I'm planning to retire at 59 in another country outside the US that is free, safe and very cheap with a high quality of life and good healthcare. I could fully just rely on only my SS if I wanted to when that times arrives but l'll also have at least one pension, a 403 (b) and a very prolific Investment account with my Stephanie Stiefel my FA. Retiring comfortably in the US these days is almost impossible
I know this lady you just mentioned. Stephanie Janis Stiefel is a portfolio manager and investment advisor. She gained recognition as an employee of neuberger berman; a renowned investor she is. Stephanie Janis Stiefel has demonstrated expertise in investment strategies and has been involved in managing portfolios and providing guidance to clients.
I’m planning on moving to Thailand in the next 5 years if trump’s government doesn’t do anything with the high prices of groceries and taxes What about you??
She doesn't have to be a citizen. Trump is and that gives Barron citizenship. Elon isn't a natural born citizen and can be deported for certain infractions.
Trump is a citizen so therefore his children are also citizens. If one person is illegally here and one is a citizen the children still have citizenship
@gagelong3366 um no. That's the term "family separation." His last term, Trump deported the one parent, 99% the bread winner of the family, who was here illegally. Undocumented, is a false word, because many immigrants have tax ID numbers and file tax returns, but just cannot get any money back until they become a citizen. All the taxes paid by immigrants suddenly gone, will destroy our small cities and communities.
@@gagelong3366 mr$$$ melmac trump had her ANCHOR BABY to pave her way . trump can start by sending her and kid to slovakia as soon as she wants a divorce.
@@ListenUpDemocracyVivek’s father never got and refuses to this day to get his citizenship. So that would put Vivek and his father right in the crosshairs.
To the Republican party, there is strength in numbers if you ever want to stand up to a bully and his threats, because Donald Trump cannot primary everybody.
How is ending birthright citizens being nasty. I don't know what Rick this guy has been under. But I've watched millions of dollars being allocated to illegal aliens in my community for years. Program upon program, set up specifically to assist them with everything. The school systems funded tutors for the children; they are placed right in the classrooms. Which is a distraction and slows down the learning process. Forty plus million came in unvetted and they need to go. Everyone is questioning where funding is going to come from to deport them. Well ... The same fund Biden used to expedite them in illegally.
His children don't even talk to him. Elon is against Transgender and his boy is one. His son even changed his name because he doesn't want to be affiliated with his father's name.
No, it does not. His wife is a naturalized citizen (she can be deported for certain infractions) and his son was born of one citizen parent and automatically has citizenship.
they are white. my family has been here since the 1600s but Vivek Ramaswamy and Nikki Hayley think I don't belong here bc I am black. I know black people with lighter skin than him. the irony.
His son was born here to a U.S. citizen. People regularly come in on vacation visas just to get US citizenship for their unborn babies. That is totally different but your hatred of Trump won’t let you admit that.
Trump's own mother came and wasn't a citizen for a long time, either. I think this is a woman-hating thing with him, tbh. One of those guys who calls immigration services if his foreign-born woman isn't "behaving." 🙄
Hardly, anchor babies are to prevent being deported for illegal immigrants, which neither Trump nor his wife are. Check your trump hatred. Your logic is hilariously flawed.
I am a dual French American citizen !! I was born in Verdun where my father, a Michigan born natural Citizen, was serving in the US Army. I didn’t know I was French until 1980!! I am absolutely for natural born citizenship. Waiting to see whether or not stupid will send US Soldiers to die in Panama!! Thank you !!😊
French people have neither the courage nor heart to defend themselves or their country! Leave ours alone and go learn German! Without the US there would be no France!!!!
No we're going to find out if the scrotus is going to make law again, instead of their ACTUAL job, interpreting laws that exist in the real world. I love to see them show me where it says the president has immunity for committing crimes
The part of the 14th Amendment that affirmatively states that the freed slaves are citizens was key because the Supreme Court ruled in the Dred Scott case that they were not citizens. So the 14th Amendment overturned the Dred Scott decision.
Harry, the two judges that Trump appointed to the Supreme Court both said that Roe v.s. Wade was establised law during their confirmation hearings, but later voted to repeal it. Is there any way that they could be charged for lying during the hearings?
They might be able to impeach them for lying to Congress, which is a crime. Won't happen until we get both houses of Congress back. So I'm betting on 2026
Hi Harry, I'd like to see you address HR 6976, a law that would make DUIs and even wet reckless immediately and retroactively deportable offenses, and make it so that person could never come back to the US. It's apparently passed the House and is headed to the Senate. I work in the court system as a Certified Spanish interpreter and the lawyers I work with are just getting continuances for their cases to wait and see what happens with this law.
