Gene Clark Albums Ranked From Worst to Best
HTML-код
- Опубликовано: 24 авг 2024
- This week we're looking at the solo career of former Byrd, Gene Clark. Kram's got the week off this week, so it's just Jason and Joe ranking the 7 studio albums.
****
Harold Eugene "Gene" Clark (November 17, 1944 - May 24, 1991) was an American singer-songwriter and founding member of the folk rock band the Byrds. He was the Byrds' principal songwriter between 1964 and early 1966, writing most of the band's best-known originals from this period, including "I'll Feel a Whole Lot Better", "She Don't Care About Time", "Eight Miles High" and "Set You Free This Time". Although he did not achieve commercial success as a solo artist, Clark was in the vanguard of popular music during much of his career, prefiguring developments in such disparate subgenres as psychedelic rock, baroque pop, newgrass, country rock, and alternative country.
****
Thanks for watching! Let us know how you rank the albums and what you think of our lists by leaving a comment below.
Next week: Don Henley
After that: Arcade Fire, Massive Attack, April Patreon Selection [TBD]
#GeneClark #AlbumsRanked #WorsttoBest
~~~
Patreon: / tasteslikemusic
Merch: tasteslikemusi...
Website: tasteslikemusi...
Instagram: / tastes_like_music
Facebook: / tasteslikeyoutube
Twitter: / tasteslikemus1c
Wonderful to see some attention given to one of, if not the most overlooked artist of the rock n roll era. Back in the day I used to wonder how "No Other" never received the same kind of adulation that many of his contemporaries like Jackson Browne and Gram Parsons received for their albums. This is truly an undiscovered masterpiece. Very nice to see appreciation for it coming from music lovers like Joe and Jason who weren't even alive when that album was first released.
The high billing of the Gosdin Brothers was due to Gene's manager Jim Dickson managing both Gene and The Gosdins. Gene wanted to call his first solo album "Harold Eugene Clark". The Gosdins only contributed backing vocals so they did NOT deserve equal billing. Some great players on that album, Glen Campbell, Leon Russell, Clarence White, Doug Dillard, Chris Hillman and Van Dyke Parks.
Nice to see you here Indigo M.
@@pamelahay6242 hi Pamela!
I was so excited to learn that you were giving Gene Clark his own week. He was on my list of artists that I planned to request for my patron picks but you beat me to the punch. I don't remember how I first got into Gene. I found White Light and fell in love with it sometime in the mid 00s and also became familiar with him as a songwriter from the songs Alison Krauss and Robert Plant covered on Raising Sand. I long coveted the Dillard & Clark albums for that reason but at that time found them impossible to find in any form. That is probably why I never really heard any of his other albums beyond White Light until the last year.
I had No Other on my computer for a few years before I actually gave it the love it deserved. My dad had a copy on CD which I ripped but slept on for a long time. It was only last year when listening to music for Songs of the Year that I decided to listen to it and I was blown away! It has since become a top album for me as well. The emotional response some of those songs elicit in me cannot be denied (Strength of Strings comes immediately to mind). I'd also heard Firebyrd before this week because how could I resist an album with a song called "Vanessa" on it but had foolishly not heard much else. And this week I loved it all. Two Sides to Every Story was the biggest revelation of the week for me. I absolutely love it, from the opening track with that banjo and those sweet Emmylou harmonies I was sold. So happy that Joe has made it his mission to spread the word on Gene!
7. Firebyrd - 4 (7.8)
6. Gene Clark with The Gosdin Brothers - 4 (8.1)
5. So Rebellious a Lover - 4 (8.3)
4. Roadmaster - 4 (8.5)
3. Two Sides to Every Story - 4.5 (9.3)
2. White Light - 5 (9.7)
1. No Other - 5 (10)
Thanks Joe! What amazing timing as I myself, a longtime Byrds fan, have also lately been undergoing a revelatory and rewarding phase of discovering Gene Clark’s post-Byrds solo career. I’ve also been reading several fascinating biographies about the man. Here’s a paragraph by Johnny Rogan:
“It was part of Gene Clark’s complex character that, despite the greatness of his talent, he was always one of rock music’s most frustrating underachievers. For every celebrated moment of his musical life there were comparable memories of opportunities lost and projects abandoned or unrealized. At the heart of his story lies a powerful ambivalence towards the rock star life. He was capable of consuming the trappings of fame with the appetite of an excessive whilst simultaneously writing some of the most spiritually uplifting songs imaginable. He almost single-handedly kick-started the proliferation of singer-songwriter LA rock - setting an example by leaving an internationally famous group in order to pursue solo work. What seemed a daringly ambitious and innovative idea was equally symptomatic of a mercurial and fragile personality. That summed up Gene Clark’s career - giant steps forward, all too often accompanied by anti-climactic retreats into culthood. He never received the commercial success that was undoubtedly his due in the late Sixties and early Seventies. This brought an enigmatic edge to his tale, as well as ensuring the undying love of his more ardent supporters.”
Skip Spence is another fascinating underachiever . . Jackson Frank . .
No Other is a great album that I first heard about here from Joe. Cheers Joe, I am indebted!
The mission is working Joe. The people (myself included) are discovering Gene Clark thanks to you!
Great choice of artist - Gene Clark did some truly amazing work. In terms of songs one of his greatest was one he never got to record - Back Street Mirror, which turns up a David Hemmings (the old actor) album from about 1967. The track was arranged by Leon Russell, brilliantly, and was all ready to go but for whatever reason Gene didn't do it so Hemmings just sang over the top. Amazing song. Old Gene sure had a dark side but his talent was undeniable.
Back Street Mirror, the Clark version, appears on the Sierra release The Lost Studio Sessions. An album well worth picking up. It's also on the Back Street Mirror EP, which has 4 unreleased Clark tracks.
