Learn two years of university-level Arabic in six months by joining the 6-Month Arabic Intensive starting July 2024. Visit themadinanway.org/arabicintensive to learn more.
keep dreaming. this makeshift sword of yours-may I ask how many books, research papers, articles etc has he written on Hadith ?? no one knows most likely you have never read anything by him on the topic either. @@LowlierThanThow
It's not even a debate. Fear Allah old man. If Shaykh al-Mujadid Muhammad Nassiruddin al-Albaani was still alive then it won't take even 1 min for him to make u lose the debate
@@mocro4life5713you know who is funnier ? People like wahhabis who‘s only „scholars“ they have (ibn baz ibn uthaymeen al albani and salih fawzan) literally contradict the Great majority of Ulama throughout history and the salaf us salih in even fundamental things
@@champ_maroc_1223 your the funniest when i speak about aqeedah i mention the books of the first 300 years of the muslims not even sheikh ibn baz , al albani or uthaymeen rahimom allah they are great scholars who we should follow but the salaf is greater when i speak about aqeedah i mention the book of imam bukhari khalaq afaal ibaad or i mention rad ala zanadiqah wa jahmiyyah of imam ahmed or kitab as sunnah of imam abdullah ibn ahmed or rad ala marisi of ad darimi or kitab tawheed of ibn khuzaymah or sarh ou sunnah of imam muzani or the poem al hai’iyyah of ibn abi dawood the son of of the compiler of sunan abu dawood i qoute the salaf
Adab al Mufrad is a famous book. Even the newest students of knowledge know about it. To claim that Al-Albani didn't know about its content (being Sahih or Da'eef) is hard to believe and digest. And furthermore, where is the evidence for this "debate"?
Shaykh Al bani رحمه الله تعالى Has performed the تخريج of Al adab and differentiated between the sahih and daeef ahadith he has 2 books صحيح و ضعيف الأدب المفرد
I was thinking the same and changing name of scholar after given daleel is not digestible?? Mean he said bukhari u gave daleel and he said muslim u gave daleel,May Allah suppress the oppressor and upon the liar be the curse who knowingly say something to malign someone Ameen
That's precisely the point, that means he must have known that Bukhari, despite being the most rigorous of authenticators used weak hadith. Hence, to claim that it's wrong to quote weak hadith in any instance is valid from the scholars of hadith. Yet, Shaykh al-Albani denied his.
Any pure sunni scholor can win a debate with a salafi. The sunni creed goes back to the salaf and eventually the prophet. The wahhabi creed goes back to najdi and it is only 250 years old.
Only Idiot like you will make a comment like that.😂 Go back and study these books authored by the imams of salaf and don't take aqeeda from pagan Greek philosophers. Kitab Us Sunnah by Imam Abdullah bin Ahmed bin Hanbal As Sunnah by Imam Abu Bakr Al Khallal Dham Al Kalam Wa Alihi by Imam Ismail Al Harawi Naqd Uthman bin Said Ad Darimi by Imam Ad Darimi Khalq Afaal Al Ibaad by Imam Bukhari Kitabul Iman by Imam Ibn Abi Shaybah Kitab Ar Radd Alaz Zanadiqah va Jahmiyyah by Imam Ahmed bin Hanbal Al Ibanah Al Kubra by Imam Ibn Battah Al Ukhbari
If you read the aqeedah of the 4 imams, you will call then Wahhabis too, they were athari salafi in aqeedah, you are not from ahlus Sunnah, you are mubtadis, you are upon Biddah, the salaf as Saleh are free from you
@gamingwith15 you don't know nothing about the 4 madhabs at all. If you read fiqh akbar. Fiqh absat and al wasiya of Abu hanifa. It makes direct takfeer on the mujasima (wahhabies ) Don't ever dare to compare wahhabies to ahla sunna you ahlul bidah dallal
Masha Allah Dewbandi Are All over in World And dewbandi is true path In Islam and dewbandi is real Ahle Sunnat Wal Jamat and Bareilvi is Not Islam Bareilvi Biddat and Ahmad Raza Khan is Not Muslim Ahmad Raza Khan Keep out in Islam
@@hashimkhan5895you’re pathetic stop speaking and doing takfir on people as a layperson even the deobandis don’t accept this and even your elder scholars praised Imam Ahmad Raza Khan and didn’t takfir him (despite them thinking he’s misguided) so who are you to say this
@@hashimkhan5895then why did asraf ali thanvi say on his death r.a that the hanafiyyat and ahlussunat has died from the subcontinent today ....😂 He was a pious scholar an imam of his time imam ahmed raza khan al barelvi r.a also hussain ahmed madni defended thier claims when he had tk refute qadianis refer to qari tayyeb😅
Is your purpose to educate people regarding the usage of weak ahadith or to show that a certain scholar lost a debate? Are you truly giving Naseehah or are you pleasing your Nafs in the process? Is there no other way to spread good than to discredit others and look down upon them? ادع إلى سبيل ربك بالحكمة والموعظة الحسنة وجادلهم بالتي هي أحسن If one is commanded to do so with the kuffar then what stops you from doing so with your fellow brothers? This isn't the only video where you've done this. While the point you are defending may be correct, the way you present it will turn away many sincere brothers. Whats the point of translating all these videos if they are only geared toward a group which already agrees with your point?
You like people and your teacher have no knowledge therefore you and your teacher albani use such damn things to To provoke anger and deviate from the debate which Wahabees are losing
This wasn't a debate. This was an alim schooling a layman. Al-Albani wasn't an alim in anything except repairing watches. People who think he was an alim or muhaddith, simply don't know the technical definition of these terms, or were misguided by the heretical Salafi sect or influenced by Sheikh ibn-ternet who told them 🤖: "If his youtube views are high and google or wiki says he's a scholar, then he must be!"
Fear Allah, you will be held to account for what you have said. If you disagreed with the sheikh you didn’t have to go that low in to mocking him سبحان الله
@@iymuslimYOU fear Allah for following someone without knowing how to assess whether or not he's actually a scholar. What makes you so sure he's an alim? Do you know the meaning of the word and how one acquires this title or even what the jurisdiction of different ranks of ulema are?
so these volumes on Takhrij e Hadith were written by your dad? or this Alim? I don't even know 1 ONE book on Hadith or 1 ONE paper written by this Sheikh
Masha Allah Dewbandi Are All over in World And dewbandi is true path In Islam and dewbandi is real Ahle Sunnat Wal Jamat and Bareilvi is Not Islam Bareilvi Biddat and Ahmad Raza Khan is Not Muslim Ahmad Raza Khan Keep out in Islam
@@karimtemri1664 Dewbandi is not bidda dewbandi is also tauheedi and Ahle Hadees is also true Islam and dewbandi and Ahle Hadees is brother brother but Bareilvi are not muslim Bareilvi are biddati mushrik
Oh! You who believe fear God and speak truth. Shyakh Albani( rahamtullah) was a great Hadith scholar who dedicated his life to the service of Sunnah. He is rightly known as Reviver of sunnah. Wallah! The research which is going on now in whole arab & ajam was stared by shyalk albani.. He was a great researcher of Hadith & it's allied sciences but he is not Infamible. He has his mistakes but his goods are like Himaliya mountain in comparison to his mistake just just a few. One who don't know his level in Hadith science should go through his original book like Irwa al galeel Or silsila sahiya and see how beautiful he was. May Allah give him jannatul firdous
From whom he learned hadith? Who is his teacher? I googled it, and i still cant find it, all i found was he studied book of hadith alone in the library without mentor, can u help me?