You don't want to do that. It requires brain trauma... AND your body will suffer and age faster just laying in one place all the time. Yes you will survive chRump being lucid. The nation is counting on you.
My family came here legally. They can here before the the Chinese Exclusion Act of 1882, the first migration law. Most conservatives are too ignorant to learn from histroy. "In the mid-nineteenth century, many Americans began to feel threatened by an increase in immigration from China to the United States. Reasons for this included xenophobia, or dislike of foreigners, as well as more complex causes such as labor tensions and shifting national identities. Working-class Americans and European immigrants worried that Chinese immigrants would compete unfairly for their jobs by working for lower wages. Irish immigrant railroad laborers in particular found themselves in competition with Chinese workers, as both groups struggled at the lower end of the wage scale."
AND, unemployment is a policy outcome. There is no real reason for anyone who wants to work, to be unemployed. The US can never run out of the money it creates. But inflation, you say? Wrong again.
@@erickborling1302 "The main causes of structural unemployment are: Technological advancements, fundamental changes in consumer preferences, globalization and competition, and education and skill mismatches."
An overlooked problem that caused the exclusion act was that the immigrants for China at that time were from a different part of China than the area that the previous immigrant railway workers came from, and didn't mix well with the existing culture. Also a significant number of the Chinese immigrants of that era were daughters of Chinese families sold to brokers who brought them to the US to sell for prostitution. Instead of vetting them, the solution was to shut it down. Watch the movie "Broken Trail." It's story includes this issue.
@@chashue6032 it doesn’t matter whether one or both parents are native born or immigrant, doesn’t matter their status, as long as the kid is born in America, which Barron was, in Manhattan specifically, he’s an American citizen just like the rest of us who have immigrant ancestors.
Kicking out illegal immigrants is not racism. We have had an influx of illegal immigrants from China and other countries, not just Mexico. Race has nothing to do with it. Apply to come, not just come in illegally or have your baby born here while on a tourist visa.
Anyone born in the U.S. is an American citizen! Doesn’t matter which parent is an immigrant or not, legal or not. Born on U.S. soil you’re a citizen. Why that’s such a hard concept is baffling.
@@lisashapiro9165 The United States recognizes two bases for birthright citizenship: in addition to being born in the United States, there's being born to one or more US citizens, irrespective of where in the world one is born. If a US-citizen artist working in, say, Nairobi gives birth there, the US considers her child her child a US citizen and she can apply at the nearest US embassy or consulate for a US State Department form certifying the child's birth as a citizen. That form, rather than the local birth certificate, will subsequently serve as the child's legal US birth certificate.
I read that DJT's paternal grandfather lied on his application for immigration when he arrived from Germany. Does it have any implication on DJT's status?
So what would happen if white billionaire American born citizens have a child while out of the country on their yacht? Would Trump consider the child to have American citizenship?
If Switerland holds that a person can claim Swiss citizenship by virtue of having been born to Swiss nationals, and if your parents hadn't yet applied for US citizenship at the time of your birth, the answer might be "yes". There may also be an age limit before which one needs to apply.
the fact is without birthright citizenship, how do you prove you are a citizen? being born here doesn't prove anything. Now do you have to prove your parents were born here? What if they weren't? Do you have to prove they immigrated legally, in 1940? This idea is almost entirely unworkable.
What about “Malaria’s Einstein VISA”issue. What is her qualification for receiving a VISA that is reserved for individuals with extraordinary intelligence?
@ 💯 We really need to get to a point where money can’t buy you freedom or special treatment. I’m trying to stay optimistic but Trumpy is an animal. He only answers to himself. His brain is so fried that he can’t even understand himself. Narcissistic individuals are toxic.
Easiest Trump lie easy to dubunk " No other country does this (grants birthright citizenship)" - when in fact there are about 30 other countries that do this.
If the birthright children wanted to remain, would the government have to pay room & board for them until they turn 21? I have 2 spare bedrooms and no income! This $86 billion program could be a godsend! I think $750 a week is reasonable plus the govt pay the healthcare, clothing, and allowances for these legal Americans who they’re leaving parentless
I think there needs to be a change to our “birthright citizenship”. There are people who come here specifically to have their children get US citizenship. A system more like that in the UK is probably what we need to adopt. For foreigners who give birth there, citizenship is given to the child only if the parents are “settled” at the time of birth. That means that they have permanent housing, and at least one parent is legally working (studying?) or has the “right to remain”. This makes far more sense than some of the birth tourism we currently have.
