I think it's pretty fair to say that ITZY is equal in any sense 😭 every member has showcased their vocal, rap, and dance, and each one of them has their own song to shine, which means ITZY isn't just a group, is a legend
@@marshall2049 I got it from standard deviation. I did the method similar to ultimatekpop but they basically do the calculation of the standard deviation divided by the mean. The mean is all of the members’ percentages inside the song divided by the number of members inside the group or the number of members who participated inside the song.
Can we appreciate how much hard work @kstat puts in to give us these? Think about how long this would take to work out let alone making that format at editing everything and making it pretty. Thank you!!!!
given this is shared over 9 albums/EPs and a handful of singles its damn impressive how good Itzy line distributions are you can always be sure each member will shine in every song
Yeah , everyone has been first at least once and their positions are respected. (Probably except chaeryeong who never got dance break despite being main dancer) but they still all shine anyway
Even though my bias is Yuna and ofc it kinda hurts to see her at the bottom, I still have to say, this line distribution is straight up perfect and the ones with the little lines are still very much noticeable (to be fair, that's much easier for a 5 member group than for example one with 9 members
Yeji thought she was home safe at the end but she got ROBBED 😂😂😂😂😂 I love how there’s not half a screens worth of difference in the vocals to the rap. Most groups either have a lot more vocals or a lot more rap❤
I think its pretty fair! 1. they all get to shine 2. their positions are respected 3. they get to showcase why their position is vocalist or rapper 4. they get to showcase all their skills _(ex. if they dont have the rapper position they still get to showcase their rapping skills)_ + the vocalists are at the top
@no4528 plus why would anyone listen to you about factual things, you are obsessed with hating on bahiyyih for something that wasn't her fault and ignore all logic.
1) Main vocalist, sub rapper 2) Lead vocalist (treated as main), sub rapper 3) Vocalist (treated as lead), sub rapper 4) Main rapper, sub vocalist 5) Lead rapper, sub vocalist
@@Robalexe No, maybe I explained it to you badly Did you listen in b-side Bet on me,None my business, Psychic lover,Bratty(?)? I don't intend "have more line" but the way how she sang the verse
@@lucreziadamilano7445 She only has one genuine vocal line in each one of those songs, but even if that's not important here, the way she sings those verses is not at all lead vocalist-esque. All of them ride on her more sensual lower tone, JYP almost exclusively uses her vocals for that purpose. When there's a line that requires that kind of voice, they give it to Ryujin, cuz she's the one that can sound like that, and that's about it.
I hope all groups has same itzy line distribution the gap of first and last isn't huge and it is according to their position ❤🎉 now Itzy never join the Twice, Blackpink, Aespa at Ive trend were Lead Vocals sing too much (Rosé is actually first including hard to love) (still hoping Ningning and Liz will be on top) (Twice i feel all once gonna die but Nayeon still on top) back to itzy line distribution is fair but some songs are annoying
just a tip, cuz ur the pro here, but I think you should add more categories to the fairness chart at the end, because if you call le sserafim very unequal, then I'm sorry, but WHAT THE HELL IS EVERGLOW
Itzy has the fairest line distributions ever! Ever member gets their time to shine in every song! I love it! Of course Lia+Yeji are getting more lines, as the rest, but they’re the two best vocalists of the group… It's fair. Chaeryeong who is the 3rd best vocalists gets the 3rd most lines. And Yuna+Ryujin, who aren’t that good at singing and better at rapping, are getting the least lines… It’s completely fine.
![ITZY ~ All Songs Line Distribution [from DALLA DALLA to RINGO]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/yGYgMOI0p2U/mqdefault.jpg)
![ITZY ~ All Songs Line Distribution [from DALLA DALLA to RINGO]](/img/tr.png)
![ITZY ~ All Songs Line Distribution [from DALLA DALLA to BORN TO BE]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/9-b46ngNjyY/mqdefault.jpg)
I think it's pretty fair to say that ITZY is equal in any sense 😭 every member has showcased their vocal, rap, and dance, and each one of them has their own song to shine, which means ITZY isn't just a group, is a legend
Average/Line Distribution per song
Lia: 37.2 | 22.6%
Yeji: 36.6 | 22.3%
Chaeryeong: 31.7 | 19.3%
Ryujin: 29.5 | 17.9%
Yuna: 29.4 | 17.9%
Variation: 11.6%
its so fair
@@w.g.m7029mhm
How to calculate the variation?
