Carl, i want you to know 3 years ago labor day weekend. I found your channel i was lost and addicted to drugs. your videos helped me get free from all of the addictions and now i am in ministry doing small groups for others who were like me. so thank you and may the Lord God Almighty bless you!!
Thank you Carl for sharing this video. I am a practicing psychiatrist myself and I found your videos particularly helpful for my clients as well as myself. You videos are concise and deliver the messages very clearly.
By minute 3 i had to stop the video and take a deep breath. I still comunicate passively (= i don't communicate) but I am working very hard on being assertive. I am sick of people walking over me, but I dont know the difference between being kind and being a pushover. Work, work, and more work to change that, express myself correctly and compromise. Thank you.
You're very welcome! Best wishes on your journey to healing and becoming your True Self. Being assertive is not being selfish. It is letting your needs and feelings be part of the negotiation of any healthy relationship.
Its a self journey.Every person needs to understand himself before trying to train this skill.You need to know your passive state and your agressive state, how do you behave...and then you in a slowly but rewarding process you will get your own center... calm and assertive..you are in control of yourself so you can actually think about the other.A hug from Argentina.
Silberpfote7 Oh,, 1 more thing.You can actually communicate passive, agressive and assertive state just with your body.Do you know about body language?Being assertive is olso understanding your body (sometimes unconscious) communications.Match your words with your body so people can actually feel you more deeply.Its a huge concept, dont take it easy, it is difficult.If you want help contact me.. i will be glad to help you in your journey.I olso struggle in the past with things like yours.
The most simple, easy to understand explanation without having to use fancy words that I have to twist my brain while trying to understand! Thank you so much
- this lesson helped me realize that i tend to use passive communication because i do always feel like life is doing it’s own thing and i don’t get to choose, Carl describes it as a type of depression which i don’t fully resonate with but i do feel in a way stuck and unable to heal or grow and i feel like in my relationships the issues are never addressed but it’s a good thing to recognize in my life in order to change it
I enjoy listening to your videos. They are short, practical and direct to the point. It has taking me three years to understand that I had to educate myself about codependency and make a change for my own good. Thank you for your informative videos.
i have always been a passive agitator and have been practicing assertiveness the past two years. ive learned a lot of this passive agression from dealing with an angry, previously alcoholic, blaming, narcissistic father. he can be very caring though and has my best interests at heart but he puts his family through a lot of bull . he has had a therapist for a while now ever since he got a dwi back in 2019
I search for styles of Assertive Passive and Aggressive Communication on youtube and I really like your video and it is easy to understand. thank you, sir
Thank you very much for summing this all up in a nutshell. As below, these are very "to the point" without any fluff. Great for presenting to others - !!!
It’s crazy, I’m passive and it feels like lately that I’m so disconnected from myself that I wouldn’t even know how I feel about this or that, or even how to recognize red flags all the time. I was raised to ignore my emotions and my internal guidance system, being walked on was how I was always treated by my parent so it’s normal to me in my mind. I really am trying to work on my voice but it’s so hard when I don’t even know what I am actually feeling.
Love your videos, Carl. The style is so refreshing and the messages are concise and clear. To the point. Love that. Thank you for sharing and best wishes for the new year!
Thank you so much for your amazing and helpful videos! I'm 20 years old and developed Depersonalization last year and through that I learned that I was raised in a dysfunctional family. I'm still in the process of trying to integrate and accept the trauma I experienced. Sadly its not that easy to admit to myself what I experienced. Your Videos are very helpful for me to make good changes in my life, heal and get unstuck. Thanks!!
Hello :) Your lessons are very simple and direct. You talk slowly and very fluidly. Just wanna say: Thank you. You are helping me and i m sure you are helping others too. Bllesings :)
Thanks for telling me when I can be aggressive. If it wasn’t for you I would’ve said to someone assaulting me “Sir, when you hit me in the face with that board, it greatly upsets me, so please stop”
Hey Counselor Carl. Just watched your video on our huge smart board with my nursing class to learn how to properly communicate to patients! Very helpful stuff. Kept us interested with some good humor. We enjoyed the pictures you placed as well. will be coming back for reference. Thanks a lot!