In order to do what you are saying The Constitution has to be amended.That is going to be EXTREMELY hard to do The constitution doesn’t care what you may think ..Thank God
Not what our Constitution says. If you want it changed, contact your elected representatives and suggest they work on a bill…just FYI, it’s very difficult to make a new Amendment or change an existing one.
@ I understand that it’s not the law, and I know how hard it is to get amendments passed (ERA). I just wanted to provide a moderated response to all the craziness. I do think we need to look into citizenship, as times have changed and there are people who try to abuse the system.
Nope im gen x. Birthright citizenship means pregnant women gose into labor runs across the border pops out a baby and screems my baby is a us citizen. That was a huge problem in the 80s.
I love the diversity of our people! That way I get to eat all of their great foods!!!😋 "So where are you from?" Says stuff about themselves... "Oh I see! Can you translate that into foods and flavors"?😆
I enjoy learning about the finer points of these legal issues. It’s very good that you discuss these things. The more we average folks cal learn about these things, the better placed we will be to form our own opinions and conclusions. So, thank you!
It appears that this would create a category of "stateless" people. I believe it would be up to one or both parents to actually register their child's birth at the embassy or consulate of the country in which they hold nationality. But what if they don't do that ? What nationality would the child have ? Cuba for one is not even taking back its own citizens who've fled abroad not to mention any child born abroad. This is truly insane and illegal.
We have to remember that Federalist Society judges are activist judges and good Republicans, too. If they want to reinterpret the language -- calling it originalism -- they will do it if it fits their agenda and within their moral and ethical framework which isn't a very good one, to say the least. Look at what they did with presidential immunity. Further, there is a Southern flavor to the Federalist Society so there might be a larger reason to reinterpret the 14 Amendment to fit into their longer-term agenda like the Red States not providing education or vouchers for temporary resident workers or in the case of the Christian nationalist judge's values to deny citizenship to non-citizen US soldiers, their wives, and families to denying things like social security benefits to green card holders or habeas corpus protection. It was religious people and judges who went along with the Third Reich in the 1930s.
Hi Harry,, my name is Christy Clarke. As a student of the Nuremberg trials, can we not charge Trump and Company with crimes against humanity and crimes against peace. Have we learned nothing.
My country stopped birthright citizenship at the same time it made work visas for seasonal workers (people to harvest crops). That seems sensible. Then your immigration is people you decide, not low skill labourers who happen to have a baby with a local while working.
To the person who thought Melania wasn’t a citizen when Barron was born she got her citizenship the year he was born in Manhattan! Citizen or not if you’re born on U.S. soil you ARE an American! Smarten up!
Aside from the possibility of trying to bring this issues to the Supreme Court’s adjudication of those children’s citizenship; we also need to have a full accountability of the children that were taken out of the arms of the parents that were sent out away, or into this Nation’s arms and disappeared as far as the National events are concerned! All of those children need to be brought to justice at the Supreme Court’s processes and adjudicated for their rights and freedoms to be respected! Aside from the aforementioned issue, the 14th amendment Section 3 , must be enforced just as the forefathers of this Nation intended! Aside from the fact that they have been violated or protected they are to be considered Americans since this is the Nation, if still viable, regardless of the status at the entry of their parents, this is the only nation those children are cognizant of belonging! We are not in Russia or any other nation that have horrible practices, where their identities are obliterated, we are better than that as Americans! As we now have North Korean solders are used as pawns(?) in the Ukrainian war for the North Korean and Russian purposes the need for clear protection from these types of crimes, by extension we could also use the same Russian tactic’s if we don’t heed the historical content before us.
Would anyone put it past Trump and his administration to just ignore the Constitution and the courts? And according to SCOTUS his unconstitutional actions, if done as a Presidential act, are completely legal.
Harry see if you can cover the order regarding Fanni Willis being required to abide by the subpoena to testify before the Georgia Senate, Looks like we may be one step closer to finally seeing Fanni and her team being indicted and hopefully jailed for their role in trying to derail Trumps presidential win, thanks to you and all the attention you’ve helped bring to this issue. 🇱🇷🇱🇷🇱🇷🇱🇷
I'm planning to retire at 59 in another country outside the US that is free, safe and very cheap with a high quality of life and good healthcare. I could fully just rely on only my SS if I wanted to when that times arrives but l'll also have at least one pension, a 403 (b) and a very prolific Investment account with my Stephanie Stiefel my FA. Retiring comfortably in the US these days is almost impossible
I know this lady you just mentioned. Stephanie Janis Stiefel is a portfolio manager and investment advisor. She gained recognition as an employee of neuberger berman; a renowned investor she is. Stephanie Janis Stiefel has demonstrated expertise in investment strategies and has been involved in managing portfolios and providing guidance to clients.
