the films of Andrei Tarkovsky (ranked)
HTML-код
- Опубликовано: 26 июл 2024
- Jake discusses and ranks Tarkovsky movies.
Our other channel:
/ mancarryingthing
Nadia's Instagram: womancarrying?i...
Jake's Instagram: / mancarryingthing
Jake's twitter: / mancarrying
Patreon: / mancarryingthing
TikTok: / mancarryingthing
Reddit: / mancarryingthing
Discord: / discord
Jake's Letterboxd: letterboxd.com/ManCarrying/
Want to send us something? Do it here:
PO Box 7887
Bonney Lake, WA 98391 
Развлечения
![Finesse2Tymes - Pretty Ricky [Official Music Video]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/xIoP_mhYRT0/mqdefault.jpg)
He is the greatest filmmaker to me, Mirror is my all time favorite piece of art. A fairly short filmography but pretty much full of masterpieces, even his documentary and student films are brilliant. Nobody offers similar atmospheres and emotions. I am completely atheistic, but his films are the closest that I've ever felt to a spiritual experience lol
RUclips commenters writing the most beautiful piece of text ever made, using all of their soul to captivate the readers and then writing "lol" at the end
@@filipinosmarcabranca the duality of man
Well said! It's actually funny you should mention your contradictory, almost religious-like feelings, being an atheist, since it's a pretty common observation among Tarkovsky lovers. People often say that if there's any proof of God's existence - it's Tarkovsky films. My relationship with this joke is similar to yours as I share a similar worldview. However, I like to say, very conveniently, that I'm on a "No man's land" as Bertrand Russell once cleverly said in his book.
These director ranking videos are so great. I'd love for you to talk about Akira Kurosawa, David Lynch, and Martin Scorsese when you have the chance. As for Tarkovsky, I've only seen Solaris and Stalker, both of which I loved. I need to seek out the rest of his filmography
LOTS OF SCORSESE I STILL NEED TO SEE. i could do david lynch, but i still need to see inland empire. Kurosawa, again, a lot i need to see
@@womancarryingman Haha I'm a huge David Lynch fan but I have not seen Inland Empire either. Whatever idea you decide to pursue with your videos, I'm sure it will be a good one
both of you desperately need to see inland empire, possibly the craziest movie I've seen
@@filipinosmarcabrancafor sure, personally it’s my favorite David lynch film, words really cannot describe the incredible, hypnotic and surreal experience of watching it and just having that experience, at this point I’ve watched it 3 times and it just gets better each time
@@womancarryingman I think you'd like Inland Empire a lot
A film professor I had at uni told a great story about Stalker. He invited all his friends over to watch Stalker and he said about 30-40 minutes in everyone but him was asleep. But he emphasised that was okay and that being sometimes bored is not a bad thing. I think about that often.
I would even say that falling asleep isnt a sign of being bored. Stalker is the classic falling-asleep movie for me haha
Couple Carrying Wish Granter
I watched Mirror on psychedelics once. I cried through most of it. Its the closest a film has ever come to pure poetry in my eyes. But things like that are hugely subjective, so I can understand it not hitting the same way for everyone. Every Tarkovsky film is a masterpiece.
Speaking of the world of Bergman, The Sacrifice was also shot by Sven Nykvest, Bergman's go to cinematographer.
Glad to see you agree that The Sacrifice is top tier Tarkovsky. I was fortunate enough to see it in a theater recently and it confirmed for me that it's not only my favorite from him, but one of my favorite films of all time. Such a moving film that deals with religion, philosophy, and survival in an incredibly unique way.
wow this channel is doing NUMBERS
Tarkovsky is one of my favourite directors and for me personally Nostalgia is his best film. Even though it is not his last, it kind of feels like a reflection of all his previous work.
it would be awesome to see you rank the films of jacques tati! i’m currently going through his filmography and loving it.
I absolutely agree Stalker is number one. The climax of that film is so low-key but so, so powerful. It did something to me that no film has ever done before or since, and I still can't explain that feeling years later. You said it makes you feel like magic exists and I completely agree. Tarkovsky isn't my favourite filmmaker, but the man had something you just couldn't teach.
And I would absolutely love to see a Kurosawa ranking.
this was an extremely pleasant surprise, I really enjoyed hearing your takes on these films! Solaris was the first Tarkovsky movie i had seen, a few years ago when i was just starting college. shortly after, I watched Stalker. both films changed my perspective on life. also, as you were explaining Stalker, i realized that it’s magical world building is very similar to Annihilation
i would love to see future vids on the works of the Coen Bros, David Lynch, John Carpenter, and David Cronenberg!
would also love to see some reviews of films i cherish such as Mandy and Drive
When you are going through a spiritual or mental battle, Stalker just hits different. Stalker is my favorite movie by him.