Albani have more knowledge of hadith than Imam Bukhari he even corrected mistakes in Sahih Bukhari He had mentioned that some of the The hadith in Bukhari are of Hasan level
@@thetruth9918 He do not have anyone to learn from or rely on. Anyone can learn from internet or books but they still have some form of pass down knowledge. A person can picked up a book and learned from it. Albani challenged the book and reject the way of the original Salaf He is probably self taught like Buddha or using his own desire to make judgement of which hadith is Sahih or not. Allah know best
@@anassikhan2512 astaghfirullah, brother, this hadith, words of rasul, this is not buddhisim, even rasulullah was taught by Jibril, how come albani self taught??
Imam Ahmad Ibn Hanbal (رحمه الله) was among the people the hardest towards Abdullah ibn Sa'id ibn Kullâb and his followers like al-Harith [al-Muhâsibî] and others. "Siyâr A'lâm An-nouboulâ" by Adh-Dhahabî volume 14 page 380
Masha Allah Dewbandi Are All over in World And dewbandi is true path In Islam and dewbandi is real Ahle Sunnat Wal Jamat and Bareilvi is Not Islam Bareilvi Biddat and Ahmad Raza Khan is Not Muslim Ahmad Raza Khan Keep out in Islam
I never trust these short beard scholars.. Anyways Sheikh Albani never claimed we should reject weak hadith all together.. Some people try to become famous by throwing dirt at someone who is truly famous,, this uploader doesn't know the meaning of the word 'debate'. In fact I can guarantee that if Dr. Ali Gomaa see this title he wouldn't approve of it.
what you should take into account is that this was early in al bani life ....towards the end he claimed that there were some hadiths in bukhari that we weak and wrong and his Intention was that only the book of Allah will be without errors and that is 100% the truth !!! you can only use a weak hadith to strengthen a Hasan hadith and that's only if there is alot of weak hadiths that support it. the science of this is very deep. Wallahi if you reach 1% of what albani dedicated in his life you should be grateful....this ummah is so far away subhanallah may Allah guide us and grant us victory Allahumme ameen
Talk about Shej Albani here but forget that Sheikh Albani searched for 10 years during his life for a part of a hadith to find this part of the hadith as written by Muslim or Bukari, may God have mercy on both Muslim and Bukari in order to find the rest of the hadith, he read all the university books in the Faculty that he taught Sheikh Albani was a person who did not give answers with his head, but he always said the answer from those great scholars who took the Deen from the prophet and the continuing chain like Muslim Bukhkari and many other scholars while this Scholar is appearing to have won a debate against Shej Albani on one issue, first to say this, look for the research on this issue, how Shej Albani responded to these that second in Islam there is no one and where we will defeat and where we will laugh at how to be weak in Islam, Sheikh Albani did not have and there is no such Islam because the work of Sheikh Albani was from the first chains of knowledge from the time of the prophet and after his death the prophet as a scholar Muslim Bukhari My question for this scholar is To which sect does this scholar belong? God Forgive us ane save us from Shirk and Bidat
did any of you who keep saying “it’s not a debate cause al-Albani can’t defend himself he’s dead” actually watch the video ?? the Shaykh is referencing a debate which was held between them IN THE PAST back when al-Albani was still alive, no one is saying that the debate is this video itself, Shaykh Gomaa is simply relaying to us the conversation that took place when al-Albani challenged him and his Shuyukh 🤦🏽♂️
And you think this man can challenge Al Albani, how many books did Al Albani write? And how many books did this man write?. Al Albani received the national King faisán prize for islaamic studies for effort on the knowledge of peophetic hadeeth. He is thee greatest scholar in the world. Scholars read Al Albani's books before writing a book. That shows a lot of who Albani was.
ممّا أتوقّع من فضيلته أنّه من أهل العلم ،ولا أتصور لشرف علمكم أن يخفى لديكم منهج الشيخين وشرطهما في صحيحيهما مع ما أورداه خارج الصحيحين، وما ذكره مسلم في المقدمة والذي ذكره في أصل الصحيح...
Click bait but it worked. Wait, it's actually very sad that a Shaykh would make a claim like this with no proof or witnesses. I want to believe him but...
For a detailed discussion on this topic here is a whole series dedicated to weak hadith, albani is mentioned as are several other outstanding hadith scholars: ruclips.net/video/gOrx7J2DwYw/видео.html
All respectfully he's claiming that sheikh Albani picks and chooses hadiths when sheikh Albani accepts every authentic hadith no matter what. If you're gonna accept weak hadiths that are not considerably weak means you're gonna pick and choose put some respect on sheikh Albani Allah yer7amo
Respectfully al albani is not a muhaddith in the first place, he studied hadith my himself in the library, with all due respect he is not a scholar of hadith
@@mamadoufarissou7312 with all due respect he taught at the University of Madina twice where they invited him because a known scholar convinced the University to invited him but he ended up leaving due to minor disagreements about if the Niqab is mandatory or not he held the position that it is not mandatory while they held the position its mandatory even after that he left and they invited him back to teach at the University. And after all of that when he disagreed with the University again he left but he still had the respect of the scholars at there university of medina and was friends with some of them for years he a scholar and you should only accept authentic hadith
@@aosel-gharably1070 so what, wahhabis at the university of medina invited another wahhabi to teach, circular argument, it doesnt mean he is credible, otherwise yasir qadhi should be credible as well because he finished top his promotion in medina
@@mamadoufarissou7312 there is no such thing as wahabi we follow the Sunnah of the prophet according to the interpretation of the first 3 generation which are the Salaf. The Quran says to follow almuhajiroon which are the migrants that migrated from Makkah to medina and the Quran says to follow alansar which are the people of medina. That's all in chapter 9 verse 100. Also in an authentic hadith there prophet says the best generations are mine then those who came after them and then those who came after them which are the generations of the salaf. May Allah guide you I know you just don't know
@@mamadoufarissou7312 yessir qadi is a deviants may Allah guide him her doesn't even believe that the Quran was preserved don't compare sheikh Albani to him because you're clearly a person still learning since you wanna argue to use unauthenticated hadith
This man is the same man who said it is allowed to ask the dead for help, the same man that said that mixing and being friends with non-mahram woman is halal. Sufis are not Sunnis and Salafi are Sunnis alhamdulillah.
@@ibniftikhar It's not grammatical mistakes, it's simple dialect, only when your reciting the quran you have to recite the alphabet according to the rules of Tajwid
What is Ali Jumuah compared to Sheikh Albaani in the knowledge of Hadith except like a drop of water compared to an ocean. The people of bid’aah hate Sheikh Albaani soo much and try to make him look bad in any way they can. Sheikh Albaani was a scholar of hadith, upon the sunnah, with the correct aqeedah, unlike your Sufi sheikh who is upon innovation and wrong aqeedah, May Allah guide him and the likes of you who put these kinds of videos. Haven’t you seen how Allah accepted from Sheikh Albaani that his name is mentioned in all over the whole behind the mention of the ahaadith of Prophet صلى الله عليه وسلم. Yes, Sheikh Albaani is a human being, and just like other human beings and scholars, he makes mistakes. But his mistakes are not upon desires, they are upon ijtihaad. May Allah have mercy upon Sheikh Albaani. It has been more than 20 years since he passed away and the general Muslims, students of knowledge, and scholars all over the world still benefit from his knowledge on issues of hadith, aqeedah, fiqh, and even the Arabic language. Written on the 20th of Dhul Hijjah 1442 corresponding to July 30 2021.
