Only a secular Kurdish state is guarantee that Christians and Alwites and other minorities will not be prosecuted. Everything else is just more bloodshed and head chopping. History has shown that the worst gen0cides against Christians because of their faith were committed in Anatolia by the same people invading Syria now
Welcome to the middle east, where everyone is swearing over the destruction of the next guy. It would be super funny to see how many invasions would take place and how many genocides if the US would pull out from all their bases in the middle east.
Since most of the Syrians who had stake in Syria in the north become refugees in Turkey some are even sent from Europe to Turkey, it is kind of within their rights to intervene by extension of the stakes of refugees. Turkey wants them return, it is not possible if YPG snatches up that land.
@ sure, they are not even just Kurds, diverse groups join for common interest is fishy, supports Turkey's thesis them being opportunist mercenaries supported by minority.
Depends if you have been watching anti Turkish racist western media that not only ignores israhel occupation of Syrian land and actively bringing european khazars to colonise Syrian land
I love how people condem israel for taking control of the buffer zone (for the high mountain points) but ignore turkey literally land grabbing from syria, turkey just wants to continue to oppress kurds and other minority but the world ignores it.
There are thousands of kurds proudly serving in the turkish army. There are 2 minister and a vice president of kurdish origin in erdoğan's cabinet. Kurds are not oppressed in turkiye. We are targetting terrorists not kurds. SDF is a terrorist organization consists of not only kurds.
Erm, the fact we're here commenting on this video proves we're not ignoring Turkish aggression. But it is appropriate to pay more attention to foreign aggression that our own governments are enabling. Especially when there is so much disinformation being spread about the aggression, such as that it's "only a buffer zone", despite the fact that there are at least 20,000 Israeli non-military citizens settled on Syrian territory in the Golan Heights. This is clearly territorial expansion.
In a world of hypocrites, Türkiye is the most hypocritical of all. Turks in Cyprus and Palestinians have right to self determination (fair enough) but Kurds (or Uyghurs) no? Boycott Türkiye.
As usual, the Western media is still trying to separate the Kurdish minorities from their Arab surroundings. In Syria specifically, the Kurdish minority does not exceed 10% of the population, and they are spread and integrated throughout northern Syria, and are not concentrated in northeastern Syria only. Also, the lands east and north of the Euphrates River are full of Arabs, and therefore more than half of the population of the new state will be Arabs in any independence.
They in fact not only exceed 10% of the population, they are the 3rd largest ethnic group in Syria (if not 2nd), and the Kurds make up about half of the population of Rojava. Rojava itself as a group isn't even stated to be run by Kurds on its entirely, but made up of both Kurds and Arabs.
@@supb1848There are not even 2 million Kurds in Syria. There are 15 million Arabs and 5 million Turkmens. But you are occupying half of the country. The terrorist PKK, the servant of imperialism, will be expelled from Syrian lands!
Have you ever been in Syria? According to last Syrian census Kurds were 10% of Syria. But half of Arabs left Syria and consequently Kurds constitute nearly 20% of Syria and 65% of SDF-controlled region.
Wow, while the Kurds were fighting ISIS and the barbaric Assad, the Arabs were just running away. That's why Türkiye and all of Europe were filled with huge migrations of refugees. And now the Arabs have that land
The US has 2000 troops in Syria. didn't you hear? Pentagon spokesman said "Ooops! We had 1100 more troops in the region. I am sorry we have just been told!" We don't want to Invade Syria. We are not either Israel or Russia. We want however a secure zone along our southern border. If the US has a right to create a zone between the US and Mexico. If Israel had this between them an Syria, Lebanon and Egypt, if Greece has a right to build walls to stop refugees so we Turks has this right too. About the Kurds. A state is not given. It is in no one's right to do so. British and France tried this after the WWI with Sykes and Picot agreements and bloodshed never stopped. If you deserved a state, you have a state already. If you don't that means you do not have a state culture. Kurds never had one. They have a right to live free and in peace like any other people. But Kurdish people do not want a state like other people does. Other people unite to have their own state and fight against whatever strength they muster as a strong fist. However, these terrorist organizations come from Kurdish communities cannot care less about having a nation. They do not fight for a nation. They fight for a base so they can handle their drug, human and arms trafficking easier. What? Did you think these people were innocent freedom fighters? 80% of the crime run through PKK and YPG in Europe. Just ask Sweeden and they will give you all the information. Russians used Kurdish terrorist groups before the US taken over them. They went from one country to another for support ever since. Well, after decades later they can't find anyone to sit on their lap. These terrorist organisations will become worm food very soon. Our civilian Kurdish brothers and sisters are welcome to live amongst us as they had. But anyone take up arms against to Turkish or Syrian forces will simply die. This is not a treat. This is eventuality.
