@@s.kurass the guitar and the dance break made the whole thing felt way less repetitive to me. Even the repeated chorus at the end was super satisfying. I've been listening to this version a lot eversince it existed
@@TheSinlessAssassin i totally agree with you and the person above, but i still feel like they should upload it seperate like blackpink would do and call it like stage version or a remix
going to aespa concert is the best thing i had done The performances and stage arrangements are so cool plus the members put so many efforts in every performance and it's really worth spending money on tickets.
WOW…. What an amazing rendition. Loved the rock influence and I never knew winter can shred on guitar like that!!! What a talent!! Also… sorry but NingNing main slayer.. she was born to perform… her performance in this shows she’s more than capable of being a main vocal, main dancer, center, and face of the group. She OOZES star power and charisma. Her dance is so sharp and studied too. A true ACE
@@karinalixsiblings Not even a single like for ur comment. It proves that no one agrees. The commenter just spits the truth. Don’t be m.a.d, Karina’s fan. First, The fact that Ningning is the only main slayer in aespa is acknowledged by many people. That’s why Ningning was the only one trending no.1 on twi in america when performing in Coachella. Second, Ningning’s official position is the main vocalist, so yeah, Ningning’s singing ability wins every other member in aespa. For this, you can watch behind-the-scene recording of “Time after time”. Third, Ningning’s dancing is also praised by many people, especially in illusion and girls comeback. To be honest, Karina is not a strong main dancer, especially compared with sunbae main dancers in s.m company. Karina really doesn’t have a dominance in dancing in aespa. Fourth, Ningning is the only aespa member who get ranked in “The 100 most beautiful faces” since debut, and a lot of people also think Ningning is the prettiest member, so yeah, she can be a strong visual.
Not even a single like for ur comment. It proves that no one agrees. The commenter just spits the truth. Don’t be m.a.d, Karina’s fan. First, The fact that Ningning is the only main slayer in aespa is acknowledged by many people. That’s why Ningning was the only one trending no.1 on twi in america when performing in Coachella. Second, Ningning’s official position is the main vocalist, so yeah, Ningning’s singing ability wins every other member in aespa. For this, you can watch behind-the-scene recording of “Time after time”. Third, Ningning’s dancing is also praised by many people, especially in illusion and girls comeback. To be honest, Karina is not a strong main dancer, especially compared with sunbae main dancers in s.m company. Karina really doesn’t have a dominance in dancing in aespa. Fourth, Ningning is the only aespa member who get ranked in “The 100 most beautiful faces” since debut, and a lot of people also think Ningning is the prettiest member, so yeah, she can be a strong visual.
Y'all sleeping on ningning? She literally showed that she is capable of everything her solo performance rap was awesome and the dance break tho she slayed she's really a lead dancer material 😫❤️🔥
Aespa is the perfect mix of my three favorite music genres, rock, electronic, and kpop ♡ I still believe they are underrated, their songs are so fresh and energetic
this is mental... girls was a long song anyways but they made it longer and performed it perfectly. usually girl groups have more than 4 members so they share out the vocals but with 4 members and the dance - all i know is aespa is crazy talented... i just hope in this way their talent is truly appreciated across kpop and the world too.
Ningning giving enough amount of energy, vibe, expression, stage presence and blending. She knows how to get attention. Indeed born to form. They all did well and improved a lot. Love this vesion
Ngl making sub unit for those 2 would just make the favoritsm more obvious and worse. MYs already tired of it and some of them even became a solo stan instead. It's better for them to do solo debut instead of sub unit
can't wait to see them perform this again on a future concert. This version is amazing, but no matter how much i love the girls i can't deny there's a significant lack of stage presence and energy. Lots of groups perform awkwardly in the beginning, then have impressive growths as they gather experience. I'm sure aespa will too, they're so talented after all and this song is epic!
