Discourse Analysis Part 2: Foucauldian Approaches
HTML-код
- Опубликовано: 8 июн 2024
- From a lecture given in 2015 by Graham R Gibbs at the University of Huddersfield.
This second session examines the ideas behind a Foucauldian Discourse Analysis and draws also on some ideas from Critical Discourse Analysis. The distinctive contributions of Michel Foucault's approach are discussed before some of the key ways of carrying out a Foucauldian analysis are examined. The session ends with a brief discussion of some of the criticisms of both Foucauldian and Psychological discourse analysis.
Sounds and music: 'Fifth Avenue Stroll' from iLife Sound Effects,
images.apple.com/legal/sla/doc...
Images: Freizeitanlage Kräwinklerbrücke, Kräwinklerbrücke in Remscheid
by Frank Vincentz, Wikimedia Commons, licensed under the
Creative Commons Attribution-Share Alike 3.0 Unported license.
Michel Foucault, from Wikipedia from Exeter Centre for Advanced International
Studies Research Priorities under fair use.
en.wikipedia.org/wiki/File:Fou...
References
Hall, S. (1992). The West and the Rest in Hall, S., & Gieben, B. (Eds.). (1992). Formations of modernity (p. 1275). Cambridge: Polity Press.
Edley, N. (2001). Analysing masculinity: Interpretative repertoires, ideological dilemmas and subject positions. In Wetherell, M, Taylor, S. and Yates, S. J (Eds) Discourse as data: A guide for analysis, 189-228.
Parker, I (1992) Discourse Dynamics: Critical Analysis for Social and Individual Psychology, London: Routledge
I'm an undergraduate psychology student and currently writing a proposal assignment for an experiment stemming from Foucault's approach. This video was so helpful. Thank you.
I'm doing my first Uni essay on discourse analysis and I was so lost, thank goodness I found your videos!!!!
I'm so grateful that I've found this fantastic lecture. Thank you so much. I've taken a lot out of this in preparing for my phd 1st year review. I'm using Foucault's theories about power, discourse, and knowledge to explore the concept of compassion in the NHS. Fascinating work, especially using Foucault's oeuvre. This stimulated my thinking in the early stages of my reading. Thanks again.
It is a rare talent indeed that enables one to deliver a lecture about Foucault and make his philosophy sound positively sensible. Thank you for sharing!
Gibbs' rendition of Foucauldian discourse analysis compensates for the utter lack of relatability and concision in the original author's treatises on the subject. Along with Gibbs' lecture on discursive psychology, this is a must-watch for anyone struggling to navigate a realm of thought that might otherwise remain hopelessly inaccessible.
Just thrilled by this detailed lecture. Was struggling very long with this topic. Finally came to the satisfaction level. Thank you so much sir for your benevolent work.
I m overjoyed to watch this helpful video ......thanks
Fantastic lecture. Thank you so much for putting it online, very helpful!
Hi, i found this video very pleasant to watch. It was very clear, very detailed, not overwhelming and above all very well delivered and helpful. Thanks.
Thank you very much sir
CONCISE, PRECISE and TO THE POINT
Marvellously helpful. Tremendous to have such a wonderful teaching tool free to all. Much appreciated.
Thank you very much sir for this act of kindness
Very helpful. Thank you so much for your time. Helped me better digest my readings a little better. Please don't stop helping us in this way.
Thank you~ This lecture is really well- structured and extremely helpful!
You're a bloody legend, Graham. Thank you for this brilliant video.
Thank you very much Dr Graham for uploading this video. I had a great time watching and understanding your lecture.
extremely useful and practical, thank you!
Thank you so much for this. You have an excellent way of explaining Foucault with clarity and precision.
Can we use this on movies ?
really clear and concise explanation, thank you so much so helpful!
Thank you for giving clear explanations, really helpful for me to understand the concepts because sometimes the books are very hard to understand.. Thank you very much!!
Thank you very much for preparing this video. It was very helpful.
Thanks a lot Dr Graham for preparing this video. Its really interesting and useful.
Thank you so much for an extremely helpful explanation.
Extremely helpful, thank you!
Thank you very much for the hard work! I have much clearer understanding of discourse analysis now :)
This has been extremely useful, thank you!
I was struggling to read arch. of knowledge, this really helped!
