Chelse struggling with the dance reharsal BUT ABSOLUTELY DEMOLISHING the singing reharsal will forever be iconic to me, she came so far in the end, she proved to be a tough competitor and a queen in this show ♥
The girls just picked apart Chelsea's dancing to death because Chelsea is absolutely gorgeous and had a voice from heaven. It's just a lot of jealousy, in my opinion. Yes, Chelsea's dancing needed work, but she's not horrible. You can't have it all. Melissa S. not only struggled immensely with singing, but her attitude was an absolute miss.
@@ditzygypsy Neither Asia, Chelsea, Melissa R. were fit to be in PCD anyway. They'd just end up being back dancers for Nicole. They should have been their own group in the end and let Anastasia or Mariela be a doll. Chelsea did become part of Paradiso Girls under Robin but still they only did 2 songs since Robin ran a girl group factory left and right at that time.
i think the reason melissa s hated on chelsea so much is most likely because she seen something in her that she doesn’t in herself . she was always trying to prove to chelsea that she was better instead of worrying abt herself and the competition . but karma got her when it mattered and she got sent home which was the best part of the entire episode .
Vocal gymnastics - like they said in another episode. When she isn’t trying to do that sound and actually uses her true voice, she’s got pipes. Melissa R has the most unique tone, love it.
She doesn’t have vibrato. She has a Stevie Nicks’-type vocal tick. But she can sing smoothly sometimes. She needs to stick to that, because she is terribly pitchy, and she can’t nail any of the arpeggios at ALL. And she needs to quit that finger twitching nonsense! Ron Fair was right to dislike her all the way through. But they didn’t want a singer or a striking beauty who might outshine Scherzinger like Chelsea or Melissa R.; they merely wanted a background dancer who could pick up moves and routines quickly. They definitely got what they wanted.
I don’t get why Melissa S was so out to get Chelsea. How does Chelsea not being a good dancer really affect her? There is one winner, and at this point it’s every girl for herself. It just seems so pointless to hate on one person so much when they don’t even affect you in the competition or personally.
I think the show just made her out to be a hater so that the show itself can get many views. I’ve read in different articles that the other contestants got along with her in the house. Even Anastasia mentioned that Melissa S. was the sweetie of the house.
See I liked all of them I think if Chelsea didn't sing as good as she is would have been kicked out. I don't care for Melissa s attitude but she was a better dancer than Robin gave her credit for I think. I've watched this loads but still enjoy it. Girlicious isn't bad either.
For me I never thought any of them were perfect for the Pussycat Dolls. Melissa S looked like she would fit in the most, Melissa R had the best attitude, Chelsea had the best voice and Asia had killer dance moves.
I feel bad for Chelsea and how harsh they were on her. She was clearly trying her best and didn’t deserve that criticism. Glad Melissa S was the one sent home that week
I was kind of sad about Chelsea, but really I was always thinking, what the hell she was doing in a show where they try to find a new member for a mainly dancing group??? Chelsea have a great voice, the best of all the contestants but when I think about PCD I only think about dancing, gymnastics move and more. Still Melissa S was annoying . the best definetily was Melissa R.
Chelsea is the ONLY one still working in show buisness. Asia left the group after three months so she could be with her kid... Work that hard and steal a dream from someone who actually wanted it and COULD do it. Like my girl chelsea. Omg she was the beat one from day one.
@@annefontaine3236 That's what the press said, but did that actually come out of Asia's own mouth? Girl needs to do an interview soon cause I'm sure that her NDA is expired by now
IMO Melissa S is lucky to have made it as far as she did, I think she should've been eliminated in the second episode instead of Brittany after she messed up her lyrics For someone who had little to no dance training to have made it as far as Chelsea did shows how hard of a worker she is and also that she's a quick learner, she should be proud of herself
I was very disappointed when they eliminated Brittany in the second episode instead of Melissa. The two were definitely the weakest performers in that challenge, but Melissa took her weakness to the next level when she flubbed the "Crazy in Love" lyrics and looked like a deer in headlights. Frankly, I felt that Melissa should have been held to a slightly higher standard than the other girls because she had already done Making the Band. She made it all the way to the finals on that show, then she came to this one and demonstrated her inability to recover on stage? No, ma'am. Oh well. At least they axed her before Chelsea on this show.
