Point to be noted : " women in general might not be able to handle the stress and strength required in combat positions ' why deny it to those who can' . "
Indian female has avarage hight of +-5 ft . So abave avarage hight should be within 5.5 , because going too high will only get you thin girls 🤣 Fun aside too high girl can easily catch attaintion , in case of undercover operation it may be a disadvantage .
Men in the army don't get commanding position tat easily unless u r qualified. They work hard and through results they get that position of authority. So women should go through the same effort to get this authority. And there are women who can do it. Better to get qualified through results than based on gender. Welcome this move by SC🙏
Women have been in combat roles in capf and there is no relaxation in standards. What do u mean by men standard ? Can all men meet the physical standards of combat ?? Btw do u know who is Seema Rao and who were Rani Laxmi Bai , Durgavati, Naika Devi etc
@@sjzz you too are not aware of the real capabilities of women round the globe bcoz you have never come across one so far. Read the Indian history which is repleted with so many female historical warriors and soldiers. Anyways how u will know when u are suffering from tunnel vision syndrome and FYI whatever names I suggested above are all real females in real world. If u don’t know about time that does not mean they are not out there. Come out of ur intellectual slumber, bro
@@lifethruvideos you think I don't know? Lol.....you think every women or men are capable to handle army? Do you know the hell these men have to go through just to protect your asses in home and writing these messages. Sure there are women who can be as physical powerful as men but those people are numbered. Their is a reason why people say don't hit a girl. Don't think that army is easy that anyone can do. Your mindset of women can do everything thing is what is narrow. There are differences and accept those differences. But don't be soo naïve when you hear that women are physically weaker than men because they are that's the biology. You people just don't want to accept it. Yes you are not aware of real world if you think women in armies can handle exact training like men do.
@@sjzz mr u r stereotyping things. People say so Bcoz from last several centuries since advent of foreign rule our society has tended to be over protective for women. And hitting anybody, man or woman, unnecessarily is wrong. And do u think all men qualify army ?? Like not all men, all women can’t be accepted in army only in the name of being female or in the name of misplaced feminism. Bro, Who is Usha Kiran ? She is a female CoBRA commando officer of CRPF engaged with naxals. Similarly we have female combat officers in BSF and thousands of low ranks female soldiers in CRPF, BSF, ITBP, Assam Rifles etc. - all posted in front lines. Even Yajur Veda says in 17.44 and 17.45 verses that women should undergo military training and capable ones should join army and fight for the nation and society. But as a society we deviated from Vedic injunctions and adopted a mindset which suppressed feminine power, though we continued to worship femininity in idols only .
A soldier should odey each and every order of his senior ...and a senior is recognised by his rank and rank only..the question of which gender a officer belongs to should never be seen arising
We need more videos like this mam please we have to get our position in army... Jitna hak admiyo ka hai desh ke liye ladne ka utna hamara bhi hai.. and all my strong woman out there... Please ignore these man here and there crying about biological difference you don't need to waste your time on them.. post content, work for, spread awareness ❤
if India has to evolve into a modern nation state, there has to be a sea change in its attitude towards women. Even a small number making the cut would be a major achievement.
many first world country deny combating roles in army to women..they can serve at any only if they go through exactly all the challenges that men need to go...
bro those women who fit in fitness criteria should be selected. no reservation should be implemented just beacause they are women or else army will suffer
@Mars Invaders first you do graduation okay 😂 there is no particular regiment of the Indian Army for lady medical officers all doctors are serve under AMC(Army medical Core) . And my mom is a doctor in the Air force and is the Commandant of AF Hospital Sulur, who told you that with a 2-3 times more security 😂😂 mela thodi laga hai 😂 and that are given pension and other benifits okay so do check your facts and knowledge and then point others!!
The question isn't about commanding role, the question is about the combating role, which isn't just viable for a woman as none of the so called western countries ever employ women in frontline conflicts.
Exactly... At one point in my life I had a strong drive to become an Air force pilot.... But when my dad told me that women are not allowed in combat and I finally had to face the reality that just because I was born a certain way, without a certain body part, I won't be allowed to serve my country. Just because I belong to a certain gender... I will be underestimated and degraded my whole life and my capabilities and talents will always be doubted and I will always be the weaker one no matter what... My life kind of changed a lot after that.
@@shreyarishi2720 You are missing the point, meanwhile physical requirements for military induction can't be replaced by feminist one. PS: Sorry to burst your bubble.
@@NoneOfTheAbove123 I'm sorry, I don't see how my acknowledgment of the sad truth portrays me as being 'in a bubble', maybe you need to work on your metaphors, along with your basic education in Biology and Equality. Just because you along with some misogynistic men believe that women are not capable of handling physical strain, does not make it true. Maybe try getting out of the comfort of your house and see what happens in the real world. What did you ever achieve 'as a man' that gives you the right to judge an entire gender on the basis of little to no real-world knowledge? There ARE women who can fulfill the physical requirements to join the military and engage in combat.. but do you know why we don't see any? Because of men like you :) who just think that women aren't capable of displaying strength and that your judgment is the only correct one out there. you are the problem my man... sorry to burst your patriarchal bubble :)
@@shreyarishi2720 hey we have olimpics, mma, all kind of sports. How about you play there and try to be as strong, fast and endurant as men, and if you do better then you can play god where people's lives are at stake
Blind comparison of selection criteria to combat roles to create an efficient army Two persons A, B Average Strength ************* A > B Average Weight ************* A > B Average height ************* A>B Bone density and bone strength *********** A>B Testosterone level ************* A>B How fast they can run ***************** A > B Ease of getting injured **************** B >> A Whether A or B bleed atleast once in a month? ********************** A - ❌️ B - 3-7 days bleeding, requires changing tampons frequently, mood shifts and affecting performance Whether A or B could undress themselves or change clothes in front of the majority of force? ********************** A - ✅️✅️ B - Don't even ask that..You might end up in jail Whether A or B can share the same toilet or bathroom, can stay closely stuck to each other for days,sleep together and needs less privacy while being with majority of forces? ************************** A - ✅️✅️ B - Time for the entire battalion to be charged of rape Whether A, B can affect the discipline of the majority forces in terms of Sexual relationships? ************************* A - chances are very very low B - Very high chance Considering all the above points and assessing them based on common sense, A is the best suitable for combat roles... If you think reverse you are a hypocrite
You are acting as if all women have these problems,if a women like mary Kom came to join army she would easily trash all the average males,if all the average males are given chance just because of being"male", why not all the exceptional females?
@@aakashgarain only in boxing not in combat. And there is weight category in boxing. National level boxing champion can easily beat Olympic medalist female boxer.