![[MMA2023] aespa FULL Performance | #TrickorTrick #Drama #MMA2023](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/PI-bhsvHdxM/mqdefault.jpg)
![[MMA2023] aespa FULL Performance | #TrickorTrick #Drama #MMA2023](/img/tr.png)
![[HD] aespa NINGNING "Wake Up" Solo Stage Performance (Concert Ver.)](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/sdiekFzgMcs/mqdefault.jpg)
![[2024 KWDA] aespa (에스파) - Supernova + Armageddon](/img/1.gif)
This performance is a masterpiece...TT
Winter's high pitch OMG...
1:30 and 4:38 Winter already was my bias, but BRO after that solo and this insane high note. She's my favorite of all time
Winter dance, rap, vocal, sp, visual, and electric guitar OMG 👑👑👑💗💗💗💗💗
Winter was the highlight here like the high note and the electric guitar also Karina slayed the dance break with ningning + Giselle charisma here
Had no idea Winter could play guitar like that!!! It is awesome!!! Need more of that!
winter was the most praised member during the concert
Winter guitarist 🔥🔥 The intro of guitar Winter is so cool!!
이 무대를 위해 얼마나 많이 연습했을 지... 너무 멋있다 컴백 첫주 때 안무 하나도 안 맞고 라이브 못한다고 욕 먹은게 엊그제 같은데 이 노래 너무 좋아하는 나로서는 너무 마음에 들고 감동적인 무대 ㅠㅠ
이거 어떤 프로임?
@@anmvx2534 콘서트 한거임
립싱크인데요?
@@astella525 라이브임 이거 댄브에 숨소리 다들림
winter is really the hidden ace of aespa
I need this version to have a release on a album
Fr😢
It might be in their new album...
hope that they will release the concert live album
me too, but i think they wil not 😭
They will, after the tour they probably will release it
best version of Girls, they should release this version instead of the original, it has more layers and more alive
people will find it too long and repetitive, imo this version could be only used for special stages like these
@@s.kurass the guitar and the dance break made the whole thing felt way less repetitive to me. Even the repeated chorus at the end was super satisfying. I've been listening to this version a lot eversince it existed
@@s.kurass I like long songs and would love it as it is.
@@TheSinlessAssassin i totally agree with you and the person above, but i still feel like they should upload it seperate like blackpink would do and call it like stage version or a remix
They should at least add the guitar solo or change the choreo from the chorus to th choreo for th last part of the song, it's top good 💜
Winter being the ace and she owned/owning the Girls era. Love them all
I’m obsessed with this version
Same
The instrumental just... 🔥🔥🔥
yesss... same 🥰🥰
AGREEEEEEE
And Winter holding that note was also awesome!!!
the best version of girls
going to aespa concert is the best thing i had done
The performances and stage arrangements are so cool
plus the members put so many efforts in every performance and it's really worth spending money on tickets.
왔구나 반가워 재밌었지
I'm jealous 😢😢😢
WINTER SLAYED IN THE GUITAR IM LITERALLY DYING 😨
Aespa are queens of dance , Voice , rap , visual ❤
WOW…. What an amazing rendition. Loved the rock influence and I never knew winter can shred on guitar like that!!! What a talent!! Also… sorry but NingNing main slayer.. she was born to perform… her performance in this shows she’s more than capable of being a main vocal, main dancer, center, and face of the group. She OOZES star power and charisma. Her dance is so sharp and studied too. A true ACE
Winter likes to instruments when she was younger before becoming idol 😊
I first really noticed Ning Nings dancing 💃 at Coachella. She was tearing it up!
She can be what you said in another group not in aespa
@@karinalixsiblings Not even a single like for ur comment. It proves that no one agrees. The commenter just spits the truth. Don’t be m.a.d, Karina’s fan.
First, The fact that Ningning is the only main slayer in aespa is acknowledged by many people. That’s why Ningning was the only one trending no.1 on twi in america when performing in Coachella. Second, Ningning’s official position is the main vocalist, so yeah, Ningning’s singing ability wins every other member in aespa. For this, you can watch behind-the-scene recording of “Time after time”. Third, Ningning’s dancing is also praised by many people, especially in illusion and girls comeback. To be honest, Karina is not a strong main dancer, especially compared with sunbae main dancers in s.m company. Karina really doesn’t have a dominance in dancing in aespa. Fourth, Ningning is the only aespa member who get ranked in “The 100 most beautiful faces” since debut, and a lot of people also think Ningning is the prettiest member, so yeah, she can be a strong visual.