Hi Counselor Carl, I think you look like George W Bush! I would say that assertiveness is good to a certain extent but it does not solve all problems. I think counsellors need to be realistic here in that dealing with bullies in the past, whenever I have confronted them they are unwilling to respect me even when I say how they make me feel. You cannot change the way other people feel about you. In such circumstances, I think assertiveness needs to be brought to a level of being strategic. Example, if you are bullied at work, know your rights to raise a formal grievance/ HR. If you are having problems with a flatmate not paying bills, threaten legal action/ small claims court. I think a lot of every day problems could be avoided by being streetwise and having the knowledge of such circumstances. Simply by being assertive will not necessarily allow your rights to be respected or heard, you really need to be aware and knowledgable as well. I think the whole concept of this is a bit of a red herring.
Scott Barclay. Others have said I look like George Bush, too, LOL! Assertiveness is more than words. It also involves actions such as you describe. Setting healthy boundaries even when using the legal system to do so is simply a special case of assertiveness. And yes there are times to be passive, like avoiding an argument with an intoxicated or dangerously abusive person. But you don't remain passive for long. You still find a way to assert for your own self care, safety, and long-term best interest. So, I agree with pretty much everything you said. Still, assertiveness is by far the most effective form of communication in most situations.
I communicate passively most of the time. Also, rather then speaking up for myself, even if it's just a little things, I would often just leave the relationship and be a loner. I hope I'll be able to speak up for myself in the future. I have a question, what if I'm having problem to even understand what I'm actually thinking? I often realize that I didn't like what heppened too late and then I'm already too frustrated and resentful to speek up for myself assertively...
Hi, Marketa. Codependents are other focused, meaning that they disconnect from their own needs and feelings in order to be what others want them to be. Recovery from codependency involves learning to honor and value your own needs and feelings, but before you can do that, you must start paying attention to your inner world of needs, feelings, and thoughts so you can get to know your needs feelings, likes, dislikes, opinions, etc. They are all there insides of you, but you must practice getting to know them. There are codependency workbooks that can help you learn to do this.
@@Serenityonlinetherapy thank you. Do you think it is a good start for a condependent who feels unabale to establish good, mutual, inspiring relationships/friendships? To focus on the inner work first, find what I feel, need, like, want and start to honor it through my actions (speaking up, settings boundaries)? I've always focused on the relationships and what I'm doing wrong and how to find the right friendships and it seemed to never work so far, it only leaves me more and more frustrated.
@@marketa7752 Yes, I think codependents in recovery need to focus on themselves as they learn to recognize their codependent patterns and learn healthy relationships skills through study and practice. In the process they may realize they have collected a lot of unhealthy relationships, so they must sort them out and distance themselves from the toxic and severely dysfunctional ones. Then they can practice their new healthy skills with their healthier friends and family. And, yes, it is important to spend time getting to know yourself - your needs, feelings, opinions, likes, and dislikes so that you can be a good advocate for yourself and develop good self-care skills.
That is often the case. For those, it is a progression from being disconnected from one's feelings and needs, to learning to identify feelings and needs, to learning to express feelings and advocate for one's needs in relationship.
I was never taught how to be assertive. Im passive :/ I want to learn to set boundaries and speak up for myself. But it seems even when i do speak up like for example with my bf im not heard 😔
Well, you can invite your boyfriend to get some kind of help in learning to communicate more effectively. If he refuses, then you will have a difficult decision to make. Can you live with a person who doesn't want to learn how to communicate in a healthier way?
Hi, Deepak, skillful assertive communication includes being aware of body language, including facial expressions, voice tone, and choice of words that indicate respect to the listener. "Say what you mean, mean what you say, but don't say it mean."
extremely helpful video such clear examples it helped me on my presentation to my counselling class thank you so much ,, will be thanking you in my class tooo :)
This content exemplifies intellectual depth and exploration. Reading a book with related themes was an empowering and enlightening journey. "The Art of Saying No: Mastering Boundaries for a Fulfilling Life" by Samuel Dawn
Thank you for your kind comments. I try to make complex concepts easy to understand.
Carl, i want you to know 3 years ago labor day weekend. I found your channel i was lost and addicted to drugs. your videos helped me get free from all of the addictions and now i am in ministry doing small groups for others who were like me. so thank you and may the Lord God Almighty bless you!!
Hi Jordan,
Thank you for sharing your story. Congratulations on finding your pathway to recovery. I wish you the best!