Sometimes it feels like they kept Chelsea as long as they did just so they could keep humiliating her about her sub-par dancing skills. Melissa S. was always mocking her and Mikey was RUTHLESS. "Do you think Nicole would be having that? No, she'd push you over". Like, really? And these girls were supposed to aspire to be in a group with Nicole? This show was entertaining but so damn fake. They were never looking for "the whole package", they were looking for a sexy backup dancer, period.
“This competition isn’t really about being a good person” well don’t worry about it then because you’re not! She’s such a jealous, mediocre, completely forgettable person that doesn’t hold a candle to Chelsea’s talent, beauty, or personality. She was so mean to her because she knows Chelsea is better than her! I think she definitely deserved to go home before the final 3 for sure!
Soy de Lima Perú y veia este reality por MTV mi favorita siempre fue Chelsea me molestaba mucho cuando Melisa S la molestaba xq chelsea no baila como las otras pero a ultimo fue eliminada por chelsea que tenia una exelente voz ❤
It’s hilarious because Chelsea was a better singer by miles ahead than everyone on the show. Melissa could dance and they all could but they were far behind Chelsea. So far behind that Chelsea that Chelsea really only needed to learn the moves and just sing.
does anybody else find it non coincidental that they cut melissa's hair to make her look like chelsea? And than melissa went home because she couldnt outshine chelsea
say what you want about asia she was always helping the other girls and i always liked her as a person. she's was so young here and watching as someone way older now, i can't seem to hate her like i did the first time i watched
None of them listened to Ron when he said to drop the “mask”. They are all singing through their noses because in their head, the bone conduction hearing makes them think it sounds warm and rich, but it sounds stifled and nasally. This is where more experience in the studio and paying attention during playback would benefit them. I’ve worked as a session singer since I was 14, and there is nothing like session work to help you hone your skill and force you to face what you really, truly sound like and fix it.
if i was melissa s i would’ve said asia or melissa r to go home, you want to stand with chelsea in the end cause you know they ain’t gonna pick her 🤷🏻♀️
I dont know why robin was looking for an excellent singer, nicole is the only one who sings anyway. Personally an alrightish singer and amazing dancer should have been selected (Melissa M) even though i hate her attitude. Meliisa R looks similar to Nicole so No, Chelsea gorgeous but cant dance PCD style so No, Asia well she had distractions. MELISSA M should have been selected.
Robin couldn't admit that at the time. It all came out in 2019 or something. In 2007 they were giving interviews belittling anyone who claimed that only Nicole was singing so they had to keep that image going.
Robin could end This reallity show on Episode 5...choosing Mariela. She was the best dancer. Nicole was the only one who were Singing ALL the songs lol
I find it funny that as much as hate Melissa S received, she is quite relevant today even with her mom tik toks and stuff. She also has had music, commercials and I think appeared in a show. She’s quite successful while the rest of the girls were one hit wonders lol. She’s a hustler and we gotta respect that.
Good lord that dude choreographer is just mean for the sake of being mean. Highly unmotivating and wholly unlikeable. That’s never how you get excellent results.
Melissa interpreted the song differently from Ron’s more emotional interpretation . She was cutesy and sexy and kind of sang it how Britney Spears would. Melissa doesn’t have a soul full voice.
Yes I think they did too she had the better voice but Robin probably shouldn't have kept her in as her dancing isn't that great despite improving lol. Jamie should have stayed as least was better overall. Melissa S is kind of right Chelsea should have gone home ages ago. Asia's voice is screechy don't get why she won even though she was a god dancer. Melissa R should have won!
Funny Melissa S keep saying Chelsea can't dance.. but whos been in the bottom 2 basically all of the episodes 😂
i like how melissa r was always sticking up for chelsea and never put her down
That was Asia
Chelse struggling with the dance reharsal BUT ABSOLUTELY DEMOLISHING the singing reharsal will forever be iconic to me, she came so far in the end, she proved to be a tough competitor and a queen in this show ♥
The girls just picked apart Chelsea's dancing to death because Chelsea is absolutely gorgeous and had a voice from heaven. It's just a lot of jealousy, in my opinion. Yes, Chelsea's dancing needed work, but she's not horrible. You can't have it all. Melissa S. not only struggled immensely with singing, but her attitude was an absolute miss.