Not even a single like for ur comment. It proves that no one agrees. The commenter just spits the truth. Don’t be m.a.d, Karina’s fan.
First, The fact that Ningning is the only main slayer in aespa is acknowledged by many people. That’s why Ningning was the only one trending no.1 on twi in america when performing in Coachella. Second, Ningning’s official position is the main vocalist, so yeah, Ningning’s singing ability wins every other member in aespa. For this, you can watch behind-the-scene recording of “Time after time”. Third, Ningning’s dancing is also praised by many people, especially in illusion and girls comeback. To be honest, Karina is not a strong main dancer, especially compared with sunbae main dancers in s.m company. Karina really doesn’t have a dominance in dancing in aespa. Fourth, Ningning is the only aespa member who get ranked in “The 100 most beautiful faces” since debut, and a lot of people also think Ningning is the prettiest member, so yeah, she can be a strong visual.
ITS SUCH A HUGE CRIME IF SM DO NOT RELEASE THIS VERSION OFFICIALLY ON RUclips OR SPOTIFY ISTG
Aespa is insane for this version of GIRLS ...... OMGGGG.....They have improved in their stage presence soooooo much..... Aespa is unbeatable
This version is so daaaamn good
3:28 THIS IS EVEN BETTER THAN THE ORIGINAL, AND THE GUITAR SOLO WAS MORE THAN AMAZING
The members said that Winter bled her fingers while practicing Girls on electric guitar! She's so awesome!!
Watching winter playing that guitar makes me feel things
Ningning's vocal, dance, stage presence, everything is on point.
링링 한국에서 가장인기 없어
그저 중국 공산당 나라 사람들 앨범 판매용이야
한국인들은 중화사상을 싫어해
가창력과 청순함은 winter 가 더 좋고
비주얼과 댄스는 karina 더 잘하고
Y'all sleeping on ningning? She literally showed that she is capable of everything her solo performance rap was awesome and the dance break tho she slayed she's really a lead dancer material 😫❤️🔥
What solo performance? That was winter
Winter plays the guitar she is really good at it 👌 go Winter
1:41 Winter...Wow...
Aespa is the perfect mix of my three favorite music genres, rock, electronic, and kpop ♡
I still believe they are underrated, their songs are so fresh and energetic
They really put the hype in Hyperline 😍🤩❤️🔥
Winter is definitely talented.
AAHHH NINGNING DANCE BREAK I SCREAMED ON MY PHONE I CANT IMAGINE WHAT ID DO IF I SEE THAT LIVE!!!! SEE YOU IN KVERSE PH MY GIRLS I LOVE YOU
If only all 4 members did it, the energy built with Ningning then abruptly ended…
winter really upped her stage presence wow
4:15 hold up 할때 닝닝이랑 카리나 혼합 너무 좋다
this is mental... girls was a long song anyways but they made it longer and performed it perfectly. usually girl groups have more than 4 members so they share out the vocals but with 4 members and the dance - all i know is aespa is crazy talented... i just hope in this way their talent is truly appreciated across kpop and the world too.
Winter is amazing 👏 AESPA YOU ROCK 🎸 YES YES YES YES 👍
I'm a fan of any good music, without any particular interest in "K-pop". But Aespa - THESE girls are 🔥🔥.
Ningning was born to be on the stage! Every time she performs she gave her all. Look at the expression, vocals and dang she dances so well and good!
