@@tbraghavendran well look what she said at the start of the video that too in front of media . "I don't worry about anyone's comments". Now what kind of finance minister said that.
On getting salary we income tax. There after every purchased stuff or savings come under GST. GST is paid on MRP of most goods. MRP includes tax Rich people play safe Middle class people crushed Low class people least bothered. Any highly educated economist please calculate the average lifestyle (50k + ,/month) ends up paying tax
No jobs, No increment from past 7 to 8 years if someone has job, High taxes, skyrocketing inflation, falling GDP, Polluted air, potholes in roads and highways, corruption all over.
She doesn't hav to worry for anyone's comment as she is Rajya Sabha MP. People lack d chance of providing her feedback that has a direct impact for her. She's is directly controlled puppet minister of PMO.
The finance minister is not as genius as Dr. Manmohan Singh or Raghuram Rajan so common people has to suffer for the mad finance policies of the present government. People are fed up with this goverment which has failed in all sectors.
The most simple tax is NO TAX. Just abolish all taxes. LTCG, Income Tax, Toll Tax. Dissolve the tax collection department and make the Revenue secratary and the one who just turned RBI governor resign. More dangerous than mosquitoes.
GDP is gross goods and services totally produced in a country. In 2019 Electoral Bonds were issued worth appx Rs 12500/- Crores were issued by various corporates and establishments as a donations to political parties. These companies were producing essential goods like cooking oil, pharmaceuticals etc. As a result of this, the costs of essential goods & sevices doubled and some tripled during 2019-2023. GST on this also increased by way of indirect taxes, which has lead to high inflation . This created a fake growth in GDP figures. In the 1st quarter of 2024 Supreme Court declared Electoral Bonds as illegal. So whatever growth you see in GDP was because of doubling of costs of products, but consumption to these products have fallen due to fall of savings rate per family unit due to little growth or stagnant in salaries. As a result production is also slowed down and fall into GDP growth rate. I don’t know whether this high taxes, are used for common prosperity of nation or to write off loans of NPA big corporates. This point is overlooked or deliberately avoided by various media.
Anyone filing GST returns for big manufacturing companies? Paying tax on Caramelised pop corn is much simpler. It is a bogus return, full of confusing things and the tax men come up with demands for not filing returns correctly (even though you pay the taxes correctly).
taxing 18% itself is a crime. Most developed nations tax at 5-10% GST for Goods and many services are at 12%. How can 28% be justified on commonly used items like cement, steel, etc. Even after so much tax sources, this FM will not leave chance of taxing caramelized popcorn. WTF is wrong with her. Even for loading my own money to travel card, i get charged 18% GST !!!
1. GST sends all funds to Modi and makes states beg. So obviously we got weak state govts and Dictator at Center. 2. GST taxes equally but a worker in Orissa doesn't get as much as Mumbai. So that person pays higher tax. Earlier state taxes according to income were affordable for people. 3. Also Consider this PM shifts all projects to Gujarat. States are weak due to GST regime so they can't compete. 4. Frauds are very common in GST. Also there are huge fluctuations because instead of state independent taxes all taxes have to be Centralized. So state to state different problem occurs. For example the tax of Bun Muska and cream case in South may not be as frequent in North as food habits differ.
Durbhagya hai hmara ki hm is desh me janam liye jahan mera 50-60 percent earning direct and indirect tax me chale jaata hai. Aur milta kuch bhi nhi, health, education ke naam pe tatti milti hai and saare tax ke paise corruption, minority and poor appeasement me chala jaata hai. And the citizens never come together to protest even after such a bad situation
Avid follower of Newslaundry but you got to keep the facts straight. At 7.09 onwards it reads 'state requires permission to change rates' is totally wrong. The power is vested with GST Council which is body of all states and center
Leaving India should not be an option Bettering India should be the only option. Vote out incompetent government. Let only development be the election issue and nothing else.
That's what I don't understand, the industries the government is saying will be the future is being taxed at such a high rate, electronics 3d printing services and other businesses that will help us make devices are taxed higher. Virtue signalling
You need to compare it with VAT and other taxes at the state level. Did you know how each state managed it at its own whims and fancy. So, please don't trivialize things you cannot understand. Some aspects are complex, but it is still way simpler than what it was because a normal journalist now can comment on it.
