Only music, only music is left. The singers and the Maestro are very good. Modern and megalomaniac theater directors should start digging the earth, without any mercy.
I watched this live with the same cast, except for Adela Zaharia (Gilda) who was ill or something and was replaced by Rosa Feola last minute, and the staging was mostly out of place. True is, some moments were hilarious, like the entrance of the "Duke of Reguetón" or poor Ludovic with the BDSM attire instead of the typical multicolour joker look, and the way the Duke and Maddalena interact is pure sitcom. The twerking women and "nude dancers" were too intrusive though, especially in "Caro nome" aria.
I actually liked the production and the color scheme. Camarena sounds pretty good here, Tezier was superb, one of his best performances this year (even better than his Scarpia and Don Carlo) Adela Zaharia was a wonderful Gilda . Well done!
Well you obviously have a tin ear (you call this 'me---e' good singing? The singers are shouting, off key or straining in many cases. ........ and visually you are blind to say this is a good physical production. It is so bad, the worst Rigoletto I've ever seen.
Gracias OV y Teatro Real. A mi si me gustó la conducción de Luisotti. Muy buena Gilda. El resto de voces, sin comentarios. Alfredo Kraus un fantástico duque de Mantua. Gracias❤❤❤
Que puestas en escena son esas???, eso es denigrante.....la ópera debe ser como la pensaron sus escritores, no esas cosas modernistas que se les ocurren ahora....
@@joancarlestomas Sinceramente, una cosa es cosas nuevas e interesantes y otra ese conjunto de bailarinas que parece que están perreando con la música de Rigoletto. Lamentable
Regie come questa, completamente senza senso, estranee alle indicazioni del libretto, compromettono oltre quella visiva anche la parte musicale, che cantanti pur all'altezza del compito - nel contesto - sono assai spaesati. Regista incompetente che andrebbe allontanato dai palcoscenici lirici per il bene del Melodramma.
Quieren estirar tanto la cuerda del "performance" hasta que se rompe y genera un ruido visual con tal amplitud que obliga a ignorarlo para solo apreciar por separado únicamente la genuina belleza original de la música y las voces.
È inguardabile, disgustoso, rivoltante, degradante! Che peccato per tanti talenti nel cast! Ma lo fanno apposta, o sono diventati incapaci di fare meglio? Perché è permesso?
Possono avere le voci più belle possibili, ma con una regia così orribile non ci sono parole o commenti da fare....Il cosiddetto regista non ha minimamente letto il libretto, il risultato è una porcheria...
Non hanno neanche voci bellissime - Come diciamo in inglese.... their voices are very average and not comparable to great singers I have heard on disc in the past.
@@michelegiovetti6678 Lavoro nell'ambiente musicale, sinceramente mi sono termovalorizzato gli attributi a forza di vedere "regie" che definire terrificanti è eufemismo. Leggere il libretto, basta poco, eppure, è questa ne è l'ennesima pessima occasione persa, si vedono stravolgimenti simili...chissà perché nella prosa si fa molto meno...
Les chanteurs sont très bons !!! Ludovic Tezeir est le plus grand baryton de son époque et un des meilleurs artistes lyriques du moment. Encore un grand bravo et merci à Verdi. Par contre il faut interner en asile psy avant qu’il fasse une bêtise. C’est un grand malade. Et en plus il a du coûter énormément d’argent à la production.
Well, thanks Opera Vision for the rebroadcast. At one point I just started listening, without looking. However no matter how vicious the Duke of Mantua may be, the "visualization" of his depravity (through the choreographic vision) was a bit too much. The orchestra, the performers and the sublime music of Verdi ignited my imagination and I "saw" Rigoletto in its own version.
Is it me or is the whole thing very slow. The playing just sags. Camarena is a marvelous singer but seems out of sorts here. Rigoletto is such a good opera but this was painful to watch and listen too
This is a totally disgusting production with a solidly stupid director (Miguel del Arco) who has injected his own personal view into Rigoletto disregarding what is in the libretto or in the music. Making Gilda this totally different young woman is so alien to me that I finaally turned off this piece of rubbish that has me angry and seeing red. Verdi must be rolling over in his grave. I will admit IL DUCA DI MANTUA is a monster and most don't see him as a very evil man because of the glorious music Verdi gives him to sing. But what was Verdi supposed to do? Give him bad music to sing! If directors/people in general were bright they would insist to look carefully at every word uttered by the Duca to understand what a rotten scoundrel he really is. Further, the design of Rigoletto's costume in the prologue: it's silly and disgusting. It makes Ludovic Tézier (Rigoletto), a very physically unfit singer. look like a fat old woman with flabby arms. Even the singing is not first rate compared to the singers I have heard on disc from past years. I might be a bit green compared to older viewers, but I can judge for myself what I like visually or what is pleasant to me aurally. And this production of Rigoletto is a "0". I stayed with the opera until after Gilda's appearance to make sure I was correct in my opinioon that this is NOT good singing and that the set is offensive. The end of the prologue with all those writhing girations is yet another insult to the eyes. I'm leaving during the Rigoletto/Gilda duet in Act I. I'm missing nothing.