They picked Asia in the end. They clearly did not want a stunner or an actual singer.
@@ditzygypsy Neither Asia, Chelsea, Melissa R. were fit to be in PCD anyway. They'd just end up being back dancers for Nicole. They should have been their own group in the end and let Anastasia or Mariela be a doll. Chelsea did become part of Paradiso Girls under Robin but still they only did 2 songs since Robin ran a girl group factory left and right at that time.
It was very satisfying seeing Melissa S go home lol
🙌
Exactly. Asia was very kind to help Chelsea.
That's what she get for ruining her mouth
😂
Yes it was. She really thought her shit didn't stink, so naturally, she fumbled.
i think the reason melissa s hated on chelsea so much is most likely because she seen something in her that she doesn’t in herself . she was always trying to prove to chelsea that she was better instead of worrying abt herself and the competition . but karma got her when it mattered and she got sent home which was the best part of the entire episode .
Melissa R represented Filipino-Americans so well. So much talent. I hope she is happy and successful
amen, this performance was the best one in the series. still get chills.
She’s from making the band
@@awesomestar7597Melissa S is not Melissa R.
@@awesomestar7597 Melissa S was from Making The Band
When Asia doesn't force her voice to do all those runs and vibrado, I wanna listen to her.
Fr. I think she was trying to imitate christina aguilera .asia did say that was her idol
Vocal gymnastics - like they said in another episode. When she isn’t trying to do that sound and actually uses her true voice, she’s got pipes.
Melissa R has the most unique tone, love it.
It's funny that she said that this song wasn't right for her voice because this is the best I've heard her!
She doesn’t have vibrato. She has a Stevie Nicks’-type vocal tick. But she can sing smoothly sometimes. She needs to stick to that, because she is terribly pitchy, and she can’t nail any of the arpeggios at ALL. And she needs to quit that finger twitching nonsense! Ron Fair was right to dislike her all the way through. But they didn’t want a singer or a striking beauty who might outshine Scherzinger like Chelsea or Melissa R.; they merely wanted a background dancer who could pick up moves and routines quickly. They definitely got what they wanted.
I don’t get why Melissa S was so out to get Chelsea. How does Chelsea not being a good dancer really affect her? There is one winner, and at this point it’s every girl for herself. It just seems so pointless to hate on one person so much when they don’t even affect you in the competition or personally.
@Chris Moranchel same with Jenna. It’s kind if weird though considering Melody couldn’t really dance all of the PCD choreography either.
She was just a hater because no matter how many shows, commercials, etc, ultimately nobody wanted her lol 🤭😂
Melissa S was such a hater for no damn reason lmao
Oh no there is a reason hunny
I think the show just made her out to be a hater so that the show itself can get many views.
I’ve read in different articles that the other contestants got along with her in the house. Even Anastasia mentioned that Melissa S. was the sweetie of the house.
See I liked all of them I think if Chelsea didn't sing as good as she is would have been kicked out. I don't care for Melissa s attitude but she was a better dancer than Robin gave her credit for I think. I've watched this loads but still enjoy it. Girlicious isn't bad either.
So was Chelsea in regards to Anastasia
@@karmabutterfly7985 How come? I’m sorry if I’m coming off as rude but I’m just really curious
For me I never thought any of them were perfect for the Pussycat Dolls. Melissa S looked like she would fit in the most, Melissa R had the best attitude, Chelsea had the best voice and Asia had killer dance moves.
I feel bad for Chelsea and how harsh they were on her. She was clearly trying her best and didn’t deserve that criticism.
Glad Melissa S was the one sent home that week
most satisfying moment in tv history when melissa went home
I agree lol
My favorite is Melissa S. Being a hater and getting sent home… lol again!
Lol
We all knew that Melissa S hated Chelsea
I was kind of sad about Chelsea, but really I was always thinking, what the hell she was doing in a show where they try to find a new member for a mainly dancing group??? Chelsea have a great voice, the best of all the contestants but when I think about PCD I only think about dancing, gymnastics move and more. Still Melissa S was annoying . the best definetily was Melissa R.