Well the cost you pay in the end for a butter or no butter they are different , are they of same price. If not then tax will differ and if they are of same price then the tax will remain same. Well I am not supporting her but I just wanted to highlight it. What most important is reducing the tax on fuel, which has remained same and this is keeping things expensive. Why they are not reducing or talking about it . MAybe these are diversions. Bottom line the fuel needs to be cheaper. Just think popcorn is not daily consumption food, its the fuel and the food prices
So according to you more vat is good since the name is different. Don't spoil country by supporting congress. 60 odd years of congress rule only resultant is full of corruption in people mind
It's horrible to see that baby food came under 18% GST slab.
It's should be came under 5% or less.
Nirmala is not an economist like Dr. Manmohan Singh. Manmohan Singh was an educated genius. While Nirmala is a half baked cake.
Manmohan was toilet economist
I'm more worried about how the
taxation impacts SMEs and small businesses which get impacted and never get waivers with common man's savings.
It is hard to file a return. The website is very complicated. There's no other way anyway. And then, there are a whole bunch of charges.
most of the sme's and kirana stores don't pay taxes that's the headache. That's why govt. is punishing everybody with indirect tax
People will have to start going back to grandmother's recipes for making things at home 😂😂😂😂
Atlas cycles and Grandma's recipes back to square one...lol
its actually a reality bro.. people stated doing terrace terrace/backyard farming and also doing vlogs about it..although not all get monetized....
Very informative! Keep it up team. More power to you
She doesn't care about the opinion of the people who are actually paying that tax she's imposing.
Why 🤔
@@tbraghavendran well look what she said at the start of the video that too in front of media .
"I don't worry about anyone's comments". Now what kind of finance minister said that.
@Noone91875 she isn't Lok Shabha MP.
Add another 1% if the consumer is deiabatic, added sugar no?😂😂
I can't scold her , but feel to do . when ever I saw her and hear 🙉 her voice 🤬🤬🤬. When ever she comes to Media bring new GST rates as taxes .
Countries are laughing at us
On getting salary we income tax.
There after every purchased stuff or savings come under GST.
GST is paid on MRP of most goods.
MRP includes tax
Rich people play safe
Middle class people crushed
Low class people least bothered.
Any highly educated economist please calculate the average lifestyle (50k + ,/month) ends up paying tax
Undeserving politicians and becoming ministers of our country
As always a very informative video. Keep it up ❤❤❤
"I don't care about people comments "
That says it all.
Worst FM
Good Work good reporting 👍
No jobs,
No increment from past 7 to 8 years if someone has job,
High taxes, skyrocketing inflation, falling GDP,
Polluted air, potholes in roads and highways, corruption all over.
history learned posing as economist.
Very good good ❤
Hi, I haven't studied journalism or news broadcasting. I truly appreciate your work, but can we have news with any background music.
She doesn't hav to worry for anyone's comment as she is Rajya Sabha MP. People lack d chance of providing her feedback that has a direct impact for her. She's is directly controlled puppet minister of PMO.
The finance minister is not as genius as Dr. Manmohan Singh or Raghuram Rajan so common people has to suffer for the mad finance policies of the present government. People are fed up with this goverment which has failed in all sectors.
Thanks
India is a democratic country and ministers will do what the public wants and not what the minister wants
The most simple tax is NO TAX. Just abolish all taxes. LTCG, Income Tax, Toll Tax. Dissolve the tax collection department and make the Revenue secratary and the one who just turned RBI governor resign. More dangerous than mosquitoes.
GDP is gross goods and services totally produced in a country. In 2019 Electoral Bonds were issued worth appx Rs 12500/- Crores were issued by various corporates and establishments as a donations to political parties. These companies were producing essential goods like cooking oil, pharmaceuticals etc. As a result of this, the costs of essential goods & sevices doubled and some tripled during 2019-2023. GST on this also increased by way of indirect taxes, which has lead to high inflation . This created a fake growth in GDP figures. In the 1st quarter of 2024 Supreme Court declared Electoral Bonds as illegal. So whatever growth you see in GDP was because of doubling of costs of products, but consumption to these products have fallen due to fall of savings rate per family unit due to little growth or stagnant in salaries. As a result production is also slowed down and fall into GDP growth rate. I don’t know whether this high taxes, are used for common prosperity of nation or to write off loans of NPA big corporates. This point is overlooked or deliberately avoided by various media.
Anyone filing GST returns for big manufacturing companies? Paying tax on Caramelised pop corn is much simpler. It is a bogus return, full of confusing things and the tax men come up with demands for not filing returns correctly (even though you pay the taxes correctly).
