciate her is all I say. 😘
Treated me kind Sweet destiny Carried me through desperation To the one that was waiting for me It took so long Still I believed Somehow the one that I needed Would find me eventually I had a vision of love And it was all that you've given to me Prayed through the nights Felt so alone Suffered through alienation Carried the weight on my own Had to be strong So I believed And now I know I've succeeded In finding the place I conceived I had a vision of love And it was all that you've given to me I had a vision of love And it was all that you've given me I've realized a dream And I visualized The love that came to be Feel so alive I'm so thankful that I've received The answer that heaven has sent down to me You treated me kind Sweet destiny And I'll be eternally grateful Holding you so close to me Prayed through the nights So faithfully Knowing the one that I needed Would find me eventually I had a vision of love And it was all that you've given to me I had a vision of love And it was all that you turned out to be
She sounds the same only sings her song completely different now but I honestly think she chooses to to save some vocals in her voice. Not that she cant do it because she clearly only changed small parts in this live performance, just left out some high moments but nothing serious. Haha I love this girl she killed it ❤👍😊😊
Mariah Carey nunca repete os vocais, ela sempre traz novidades Já cantou essa música mais de um milhão de vezes e sempre cantou de maneira diferente. Ela é surpreendente
I think the thought that we think that her voice cannot handle the old ways she sings was the one that make us see that she cannot be the same as before but this video shows that in some part she actually did better so she can still sing really well bitches
please upload the performance to the right as it was removed
7 лет назад+1
essa performance de 2005 pra mim é uma das melhores dela! Tá tão solta e segura! Quanto a de 2017, a Voz dela já esteve pior, parece que se recuperou um pouco, foi uma boa apresentação sim, mas essa de 2005 é insuperável rsrs.
When I use headphones, the audios are in the wrong place. The 2005 should go on the the left headphone, while it's one the other one, and the same with the 2017, it's on the left while it should be on the right one.
Resonance: 2017 Mid belts: 2017 Upper belts: 2005 Tone: 2005 Runs and riffs: 2005 Low notes: 2017 Vibrato: 2005 Power: 2017 and 2005 And also the fact that she still looked the same thooo after 12 years. And also 2017 is after the pregnancy but she still looked the same as 2005. Ageless queen 👑💅
she still sound the same in some major part.. of course i live for the 2005.. her whistle at the beginning blown me away.. and yess i will love you till death too..
#legend She had bronchitis and still sounded the same as 2005!! If she didn't have bronchitis at the kimmel show, she would've slayed more than she did, she would've had more agility, more power and less nervousness and for sure more confidence
Oh my. This is close, Both have good belts, and 2017 held them longer, but GROWLS! The falsetto was better in 2017, but that's it, 2005 slayed me with the whistle! The runs were better in 2005 and her tone was clearer.
I think this is not FAIR. Because Mariah said in an interview this 2017 that she's suffering from bronchitis, but she still slayed tho. BTW love your channel and your vids.
Lol I didn't want to make this showdown video because I know this is not her full potential best... but the 2005 BET vibes from that Jimmey Kimmel performance was so evident 😍😍 (the arrangement, some vocals, movements, etc.) which inspired me to make this. Thanks for watching btw ❤️
#TheFandom IS REAL and the cleavage too 😂😂😂
Jerwin Dapitan what interview is this
Charmbracelet its a sickness for life
and let's not forget during the infinity shows as well...
WOW she never gets old. Even her arms are still firm as 2005.
