Ming W Shane's logic was undeniable in a lot of the situations the group was in. Everybody except for him couldn't let go of their pride and ego to at least consider Shane's proposals. Everybody looked and treated him like the bad guy until he continuously proved them wrong. Andrea was the only person who understood him completely. He's no saint, but he made tons of sense
@@YT_FALLENX I dont think he really wanted to kill Rick. I believe he wanted Rick to kill him out in that field. And he didn't kill Otis...the walkers did, he just maimed him 😂🤣
Season 3-6 was the best 3 seasons I’ve watched out of any tv series. Many would say the same. The Walking Dead never died it just went downhill at season 8 but it’s fanbase is going back up now.
For me Shane was by far the most interesting and compelling character on the show & he only had 2 seasons. Jon Bernthal's portrayal of him was amazing and the other characters for me just aren't or weren't as interesting as Shane. Great video btw! Probably my favourite tribute from you :)
Shane was and still is my favorite character on the walking dead even though we r now in season 5. If u compare how the group is acting now in season 5 it is exactly how Shane was acting in season 2 when everyone thought he was crazy
He's my favorite character still. He's gone through a lot and got confused with that went on with him, Rick, and Lori. He was tough and very smart with trying to keep the group alive. Killing those Zombies in the barn, wanting to Randal, and not risking to for others to get hurt during the search for Sophia. Daryl got hurt and wanted no one else to get hurt. There is just some things he can't handle but still a good character
Shane is such an essential character to Rick, TWD show as a whole and their story's progression, there's no wonder a lot of us like him, even if you take out how much you can sympathise with him, brilliantly written by Kirman's team and perfectly portrayed by John Bernthal.
Simply amazing tribute to the best TWD character. Shane is my favorite. Everyone below me pretty much said all my thoughts: that TWD hasn't been the same since Shane died, Shane was ahead of his time and understood what it took to survive, and he's a very complex and compelling character. Jon Bernthal was wonderful in this role -- this was my first time playing him and it is his superb acting skills that made me love Shane so much.
Shane was proven to have better leadership skills, than Rick more than once. 1: He didn't wanna go and leave the whole camp, just to save a meth addict. 2: He beat Ed, for hitting Carol. 3: He went to go talk to Jim, when he was out there digging and calmed him down. 4: He wanted to go to Fort Benning, where there was guns, food, water, and shelter. 5: He created a distracted, so that him and Otis could get past the walkers. 6: He killed Otis, instead of them struggling to make it out together. 7: He didn't wanna waste time, looking for a lost little girl, when they could have been looking for guns, ammo, food, water, clothes. 8: He broke open the barn, instead of letting Rick help Hershel, put more walkers in there. 9: He cleaned Carol up and apologized for her loss. 10: He went and got Lori and brought her, back to the farm. 11: He led Andrea, T Dog, and Daryl, to kill the walkers in 2x12. 12: He snapped Randall's neck, in the woods, instead of letting him go, risking the chance of him, coming back with 30 of his men, preventing them from killing him, Rick, Carl, Glenn, T Dog, Daryl, Hershel, and Jimmy, and raping Lori, Andrea, Carol, Patrica, Maggie, and Beth.
This show has so many misunderstood villains. Merle, Shane, The Governor. Even Gareth. I really like how they show why these people are who they are. Merle was abused Shane, let's face it, he was being unfairly treated by Lori and Rick. The Governor could never be the same after his daughter's death and wanted to make sure nothing like that ever happened to his people again. Gareth did what he thought he had to do in order to protect his people. The writing of this show is so underrated.
Agreed. They are very complex and well developed characters. Shane, Merle and The Governor remain my favorites on this show aside from Rick. Especially Shane, loved his character.
anythingnew Yes, but why was he like that? because he lost his daughter and he didn't want to lose anyone else. Now Rick is exactly like him, if not worse because he feels the same way.