Loved hearing your thoughts! You put it beautifully about Stalker, that it makes you temporarily believe in magic. I think tarkovsky is very good at this-- communicating that art is a form of mysticism, and a spiritual experience in itself. As for another director, I'd love to hear your thoughts on Cassavetes!
I was really hoping to see more on Stalker after the recent skit on it!
It's such a bizarre movie, I love how much faith Tarkovsky puts in his audience and how involved I felt watching it.
If anyone's looking for something with similar vibes, I can't recommend the novel Annihilation enough
What was the recent skit?
@@soulshinobi can't remember the title but it's one of the recent ones on the man carrying thing channel
@@drummerofawe I'll check it out, thanks!
Jake has the Leslie Nielsen effect on me now.
I click on the videos without really reading the title or what it's about, and for the first 30 seconds I'm not quite sure if he's talking nonsense or making a serious video. :D
However, a Tarkovsky ranking video is a great idea and I want to stress that I enjoy watching his book and film videos at least as much as the comedy stuff! If not more!
Ivan's Childhood is one of the best war movies of all time up there with Come and and See and The Thin Red Line
The final shot of the zooming in of the tree will always haunt me. Don't know if it's on par with Come and See or Thin Red Line though.
My favorite part of Stalker is the trip on the rail car going to the zone.
Hey Jake! Not sure if you've played it yet, but I recommend you seek out Pentiment. While obviously a big influence for it is Name of the Rose, Josh Sawyer (the game's director) also mentioned Andrei Rublev as an inspiration, which becomes especially apparent in the characterization of its protagonist and in the third act. Well worth a go!
I'll let the low placement of Mirror slide... 😛
Great video! I love Tarkovsky films, and it was interesting to see your takes! My favorite is Andrei Rublev, I liked Nostalghia but could see why some people wouldn't like it. Anyway, you should definitely rank some more filmmakers!
Well I just watched andrei rublev for the second time in the cinema and, although I'll admit it wasn't as unbelievable as the first time I saw it, it's still an incredible epic. That bell chapter is terrific.
Now we need to see your Bergman list!
Pretty much agree with Stalker and Sacrifice at the top. I have a found spot for Rublev. That ending man. With regards to you revisiting it, I can tell you that each year for the feast of St Andrei Rublev, I try to watch it, and every time I get something new and different out of it. I think it's just how great artistic works are: they have such depth you can always bring back new and fresh water out of them like some kind of magical well.
Mirror is my favourite, effected me emotionally and the way the camera floats through the movie is so cool
he never misses! oh sorry wrong channel
Stalker is special, even in Tarkovsky's filmography. I actualy really like Nostalgia. I would love to see ranking of Sergio Leone's movies.
I've only seen Stalker and Solaris, both are good
Would love to hear your thoughts on David Lynch’s filmography. Great video and a phenomenal filmmaker. Love these ranking videos!
Wow this channel is doing NUMBERS
Stalker is one of my favorite movies. I liked Mirror and Nostalghia, but with the rest I struggled.
Since you mentioned De Palma, would love to see your ranking of his films.
love de palma - still have a lot to see. just saw snake eyes - loved it
Wow this channel is doin numbers! You should make a second second channel
It's quite amazing how much your ranking and interpretations align with mine. Replace Sacrifice with Ivan's Childhood on the 3rd place and put Solaris as 2nd instead of Rublev. But then again, you very rightfully stated that our opinions/experiences watching movies are highly influenced by our headspace at the time. Just like you said about Mirror. Subconsciously I was very impressed with the movie, I felt the presence of Tarkovsky right there on screen, I was mesmerized and intrigued... But it wasn't quite the same as with Stalker, which is my strong favorite. Stalker just happens to have checked so many boxes for me; the ambience of a spiritual journey, power of the philosophical dialogue and subtle meanings, superb acting and tention between characters at the end, stunning visuals. I don't know, some things just have to be experienced. Just like the Writer said in the movie: "These are all rather intangible things: once you label them, their meaning vanishes, dissolves, evaporates... much like a jellyfish under the sun".
Thanks a lot for your video! It was so cool to discover someone who has very similar takes on Tarkovsky films as me!
Solaris and Andrei Rublev are among the greatest handful of films ever. Mirror is also great but is sometimes self-absorbed. These are Tarkovsky's three best.
