Keith, I think you and Rob had the top two. Seeker and Raven right behind. All 4 bags were well worth it! Keep these type of content coming! Very enjoyable!
I think this seller is smarter than the average bear boo boo I think these boxes may have been extra stuffed only way to find out is if one of the subscribers to any of your channels orders one and let’s us know… was still a great mystery bag series enjoyed it and I don’t think any one box was better than another you all did well obviously. Thanks for sharing see you on the next one 👍🏼👊🏼
Gotta be extra love after recognizing Rob's PO box. How can you keep the lights on selling $200 + mix for $150. I don't think the rangers like this unsustainable business model Yogi 🐻
I can end that mystery for you. I ordered from the same guy. I didn’t get near the value. And honestly a lot of it was face value stuff I want into the coin jar to be rolled and taken to the bank. Every RUclipsr I see a good bag. I don’t think there’s any mystery as to what’s happening here.
My rank for all four videos: 1) Silver Seeker 2) Rob 3) Coin Crew Keith 4) RavenHawk Coins Great videos guys! Enjoying the content. I would be happy with Raven’s box.
Obviously you guys all have vast amounts of supplies, though jeweler's loops are always excellent to have extras. For a beginner set, these bags would be amazing! It is fun watching all four of you opening these mystery boxes. Rob's seems to be the best value, but all of them were almost identical with the exception of the larger valued pieces, it comes down to preference of those pieces. Great video, thank you.
The assortments are remarkably similar, and all were worth more than you paid. I like yours the most, because of the Canadian commemorative and the Krugerrand. I collect a lot of.999 silver coins, and I have a special interest in Canadian silver. All of you got a really nice Benji proof, so props to the seller for that. I would have been happy with any of the four mystery boxes, but I felt like yours edged out the others slightly. Thanks for posting a great competition. 👍
Rob definitely won this competition. The seller treated rob better due to recognizing the P.O box. Seeker done slightly better than yours. Raven is last place. I went for the $250.00 option a few months ago. I done alright.
I've watched yours, Raven's, and Silver Seekers so far and my opinion is Silver eeked you out by a few dollars and Raven just got his money back. Fun vids. New sub also.
You all got a beginners package. Your buffalo nickels we're better than RFTs and your PC GS coin was as good as the others. All were light on silver. You all were practical in the common coins. The variety is similar in all but no one got an exceptional coin. No one got a W quarter. Too generous on loose buffalos which were dup's and poor. Dead heat.
It's a tough call Keith. A lot of items in each box were very similar. I would say Rob with the innovation coin and the hard poured bar and the proof Franklin squeezed out the win. Your kruggerand put you ahead of Raven just because I don't care for IKEs myself. But you are Beck and neck with Seeker for 2nd place since I really love full band mercs.
All the bags looked fairly consistent with value. There were a lot of constancy on the cheaper BU coins. Probably broke up a BU roll for those. I can't choose a clear winner. Out of the higher value random selection that you each each got, such as nicer slabs and silver. I would have to say I liked Silver Seekers the best. Still good value over all!
Rob was discovered & all 4of you purchased them on the same day & the guy watches at least a few of your channels, so its going to be hard to figure out if this is a good representation of what to expect. Keep in mind, its not everyday that someone buys a $150. Mystery bag from him off ebay, so him getting 4 in one day... I'm sure he figured it out
I think all 4 bags were awesome. I think these were the most bang for you buck grab bags I've seen. Who got the best bag? I think every collector has the items they fancy and favor. So the best bag would be asubjective . All 4 of you, in my opinion, did fair and objective assessments. I'm gonna order one! Lol
So far I've seen yours and Raven's boxes, they look pretty much the same, I'm off to see the others and see if they get anything different. thanks for the series, I love these mystery boxes but I wonder if the seller knew who u guys are, maybe try to get some random person to order one and compair them...Thanks for sharing. 😍
You are going about the same lot as far as the supplies in the coins so if they were padded because he recognized one of you, he gave y’all about the same
def got a grab bag valued very nice after watching all 4 videos i will have to say SEEKER had the best bag in my opinion just edging out rob finds treasure by a hair to be honest all 4 were fantastic grab bags
I ordered 2 of these for xmas presents. Came in last week and went right under the tree. By watching these, I think we will be happy when we open them for xmas.