According to Marine Corps Times, in 2018, a total of 92 women were operating in a multitude of combat billets across the Corps. “Yet, only 11 enlisted women are serving today in the traditional ’03’ infantry career fields,” it said, quoting Marine Corps officials. The report added that no woman has attempted the Basic Reconnaissance Course or Amphibious Reconnaissance Course, and there are no female snipers, according to data provided by Manpower and Reserve Affairs. “Of the women serving in combat billets, most are in less physically demanding roles…,” according to data obtained by Marine Corps Times. This is bound to happen given their physical limitations. In Israel, too, women are mostly deployed in the military police and perimeter security rather than in actual combat
'This is bound to happen because of their physical limitations'?! Dear sir after reading all your comments I sincerely request you to either update your mindset to the times you're living in or go rot in the dark ages. I can name hundreds and thousands of women who are more physically capable than half or more than half of the men appointed in the military. Just because you're a 'man' doesn't make you naturally stronger! 😂 You have to work to gain the strength. And yes due to the lack of high levels of testosterone women have to work harder for that strength but that doesn't mean they can't achieve that equal amount of strength 😂😂😂😂 Oh baby you're so uneducated and backward I can't even believe you know how to type. I'm sure it must be very easy to underestimate a whole gender while sitting on your lazy ass behind that keyboard. Why don't you have a one on one combat with a physically sound woman? Then maybe your braincells might work better after getting your ass kicked...
@@shreyarishi2720 dear , When a woman would train rigorously, then for sure she can become stronger than an average man. But we are not talking about average man. We are talking about military men. As the woman would train the men would also train. So obviously again, the advantage of training is nullified. Again, men would be even more stronger now. Also the point is not only about being strong. Women are made in such a way that they are great in doing many ,many things at the same time. Which is a natural talent in itself. But men can't do. Unfortunately a soldier requires his ultimate attention towards his goal without hindering to obstacles and foreign noise. Hope you understand what I am saying
@@shreyarishi2720 you need reality check. Women not naturally powerful as men because of harmons, puberty. If men and women train for same amount of time then men always dominant women in any kind of any form physical activity.
Girls can make batter sniper then boys , during WW2 Russia employed many females sniper , they really worked very well We are indians girl we fought against British in chattagon , in Azad hind fouj in jansi Psychological advantage - girls are more clam and attentive and can stick on task Physical advantage - Indian girl are smaller and shorter in shape can easily bland in and hide . If traind well they can work very well
Ever heard of Jhansi Ki Rani ....... Khub ladi mardani .... She fought with valour which surpassed her male counterparts. Physiologically yes females are less muscular but let's give opportunity to those who can handle .
@@nethravadannayak5626 have u heard of Rani Jhansi ‘s female army which had 1000s of able bodied female solders and was led of female officers like Jhalkari Bai .Learn Some history in an objective way First
exactly, at taht time females were stronger but now if you are hoping to reduce the fitness criteria for females to get into army then you are literally speaking stupidity
She would've been equally tortured. That is a part of becoming a soldier sir. You have to face the brute reality of the situation.... Just because I'll be brutally raped and tortured doesn't mean I should not be allowed to protect my country when I'm perfectly capable of it. And it's not like I'm completely safe In my own sweet country ☺️ I'm sure the torturers will show me more kindness than the men who treated Nirbhaya and Priyanka Reddy and so many others with so much respect 👏👏👏👏👏👏
@Feminism Ducks because people like your mentality are still out free. just to prove a point talking senseless is all you are doing right now. seriously! you're comparing sexual assault at home with a war field officer.
@Feminism Ducks actually education is not only a sheet of paper. And about the writing thing I don't want to say much because at the end it's a wall on which I am banging my head. Lastly that's a huge curriculum you have mentioned above, just curious the name on the sheet is also feminism ducks? :) quite a rare name.
@@NishaSingh--qc8et But I think that you should gain some intellectual capabilities. If he lacks knowledge after cracking IIT in your mind then I think you are the dumbest girl.
Let women go to combat roles in the army and if situations are bad, they will also die, why should men have all the deaths and suffering, if the woman wants to let her fight and die, don't stop.
In Siachen, there are posts with only four soldiers. They sleep and share the same cramped post to attend nature’s call. Can one imagine a female soldier there? Soldiers undertake patrols that last for over 20 days at times. During this period, the men sleep and bathe together, and do the morning chores in open, often with another team keeping a watch for a possible ambush. There can be no separate arrangements for women.
@@shreyarishi2720 yeah what you are saying is right, but can you think how much time will it take to digest a naked woman bathing in front of men. Our society needs time to evolve. Sadly we were prehistorically already too modern, at that time nudity was ok. But due to the middle years , British Raj, we have become more conservation
First of all, the Center's argument was pathetic and stupid. This video has just skimmed over some facts leading to draw wrong conclusions. Female fighter pilots have been sent for missions only in peacetime, never for one-on-one dogfights deep in enemy territory and for wartime missions. Countries in the west that have taken women into combat units have never sent them to the frontlines. US Military clearly says that women selected are given less physically demanding duties. There are things( muscle mass, lung capacity, endurance, etc.) that are different in men and women( can Google it for the data) and won't change by protesting or by going to court. That doesn't mean that women are behind in all aspects! No, never, but they are in some, currently.
In that case, we have more female forces in combat than USA bcoz female CoBRA commandos, female anti naxal CRPF jawans, BSF female officers and jawans including ITBP and Assam Rifles all are operating in combat zones in jungles and borders. Coming to lung size etc whatever u r citing reasons here, female jet fighters are better equipped to handle G forces than men physiologically bcoz distance between their heart and brain is lesser than men. Just watch one documentary in Discovery or NGC where this research was published. So let’s think out of box, bro.
Women indeed can become choke point for any regiment in combating role but its upto women herself, after knowing that if she still wanted to serve her country so their should be no obligation to do so and if we claims to be biggest democracy we have to give equal rights to every one
For the commanding roles, They must had been in that situation in past. Means, they should be combat. Can they be in combat? Can they carry heavy weight (25-40Kg) for 8-10 days..?? Can they shit and piss in front of their men??? If they can, they should be allowed?? One more point, If she came back after pregnancy, she will be able to pass the fitness test??? What to do if they don't?? She have to leave the combat role??
No body is changing the rules for women combat women officers. And Usha Kiran, female CoBRA commando officer from CRPF fighting naxals, operate in jungles of Bastar and also hundreds of female CRPF anti naxal jawans do the same in jungles of Jharkhand and Chhattisgarh. They finish their pregnancy and join back after clearing all physical tests. See the world around u first and don’t believe on these stereotypical things blindly. Those women who don’t have typical female issues should be only allowed to join Combat.
@@cinemauniverse1437 bcoz of people like u who don’t want to change their thinking pattern. Chanakya used to maintain special women spies and women forces in his times. Read some history bro.
I don't think there is any organization which has benefitted from hiring people which don't meet up the requirements They should have opportunity to enter and try to qualify for it but only hire them if they make the cut
The center consists of old people ,none of whom have ever been under the command of a lady officer. Where as we the younger generation having been seen the power and competitiveness of lady officers fully support the supreme courts move. #WOCRO : women in combat roles
we will pay for being politically correct every time... women can become weakness to for army if they given combat role...they could be administrate but not fighter ...physical strength of women is 1/5 or less than man...which is real issue...being women is not issue its blessing...