Mind you that the one talking about Al Albani has signed a fatwa stating that it is permitted to sell Alchohol and Pork in the west 😂. Not only that but he said women can be presidents and lead muslim countries in this day and age. Not only that he went as far as saying women can be judges 😂😂 a total joke and a coward of a man. If Albani was sitting in front of him he would not dare to utter those words.
Ali Gomaa is a sufi practicing bidah(innovation, sin) proven in this video "Sufi Dhikr in Egypt (Fully Translated) - Natawassal Bil Hubaabah - Habib Umar, Ali Gomaa" ruclips.net/video/TqJibY3ZDVQ/видео.html&ab_channel=HashimAziz
Masha Allah Dewbandi Are All over in World And dewbandi is true path In Islam and dewbandi is real Ahle Sunnat Wal Jamat and Bareilvi is Not Islam Bareilvi Biddat and Ahmad Raza Khan is Not Muslim Ahmad Raza Khan Keep out in Islam
Muhammad Umar Mustafa, the brother Abu Aaliyah Abdullah Battle who has: a B.A Degree in Islamic studies (Hadith and its sciences), an M.A (Fiqhus Sunnah) and is currently a Ph.D Student (Hadith ) made the following reply to this video on Facebook. ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- 'I watched some of it and the point he made about imam al- Bukhari’s others book which have weak to show they are accepted so as long they aren’t extremely weak. This can be answered from many angles the first is that yes they can be collected and in the event another Hadith comes by way of a different chain, narrator or meaning then the Hadith goes from being weak to hasan li ghayrihi.' 'The second point is bukhari didn’t make it a condition to narrate all authentic Hadith in those books but cited them for various reasons . This is similar to the 4 Sunnan . Take for example abu Dawud who collected all the Hadith the fuqaha acted on in his time , similarly to at tirmithi.' 'The other issue about the intro to sahih Muslims intro being different than his sahih and he claims only al albani took this position is a flagrant lie as; 1- imam Al Albani never takes a position unless he has an imam who has preceded him in it 2- there is no ijma on this topic as imam ad daruqutni preceded sh Nasir in that and I’d say refer to Shaykh Rabee Al madkhalis masters Thesis ( between the two imams ad daruqutni and Muslim).'
what im going to say right now is directed to the owner of this channel however anyone can feel free to respond. dua is a act of worship right? we as muslim only worship allah alone which concludes to the fact that when someone makes dua(act of worship) to other than allah that means he isnt worshiping allah rather he is worshiping the one who he is making dua too
Dua is act of worship, Allah alone is the ultimate provider. I think you are getting confused between Dua and Isthagatha. Istagatha is also a form of Waseela, as Allah, his Angels, Gabriel and righteous servants are the helpers. Remember, the Wobblers might trick you saying Iyya ka Na’budu We seek only from Allah Remember, Alhamdolillah also means All praiseses are to Allah, but when we praise creation it is also allowed. Allah is the ultimate provider and all praises are due to him alone.
@@MustafaHasanKhan you istigatha from other than Allah is falsehood here is evidence It was narrated from al-Nu’maan ibn Basheer that the Prophet (peace and blessings of Allaah be upon him) said: “Du’aa’ is worship,” then he recited (interpretation of the meaning): “And your Lord said: ‘Invoke Me [i.e. believe in My Oneness (Islamic Monotheism) and ask Me for anything] I will respond to your (invocation). Verily, those who scorn My worship [i.e. do not invoke Me, and do not believe in My Oneness, (Islamic Monotheism)] they will surely enter Hell in humiliation!’” [Ghaafir 40:60] Narrated by al-Tirmidhi, 2895; Ibn Maajah, 3818; classed as saheeh by al-Albaani in Saheeh al-Tirmidhi, 2370.
Mouaad boettgenbach - yes dua is worship, but not all dua is worship. There are many examples throughout the Quran and sunnah where the word "dua" or a derivative of it is used but not in the meaning of worship. So you would have to concede that IF someone makes dua to other than Allah then which intention are they doing that with? IF its for worship then its shirk. IF it's not for worship then it's not. BTW an example of a verse of the Quran is when Allah tells the people, "Do not call the Prophet صلى الله عليه وسلم the way you call one another..." the word "dua" is used. May Allah guide us. Ameen.
@@mmaman6931 his political views are abominable. He supported the coup against Morsi and encouraged the soldiers to kill protestors. After the rabaa massacre he still justified the army's actions. Their deaths are on his hands
@@thestealth2448 the same applies to Ibn Bayyah. Although these scholars are knowledgeable (I am a small fish I won't deny that) their political actions and stances are a total disaster. I rather follow people like Shakyh Dedew or Tarifi. But I don't wanna make fitna now :)
@@zerochance7708 dedew and tarifi?never heard of them...i know shaykh mohammad al yaqubi ...he is 34 descendant of imam hassan ...i like his personality and him being descendant of imam hassan ,i can follow him without any fear...nowadays there are a lot of scholars who are not very knowledgeable or truthworthy
Sufi where were you when sheikh Albani was alive why didn't you speak to sheikh Albani face to face because sheikh Albani criticized Sufi about the preying which not following the Sunna of our prophet Muhammad S.a.w the time of prey Salah is not to prey four rahkat in 5 minutes and after finishing prayers our prophet Muhammad S.a.w didn't said to have a dance in house 🏠 of Allah this is Sufi doing against the Sunna of our prophet Muhammad S.a.w shame on you .
You don’t even know how to judge what greatness is. Al-‘Utbi reported: Al-Harith ibn Hut came to Ali and he said to him, “Do you see that I think Talhah, Al-Zubayr, and Aisha have united upon falsehood?” Ali, may Allah be pleased with him, said, “O rebel, you are confused! Verily, truth and falsehood are not known by the statures of men. Know the truth and you will recognize its people. Know falsehood and you will recognize the one who brings it.” Source: Ansāb al-Ashrāf 2/274 We have criteria from blessed mouth of the messenger of Allah ﷺ. A chain of narration back to him as one. Albani had no Sanad back to the prophet in anything and won’t be mentioned in chains of narration. The best of us have come and walked this earth and died (salaf) who is albani in comparison to them as he contradicts them in 70% of his works including his own contradictions amongst his grading me and knowledge of men in his process. We know the great scholars of Hadith, till this day and amongst the Sunni circles of knowledge preserved through Sanad! Not a claim of sayings, through Sanad. Albani has never been mentioned amongst them. May Allah have mercy on his soul.
In your dreams he has done fuhush mistakes 😂 ...when comes across the fazail of ali a.s he says the sanad is sahih but my heart doesnt accept it ....poor folk would he been here today i would have helped him with a heart surgery for free ....😂
Oh? Who told you this and why do you believe them? Let me guess your answer: "The other scholars said so." Really? What makes you think they're scholars? That's the question people never ask: what is the standard for determining if someone is an alim?