How were your boxes you ordered? Were they about the same as what we saw in these videos? I might order one so just wanted to know how yours are. Thanks
Keith, does that Litecoin represent an actual coin? It should have numbers and such representing the address or something. Should look into it. Litecoin is trading around $76 a coin!
Well I like the silver coins of course, the nickels excluding the proof, the quarters, and the pennys cost face in my book, just shows I'm not really in to Numismatics 😆 no judgment for those that do, my big take away is the Canadian Dollar I don't got that one in my collection a little jealous. Till next we meet ❤ 🤍 💙 🥃 💀 Sköl
Another fun collab with the FAB 4
Agreed my friend, watching to see what you got right now.
Nice box brother! I think your Benji is more closer to $50 but I love Benjis! Looks like we all got our value worth in my opinion.
I just valued everything about what I sell it for on auction. Didn't look anything up, however you are probably right.
GOOD FINDS 👍 ❤️ 👍
Thank you.
A great mystery box! And fair. And all were pretty equal!
Heck of a box Keith! Nice Benji... it's definitely worth more than $4!!! LOL but it's also worth more than the $40 you meant to say IMO. :)
I think so too, now that I think about it.
Nice grab bag, love the Canadian dollar and Benji
Thanks.
Keith, I think you and Rob had the top two. Seeker and Raven right behind. All 4 bags were well worth it! Keep these type of content coming! Very enjoyable!
I think this seller is smarter than the average bear boo boo I think these boxes may have been extra stuffed only way to find out is if one of the subscribers to any of your channels orders one and let’s us know… was still a great mystery bag series enjoyed it and I don’t think any one box was better than another you all did well obviously. Thanks for sharing see you on the next one 👍🏼👊🏼
Thanks for your opinion. I will mention it to the guys and see if they know someone who will order one.
Gotta be extra love after recognizing Rob's PO box. How can you keep the lights on selling $200 + mix for $150. I don't think the rangers like this unsustainable business model Yogi 🐻
@@CoinCrew I ordered 3, hope they are consistent with the collaborators. Will let you know how it turns out.
I can end that mystery for you. I ordered from the same guy. I didn’t get near the value. And honestly a lot of it was face value stuff I want into the coin jar to be rolled and taken to the bank. Every RUclipsr I see a good bag. I don’t think there’s any mystery as to what’s happening here.
@@davidk5242 thanks for taking the hit for us bummer it was a bad bag David 😡
Great box! I loved watching all of the collabs! Great Job!
Thank you Katie, we all really appreciate it.
Love the Benji. It's not a bad box. Thanks for sharing.
Nice video! Mystery boxes are always my favorite. Thank you for sharing.
Glad you like them!
My rank for all four videos:
1) Silver Seeker
2) Rob
3) Coin Crew Keith
4) RavenHawk Coins
Great videos guys! Enjoying the content. I would be happy with Raven’s box.
Thank you for your vote and watching.
Fun grab bag Rob's so far last but not least Seekers next
Awesome video and nice coins thanks for sharing coin crew
Yes you got your money back
Thank you.
VERY NICE!
Thank you! Cheers!
Wow! Very nice indeed. You got the value, variety, and that Benji. Woo Hoo!
I think I did.
I like the Franklin half! Nice grab bag.
Great variety. Yeah, You got your money's worth for sure Just A Guy
All look good, I agree with your guesstimate on the value.
Thank you. Appreciate your opinion. We all had fun.
Another fun grab bag. I think you priced them well. You know I love my Wheaties!
Thank you Will.