I’m planning on moving to Thailand in the next 5 years if trump’s government doesn’t do anything with the high prices of groceries and taxes
What about you??
Been debt free for two years thanks to Stephanie Janis Stiefel. So sad to see my friends in their 40s with car loans, mortgages and credit card debt.
My sister lives in Aussie. They have good healthcare better than America. I am also moving there after I retire.
Please stop gentrifying countries
His mother and two of his wives were immigrants, so does he lose his citizenship?
Right.
Hope so, then he can deport himself.
He doesn't lose his citizenship but according to his border czar...if he want to stay with his family he can get on the bus with them
According to his theory he has citizenship through his US citizen father.
no. they are white
Elon and trumps boy Barron should be included especially because Barron’s mother Melania wasn’t a citizen when he was born
She doesn't have to be a citizen. Trump is and that gives Barron citizenship. Elon isn't a natural born citizen and can be deported for certain infractions.
Trump is a citizen so therefore his children are also citizens. If one person is illegally here and one is a citizen the children still have citizenship
@@gagelong3366 That is correct, with the child born and residing here in the physical custody of that parent. Even if he were born in Bangladesh.
@gagelong3366 um no. That's the term "family separation." His last term, Trump deported the one parent, 99% the bread winner of the family, who was here illegally. Undocumented, is a false word, because many immigrants have tax ID numbers and file tax returns, but just cannot get any money back until they become a citizen. All the taxes paid by immigrants suddenly gone, will destroy our small cities and communities.
@@gagelong3366 mr$$$ melmac trump had her ANCHOR BABY to pave her way . trump can start by sending her and kid to slovakia as soon as she wants a divorce.
It means that Melania,and Musk and Vivek, must go!!
And Melania son barron has to go two.
i despise vivek but he is a citizen
Melania and Musk are not illegal aliens. If you want to be here, apply legally.
@ListenUpDemocracy It doesn't matter because trump said he's going to take away birthright citizenship. Nobody is safe
@@ListenUpDemocracyVivek’s father never got and refuses to this day to get his citizenship. So that would put Vivek and his father right in the crosshairs.
why don't we take his birthright citizenship away for being a traitor
And his own children
He can’t, and neither can you.
Hear! Hear!👏👏👏
👏👏👏👏👏
@@robertflorentine his father and mother were immigrants maybe according to trumps own rules he would not be American lol
What’s interesting is to look at the birthright citizens in Trump’s cabinet.
It's one reason for their lack of allegiance to the Constitution. It's not their country.
And his kids.
Trump loves non Americans if they are the skin color of his own.
@@jimcoogan1529his kids aren't anchor babies.
Learn what you're talking about before proving your ignorance publicly.
To the Republican party, there is strength in numbers if you ever want to stand up to a bully and his threats, because Donald Trump cannot primary everybody.
And to be honest...if they stood up to trump...maybe more people would actually vote for them because they showed some spine
50% of the senate is up for re-election every 2 years. 2026 50% , 2028 50%.
@itsknotmagic thank you that is exactly my point.
First they have to have spine transplants, because most of them don't have them
How is ending birthright citizens being nasty. I don't know what Rick this guy has been under. But I've watched millions of dollars being allocated to illegal aliens in my community for years. Program upon program, set up specifically to assist them with everything. The school systems funded tutors for the children; they are placed right in the classrooms. Which is a distraction and slows down the learning process. Forty plus million came in unvetted and they need to go. Everyone is questioning where funding is going to come from to deport them. Well ... The same fund Biden used to expedite them in illegally.
Pres ELON's children will NOT be HAPPY
His children don't even talk to him. Elon is against Transgender and his boy is one. His son even changed his name because he doesn't want to be affiliated with his father's name.
he is white
@ListenUpDemocracy president ELON was born in sth Africa, where were his children born? Birthright?
@@ListenUpDemocracyHe's not "came over on the Mayflower white".
They are wealthy. The laws do not apply to them.
So does that mean his son barron and his wife must go back to her home country then cause his mom is here illegal 🤔
If Trump can get away without paying the pre-nup, absolutely yes.
No, it does not. His wife is a naturalized citizen (she can be deported for certain infractions) and his son was born of one citizen parent and automatically has citizenship.
@chashue6032 no she. Not she lied on her form stop trying gaslight she here illegal point blank
@@chashue6032Barron doesn't have citizenship because his father is a citizen. He has it because he was born in this country.