Not bad, but I like more the previous performance of Rigoletto, which Opera vision was streaming almost 3 years ago from Al Gran Teatre del Liceu Singers where better, maybe except for the singer who sings the title role, and that performance was more exciting for me.
I really liked the way the character of Rigoletto sounds in Ludovic Tezier's voice. I respect the work of the stage design, but I don't like to see operas with modernisms that are out of step with the original libretto. They should study the librettos carefully to create a stage setting and costumes with modern resources and not make the opera out of place and time.
Rigoletto is an opera about the power of men over women. It is an evil play and Verdi shows these abysses very clearly. However, if a director wants to show this by turning women into objects on stage and letting them walk around naked, it backfires.
Osée mise-en-scène. Excellentissime distribution, même pour à certains moments tant offrir. Sublime maîtrise. Mais l'osé de la mise-en-scène prend une sorte de revanche à la toute fin. Ou bien nous jette à la figure l'insensé de beaucoup de nos insolences. Mais il y en a plein que le vide attire. Reconnu médical ou pas, le vide attire.
La produccion no me gusta ...la opera una maravilla... Rigoletto bien... Gilda buen y el Duca solo correcto...el rol no le va en exceso...a parte q no es el Camarena de hace 8 o 10 años ...ha bajado un poquito ...el fiato no es el mismo y esos agudos fáciles y rutilantes ...han bajado enteros.
Truly one of the worst productions of a professionally staged opera I have ever seen. Kept with it hoping the singing or the conducting would salvage the staging. Was not to be.
This is why I prefer concert performances more and more.
Tezier is one of the best Rigolettos I've ever heard
Only music, only music is left. The singers and the Maestro are very good. Modern and megalomaniac theater directors should start digging the earth, without any mercy.
I watched this live with the same cast, except for Adela Zaharia (Gilda) who was ill or something and was replaced by Rosa Feola last minute, and the staging was mostly out of place. True is, some moments were hilarious, like the entrance of the "Duke of Reguetón" or poor Ludovic with the BDSM attire instead of the typical multicolour joker look, and the way the Duke and Maddalena interact is pure sitcom. The twerking women and "nude dancers" were too intrusive though, especially in "Caro nome" aria.
@alejandrotm 😊👍
Teziers singing simply magnificent. Some singing of arias as good as Titto Gobbi
Whoever cast this production got it right. 💕
nice
GOT IT WRONG is more like it!
yum
I actually liked the production and the color scheme. Camarena sounds pretty good here, Tezier was superb, one of his best performances this year (even better than his Scarpia and Don Carlo) Adela Zaharia was a wonderful Gilda . Well done!
Well you obviously have a tin ear (you call this 'me---e' good singing? The singers are shouting, off key or straining in many cases. ........ and visually you are blind to say this is a good physical production. It is so bad, the worst Rigoletto I've ever seen.
@@peterdevita6308 better a tin ear than a tin brain...
@@peterdevita6308 better a tin ear than a tin brain
Gracias por la retransmisión 🤗🥰🎼🎄
Magnifico Tezier!!!!!! 👏🏻👏🏻👏🏻👏🏻👏🏻👏🏻👏🏻👏🏻👏🏻👏🏻👏🏻👏🏻👏🏻👏🏻👏🏻👏🏻👏🏻👏🏻👏🏻👏🏻👏🏻👏🏻👏🏻
Это было прекрасно! Риголетто и Джильда восхитительны! Очень современная и завораживающая постановка
how dare the author of this version dare profane such a sublime artistic musical opera into a dirty and pornographic peice of rubbish
BRAVO 👏 👏 👏 Ludovic Tézier ❤❤❤SYMPLY THE BEST!!!
@@judithvogt4128 nice to see you here as well as on instagram Judith haha :)
Gracias OV y Teatro Real. A mi si me gustó la conducción de Luisotti. Muy buena Gilda. El resto de voces, sin comentarios. Alfredo Kraus un fantástico duque de Mantua. Gracias❤❤❤
Fantastisch Ludovic🩷 Liebe Grūsse an Dich, Mascha.
He's not too good as Rigoletto in this production.
@@maschamueller4643 This is Not Rigoletto 👎👎👎
Verdi's music is amazing!. Voices are beautiful!, But staging is awful, dances are so vulgar!