Exactly what I needed. Thanks!
Dr. Graham Gibbs,
These are great videos you are making and taking from your time to do them for free is a generous thing of you. I learned a lot from all the case study videos you made as I'm now working now on my case study research that is actually semi-structure interviews. I've only little question, do you think when writing my paper the " Finding " section can be discussed in the discussion section or do I have to the finding in a separate section of its own as I see some literature some papers they put it inside the discussion and some put it outside. What is your recommendation or view about this?
Thanks
@Yaser Hadi: so how is your research, sir?
Dear Graham, That was extremely useful and interesting. I am watching your videos for my thesis right now
+Jorge Ramiro Pérez
Hi Jorge, wot are you writing about?
Or wot have you written about?
Mine is about CDA on political speeches focusing on the relational value of personal pronouns.
Hi soxan. I would be interested in reading your work :)
Soxan S. I would also be quite interested in reading that :)
Thank you! Greetings from York University (TO)!
thanks a lot Dr. Gibbs. this is extremely helpful.
Thanks very much for this clarifying lecture!
Thanks for the video. It really helped me understand the content.
very insightful presentation about an obscure system of theories
Thank you so much for this video!
This is a great lecture!
This was so so helpful! thank you
A very helpful lecture.. I'm profoundly grateful
Excelent video, it helped me a lot, thanks!!!
Thank you very much indeed for this video! Could you make one about Discourse markers please??
Thank you!
Really enjoyable! Thank you!
Thanks you, very good overview.
thank you for this video
Thank you! :)
Thanks, this is very helpful.
Thanks for this excelent video
Currently writing a dissertation on discourse surrounding the vegan lifestyle, thank you so much for this.
Thanks for summing that up ;)
thank you! so helpful!
you just saved the day !
Thank you, Thank you.
Life saver !
Absolutely fantastic and invaluable video; particularly for new students. Thank you so much for sharing!
Thank u :)
thaNks for the videos. Why are you not uploading any new videos?
Is there anyone who have some literature on a FDA being carried out on visual images? Currently writing a paper, and am only able to find a source in German, which is not my strong side...
me too....need them so bad
how and why discourse analysis is considered as multivoiced
Dear Graham,
I was wondering wether you think it possible to use a Foucauldian DA approach to analyze a large amount of Facebook comments (800) on a Facebook post to see how identified discourses shape and form a person's or organization's brand?
Sincerely,
S.
One of my PhD students has done something very similar. He used Foucauldian DA to analyse photos from websites (actually about food banks). He too had several hundred images, but he use a coding process to classify the images (by topic and by discursive act) in order to pre-process the data and make it more manageable. You might think about doing the same for the comments you are analysing. The key is to identify the discursive acts or concepts that the comments represent.
@@GrahamRGibbs Thank you for your answer, Graham! It is much appreciated. I am unsure of what "discursive acts" is though, and can't seem to find much about it when searching online. Is it like speech acts?
Always faucauld is difficult for me
But, is this a correct interpretation of Foucault's work? Derek hook (2001) in "Discourse, knowledge, materiality, history; Foucault and discourse analysis" doesn't think so: "Discourse analysis has come to represent something of a ‘growth industry’ in both research and critical psychology. Despite the apparent indebtedness of many such methods of discourse analysis to Foucault, there exists no strictly Foucauldian method of analysing discourse."
Could it be that Parker (1992) has (mis)appropriated the Foucauldian understanding of discourse by going into the meaning of the sign and the psychology of the subject instead of sticking to the level of the statement?
Foucault's Achaeology of Knowledge seeks to describe discourses in the conditions of their emergence and transformation rather than in their deeper, hidden meaning, their propositional or logical content, or their expression of an individual or collective psychology. Archeological analysis studies discourse only at its level of positive existence, and never takes discourse to be a trace or record of something outside of itself.
Of course, there are many different interpretations of Foucault and Hook's is one of them. Your 'growth industry' point is one that Hook himself makes in his article. In this video I was more concerned to show what was distinctly different from discursive psychology in Foucault's approach. I certainly want to avoid claiming that I have offered a definitive and 'correct' account of Foucault's work, although what I have said is a fairly common interpretation.
thank you! this was very helpful.
so helpful, thank you!