Bro are you serious...a women while giving birth bears up to 25 units of pain that is equal to 20 bones being crushed all together...there have no instance recorded where a man is Abel to bears so much of pain. Above all we should never forget that even Hindu Goddess themselves have weapons in their hand ....?
@@sohamdeshpande7141 an officer is an officer...the rank is not known by gender. Israle and many other nations already have women fighting at the front. Let me make it clear...ours is a professional army...and never has been a case where an officer is kidnapped😂
@@sahilmulani9838 no.Equal mental capabilities ...yes.Equal physical capabilities no.Even then if u want equality,then women should be treated as equal during combat selection.Same time limit where men and women should run 400mts in 1.50 sec. and and everthing else.
do you know why they are not allowed? beacuse they never fit into the fitness criteria. they are women who are stronger and fit for army and can qualify the fitness round without reservation or reduction in criteria. only they desreve to be in army not women who want a special resrvation or reduction in fitness criteria
Women might not be as physically strong as some men but that doesn't make them weaker then all men. Women ARE strong, we ARE capable of developing hardcore physical strength. Only if we will be encouraged to have them biceps rather than the 'smooth skin' and the 'soft nurturing hands' by the society maybe we can see a woman's actual potential and stop characterising her as a weaker being! Which we are not! Biologically speaking, it is not impossible for a woman to have brute strength and we do have equal intellectual capabilities. So men thinking we're not at par with them.... Maybe go and re-attend school for some basic education.
@@kipayaji7731 yes I have seen it happening multiple times but it's ok, I see what really is powerful about men has to be proven over and over again in every single comment 1 year after the comments were made. Yes that surely proves how strong men really are. Why don't you try fighting a well trained woman and then bring your sorry ass back here? Your entire world view is based on a few examples. Well did you forget about the 'battle of the sexes' the woman won there. Does that prove women are stronger than men? No. But it does prove that we're equally physically capable, not all of us, but at least some of us, but how many are in combat positions? None of us. It's so easy to be born into a certain gender and talk from a priviliged perspective, but we too have the spirit of nationalism within us, we too want to fight for our country and we sure can. There are multiple armies around the world where women are in combat positions and they're some of the strongest armed forces in the world. But ok, go off after a single woman in a comment section to prove your superiority. Hope that helps you get over your insecurities. Bigottry is an entertaining thing to witness, but rest assured, men and women have more similarities than differences and if average women train even as little as average men and get proper physical training they can match up against most men if not all. Men are physically stronger than women,but physical strength is not the only way to fight dumbass, I've seen giant wrestlers get rekt by tiny martial artists. Maybe use your brain for something other than bringing an entire gender down because of your insecurities? And try recognizing your priviliges?
@@shreyarishi2720 hahaha...u r the one to make it gender based comment by saying women are not less than men...nobody said women are weak...in all things.. physically they are weak but it doesn't make us superior...there are lot of things which only female can do... Ofcourse a highly trained woman can beat a man with no training...but do u think a highly trained woman can beat a highly trained man...if women were physically same to men than there would be no separate sports for women they both would be playing together... Serena Williams lose to 203rd ranked man in tennis... and that man also beat her sister back to back... don't talk with ur emotions...just because a man opposing ur opinion it makes him sexist, mysoginist etc... Can a woman be easily able to carry a 70kilo man with extra weight of equipments plus her equipments...
Here in my state its not like ur delhi,up, bihar, wherever u r from...our society don't judge woman just because they are wearing short dresses...its free here for women... Ur whole point doesn't make ant sense but to degrade someone who's not ok with ur opinion... Now i know, feminists don't care about facts...
Where r u, bro ? Are u referring to school NCC system ? Have u been to the basic military training in Airforce , Navy , BSF, ITBP, CRPF etc, they are all trained same as men and along with men. So no relaxation for them at all. Historically we had many female warriors and present day have u heard of Seema Rao, Tanushree Parikh, Usha Kiran etc. first one is commando trainer and the other two are BSF and CRPF combat officers in BOPs and Naxal areas of Bastar and Dantewada. Wake up bro
@@lifethruvideos from where are you getting these false information. Yardstick for training for men and women are very different. Standards for women are much lower compared to men.
Ok , its good but they must take equal responsibility , just like men no compromises, if they are weak then they must push themselves to men's level, if they have equal rights then they must take equal responsibility
The male female birth ratio is improving , in higher education male female ratio is also improving . In near future we are going to get more and more eligible female candidates for army . We have to train our girls for battlefield very soon . We are indians women . We have taken equal part in independence movement . Even rule the country , we should ready ourselves to save our mother if needed . There is nothing bigger than our country . In army they train soldiers to properly respect women so it's just funny how some politician are not ready to accept the fact that our army can easily accept women and says that they are not ready . They are indian man , born from women , raised by women , study at school with girls , went college with them and work side by side in every field why not in army Indian female has best physical advantage of ambush attack than direct attack
We all think the same as you...then we joined the forces and the fact of life hit us hard...except for one or two...all are a big time liability. A male Captain can handle more stress and tasks than a women with a rank of Colonel /Lt Col in the Indian Armed forces. Physically the male counter part is tougher on an average. So the fights is to have equal selection criteria and still not be gender bias. Everything in the forces is validated through realtime exercises. This recommendation by the center is also a validated exercise. The supreme court is just trying to pressurize the center and the armed forces. Zyada garmi hai,Aajana border par volunteer duty Dene. Most welcome to all.
I also want to join Indian army as a Commander and want to serve my nation also give my best in combat zone so according to my points of view girls are able to handle in a combat field because in our India there is many girls who want to join Indian army as a woman commander and they want to go in a battlefield......but problem is that our nation's peoples think that girls cannot do anything they can't survive in a hard situation like a male soldiers. But please I request uh the people to change this policy and your thinking & please as soon as it possible give chance to women also to present them best in a battlefield cause girls can do anything and they are not more less than boys....Jai Hind🇮🇳🙏♥️
@Feminism Ducks just for clarity war is not about being aggressive we are living in the 21st century okay. if it was so, then why SF is called silent killers? and talking about the period and other losses those who will be applying for the role knew about it. it looks like you are tenser than women. :' complain comes when women are allowed to be a part of combat roles. those who are applying for the position they male/female are freaking aware of all the aspects that's why they're soldiers of the Indian army.
Imagine what Pakistanis would've done to a female pilot if she was in the plane which Abhinandan was flying. Seeing your female soldiers being paraded naked on the streets can be very demoralising for the other soldiers. I'm not against women joining the armed forces but they should work in a support role, like in intelligence, medical, transport/reconnaissance, planning and away from combat roles
Mam for your kind information army walo mai apse bhi jyda sochne or smjhne ki sakti hai aapko ghar baith kar gyan dene ki jrurt nahi hai. Wo jo decision lete hai kuch soch smjh kar lete hai or yha jo comments mai bakwas karte hai equality ki gahr baith kar mai yek women hokar bol rhi hu. Women army kitni hi strong ho unse boforce ki yek bullet tak nai uth skti war to aise hi haar jaenge hum smjhe yha baat machinery ki hai weight ki hai koi mjak nai hai jo yha equality dikha rhe ho. Arry bhai khud jaa kar army ko serve krke dekho tab pta chlega.