@@supb1848 Everyone calls Trump a businessman and do not respect his patriotic side. The US in the middle east for two reasons. One petrol, Two Israel. Jewish media and businessman in the US never liked or cared about Trump (or any other American than themselves for that matter), and two all the petrol in the region is not wort losing the entire east to China. Trump knows math. So, he doesn't want to spend too much hard power in the Middle East while there was more powerful foe rising in the East. He will try to use soft power against Türkiye like he did before with the embargos and such, but he cares less about Israel nor the Middle East anymore. As long as Türkiye doesn't push Trump, Trump won't push back.
The kurdish people do want independance, but they were literally split between 4 nations (divide and conquer style) For a people who are a minority in every state they inhabit, guerrilla warfare (+ terrorism) seems like a logical outcome. I am not justifying terrorism, but the PKK did not appear on a vacuum....
@@I_am_somebody_1234 No! Kurdish people weren't divided and conquered. They were like pre-colonised African people living in small groups without caring whatever flags flew above them. People from Europe doesn't realize this or realize but don't care because they profit a lot from the chaos in the region but this much division in the Middle East not healthy for the people. Middle East isn't like Europe. Let's talk about Finland. It has 5.6 million population and 5 million of them is Christian Finnish. Syria isn't like that, there are Turkmens, Arabs, Durzis, Kurds, Jews, Christians etc. etc. etc You cannot divide a demographics like that since the biggest country would be the size of a town in London. A lot of Arabic tribes are actually rebelling against to SDF in the areas they are controlling right now. So, what about those people? Divide and conquer is not a Middle Eastern concept. Born in the East and embraced by the West. Answer this question. Why would the EU and the UNITED States would push this nationalist right-wing agenda in the Middle East but when it came to themselves, they keep uniting? Everyone else but Middle east is getting united. EU, BRICS, OTS etc. etc. Turkish supported HTS is establishing order, opening reinstating municipalities, schools, hospitals, trade etc. They came to power 12 days ago. What did the US supported SDF do in last 12 years other than stealing petrol? As soon as they realized their days numbered in the region, the US killed the ISIS leader. And started to say ISIS is a treat again. Anyway. Long story short There are some Kurdish terrorist organisations trying to pump people with these nationalistic ideas, but people don't care less. Otherwise with this many weapons and money coming from the US they could have overthrown Essad themselves, but these terrorist organisations actually terrorize Kurdish civilians first. As long as they were able to sell petrol to the US, traffic Essad's drugs and align their pockets with money, they were happy the things as they were.
Correction: there are currently 2000 US troops on Rojava. I understand you it's hard to keep up with all the info. I hope this does not come off as an attack.