Merle and Shane are some of the best misunderstood characters on TV ever. they are the best misunderstood characters on the show. But I believe you don't need the villain to be misunderstood to be awesome. Negan (in my opinion) is the best villain the show has ever had. And i don't find him misunderstood at all. He loves what he does. Yes i know the comics and have read Negan's comic back story. But even with that he's not misunderstood. He lost family and some people then became a leader and really took over everything. He's not misunderstood, yeah he thinks what he's doing is right but that doesn't make him misunderstood. He became a king who rules through fear. I also don't think the Governor is misunderstood either. He lost his daughter and became a murderer who's "protecting" his people. Even though killing he killed a good majority of them for simply retreating from a battle they probably wouldn't have won and a battle they didn't wanna be in in the first place. He killed Martinez, Milton, Andrea, Allen. Who of whom were his people at one point or another. Yeah he wasn't misunderstood just a psycho who thought he was right. Gareth was more misunderstood but still not really. His group got really hungry and chose to eat other people. Instead of looting nearby towns or growing their own food like other communities have. My point with this was basically I agree that SHane was awesome and Merle was fantastic.
You know I haven't seen a better Shane video since SuperJacksonHills video Rip Shane. The song, scenes, title defines Shane Walsh. It makes me sad I probably wont find another character as good as the one Jon Bernthal portrayed in the Walking Dead as Shane. Amazing job on the video.
shane was a great character who made a lot of decisions normal people would but went crazy after killing otis miss dale as well he died to early as well
Man i love your shane tributes and choice in music from the warrior and I hope lauries and ricks baby grows up to look like shane and very slowly as the kid gets older it just looks more and more like him and just messes with the 2 ultimate shane revenge lol
Miss this guy Jon bernthal is from Washington d.c he lived not far from me such a good guy and great actor. Ashame they look him off the show fuck the comic book. He was the walking dead. Made the show...they fucked up by killing him off.
I love this video, it shows just perfectly how hard it all was for Shane... I feel so sorry for him, he fought so much to survive zombie apocalypse, and ended up dying by a hand of his best friend
Wow, one of the best videos you have ever made. It really showcases what he went through and really makes you feel for him even though he went crazy. Amazing, amazing job
I absolutely love it! We need more Shane videos! :D It's very deep and emotional, specially because Shane was one of my favorite characters. Amazing job, Heather! :)
+Teh Turmenuter THAT KID just told Daryl that his group raped 2 girls and he knew where the farm was , did u even watch the show ? Let the kid go so he can tell his group where the farm is and they can come rape all the woman ? Yea smart lmao
His group might've done something horrible, but does that mean that he is bad? And yes, he probably would have told his own group, but theres not a way to be 100% sure. And yes, i did watch the show. You can obviously see that from my previous comments. And i feel like we have a shane fanboy here
+Teh Turmenuter I feel like we have a Shane hater here , it's funny that the group does the same things Shane was doing back when now in season 5 and 6 of twd. But nobody gets on them just Shane , most people realize that but there's still a few out there like u that haven't realized almost everything Shane did was right
I'm not a shane hater. I actually like him. But i do realize he was a mad man. He did the things he did way too early. He was too perfect for the infection. And several years passed between season 2 and 6
Shane is my favourite character from TWD together with Dale and Rick.. Why Shane? Because he was the one who knew how the world has ended and he was the one who understood that there is no hope and if you want to survive, you need to fight for it. I wish they would kick him out of the farm and he would come back as a villian later in like season 5 or 6, that would be so awesome!
in the end shane was always right and rick became exactly who he was love him or hate him shane knew what everything would come to that we would enviably find a governor or a negan and would have to enact darwinism
I think you should make a tribute video to the WARRIOR movie also you should definitely make another tribute to Shane Walsh he is truly the greatest Walking Dead character.
thank you so much, that means a lot coming from you| :) Yeah I've thought about that but I'm not feeling very inspired lately :/ But that's definetely something I should give more thought about it! :)
Heather, have you heard "Truth - Alexander" from Breaking bad? Amazing song. I think it'd suit one of your videos perfectly. EIther that be one about Shane or Breaking bad
Shane era un gran personaje, de hecho es uno de los mejores para mi, el amor hacia Lori lo llevo a la muerte, ya que se sentía celoso de Rick que era su mejor amigo. Que pena que fue matado por su mejor amigo Rick ;(
Essentially it seems as if the "good" characters are playing a game of catch, with implied overtones of struggling to maintain a decent morally sound existence. Take Shane for example; he obviously is flawed ethically and in other compassion type thought processes. But would he have kept more ppl "alive" for longer? I believe yes. However his desires both based upon lust and power are essentially what does him in. Therefore he was not a good person to share the proverbial "fox hole" with. Now, Shane tosses the ball to Dale who had been questioning his ethos in a nonchalant manor. Obviously, Dale's role was that of a preservation of our "Humanity". Once his death occurs the "ball" is then passed to Morgan I believe. I'm not trying to make any specific point or discredit any other opinions. I just enjoy stating my own understanding of this show.