What the fcuk! Dude Indian army is for security of the nation. It's not for creating employment or playing gender equality games. Even the SC should not interfere in that elite organization. Brotherhood is very important in organisations like Army. It's not Air Force or Navy.
In my point of view that is right why should girls not go in the war . Before years there jobs in medical army officer.... etc not in a wars this is totally wrong this is also a discrimination for girls . Before years the jhansi rani and many women go in the battle to fight against the king then why should we are not allowed in the wars. We are requested to supreme court that pls give the all opportunity equally treated with boys and girls. And I say second time to humble request pls this my aim to die on the flag so this my request. JAI HIND JAI BHARAT 🇮🇳🇮🇳🇮🇳
One can go on and cite numerous examples. It is important to stop pushing the romantic notion of women in combat roles and start thinking from a practical point of view, keeping the reality in mind
Why are woman not allowed to participate in war and operation as a gd soldier😂😂,..we never heard of girl being martyred why??why every time we heard man casualty??why isnt it about equality??learn to be equal not only in easy environment but also in difficult ones.....
one cannot guarantee that women will come across only female combatants. Wing Commander Abhinandan Varthaman was shot down last year in an aerial combat with Pakistan Air Force and captured. Imagine the outpouring of emotions nationally if this was a female pilot. Now, please don’t say that it would not have mattered. We are a country that fell to its knees when a civilian aircraft was hijacked by terrorists, forcing us to release terrorists who continue to haunt the country with attacks after attacks, taking more lives than what was exchanged for. In the Army, female officers are regularly deployed to the front, especially as doctors who are also sent for medical camps in Kashmir. However, extra precaution is involved to prevent their kidnapping. Also, one is often given the example of foreign armies like the US and Israel that have female combatants. But even their forces don’t deploy women in direct infantry combat.
No offense..but sitting inside an air conditioned room and thinking out loud to everyone isn't something new....it's not easy to deploy any kind of troops that instantly...lots of experiments and money and time is needed..who doesn't want to fight along with our mothers and sisters..we'll be proud..so...Indian military and government sexist nahi hai...but at the same time itna stupid bhi nahi hai ki bas logo ne chillaya aur bina soche samjhe kar diya...no offense again sister...✌
Ma'am ek male ko Indian army mein qualify krne k liye 1600 metre Just 5 min mein lagane hotein Whereas the same distance for women are given 7-8 min Indian commando ki 3 saal ki tough training plus plus 6 mahine dead training hoti hai Whereas after many test ye prove ho chuka hai ki women's ye Puri nhi kr payengi tau jaise running mein privelges milli hai unhe isme bhi kuch privelges Dene padenge Aap equality ki baat krti hai naa😏 Tau Zara ye bataiye kyaa koi village boy kisi aise ko apna senior accept kr payega jinki combat skills and mental skills khud usse bahut neeche ho 😏😂 Apko superior position kab dii jaati hai jab apki skills apke juniors se achi ho reservation ka prasad tau bat nhi Raha ki aao aur le jaao reservation k naam pe We don't have any problem but pehle simple army running mein men's ki tarah 5 min mein 1600 metre ki equality leke aaiye uske baad equality ki baat ki jaaye
>•Madam it much easier by doing makeup and came in front of camera and said about this but actual reality is very different in combat in special forces they have mentally physically morally become super fit to part of special forces and there is not about men or women ok . •when you go in operation are you able to take your clothes in front of your men?? Are you comfortable to sleep together in night with other male, are you able do climbed and conduct sreaching operation more then 20 days and so more there was no excuse work, on you are in operation or fighting and hunting there is no place for any excuse and we have to accept that there was health difference between male and female , women have a menstruation cycle are you capable to do your duty hunting over mountain in the "period" without maintaining any hygienic conditions .. If you are accepted this all circumference and conditions then you can you will join in the "combact "
Its gud...even lord shiva want gender equality. But, what about next generation ? who will take care of their child and most importantly who will teach them ethics and moral values ?
Subscribe Indiatimes for more updates 👉🎥⤴️
Give the role who deserves it .......not on the basis of gender ,caste, community or creed. Jai Hind👮👩✈️🇮🇳
Didi aap pehle apne mohalle ke 10 saal ke baache se ladlo. uske bad Pak ya china army se ladna
If they are capable of handling the situation then they should be given role
The ones who can handle the pressure and are qualified for such roles should be given opportunity... A good and progressive decision definitely...
Point to be noted : " women in general might not be able to handle the stress and strength required in combat positions ' why deny it to those who can' . "
Recruitment should be done equally like males soldiers are recruited with same physical tests
Indian female has avarage hight of +-5 ft . So abave avarage hight should be within 5.5 , because going too high will only get you thin girls 🤣
Fun aside too high girl can easily catch attaintion , in case of undercover operation it may be a disadvantage .
Men in the army don't get commanding position tat easily unless u r qualified. They work hard and through results they get that position of authority. So women should go through the same effort to get this authority. And there are women who can do it. Better to get qualified through results than based on gender. Welcome this move by SC🙏
If they pass all the physical in men standards...no issue !
Women have been in combat roles in capf and there is no relaxation in standards. What do u mean by men standard ? Can all men meet the physical standards of combat ?? Btw do u know who is Seema Rao and who were Rani Laxmi Bai , Durgavati, Naika Devi etc
@@lifethruvideos you are not aware of real world.
@@sjzz you too are not aware of the real capabilities of women round the globe bcoz you have never come across one so far. Read the Indian history which is repleted with so many female historical warriors and soldiers. Anyways how u will know when u are suffering from tunnel vision syndrome and FYI whatever names I suggested above are all real females in real world. If u don’t know about time that does not mean they are not out there. Come out of ur intellectual slumber, bro
@@lifethruvideos you think I don't know?
Lol.....you think every women or men are capable to handle army?
Do you know the hell these men have to go through just to protect your asses in home and writing these messages.
Sure there are women who can be as physical powerful as men but those people are numbered.
Their is a reason why people say don't hit a girl.
Don't think that army is easy that anyone can do. Your mindset of women can do everything thing is what is narrow. There are differences and accept those differences.
But don't be soo naïve when you hear that women are physically weaker than men because they are that's the biology.
You people just don't want to accept it.
Yes you are not aware of real world if you think women in armies can handle exact training like men do.
@@sjzz mr u r stereotyping things. People say so Bcoz from last several centuries since advent of foreign rule our society has tended to be over protective for women. And hitting anybody, man or woman, unnecessarily is wrong. And do u think all men qualify army ?? Like not all men, all women can’t be accepted in army only in the name of being female or in the name of misplaced feminism. Bro, Who is Usha Kiran ? She is a female CoBRA commando officer of CRPF engaged with naxals. Similarly we have female combat officers in BSF and thousands of low ranks female soldiers in CRPF, BSF, ITBP, Assam Rifles etc. - all posted in front lines. Even Yajur Veda says in 17.44 and 17.45 verses that women should undergo military training and capable ones should join army and fight for the nation and society. But as a society we deviated from Vedic injunctions and adopted a mindset which suppressed feminine power, though we continued to worship femininity in idols only .