Mirror is one of the greatest films I have ever seen. Tarkovsky was genius like no other.
Do PTA! Great ranking, by the way. I have seen and have Stalker, The Sacrifice, and Zerkalo, I have seen Andrei Rublev and Solaris, and the others are yet to be seen!
Having only seen Stalker my opinion only matters so much, but I figured I'd share my two cents in agreeing with you on it's transcendence:
In a nutshell, as someone who's lived with fibromyalgia/chronic fatigue for a couple of years to the degree of it being a disability and completely destabilizing my life, I really resonate with the moment when the characters are very much in the Zone, about an hour and a half in, already having braved the potential death around them and existential decay, and that basically the Stalker takes a nap.
He lays his head down on that rock. We see that shifting ground, water covered in vegetation so that the very earth feels filled with spirit. The dancing of the dust above it, the spirit throughout all of nature. We hear that small *plink* of water droplets... as though the water is slowly dripping off of God's feet onto the marble... it just feels so immanent.
I can't remember the words exactly but the vagueness of 'the mighty men all screaming out... please hide us from the wrath of the lamb, and who will be able to stand?' I have felt like I wasn't able to stand. All of it is so fearsome and beautiful and strange and so delicate. It's a dream. The intensity of it all being buffered by the subconscious of it all. It's the Pathfinder dreaming.
I don't have much of a greater point beyond how much being sick and struggling to get through the day aligns with the strangeness of the space that we are taken through. No matter where you are in that struggle, at some point you will lay your head down and rest, often right in the midst of deep pain. I find that very beautiful and encouraging.
Someone else pointed out a brilliant part of the symbology in that dream, as the camera pans over dirty pool, it is filled with symbols of man's achievements, all fading away - but as the whispering poetry says this refrain about those trying to hide, those unable to stand, we see this bowl filled with fish. They are in the water that holds all of these faded symbols... and yet they are stuck in the bowl. This is such a brilliant symbol of man's consciousness, that he may be dwelling on an ideology that is not 'living' anymore, it's important to note there are even religious symbols and icons in this pool. Man is a part of the universal water of consciousness, and yet finds himself apart. Whether he put himself there or not is unclear. That's just a small part of what makes this film brilliant.
Stop it. You’re already pretty much my favorite RUclipsr. Then you casually drop (by drop I mean carry) a Tarkovsky ranking video? Dude! Stop it!! I’m already sold!
JAJAJAJJAJAJA
Definitely recommend that you check out Nostalghia again. I think it’s one of his most thematically and philosophical important.
He never misses, the absolute legend! Also Stalker is the GOAT.
The Sacrifice is such a perfect and special movie and Nostalgia left me speechless like no other movie I’ve ever seen
Do Billy Wilder! I feel like the old school Hayes-code era Hollywood filmmakers aren't talked about as much.
Great video!
Stalker is, in my mind, one of the very few films that can actually genuinely be considered as high art. The way in which Tarkovsky is able to poetically communicate so many ideas and concepts so ambiguously and effortlessly is genuinely absurd. He definitely, at the very least, matched 2001 in that aspect.
I'd say there are hundreds of movies that qualify as high art
@@ColorOfPomegranatesEnjoyer Well that's your opinion, and you're definitely welcome to it, but I personally feel like there are hundreds potentially even thousands of great films, but what counts as 'high art' (to me at least) is really the best of the best of any given artform, and Stalker (in my own very limited opinion) is one of those films.
just wondering if you think the same of persona?
@SuperGamingempire absolutely yeah. Persona is terrific, and I also really like Fanny and Alexander from Bergman specifically as well.
Absolutely. There's something about great art that goes far beyond the superficial elements of what it's composed of. It ceases being just a mixture of pictures, actors, props etc. It becomes an experience. And not just a fleeting one but the one that always stays with you. Stalker is one of those films for me as well.
good video, my ranking would probably go like this (i am yet to see Andrei Rublev, i kinda want to leave the epic for a good moment when i have the time to concentrate to the whole thing.)
1. The Sacrifice
2. Nostalghia
3. Solaris
4. Stalker
5. Ivan's Childhood
6. The Steamroller and the Violin
7. Mirror
8. There Will Be No Leave Today
I've only seen Stalker and Solaris... I feel like anyone who's only seen two Tarkovsky movies, has seen Stalker and Solaris. I actually think about Solaris more often.
great video! just curious, have you considered ranking david lynch at some point? i'd love to see that!