he was rejected by the group he adapted faster than any of them by 3 years look at Rick,Glenn,Carol,Daryl and Carl (don't technically count because he was younger)
Rick now is totally a worse copy of Shane? Shane was only a logical person nobody wanted to think logically Everybody was following their own emotions only Nobody wanted to see how many good things that Shane have done in the beginning I only can blame Lori all time Shane blood is on her hands Well you guys saw the proof Maggie Rick Dayrl And even the most sweet and coward woman (carol) is double worse than Shane now Well I feel sorry for Shane
see in my opinion Shane would have been the better leader and no can't blame Shane for being with Lorie and taking care of Carl. because he thought his best friend died so shit talking do no good there. Shane would have protected Lorie and the baby and Carl and Carl wouldn't have his eye gone. if people listened things would having been better. so that's just me and he is awesome but hey no one would have been a punisher lol 😀
I just hate how everyone in the the group disrespected him and never thought to see it his way. He made so much sense before he went crazy.
No one ever disrespected him. And he never went crazy, he was just so far ahead of everyone that he seemed crazy to normal people
Ming W Shane's logic was undeniable in a lot of the situations the group was in. Everybody except for him couldn't let go of their pride and ego to at least consider Shane's proposals. Everybody looked and treated him like the bad guy until he continuously proved them wrong. Andrea was the only person who understood him completely. He's no saint, but he made tons of sense
He was the best character on this show. Season 2 Rick was not enough. Shane was the true hero.
@@mingw2304 he did go crazy. He tried to kill Rick and killed Otis other than that he was right about everything. I loved his character.💔
@@YT_FALLENX I dont think he really wanted to kill Rick. I believe he wanted Rick to kill him out in that field. And he didn't kill Otis...the walkers did, he just maimed him 😂🤣
I miss Shane so much. He was my favorite character. Still is.
Bro you living ?
When Shane died so did some of the show, but I'm glad they didn't kill him off as early in the comics.
They did
Radio Chicken ? No shane literally the first issue in the comics and Robert Kirkman said he regretted killing shane off so early In the comics
Season 3-6 was the best 3 seasons I’ve watched out of any tv series. Many would say the same. The Walking Dead never died it just went downhill at season 8 but it’s fanbase is going back up now.
Until this day, he is my favourite character
nesreen galal coming back season 9🔥
Gonzalo 2001 Yea I will
9 years ago...
For me Shane was by far the most interesting and compelling character on the show & he only had 2 seasons. Jon Bernthal's portrayal of him was amazing and the other characters for me just aren't or weren't as interesting as Shane. Great video btw! Probably my favourite tribute from you :)
YEAH WAAAAAAA I CRY
***** Season 4 was shit
***** Second half was awful
Shane was my favorite character on the walking dead in someways I can relate to Shane about certain things.
9 years ago...
Bro you living ?
Shane is the best character :D
Shane was and still is my favorite character on the walking dead even though we r now in season 5. If u compare how the group is acting now in season 5 it is exactly how Shane was acting in season 2 when everyone thought he was crazy
Exactly! I think the same and everyone thinks I'm crazy
Don't worry us Shane fans know the true story
vincent duchesne He just evolved way too quickly for the group in Season 2 to understand.
Yea they couldn't handle it that early
vincent duchesne He would have been perfect for Season 4 onward.
Got season 1 and 2 on repeat. Can't get enough of the good ol days
True
New seasons sucks
Love your channel bro
Team Shane are here !
I really miss this guy. Despite his huge ego, he was one of the strongest and best characters in The Walking Dead. So much influence in the series.