A soldier should odey each and every order of his senior ...and a senior is recognised by his rank and rank only..the question of which gender a officer belongs to should never be seen arising
Then standards for physical fitness must be equal for both gender 👍
Hey there, I've a question like
:- Are women officers sent to war like the male officers?
Pls answer
No , as they're not yet allowed in combat positions in army
Someday there will be......
Keep hopes high
We need more videos like this mam please we have to get our position in army... Jitna hak admiyo ka hai desh ke liye ladne ka utna hamara bhi hai.. and all my strong woman out there... Please ignore these man here and there crying about biological difference you don't need to waste your time on them.. post content, work for, spread awareness ❤
Women should be allowed for combat roles but the mark for qualifications shouldn't be compromised
equal fights equal rights.
if India has to evolve into a modern nation state, there has to be a sea change in its attitude towards women. Even a small number making the cut would be a major achievement.
many first world country deny combating roles in army to women..they can serve at any only if they go through exactly all the challenges that men need to go...
bro those women who fit in fitness criteria should be selected. no reservation should be implemented just beacause they are women or else army will suffer
Don't mislead People of India ....
@Mars Invaders ohh seriously!!.?
@Mars Invaders than why do women officers are appointed as doctors in the front line areas in war!.?
@Mars Invaders first you do graduation okay 😂 there is no particular regiment of the Indian Army for lady medical officers all doctors are serve under AMC(Army medical Core) . And my mom is a doctor in the Air force and is the Commandant of AF Hospital Sulur, who told you that with a 2-3 times more security 😂😂 mela thodi laga hai 😂 and that are given pension and other benifits okay so do check your facts and knowledge and then point others!!
@Mars Invaders first go and check your knowledge 😂😂 Ata jata kuch nhi aagaye behas karne
It's good everyone should have equal rights! And the hardworking and deserving people should get what they want! Irrespective of there gender!
The question isn't about commanding role, the question is about the combating role, which isn't just viable for a woman as none of the so called western countries ever employ women in frontline conflicts.
Exactly... At one point in my life I had a strong drive to become an Air force pilot.... But when my dad told me that women are not allowed in combat and I finally had to face the reality that just because I was born a certain way, without a certain body part, I won't be allowed to serve my country.
Just because I belong to a certain gender... I will be underestimated and degraded my whole life and my capabilities and talents will always be doubted and I will always be the weaker one no matter what...
My life kind of changed a lot after that.
@@shreyarishi2720 You are missing the point, meanwhile physical requirements for military induction can't be replaced by feminist one.
PS: Sorry to burst your bubble.
@@NoneOfTheAbove123 I'm sorry, I don't see how my acknowledgment of the sad truth portrays me as being 'in a bubble', maybe you need to work on your metaphors, along with your basic education in Biology and Equality.
Just because you along with some misogynistic men believe that women are not capable of handling physical strain, does not make it true. Maybe try getting out of the comfort of your house and see what happens in the real world.
What did you ever achieve 'as a man' that gives you the right to judge an entire gender on the basis of little to no real-world knowledge?
There ARE women who can fulfill the physical requirements to join the military and engage in combat.. but do you know why we don't see any? Because of men like you :) who just think that women aren't capable of displaying strength and that your judgment is the only correct one out there.
you are the problem my man... sorry to burst your patriarchal bubble :)
@@shreyarishi2720 hey we have olimpics, mma, all kind of sports. How about you play there and try to be as strong, fast and endurant as men, and if you do better then you can play god where people's lives are at stake
@@Belarus2012 aisa hohi nahi sakta kyuki rounds rosey ko average mma male fighter bhi squash kar sakta hai
Blind comparison of selection criteria to combat roles to create an efficient army
Two persons A, B
Average Strength
*************
A > B
Average Weight
*************
A > B
Average height
*************
A>B
Bone density and bone strength
***********
A>B
Testosterone level
*************
A>B
How fast they can run
*****************
A > B
Ease of getting injured
****************
B >> A
Whether A or B bleed atleast once in a month?
**********************
A - ❌️
B - 3-7 days bleeding, requires changing tampons frequently, mood shifts and affecting performance
Whether A or B could undress themselves or change clothes in front of the majority of force?
**********************
A - ✅️✅️
B - Don't even ask that..You might end up in jail
Whether A or B can share the same toilet or bathroom, can stay closely stuck to each other for days,sleep together and needs less privacy while being with majority of forces?
**************************
A - ✅️✅️
B - Time for the entire battalion to be charged of rape
Whether A, B can affect the discipline of the majority forces in terms of Sexual relationships?
*************************
A - chances are very very low
B - Very high chance
Considering all the above points and assessing them based on common sense, A is the best suitable for combat roles...
If you think reverse you are a hypocrite
You are acting as if all women have these problems,if a women like mary Kom came to join army she would easily trash all the average males,if all the average males are given chance just because of being"male", why not all the exceptional females?
@@aakashgarain only in boxing not in combat. And there is weight category in boxing. National level boxing champion can easily beat Olympic medalist female boxer.
Female goddess in Hindu mythology have since era's had weapon in their hands.. it's now time to see the goddess avatar in kalyuga
Very correct...i loved your opinion
@@prajotsatardekar9624 didn't get you?
According to Marine Corps Times, in 2018, a total of 92 women were operating in a multitude of combat billets across the Corps. “Yet, only 11 enlisted women are serving today in the traditional ’03’ infantry career fields,” it said, quoting Marine Corps officials.
The report added that no woman has attempted the Basic Reconnaissance Course or Amphibious Reconnaissance Course, and there are no female snipers, according to data provided by Manpower and Reserve Affairs.
“Of the women serving in combat billets, most are in less physically demanding roles…,” according to data obtained by Marine Corps Times.
This is bound to happen given their physical limitations.
In Israel, too, women are mostly deployed in the military police and perimeter security rather than in actual combat
'This is bound to happen because of their physical limitations'?!
Dear sir after reading all your comments I sincerely request you to either update your mindset to the times you're living in or go rot in the dark ages.
I can name hundreds and thousands of women who are more physically capable than half or more than half of the men appointed in the military.
Just because you're a 'man' doesn't make you naturally stronger! 😂 You have to work to gain the strength. And yes due to the lack of high levels of testosterone women have to work harder for that strength but that doesn't mean they can't achieve that equal amount of strength 😂😂😂😂
Oh baby you're so uneducated and backward I can't even believe you know how to type. I'm sure it must be very easy to underestimate a whole gender while sitting on your lazy ass behind that keyboard. Why don't you have a one on one combat with a physically sound woman? Then maybe your braincells might work better after getting your ass kicked...
@@shreyarishi2720 dear ,
When a woman would train rigorously, then for sure she can become stronger than an average man. But we are not talking about average man. We are talking about military men. As the woman would train the men would also train. So obviously again, the advantage of training is nullified. Again, men would be even more stronger now.