Lots of excellent stuff in the 70s records in particular.
1. No Other - 8.5
2. White Light - 8
3. Roadmaster - 8
4. Two Sides to Every Story - 7.5
5. Gene Clark with the Gosdin Brothers - 7
6. Firebyrd - 6.5
7. So Rebellious a Lover - 6
“No Other” is a good record. It has a few great songs, but it is very overrated. “Gene Clark” otherwise known as “White Light” is his best album by far, followed by “Two Sides To Every Story,” which is a very overlooked LP. After that it’s anybody’s guess. A lot of good songs on a lot of spotty albums!
There was a demo of “Gypsy Rider” put out on a flexi-disc as a giveaway with some music magazine that is far superior to the version on “So Rebellious A Lover.”
I agree with the host that Carla Olson is more of a distraction than a complement to Gene on that record. Her harmonies are passable, but it is difficult (for me) to listen to her lead vocals!
So glad that Joe was moved to discuss and analyze the underrated, sometimes forgotten incredible talent of Mr. Clark! Thanks to Jason for starting the podcast reviews of various artists. I’ve been following you guys for the last few months. Props, praise and thanks. This is going to be a fun view to hear your opinions of Gene Clark! 👍🏻👍🏻👍🏻
Thanks Bob. - Joe
Love Gene Clark. Such a cool songwriter. Everything I have by him I love. Made the Byrds the Byrds. For me nothing weak
The guy was a genius but his discography is a mess - but he is untouchable at his best. Check out his demo version of One In A Hundred - sublime
I just listened to a few tracks off No Other and I can see why one might become obsessed. Good call.
Thanks guys for discovering a great catalog to me.
I fell in love with No Other a few months ago following Joe's high praises and this week has been a real pleasure to listen to all his previous releases.
He's a great singer, a talented song writer and all his records sound so tasteful.
He arrived to stay, I'll be checking him regularly.
Thanks again!
What a wonderful surprise! Like you Joe, I fell for Gene hard once I discovered him as a solo artist. That voice. So mournful and expressive. I love his voice. I would include the Dillard & Clark records, though. Clark is the frontman on those. I like So Rebellious a Lover more than you guys. Weak that Kram skipped out on this one. There are some excellent live bootlegs of Gene out there. Solo acoustic shows.
You'd figure Kram would skip out on next week's artist (Don Henley) instead, given his distaste for all things Eagles. Maybe the entertainment value of Kram crapping on Henley was just too lucrative for the channel.
I had the week scheduled off regardless
I have always loved No Other, but I hadn't heard anything else from him until recently. His discography is a bit scattered in terms of my ratings but I wasn't disappointed by most of it.
1. No Other (1974) 25/25 ★★★★★
2. White Light (1971) 21/25 ★★★★
3. Gene Clark And The Gosdin Brothers (1967) 20/25 ★★★★
4. Two Sides To Every Story (1977) 19/25 ★★★ ½
5. Roadmaster (1973) 16/25 ★★★
6. Firebyrd (1984) 12/25 ★★
7. So Rebellious A Lover (1987) 11/25 ★★
The beauty of the albums entire structure is that the sound is sort of layered. A lot going on but it is NOT a muddy mix or dirge that could easily have resulted. I am hearing impaired since birth yet the sound is crystal clear and astonishingly melodic. Love the structure, the songs, and Gene's incredible vocals and phrasing. It was hard to get his output in Australia in the prior to the internet. I got No Other in a second-hand store. Could not believe my luck. Into Gene since Here Without You on The Bryds first album. RIP Gene. Certainly there is NO OTHER>
Hi guys, This is the one i've been looking for, I hope Joe won't get fed up in the long run with " No Other" after so many listening! it is indeed a life changing album, It's definitely in my top 10 albums ever, could even be in my top 5. I like the way you delve deep into production, harmonies, lyrics, musicians involved and so on
My fav Gene Clark albums are at the moment:
1) No Other 5 stars deluxe
2) White Light ( The white light demos are great too!) 5
3) The fantastic expedition of dillard & clark 4.5
4) Roadmaster 4
5) Gene Clark with the Gosdin Brothers 4
6) So Rebellious a lover 4
7) Two sides to every story 3.5
I am 61, and have a voracious appetite for music. I gather information and inspiration from numerous sources including you three guys on music I may like, both newer and older. Now I knew Gene Clark from The Byrds, but as Joe said I didn't know solo stuff. I am loving many of the suggestions, Gene Clark included. I listen to so much different stuff, so I haven't gotten right back to Gene, but you can bet i will. "No Other" is an amazing underheard hidden gem.
Just trying to spread the gospel of Gene. - Joe
Thanks Joe. I think your thoughts and summations on Gene’s music & discography are well considered and on the mark. Very pleasing to know that so many people are getting a chance to hear GC for the first time, so long after he recorded and decades after hus death. Pretty sure he’d be totally amazed that anyone has revisited and re-released his albums. Geffen let his personal feelings get in the way of a landmark album when he snuffed No Other with no promo budget. Effectively snuffed out Gene too who despite recording his latter albums, was launched into a downward spiral from ‘74 on. 😢
Interesting take on Gene's catalog. As much as I love No Other, I like the stripped down songs better. The only things I dislike ( sorry Joe ), is the backup singers on Life's Greatest Fool, and the dreadful artwork. White Light would top my list, but it's all subjective. Great video, thanks guys ! Nice to see Gene get some recognition.
Two great videos. I was gifted No Other a number of years ago and loved it. Added White Light to my collection. And this week's discussion will help me dig deeper.
It was disarming to see usual grouch Joe positively ebullient as he discussed an artist he thinks very highly. I was not expecting that, knowing how critically praised Gene Clark has been. Both Joe & Jason had some sharp and thoughtful insights.