Obviously you guys all have vast amounts of supplies, though jeweler's loops are always excellent to have extras. For a beginner set, these bags would be amazing! It is fun watching all four of you opening these mystery boxes. Rob's seems to be the best value, but all of them were almost identical with the exception of the larger valued pieces, it comes down to preference of those pieces. Great video, thank you.
Thanks for watching, glad you enjoyed the series.
This is such a cool challenge. I hope you keep this up.
This is the 2nd time we did this challenge.
Looks consistent across the group. As long as the seller wasn't selective for your bags it's a good deal. Thanks
I thought that they were all pretty consistent.
Across the group yes.. if you check out other peoples grab bags it shows a WAY different story
You did good!
Thank you.
I'd have to say Rob did the best, Seeker did the 2nd best, you came in 3rd, and Ravens was the worst. Rob and Seeker actually did pretty good.
Thank you for your vote.
Rob find treasures got the better ones
The Benji, Standing Liberty quarter, and Krugerrand are nice!
Thank you
Great video Keith 👍
Thank you.
Nice Benji..overall for a grab bag not bad!
Thanks for watching GenX, appreciate it.
Decent deal on common stock
I think you came out on top, though I like Robs best
Thank you.
Awesome video Keith.
Thank you.
Keith you Won !
It was very close.
The assortments are remarkably similar, and all were worth more than you paid. I like yours the most, because of the Canadian commemorative and the Krugerrand. I collect a lot of.999 silver coins, and I have a special interest in Canadian silver. All of you got a really nice Benji proof, so props to the seller for that. I would have been happy with any of the four mystery boxes, but I felt like yours edged out the others slightly. Thanks for posting a great competition. 👍
Great job Keith! Love the unboxing videos and how well you sharp guys can accurately price items blindly. Keep up the great work!
Thanks! Will do!
Nice mystery box Keith, I really do think all four of you got a great deal, pretty even across the board 👍
Rob definitely won this competition. The seller treated rob better due to recognizing the P.O box. Seeker done slightly better than yours. Raven is last place. I went for the $250.00 option a few months ago. I done alright.
Thank you for your input. It's good to hear someone else ordered from him and did alright.
I've watched yours, Raven's, and Silver Seekers so far and my opinion is Silver eeked you out by a few dollars and Raven just got his money back. Fun vids. New sub also.
Thanks for the sb. Hope you enjoy the channel. Also thanks for watching.
I've only watched yours and RFTs so far. They are both good but I think ribs is better. I like the silver bar he got.
The bar Rob got is nice.
I feel Rob won. You were 2nd.
Thanks for your vote and watching.
great score Keith. Do you need my address to send the Benji and Krugerrand? HAHAHA
I think I might be good with them... LOL, thank for the offer.
👍
Great grab bag! Your low on the Benji Slab & the Fort Moultrie! JJ
What can I say.... I'm Just A Guy.
@@CoinCrew Results SEEker CC Rob Raven.
@@johnjacobs1625 Thanks for the results
Just ordered mine. Wish me luck
Good Luck.
You got a good box!
Thank you.
You all got a beginners package. Your buffalo nickels we're better than RFTs and your PC GS coin was as good as the others. All were light on silver. You all were practical in the common coins. The variety is similar in all but no one got an exceptional coin. No one got a W quarter. Too generous on loose buffalos which were dup's and poor. Dead heat.
I noticed after watching all the vids, they were extremely similar.
It's a tough call Keith. A lot of items in each box were very similar. I would say Rob with the innovation coin and the hard poured bar and the proof Franklin squeezed out the win. Your kruggerand put you ahead of Raven just because I don't care for IKEs myself. But you are Beck and neck with Seeker for 2nd place since I really love full band mercs.
Thanks for your input and vote.
@@CoinCrew u sent a message through your website by the way.