Absolutely, Melania and Barron needs to go first to be a role model of Trump's laws he wants to pass
Guessing he has to deport his son because his mother was not a citizen at the time of his birth
they are white. my family has been here since the 1600s but Vivek Ramaswamy and Nikki Hayley think I don't belong here bc I am black. I know black people with lighter skin than him. the irony.
His son was born here to a U.S. citizen. People regularly come in on vacation visas just to get US citizenship for their unborn babies. That is totally different but your hatred of Trump won’t let you admit that.
And the 3 oldest too there mother wasn’t either
@@ListenUpDemocracyAnd that's the story of America. 🤦♀️
Trump's own mother came and wasn't a citizen for a long time, either. I think this is a woman-hating thing with him, tbh. One of those guys who calls immigration services if his foreign-born woman isn't "behaving." 🙄
This is what the people want !! 😂 🇺🇲
VIVEK R. has Birthright Citizenship, his parents weren't citizens when he was born and his dad still isn't.
That is true.
That's one example of twunt's stupid plan
Barron is an anchor baby
Same as jr, ericand ivanka
Same as vances 3 kids
So is Donald's father.
So we’re jr Eric and Ivanka their mother wasn’t a citizen either when they were born
Hardly, anchor babies are to prevent being deported for illegal immigrants, which neither Trump nor his wife are. Check your trump hatred. Your logic is hilariously flawed.
I am a dual French American citizen !! I was born in Verdun where my father, a Michigan born natural Citizen, was serving in the US Army. I didn’t know I was French until 1980!! I am absolutely for natural born citizenship. Waiting to see whether or not stupid will send US Soldiers to die in Panama!! Thank you !!😊
In
Sure
I think that'll be a very hard case to make. Aside from the fact he's got accelerating dementia
So your dad was in France legally. Got it.
French people have neither the courage nor heart to defend themselves or their country! Leave ours alone and go learn German! Without the US there would be no France!!!!
I’m going to trust and pray you are right Harry
No matter how hard he tries to push this BS, it isn't going to fly.
That racist is going to push it hard, unfortunately
@@lisashapiro9165 And so his supporters will too.
Love your podcasts!🎉
It looks like we are about to find out just how authoritative our Constitution actually is.💙
Like SCOTUS has already done based on their "interpretation" of our black and white constitution! 😡
No we're going to find out if the scrotus is going to make law again, instead of their ACTUAL job, interpreting laws that exist in the real world. I love to see them show me where it says the president has immunity for committing crimes
You can forget all about the Constitution for the next four years
Seems we already have a pretty good idea how vulnerable our Constitution is with a Republican dominated SCOTUS.
The Constitution won't be worth the paper it's printed on.
Good evening from New Brunswick Canada 🇨🇦💙💙👍😀
Hi! I love Canada 💙
@@Jeannie-d2u Me too, I wish I was born there.
Hi
The part of the 14th Amendment that affirmatively states that the freed slaves are citizens was key because the Supreme Court ruled in the Dred Scott case that they were not citizens. So the 14th Amendment overturned the Dred Scott decision.
Harry, the two judges that Trump appointed to the Supreme Court both said that Roe v.s. Wade was establised law during their confirmation hearings, but later voted to repeal it. Is there any way that they could be charged for lying during the hearings?
They might be able to impeach them for lying to Congress, which is a crime. Won't happen until we get both houses of Congress back. So I'm betting on 2026
All 3 he appointed said Roe was settled law and they lied to get on the Supreme Court how ironic.
Thank you Harry 🙂
"...the world is my country, allmankind are my brethren, and to good is my religion..." Thomas Paine
Now go meet them.
This all makes me sick 🤢🤮
Why?
Let it make you vocal and active. ❤
If you are born in the US, you are a citizen.
You, my sir, have just described a “cast system” similar to what’ found in the Punjab!
Hi Harry, I'd like to see you address HR 6976, a law that would make DUIs and even wet reckless immediately and retroactively deportable offenses, and make it so that person could never come back to the US. It's apparently passed the House and is headed to the Senate. I work in the court system as a Certified Spanish interpreter and the lawyers I work with are just getting continuances for their cases to wait and see what happens with this law.
The birthright thing I think it applies to every country. It does for sure in Canada
30 countries do this
It doesn't
It does apply to Canada.
I recall that in many Muslim countries, you are a citizen thru your father, not according to birthplace.
@jeannerogers7085 and in Muslim countries if your gay, will throw you off the tallest structure
About time you said trump is traitor a long time agoi😮😮😮
Thanks Harry 💙💙💙⚖️🇺🇸
What about people here legally but temporarily? College babies. Tech visa babies. Etc. A lot of people would choose not to come if that were the case.