If Asia would stop over singing and over using her vibrato she’d be fine
Its absolutely mind-blowing how good lil kim is correcting singing mistakes, mean that she is not a real singer. Love lil kim.❤
Chelsea is the ONLY one still working in show buisness. Asia left the group after three months so she could be with her kid... Work that hard and steal a dream from someone who actually wanted it and COULD do it. Like my girl chelsea. Omg she was the beat one from day one.
Do you know what Chelsea is up to now?
@Mrs Davis true!
Melissa S is an actress
Actually Asia left the group purchase her solo career.
@@annefontaine3236 That's what the press said, but did that actually come out of Asia's own mouth? Girl needs to do an interview soon cause I'm sure that her NDA is expired by now
Every time Asia sings I CRINGE
Me too. She and Melody could just scream at each other whilst everyone else does the business.
I never liked Melissa S but I just noticed that she really did the best dancing during the group performance
IMO Melissa S is lucky to have made it as far as she did, I think she should've been eliminated in the second episode instead of Brittany after she messed up her lyrics
For someone who had little to no dance training to have made it as far as Chelsea did shows how hard of a worker she is and also that she's a quick learner, she should be proud of herself
I was very disappointed when they eliminated Brittany in the second episode instead of Melissa. The two were definitely the weakest performers in that challenge, but Melissa took her weakness to the next level when she flubbed the "Crazy in Love" lyrics and looked like a deer in headlights. Frankly, I felt that Melissa should have been held to a slightly higher standard than the other girls because she had already done Making the Band. She made it all the way to the finals on that show, then she came to this one and demonstrated her inability to recover on stage? No, ma'am. Oh well. At least they axed her before Chelsea on this show.
The last few episodes Melissa S annoyed tf out of me. So insecure when it came to Chelsea. I was glad when she finally went home.
Melissa was right chelsea was on a swing.
Melissa S and Chelsea commercial part was so tense between the 2 🤣
I loved the show but I’m also glad this show was a joke cause at the end of the day we never saw the “winner” as a Doll neither with the PCD lol 😂😂😂
YAS 😂 Robin is so problematic 😮💨
We did but only for a very short time, like a couple months. Asia quit to be with her daughter.
Sometimes it feels like they kept Chelsea as long as they did just so they could keep humiliating her about her sub-par dancing skills. Melissa S. was always mocking her and Mikey was RUTHLESS. "Do you think Nicole would be having that? No, she'd push you over". Like, really? And these girls were supposed to aspire to be in a group with Nicole? This show was entertaining but so damn fake. They were never looking for "the whole package", they were looking for a sexy backup dancer, period.
Yep. A blend-in-the-crowd, silent, backup dancer. That’s what they chose.
“This competition isn’t really about being a good person” well don’t worry about it then because you’re not! She’s such a jealous, mediocre, completely forgettable person that doesn’t hold a candle to Chelsea’s talent, beauty, or personality. She was so mean to her because she knows Chelsea is better than her! I think she definitely deserved to go home before the final 3 for sure!
They filmed the Beep dance performance multiple times. Look at Chelsea’s hood, it’s on then off then on then off.
Soy de Lima Perú y veia este reality por MTV mi favorita siempre fue Chelsea me molestaba mucho cuando Melisa S la molestaba xq chelsea no baila como las otras pero a ultimo fue eliminada por chelsea que tenia una exelente voz ❤
Melissa S was obsessed with Chelsea
me too girl she's not alone
Damn Chelsea did so good
It’s hilarious because Chelsea was a better singer by miles ahead than everyone on the show. Melissa could dance and they all could but they were far behind Chelsea. So far behind that Chelsea that Chelsea really only needed to learn the moves and just sing.
does anybody else find it non coincidental that they cut melissa's hair to make her look like chelsea? And than melissa went home because she couldnt outshine chelsea
Very strange indeed. I always used to wonder if Melissa S was secretly jealous of the attention that Chelsea was getting?
Omg Asia had the worst voice ☠ but of course for the PCD they needed a new backup dancer, not a singer
Asia was my favorite and the baddest
Melissa S. was just jealous if Chelsea.😖
Obviously!