È inguardabile, disgustoso, rivoltante, degradante!
Parece más el teatro chino de Manolita Chen que a una ópera 😢😢😢😢
Que puestas en escena son esas???, eso es denigrante.....la ópera debe ser como la pensaron sus escritores, no esas cosas modernistas que se les ocurren ahora....
Qué aburrimiento das, en serio. Menos mal que en los teatros no os hacen caso, y así tenemos cosas nuevas e interesantes para ver
Disfruta un poco
@@joancarlestomas Sinceramente, una cosa es cosas nuevas e interesantes y otra ese conjunto de bailarinas que parece que están perreando con la música de Rigoletto. Lamentable
I didn't expect a Teatro Real Madrid production to be so disgusting and horrible
Ridícula producciónSe cagaron en Verdi🥵
Como permiten al Sr del Arco hacer semejante porqueria. Un espanto. Denigra la opera este Sr.
In queste scene é difficile riconoscere l´opera il Rigoletto come ancheil baritono grande voce ma lontano dal buffone
Escuchar las voces de estos cantantes en CD, perfecto. Pero la producción es un bodrio insoportable. Malísima.
Un espanto de puesta en escena
Wonderful voice Gilda! ❤
Regie come questa, completamente senza senso, estranee alle indicazioni del libretto, compromettono oltre quella visiva anche la parte musicale, che cantanti pur all'altezza del compito - nel contesto - sono assai spaesati. Regista incompetente che andrebbe allontanato dai palcoscenici lirici per il bene del Melodramma.
I think Zaharia was well above Camarena. She has such a control over her superb voice!!
Quieren estirar tanto la cuerda del "performance" hasta que se rompe y genera un ruido visual con tal amplitud que obliga a ignorarlo para solo apreciar por separado únicamente la genuina belleza original de la música y las voces.
Great cast and conducting! Horrible production!
Thank You so much.
È inguardabile, disgustoso, rivoltante, degradante! Che peccato per tanti talenti nel cast! Ma lo fanno apposta, o sono diventati incapaci di fare meglio? Perché è permesso?
Buhahahahah
Thank you from Budapest. Sorry for my idiot prime minister.
@blackmonsterhu hang in there chief!
Possono avere le voci più belle possibili, ma con una regia così orribile non ci sono parole o commenti da fare....Il cosiddetto regista non ha minimamente letto il libretto, il risultato è una porcheria...
Parole Sante! Una regia completamente sbagliata! Mai visto il libretto e men che meno la partitura!
Non hanno neanche voci bellissime - Come diciamo in inglese.... their voices are very average and not comparable to great singers I have heard on disc in the past.
@@60bui ahahahahahaha adoroooo
@@michelegiovetti6678 Lavoro nell'ambiente musicale, sinceramente mi sono termovalorizzato gli attributi a forza di vedere "regie" che definire terrificanti è eufemismo. Leggere il libretto, basta poco, eppure, è questa ne è l'ennesima pessima occasione persa, si vedono stravolgimenti simili...chissà perché nella prosa si fa molto meno...
Bravo!
Fabulosa representación! Bravo!
Allestimento pessimo non degno di alcun commento
Hanno offeso il Genio di Verdi
Ormai il pubblico di oggi accetta tutto
@@salvatore_3968 🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣
Horrible stage and acting....why is sex and porn on the stage? 😢
@@michaelbuchmann5886 because Rigoletto is an opera about sexual abuse. It's sad if you didn't notice it
Teatro Real is in Madrid, Spain.
La voz del duque es más tirante y debe cubrir más los concertantes. La voz de Camarena no es para este rol.
Les chanteurs sont très bons !!! Ludovic Tezeir est le plus grand baryton de son époque et un des meilleurs artistes lyriques du moment. Encore un grand bravo et merci à Verdi. Par contre il faut interner en asile psy avant qu’il fasse une bêtise. C’est un grand malade. Et en plus il a du coûter énormément d’argent à la production.
Je parle du metteur en scène
Well, thanks Opera Vision for the rebroadcast.
At one point I just started listening, without looking. However
no matter how vicious the Duke of Mantua may be, the "visualization" of his depravity (through the choreographic vision) was a bit too much. The orchestra, the performers and the sublime music of Verdi ignited my imagination and I "saw" Rigoletto in its own version.
It's disgusting.
Is it me or is the whole thing very slow. The playing just sags. Camarena is a marvelous singer but seems out of sorts here. Rigoletto is such a good opera but this was painful to watch and listen too
Rigoletto is not a demanding opera for anyone? I wonder what the principal singers would have to say about that.
Rigolleto in drag!!!! I'm otta here...