Great stuff. Tarkovsky is the greatest. Stalker seems to me to encompass everything of importance, man's difficult place in our modern dystopic world, our deep yearning for things mystical, the tripartite nature of the soul, life as struggle and movement towards God, etc. For me there is a deep sense of liturgical action in the combination of shared vision and intent they have following this bizarre non-linear path to the room, which like the divine liturgy really does pull you into another order of reality. A piece of it's own, a perfect film.
My ranking
7 Ivan's Childhood
6 Solaris (I agree with you that the earth sequence is my favourite in this film)
5 Nostalgia (I think I know what you mean with it not landing quite right but the sequence with the Madonna and the birds is amazing and the sequence with the candle is perhaps his greatest but it otherwise feels muddled)
4 Mirror
3 The Sacrifice
2 Andrei Rublev
1 Stalker
I am a convert to Catholicism and feel indebted to Tarkovsky for helping to plant the seed.
Though I only watched Stalker but was so shocked as I remembered and felt like I somehow fallen into some rabbit hole as the three explorers. Can’t agree more with what you felt and the comments.
If you see Roublev again you might change your mind , like you said - it is a profound moment , just like you said
I noticed that for some reason The Mirror movie is much more accessible for Russian (of post-Soviet) audience, than for the Western audience.
I tend to rank Tarkovsky films based on the order i last watched them. (Except Stalker is always number 1, and i just watched it again two day ago)
Stalker
Sacrifice
The Mirror
Nostalghia
Andrei Rublev
Solaris
As someone who enjoys both Tarkovsky and Bergman, I don’t see Sacrifice as a Bergman-esque Tarkovsky film.
I knew Sven Nykvist - Bergman’s regular cinematographer - was also the cinematographer for this film. And I also knew Erland Josephson had appeared in many Bergman’s films.
But, Sacrifice still feels 100% Tarkovsky. The long shots, the dialogues, the metaphysical imagery, those are characteristically him, not Bergman.
Do you know Robert Bresson? He comes in second place of favorite filmmakers right behind Tarkovsky. Another legend in pushing cinema as an important art medium, and Tarkovsky said Bresson served as an influence for him. His films aren't as entrancing or ethereal as Tarkovsky's, but his films speak to the immensity of the world all the same, even if with colder methods. Bresson said that for him the only way to achieve something hot it must be done cooly, and that's reflected in his films perfectly. I highly reccomend reading on him and watching his films and would love to see a ranking on him!
for me personally, A.Rublev made me think the most, and Ivan's Childhood gave me the most beautiful and most scary scenes I ever watched
I’d love to see John Cassavetes or the works written by Charlie Kaufman next
Subscribed immediately
The only part of Solaris I liked was the long driving scene. The shots of planets were cool. After they went to space it went way downhill for me.
Could you make a video about the ending of Sunset Blvd?
I could understand why The Mirror is not someone's cup of tea. But I was deeply affected and moved by it. After the movie ended I just went and hugged my mother.
Listen man, I've been watching these rankings for some time now and I would absolutely love if you could make a David Fincher ranking, he's my favourite director and I would love it if you could
plan to do it soon, maybe before release of the Killer. still have to see the game and alien 3
I kept waiting and waiting on where would you rank Dersu Uzala before remembering that it was actually a Kurosawa joint. Still baffles me how he made a Russian speaking film in a Soviet era (or any) Russia. In any case, it's one of the best bromance movies I've seen.
BRO WTFFFFFF MIRROR IN 5. But, amazing video 🤝
You should make a Coen Brothers ranked!
Very good. Here's mine...
7) Andrei Rublev
6) Ivan's Childhood
5) Sacrifice
4) Nostalgia
3) Stalker
2) Solaris
1) The Mirror
Not sure if your a Malick head, but it would be great to see you rank Terrance Malick.
Great video. I'd love to hear your thoughts on Dario Argento.
Good video
Switch Mirror with Sacrifice, and that's my ranking of his movies!
I thought I didn’t like Mirror when I first watched it but then I kept wanting to watch it again. That says something.