I wonder if Rabbit Fur Coat being credited to Jenny Lewis and The Watson Twins was a nod to Gene Clark with the Godsin Brothers?
Great discovery. Thanks, Joe
Interesting...we're on the same page...my fav Gene Clark albums are White Light, Roadmaster and No Other and I have them all on vinyl! He is an excellent song writer and love his voice.His two Dillard and Clark albums are also excellent e.g.Kansas City Southern...thank you for your thoughtful reviews...cheers
Alright, i'd heard "No Other" before (admittedly after all the Gene talk on The Byrds ranking episode) , but not till i listened to this discussion of it here and revisited it did i really HEAR it.......... its clicked, what a album, thanks guys for the newfound appreciation of it, that's why i love this channel
Damn! We haven't seen Joe this excited about an artist since Kate Bush.
No Other is one those once unavailable cult albums that I read about in my younger days which had a heavy rep. I managed to hear two songs from it on cassette through a friend and they consolidated my interest. Since I heard the album properly in the early 2000s it has definitely reached top ten album of all time status. It is heavier than it's rep. I shall actually do a top ten songs tomorrow, so I shall. Peace y'all ✌️
No Other took several listens to grow on me, but it is a stunning masterpiece when all is said and done. Amazing record!
I've been looking forward to this one. A pretty easy artist to rank for me. Thanks guys!
Gene Clark is easily one of my favorite singer/songwriters. I'll reach for a Clark album over a Byrds one almost every time and on the occasions I do play a Byrds album a Clark binge usually follows.
For someone who claimed to never read literature his lyrics are remarkably good.
I'll only rank the albums I own.
7) Echoes. 3 stars (Gosdin Bros album + 6 extra Byrds tracks)
6) Gene Clark Sings for You. 4 stars (a collection of early songs - although sometimes the vocals are shaky here and there, it's much more fun to listen to than the schmaltzy Gosdin album)
5) So Rebellious a Lover. 4 stars (a very good record that took me some time to absorb)
4) Two Sides To Every Story. 4 stars (An odd duck in the canon with some great songs)
3) Roadmaster 4.5 stars (not much to say but I like this one a lot and was the last I bought/heard)
2) White Light/Here Tonight: The White Light Demos. 4.5 stars (a superb album and for those who don't like the production on White Light, the demo album is a great alternative)
1) No Other. 5 stars (a masterpiece by any measure and one of the great albums of the 70s)
The Fantastic Expedition Of Dillard & Clark is also 5 stars for me.
Really surprised Jason had never heard No Other all the way through before this. Glad you’ve had a life changing experience with that masterpiece of an album, Joe. Joe’s impression that nobody has ever heard Gene Clark is interesting. I think when he mentions that Spotify never suggested him (or something like that) it begins to make some sense. I never would have discovered Gene Clark’s solo material if I wasn’t a purchaser of physical media. Reissues (CD and vinyl) of White Light and No Other were my gateway to his music. Cheers ✌🏻
I sort of had tuned out music from 2017- until joining Listo, so I must have missed the Gene renaissance. - Joe
I was as well astonished (but I always am) when I noticed that what I think is a household name is mentioned in an "obscure" artist context. But from the boys perspective I understand it now, the man started with a number 1 hit and was an early superstar, he had the looks, the voice the talent and he made SO LITTLE out of it. He worked hard to be forgotten, or the drugs worked it for him. Maybe he is not the artist to be discovered looking back if you had not been there when he started?
Jon - Gene spent a ton of David Geffens money on No Other & it has aged well , like fine wine ! 🍷
@@TastesLikeMusic I wouldn’t say there has been a renaissance per se. You’re correct in assuming that not that many people are aware of his solo material - in the broader sense.
I've only got and heard White Light and No Other.
White Light is great. No Other is astonishing.
And aren’t they production wise at lesst, so different from each other? But the strong link between is Gene Clark’s writing and voice. I love them both two and which I listen to at any particular time really just depends on my mood or what I need to hear at a particular time. 😊
I happy that you’re covering Gene Clark. Ive just started watching so I don’t know what you’ll have at the top. For me it’s definitely No Other, but I’ve only heard four of his albums.
Another semi-obscure American artist that I would love to hear you review is Tom Rush
This was nice. I hadn't paid attention to Gene Clark after The Byrds. Thanks for giving something new to try. Good idea, Joe
Hope you’ve got to listen and be excited by some of Gene’s work. Yes, it’s always wonderful to hear something different, not heard before. 😊
Thank you for all the great music recommendations guys.
No Other - 4.5 stars (8.6)
Roadmaster - 3.5 stars (7.8)
White Light - 3.5 stars (7.4)
Two Sides to Every Story - 3 stars (6.7)
Gene Clark with Gosdin Bros - 3 stars (6.5)
Firebyrd- 3 stars (6)
So Rebellious A Lover - 2.5 stars (5.8)
7. Gene Clark with the Gosdin Brothers 2.5 stars
6. Through the Morning , Through the Night ( Dillard and Clark ) 3 stars
5. Two Sides to Every Story 3 stars
4. The Fantastic Expedition of Dillard and Clark 3.5 stars
3. Roadmaster 3.5 stars
2. White Light 4 stars
1. No Other 4.5 stars
Really interesting exercise with an artist i was aware of but knew little about ( and not normally a genre of music i listen too much these days) . Thanks to Joe who really championed this guy around Byrds week if I recall. I didn't spend a lot of time with these records ( 2 listens) so time will probably improve some of my rankings. No Other clearly stood out for me without doing any research in advance, as a real great record. Good stuff, thanks Joe and Jason.: Note : I obviously missed Firebyrd and So Rebellious a lover..best I could do .
