I am not trying to put up anything, I am just genuinely amazed. "How is that possible" is just an expression. I hope you don't misunderstand me. Thank you☺️
Cuz they did one with in ears after that they repeated the performance by lipsynching to their own studio song so they can get cooler better shot and get them to gether .. the vocals are live but the stage was shot days ago with with shots from at least 3 different performances
i'm glad that junkyu's voice is back to his normal voice. bcos in the radio his voice is like hurt, donghyuk said that time junkyu's throat is not working normally. i don't know how to say this but we know that junkyu always nervous since ygtb, but NOW HE'S GROW GUYS. HE CAN CONTROL HIS NERVOUS (。>﹏
This is real because there are parts where you cannot fake: 1. 0:17 Doyoung's accent "lewv" 2. 0:20 Jaehyuk's swag voice 3. 0:40 Yedam's sudden deep voice because of the choreo 4. 1:10 Haruto hyping his line 5. 1:20 Hyunsuk pronouncing "jichim" as "CHICHEWWMM" and "jikjin" as "CHIKCHEEENNN" Hard choreo + high notes and yet Treasure never failed to amaze us
I believe in this MR removed because I watched the live earlier at Mcountdown and I can say that they really have stable voices like did they eat cd for lunch
I already know how stable Jeongwoo's live vocal is but it still surprises me every single time. sounding like that at 17 is a huge thing to brag about, plus theres still a lot of room for growth so i cant wait to see how much he has improved in the future. from ygtb up until now, he never really disappointed me tbh. that's KINGIE!!
Mashiho always the most stable one every comeback. His control on his voice was on another level. A top notch ace for me. Im in love with his Jikjin line at the end of the song, the most soothing and powerful one!!! Mashiho voice need more recognition!! I said what I said he deserves because he own it. He got unique voice of park BOM and lee honggi ftisland.
Tf, yoshi always sounds like the studio version, I observed that almost all parts he is dancing but he still sounds good. Jeongwoo's voice is heaven as always, yedam as well. Treasure 2nd win lezzgo✨
I don't know if it's just me, but yedam's note is much more higher than the studio version. From the pre-chorus, it seemed really higher than the normal note.
Jeongwoo punya suara ni stable gila, klau tgok diorang perform je aku selalu contemplating dia ni live ke x, tapi bila tgok members ada je dengar live tu. Conc, suara dia sedap nak mampos makan cd kot hari2, x paham aku.
Even in the actual (non-mr) version, we can literally hear them breathe (plus who would miss out on Hyunsuk’s emphasis on his parts aka “Jiiiikjeeewwwnnn” haha). That alone proves it’s live. This mr removed video just strengthened it. Ahhhh TREASURE OUR PRIDE!!!
I really like Junkyu and Junghwan's tune this comeback. Jaehyuk improvement im so happy for him. And their is Mashiho who sing so chill despite the choreo. Jeongwoo and Yedam's chorus is a definitely a favorite!
it's obvious without even pointing specific timestamps that they are singing live. uneven levels indicate that it's not just them recording a fake live over. i think the one thing that confuses people tho is that, idols often perform the same song several times due to camerawork. 1st recording to get main shots, 2nd time to make it look perfect on TV, and 3rd time sometimes to get all the individual member fancams (if they weren't able to get all of them in the previous two shots). that's why fancams sometimes look completely different from the live stage performance. that doesn't mean it was lipsync tho, it just means that it was edited for broadcast with the best live sound and best visual performance. that's just how kpop is - perfection is so important to them (and honestly why not when you are prerecording anyway might as well make it perfect).
What's going on with Jaehyuk tho??? He sounds so confident, growling and doing adlibs so stable, we know he's the personification of hard work we can tell hardworking is paying off. We're so proud of you Yoon Jaehyuk 👏🏻😭❤️
"NO HARD CHOREOS TO HAVE STABLE VOICES"
WHILE TREASURE: FLYING🤸♂️🤸🏻♂️🤸♂️
🤣🤣
They aren't even wearing an in-ear! How is that possible.. I stan PURE TALENTS
they usually wear the ear piece when there's an audience so they can still hear their selves despite the screaming
@@kpopblizz7737 I also watch other artist 's performances on Mnet today, and they are wearing theirs. But thank you though! ☺️
I am not trying to put up anything, I am just genuinely amazed. "How is that possible" is just an expression. I hope you don't misunderstand me. Thank you☺️
Cuz they did one with in ears after that they repeated the performance by lipsynching to their own studio song so they can get cooler better shot and get them to gether .. the vocals are live but the stage was shot days ago with with shots from at least 3 different performances
look how stable their voices are. Y'all let's give them encore stage, fighting!