Is this guy insane?!! He said weak Hadith. Weak is weak. How come you take from the weak?!! If you take the weak then what’s the difference between you and the jews and the christians who take the weak!
No there are different types of weak ahadith For example in Hanafi madhab if you have for a lot of weak hadith narrating the same thing Then they accept it
😂 Sheikh Albani is the one who everyone respected and the one who if you went to him then you would fear Allah and be shocked and he is the one who was seen in a dream with the Prophet Muhammad scw
Assalla Muallikuum May Allah guide these sufis Many mushrikuns around attempting to poison Islam Sheikh Albani job was to collect hadiths May Allah give him Jannah
Albani was the best muhadith on the earth may Allah have mercy on him. As for the other guy and this speaker I never heard of. Fake people speaking fake about gratest muhadith
Imam Al Bukhari Rahimullah did not claimed Sahih for all of his books expect the book of hadith which called Sahi al Bukhari. when any intellectual people read the chain mention in al adab al mufarad, the chain is weak according to Imam Bukhari himself claimed in his Sahih... so when Shykh Al Bani rahimullah gave references to other books, he made according to the usool al hadith wa jarah o tadeel plus according to the knowledge of Asma ur rejal....
i don't understand the point of this video. anybody can say "we brought him excerpts, so no one was left for him except himself." it remains a comment. nobody can prove it. there are weak/problematic ahadith in sahih al bukhari (and no book is free from mistakes except the Qur'an). we have to get rid of this hadith extremism as an ummah. There is hadith literature available for the lay people, like imam maliks muwatta. but sahih al bukhari definetly isn't hadith literature for layman. and the scholars have to be honest about it and don't push this "bukhari and sahih propaganda", as lot of evil can emerge from this.
The point of the video is in the start and in the thumbnail, Nasir Al Din Sahab rejected all weak hadith and made a claim that it was the methodology of the foremost hadith scholars, which was proven to be not the case by Dr Ali here as all the foremost hadith scholars included weak narrations provided they aren't considerably weak, for use in virtues of deeds etc.
@@MirOmran are you sure? look how Imam Malik dealt with weak Ahadith and ahadith in general. I know the argument, which the shaykh mentions in this Video. But why is he mentioning Imam Muslim's "Muqaddimah" only when it comes to weak narrations? sahih al Bukhari isn't mentioned at all, as it is always the case... that doesn't change the fact, that there are weak Ahadith in these books (sahih al bukhari and sahih muslims and other hadith collections). No matter how you try to suggar code it. We need sincere scholars, who help this ummah to get a healthy mindset of accepting -and rejecting-(!) Ahadith when it comes to unauthentic narrations. But with this video and these words from the shaykh, the "sahih propaganda" is pushed to the limit. I don't have a problem, that people want to do good acts, if they're narrated in a weak hadith but in the same way people should be open, when someone says, that a hadith in sahih al bukhari is weak.
![Shaykh Nasiruddin Al-Albani [RA]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/IojPF1F6WT8/mqdefault.jpg)
![Shaykh Nasiruddin Al-Albani [RA]](/img/tr.png)
Learn two years of university-level Arabic in six months by joining the 6-Month Arabic Intensive starting July 2024.
Visit themadinanway.org/arabicintensive to learn more.
Jazak Allah shaykh Dr. Ali Gooma Hafizahullah.The great scholar of Ahnaf.
comparing Sheikh Al Albani with this Dr.Ali Gomaa is like comparing the sword with a stick!!!
You're right.
Ali Goma is like a sword.
keep dreaming. this makeshift sword of yours-may I ask how many books, research papers, articles etc has he written on Hadith ?? no one knows most likely you have never read anything by him on the topic either. @@LowlierThanThow
@@DAWAHTIME1 Why don't you comment on the number of ijāzas they each have.
It's not even a debate. Fear Allah old man. If Shaykh al-Mujadid Muhammad Nassiruddin al-Albaani was still alive then it won't take even 1 min for him to make u lose the debate
Dawatul wahabiya don't bark
yes only you have barking rights@@faizanhashmi389
All the Salaf, even Imam Ahmad Bin Hanbal, said daef hadith can be used in certain cases.
Good Joke. Gay Albani
@@khalidshaikh5963 it's alright for you to not to take and learn from Albani but to call him gay just makes you look like an idiot.
Any proof of the debate? Or are we expected to take your word for it.?
@@dardandema9298 he's a master of taqiyyah like the shia
Debate? That was a monologue 😂 Then I won in debates against Fakhruddeen al-Razi, al-Ghazali and Suyuti😂
Ahhahaahahhaahh whallahi these jahmi asharis are funny 😂😂
He is relating to us the debate he had.
Did you meet Fakhr ud-Deen ar-Rāzi and debate him?
bro u will never ever come close to the level of knowledge and piety of those great people. Stay in ur lane.
@@mocro4life5713you know who is funnier ? People like wahhabis who‘s only „scholars“ they have (ibn baz ibn uthaymeen al albani and salih fawzan) literally contradict the Great majority of Ulama throughout history and the salaf us salih in even fundamental things
@@champ_maroc_1223 your the funniest when i speak about aqeedah i mention the books of the first 300 years of the muslims not even sheikh ibn baz , al albani or uthaymeen rahimom allah they are great scholars who we should follow but the salaf is greater when i speak about aqeedah i mention the book of imam bukhari khalaq afaal ibaad or i mention rad ala zanadiqah wa jahmiyyah of imam ahmed or kitab as sunnah of imam abdullah ibn ahmed or rad ala marisi of ad darimi or kitab tawheed of ibn khuzaymah or sarh ou sunnah of imam muzani or the poem al hai’iyyah of ibn abi dawood the son of of the compiler of sunan abu dawood i qoute the salaf
Adab al Mufrad is a famous book. Even the newest students of knowledge know about it. To claim that Al-Albani didn't know about its content (being Sahih or Da'eef) is hard to believe and digest. And furthermore, where is the evidence for this "debate"?
Shaykh Al bani رحمه الله تعالى
Has performed the تخريج of Al adab and differentiated between the sahih and daeef ahadith he has 2 books صحيح و ضعيف الأدب المفرد
I was thinking the same and changing name of scholar after given daleel is not digestible?? Mean he said bukhari u gave daleel and he said muslim u gave daleel,May Allah suppress the oppressor and upon the liar be the curse who knowingly say something to malign someone Ameen
That's precisely the point, that means he must have known that Bukhari, despite being the most rigorous of authenticators used weak hadith. Hence, to claim that it's wrong to quote weak hadith in any instance is valid from the scholars of hadith. Yet, Shaykh al-Albani denied his.
Any pure sunni scholor can win a debate with a salafi. The sunni creed goes back to the salaf and eventually the prophet.
The wahhabi creed goes back to najdi and it is only 250 years old.
Only Idiot like you will make a comment like that.😂
Go back and study these books authored by the imams of salaf and don't take aqeeda from pagan Greek philosophers.