I wonder how much it would cost to have a doctor induce a 4 year coma, "on demand"? Because I certainly won't survive being lucid
Unprecedented chaos 🤢.
Expensive I guess😅😅 but might be a good idea
@@victoriajane9687 Thank you for your input VJ. I guess I'll need to sleep on it Cheers
@@Donna-op9nw Like my grandmother would yell in church and my stepdad would say down at the mill... "BINGO! You Nailed it"
You don't want to do that. It requires brain trauma... AND your body will suffer and age faster just laying in one place all the time. Yes you will survive chRump being
lucid. The nation is counting on you.
Baron trump was born before Melania got her citizenship
Anchor baby he's out
It doesn't matter, his father is a citizen (just not a good one).
@@lisashapiro9165 Incorrect.
My family came here legally. They can here before the the Chinese Exclusion Act of 1882, the first migration law. Most conservatives are too ignorant to learn from histroy. "In the mid-nineteenth century, many Americans began to feel threatened by an increase in immigration from China to the United States. Reasons for this included xenophobia, or dislike of foreigners, as well as more complex causes such as labor tensions and shifting national identities. Working-class Americans and European immigrants worried that Chinese immigrants would compete unfairly for their jobs by working for lower wages. Irish immigrant railroad laborers in particular found themselves in competition with Chinese workers, as both groups struggled at the lower end of the wage scale."
Yes true. Thank you for posting that.
AND, unemployment is a policy outcome. There is no real reason for anyone who wants to work, to be unemployed. The US can never run out of the money it creates. But inflation, you say? Wrong again.
@@erickborling1302 "The main causes of structural unemployment are: Technological advancements, fundamental changes in consumer preferences, globalization and competition, and education and skill mismatches."
Most US citizens are, sadly, extremely ignorant of history
An overlooked problem that caused the exclusion act was that the immigrants for China at that time were from a different part of China than the area that the previous immigrant railway workers came from, and didn't mix well with the existing culture.
Also a significant number of the Chinese immigrants of that era were daughters of Chinese families sold to brokers who brought them to the US to sell for prostitution.
Instead of vetting them, the solution was to shut it down.
Watch the movie "Broken Trail." It's story includes this issue.
Bye, Barron, the anchor baby!!
He was born here despite your hating his mother. Grow the hell up!
@lisanidog8178 ANCHOR BABY TO AN ILLEGAL!!!
Nope, his father is a citizen, albeit a bad one, and that makes him a citizen.
@@lisanidog8178 Grow up? What a Trumper and Trump can't seem to do.
@@chashue6032 it doesn’t matter whether one or both parents are native born or immigrant, doesn’t matter their status, as long as the kid is born in America, which Barron was, in Manhattan specifically, he’s an American citizen just like the rest of us who have immigrant ancestors.
Do u remember how Trump and MAGA whined in 2017 no we’re not racist? 🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣
He's an idiot and a liar. And, and and...
Kicking out illegal immigrants is not racism. We have had an influx of illegal immigrants from China and other countries, not just Mexico. Race has nothing to do with it. Apply to come, not just come in illegally or have your baby born here while on a tourist visa.
Pay attention to what they DO, not what they say!
@lisashapiro9165
??? Words matter also...
During his first term he attempted to deny citizenship to children born to women in the military if the children were born overseas!
Love the way he expects to be obeyed when he wants to change the constitution 😮
If stupid were an Olympic sport, hump would have won the gold😂😂😂😂😂
Thank you!
You said it. Our "man of the -hour- year" is pulling holiday duty! We'll have to crowdsource some funds to get him a much deserved Va-K-shun
Anyone born in the U.S. is an American citizen! Doesn’t matter which parent is an immigrant or not, legal or not. Born on U.S. soil you’re a citizen. Why that’s such a hard concept is baffling.
Just more Dumpster BS to fire up the MAGAts and distract them from the upcoming horrible economy.
I wouldn't put anything past this Supreme Court
Tortured arguments are this Supreme Court’s meat and potatoes.
Many thanks, Harry. I hope you know that you're one of our champions for Democracy. We are fortunate.
Especially when Trump has the Supreme Court in his right pocket.
🤔 but aren't we ALL birth right citizens?
If you were born in this country, then yes. Naturalized citizens became that by passing procedures that allow for that
Yes
@@lisashapiro9165 The United States recognizes two bases for birthright citizenship: in addition to being born in the United States, there's being born to one or more US citizens, irrespective of where in the world one is born. If a US-citizen artist working in, say, Nairobi gives birth there, the US considers her child her child a US citizen and she can apply at the nearest US embassy or consulate for a US State Department form certifying the child's birth as a citizen. That form, rather than the local birth certificate, will subsequently serve as the child's legal US birth certificate.