Honestly am I the only one noticed is almost exactly the same as 12 years ago yet somehow people swear up and down that she can't sing. The only difference is that she's lost some of the ease with the notes after D5 and has lost some agility but other than that it's almost the same to me and trust I love her to death! ❤️
I meant her tone btw is almost exactly the same
Zamier1212 Mariah was not confident. She definately could go further with her vocal condition, but avoided some high notes. I loved her tone in "I don't"
Victor Hugo this is very true she hit a couple of live F5's in 2016 because she was confident, she just needs to get used to performing on live TV again honestly, but I lbelieve in her. Her tone on I don't was great I wish there was a way to bring back the TEOM tone she had it was amazing, raw and honest to her voice at that time
Zamier1212 Tbh, I only liked the tone of televisioned performances. I didn't like the vocal from tour. Anyway, I'm very excited with her tour with Lionel
Victor Hugo me too I'm excited to see what kind of vocals she'll give honestly 🤗
i know we're comparing the voice here. but can we just have a moment to amaze how this woman not aging at all. its almost scary.
MrRaccoon92 same haha
MrRaccoon92 omg i know its been 12 years she looks the same, its just 2017 has higher definition camera so you can see everything, but still she has the same face abd everything
Blacks Dont Crack
@@kennethdennisrojo1891 Or Biracial doesn't wrinkle. 😛😉
Anthony James Crowe good one lol 😝
The only woman alive who can harmonize with herself, y'all can say what you want of Mariah.. but she still slays all of your faves
Facts
she still fucking sounds the same omg she is amazing. is it me or does she look more of a glow now than she does In 2005? holy moly
They do sound very similiar and I believe she cut down on some of the drinking and got some rest :) If she'd continue doing that she could probably sound even better than 2005 :) go mariah!!
tbh, I cried cause I could see the courage of this strong woman had made through this industry for so long despite the haters had tried to put her down so many times. I respect and love Mariah till death. What a strong woman and forever my one and only butterfly! love you so much for making this A+MAZING video !!
Yass, and ty! 😍❤️
Still writing, singing and touring. This is beyond talent.
That is so true.... That's why i really love her because she never stop doing her passion.... As long as you have "peace" in yourself, everything is possible no matter what 🙏
My honest opinion: her 2017 was an incredible performance, that ending iconic run had more soul than anything ive ever heard, how she bent down and did a closing run after such a long sustained belt was just incredible
She just was nervous as fuckkk. I wanted to hug her haha.
if Mariah were two. i believe i might be passed away if i were ever able to see them perform together 😂
AMAZING MY QUEEN❤
OH MY GOODNESS SO AMAZING!!!! Same key and same tone!!!! she just dodged some big notes in 2017 but still sounded great! uh-mazing!!!!!!!
bitch I didn't expect mine again to be blasting in your intro!!
I wasn't prepared!!
resonance!!!🙌🙌🐑🐑🐑
them lowss!!!😍😍😍
Araich Zedlav 😍😜
LMAO SAME
Mariah Carey is the only artist who would be able to due a duet with herself and as a hologram
I was smiling hard the whole time throughout the whole video.
Tbh i prefer 2017's run at the end(remove the whistles ofc) Idk why i think her voice is more powerful there even if its quite short and due to mariah has bronchitis and nodules. It proves that her voice is still there and she can still snatch ur wigs.
Btw this video is legendary omg
I thought I was the only one that noticed how good her agility was in the 2017 performance. That was run was insane.
12 years apart, she still kills it.
2:47 SLAY, MARIAH #lambily
Felipe Marinho me dio vida!
3:14
she actually sounds the same 😍 it's just that she needs more confidence now
Sean Soler I agree she looks defeated. she kind looks scared to fuck up. poor MC I hate when people praise and build the celebrities to super stardom. and then try to tear them down
MrThrob411 True! She's so careful here that she played safe. I went to her vegas show and she killed it! I recorded the whole show lol and it's in my channel
Sean Soler I'll check it out. thank you
I love Mariah for creating different versions of her own songs. The 2 clips blend well.
That fucking intro 👌😍 loooove it
That only proves who is better than Mariah? Mariah singing with Mariah! lol. I love both performances! The 2005's one is very special because of the Era! I love it! And 2017 is almost better because once again she needed to Prove herself... after they tried to bring her down again! I can't wait to see her this summer!
wow! I didn't think these sounded so similar! Great video
Nomadic David Ty!! ☺️
im a bit bothered that the audio sides are switched
Zimmer Motah yeah hahaha
Yeah they are..
damn she fucking killed it and still looks the same omg
Lets not lie 2005 was better. But then again she was playing it safe here.