YES PLEASE I NEED IT
FIGHTING
i'm glad that junkyu's voice is back to his normal voice. bcos in the radio his voice is like hurt, donghyuk said that time junkyu's throat is not working normally. i don't know how to say this but we know that junkyu always nervous since ygtb, but NOW HE'S GROW GUYS. HE CAN CONTROL HIS NERVOUS (。>﹏
then we find out they had TWO radio schedules that day so by the time it was dk's radio at 12am, it makes sense they are tired
@@aiurlevi yea it's busy schedule for them, but i know that they're happy with that. after 1 year they dont have youtube or tv program schedule
This is real because there are parts where you cannot fake:
1. 0:17 Doyoung's accent "lewv"
2. 0:20 Jaehyuk's swag voice
3. 0:40 Yedam's sudden deep voice because of the choreo
4. 1:10 Haruto hyping his line
5. 1:20 Hyunsuk pronouncing "jichim" as "CHICHEWWMM" and "jikjin" as "CHIKCHEEENNN"
Hard choreo + high notes and yet Treasure never failed to amaze us
hyunsuk adlib at 1:59 too. and the other adlib
Not the *CHICHEWWWMMM* 😆😆
Jikcheemmmmmm
I laughed at your no. 1 there- Doyoung’s accent of love- *lewv* haha XD
You got me at the chichwemm and chikcheenn
왜 한국 댓글이 없냐 미쳐따..역시 실력은 와이지 무시 못한다
treasure는 아직 본국의 한국에서 지명도가 낮습니까?
조금씩 지명도가 오르고 있는 것일까요?😭
번역기를 사용하고 있으므로 한국어가 잘못되면 미안해.
Yg 진짜 실력하나는 보장
@@choiEHOFo 진짜 다행이다 ㅠㅠ
WE DON'T MAKE 'HARD CHOREO' AS AN EXCUSE BECAUSE,,, EXCUSE ME???! MY BOYS ARE REAL, HELLA LIVE PERFORMERS!! STABLE VOCALS? YOU JUDGE.
yes hard choreo is not an excuse to lipsync
Periodddd
As always Jeongwoo stable af.
I believe in this MR removed because I watched the live earlier at Mcountdown and I can say that they really have stable voices like did they eat cd for lunch
they forgot what to eat and suddenly saw random cd .. so they take decision to eat it😔💜
Right. Sometimes their live singing isn't 100% sync with the bgm. Only proves that they sing live. BEAUTIFULLY
jaehyuk's improvement on his vocals are so good hes more confident now and the way he growled DAMNN
That growl really got me
I already know how stable Jeongwoo's live vocal is but it still surprises me every single time. sounding like that at 17 is a huge thing to brag about, plus theres still a lot of room for growth so i cant wait to see how much he has improved in the future. from ygtb up until now, he never really disappointed me tbh. that's KINGIE!!
Mashiho always the most stable one every comeback. His control on his voice was on another level. A top notch ace for me. Im in love with his Jikjin line at the end of the song, the most soothing and powerful one!!! Mashiho voice need more recognition!! I said what I said he deserves because he own it. He got unique voice of park BOM and lee honggi ftisland.
yeah,he is the best.
they shoud give MASHIHO more line.
와..무대봤을때 처음에는 음이 약간 다른 부분 보고 음? 생라이브인가? 했는데 뒤에서 그냥 음원같아서 아닌가? 헷갈렸었는데 진짜 대박이다..얘들아 너네 개쩐다
Mashiho so stable
He need more lines. Even in thier U b-track he was so stable!!!
어떻게 딸리는 멤버 하나 없이 다 잘 하냐 이건 말도 안 된다. 노래할 때 랩 할 때 다 흔들리지도 않고 진심 미쳤어 보석함 때부터 챙겨본 조용한 트메 아닌 트메인데 진심 얘넨 뜬다
이렇게 잘하는데 앵콜무대 보고싶다.. 직진 1위를 하긴했다지만 팬들앞에서 앵콜한적은 한번도 없으니까..ㅜ
Yedam's "woooo~oooo" on 0:08 always got me.