The show died with shane WALSH
Victorian Fox that s right
He's my favorite character still. He's gone through a lot and got confused with that went on with him, Rick, and Lori. He was tough and very smart with trying to keep the group alive. Killing those Zombies in the barn, wanting to Randal, and not risking to for others to get hurt during the search for Sophia. Daryl got hurt and wanted no one else to get hurt. There is just some things he can't handle but still a good character
Shane is such an essential character to Rick, TWD show as a whole and their story's progression, there's no wonder a lot of us like him, even if you take out how much you can sympathise with him, brilliantly written by Kirman's team and perfectly portrayed by John Bernthal.
I loved the Shane Walsh character. I wish he could come back :(
Still come back to this video all these years later.
Yep
WONDERFUL tribute for one of my favourite character, a brave, courageous man called Shane.
Shane will always be my first fav char ever next to merle and rick
***** yeap my favs in order shane merle and rick
***** haha wtf you're the first guy that had the same order as me XD
Never really cared for any character on this show except SHANE WALSH !!!!
KILL RICK IN REAL N SHANE LIVE FOR EVER
Shane Walsh ok
Shane was wonderful. Its a damn shame they killed him off as soon as they did. He was a warrior.
Bro you living?
@@melihkara9476can you shut your mouth
Simply amazing tribute to the best TWD character. Shane is my favorite. Everyone below me pretty much said all my thoughts: that TWD hasn't been the same since Shane died, Shane was ahead of his time and understood what it took to survive, and he's a very complex and compelling character. Jon Bernthal was wonderful in this role -- this was my first time playing him and it is his superb acting skills that made me love Shane so much.
"Survive means make hard decisions" - Shane
I've been watching this one video
For 10 years and I relate to Shane
More and more as the years pass
Shane was proven to have better leadership skills, than Rick more than once.
1: He didn't wanna go and leave the whole camp, just to save a meth addict.
2: He beat Ed, for hitting Carol.
3: He went to go talk to Jim, when he was out there digging and calmed him down.
4: He wanted to go to Fort Benning, where there was guns, food, water, and shelter.
5: He created a distracted, so that him and Otis could get past the walkers.
6: He killed Otis, instead of them struggling to make it out together.
7: He didn't wanna waste time, looking for a lost little girl, when they could have been looking for guns, ammo, food, water, clothes.
8: He broke open the barn, instead of letting Rick help Hershel, put more walkers in there.
9: He cleaned Carol up and apologized for her loss.
10: He went and got Lori and brought her, back to the farm.
11: He led Andrea, T Dog, and Daryl, to kill the walkers in 2x12.
12: He snapped Randall's neck, in the woods, instead of letting him go, risking the chance of him, coming back with 30 of his men, preventing them from killing him, Rick, Carl, Glenn, T Dog, Daryl, Hershel, and Jimmy, and raping Lori, Andrea, Carol, Patrica, Maggie, and Beth.
I fucking miss shane!! I want him back :'(
9 years ago...
shane for me was the best
This is the best video about Shane i've ever seen!
Today is exactly 2 years since Shane was killed :( R.I.P. :(
This show has so many misunderstood villains.
Merle, Shane, The Governor. Even Gareth. I really like how they show why these people are who they are.
Merle was abused
Shane, let's face it, he was being unfairly treated by Lori and Rick.
The Governor could never be the same after his daughter's death and wanted to make sure nothing like that ever happened to his people again.
Gareth did what he thought he had to do in order to protect his people.
The writing of this show is so underrated.
Agreed. They are very complex and well developed characters. Shane, Merle and The Governor remain my favorites on this show aside from Rick. Especially Shane, loved his character.
anythingnew Yes, but why was he like that? because he lost his daughter and he didn't want to lose anyone else. Now Rick is exactly like him, if not worse because he feels the same way.
Who the fuck is Gareth
Gareth was the leader of ''the hunters'' at terminus.
Merle and Shane are some of the best misunderstood characters on TV ever. they are the best misunderstood characters on the show.
But I believe you don't need the villain to be misunderstood to be awesome. Negan (in my opinion) is the best villain the show has ever had. And i don't find him misunderstood at all. He loves what he does.