7- Firebyrd (1984) 3/5
6- So Rebellius a Lover (1987) 3.5/5
5- Gene Clark with the Godsin Brothers (1967) 4/5
4- Two Sides of Every Story (1977) 4/5
3- No Other (1974) 4.5/5
2- White Light (1971) 4.5/5
1- Roadmaster (1972) 4.5/5
2 outta 3 aint bad
i liked gene , the albums are very close
7 so rebellious a lover 3.0 stars
6 2 sides to every story 3.0
5 firebyrd 3.0 +
4 gene clark with the gosidin brothers 3.5
3 roadmaster 3.5
2 white light 3.5+
1 no other 4.0
pretty fun week🐯🐯🐯🐯
Great to see you cover Gene Clark. No Other, White Light, and Roadmaster all have great songs on them, but yes, No Other is the masterpiece Although Gene’s solo work never achieved much commercial success, among Byrds and country-Rock fans, he is legendary. You should also know that there are a bunch of live bootlegs of Gene Clark that are also very good and worth checking out.
1. No Other (1974) 5/5
2. Gene Clark With The Gosdin Brothers (1967) 4.5/5
3. White Light (1971) 4/5
4. Roadmaster (1972) 3.5/5
5. Two Sides To Every Story (1977) 3/5
6. Firebyrd (1984) 3/5
7. So Rebellious A Lover (1987) 3/5
CHRONOLOGICAL ORDER:
4.5 Gene Clark With The Gosdin Brothers (1967)
4.0 White Light (1971)
3.5 Roadmaster (1972)
5.0 No Other (1974)
3.0 Two Sides To Every Story (1977)
3.0 Firebyrd (1984)
3.0 So Rebellious A Lover (1987)
BONUS "DILLARD & CLARK" RANKING:
1. The Fantastic Expedition Of Dillard & Clark (1968) 4.5/5
2. Through The Morning, Through The Night (1969) 3.5/5
For my money, Gene Clark was the most talented member of The Byrds and I think his solo career (as well as his collaborations with Doug Dillard) bear that out. His 1967 debut draws on variety of styles that were big in California at the time and mixes them with his impeccable songwriting. Critics loved the album but the public ignored it, which prompted Clark to switch gears and team up with banjo extraordinaire Doug Dillard in 1968 to form Dillark & Clark. (A group also notable for including the future Eagles guitar player, Bernie Leadon.) Their first LP, The Fantastic Expedition Of Dillard & Clark, almost beat The Byrds themselves to the country-rock punch. A tour-de-force of bluegrass fusion, it was released just a few weeks after Sweetheart of the Rodeo. (Personally, I prefer it to 'Sweetheart.' It's about as good as any Byrds record.) Unfortunately, the group ran out of steam after their second album and Clark returned to his solo career. His next offering- 1971's White Light- has a stripped-down, '70s singer-songwriter vibe to it. It constitutes a step down from his solo debut but still features a handful of compelling tunes. Roadmaster, from 1972, recycles a few previously released songs and partly feels like a holding pattern. It doesn't hint at the masterpiece that came next- 1974's No Other, an album that has achieved cult classic status for good reason. The whole thing is irresistible. His last 3 solo LPs are nominally good but largely unremarkable affairs. Gene Clark wouldn't make my all-time top 100 list on his own, but he's already included as a member of The Byrds. (I have a policy where I don't allow any individual musician to appear in my top 100 more than once, in an attempt to make room for more artists.) This week was a blast! Gene Clark is one of rock and roll's great unsung heroes.
MY RATING SYSTEM:
5.0 = major classic (consistently great *and* stratospheric highs)
4.5 = minor classic (consistently great *or* stratospheric highs, but not both)
4.0 = great (more than 50% is worth revisiting and it's an essential record for this artist/style - passes my "it'll make a fan out of someone who's new to this artist" test)
3.5 = seriously good (more than 50% is worth revisiting)
3.0 = nominally good (less than 50% is worth revisiting)
2.5 = decent (competent but uninspired - not worth revisiting)
2.0 = poor (difficult listen)
1.5 = awful (can't finish it)
1.0 = historically awful (musical apocalypse)
*Note: "Consistently" does not mean "flawlessly." I allow for a few clunkers if the rest of the songs are good enough. Also, I don't go below 1 star because once I'm in the realm of the truly terrible I don't care to differentiate anymore.
Interesting that you have the debut so high on your list.
@@Sir_Eyeball I've come to love almost every track on it. Overall, Gene's solo debut would be my 3rd favorite album of his, behind No Other and The Fantastic Expedition Of Dillard & Clark.
Love your YT handle!
I think you’re being s little harsh on Roadmaster . You kind of have to yhink of it as 2/3’s GC album X a 1/2 Flying Burritos EP…. Pity he never got to lay down an extra 4 tracks with the ssme production style as the 8 he did. I still tecall the goosebumps from first hearing In a Misty Morning”; so easy to stand with GC in the quiet, , moist dark air of the morn and feel it too.
Gene could consistently surprise you. 💖
I listened to Gene Clark for two whole years, very little else, love all his music, everything he did, he is probably my favorite artist of all time.
You are a great human. - Joe
Noted Byrds expert & author / musician Sid Griffin has cited Gene Clark as his favorite Byrd. So Rebellious A Lover is my favorite album of his with Sid's former band mates ( The Long Ryders ) very capably backing Gene & Carla. Nice , underrated 80's record.
"I’ve been loving Gene for about a year now”. Lmao, that’s something I would say verbatim. Y’all have a great sense of what makes music good or otherwise meaningful, and on top of that the rapport you guys share amongst yourselves really makes it feel like I’m having this conversation with my own friends. Great video!