BIN the $4 dollar Benji
LOL
All the bags looked fairly consistent with value. There were a lot of constancy on the cheaper BU coins. Probably broke up a BU roll for those. I can't choose a clear winner. Out of the higher value random selection that you each each got, such as nicer slabs and silver. I would have to say I liked Silver Seekers the best.
Still good value over all!
Thank you for your opinion and vote.
I'd be very happy with this purchase, I think you got the best 1 this time
Thank you.
Nice video
You got your money's worth. In the future, you might want to use a decoy address to eliminate the possibility of them 'seeding' the goods :)
Sure does not take very much to get you all excited!
I'm Just A Guy, what can I say...LOL
That's a pretty awesome box, Keith!
I would go to a coin show and spend $150 on things I want and have gotten much better value and not what someone wants to get rid of.
We do these types of videos to show others what to expect from a mystery box / grab bag.
Great video , Really Fun 🎉 to watch 🤓 💙🪙🔬
Nice grab bag challenge. I think Rob did get the h better bag though. Still very nice
After watching the others videos I think Rob definitely got the best grab bag.
I think Rob did well.
So far, Seeker has the better grab bag, but still not bad, Franklin was nice, and Kuggarand's are always great.
Thank you.
Seems like the guys who the seller recognized got the better bags. All of you got more than what you paid for though....
I think he did recognize one of us.
Rob was discovered & all 4of you purchased them on the same day & the guy watches at least a few of your channels, so its going to be hard to figure out if this is a good representation of what to expect.
Keep in mind, its not everyday that someone buys a $150. Mystery bag from him off ebay, so him getting 4 in one day... I'm sure he figured it out
It's hard to say, but I think that was the case. He probably watched one of the channels
My only issue is that your box is roughly the same as the other boxes the guys received. Good value though.
I did notice that I wish we would have all had a little bit different variety.
I watched all 4 of your guys videos. I think it's a great gift idea for new collectors or people who are giving gifts.
That's a good thought.
I think all 4 bags were awesome. I think these were the most bang for you buck grab bags I've seen. Who got the best bag? I think every collector has the items they fancy and favor. So the best bag would be asubjective . All 4 of you, in my opinion, did fair and objective assessments. I'm gonna order one! Lol
Sounds like a plan.
So far I've seen yours and Raven's boxes, they look pretty much the same, I'm off to see the others and see if they get anything different. thanks for the series, I love these mystery boxes but I wonder if the seller knew who u guys are, maybe try to get some random person to order one and compair them...Thanks for sharing. 😍
Thanks for watching, I do think one of us was recognized.
You are going about the same lot as far as the supplies in the coins so if they were padded because he recognized one of you, he gave y’all about the same
Hey, Keith
Hi Jimmy1312
def got a grab bag valued very nice after watching all 4 videos i will have to say SEEKER had the best bag in my opinion just edging out rob finds treasure by a hair to be honest all 4 were fantastic grab bags
Thanks for your vote.
I ordered 2 of these for xmas presents. Came in last week and went right under the tree. By watching these, I think we will be happy when we open them for xmas.
Wow! That sounds great.
How were your boxes you ordered? Were they about the same as what we saw in these videos? I might order one so just wanted to know how yours are. Thanks
Keith, does that Litecoin represent an actual coin? It should have numbers and such representing the address or something. Should look into it. Litecoin is trading around $76 a coin!
Will do.
1979 is my birth year, would you be interested in parting with the mint set and proof set?
Call the my coin shop tomorrow or email me, have some in stock
you got the worst box
I think I might have.
u r giving very generous amounts, most of that is face value junk
The seller found out that Rob was one of the buyers
Yes they did.
You're breathing awfully hard
I am learning not to be so close to the mic.. LOL
Well I like the silver coins of course, the nickels excluding the proof, the quarters, and the pennys cost face in my book, just shows I'm not really in to Numismatics 😆 no judgment for those that do, my big take away is the Canadian Dollar I don't got that one in my collection a little jealous. Till next we meet ❤ 🤍 💙 🥃 💀 Sköl