Also the point is not only about being strong. Women are made in such a way that they are great in doing many ,many things at the same time. Which is a natural talent in itself. But men can't do. Unfortunately a soldier requires his ultimate attention towards his goal without hindering to obstacles and foreign noise. Hope you understand what I am saying
@@shreyarishi2720 you need reality check. Women not naturally powerful as men because of harmons, puberty. If men and women train for same amount of time then men always dominant women in any kind of any form physical activity.
Girls can make batter sniper then boys , during WW2 Russia employed many females sniper , they really worked very well
We are indians girl we fought against British in chattagon , in Azad hind fouj in jansi
Psychological advantage - girls are more clam and attentive and can stick on task
Physical advantage - Indian girl are smaller and shorter in shape can easily bland in and hide .
If traind well they can work very well
Ever heard of Jhansi Ki Rani ....... Khub ladi mardani .... She fought with valour which surpassed her male counterparts. Physiologically yes females are less muscular but let's give opportunity to those who can handle .
Rani lakshmi has thousands of men's in his army
Lol who said she surpassed her male counterparts?
@@nethravadannayak5626 have u heard of Rani Jhansi ‘s female army which had 1000s of able bodied female solders and was led of female officers like Jhalkari Bai .Learn Some history in an objective way First
@@lifethruvideos fake history 😂🤣🤣🤣😭😭
exactly, at taht time females were stronger but now if you are hoping to reduce the fitness criteria for females to get into army then you are literally speaking stupidity
Never lower the standards in army. Give them combat roles, women are equal..the point is because if you lower standards you make weak army.
Just one question, what if in place of abhinandan, pakistan would have caught abhinandaNI?
She would've been equally tortured.
That is a part of becoming a soldier sir. You have to face the brute reality of the situation.... Just because I'll be brutally raped and tortured doesn't mean I should not be allowed to protect my country when I'm perfectly capable of it.
And it's not like I'm completely safe In my own sweet country ☺️ I'm sure the torturers will show me more kindness than the men who treated Nirbhaya and Priyanka Reddy and so many others with so much respect 👏👏👏👏👏👏
@Feminism Ducks because people like your mentality are still out free. just to prove a point talking senseless is all you are doing right now. seriously! you're comparing sexual assault at home with a war field officer.
@Feminism Ducks actually education is not only a sheet of paper. And about the writing thing I don't want to say much because at the end it's a wall on which I am banging my head.
Lastly that's a huge curriculum you have mentioned above, just curious the name on the sheet is also feminism ducks? :) quite a rare name.
@Feminism Ducks actually you need to expand intellectual thinking.
@@NishaSingh--qc8et But I think that you should gain some intellectual capabilities. If he lacks knowledge after cracking IIT in your mind
then I think you are the dumbest girl.
Let women go to combat roles in the army and if situations are bad, they will also die, why should men have all the deaths and suffering, if the woman wants to let her fight and die, don't stop.
deserving candidates should be given a chance. you are just squashing someone's dream otherwise.
In Siachen, there are posts with only four soldiers. They sleep and share the same cramped post to attend nature’s call. Can one imagine a female soldier there?
Soldiers undertake patrols that last for over 20 days at times. During this period, the men sleep and bathe together, and do the morning chores in open, often with another team keeping a watch for a possible ambush. There can be no separate arrangements for women.
Then maybe make female nudity more normal and treat female soldiers like you would treat any of your male comrades.
@@shreyarishi2720 yeah what you are saying is right, but can you think how much time will it take to digest a naked woman bathing in front of men. Our society needs time to evolve. Sadly we were prehistorically already too modern, at that time nudity was ok. But due to the middle years , British Raj, we have become more conservation
@@shreyarishi2720 its not gender discrimination,its basic biology
@@shubhammaideo7345 you cant change human nature by 'evolving society' or whatever you mean.
First of all, the Center's argument was pathetic and stupid.
This video has just skimmed over some facts leading to draw wrong conclusions.
Female fighter pilots have been sent for missions only in peacetime, never for one-on-one dogfights deep in enemy territory and for wartime missions.
Countries in the west that have taken women into combat units have never sent them to the frontlines. US Military clearly says that women selected are given less physically demanding duties.
There are things( muscle mass, lung capacity, endurance, etc.) that are different in men and women( can Google it for the data) and won't change by protesting or by going to court. That doesn't mean that women are behind in all aspects! No, never, but they are in some, currently.
In that case, we have more female forces in combat than USA bcoz female CoBRA commandos, female anti naxal CRPF jawans, BSF female officers and jawans including ITBP and Assam Rifles all are operating in combat zones in jungles and borders.
Coming to lung size etc whatever u r citing reasons here, female jet fighters are better equipped to handle G forces than men physiologically bcoz distance between their heart and brain is lesser than men. Just watch one documentary in Discovery or NGC where this research was published. So let’s think out of box, bro.
Women indeed can become choke point for any regiment in combating role but its upto women herself, after knowing that if she still wanted to serve her country so their should be no obligation to do so and if we claims to be biggest democracy we have to give equal rights to every one
For the commanding roles,
They must had been in that situation in past.
Means, they should be combat.
Can they be in combat?
Can they carry heavy weight (25-40Kg) for 8-10 days..??
Can they shit and piss in front of their men???
If they can, they should be allowed??
One more point,
If she came back after pregnancy, she will be able to pass the fitness test???
What to do if they don't?? She have to leave the combat role??
Yes bro this feminists don't understand basic biology
No body is changing the rules for women combat women officers. And Usha Kiran, female CoBRA commando officer from CRPF fighting naxals, operate in jungles of Bastar and also hundreds of female CRPF anti naxal jawans do the same in jungles of Jharkhand and Chhattisgarh. They finish their pregnancy and join back after clearing all physical tests. See the world around u first and don’t believe on these stereotypical things blindly. Those women who don’t have typical female issues should be only allowed to join Combat.
@@lifethruvideos Then tell me why there are no women in special forces
@@cinemauniverse1437 bcoz of people like u who don’t want to change their thinking pattern. Chanakya used to maintain special women spies and women forces in his times. Read some history bro.
@@cinemauniverse1437 bro, CoBRA is a special force unit of CRPF who fights against Naxals :)
Mera Desh Badal raha hai Jai Hind🇮🇳
I don't think there is any organization which has benefitted from hiring people which don't meet up the requirements
They should have opportunity to enter and try to qualify for it but only hire them if they make the cut
My dream is to join indian
And do my service in combat role
The center consists of old people ,none of whom have ever been under the command of a lady officer. Where as we the younger generation having been seen the power and competitiveness of lady officers fully support the supreme courts move.
#WOCRO : women in combat roles
Childcare and familycare; most important points .
If women can go to combat zone why can't man take care of children . 50%of a child 's dna came from father , they should take responsibility .
@@madhusudanchanak9714 2 sal tak breastfiding to mein apne kis chiz se karun agar biwi ne army join kar rakkha to
we will pay for being politically correct every time... women can become weakness to for army if they given combat role...they could be administrate but not fighter ...physical strength of women is 1/5 or less than man...which is real issue...being women is not issue its blessing...