Kitab Us Sunnah by Imam Abdullah bin Ahmed bin Hanbal
As Sunnah by Imam Abu Bakr Al Khallal
Dham Al Kalam Wa Alihi by Imam Ismail Al Harawi
Naqd Uthman bin Said Ad Darimi by Imam Ad Darimi
Khalq Afaal Al Ibaad by Imam Bukhari
Kitabul Iman by Imam Ibn Abi Shaybah
Kitab Ar Radd Alaz Zanadiqah va Jahmiyyah by Imam Ahmed bin Hanbal
Al Ibanah Al Kubra by Imam Ibn Battah Al Ukhbari
That's horribly ironic
If you read the aqeedah of the 4 imams, you will call then Wahhabis too, they were athari salafi in aqeedah, you are not from ahlus Sunnah, you are mubtadis, you are upon Biddah, the salaf as Saleh are free from you
Pure Sunni and Salafi is the same thing
@gamingwith15 you don't know nothing about the 4 madhabs at all. If you read fiqh akbar. Fiqh absat and al wasiya of Abu hanifa. It makes direct takfeer on the mujasima (wahhabies )
Don't ever dare to compare wahhabies to ahla sunna you ahlul bidah dallal
May Allah grant Imam Albani one of the highest positions in Jannah
Alhamdulillah... Sheikh Albani rahimahullah is quoted all over the world... Iam from India.
yeh and no one even knows this man
Misleading Title
Your translation skills are exemplary, mā shā Allah. May Allah increase you in good.
Masha Allah Dewbandi Are All over in World And dewbandi is true path In Islam and dewbandi is real Ahle Sunnat Wal Jamat and Bareilvi is Not Islam Bareilvi Biddat and Ahmad Raza Khan is Not Muslim Ahmad Raza Khan Keep out in Islam
@@hashimkhan5895you’re pathetic stop speaking and doing takfir on people as a layperson even the deobandis don’t accept this and even your elder scholars praised Imam Ahmad Raza Khan and didn’t takfir him (despite them thinking he’s misguided) so who are you to say this
@@hashimkhan5895then why did asraf ali thanvi say on his death r.a that the hanafiyyat and ahlussunat has died from the subcontinent today ....😂 He was a pious scholar an imam of his time imam ahmed raza khan al barelvi r.a also hussain ahmed madni defended thier claims when he had tk refute qadianis refer to qari tayyeb😅
Is your purpose to educate people regarding the usage of weak ahadith or to show that a certain scholar lost a debate? Are you truly giving Naseehah or are you pleasing your Nafs in the process?
Is there no other way to spread good than to discredit others and look down upon them?
ادع إلى سبيل ربك بالحكمة والموعظة الحسنة وجادلهم بالتي هي أحسن
If one is commanded to do so with the kuffar then what stops you from doing so with your fellow brothers?
This isn't the only video where you've done this. While the point you are defending may be correct, the way you present it will turn away many sincere brothers. Whats the point of translating all these videos if they are only geared toward a group which already agrees with your point?
Gomaa-r in albanian language means donkey
😂
Albani in arabic means my milks, so what is your point
You like people and your teacher have no knowledge therefore you and your teacher albani use such damn things to To provoke anger and deviate from the debate which Wahabees are losing
The Great Scholar Shaikh Ali Guma ❤️❤️ 🇮🇳
This wasn't a debate. This was an alim schooling a layman. Al-Albani wasn't an alim in anything except repairing watches. People who think he was an alim or muhaddith, simply don't know the technical definition of these terms, or were misguided by the heretical Salafi sect or influenced by Sheikh ibn-ternet who told them 🤖: "If his youtube views are high and google or wiki says he's a scholar, then he must be!"
😂😂😂
Yeah he repair watches just like your ulmas 😂😂😂
Fear Allah, you will be held to account for what you have said. If you disagreed with the sheikh you didn’t have to go that low in to mocking him سبحان الله
@@iymuslimYOU fear Allah for following someone without knowing how to assess whether or not he's actually a scholar. What makes you so sure he's an alim? Do you know the meaning of the word and how one acquires this title or even what the jurisdiction of different ranks of ulema are?
so these volumes on Takhrij e Hadith were written by your dad? or this Alim? I don't even know 1 ONE book on Hadith or 1 ONE paper written by this Sheikh
This guy debated a dead person!! Dammmmnnn!
Isn't Ali gomaa the same guy who promoted building churches on tv?
Lol
U promote that u are in qufr
Masha Allah Dewbandi Are All over in World And dewbandi is true path In Islam and dewbandi is real Ahle Sunnat Wal Jamat and Bareilvi is Not Islam Bareilvi Biddat and Ahmad Raza Khan is Not Muslim Ahmad Raza Khan Keep out in Islam
@@hashimkhan5895 where did Allah or his messenger talk about deobandi
@@hashimkhan5895 deobandi also bas many bidaah. Salafiya is the correct form of Islam!
@@karimtemri1664
Dewbandi is not bidda dewbandi is also tauheedi and Ahle Hadees is also true Islam and dewbandi and Ahle Hadees is brother brother but Bareilvi are not muslim Bareilvi are biddati mushrik
Oh! You who believe fear God and speak truth.
Shyakh Albani( rahamtullah) was a great Hadith scholar who dedicated his life to the service of Sunnah. He is rightly known as Reviver of sunnah. Wallah! The research which is going on now in whole arab & ajam was stared by shyalk albani.. He was a great researcher of Hadith & it's allied sciences but he is not Infamible. He has his mistakes but his goods are like Himaliya mountain in comparison to his mistake just just a few. One who don't know his level in Hadith science should go through his original book like Irwa al galeel Or silsila sahiya and see how beautiful he was. May Allah give him jannatul firdous
From whom he learned hadith? Who is his teacher? I googled it, and i still cant find it, all i found was he studied book of hadith alone in the library without mentor, can u help me?
Albani have more knowledge of hadith than Imam Bukhari he even corrected mistakes in Sahih Bukhari
He had mentioned that some of the The hadith in Bukhari are of Hasan level
@@anassikhan2512 ok, still, who were his teacher? From whom he learned hadith?
@@thetruth9918 He do not have anyone to learn from or rely on.
Anyone can learn from internet or books but they still have some form of pass down knowledge.
A person can picked up a book and learned from it. Albani challenged the book and reject the way of the original Salaf
He is probably self taught like Buddha or using his own desire to make judgement of which hadith is Sahih or not. Allah know best
@@anassikhan2512 astaghfirullah, brother, this hadith, words of rasul, this is not buddhisim, even rasulullah was taught by Jibril, how come albani self taught??
Why he call "create Actions of the slave?" Directly
LA ILAHA ILLALLAH
MUHAMMADUR RASULULLAH
ALLAH k siwa koi mabud nhi or muhammad (s.w) ALLAH k rasul he
There's problem with the description of the video. Sheikh Albani cannot debate while he is with the Muslim who passed away
I think it wasn't even a debate ,
و الله أعلم .
الله يهدينا .
Imam Ahmad Ibn Hanbal (رحمه الله) was among the people the hardest towards Abdullah ibn Sa'id ibn Kullâb and his followers like al-Harith [al-Muhâsibî] and others.
"Siyâr A'lâm An-nouboulâ" by Adh-Dhahabî volume 14 page 380
Liars .
How can you.
Which kind of debate is this when person is dead and another is alive. Bro, May be.....