We literally fought IS1$ away and made Europe safe, and this is our thanks..?!?!?????? You can sleep without IS1$ attacks, and this is how you thanks the Kurds for defending you??!?!?!? See what you did made me and u break my Kurdish heart … I want to have a place to belong to, I want to have a home, a motherland I can call for mine, and not get bullied by everyone in school for not having a counti can call mine, I am no one, I belong to nowhere
We, the Ards, fought too, not just the Kurds, but you should not do this. Also, these organizations you are talking about are organizations of American manufacture, and they placed them among us anyway
Israel is deploying troops to the demilitarised zone, not "seizing Syrian territory." And if one reads the 1974 disengagement of forces agreement, one would know that according to that agreement, all of the territory east of the purple line (the de facto border between Israel and Syria) was to be administered by Syria, and all of the territory west of the purple line, was to be administered by Israel, pending a final settlement on the Arab Israeli Conflict. That's s binding international law. The dmz was placed strictly west of the Purple line, in Israeli territory. When the Syrian government and military collapsed, Israel was within its right to deploy troops on its side of the Purple Line. So please stop with the lies and hypocrisy. 🕎
Let's add the rest of the information you deliberately left out in this video: - Turkey has just shy of 5 Million Syrian refugees, more than the entire sum of entire Syrian refugees in the world if you leave Lebanon out. - Turkey is 3rd most affected country after Syria and Lebanon because of the war, including mass migration, mass terrorism, border insecurity, artillery shelling... - The so-called SDF, Syrian Democratic Forces, are neither Syrian nor Democratic. They are an autocratic armed militia who are oppressing anyone who are not Kurdish, such as Sunni Arabs. The Kurdish superminority is ruling over vast swathes of land that have nothing to do with Kurds or Kurdish history or culture. - Turkey has stellar relationship with the Kurdish State in Iraq. Iraqi Kurds are also on bad terms with this so-called SDF. - Kurds in Turkey are not some "oppressed minority", but enjoy high living standards for around 80-90% of the Kurdish population. Kurds "enjoy" free gas, electricity and amenities because it is impossible to regulate the area. Any Kurd can set up shop anywhere in Turkey, but a Turk setting up shop in a Kurdish region would result in arson or murrder and that is an objective fact. - SDF is the #1 arms, drugs, and counterfeit money supplier into Turkey, including acting as a staging ground or an escape route for virtually all terror operations in Turkey. - Despite the US failure to support the 2nd most powerful NATO country, and despite their trusting of the so-called SDF in the fight against ISIS, and despite cancelling all arms deals, Turkey is fighting NATO enemies all over the place, including beating Russia 3 times in Libya, Armenia-Azerbaijan Conflict, and Syria. Turkey literally toppled the "butcher" and "dictator" Assad regime within a week, so I don't understand what is wrong from the perspective of so-called liberal, democratic Western views. Last but not least: The relations between Lebanon, Syria and Turkey are rooted beyond the Ottoman Empire. The humanitarian aid provided to the region is virtually unparalleled by any other nation for earth. For more than a decade, literal millions and millions of Syrians have worked and went to school in Turkey. They have started families, they have had children and grand children. So before some random Brit or American says anything about the situation, such as "muh ottomans" or "muh lesbian Kurdish freedom fighters", stop listening to mainstream slop and try to get an idea of what it means to be actually involved in real world affairs.
lol, nice try. We know for a fact that Turkey is moving Syrian refugees illegally to Europe, Frontex has caught countless Turkish traffikers. also, NATO's second most powerful country is either France or Britain, so keep dreaming. and lastly, every human rights organization has condemned the treatment of Kurds by Turkey. Turkey is a totalitarian regime with no respect of basic human rights, that's why every attempt to join the EU has been denied. stop lying
Exactly! I can not believe people think Turks are invading Syria, although we are the ones who literally brought the peace and help demolish a dictatorship. It feels like global media shows racism towards us Turks. Also no, SDF have no right to have land in Turkey.
This channel slowly became more and more political, from an entertaining hannel that aims to be objective, to a fairly obviously political news filter channel, oh well, time to look for something else 😢
I don't understand why people think Turkey is invading Syria. The Turks are in Syria because the Syrian people want the Turks, because Syria is still not completely safe and they are not afraid of the Turkish army. If the Turks were not on the side of the Syrian people, the regime would be standing. Turkey has a large share in the collapse of the regime. More than 5 million Syrians lived in Turkey. Don't comment on topics you don't know about.
"I don't understand why people think Russia is invading Ukraine. The Russians are in Ukraine because the Ukrainin\an people want the Russians, because Ukraine is still not completely safe and they are not afraid of the Russian army. If the Russians were not on the side of the Ukrainian people the Maidan regime would still be standing. Russia has a large share in the collapse of the regime. More than 2 million Ukrainians lived in Russia. *Don't comment on topics you don't know about* " /s
Syria is home to many ethnic and religiously diverse people. No geographical area is homogeneous Dividing Syria into many states or administrations based on ethnic and religious grounds willead to endless wars. Is this war environment deliberately desired to continue? Who will benefit from it? The Middle East has suffered greatly from ethnic and religious micro-nationalisms. Instead, wouldn't it be a better approach to build a unitary state where every individual in Syria benefits from equal citizenship rights? Previously, Kurds did not have citizenship rights or official identities. However, now the central government is calling on everyone to be represented in the administration. Contrary to your claim, Professor, laying down arms and electing and sending civilian deputies to the Syrian parliament seems like a more civilized and peaceful approach Why do you find it so difficult to focus on the common interests of Syrians instead of using ethnic and religious differences to feed micro- ?nationalisms
If there was an armed terrorist organization in your neighboring country that wanted to divide and destroy your country, would your country remain silent about this? That's what I thought too.