Yes i know the comics and have read Negan's comic back story. But even with that he's not misunderstood. He lost family and some people then became a leader and really took over everything. He's not misunderstood, yeah he thinks what he's doing is right but that doesn't make him misunderstood. He became a king who rules through fear.
I also don't think the Governor is misunderstood either. He lost his daughter and became a murderer who's "protecting" his people. Even though killing he killed a good majority of them for simply retreating from a battle they probably wouldn't have won and a battle they didn't wanna be in in the first place. He killed Martinez, Milton, Andrea, Allen. Who of whom were his people at one point or another. Yeah he wasn't misunderstood just a psycho who thought he was right.
Gareth was more misunderstood but still not really. His group got really hungry and chose to eat other people. Instead of looting nearby towns or growing their own food like other communities have.
My point with this was basically I agree that SHane was awesome and Merle was fantastic.
You know I haven't seen a better Shane video since SuperJacksonHills video Rip Shane. The song, scenes, title defines Shane Walsh. It makes me sad I probably wont find another character as good as the one Jon Bernthal portrayed in the Walking Dead as Shane. Amazing job on the video.
Great video. Rest in peace Shane.
shane was a great character who made a lot of decisions normal people would but went crazy after killing otis miss dale as well he died to early as well
I love Shane the most from the show, wish he was still around he stole my heart.
I wish Shane could have been around longer. Awesome video as usual.
Man i love your shane tributes and choice in music from the warrior and I hope lauries and ricks baby grows up to look like shane and very slowly as the kid gets older it just looks more and more like him and just messes with the 2 ultimate shane revenge lol
This, my heart.
Rick act like Shane now
Damn I miss Shane! :(
In a way Rick consumed Shane. He became Shane himself. Shane made him better by taking it to the point of no return.
Miss this guy Jon bernthal is from Washington d.c he lived not far from me such a good guy and great actor. Ashame they look him off the show fuck the comic book. He was the walking dead. Made the show...they fucked up by killing him off.
That's what I'm saying !!! It's not like jon bernthal is in the comics ! He is an amazing actor so let the danm character live !!!
I love this video, it shows just perfectly how hard it all was for Shane... I feel so sorry for him, he fought so much to survive zombie apocalypse, and ended up dying by a hand of his best friend
Wow, one of the best videos you have ever made. It really showcases what he went through and really makes you feel for him even though he went crazy. Amazing, amazing job
btw, I love your song choices, they always fit so perfectly! :)
beautiful as always! you captured his character perfectly! :)
R.I.P Shane Walsh
I absolutely love it! We need more Shane videos! :D It's very deep and emotional, specially because Shane was one of my favorite characters. Amazing job, Heather! :)
Just ain't the same without ol' Jon Bernthal.
I love your video and this song is so awesome i miss Shane he was my favorite character on the walking dead show Daryl is my favorite character
It was actually pretty sad, how many chances Rick gave shane, even after shane has tried to kill him several times, Rick tried to ignore it....
It was pretty sad how many times Shane put up with Rick and his idiotic decisions
+Teh Turmenuter THAT KID just told Daryl that his group raped 2 girls and he knew where the farm was , did u even watch the show ? Let the kid go so he can tell his group where the farm is and they can come rape all the woman ? Yea smart lmao
His group might've done something horrible, but does that mean that he is bad? And yes, he probably would have told his own group, but theres not a way to be 100% sure. And yes, i did watch the show. You can obviously see that from my previous comments. And i feel like we have a shane fanboy here
+Teh Turmenuter I feel like we have a Shane hater here , it's funny that the group does the same things Shane was doing back when now in season 5 and 6 of twd. But nobody gets on them just Shane , most people realize that but there's still a few out there like u that haven't realized almost everything Shane did was right
I'm not a shane hater. I actually like him. But i do realize he was a mad man. He did the things he did way too early. He was too perfect for the infection. And several years passed between season 2 and 6
BRING SHANE BACK PLEASE
How?
0 dislikes .. not even those who hate shane put you dislike this video, thank you very much for a great video heather =)
A part of the show died along with shane, season 5 has been a total let down so far
Season 5 was awesome
Just love this vid hun and great song choice too
I love your video and this song
My favorite character of all tv shows
This makes me miss Shane even more :|.