Wicked stuff! May Allah reward you for all your efforts. One of my fav channels on youtube
Masha Allah Dewbandi Are All over in World And dewbandi is true path In Islam and dewbandi is real Ahle Sunnat Wal Jamat and Bareilvi is Not Islam Bareilvi Biddat and Ahmad Raza Khan is Not Muslim Ahmad Raza Khan Keep out in Islam
@@hashimkhan5895 the ulama of Deoband were not those called people non Muslims so recklessly. Fear Allah and stop speaking with such ignorance
ali gomaa is nothing compared to Al Albani. that egyptian puppet 😂
احمن عهعن يصووو 😂
I never trust these short beard scholars.. Anyways Sheikh Albani never claimed we should reject weak hadith all together.. Some people try to become famous by throwing dirt at someone who is truly famous,, this uploader doesn't know the meaning of the word 'debate'. In fact I can guarantee that if Dr. Ali Gomaa see this title he wouldn't approve of it.
Albani used to trim his beard too lol
Santa Claus might be a better scholar than Albani, he doesn't trim his beard, but Albani did.
@@ibnawesome Do not disrespect the scholar, you KADHAB
A ajami deobandi or wahabi tell what is correct
@@faizanhashmi389 so basically you are saying that Arabi is superior to ajami
Jazak Allah khair, the Sunnis need videos like these, to prevent the hijacking of Ahlus Sunnah by Wahabis...
Albani was not a wahabi
@@W67w They are just stupid they are jealous of Sheikh Albani and they know that he is on the truth
@@Hamza-bk9m lol
what you should take into account is that this was early in al bani life ....towards the end he claimed that there were some hadiths in bukhari that we weak and wrong and his Intention was that only the book of Allah will be without errors and that is 100% the truth !!! you can only use a weak hadith to strengthen a Hasan hadith and that's only if there is alot of weak hadiths that support it. the science of this is very deep.
Wallahi if you reach 1% of what albani dedicated in his life you should be grateful....this ummah is so far away subhanallah may Allah guide us and grant us victory Allahumme ameen
Salafi's are real Ahle Sunnah not grave worshipping sufi's.
Talk about Shej Albani here but forget that Sheikh Albani searched for 10 years during his life for a part of a hadith to find this part of the hadith as written by Muslim or Bukari, may God have mercy on both Muslim and Bukari in order to find the rest of the hadith, he read all the university books in the Faculty that he taught Sheikh Albani was a person who did not give answers with his head, but he always said the answer from those great scholars who took the Deen from the prophet and the continuing chain like Muslim Bukhkari and many other scholars while this Scholar is appearing to have won a debate against Shej Albani on one issue, first to say this, look for the research on this issue, how Shej Albani responded to these that second in Islam there is no one and where we will defeat and where we will laugh at how to be weak in Islam, Sheikh Albani did not have and there is no such Islam because the work of Sheikh Albani was from the first chains of knowledge from the time of the prophet and after his death the prophet as a scholar Muslim Bukhari My question for this scholar is To which sect does this scholar belong?
God Forgive us ane save us from Shirk and Bidat
did any of you who keep saying “it’s not a debate cause al-Albani can’t defend himself he’s dead” actually watch the video ?? the Shaykh is referencing a debate which was held between them IN THE PAST back when al-Albani was still alive, no one is saying that the debate is this video itself, Shaykh Gomaa is simply relaying to us the conversation that took place when al-Albani challenged him and his Shuyukh 🤦🏽♂️
And you think this man can challenge Al Albani, how many books did Al Albani write? And how many books did this man write?. Al Albani received the national King faisán prize for islaamic studies for effort on the knowledge of peophetic hadeeth. He is thee greatest scholar in the world. Scholars read Al Albani's books before writing a book. That shows a lot of who Albani was.
ممّا أتوقّع من فضيلته أنّه من أهل العلم ،ولا أتصور لشرف علمكم أن يخفى لديكم منهج الشيخين وشرطهما في صحيحيهما مع ما أورداه خارج الصحيحين، وما ذكره مسلم في المقدمة والذي ذكره في أصل الصحيح...
Click bait but it worked.
Wait, it's actually very sad that a Shaykh would make a claim like this with no proof or witnesses. I want to believe him but...
Where is the isnad for this? Were there any witnesses who saw this? He is lying.
He is joker no brain 🧠 shaykh al Albani is greatest scholar this era
Only for wahabis.
what he says now is called fool me if you can
Does he mean we should also take the mawdhuu hadith that was compiled by imam bukhari?be serious
There is more than 40 level of weak hadith, not all weak hadith are thrown out, because all scholars of hadith throughout ages used them.
@@mamadoufarissou7312 Not in aqeedah
@@alwiali6545 true, not in aqeedah
@@mamadoufarissou7312 but remember Allah(3aza wajal) has promised to preserve this religion so whats weak is not worth anything
@@alwiali6545 again, weak has more than 40 grades, are you equating all grades of weak hadith ? That would be a waste of knowledge
ما أسهل الفوز عندما تناقش ميتا أو غائبا!.
For a detailed discussion on this topic here is a whole series dedicated to weak hadith, albani is mentioned as are several other outstanding hadith scholars:
ruclips.net/video/gOrx7J2DwYw/видео.html
May Allah Guide you. Is this person the Egypt Mufti . Who gave fatwa to dayus.
A debate is when both parties are alive not one. This man can never compare to Al Albani.
All respectfully he's claiming that sheikh Albani picks and chooses hadiths when sheikh Albani accepts every authentic hadith no matter what. If you're gonna accept weak hadiths that are not considerably weak means you're gonna pick and choose put some respect on sheikh Albani Allah yer7amo
Respectfully al albani is not a muhaddith in the first place, he studied hadith my himself in the library, with all due respect he is not a scholar of hadith
@@mamadoufarissou7312 with all due respect he taught at the University of Madina twice where they invited him because a known scholar convinced the University to invited him but he ended up leaving due to minor disagreements about if the Niqab is mandatory or not he held the position that it is not mandatory while they held the position its mandatory even after that he left and they invited him back to teach at the University. And after all of that when he disagreed with the University again he left but he still had the respect of the scholars at there university of medina and was friends with some of them for years he a scholar and you should only accept authentic hadith
@@aosel-gharably1070 so what, wahhabis at the university of medina invited another wahhabi to teach, circular argument, it doesnt mean he is credible, otherwise yasir qadhi should be credible as well because he finished top his promotion in medina
@@mamadoufarissou7312 there is no such thing as wahabi we follow the Sunnah of the prophet according to the interpretation of the first 3 generation which are the Salaf. The Quran says to follow almuhajiroon which are the migrants that migrated from Makkah to medina and the Quran says to follow alansar which are the people of medina. That's all in chapter 9 verse 100. Also in an authentic hadith there prophet says the best generations are mine then those who came after them and then those who came after them which are the generations of the salaf. May Allah guide you I know you just don't know
@@mamadoufarissou7312 yessir qadi is a deviants may Allah guide him her doesn't even believe that the Quran was preserved don't compare sheikh Albani to him because you're clearly a person still learning since you wanna argue to use unauthenticated hadith
So many ignorant people in the comments. Sure the title is a bit click-baity but it's still a very important video.
May Allah guide these misguided people(Salafis).
This man is the same man who said it is allowed to ask the dead for help, the same man that said that mixing and being friends with non-mahram woman is halal. Sufis are not Sunnis and Salafi are Sunnis alhamdulillah.