Tori Patelli She said in an interview she has bronchitis during that performance.
She still sounds Amazing.
Tori Patelli @ i dont think so, 2017 imho is equal.
12 year gone and her voice is still mega amazing!!!
thank you for making this.💗💗💗this makes me cry..MC will forever my queen..BIG respect to the vocal supreme💗💗💗
zubelle Luis Miguel ❤️️ ur armpit more than mariah!
The climax gave me goosebumps
After 27 years, that's enough for me !
Mariah's consistency is amazing!
she is definitely giving us The Emancipation of Mimi vibes a lot lately!!!!
ageless queen and superior legend
Love the intro!!!
TY!! ❤️☺️
2005 mariah wanted it more she fought through with that song and belted the heck out if it. her run attempts and growls were way superior and the whistle at the end was on point. i think that 2005 performance of VOL was the best ive heard so far even compared to earlier performances. 2017 version is ok but i wonder if she would get those vocal abilities back
She still has the ability, but she's 47 now so it takes a little more energy. She still hits that high note live when she feels like it. Plus, 2005 was her biggest comeback to date. People were saying she can't sing and should retire, and she hit 'em with Emancipation. 2017 got off to a rough start, last album didn't do well, so she's playing it safe.
3:13 😍😍😍😍 I really love this video 😊
OMG! This changed my life! Loving you long time MiMi.
Honestly the best comparison video of her I have seen to date. Not too bad. Almost the same. Proud of her strength and courage after all thats been goin on
This shot me directly in the feels! Go on Mariah, dont ever not be you because you are the only MC "never imitated, never duplicated" WD
Omg this is amazing, could you pleases do a showdown between Vol 2005 & her Vol from sept 7 2016 that would be awsome☺️
I love how synchronized it is when they both lean at 3:13
This was a true showdown, I think this is one of my fav videos from you.
This is such a smart comparison! Great work!!! Amazing~
The point is she is still a vocalist yay! Thank u for this vid
That intro is everything
pleeeeeeease more of this
This is a beautiful video 😍 I really enjoyed it! Great job! 😀
I love Mariah thank you for this video❤️❤️
wow same mariah but it's like watching 2 singer with different redention of vol.. anw, i really enjoy this😍
With earphones is such a blessing omg
thats amazing!! mariah is mariah no body can touch that.. she's the queen..
MAKE MORE SHOWDOWN😍
It’s so magical 😭😍
This was awesome the only singing that compares to her is HERSELF Lol.. Luv Mariah!!! She sings whenever she really feels like it, yup we can do this again in 2027 Still Her sound hun.
the queen
Wow! Mariah is truly amazing! ❤
ITS FANTASTIC AN AMAZIN EDIT I HAV TO SAY
Soo gooood and soo different 😍😍
The music on the left speaker seems to be for the clip on the right side and vice versa haha goodjob
Mariah SLAYED she still sounds the same! Fantastic!
Thanks for making this video
Omg let her live I get it she's a public figure and people want to judge her on every performance. She has an angelic voice and is a living legend. I don't like thinking negatively but when she passes away all y'all judging her will be like she was so talented she was a legend blah blah blah enjoy her and her music while she is in the present it's so great you can watch her live this living legend in one of her concerts right now so appreciate her is all I say. 😘
this is amazing and and amazing channel. inspires me to grow mine. thanks Lamb 😘😘😘😎😃
The earphone thing is AMAZING
2017 her looks is best but I really2 love the 2of that perfomance
12 years later, still slayed.