You don't watch the films by Tarkovskij, you experience them. No one makes movies like he did
Every film of his is an 8+, but for me there's still two tiers of his filmography. Mirror is one of the greatest films of all time, it's one of those extremely few movies that are like no other. Andrei Rublev is up there as well, and The Sacrifice is probably up there as well though I need to rewatch it, but I love the Bergman feel of it merged with his own thing. Nostalgia and Ivan's Childhood are very good but I wasn't as engaged as with the previously mentioned. Then there is Stalker and Solaris, honestly I don't get the "one of the best films ever" and "rival to 2001: A Space Odyssey" hype. Talking about philosophy and the human experience doesn't mean that it translates to a movie with the same profound qualities. You didn't mention the source material for those two, but they're superior as far as I'm concerned (as far as you can compare different art forms). The look of Stalker is obviously great, and I love the look of Solaris when on earth, the highway scene I particularly remember, but the station just feels very cheap. But as I said, I still think they're very good films. He's got the most consistently great filmography of any director that I've stumbled upon anyway, so there's very few filmmakers I hold above him. Now I want a Bergman Ranking :)
I would love a Gus Van Sant ranking
Yooo we need some Bergman ranked video, cause theres not like a really good one on YT
For me, I would rank them:
1) Solaris
2) Stalker
3) Nostalghia
4) Mirror *
5) Andrei Rublev
6) The Sacrifice
7) Ivan's Childhood
*3 & 4 are interchangeable. Nostalgia might be slightly more rewatchable, but Mirror is the better movie.
Normally I hate to "suggest" things for content creators to do, but since you asked for suggestions, maybe a ranking of Bergman, Wim Wenders, Wong Kar-Wai, Godard, Kevin Smith, maybe Fincher? Hal Ashby, Woody Allen, maybe Kurosawa? Perhaps Sam Peckinpah?
would love to see a wong kar ranking or michael haneke
please do a video on Alejandro Jodorowsky
Very nice. I get what you mean about Mirror, I think if you didn't live through that period in Russian history then the lived experience just isn't there to fully relate to it. My favourites are The Sacrifice, Andrei Rublev and Solaris. Have you considered checking out Theo Angelopoulos? Although there are notable differences, he is the only filmmaker I've seen comparable to Tarkovsky (slow, long takes, poetic visuals, etc., but much focuses more on Greek history instead of religion).
Haven't seen that much of his films, but Béla Tarr always seemed "Tarkovskyan" to me. The Turin Horse is great.
@@Rik-B I've only seen Sátántango, but I saw Stalker's fingerprints all over it. It was pretty good, but not on the level of Tarkovsky or Angelopoulos. Tarr is definitely slow, but I find sometimes he ends up indulging with his slowness for its own sake rather than because he's being poetic with it. Still want to watch his other stuff though, including The Turin Horse.
I'm a big fan of him too bro😊
My rank
1) Stalker
2) The Mirror
3) Andrei Rublev
4) Nostalgia
5)The sacrifice
6) Solaris
Haven’t seen Ivan’s Childhood, all of them are masterpieces but Solaris wasn’t really a good story for him I think
Man, would you consider doing the films of Hayao Miyazaki?
The Grey room makes your hair look Grey. I was almost confused like "why does he look old, is it a joke or skit?"
Alexander Payne has a fantastic filmography and/or Nuri Bilge Ceylan
I literally just finished watching andrei tarkovsky filmography
Just started watching Tarantino movies (Pulp Fiction, Revervoir Dogs, and now Hateful 8) so if you have seen enough of his films i would be interested in ehat you think of them
Judd Apatow ranked next pls
Can’t believe you forgot Samurai Jack💧
The first pick is my favorite Tarkovsky film 😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭
Talking about numbers, you should collab with numberphile. On what exactly, I have no idea.
lessgo, thanks for listening to me and others ofc, I m proud of you, Man Carried by Woman!
hope you have a good day
edit: satyajit ray or fincher next time you do this? 👀
love them both - but i need to see more Ray before doing that
@@womancarryingman oo yea for sure, me too actually(ik a shame considering I am Indian) but I have only read his Feluda books( a series of detective stories he wrote) so far. Looking forward to checking the rest out tho.
Please do Tarantino at some point 🙏
Make a Bergman list
this is dope.
I wonder if you’re familiar with the films of Bela Tarr? Perhaps my favorite filmmaker, more so even than Tarkovsky, Bergman, and Malick, though his films are deeply challenging.
I don’t know. When I meet someone who appreciates or even loves Tarkovsky, I wonder if they would or do also appreciate Tarr.
As a Nostalghiahead, this ranking is blasphemous.
But in all seriousness, I agree with just about everything you said in this video. Especially towards the end. Tarkovsky really is in a league of his own.
Could you do Miyazaki films?
Alright now you really have to do David Lynch
are you familiar with the works of wong kar wai or jacques demy?
Jake I just watched Andrei Rublev and to put it simply, I didn’t get it. And I didn’t really see the point
The first and only Tarkovsky I've ever watched is The Sacrifice. I watched it when I was 16. Bad idea.
Steamroller and Violin is worth a watch
Pauly Shore movies ranked when?