@@AbuInayaAl-Athari-po3yjSalafis are sunnis joke of century😂
He needs to learn how to pronounce Arabic properly first. He is not a common Egyptian that he says gamee' instead of Jamee' or gaal instead of Qaal
This is not tajwid quran competition
@@rayanjalaluddinallibnani3154 it's not tajwid. It's called proper grammar. Umar al-Khattab emphasized that even kids don't make grammatical mistakes.
@@ibniftikhar It's not grammatical mistakes, it's simple dialect, only when your reciting the quran you have to recite the alphabet according to the rules of Tajwid
What is Ali Jumuah compared to Sheikh Albaani in the knowledge of Hadith except like a drop of water compared to an ocean. The people of bid’aah hate Sheikh Albaani soo much and try to make him look bad in any way they can.
Sheikh Albaani was a scholar of hadith, upon the sunnah, with the correct aqeedah, unlike your Sufi sheikh who is upon innovation and wrong aqeedah, May Allah guide him and the likes of you who put these kinds of videos.
Haven’t you seen how Allah accepted from Sheikh Albaani that his name is mentioned in all over the whole behind the mention of the ahaadith of Prophet صلى الله عليه وسلم. Yes, Sheikh Albaani is a human being, and just like other human beings and scholars, he makes mistakes. But his mistakes are not upon desires, they are upon ijtihaad.
May Allah have mercy upon Sheikh Albaani. It has been more than 20 years since he passed away and the general Muslims, students of knowledge, and scholars all over the world still benefit from his knowledge on issues of hadith, aqeedah, fiqh, and even the Arabic language.
Written on the 20th of Dhul Hijjah 1442 corresponding to July 30 2021.
Syeikh Albani never even had a chained understanding of hadith, he's just a watch maker
Mind you that the one talking about Al Albani has signed a fatwa stating that it is permitted to sell Alchohol and Pork in the west 😂. Not only that but he said women can be presidents and lead muslim countries in this day and age. Not only that he went as far as saying women can be judges 😂😂 a total joke and a coward of a man. If Albani was sitting in front of him he would not dare to utter those words.
If shiakh was live thses sufis grave worshippers wouldn't come near to shaikh 😂
Many triggered Albani Fans here:-)
Ali Gomaa is a sufi practicing bidah(innovation, sin) proven in this video "Sufi Dhikr in Egypt (Fully Translated) - Natawassal Bil Hubaabah - Habib Umar, Ali Gomaa" ruclips.net/video/TqJibY3ZDVQ/видео.html&ab_channel=HashimAziz
The Pro-Albani Followers showing their ugly colours in the comment section with insults & downright rejection of the actual Sheikh above.
Albani is not to blame for this as goma's followers snide comments cannot be blamed on him either.
SubhanaAllah
Assalamualaikum
Masha Allah Dewbandi Are All over in World And dewbandi is true path In Islam and dewbandi is real Ahle Sunnat Wal Jamat and Bareilvi is Not Islam Bareilvi Biddat and Ahmad Raza Khan is Not Muslim Ahmad Raza Khan Keep out in Islam
اللهم صل وسلم على سيدنا ومولانا محمد عبدك ورسولك النبي الأمي وعلى آله وصحبه وسلم
Who?
The Ashari?
Quburi?
Murji? 😂😂🤡Cmon seriously nice try dude
😂 This gomaa is a straight flop. He is lying about Imam Al Bani رحمه الله
Muhammad Umar Mustafa, the brother Abu Aaliyah Abdullah Battle who has: a B.A Degree in Islamic studies (Hadith and its sciences), an M.A (Fiqhus Sunnah) and is currently a Ph.D Student (Hadith ) made the following reply to this video on Facebook.
-------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
'I watched some of it and the point he made about imam al- Bukhari’s others book which have weak to show they are accepted so as long they aren’t extremely weak. This can be answered from many angles the first is that yes they can be collected and in the event another Hadith comes by way of a different chain, narrator or meaning then the Hadith goes from being weak to hasan li ghayrihi.'
'The second point is bukhari didn’t make it a condition to narrate all authentic Hadith in those books but cited them for various reasons . This is similar to the 4 Sunnan . Take for example abu Dawud who collected all the Hadith the fuqaha acted on in his time , similarly to at tirmithi.'
'The other issue about the intro to sahih Muslims intro being different than his sahih and he claims only al albani took this position is a flagrant lie as;
1- imam Al Albani never takes a position unless he has an imam who has preceded him in it
2- there is no ijma on this topic as imam ad daruqutni preceded sh Nasir in that and I’d say refer to Shaykh Rabee Al madkhalis masters Thesis ( between the two imams ad daruqutni and Muslim).'
what im going to say right now is directed to the owner of this channel however anyone can feel free to respond.
dua is a act of worship right? we as muslim only worship allah alone which concludes to the fact that when someone makes dua(act of worship) to other than allah that means he isnt worshiping allah rather he is worshiping the one who he is making dua too
Dua is act of worship, Allah alone is the ultimate provider.
I think you are getting confused between Dua and Isthagatha.
Istagatha is also a form of Waseela, as Allah, his Angels, Gabriel and righteous servants are the helpers.
Remember, the Wobblers might trick you saying Iyya ka Na’budu
We seek only from Allah
Remember, Alhamdolillah also means All praiseses are to Allah, but when we praise creation it is also allowed.
Allah is the ultimate provider and all praises are due to him alone.
@@MustafaHasanKhan you istigatha from other than Allah is falsehood here is evidence
It was narrated from al-Nu’maan ibn Basheer that the Prophet (peace and blessings of Allaah be upon him) said: “Du’aa’ is worship,” then he recited (interpretation of the meaning):
“And your Lord said: ‘Invoke Me [i.e. believe in My Oneness (Islamic Monotheism) and ask Me for anything] I will respond to your (invocation). Verily, those who scorn My worship [i.e. do not invoke Me, and do not believe in My Oneness, (Islamic Monotheism)] they will surely enter Hell in humiliation!’”
[Ghaafir 40:60]
Narrated by al-Tirmidhi, 2895; Ibn Maajah, 3818; classed as saheeh by al-Albaani in Saheeh al-Tirmidhi, 2370.
@@MustafaHasanKhan Also iyyaka na’boudo means you alone (Allāh) we worship
Mouaad boettgenbach - yes dua is worship, but not all dua is worship.
There are many examples throughout the Quran and sunnah where the word "dua" or a derivative of it is used but not in the meaning of worship.
So you would have to concede that IF someone makes dua to other than Allah then which intention are they doing that with? IF its for worship then its shirk. IF it's not for worship then it's not.
BTW an example of a verse of the Quran is when Allah tells the people, "Do not call the Prophet صلى الله عليه وسلم the way you call one another..." the word "dua" is used.
May Allah guide us. Ameen.
not a big fan of gomaa but he deffo won this
Why not? Im not familiar, just want be sure who i am listening to
@@mmaman6931 his political views are abominable. He supported the coup against Morsi and encouraged the soldiers to kill protestors. After the rabaa massacre he still justified the army's actions. Their deaths are on his hands
@@thestealth2448 the same applies to Ibn Bayyah.