Thank you Carl for sharing this video. I am a practicing psychiatrist myself and I found your videos particularly helpful for my clients as well as myself. You videos are concise and deliver the messages very clearly.
Thank you very much! That is my goal, to deliver helpful information in a clear and concise manner.
By minute 3 i had to stop the video and take a deep breath. I still comunicate passively (= i don't communicate) but I am working very hard on being assertive. I am sick of people walking over me, but I dont know the difference between being kind and being a pushover. Work, work, and more work to change that, express myself correctly and compromise.
Thank you.
You're very welcome! Best wishes on your journey to healing and becoming your True Self. Being assertive is not being selfish. It is letting your needs and feelings be part of the negotiation of any healthy relationship.
Its a self journey.Every person needs to understand himself before trying to train this skill.You need to know your passive state and your agressive state, how do you behave...and then you in a slowly but rewarding process you will get your own center... calm and assertive..you are in control of yourself so you can actually think about the other.A hug from Argentina.
+Iván Kugelmas Thank you for your helpful comments and observations!
Silberpfote7 Oh,, 1 more thing.You can actually communicate passive, agressive and assertive state just with your body.Do you know about body language?Being assertive is olso understanding your body (sometimes unconscious) communications.Match your words with your body so people can actually feel you more deeply.Its a huge concept, dont take it easy, it is difficult.If you want help contact me.. i will be glad to help you in your journey.I olso struggle in the past with things like yours.
Thank you for sharing your excellent insights!
The most simple, easy to understand explanation without having to use fancy words that I have to twist my brain while trying to understand! Thank you so much
You're welcome, Nathan! Thanks for the kind words.
- this lesson helped me realize that i tend to use passive communication because i do always feel like life is doing it’s own thing and i don’t get to choose, Carl describes it as a type of depression which i don’t fully resonate with but i do feel in a way stuck and unable to heal or grow and i feel like in my relationships the issues are never addressed but it’s a good thing to recognize in my life in order to change it
Wow. My teacher suggest your video for one of our assignment. You are amazing. Thanks.
jafar habibnia. You're welcome!
I enjoy listening to your videos. They are short, practical and direct to the point. It has taking me three years to understand that I had to educate myself about
codependency and make a change for my own good.
Thank you for your informative videos.
You're welcome, and best wishes!
i am a facilitator on a mens group online. i use your material for all my material in running meetings. youre a good man
Thank you!
i have always been a passive agitator and have been practicing assertiveness the past two years. ive learned a lot of this passive agression from dealing with an angry, previously alcoholic, blaming, narcissistic father. he can be very caring though and has my best interests at heart but he puts his family through a lot of bull . he has had a therapist for a while now ever since he got a dwi back in 2019
I search for styles of Assertive Passive and Aggressive Communication on youtube and I really like your video and it is easy to understand. thank you, sir
You're welcome, Vinny! Best wishes!
Thank you very much for summing this all up in a nutshell. As below, these are very "to the point" without any fluff. Great for presenting to others - !!!
Thank you, Annie! I'm glad you found my video helpful.
It’s crazy, I’m passive and it feels like lately that I’m so disconnected from myself that I wouldn’t even know how I feel about this or that, or even how to recognize red flags all the time. I was raised to ignore my emotions and my internal guidance system, being walked on was how I was always treated by my parent so it’s normal to me in my mind. I really am trying to work on my voice but it’s so hard when I don’t even know what I am actually feeling.
Natasha Rodriguez. Don't give up! What you described is learned behavior, which means you can learn healthier ways. Best wishes!
This is a very rich, wise, and beautiful video. Thank you Dr. Carl for your videos and presence.
You're welcome, Aya!
So glad i found this channel! It's truly helping me change my life...
You're very welcome!
Love your videos, Carl. The style is so refreshing and the messages are concise and clear. To the point. Love that. Thank you for sharing and best wishes for the new year!
Thank you for your kind words, Evelyn! I'm glad you find my videos helpful. Best wishes for the new year to you as well!
Thank you so much for your amazing and helpful videos! I'm 20 years old and developed Depersonalization last year and through that I learned that I was raised in a dysfunctional family. I'm still in the process of trying to integrate and accept the trauma I experienced. Sadly its not that easy to admit to myself what I experienced. Your Videos are very helpful for me to make good changes in my life, heal and get unstuck. Thanks!!