That "jurisdiction" thing is just like the BS about whether Trump "holds office" to apply the 14th.
I read that DJT's paternal grandfather lied on his application for immigration when he arrived from Germany. Does it have any implication on DJT's status?
No.
What is wrong with that guy, he’s so destructive no wonder he wants total immunity. You are all in for one hell of a ride.
In Canada that would give you duel citizenship .
They have to go through the courts first can't change a law just because you don't like it
He can’t do it. It would require a change in the Constitution. No chance it passes.
So what would happen if white billionaire American born citizens have a child while out of the country on their yacht? Would Trump consider the child to have American citizenship?
I'm first-born in the US. My parents immigrated from Switzerland. Can I go back?
If Switerland holds that a person can claim Swiss citizenship by virtue of having been born to Swiss nationals, and if your parents hadn't yet applied for US citizenship at the time of your birth, the answer might be "yes". There may also be an age limit before which one needs to apply.
Great report
the fact is without birthright citizenship, how do you prove you are a citizen? being born here doesn't prove anything. Now do you have to prove your parents were born here? What if they weren't? Do you have to prove they immigrated legally, in 1940? This idea is almost entirely unworkable.
TY Harry.
Thank you 💙 ⚖️🗽🇺🇸
Greatly appreciated as ever 👍
I can hardly wait!!
What about “Malaria’s Einstein VISA”issue. What is her qualification for receiving a VISA that is reserved for individuals with extraordinary intelligence?
She can slap a hand ✋, extremely fast.
@ 💯 We really need to get to a point where money can’t buy you freedom or special treatment. I’m trying to stay optimistic but Trumpy is an animal. He only answers to himself. His brain is so fried that he can’t even understand himself. Narcissistic individuals are toxic.
If Mr$$$ Melmac trump is a genius we are all deep crap.
T🍌 mp doesn't read the 14th Amendment... Neither do his Justices on the Supreme Court 🤨
Trump seems to be above the law.
Crooked SCOTUS 😡
Reading is hard for him.
Easiest Trump lie easy to dubunk " No other country does this (grants birthright citizenship)" - when in fact there are about 30 other countries that do this.
If the birthright children wanted to remain, would the government have to pay room & board for them until they turn 21? I have 2 spare bedrooms and no income! This $86 billion program could be a godsend! I think $750 a week is reasonable plus the govt pay the healthcare, clothing, and allowances for these legal Americans who they’re leaving parentless
Super!
I think there needs to be a change to our “birthright citizenship”. There are people who come here specifically to have their children get US citizenship. A system more like that in the UK is probably what we need to adopt. For foreigners who give birth there, citizenship is given to the child only if the parents are “settled” at the time of birth. That means that they have permanent housing, and at least one parent is legally working (studying?) or has the “right to remain”. This makes far more sense than some of the birth tourism we currently have.
Better solution. Ban dual citizenship. Why does all of cingress have two citizenship but it’s illegal for regular people
In order to do what you are saying The Constitution has to be amended.That is going to be EXTREMELY hard to do The constitution doesn’t care what you may think ..Thank God
Not what our Constitution says. If you want it changed, contact your elected representatives and suggest they work on a bill…just FYI, it’s very difficult to make a new Amendment or change an existing one.
@ I understand that it’s not the law, and I know how hard it is to get amendments passed (ERA). I just wanted to provide a moderated response to all the craziness. I do think we need to look into citizenship, as times have changed and there are people who try to abuse the system.
This idea is ridiculous.
Well explained. 👍I hope sanity prevails.
Nope im gen x. Birthright citizenship means pregnant women gose into labor runs across the border pops out a baby and screems my baby is a us citizen. That was a huge problem in the 80s.
So not subject to jurisdiction would kinda be like diplomatic immunity? 🤔
yes, thats the only exception
I believe he is against someone coming to the US briefly to give birth, paying a lot, then leaving.
My kitty was born here.' They're eating the 🐈🐈 and the dogs 🐶🐕 and sometimes they are eating the fish at the petting zoo,too.🐠🐟
Thanks Harry. Another day in Margolargoville.
More like dementiaville😂😂😂
Trump is following a lot of what's in the project 2025 book. So much for his not knowing about Project 2025.
Thank you
Thank you.❤
So, does this mass deportation include his wife?
And her parents.
And all his kids except Tiffani
dumb comment she;s not iilegal
@The1djdave yes she is idiot.
And he will keep doing it 😢 over and over again . ridiculous.