Bro are you serious...a women while giving birth bears up to 25 units of pain that is equal to 20 bones being crushed all together...there have no instance recorded where a man is Abel to bears so much of pain. Above all we should never forget that even Hindu Goddess themselves have weapons in their hand ....?
We are not asking for our another physical and mental stress criteria, if we are ready to bear the same than, where's the problem?
@@RahulNM2308 font pe tensions me lady officer ko kidnap hone se bachae ya tension ko sambahle
@@sohamdeshpande7141 an officer is an officer...the rank is not known by gender. Israle and many other nations already have women fighting at the front. Let me make it clear...ours is a professional army...and never has been a case where an officer is kidnapped😂
@Mars Invaders what if they prove themselves fit enough to serve in non-peace postings?
All this debate is done by non military personnel in a comfort zone.
There are plenty of roles in military for women but they are just not made for combat role
No offense but ever seen the POW situation.
Men too suffer, they are not made of metal.
@@harshranjan8526 how many kg's of military equipment can women can carry.Dont be stupid.War doesn't know ethics.It is a show of strength and power
It's upto women to decide and not male dominated central government.
@@manojkumar-jt3fw it "was" a show of power, now it not about how many kg's it's how many gb's.
@@sahilmulani9838 no.Equal mental capabilities ...yes.Equal physical capabilities no.Even then if u want equality,then women should be treated as equal during combat selection.Same time limit where men and women should run 400mts in 1.50 sec. and and everthing else.
I want to be a para ( sf ) but girls are not allowed in combat roles
However u can join in combat roles as officers in ITBP, BSF, CRPF, CoBRA battalions etc
Para sf is one of the most difficult special force training in the world
do you know why they are not allowed? beacuse they never fit into the fitness criteria. they are women who are stronger and fit for army and can qualify the fitness round without reservation or reduction in criteria. only they desreve to be in army not women who want a special resrvation or reduction in fitness criteria
Loss for indian army on basis of women empowerment
Women might not be as physically strong as some men but that doesn't make them weaker then all men. Women ARE strong, we ARE capable of developing hardcore physical strength. Only if we will be encouraged to have them biceps rather than the 'smooth skin' and the 'soft nurturing hands' by the society maybe we can see a woman's actual potential and stop characterising her as a weaker being!
Which we are not! Biologically speaking, it is not impossible for a woman to have brute strength and we do have equal intellectual capabilities. So men thinking we're not at par with them.... Maybe go and re-attend school for some basic education.
@Ajay Singh Rathore so? Stfu
You really think a average woman can beat a average male
@@kipayaji7731 yes I have seen it happening multiple times but it's ok, I see what really is powerful about men has to be proven over and over again in every single comment 1 year after the comments were made. Yes that surely proves how strong men really are.
Why don't you try fighting a well trained woman and then bring your sorry ass back here? Your entire world view is based on a few examples. Well did you forget about the 'battle of the sexes' the woman won there.
Does that prove women are stronger than men? No. But it does prove that we're equally physically capable, not all of us, but at least some of us, but how many are in combat positions? None of us.
It's so easy to be born into a certain gender and talk from a priviliged perspective, but we too have the spirit of nationalism within us, we too want to fight for our country and we sure can. There are multiple armies around the world where women are in combat positions and they're some of the strongest armed forces in the world.
But ok, go off after a single woman in a comment section to prove your superiority. Hope that helps you get over your insecurities.
Bigottry is an entertaining thing to witness, but rest assured, men and women have more similarities than differences and if average women train even as little as average men and get proper physical training they can match up against most men if not all.
Men are physically stronger than women,but physical strength is not the only way to fight dumbass, I've seen giant wrestlers get rekt by tiny martial artists. Maybe use your brain for something other than bringing an entire gender down because of your insecurities? And try recognizing your priviliges?
@@shreyarishi2720 hahaha...u r the one to make it gender based comment by saying women are not less than men...nobody said women are weak...in all things.. physically they are weak but it doesn't make us superior...there are lot of things which only female can do...
Ofcourse a highly trained woman can beat a man with no training...but do u think a highly trained woman can beat a highly trained man...if women were physically same to men than there would be no separate sports for women they both would be playing together...
Serena Williams lose to 203rd ranked man in tennis... and that man also beat her sister back to back... don't talk with ur emotions...just because a man opposing ur opinion it makes him sexist, mysoginist etc...
Can a woman be easily able to carry a 70kilo man with extra weight of equipments plus her equipments...
Here in my state its not like ur delhi,up, bihar, wherever u r from...our society don't judge woman just because they are wearing short dresses...its free here for women...
Ur whole point doesn't make ant sense but to degrade someone who's not ok with ur opinion...
Now i know, feminists don't care about facts...
The issue is men need 20 pull ups for full score while women need a 15 sec hang for it
Where r u, bro ? Are u referring to school NCC system ? Have u been to the basic military training in Airforce , Navy , BSF, ITBP, CRPF etc, they are all trained same as men and along with men. So no relaxation for them at all. Historically we had many female warriors and present day have u heard of Seema Rao, Tanushree Parikh, Usha Kiran etc. first one is commando trainer and the other two are BSF and CRPF combat officers in BOPs and Naxal areas of Bastar and Dantewada. Wake up bro
@@lifethruvideos from where are you getting these false information. Yardstick for training for men and women are very different. Standards for women are much lower compared to men.
finally girls keval Ghar me roti banane ka kaam na kryngi they can secure our nation too
Chutiya ho tum
@@deepanshusingh3059 yes I m
@@loveeclipse4752 🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣
@@suryakobebryant1641 😘😘😘😘
Ok , its good but they must take equal responsibility , just like men no compromises, if they are weak then they must push themselves to men's level, if they have equal rights then they must take equal responsibility
I want to be in it .That’s my father’s dream
The male female birth ratio is improving , in higher education male female ratio is also improving . In near future we are going to get more and more eligible female candidates for army . We have to train our girls for battlefield very soon . We are indians women . We have taken equal part in independence movement . Even rule the country , we should ready ourselves to save our mother if needed . There is nothing bigger than our country .
In army they train soldiers to properly respect women so it's just funny how some politician are not ready to accept the fact that our army can easily accept women and says that they are not ready .
They are indian man , born from women , raised by women , study at school with girls , went college with them and work side by side in every field why not in army
Indian female has best physical advantage of ambush attack than direct attack
We all think the same as you...then we joined the forces and the fact of life hit us hard...except for one or two...all are a big time liability. A male Captain can handle more stress and tasks than a women with a rank of Colonel /Lt Col in the Indian Armed forces. Physically the male counter part is tougher on an average. So the fights is to have equal selection criteria and still not be gender bias. Everything in the forces is validated through realtime exercises. This recommendation by the center is also a validated exercise. The supreme court is just trying to pressurize the center and the armed forces. Zyada garmi hai,Aajana border par volunteer duty Dene. Most welcome to all.