I think that 'Girls' is a special and powerful for Aespa and for us ❤
Too much Epic truly
Winter wow es muy talentosa
Winter EXTENDING her note :D
Just imagine if this was performed at Coachella 💥💥💥
Ningning giving enough amount of energy, vibe, expression, stage presence and blending. She knows how to get attention. Indeed born to form. They all did well and improved a lot. Love this vesion
編曲もダンスもギターもなにもかもかっこよすぎ…
Those outfits are everything! They all look so beautiful like badass fairy queens and I'm OBSESSED
I'm obsessed with ninging's dance break ❤
Winter me arrepiou que talento, muito boa mesmo!!🤩
winter's dance 🔥
The strings make this song so much more aggressive than it already is 😮😮😮 what a production change ~
Gila sumpah keren banget mereka. Berharap mereka nampilin di acara live atau award.
Wow this concert is insane
i’m so glad they finally get to preform a different version of their song 😭
Winter playing the guitar so cool
에스파 첨보자마자 너무좋아했는데 SES이후로 처음좋아하게된 여돌♡
이모팬이 응원합니다♡
락 버전 편곡 끝내준다.. girls가 이렇게 좋은 곡이었나?
넘 좋다
This extended version, especially the Dance Break Part was Chefs Kiss🤌🏻
Winter in electric guitar got me dead
This is like MAMA’s performance wow
콘서트 버전 걸스 언제 내줘요.. 현기증 나요
This is what I call Music !
They’re so good at singing live 😍
They are, but this one is pre-recorded vocals.
Winter❤❤❤❤❤❤
Winter is a ace in aespa hee and ningning like come on
The people screaming 😱 when winter did the high note
THEY SLAYED THIS
just when i thought that winter couldn’t get any cooler 😂
Omg this is crazy. They like... totally slayed. Wow.
i love aespa
I can already see Karina and Winter forming a sub unit in the future.
What about the others?
她们一共四个人肯定是各自solo啊
No winter and nining sub unit their vocal, sp and dance
Ngl making sub unit for those 2 would just make the favoritsm more obvious and worse. MYs already tired of it and some of them even became a solo stan instead. It's better for them to do solo debut instead of sub unit
@@vim2339 winter is so talented that no matter what sub unit she will be in, she will surely slay
My goshhh I can't get over Winterrr
ミンジョンカッコ良すぎる！
i love this more than the original ❤
Wow.. Aespa is always amazing
Winter did so well here
Aespa girls are so talented
Winter, I am fallin to you more ❤️
Ok ! These GIRLS are on fire !!!!!
Did that just happen - Winter on lead rock guitar? Delightful ~
Mothers ate once again😍😍 and winter with the solo they ATEEE
Winter is good at everything❤
The way ningning do a breakdance and follow by highnote as expected she slay it.🔥 she’s da real queen.
4:17 나 이거 첫콘때부터….계속봄 팔돌리기가 너무 좋음 그냥
3:31 she was starving so she ate that high note up, no actually she devoured.
This version is insane
🔥🔥 𝐚𝐞𝐬𝐩𝐚 🔥🔥
SLAY. ATE. NO CRUMBS LEFT. CLEAN PLATE. STILL HUNGRY
can't wait to see them perform this again on a future concert. This version is amazing, but no matter how much i love the girls i can't deny there's a significant lack of stage presence and energy.
Lots of groups perform awkwardly in the beginning, then have impressive growths as they gather experience. I'm sure aespa will too, they're so talented after all and this song is epic!
Winter 🎸🔥🔥🔥🔥🔥
This version is so cool. Always love their performances 🙌🏻
ningning slaying as always
Their stage presence here girls are mad
if this was the original ver. this would have slapped the charts
Those layered added instruments, so fcking satisfying so ikr
@@anonymous.13334 yeahhh, this was what the original was lacking tbh T^T, they alr had a decent key sound, it just lacked personality T^T
This version sounds so much like a game soundtrack!!!
praying so hard that there will be a studio version of this 😭🙏🙏
こうして、冬子沼にどんどんハマっていくのです😆
처음에 딱딱 맞는 거 쾌감 쩐다
They are so beautiful!
THIS IS SOOO GOOD, WE NEED THIS RELEASED AND PERFFORMED MORE OFTEN
Aespa really gave his name, with this performance.
This would happen to aespa if SM is giving all members with their fullest potential. I’m still hoping