I became a Gene Clark fan because of the two covers from the 4AD This Mortal Coil albums. Strength of Strings, and With Tomorrow sounded amazing. Later,when the label came out with the box set for the 3 albums, a 4th cd was included with the original artist's versions' of the songs. Started collecting the Byrds, first, but later I got White Light and No Other. Thanks for the rundown. Its cool to be introduced to some of Gene's other work.
No Other is superb. I had it as my number 5 of 1974 in your albums of that year, and that was a strong year for albums
Love Gene Clark and knew him with Byrds materials…almost obsessed with solo stuff now
Agree with Joe, it's a record which doesn't sound like anything else I've heard. Almost ethereal. I read that he went downhill after the record flopped. Sad.
I don’t know if someone else mentioned it, but Leland Sklar, the bass player on No Other, has a RUclips episode where he talks about the making of the album. He has a funny story about Joe Cocker walking in and ruining a recording.
Ps. Carla Olson did some interesting live stuff with a certain Mick Taylor. They did an extended version of Winter that apparently represented MT's original vision for the song. It's astonishing...
07 Firebyrd (3 stars)
06 Two Sides To Every Story (4 stars)
05 So Rebellious A Lover (4 stars)
04 Roadmaster (4.5 stars)
03 Gene Clark With The Gosdin Brothers (5 Stars)
02 No Other (5 stars)
01 White Light (5 stars)
Of course the two Dillard & Clark albums are great too, especially the first one which is a country rock classic.
Havr to day I’m aleays surprised when Gene’s “With the Gosdin Bros” Debut album is rated higher than a coiple if his latter albums. It always seems like a much more inconsistent exploratory type project than latter recordings. I’m not a fan of listings or ratings particularly. We all have subjective listening ears & for whatever reasons, may be hooked emotionally or intellectually on different albums & the order if preference can change over time too. But all of GC’s work is worth listening to I think, just to hear his progressive diversity aleays delivered with great feel regardless of style. 💖
It would have been truly flabbergasting if either of you had gone for anything else except No Other as number one. It is a towering masterpiece. What a tragedy that Gene just couldn’t keep it together consistently to sustain even a vaguely successful career. It’s great that he’s getting exposure like this so that people are prompted to try him out. No Other and the Fantastic Expedition of Dillard and Clark are my favourite albums of his and bear frequent relistening, though perhaps 5 times in a day is a bit excessive! But as you guys said every album has something great on it and they are all worth checking out.
NO OTHER- the best $200,000 David Gefen ever spent.
The similar artist for me is Peter Hammill of VDGG, not well known but I enjoy his singing style. It may not be everyone's cup of tea, but I enjoy. I'll add No Other to my list of albums to check out.
Besides of Warren Zevon, Gene Clark must be the most under rated singer/songwriter ever.
My friend of 50 years’ uncle is Richard Greene, the violinist on ‘Strength of Strings’, Some Misunderstanding and Lady if the North’
Richard Green is/was a great fiddler! 🙂
For Joe I will go into this discrophy
Hope you found lots to enjoy. 😊
More cowbell, Joe, more cowbell.
Great ranking. I haven't heard any of these albums but knew a couple of songs but I definitely will have to check him out.
Hope you havr been able to do that Slayde. 😊
I’ve mentioned John Hiatt here before but after seeing this, I’d definitely recommend him to Joe. And Jason too 😁. I’d start with a compilation to hear his different sounds over the years. A little country, a little blues, a little rock. Bring the Family is generally considered his classic. Walk On is my favorite and shows off his diversity pretty well.
I know a little John Hiatt. -Jason
@@TastesLikeMusic Is he similar to the regular-sized one?
Hi guys, I like coming back to your videos after a while, time passes and some albums can climb up the list, Roadmaster is now number two, swapping with White light , fantastic expedition 4th, the rest is the same. No other will be always top! I would suggest a Tim Buckley ranking in the future, not many albums to listen to
I'm late to this party but MASSIVE Gene fan. That hurt in his voice kills me. Astonishing abstract lyrics.
Hadn't heard the story about Silver Raven. I assumed this was a spiritual/Native American thing. He was brought up Catholic and had Native American roots. I think this explains many of his lyrics.
NO OTHER & WHITE LIGHT are probably both my fav albums despite being Soooooo different. Can you imagine any artist of the past 30 years doing such contrasting & brilliant albums. Both 10/10. Byrds did like wise of course. Astonishing!
I'm 51 and in UK. Discovered Gene via Byrds about 20 years ago. Best cover version? Have you heard Some Misunderstanding by Mark Lanegan. Alison Krauss did ok, Robert Plant did not.
Well done for doing this. Dean
Thanks Dean. Gene rules. Haven’t heard that Lanegan cover but I’m going to listen. - Joe
I grew up w Gene Clark songs. First and foremost the 2 Dillard and Clark ones. Then the one that holds 'spanish guitar' with the sunset. Outside of family and hippy friends nobody knew them so it went out of my playing repertoire. Then 'raising sand' had i think 2 or 3 Clark songs on it, 'polly'. Then it became kinda hip again.
As someone who considers The Byrds to be one of her absolute favorite artists. The Gene Clark Discography was one I was very excited to look into. And while I did enjoy listening, it never quite hit that magic the full band did. Aside from 1 album.
No Other - 4.5
White Light - 4
Gene Clark With The Godwins Brothers - 3.5
Roadmaster - 3.5
So Rebelious A Lover - 3.5
Two Sides To Every Story - 3
Firebyrd - 2.5
You’re a tough grader so that’s not bad. - Joe
Of course, not a bad artist at all!
Seconding those posting acclaim for "No Other". Astounding in every respect, never could figure out why it did not become iconic. Maybe due to his Byrds connection and how it stands by itself with such originality, only one cut (the opener "Life's Greatest Fool') that seems reminiscent of Byrds material. Get "No Other" if you don't know of it! (totally different genre but if you appreciate unknown gems look up Shuggie Otis "Freedom Flight" ("Strawberry Letter 22" was a got covered later on).