In memory of Shane Walsh
Shane is my favourite character from TWD together with Dale and Rick.. Why Shane? Because he was the one who knew how the world has ended and he was the one who understood that there is no hope and if you want to survive, you need to fight for it. I wish they would kick him out of the farm and he would come back as a villian later in like season 5 or 6, that would be so awesome!
Ruda Buffi he ain't no villain, in a world they live in there's no Villians. just survival.
Al menos ay gente que sabe apreciar a lo que fue un verdadero buen personaje #22
in the end shane was always right and rick became exactly who he was love him or hate him shane knew what everything would come to that we would enviably find a governor or a negan and would have to enact darwinism
Dammit Shane!
I think you should make a tribute video to the WARRIOR movie also you should definitely make another tribute to Shane Walsh he is truly the greatest Walking Dead character.
I love them soooo much and yours
wow..this is amazing.
Still the best character
thank you so much, that means a lot coming from you| :) Yeah I've thought about that but I'm not feeling very inspired lately :/ But that's definetely something I should give more thought about it! :)
AWESOME.
Team shane
I love Shane , his Swagger. He’s bae 💋❤️
+cHeather360x can u do when like for the walking dead game a tribute with clementine and lee?
Heather, have you heard "Truth - Alexander" from Breaking bad? Amazing song. I think it'd suit one of your videos perfectly. EIther that be one about Shane or Breaking bad
Awsome video!!" Stunning!
😭
Awsm
Which episode is the clip at 7 second from, with him sitting in the dark?
S1E3
Max S Thanks!
Shane era un gran personaje, de hecho es uno de los mejores para mi, el amor hacia Lori lo llevo a la muerte, ya que se sentía celoso de Rick que era su mejor amigo.
Que pena que fue matado por su mejor amigo Rick ;(
nice vid
Essentially it seems as if the "good" characters are playing a game of catch, with implied overtones of struggling to maintain a decent morally sound existence. Take Shane for example; he obviously is flawed ethically and in other compassion type thought processes. But would he have kept more ppl "alive" for longer? I believe yes. However his desires both based upon lust and power are essentially what does him in. Therefore he was not a good person to share the proverbial "fox hole" with. Now, Shane tosses the ball to Dale who had been questioning his ethos in a nonchalant manor. Obviously, Dale's role was that of a preservation of our "Humanity". Once his death occurs the "ball" is then passed to Morgan I believe. I'm not trying to make any specific point or discredit any other opinions. I just enjoy stating my own understanding of this show.
I subbed as well +xHeather360x
Ugh why did he go bad he alone could have killed every villain Rick encounters but himself xC
Agreed
he was rejected by the group he adapted faster than any of them by 3 years look at Rick,Glenn,Carol,Daryl and Carl (don't technically count because he was younger)
Why Shane is dead :'((((
My number 1 favorite character, 2nd Negan, 3rd Eugine, 4th Govenor, 5th Abraham
i hate when shane dies i hate that
Rick now is totally a worse copy of Shane?
Shane was only a logical person nobody wanted to think logically
Everybody was following their own emotions only
Nobody wanted to see how many good things that Shane have done in the beginning
I only can blame Lori all time
Shane blood is on her hands
Well you guys saw the proof
Maggie
Rick
Dayrl
And even the most sweet and coward woman (carol) is double worse than Shane now
Well I feel sorry for Shane
strongest character ever been in the show
i tried watching it and i got a block saying i couldnt watch it because of my country...
im canadian...
it worked after a few seconds.. but...
0.o
I keep on getting wierd feelings in me when i listin to this video
💔
21/sep/16❤️
?
Warrior 1978
Only if shane didn't bang lori in a bush!
only if lori refuse to bang with shane!
Why did they kill off Shane :( Shane would fuck the Govenor up.
see in my opinion Shane would have been the better leader and no can't blame Shane for being with Lorie and taking care of Carl. because he thought his best friend died so shit talking do no good there. Shane would have protected Lorie and the baby and Carl and Carl wouldn't have his eye gone. if people listened things would having been better. so that's just me and he is awesome but hey no one would have been a punisher lol 😀
i hated Shane but i like the video
Its his fault he got killed.
La culpa de que fuera asesinado fuera de Lori.