Who said to take all of them?admit those girls who are similar to those 1 or 2 girls you mentioned
Abe dushman male, female nai dekhta wo sirf goli se baat करता hh isliye jo capable hh use rakho je male female kya hota hh
gender equality 👍
I also want to join Indian army as a Commander and want to serve my nation also give my best in combat zone so according to my points of view girls are able to handle in a combat field because in our India there is many girls who want to join Indian army as a woman commander and they want to go in a battlefield......but problem is that our nation's peoples think that girls cannot do anything they can't survive in a hard situation like a male soldiers. But please I request uh the people to change this policy and your thinking & please as soon as it possible give chance to women also to present them best in a battlefield cause girls can do anything and they are not more less than boys....Jai Hind🇮🇳🙏♥️
@Feminism Ducks just for clarity war is not about being aggressive we are living in the 21st century okay. if it was so, then why SF is called silent killers?
and talking about the period and other losses those who will be applying for the role knew about it. it looks like you are tenser than women. :'
complain comes when women are allowed to be a part of combat roles.
those who are applying for the position they male/female are freaking aware of all the aspects that's why they're soldiers of the Indian army.
can you do the same fitness things as army men do ? if yes then you desrve to be in army
women empowerment 🇮🇳
If they are able to pass meet the same standards as men, or at least close to it, they should be allowed to get the role.
The judiciary should not interfere in army decisions, otherwise making decisions like these would can be a bog mistake
Women want equality in rights in india but don't want equality in duties
Imagine what Pakistanis would've done to a female pilot if she was in the plane which Abhinandan was flying. Seeing your female soldiers being paraded naked on the streets can be very demoralising for the other soldiers. I'm not against women joining the armed forces but they should work in a support role, like in intelligence, medical, transport/reconnaissance, planning and away from combat roles
Mam for your kind information army walo mai apse bhi jyda sochne or smjhne ki sakti hai aapko ghar baith kar gyan dene ki jrurt nahi hai. Wo jo decision lete hai kuch soch smjh kar lete hai or yha jo comments mai bakwas karte hai equality ki gahr baith kar mai yek women hokar bol rhi hu. Women army kitni hi strong ho unse boforce ki yek bullet tak nai uth skti war to aise hi haar jaenge hum smjhe yha baat machinery ki hai weight ki hai koi mjak nai hai jo yha equality dikha rhe ho. Arry bhai khud jaa kar army ko serve krke dekho tab pta chlega.
Finally someone with logic reason...i agree with u
What the fcuk! Dude Indian army is for security of the nation. It's not for creating employment or playing gender equality games. Even the SC should not interfere in that elite organization.
Brotherhood is very important in organisations like Army. It's not Air Force or Navy.
There are only
Indian Air force :- 1700 around 1%
Indian Navy :- 800 around 6%
Indian army :- 7000 around 0.56%
Indian police:- around 10% women's
In my point of view that is right why should girls not go in the war . Before years there jobs in medical army officer.... etc not in a wars this is totally wrong this is also a discrimination for girls . Before years the jhansi rani and many women go in the battle to fight against the king then why should we are not allowed in the wars. We are requested to supreme court that pls give the all opportunity equally treated with boys and girls. And I say second time to humble request pls this my aim to die on the flag so this my request. JAI HIND JAI BHARAT 🇮🇳🇮🇳🇮🇳
One can go on and cite numerous examples. It is important to stop pushing the romantic notion of women in combat roles and start thinking from a practical point of view, keeping the reality in mind
Why are woman not allowed to participate in war and operation as a gd soldier😂😂,..we never heard of girl being martyred why??why every time we heard man casualty??why isnt it about equality??learn to be equal not only in easy environment but also in difficult ones.....
If two army batlle one with female general and the ohter with male... I will bet on the latter
one cannot guarantee that women will come across only female combatants.
Wing Commander Abhinandan Varthaman was shot down last year in an aerial combat with Pakistan Air Force and captured. Imagine the outpouring of emotions nationally if this was a female pilot.
Now, please don’t say that it would not have mattered. We are a country that fell to its knees when a civilian aircraft was hijacked by terrorists, forcing us to release terrorists who continue to haunt the country with attacks after attacks, taking more lives than what was exchanged for.
In the Army, female officers are regularly deployed to the front, especially as doctors who are also sent for medical camps in Kashmir. However, extra precaution is involved to prevent their kidnapping.
Also, one is often given the example of foreign armies like the US and Israel that have female combatants. But even their forces don’t deploy women in direct infantry combat.
What do you wanna say by Kidnapping 😂?
We as a nation came to knees when civilians got hijacked which consisted of both men and women. Understood
No offense..but sitting inside an air conditioned room and thinking out loud to everyone isn't something new....it's not easy to deploy any kind of troops that instantly...lots of experiments and money and time is needed..who doesn't want to fight along with our mothers and sisters..we'll be proud..so...Indian military and government sexist nahi hai...but at the same time itna stupid bhi nahi hai ki bas logo ne chillaya aur bina soche samjhe kar diya...no offense again sister...✌
Ma'am ek male ko Indian army mein qualify krne k liye 1600 metre Just 5 min mein lagane hotein
Whereas the same distance for women are given 7-8 min
Indian commando ki 3 saal ki tough training plus plus 6 mahine dead training hoti hai
Whereas after many test ye prove ho chuka hai ki women's ye Puri nhi kr payengi tau jaise running mein privelges milli hai unhe isme bhi kuch privelges Dene padenge
Aap equality ki baat krti hai naa😏
Tau Zara ye bataiye kyaa koi village boy kisi aise ko apna senior accept kr payega jinki combat skills and mental skills khud usse bahut neeche ho 😏😂
Apko superior position kab dii jaati hai jab apki skills apke juniors se achi ho reservation ka prasad tau bat nhi Raha ki aao aur le jaao reservation k naam pe
We don't have any problem but pehle simple army running mein men's ki tarah 5 min mein 1600 metre ki equality leke aaiye uske baad equality ki baat ki jaaye
Ofc a good decision 🌟
Artillery department is waiting 🤣🤣🤣
>•Madam it much easier by doing makeup and came in front of camera and said about this but actual reality is very different in combat in special forces they have mentally physically morally become super fit to part of special forces and there is not about men or women ok .
•when you go in operation are you able to take your clothes in front of your men?? Are you comfortable to sleep together in night with other male, are you able do climbed and conduct sreaching operation more then 20 days and so more there was no excuse work, on you are in operation or fighting and hunting there is no place for any excuse and we have to accept that there was health difference between male and female , women have a menstruation cycle are you capable to do your duty hunting over mountain in the "period" without maintaining any hygienic conditions ..
If you are accepted this all circumference and conditions then you can you will join in the "combact "
Its gud...even lord shiva want gender equality.
But, what about next generation ? who will take care of their child and most importantly who will teach them ethics and moral values ?
Bla bla bla........
Can they go to siachen along with men😆
Ofc they can
They should allow women
Commanding se pehle soldier bno
They must take, responsibility, it is about country's securities so feminism won't work , the must push themselves to men's level
nahi kar sakti ma'am maan lijiye
Kanjre