@@marshall2049 I got it from standard deviation. I did the method similar to ultimatekpop but they basically do the calculation of the standard deviation divided by the mean. The mean is all of the members’ percentages inside the song divided by the number of members inside the group or the number of members who participated inside the song.
@@philip0w0hoang give me an example with explanation pls
Lia and Yeji were neck to neck until Psychic lover came! 😂
Rip yeji's 13 seconds HAHSHSHSHSS
In the album spoiler, I thought she was going to have 40-50 seconds worth of lines in that song, but she has less lines 😭
me Too I Thought Yeji Will Get Most Lines
*Yeji and Lia fighting for 1st place*
*Yuna and Ryujin Fighting for 4th place*
Chaeryoung: *Still Chaeryoung*
Can we appreciate how much hard work @kstat puts in to give us these? Think about how long this would take to work out let alone making that format at editing everything and making it pretty. Thank you!!!!
right!!!
The final line distribution is really fair. It’s suited to their positions and all members shine in ever category at least once (vocals rap and dance)
given this is shared over 9 albums/EPs and a handful of singles its damn impressive how good Itzy line distributions are
you can always be sure each member will shine in every song
Yeah , everyone has been first at least once and their positions are respected. (Probably except chaeryeong who never got dance break despite being main dancer) but they still all shine anyway
Lia mainvocalist is back in this album
Even though my bias is Yuna and ofc it kinda hurts to see her at the bottom, I still have to say, this line distribution is straight up perfect and the ones with the little lines are still very much noticeable (to be fair, that's much easier for a 5 member group than for example one with 9 members
Lia vs Yeji
Ryujin vs Yuna
Chaeryoung: *Still her natural self*
Fun fact : Whenever ryujin get most lines in a song, it becomes one of the fairest line distribution in itzy discography
yea they never wanna make an exception for her and give her more for once
yuna*
Yeji thought she was home safe at the end but she got ROBBED 😂😂😂😂😂 I love how there’s not half a screens worth of difference in the vocals to the rap. Most groups either have a lot more vocals or a lot more rap❤
Yeji & Lia: 🤬💥🗯💢💥🤬😡🤬
Ryujin: 🫤 What is she doing?
Yuna: I. WILL. PASS. YOU!! 😭
Chaeryeong: 😴😴😴😴😴
i mean they are perfectly fine.. the gap🏆between yeji and lia + ryujin and yuna is amazing.. chaeryoung doesn't have nothing to worry
Very fair imo. Lia and yeji being the best vocalists makes sense to be 1st and 2nd
It is so fair that the difference between the total lines of Yuna and that of Lía is only 4.4%
thank u for ur hard work, really love these stats!
I think its pretty fair!
1. they all get to shine
2. their positions are respected
3. they get to showcase why their position is vocalist or rapper
4. they get to showcase all their skills _(ex. if they dont have the rapper position they still get to showcase their rapping skills)_
+ the vocalists are at the top
0:51 is best
No one:
Lia and Yeji in Cheshire to KMD: ⬆️⬇️⬆️⬇️
All of Kill Shot line distribution were wrong, so I hope someone would do the correct distribution, also Bratty
How do you know they were all wrong? Did you count it yourself? And even then, if everyone has the same but yours isn't, are you sure yours is right?
@@gamerxarmymultistan no, just watch the the performance, they count the last chorus wrong
@no4528 if everyone has seen that and has their video the way it is, maybe they are right and you have missed something/ are wrong
@no4528 plus why would anyone listen to you about factual things, you are obsessed with hating on bahiyyih for something that wasn't her fault and ignore all logic.
@@gamerxarmymultistan why are you crying about Bahiyyih lmfao 🤣??? I didn't even mention her
Ryujin is 2nd while Yeji is 3rd in Cake
I had seen otherwise and therefore think otherwise but what I saw could be incorrect. In what I had seen ryujin was 3rd but it could be wrong
@@gamerxarmymultistanwatch random_k
@@gamerxarmymultistanYes you're pretty sure to be wrong
@asianindigs 💀 I had seen otherwise and therefore think otherwise but what I saw could be incorrect. Is that better?
@@gamerxarmymultistanthen you're still doubting in that case to be so-called "pretty sure" 💀
Yess queens
I just commented to your video dalla dalla to bet on me asking you to make dalla dalla to cake a few hours ago😳
This is so fair wtf
hello, and how do you calculate the percentage in "variance"? 7:49
1) Main vocalist, sub rapper
2) Lead vocalist (treated as main), sub rapper
3) Vocalist (treated as lead), sub rapper
4) Main rapper, sub vocalist
5) Lead rapper, sub vocalist
JYP has started to treat Ryujin as almost as Lead Vocalist
@@lucreziadamilano7445 No he hasn't, Chaeryeong gets way more vocal lines than Ryujin. They're not even comparable to Lia and Yeji in that regard.