You're very welcome! Best wishes on our journey of healing and growth!
Hello :)
Your lessons are very simple and direct.
You talk slowly and very fluidly.
Just wanna say: Thank you.
You are helping me and i m sure you are helping others too.
Bllesings :)
+Dominik Hrbić Thank you for your kind words.
You welcome,Counselor Carl :)
Hey Carl........ i love your work and thank you for sharing so freely
You're welcome, and thank you!
Thank you! We are starting to spread your materials here in the Philippines!
You're welcome! And thanks for sharing the video.
Thanks for telling me when I can be aggressive. If it wasn’t for you I would’ve said to someone assaulting me “Sir, when you hit me in the face with that board, it greatly upsets me, so please stop”
Hey Counselor Carl. Just watched your video on our huge smart board with my nursing class to learn how to properly communicate to patients! Very helpful stuff. Kept us interested with some good humor. We enjoyed the pictures you placed as well. will be coming back for reference. Thanks a lot!
Thank you so much for your kind words. Hello nursing class!
It such a big big help for my speech regarding communication styles. Thank you Counselor Carl :)
You're welcome! Good luck with your speech.
Hi Counselor Carl, I think you look like George W Bush! I would say that assertiveness is good to a certain extent but it does not solve all problems. I think counsellors need to be realistic here in that dealing with bullies in the past, whenever I have confronted them they are unwilling to respect me even when I say how they make me feel. You cannot change the way other people feel about you. In such circumstances, I think assertiveness needs to be brought to a level of being strategic. Example, if you are bullied at work, know your rights to raise a formal grievance/ HR. If you are having problems with a flatmate not paying bills, threaten legal action/ small claims court. I think a lot of every day problems could be avoided by being streetwise and having the knowledge of such circumstances. Simply by being assertive will not necessarily allow your rights to be respected or heard, you really need to be aware and knowledgable as well. I think the whole concept of this is a bit of a red herring.
Scott Barclay. Others have said I look like George Bush, too, LOL! Assertiveness is more than words. It also involves actions such as you describe. Setting healthy boundaries even when using the legal system to do so is simply a special case of assertiveness. And yes there are times to be passive, like avoiding an argument with an intoxicated or dangerously abusive person. But you don't remain passive for long. You still find a way to assert for your own self care, safety, and long-term best interest. So, I agree with pretty much everything you said. Still, assertiveness is by far the most effective form of communication in most situations.
super specific, informative and relevant to the core! Thankyou as I have a session on Assertiveness tomorrow and this video is of great help!
I like the step by step presentation style you use sir!
Thanks
You're welcome, Patrick! Best wishes!
Wow I was assertive today, that is growth for me.
356 Pounds TO FIT. Well done!
Kudos to you Counselor Carl 🌹👍. How can I work with my partner on getting rid of the silent treatments??? Is it possible ? Never give up hope right?
I communicate passively most of the time. Also, rather then speaking up for myself, even if it's just a little things, I would often just leave the relationship and be a loner. I hope I'll be able to speak up for myself in the future.
I have a question, what if I'm having problem to even understand what I'm actually thinking? I often realize that I didn't like what heppened too late and then I'm already too frustrated and resentful to speek up for myself assertively...
Hi, Marketa. Codependents are other focused, meaning that they disconnect from their own needs and feelings in order to be what others want them to be. Recovery from codependency involves learning to honor and value your own needs and feelings, but before you can do that, you must start paying attention to your inner world of needs, feelings, and thoughts so you can get to know your needs feelings, likes, dislikes, opinions, etc. They are all there insides of you, but you must practice getting to know them. There are codependency workbooks that can help you learn to do this.
@@Serenityonlinetherapy thank you. Do you think it is a good start for a condependent who feels unabale to establish good, mutual, inspiring relationships/friendships? To focus on the inner work first, find what I feel, need, like, want and start to honor it through my actions (speaking up, settings boundaries)? I've always focused on the relationships and what I'm doing wrong and how to find the right friendships and it seemed to never work so far, it only leaves me more and more frustrated.