🎶 Some People Might Say My Life Is In A Rut 🎶
🎶 I’m quite happy with what I got 🎶 😆
Maybe Moby Grape someday? For country lovers.
Hi Joe
I was intrigued when you voted No Other song of the year for 1974 and this is a fascinating overview of Gene Clark's body of work. I have joined you in listening over and over to No Other. I am not sure if it's a masterpiece but it's certainly up there with Gram Parsons' Grievous Angel as you pointed out. Your description of your journey is very engaging and No Other certainly deserves to be considered part of the canon. I will continue listening.
In the meantime, having surveyed the albums of the year series which is fascinating and comprehensive. But as there are always new things to be discovered (and you might have heard some of these though there is no mention of them in the AOTY series), here are some recommendations for you that might be due a re-appraisal
Jefferson Airplane SURREALISTIC PILLOW/AFTER BATHING AT BAXTER'S 1967
Love FOREVER CHANGES 1967
Tim Buckley GOODBYE AND HELLO 1967
Pink Floyd PIPER AT THE GATES OF DAWN 1967
The Byrds NOTORIOUS BYRD BROTHERS 1968
Jethro Tull STAND UP 1969
Carole King TAPESTRY 1971
Marvin Gaye WHAT'S GOIN ON 1971
Mike Oldfield TUBULAR BELLS 1973
Tom Petty & The Heartbrekers first album 1976
Portishead DUMMY 1994
Happy listening
Thanks Jim, I know a few of those and really need to listen to the rest. Notorious Byrd Brothers could sneak into my top 5 in 68. I love it. Gene forever. - Joe
I know only two albums and both are great and Gene is very underrated. I just dont have time now to explore his other records.
1. "No Other"
2. "So Rebellious a Love" with Carla Olson. One is hard-pressed to find a more haunting evocative song than "Gypsy Rider".
Thanks guys for mentioning So Rebellious A Lover, I love that album, it’s a very under-rated album. No Other is a stone cold classic, same for the album with Carla.
I’m hoping by now you have been able to hear more of Gene’s music. As poignant as Gypsy Rider may be wait until hear the heartbreaker Silent Crusade from Two Sides..
“I am told that my life is a clipper
The sea of time has tossed about
And I know that yhere’s only one skipper
That can guide that ship about”
😔 RIP Gene.
The Gypsy Angel demos cd is worth checking out. Fragile, raw and stripped down latter day Gene songs. Mostly just him. it sounds like it was recorded at the bottom of a well. Really good.
Carla Olson may not have the prettiest voice but she's a good singer. I like her earthy sound.
Agreed 👍
I do not think that the Gene Clark collaboration is the best way to be introduced to her. The Ring of Truth from 2001 is my favourite from her.
9) Firebyrd
8) Through the Morning, Through the Night
7) So Rebelious a Lover
6) Gene Clark with the Gosdin Brothers
5) The Fantastic Expedition of Dillard & Clark
4) Roadmaster
3) Two Sides to Every Story
2) White Light
1) No Other
7. So Rebellious A Lovers (1987)
6. Gene Clark With The Gosdin Brothers (1967)
5. Firebyrd (1984)
4. Two Sides To Every Story (1977)
3. White Light (1971)
2. No Other (1974)
1. Roadmaster (1973)
No Other came out when I was 8. Would've been an all time fave for me if I'd've heard it. Only heard it after Joe recommended it-- nearly 50 years later!
I just bonded with Joe.
Bonding-With-Joe Moments could be a Side 3. 😀
One of the few genuinely seminal singer-songwriters. Gene Clark with the Gosdin Brothers, Gene Clark (White Light), Road Master and especially No Other are criminally neglected classics.
Makes me sad that he’s not more well known
The only Gene Clark album I've heard is No Other, but that's a really great album.
So, hope you explored a bit more & enjoyed, even though his other recordings are much less heavily produced. Drill down to the heart of the man….
09) Firebyrd (3 stars)
08) Two Sides to Every Story (3.75 stars)
07) Roadmaster (4 stars)
06) White Light (4 stars)
05) The Fantastic Expedition of Dillard & Clark (Dillard & Clark) (4 stars)
04) Through the Morning, Through the Night (Dillard & Clark) (4 stars)
03) Gene Clark with the Gosdin Brothers (4.25 stars)
02) So Rebellious a Lover (with Carla Olson) (4.5 stars)
01) No Other (5 stars)
0 stars - irredeemably terrible/insultingly bad/the worst
.5 stars - terrible
1 star - bad
1.5 stars - pretty bad
2 stars - fair
2.5 stars - meh
2.75 stars - "It's OK, but quit playing it."
3 stars - OK/decent
3.25 stars - pretty good
3.5 stars - good
4 stars - very good
4.5 stars - excellent
5 stars - the highway symphony
notes -
* This music was completely new to me going into this.
* I figured if we were going to include So Rebellious a Lover, a collaborative album in which Carla Olson gets top billing with Gene, we might as well include the Dillard & Clark albums. Adding the McGuinn, Clark and Hillman albums seems to be taking this a bit too far though and I didn't much care for what I heard anyway.
* "I Found You" on the debut nicks the bassline from "Taxman" for the guitar intro. Seems like this is a very popular song to steal from as The Jam did it too.
* There's quite a lot of smokin' banjo on the Dillard & Clark albums, particularly on the second one which is why I put it above the first.
* I prefer Gene's version of "Tears of Rage" over the other versions. The slow, almost hesitant version by the Band doesn't sit well with me for some reason.