Amazing video
Sounds great
Love this mix at the belting
Treated me kind
Sweet destiny
Carried me through desperation
To the one that was waiting for me
It took so long
Still I believed
Somehow the one that I needed
Would find me eventually
I had a vision of love
And it was all that you've given to me
Prayed through the nights
Felt so alone
Suffered through alienation
Carried the weight on my own
Had to be strong
So I believed
And now I know I've succeeded
In finding the place I conceived
I had a vision of love
And it was all that you've given to me
I had a vision of love
And it was all that you've given me
I've realized a dream
And I visualized
The love that came to be
Feel so alive
I'm so thankful that I've received
The answer that heaven has sent down to me
You treated me kind
Sweet destiny
And I'll be eternally grateful
Holding you so close to me
Prayed through the nights
So faithfully
Knowing the one that I needed
Would find me eventually
I had a vision of love
And it was all that you've given to me
I had a vision of love
And it was all that you turned out to be
nice video! The Eb5s in 2005>>>>>>>
Could you make a video comparing her 2005 New Years eve performance with her 2017 performance?
She sounds the same only sings her song completely different now but I honestly think she chooses to to save some vocals in her voice. Not that she cant do it because she clearly only changed small parts in this live performance, just left out some high moments but nothing serious. Haha I love this girl she killed it ❤👍😊😊
I love BOTH. VOL❤️🦋
There’s parts where she blended so beautifully with herself. Amazing voice and ear.
the only legend that matters ♥️🦋
Ngl, they're both perfect
Like this so much
Mariah Carey nunca repete os vocais, ela sempre traz novidades
Já cantou essa música mais de um milhão de vezes e sempre cantou de maneira diferente.
Ela é surpreendente
Amazing video #l4l
12 years later and she looks gorgeous !!
Wow she sounds the same!!
I think the thought that we think that her voice cannot handle the old ways she sings was the one that make us see that she cannot be the same as before but this video shows that in some part she actually did better so she can still sing really well bitches
My GAWD!!!! SING MIMI, SIIIIIINNNNNGGG!!!!
She seemed almost scared to perform in 2017, as if she was shook from the NYE incident, whereas she was glowing with confidence in 2005.
please upload the performance to the right as it was removed
essa performance de 2005 pra mim é uma das melhores dela! Tá tão solta e segura! Quanto a de 2017, a Voz dela já esteve pior, parece que se recuperou um pouco, foi uma boa apresentação sim, mas essa de 2005 é insuperável rsrs.
When I use headphones, the audios are in the wrong place. The 2005 should go on the the left headphone, while it's one the other one, and the same with the 2017, it's on the left while it should be on the right one.
Resonance: 2017
Mid belts: 2017
Upper belts: 2005
Tone: 2005
Runs and riffs: 2005
Low notes: 2017
Vibrato: 2005
Power: 2017 and 2005
And also the fact that she still looked the same thooo after 12 years. And also 2017 is after the pregnancy but she still looked the same as 2005. Ageless queen 👑💅
Aren't the audios switched??
2:48 2017 Mariah eats 2005 Mariah lol
Nach Bmal Knowing the one that I NEEEDEEEEEEED!
I think that 2017 performance is so underrated. I think it’s the best one since 2006
I can't find the music video of mine again, really addicted to that song, can someone help me find. 😢😢😢
Ela foi uma grande cantora
she still sound the same in some major part.. of course i live for the 2005.. her whistle at the beginning blown me away.. and yess i will love you till death too..
The eternal fact that "WE AGES THROUGH TIME" is inevitable, thats why we call her LEGEND.
shes sounds the same but loss of confidence or something I sense bless her
She's most comfortable with Vision of Love. 😍
#legend
She had bronchitis and still sounded the same as 2005!! If she didn't have bronchitis at the kimmel show, she would've slayed more than she did, she would've had more agility, more power and less nervousness and for sure more confidence
Oh my. This is close, Both have good belts, and 2017 held them longer, but GROWLS! The falsetto was better in 2017, but that's it, 2005 slayed me with the whistle! The runs were better in 2005 and her tone was clearer.
+3:25 and +3:26 and +3:27 the same low note amazing love you mimi