DAMN YESSSS
아니 방예담 파트 왜케 중독됨....중독성 ㄹㅇ 개쩔어
they are soooo stable we have to give them an encore stage !!!!
They are trained in YG Dungjeon so no doubt they are fr talented 🤣
Yes and the dungeon has varied menu in their canteen plus unmanned convenience store, table tennis, pool tables, etc. HAHAHAH
How can Mashiho sound exactly like in the studio ver.
Agreee
12명 다 라이브 너무 잘하는거 아님..? 라이브 진짜 저렇게 춤추고 하는거 어려운데 너무 잘하는 우리 짱래저들
Tf, yoshi always sounds like the studio version, I observed that almost all parts he is dancing but he still sounds good. Jeongwoo's voice is heaven as always, yedam as well. Treasure 2nd win lezzgo✨
여태 봐왔던 mr제거 중 완벽......
Yeah!
I knew that my boys are singing live. I just came here to listen more clearly our Treasure’s stable voiceeees. So proud ^^
Wow park Jeongwoo, Yedam
진심 개잘하고....... 걍 잘한다는 말밖에 못하겠음
걍 극호감
트레저 미래의 유망주 아이돌이다
갓예담...예담아...귀에 꿀찼다;; 랩라인도 미쳤네... 짱레져..
JeongWOOW!!!
흔들림이 없음..음원이랑 똑같음 ..전체 멤버가 다 잘해..
they are singing live eventho this is their first stage comeback after 1 year
방예담이 확실히 튼튼한 감은 있는 것 같음 ...예담이 솔로 많이 내주라...
jeongwoo stable king 👑🔥
I JUST CAN'T BELIEVE THAT THIS IS LIVE, THIS IS SO GOOD
Yoksiii YG never stop to amaze us with their mr removed
SO FUCKING STABLE WTFFFF
Treasure is that one boy group with Ateez and Seventeen that 90% sings live despite their hard choreo
I don't know if it's just me, but yedam's note is much more higher than the studio version. From the pre-chorus, it seemed really higher than the normal note.
Es más cómodo cantar más alto cuando bailas. Lo difícil es mantener la voz media.
It’s the same note from the studio version. So yeah it’s just you
It's the same note, he's just sang with more throat so sounds like the note is higher.
This is TOO GOOD??!!! ARE THEY HUMAN ???!!!!!
Yes they are human who eat CDs for breakfast.
와..이게., 진정한 mr제거지ㅠ 진짜 완벽하다 트레저 💎
Already know they are singing live when i hear yedam and junkyu parts on mcountdown stage,but just want to appreciate their live vocal so i came here!
MASHIHO VOCAL IS MORE STABLE THAN MY LIFE😭😭😭😭
와 진짜 잘하긴 진짜 잘한다
Wearing earphones and hearing Hyunsuk's "bwhooo" adlib is like another level of experience... Feels like my ears are wet suddenly😆😆
Lol😭🤣
Seriously 😂 everytime I listened to the live, it feel like he spit in my ear
0:08 got me, yes God yedam
Mashiho’s voice is so unique and stable
mashiho jg stabil bgt😭✋
와 진짜잘한다!
0:08 너무 좋다~~~ YEDAMIE
라디오 때보다 무대라이브가 좋네 ㅋㅋㅋ better than radio version just wow
As usual Mashiho stability 🔥
It's very obvious that they r singing live🤩
얼굴도 춤도 노래도 다 잘해 짱레저 💎❤️
아 너무 잘한다 진짜 제발 더 떠라 이 실력 알아야함
역시 믿고듣는 트레저
내가 이래서 YG를 못놔 우리 애들은 라이브AR이 아니라 리얼 라이브거든ㅠㅠㅠㅠㅠㅠ
1:39 I’m very amazed every time I hear yoshi hit this high note so loud and clear after all those dancing
Jeongwoo punya suara ni stable gila, klau tgok diorang perform je aku selalu contemplating dia ni live ke x, tapi bila tgok members ada je dengar live tu. Conc, suara dia sedap nak mampos makan cd kot hari2, x paham aku.