@@marketa7752 Yes, I think codependents in recovery need to focus on themselves as they learn to recognize their codependent patterns and learn healthy relationships skills through study and practice. In the process they may realize they have collected a lot of unhealthy relationships, so they must sort them out and distance themselves from the toxic and severely dysfunctional ones. Then they can practice their new healthy skills with their healthier friends and family. And, yes, it is important to spend time getting to know yourself - your needs, feelings, opinions, likes, and dislikes so that you can be a good advocate for yourself and develop good self-care skills.
@@Serenityonlinetherapy good, sounds exactly like what I was doing. It's a slow process however
Thank you, this is very helpful!!! I plan on referring to your videos often!
You're very welcome!
Passives don't even know what they are feeling, its not just that they are unwilling. We were ignored and not permitted to discuss feelings/emotions.
That is often the case. For those, it is a progression from being disconnected from one's feelings and needs, to learning to identify feelings and needs, to learning to express feelings and advocate for one's needs in relationship.
Very clear and to the point. Thank you
You're very welcome!
thanks, helped out in my quest to build self-esteem, as self-assertivenss is a key pillar within it! /Alexander:)
Alexander Nilsson. Exactly! Self-care equals self-esteem.
Thanks Carl:)
You're welcome, Alexander!
U make it so simple to understand and practice 😊🙏
I try! Thank you. Best wishes!
Quality information. Thank you very much.
You're welcome!
very well. Major confusion Solved. Direction regained. Thank-you Very Much.
You're very welcome!
Can you please tell me the advantages of this technique and disadvantages?
During counseling sessions..
Assertiveness is the ONLY pattern of communication for building healthy relationships.
thank you :)
I was never taught how to be assertive. Im passive :/ I want to learn to set boundaries and speak up for myself. But it seems even when i do speak up like for example with my bf im not heard 😔
Well, you can invite your boyfriend to get some kind of help in learning to communicate more effectively. If he refuses, then you will have a difficult decision to make. Can you live with a person who doesn't want to learn how to communicate in a healthier way?
Say what you mean!
Mean what you say!
But don't say it mean!
You got it!
I'm little bit aggressive because I have bit unresolved anger because being quiet
Not speaking up
Thankyou, this has helped me so much!
You're very welcome! Best wishes!
Thank you for your video, is very helpful.
You're welcome, Jean Pierre!
brilliant video so so clear and i thank you yoy gave so much and in a very effective manner in such a short amount of time
You're welcome, Uri! And thank you!
Thank you counselor Carl 🙏
You're welcome!
This was helpful. Thank you.
You're welcome!
What should we do if someone has a little bit of all the bad ones and struggle with being assertive? CBT and Meditation?
Dan Assertiveness is a learned skill. If not learned in childhood, it can be learned as an adult through books, classes, therapy, etc.
How do people communicate despite the differences in communication style?
Thanks 🙏
You're welcome, Adarsh!
Raw concept i liked it so much
Thank you Sir for sharing knowledge.
You're welcome!
Hi Counsellor Carl . Can you please advise the relationship between tone, pitch of voice and assertive communication
Hi, Deepak, skillful assertive communication includes being aware of body language, including facial expressions, voice tone, and choice of words that indicate respect to the listener. "Say what you mean, mean what you say, but don't say it mean."
yes..i learnt lotsa knowledge in ur video
Thank you
Thank you so much
You're welcome!
extremely helpful video
such clear examples
it helped me on my presentation to my counselling class
thank you so much ,, will be thanking you in my class tooo :)
You're welcome! Glad to help!
This content exemplifies intellectual depth and exploration. Reading a book with related themes was an empowering and enlightening journey. "The Art of Saying No: Mastering Boundaries for a Fulfilling Life" by Samuel Dawn
Thank you for sharing!
I've only watched the first minute of this video and I already feel personally attacked XD
Thank you.
You're welcome!
Thank you again
You're welcome!
I subscribed! your stuff is amazing....
+Thubten Puntsok Thank you for your kind words!
it's amazing. i subscribed u. thank u very much.
Thank you!
ur wellcome
So in summary... Passive: I lose U win Aggressive: I win U lose Passive-Aggressive: I lose U lose Assertive: I win U win
I like that!
This dudes good
thank u sir
You're welcome, Nadia!
hi I heard of say what you mean and mean what you say
but I never heard of but don't be mean
Then that was the missing piece!
Superficial general concepts.