@@Robalexe No, maybe I explained it to you badly
Did you listen in b-side Bet on me,None my business, Psychic lover,Bratty(?)?
I don't intend "have more line" but the way how she sang the verse
@@lucreziadamilano7445 She only has one genuine vocal line in each one of those songs, but even if that's not important here, the way she sings those verses is not at all lead vocalist-esque. All of them ride on her more sensual lower tone, JYP almost exclusively uses her vocals for that purpose. When there's a line that requires that kind of voice, they give it to Ryujin, cuz she's the one that can sound like that, and that's about it.
did anyone notice that from 1:19 to 1:42 they were ranked according to their age
And we have people saying yuna is severely mistreated. :') Isnt ryujin v close to Yuna and Chaeryeong not far away?
I hope all groups has same itzy line distribution the gap of first and last isn't huge and it is according to their position ❤🎉 now Itzy never join the Twice, Blackpink, Aespa at Ive trend were Lead Vocals sing too much (Rosé is actually first including hard to love) (still hoping Ningning and Liz will be on top) (Twice i feel all once gonna die but Nayeon still on top) back to itzy line distribution is fair but some songs are annoying
Yeji still has more lines than Lia tho
@@illegaluser69 why?
Why was the last part necessary
@@illegaluser69 cause her voice suits their songs more (not all ofc)
@@illegaluser69you're right ruclips.net/video/Rc9suNm0Rw4/видео.html
just a tip, cuz ur the pro here, but I think you should add more categories to the fairness chart at the end, because if you call le sserafim very unequal, then I'm sorry, but WHAT THE HELL IS EVERGLOW
Please can you make updated stats for TREASURE too?
It's true that the distribution is fair, but RYUJIN should be in second place since ITZY's songs are based on rap, and she is a rapper.
And at the end it shows their vocal abilities from best to not the best
Lia
Yeji
Chaeryeong
Ryujin/Yuna
What about rap then?
@@gamerxarmymultistan from the bottom to the top ig? I was just saying, since most of their songs are vocal based
Itzy is more of a vocal group so it makes sense for the rappers to have less lines. But this is a very fair discography considering other groups.
this is very fair when you know their positions
yuna 1st on kill shot? wow
Lol the Line distribution of kill shot is wrong
The battle between Yeji and Lia continues
What's your guys favorite bside? Mine is
Love is
Psychic lover
@@zjemcikosiarke203 nice!
Psychic Lover
@@ImNOTToxicUare cool!
chillin chillin & TING TING TING 🥹🥹
He also forgot purple kiss, they released Cabin Fever with Sweet Juice and Into Violet with the japanese song Tonari.
I love it
Do u have one for ONEUS ??
Just as a suggestion, can you do Saturday line distribution?
It's actually pretty fair, especially when you compare itzy with other groups
Yeji: I’m gonna beat you Lia just wai-
Psychic Lover starts playing*
Yeji: Shoot
ruclips.net/video/Rc9suNm0Rw4/видео.html
Yeji is still first 😮
Poor Yuna
it's really a constant competition between first and second and fourth and fifth lol
Can you make Treasure version from Going Crazy until Reboot Album
The Yuna lines going slowly down show Itzy’s decrease in good music. Love the girls HATE the new music 💔
CAN YOU MAKE ONE WITH SEVENTEEN PLSS❤❤❤
Hi
Can you plz make one video for ONEUS ...... I'm new fan of them 💜💙💗💛💚
Can you do treasure?
it's cake wrong ryujin more than yeji
Plz do raniaaaa or aoa!!!!
WHY EVERYTIME MY BIAS HAS THE LEAST LINES!?
Ryujin is 2nd in cake not yeji
9,6%?
There reason why midzy don't fight for line
Itzy are the Queen and the most perfect girl group
Now i better not here someone say they dont get fair lines lmao
cake is wrong
Itzy has the fairest line distributions ever! Ever member gets their time to shine in every song! I love it!
Of course Lia+Yeji are getting more lines, as the rest, but they’re the two best vocalists of the group… It's fair.
Chaeryeong who is the 3rd best vocalists gets the 3rd most lines.
And Yuna+Ryujin, who aren’t that good at singing and better at rapping, are getting the least lines… It’s completely fine.
Kill shot line distribution is wrong