* "One in a Hundred" seems to be in a different key on Roadmaster compared to the original on White Light.
* I prefer the more pepped up version of "Mr. Tambourine Man" found on Firebyrd over the sleepy Byrds version.
* "Made of Love," also on Firebyrd, comes off as rather sexist by today's standards. There's a few songs in Gene's catalogue you could say that about.
* Carla Olson is a good singer and her voice blends nicely with Gene's on So Rebellious a Lover.
* "I'm Your Toy (Hot Burrito #1)" is rather sexually explicit.
* Some of these songs feel like they should have gone on a bit longer.
* Gene's lyrics are generally good although he is sometimes prone to nonsensical deepities. But he's always "feelin' it" so maybe that's all that matters.
* Cheers mates!!!!!!!!!
You were familiar w The Byrds, no?
@@NaughtyVampireGod Since I did the TLM deep dive, very familiar.
@@179rich Nice. I'm sure you were somewhat familiar before then. At one point, when I was a teen, they were actually on my top 10 band list. (This would have been in the 80s - When REM was actually still being compared to The Byrds.) At this point I couldn't even say if they'd be on the top 100. Couldn't do the deep dive (Byrds) b/c I just cannot stick w a band who's mostly covers . . no matter how well done. Great sound at their best. the first four albums is where I was at . . If I get a chance I will certainly listen to No Other which seems like the classic one here.
@@NaughtyVampireGod Did you ever check out No Other?
The 4AD Super Deluxe boxset of No Other is ESSENTIAL. So many sessions, an alternate of the album, SACD, a makin of bluray, album on vinyl....fab.
Please a Jackson Browne list!!!!
Roadmaster is a cover song. Gene did not write it. The album was released after Gene had be let go from A&M records, his manager, Jim Dickson, put together the tracks Gene was working on with those previously recorded tracks and released it. It was only released in Holland when it first came out.
I could have sworn I saw that it was a cover but then it didn’t have any credits on it when I was checking it out on one site. Glad it is a cover because it’s one of my least favorite. - Joe
If a superior race of aliens landed and we had one hour to demonstrate the beauty of the human race and our worthiness to join them among the stars, I would play No Other for them. This would come before Pet Sounds, Village Green, Sgt Pepper, Songs In The Key Of Life, or any other iconic cultural statement albums.
I was listening to Gene Clark before you boys were born, but yeah, you tell me what's best.
Clearly you didn’t “hear” him if that’s your attitude. - Joe
JOE JACKSON
Great video, I'm not sure exactly if I would label Gene Clark as a County artist though, at least not in the same way as I would Gram Parsons or Chris Hillman. I always associated both Mcguinn and Gene as the two members that adhered to traditional folk music the most. Absolutely Folk music overlaps with County and Bluegrass, and Mcguinn and Gene probably did enjoy all three, I just associate their solo music more with artist like Woody Guthrie or Bob Dylan than George Jones or Conway Twitty.
Duh..how could I have forgotten the best Gene of all time - "Gene"sis (my favorite band of all time)
7. Gene Clark With The Gosdin Brothers 1,5 (60s schmalz pop at its worse, it makes Scott Walker of the era sound like a rocker, some bad Everly imitators chime in the back, horrible. Music for Elevator Operators. Needing Someone saves it from the trash can.)
6. Firebyrd 2,5 (Not really terrible but far from good. Unnecessary.)
5. Two Sides to Every Story 3,0 (In deed two sides, one bad and one generic. For Eagles fans.)
4. White Light 3,5 (A good, short album, pretty standard stuff for 1971 even if Clark had once a leading role in inventing the genre. Nothing stellar or outstanding, just nice solid country rock.)
3. Roadmaster 3,5 (More a random song collection than a consistent album, quality differs a lot from song to song - the good ones however are very good.)
2. So Rebellious a Lover 4,0 (Note that Carla Olsen has some pretty good albums to her name or with the Textones that are worth checking out, also some collaborations with ex-Stones Mick Taylor. In hindsight, maybe this should have been left out of the list as the high ranking is mostly for Olsen and the musicians, less than a third goes to Clark himself - his vocals on the Fogerty and Burrito covers are in fact the album's low points.)
1. No Other 4,5 (As an album this is stronger than anything he ever did with the Byrds - or they did without him. Note - Producer Thomas Jefferson Kaye recorded his second album First Grade at the same time that he worked with Clark, the album is a MUST for anyone who cares about No Other or the first four Steely Dan albums.)
hey roxanne! What did carla olsen do with mick taylor? Full albums?
@@bengalgangster They made a full album together called Too Hot For Snakes (1988). Afterwards Taylor appeared on several of her solo albums, he played on almost every track of Within an Ace, and on a number of tracks of her next two albums. They regularly toured together and there is a large compilation "Sway" that collects their best work together.
Enjpyed this. I did a recent CD exchange with a friend and he gave me 5 CDs, including No Other. I bought it myself after 2 listens, its amazing. Will have to check out more of his discography.
That’s a good friend. - Joe
So good to see “ new listeners” catching on to Gene Clark and discovering him as both singer & songwriter. 30 years after his premature passing in May 1991. Ahead of his time in many ways, a creative being not suited to The Music Business , always writing and professional in the studio but ran with some of the wrong people outside it, to his personal detriment. The LA music scene wasn’t a healthy one in the 1970’s. Some got out in the nick of time, some did not. 😟
On my vinyl copy of Roadmaster from Sundazed the song Roadmaster is credited to Weller-Oldham....Not Gene himself
Yeah you’re right!
His voice sounds like across between Michael Nesmith,Gram Parsons and at times on No Other Jim Morrison!