Junkyu's voice is amazing, dunno why he often not feel confident
역시 우리 보석들 너무 잘해ㅠㅠㅠ 엠알 없어도 완벽 그 자체✨
their live vocals are so stable while dancing that hard choreo 🤯
SUPER STABLE AS ALWAYS.
4TH GEN ALL ROUNDED KINGS👑💎
y'all wanna hear the encore? go and watch the mv, let's give them more wins especially inkigayo
why no one talk about how stable jihoon is
THANKS FOR THE JIHOON APPRECIATION ❤ he is so underrated :(
hes, he's one of most stable vocalist of treasure
Jeongwoo's voice is wow..i really love this boy..❤️❤️❤️
트레저 너무 완벽해❤❤ 어떻게 이렇게 잘해??
트레저 라이브 장인!!
✨Jeongwoo’s voice✨
THEIR LIVE VOCALS!!
Jeongwoo!!
역시 울레저 라이브도 대단하다 이대로 우리 트메랑 직진하자~~~
Solid!!!!!! All I can say is SOLID VOCALS AS ALWAAAAYS! TREASURE NEVER DISAPPOINTS!
Mashiho's voice is incredibly great. I Stan this man. Yes. He never fails to amaze me. Saranghae shiho!!!
But that growl of jaehyuk really got me shivers
Hard coreo, amazing vocal! Treasure!
WOW! MASHIHO'S LIVE VOCAL IS INSANE! Sooo stable as always! He deserves more lines please! 👏👏
예담이는 진짜 목소리 깔끔하다ㅠㅠ
트레저 내 마음에 직진함
UNREAL THEY'RE REALLY UNREAL-
Even in the actual (non-mr) version, we can literally hear them breathe (plus who would miss out on Hyunsuk’s emphasis on his parts aka “Jiiiikjeeewwwnnn” haha). That alone proves it’s live. This mr removed video just strengthened it. Ahhhh TREASURE OUR PRIDE!!!
I really like Junkyu and Junghwan's tune this comeback. Jaehyuk improvement im so happy for him. And their is Mashiho who sing so chill despite the choreo. Jeongwoo and Yedam's chorus is a definitely a favorite!
it's obvious without even pointing specific timestamps that they are singing live. uneven levels indicate that it's not just them recording a fake live over. i think the one thing that confuses people tho is that, idols often perform the same song several times due to camerawork. 1st recording to get main shots, 2nd time to make it look perfect on TV, and 3rd time sometimes to get all the individual member fancams (if they weren't able to get all of them in the previous two shots). that's why fancams sometimes look completely different from the live stage performance. that doesn't mean it was lipsync tho, it just means that it was edited for broadcast with the best live sound and best visual performance. that's just how kpop is - perfection is so important to them (and honestly why not when you are prerecording anyway might as well make it perfect).
^^
Junkyu so clear, stable and sounds like the CD version!!! ♥️
No seriously how is Jihoon that flawless and even better live 😭 his stability is insane 😍 Im never getting over that voice
Treasure just never disappoint when it comes to live vocals.
Yedam's "woo'ooo" is so damn good!!
도랐나 트레저 씨디 삼켰나요?..
YEDAM VOICE IS REALLY INCREDIBLE
0:20 wow jaehyuk's growl 🤯💕
I really like junkyu’s voice during pre-chorus bcos his tone is very distinct and basically added the uniqueness in their songs
What's going on with Jaehyuk tho??? He sounds so confident, growling and doing adlibs so stable, we know he's the personification of hard work we can tell hardworking is paying off. We're so proud of you Yoon Jaehyuk 👏🏻😭❤️
Damn!! How can someone's voice be this much stable!?? This is crazy af!! Definitely the vocal kings in 4th gen!!
TREASURE'S VOCAL STABILITY OUT HERE SAVING LIVES 💎
4th gen vocal kings..!!!!
stream the JIKJIN MV to hear encore
生歌良すぎるな……………さすがTREASURE実力派…………
Agak khwatir sm junkyu krna d station z kmrn suaranya lg gk bagus, tp skrg suaranya perfect bngt! Syukurlah..
I didn't realise they weren't wearing in-ear but I saw a post and I was like wow
Perfect 🥰 TEUME proud of you 👏 My TREASURE 😍🤩😘