Although these scholars are knowledgeable (I am a small fish I won't deny that) their political actions and stances are a total disaster.
I rather follow people like Shakyh Dedew or Tarifi.
But I don't wanna make fitna now :)
@@mmaman6931 i heard of him but not familiar with him..i know he is knowledgeable
@@zerochance7708 dedew and tarifi?never heard of them...i know shaykh mohammad al yaqubi ...he is 34 descendant of imam hassan ...i like his personality and him being descendant of imam hassan ,i can follow him without any fear...nowadays there are a lot of scholars who are not very knowledgeable or truthworthy
Sufi where were you when sheikh Albani was alive why didn't you speak to sheikh Albani face to face because sheikh Albani criticized Sufi about the preying which not following the Sunna of our prophet Muhammad S.a.w the time of prey Salah is not to prey four rahkat in 5 minutes and after finishing prayers our prophet Muhammad S.a.w didn't said to have a dance in house 🏠 of Allah this is Sufi doing against the Sunna of our prophet Muhammad S.a.w shame on you .
So Daraqutni who said that some Ahadith from Bukhari are weak was wrong ? And hé was a wahhabi ? Hm ? Get out Sissi's slave.
🤣🤣🤣 what a joke! Shaikh Albani (may Allah's mercy upon him) is one of the greatest hadith scholars ever!
You don’t even know how to judge what greatness is.
Al-‘Utbi reported: Al-Harith ibn Hut came to Ali and he said to him, “Do you see that I think Talhah, Al-Zubayr, and Aisha have united upon falsehood?” Ali, may Allah be pleased with him, said, “O rebel, you are confused! Verily, truth and falsehood are not known by the statures of men. Know the truth and you will recognize its people. Know falsehood and you will recognize the one who brings it.”
Source: Ansāb al-Ashrāf 2/274
We have criteria from blessed mouth of the messenger of Allah ﷺ.
A chain of narration back to him as one. Albani had no Sanad back to the prophet in anything and won’t be mentioned in chains of narration.
The best of us have come and walked this earth and died (salaf) who is albani in comparison to them as he contradicts them in 70% of his works including his own contradictions amongst his grading me and knowledge of men in his process.
We know the great scholars of Hadith, till this day and amongst the Sunni circles of knowledge preserved through Sanad! Not a claim of sayings, through Sanad. Albani has never been mentioned amongst them. May Allah have mercy on his soul.
How about you better focus on his points and strong arguments?
Why did you ignore the points the Shaykh made?
In your dreams he has done fuhush mistakes 😂 ...when comes across the fazail of ali a.s he says the sanad is sahih but my heart doesnt accept it ....poor folk would he been here today i would have helped him with a heart surgery for free ....😂
Oh? Who told you this and why do you believe them?
Let me guess your answer:
"The other scholars said so."
Really? What makes you think they're scholars?
That's the question people never ask: what is the standard for determining if someone is an alim?
Haha when was this in his dreams 😂
Is this guy insane?!!
He said weak Hadith. Weak is weak. How come you take from the weak?!!
If you take the weak then what’s the difference between you and the jews and the christians who take the weak!
No there are different types of weak ahadith
For example in Hanafi madhab if you have for a lot of weak hadith narrating the same thing
Then they accept it
@Aziz Rahman what’s it?
This is a joke 😂😂😂 seriously 😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂 lie
Shaykh Albani is wrong and Ali Gomaa is more knowledgeable than him; but this is literally the equivalent of Peshawar Nights for anti-Salafis
😂 Sheikh Albani is the one who everyone respected and the one who if you went to him then you would fear Allah and be shocked and he is the one who was seen in a dream with the Prophet Muhammad scw
what a lame joke. more knowledgeable??? how many books, Papers, articles has he written on Hadith??
هذا جاهل يتهم اسياده بالجهل
C A U T I O N...!!
The one-side naration=testimoni MERELY. It's just an UNJUST
This video is containing FITNA??
Assalla Muallikuum
May Allah guide these sufis
Many mushrikuns around attempting to poison Islam
Sheikh Albani job was to collect hadiths
May Allah give him Jannah
JAHANAM
@@Mike-LitorisSoBig you fool dont know what haidith is. Following a sufi blindly.
don't follow any scholar blindly only follow Quran and Hadeeses
Mediocracy Vs super mediocracy
Greatest islamic scholar in the world at this time
who is lol?
Whos this man seriously ? Never heard of him or seen him before today. And you are calling him the best scholar in the world lol ?
@@soldierofislam1 shiekh Ali goma
You are upon the wrong manhaj
Sheikh Al Bani Was on True Path and opinion.
Albani was the best muhadith on the earth may Allah have mercy on him. As for the other guy and this speaker I never heard of. Fake people speaking fake about gratest muhadith
Imam Al Bukhari Rahimullah did not claimed Sahih for all of his books expect the book of hadith which called Sahi al Bukhari. when any intellectual people read the chain mention in al adab al mufarad, the chain is weak according to Imam Bukhari himself claimed in his Sahih... so when Shykh Al Bani rahimullah gave references to other books, he made according to the usool al hadith wa jarah o tadeel plus according to the knowledge of Asma ur rejal....
افک المبین
Haha he debated a dead man. He should have debated him when he was still alive. No disrespect to both sheikhs. May Allah guide us all.
@Anugrah Akbar upon watching it again you are right , it just seems like a lecture ,
Don’t listen to this misguided individual, he will lure you with his slippery tongue
Sheikh Albani RAHIMAHULLAH.
Albani Kafir vahabi
i don't understand the point of this video. anybody can say "we brought him excerpts, so no one was left for him except himself."
it remains a comment. nobody can prove it.
there are weak/problematic ahadith in sahih al bukhari (and no book is free from mistakes except the Qur'an). we have to get rid of this hadith extremism as an ummah.
There is hadith literature available for the lay people, like imam maliks muwatta. but sahih al bukhari definetly isn't hadith literature for layman. and the scholars have to be honest about it and don't push this "bukhari and sahih propaganda", as lot of evil can emerge from this.
The point of the video is in the start and in the thumbnail, Nasir Al Din Sahab rejected all weak hadith and made a claim that it was the methodology of the foremost hadith scholars, which was proven to be not the case by Dr Ali here as all the foremost hadith scholars included weak narrations provided they aren't considerably weak, for use in virtues of deeds etc.
@@MirOmran are you sure? look how Imam Malik dealt with weak Ahadith and ahadith in general. I know the argument, which the shaykh mentions in this Video. But why is he mentioning Imam Muslim's "Muqaddimah" only when it comes to weak narrations? sahih al Bukhari isn't mentioned at all, as it is always the case...
that doesn't change the fact, that there are weak Ahadith in these books (sahih al bukhari and sahih muslims and other hadith collections). No matter how you try to suggar code it. We need sincere scholars, who help this ummah to get a healthy mindset of accepting -and rejecting-(!) Ahadith when it comes to unauthentic narrations. But with this video and these words from the shaykh, the "sahih propaganda" is pushed to the limit. I don't have a problem, that people want to do good acts, if they're narrated in a weak hadith but in the same way people should be open, when someone says, that a hadith in sahih al bukhari is weak.
@@emindemiri2906 good point
مولانا العلامة الشيخ الاصولي علي جمعة
Cool, yesterday I had a debate with Ahmad Raza Khan.