I love the diversity of our people! That way I get to eat all of their great foods!!!😋
"So where are you from?"
Says stuff about themselves...
"Oh I see! Can you translate that into foods and flavors"?😆
I enjoy learning about the finer points of these legal issues. It’s very good that you discuss these things. The more we average folks cal learn about these things, the better placed we will be to form our own opinions and conclusions. So, thank you!
Heartbreaking
It appears that this would create a category of "stateless" people. I believe it would be up to one or both parents to actually register their child's birth at the embassy or consulate of the country in which they hold nationality. But what if they don't do that ?
What nationality would the child have ? Cuba for one is not even taking back its own citizens who've fled abroad not to mention any child born abroad. This is truly insane and illegal.
More bloviating from Trump. Unfortunately, we have to swallow everything that comes out his mouth.
Not me!
We have to remember that Federalist Society judges are activist judges and good Republicans, too. If they want to reinterpret the language -- calling it originalism -- they will do it if it fits their agenda and within their moral and ethical framework which isn't a very good one, to say the least. Look at what they did with presidential immunity. Further, there is a Southern flavor to the Federalist Society so there might be a larger reason to reinterpret the 14 Amendment to fit into their longer-term agenda like the Red States not providing education or vouchers for temporary resident workers or in the case of the Christian nationalist judge's values to deny citizenship to non-citizen US soldiers, their wives, and families to denying things like social security benefits to green card holders or habeas corpus protection. It was religious people and judges who went along with the Third Reich in the 1930s.
Thank you!
Great video! Thanks! Yikes… YIKES!!!
💙
USA,
You are soo deserving of Trump.
Hi Harry,, my name is Christy Clarke. As a student of the Nuremberg trials, can we not charge Trump and Company with crimes against humanity and crimes against peace. Have we learned nothing.
That rump needs to leave our citizens unmolested. We, the people, are everyone born here and more:)
My country stopped birthright citizenship at the same time it made work visas for seasonal workers (people to harvest crops).
That seems sensible. Then your immigration is people you decide, not low skill labourers who happen to have a baby with a local while working.
I'll bet the Supreme court will back Trump on this.
The Supreme Court can back his agenda...but can they do that and keep his kids out of it?
Hope so.😊
How can they? It’s in the constitution.
@sj6919 we will have both house and Senate soon. End birthright citizenship!
@itsknotmagic yes. Considering the parents were legal citizens at the time
Can't pick and choose the amendments you like.
Lol. Tell that to the current administration 😅
SCOTUS spins it with their "interpretation". 😡
They’re not going to have the resources to bring them to court cases
To the person who thought Melania wasn’t a citizen when Barron was born she got her citizenship the year he was born in Manhattan! Citizen or not if you’re born on U.S. soil you ARE an American! Smarten up!
Aside from the possibility of trying to bring this issues to the Supreme Court’s adjudication of those children’s citizenship; we also need to have a full accountability of the children that were taken out of the arms of the parents that were sent out away, or into this Nation’s arms and disappeared as far as the National events are concerned!
All of those children need to be brought to justice at the Supreme Court’s processes and adjudicated for their rights and freedoms to be respected!
Aside from the aforementioned issue, the 14th amendment Section 3 , must be enforced just as the forefathers of this Nation intended!
Aside from the fact that they have been violated or protected they are to be considered Americans since this is the Nation, if still viable, regardless of the status at the entry of their parents, this is the only nation those children are cognizant of belonging!
We are not in Russia or any other nation that have horrible practices, where their identities are obliterated, we are better than that as Americans!
As we now have North Korean solders are used as pawns(?) in the Ukrainian war for the North Korean and Russian purposes the need for clear protection from these types of crimes, by extension we could also use the same Russian tactic’s if we don’t heed the historical content before us.
Would anyone put it past Trump and his administration to just ignore the Constitution and the courts? And according to SCOTUS his unconstitutional actions, if done as a Presidential act, are completely legal.
They should sue..and sue
The orange man’s statements seem to be made in order to promote fear. Your legal analyses are so so welcomed.
Harry see if you can cover the order regarding Fanni Willis being required to abide by the subpoena to testify before the Georgia Senate, Looks like we may be one step closer to finally seeing Fanni and her team being indicted and hopefully jailed for their role in trying to derail Trumps presidential win, thanks to you and all the attention you’ve helped bring to this issue. 🇱🇷🇱🇷🇱🇷🇱🇷
Honest question: so "and subjrct to the jurisdiction" woild exclude, for example, the children of foreign diplomats?
That would automatically make everyone a noncitizen !
Brilliant thought behind that one...
King Donny has never failed at anything, so jokes on yall