WHY WAS MELISSA S DOING THE COMMERCIAL LIKE THAT LMAO
Melissa talking about Chelsea cannot dance yet Melissa cannot sing lol.
Well Melissa can sing but Chelsea is way better then her at singing
@@raumaankingMelissa’s singing is a 4.5/10
say what you want about asia she was always helping the other girls and i always liked her as a person. she's was so young here and watching as someone way older now, i can't seem to hate her like i did the first time i watched
None of them listened to Ron when he said to drop the “mask”. They are all singing through their noses because in their head, the bone conduction hearing makes them think it sounds warm and rich, but it sounds stifled and nasally. This is where more experience in the studio and paying attention during playback would benefit them. I’ve worked as a session singer since I was 14, and there is nothing like session work to help you hone your skill and force you to face what you really, truly sound like and fix it.
Let's hold hands 😂😂😂
wow asia is really a bad singer way too much all the time
if i was melissa s i would’ve said asia or melissa r to go home, you want to stand with chelsea in the end cause you know they ain’t gonna pick her 🤷🏻♀️
Imo
1. Melissa R
2. Asia
3. Chelsea
4. Melissa S
Melissa S is Canadian lol…polite Canadians my arse
on behalf of Canada, I am embarrassed for her. She was so rude.
I dont know why robin was looking for an excellent singer, nicole is the only one who sings anyway. Personally an alrightish singer and amazing dancer should have been selected (Melissa M) even though i hate her attitude. Meliisa R looks similar to Nicole so No, Chelsea gorgeous but cant dance PCD style so No, Asia well she had distractions. MELISSA M should have been selected.
It’s Melissa S but kinda agree
Robin couldn't admit that at the time. It all came out in 2019 or something. In 2007 they were giving interviews belittling anyone who claimed that only Nicole was singing so they had to keep that image going.
Yes! Melissa S should’ve won. To me she was the closest to a pussycat doll. She was catty and annoying sometimes but for some reason I like her.
Kinda sexist to think just because Asia had a child she couldn't be a Pussycat Doll
Robin could end This reallity show on Episode 5...choosing Mariela. She was the best dancer. Nicole was the only one who were Singing ALL the songs lol
Asia was definitelly very pitchy....let's be clear here...🤷
The backing vocals ruined the performances
It’s pre-recorded with auto tune!!! Lololol
Omg Melissa S looks like a complete psycho in this episode. She was in witch mode when Asia helped chelsea
I find it funny that as much as hate Melissa S received, she is quite relevant today even with her mom tik toks and stuff. She also has had music, commercials and I think appeared in a show. She’s quite successful while the rest of the girls were one hit wonders lol. She’s a hustler and we gotta respect that.
Melissa S was better than I thought lol... at least they gave them songs that suit them for once
I'm so glad Melissa S went home! She was SO bitchy and mean... not a nice girl AT ALL.
Karma!
Asia should’ve never helped Chelsea. But she was being the sweetheart that she is.
Good lord that dude choreographer is just mean for the sake of being mean. Highly unmotivating and wholly unlikeable. That’s never how you get excellent results.
of course kim had to put Chelsea(there as nothing wrong with her singing)
Does anybody know the song at 40:53?
Mikey still picking on Chelsea..
Melissa interpreted the song differently from Ron’s more emotional interpretation . She was cutesy and sexy and kind of sang it how Britney Spears would. Melissa doesn’t have a soul full voice.
Hahahahahahahaaaa
I was so glad when melissa S left... I hated her personnality...
Funny how awful they sing without auto tune!!
Melissa S shouldn’t have been the one to leave. She is literally top two along with Melissa r! This show was so backwards.
Asia was the only one that looked and danced like a Pussycat Doll to me
They kept Chelsea way too long. Plus those bangs are distracting
Yes I think they did too she had the better voice but Robin probably shouldn't have kept her in as her dancing isn't that great despite improving lol. Jamie should have stayed as least was better overall. Melissa S is kind of right Chelsea should have gone home ages ago. Asia's voice is screechy don't get why she won even though she was a god dancer. Melissa R should have won!
Chelsea was the only good one of this bunch but yeah ok ...
@@katharinebisset8348 melissa R was flat at singing and dancing ... she is so overrated lol. You want a dancer ? Mariella was the ONLY one.