Elencazo. Qué pena la puesta esa horrenda. Olvidable. Es para escuchar sin ver.
This is a totally disgusting production with a solidly stupid director (Miguel del Arco) who has injected his own personal view into Rigoletto disregarding what is in the libretto or in the music.
Making Gilda this totally different young woman is so alien to me that I finaally turned off this piece of rubbish that has me angry and seeing red. Verdi must be rolling over in his grave. I will admit IL DUCA DI MANTUA is a monster and most don't see him as a very evil man because of the glorious music Verdi gives him to sing. But what was Verdi supposed to do? Give him bad music to sing! If directors/people in general were bright they would insist to look carefully at every word uttered by the Duca to understand what a rotten scoundrel he really is. Further, the design of Rigoletto's costume in the prologue: it's silly and disgusting. It makes Ludovic Tézier (Rigoletto), a very physically unfit singer. look like a fat old woman with flabby arms. Even the singing is not first rate compared to the singers I have heard on disc from past years. I might be a bit green compared to older viewers, but I can judge for myself what I like visually or what is pleasant to me aurally. And this production of Rigoletto is a "0". I stayed with the opera until after Gilda's appearance to make sure I was correct in my opinioon that this is NOT good singing and that the set is offensive. The end of the prologue with all those writhing girations is yet another insult to the eyes. I'm leaving during the Rigoletto/Gilda duet in Act I. I'm missing nothing.
I saw it al and I agree fully to what you say.
Che schifo !!
¡Gracias! ¡Muchas gracias!
❤
GRACIAS POR NADA.
What a great cast!!!!!! Love it! ❤
Orchestra and singers 10/10 the rest ridiculous
Qué manera de ensuciar una ópera, imposible para los ojos
Miguel del Arco, think of another job. You are definitely not a director.
Bravoooooo!!! Viva Verdiiiiii
Not bad, but I like more the previous performance of Rigoletto, which Opera vision was streaming almost 3 years ago from Al Gran Teatre del Liceu
Singers where better, maybe except for the singer who sings the title role, and that performance was more exciting for me.
La producción anterior del Teatro Real,sin ser una maravilla,era mucho más interesante. De ésta hasta los colores me dan prurito.
im tingling right now
Camarena not for this roll.
Si si con todo el respeto del mundo pero Miguel del Arco a la mierda
I really liked the way the character of Rigoletto sounds in Ludovic Tezier's voice. I respect the work of the stage design, but I don't like to see operas with modernisms that are out of step with the original libretto. They should study the librettos carefully to create a stage setting and costumes with modern resources and not make the opera out of place and time.
От Камарены я ожидал большего,неужели он закончился. Где его знаменитые верхние ноты..
❤
Que horror de producción.
En fin solo las voces valen la pena..
The role of Duke is not for Camarena…
Es un desastre
Rigoletto is an opera about the power of men over women. It is an evil play and Verdi shows these abysses very clearly. However, if a director wants to show this by turning women into objects on stage and letting them walk around naked, it backfires.
Ich bin dabei.
it's going to get good...i can tell
Osée mise-en-scène. Excellentissime distribution, même pour à certains moments tant offrir. Sublime maîtrise. Mais l'osé de la mise-en-scène prend une sorte de revanche à la toute fin. Ou bien nous jette à la figure l'insensé de beaucoup de nos insolences. Mais il y en a plein que le vide attire. Reconnu médical ou pas, le vide attire.
👏🏾👏🏾👏🏾👏🏾👏🏾👏🏾👏🏾👏🏾
La produccion no me gusta ...la opera una maravilla... Rigoletto bien... Gilda buen y el Duca solo correcto...el rol no le va en exceso...a parte q no es el Camarena de hace 8 o 10 años ...ha bajado un poquito ...el fiato no es el mismo y esos agudos fáciles y rutilantes ...han bajado enteros.
Well I'm sorry Rigoletto needs far more rigor and vigor..and Gilda..a no from me.
Beautiful ❤❤❤❤❤
The production is antidemocratic, because extras are naked and the main singers aren´t. It should be exactly the opposite.
Ein wundervoller Abend! Vielen lieben Dank an alle Beteiligten!
Прекрасно👏👏👏
I don’t like the bariton role interpretation.
Truly one of the worst productions of a professionally staged opera I have ever seen. Kept with it hoping the singing or the conducting would salvage the staging. Was not to be.
Such an ugly production!
What a complete disaster! Horrible singers and aweful production… orchestra and conductor can’t save it, because it is opera!
Very poor production and appalling singing.
Pauvre Tézier, toujours à la ramasse avec son intonation et son jeu d'acteur.
Sembra scorrere tutto bene. Vero che Rigoletto è un'opera non impegnativa per nessuno, comunque niente male