Happy New Year 🎊
The bureaucracy has gone berserk I am telling becoz its not the poleticians who dictate terms its the bureaucrats. They shuld be held accountable
The government should adopt austerity measures, why so much tax why why why
Merry X mas and a very happy New Year🎉😊
Have zero expectations from the present FM....
STUPID INCOMPETENT FINANCE ....MINISTER INDIA HAS EVER WITNESSED
taxing 18% itself is a crime. Most developed nations tax at 5-10% GST for Goods and many services are at 12%. How can 28% be justified on commonly used items like cement, steel, etc. Even after so much tax sources, this FM will not leave chance of taxing caramelized popcorn. WTF is wrong with her. Even for loading my own money to travel card, i get charged 18% GST !!!
Even india comes in no 1 in terms of gst slab with 28%
Hungary highest gst slab 27% which is second
Nirmala should call herself 🍿 mimister 😅
Nirmala is Chanda collection agent. She used to do that for BJP before becoming FM. We need a real economist.
1. GST sends all funds to Modi and makes states beg. So obviously we got weak state govts and Dictator at Center.
2. GST taxes equally but a worker in Orissa doesn't get as much as Mumbai. So that person pays higher tax. Earlier state taxes according to income were affordable for people.
3. Also Consider this PM shifts all projects to Gujarat. States are weak due to GST regime so they can't compete.
4. Frauds are very common in GST. Also there are huge fluctuations because instead of state independent taxes all taxes have to be Centralized. So state to state different problem occurs. For example the tax of Bun Muska and cream case in South may not be as frequent in North as food habits differ.
Sweetmeats ?
No solution provided in this
Modi ji acha din aiga
Modi ji fans:🎉🎉🎉🎉
2024-2025:💀🗿🤧😱😱
Nirmala: Idon't care about comments. I serve my master Godi Bhagwan. 😂😂😂😂😂
nothing is confusing they just need to make people confused
Durbhagya hai hmara ki hm is desh me janam liye jahan mera 50-60 percent earning direct and indirect tax me chale jaata hai. Aur milta kuch bhi nhi, health, education ke naam pe tatti milti hai and saare tax ke paise corruption, minority and poor appeasement me chala jaata hai. And the citizens never come together to protest even after such a bad situation
Keeping common person in confused place tax tax GST this that but the common person should pay that tax
Avid follower of Newslaundry but you got to keep the facts straight. At 7.09 onwards it reads 'state requires permission to change rates' is totally wrong. The power is vested with GST Council which is body of all states and center
Donot consume popcorn in theatre moreover its too costly
leave india.. pay taxes for better life
Leaving India should not be an option Bettering India should be the only option. Vote out incompetent government. Let only development be the election issue and nothing else.
But the current generation of people is busy in doing Hindu Muslim and targeting other religions sites @@shaziaeramahmed1229
I don't know why she is criticised, you can bring notice to our pm , some solution probably you can expect
That's what I don't understand, the industries the government is saying will be the future is being taxed at such a high rate, electronics 3d printing services and other businesses that will help us make devices are taxed higher.
Virtue signalling
Pls. Aap. Hindi m videos bnaya kare ese topic par
One of the worst finance minister of our country Nirmala.
BjPEEs are looting by communally binding common people which people started realising.
Gujju fr...ud modi....... Katputli nirmala.
Desperation brings arbitrariness 😂😂😂 Classical example of how echo chambers work 😂😂😂
Modi vote and wining of BJP is main reason behind it
You need to compare it with VAT and other taxes at the state level. Did you know how each state managed it at its own whims and fancy. So, please don't trivialize things you cannot understand. Some aspects are complex, but it is still way simpler than what it was because a normal journalist now can comment on it.
Well the cost you pay in the end for a butter or no butter they are different , are they of same price. If not then tax will differ and if they are of same price then the tax will remain same. Well I am not supporting her but I just wanted to highlight it. What most important is reducing the tax on fuel, which has remained same and this is keeping things expensive. Why they are not reducing or talking about it . MAybe these are diversions. Bottom line the fuel needs to be cheaper. Just think popcorn is not daily consumption food, its the fuel and the food prices
Jake dub maro
RUSSIA 🇷🇺 is the best Country to live dont be fooled by medias
Modi Sahab Please change Indian FM . 🫡
So according to you more vat is good since the name is different. Don't spoil country by supporting congress. 60 odd years of congress rule only resultant is full of corruption in people mind
Number of comments posted before uploading of video is not satisfactory, betterment needed. 😅