He is all things. He is the original. - Joe
Listened to him for the first time today so it's impossible for me to know exactly how I feel having only listened to a few but I did hit on one (Life's Greatest Fool) that I could have sworn was Michael Nesmith (whom I think was a great part of The Monkees, an underrated band with four unique parts, but that's for another day)
A Monkees discography would be nice . . Always great to have that-was-just-a-kid's-show-from-the-60s people discover Circle Sky. 😎
Yes, there was more to The Monkees than they were allowed to express, but then, they were created essentially to be just the central pivot of a television show. It was The Show that mattered more than The Band, but they did get to record some time resisting hits and bring writers like Neil Diamond into vision. And eventually they managed to bring themselves into focus too as good musicians, writers and /or entertainers. As individuals The Monkees were accepted quite well I believe, by the “ more hip, cool brigade” who lived in the Canyons of LA. 🙂
Gotta be one of the most underrated musicians ever. No Other is obviously a masterpiece, but his discography is really strong as well.
7. So Rebellious a Lover (1987) ★★★
6. Firebyrd (1984) ★★★½
5. Gene Clark With the Gosdin Brothers (1967) ★★★★
4. Two Sides to Every Story (1977) ★★★★
3. Roadmaster (1973) ★★★★½
2. White Light (1971) ★★★★½
1. No Other (1974) ★★★★★
★★★★★ - Masterpiece
★★★★½ - Really great
★★★★ - Great
★★★½ - Really good
★★★ - Good
★★½ - OK
★★ - Bad
★½ - Really bad
★ - Awful
½ - The worst
Pretty much matches my list too… a bit like a tight finishing horse race… on any other day, any horse punching to the line could change its finishing order by just a nod of it’s head….😄 I’ve been lucky to have known all of GC’s work since around 1972-1976, & blessed to have bruefly met him in 1978. Gentle guy, not suited to the LA music business, wrecked by the scene as it was in those days. 😢
@@pamelahay6242 Wow, cool that you've met him! Yeah, he didn't get the career he deserved, which is a shame.
Yes, meeting Gene Clark was “ a moment in time”, which has a complicated lead up story which I won’t bore you with here. But GC is one of only two musicians I have ever wished to meet in person. Gene, because I wondered “ who is this person” who can write such lyrically beautiful songs and deliver them with fearless vulnerability, great technique, care and depth of expression?
'Roadmaster' the song is actually a cover by Spooner Oldham / Freddy Weller. It was incorrectly credited on the album sleeve/label. Probably should have included the Dillard & Clark albums cos every Gene fan does and where else you gonna put them? Especially since you mentioned Plant & Krause who covered 2 songs from 'Through The Morning...'
We’ll do a Listography jr. Episode where we take a band with a small discography and pair them with others. A Gram Parsons, Judee Sill and Dillard Clark week would be Fire. - Joe
i'd add the 'fantastic expedition of dillard & clark' ...
It’s great
Gene Clark is great .... please do something on John Martyn
Contrary to Joe, I had only heard Gene Clarkes solo stuff BECAUSE of the spotify algorithm. I believe the track was Lifes Greatest Fool. Every track I subsequently heard was of a similar excellent standard. For all the criticism of his musical approach to songwriting (when in the Byrds anyway) I have yet to hear a Gene Clark song I dont like.
When he was writing esrly material in The Byrds he was a 20/21 YO “ kid from Missouri”. Just starting out really. Still, he penned some beautiful classics through that era. 😊💖
Gene Clark…great voice, great singer, great songwriter. Sadly, the quality of his songs went downhill after his masterpiece, I still enjoyed this week a lot!
Okay Albums (2,5 Stars):
7. So Rebellious A Lover
[Not a fan of Carla Olson’s vocals.]
Good Albums (3 Stars):
6. Firebyrd
[‘Tambourine Man’ is great as always, but did we need this version? Some songs are great on here, but it’s inconsistent.]
Great Albums (3,5 Stars):
5. Two Sides to Every Story
[A bit sad to listen to this one after ‘No Other’. Most of the songs are still good, but not mindblowing. ‘Give My Love To Marie’ is the highlight on the album.]
4. Gene Clark with the Gosdin Brothers
[Great start to the album, alright after that.]
Amazing Albums (4,5 Stars):
3. Roadmaster
[A bit more Rock on this one than on ‘White Light’. Awesome stuff.]
2. White Light
[Sounds so different from the debut. Most of the songs are fantastic! Loved it. I actually prefer this version of ‘Tears of Rage’, but the vocal performance is inferior.]
Masterpieces (5 Stars):
1. No Other
[An album like No Other. You could see this as a pun, but it is also true. A unique mix of Country/Folk, Soul and Gospel. He made the best Americana album of all time (if you can call that Americana). Love, love and love it.]
I'm listening to No Other and I like the songs, but Clark's voice seems to me like he's straining to hit the notes a bit. Edit: it does sound like pretty great stuff, though, eccentric country rock.
I have a lot of time for Clark , but I think he generally worked better when collaborating with others , ie the Byrds and then Doug Dillard and Bernie Leadon . Far too often his solo songs are a bit too pedestrian for me , and I long for a bit more energy and joy in his work . Still , when he was on his game he could be great.
I didn’t hear any mention of his masterpiece and in my opinion, his best song ever, Some Misunderstanding. I would have thought that one of you would have waxed eloquently about this song…I thought you could a whole video on that one song only.
I like it a lot, some of his best lyrics… though clearly not my favorite. - Joe
The question is, how many No Other tracks will Joe have on his list tomorrow?
Well it can’t be more than 80%. … - Joe
In a Misty Morning and For a Spanish Guitar seem like locks too.
😂😂😂
Please listen to The White Light Demos........stripped down album proving that the powers that be missed the oppotunity with him when the "Singer Songwriters hit their stride,,MISSED chance by the suits.
Yep 100 listens is believable. It's possibly the best unknown album?