Me when the Rojavan government offered as part of the ceasefire deal cut ties with the PPK, agreement supported by the transitional syrian government but rejected by the Turks.
bencede ve teröristlerin ypg ile beraber çalıştığınıda göstermeliler. Türkiye o bölgede özgür suriye kurması normal bir şey , ypg nin orada ayrı bir yönetim kurmasından daha normal çünkü o bölgede teröristler var.
They will never admit to that. Hell, not only did they screw over the Kurds with the treaty of Lausanne, they banned all their shit, language, even changed their city names 😂 and forced them to join the shitty ass state turkey. How can you be a separatist when you were forced to join in the first place?? They even killed the ppl. In dersim for protesting against this oppression. So either be killed or forced to speak turkish and live under their rules and everyone that speaks up is a separatist trying to devide this so called "brotherhood". Brotherhood my ass you aren't even allowed to display a single kurdish word out there bc they get a stroke from seeing one. Which also is funny bc you can see it in these comments here as well. It's always the same excuse they try and yet some ppl. still fall for it. They claim everyone is treated so good in turkey why would you be scared of a movment if the syrian kurds have autonomy??? What is it now? Do you treat them so good that they want to live with you or do you treat them like garbage and that's why you can't have kurds close to you with autonomy??? The PKK said it doesn't operate in syria anymore, the sdf offered multiple solutions to a ceasefire, they just now even offered to have no military near the border and US Troops would control the area. Even that offer is something turkey doesn't want, if they really cared about "national security" it wouldn"t be an issue but everyone that knows history damn well knows what turkey wants.
Turkey is not trying to suppress Kurdish minorities and NEVER tried to get rid of kurdish minorities. Turkey's main concern is security. Rojava has direct connection with another terorist organization (PKK). Any nation will do their best to eliminate open threat like this
I think the main difference between the Turkish zone and the Israelis is that the Turks have zero plans to settle and annex the area, unlike Israel which has an interest in annexing territory, populating it with settlers and then annexing more territory to defend said settlers
Is Turkey really occupying? There is a group on their borders armed against their country, my friend. If the same situation had happened to any EU country or the USA, there would be no such thing as Syria. Why did you find it so offensive to create a safe haven along the border to keep their own territory safe? Moreover, the terrorist incidents and civilian deaths in Turkey over the years were caused by the SDF.
@ryboi1337 Isreal: came without invite take places to cut the water electricity and bombing force people to leave their homes, they weave their flag on someone else is country saying it is their territory now. Turkeya: hold Syrian refugees that called Turkeya to help them fix the problem that make them refugees in the first place with goal to let them go back and live in peace in their homeland, and hold that country flag saying it is Syrian country they only came to help. If this was occupation then i am iraqi i wished the 2003 was like that i will not call it invasion if it was like what Turkeya doing in Syria
@ryboi1337 no isreal came by itself and call ot their land now and force people to leave but Turkeya is helping Syrian to return to their home by cleaning the land from invader
you cant' spell the correct pronounce of the name of head of the turkish republic who is in charge nearly 2 decades and yet trying to educate ppl on politics of turkey and its neighbours.
You made a few factual errors at 2:53 About 15 million Kurds live in Turkey. And at 5:27 2000 American soldiers are in Syria now according to the Pentagon.
that's another example of bias: calling the PKK terrorists, while calling the HTS rebels. both are on various lists of terrorist oranisations. if you want to be impartial you could call both of them rebels, or both of them terrorist groups, but calling one of them rebels and the others terrorists is not impartial. the first would definitely be preferable, since even nelson mandela was part of a "terroist organisation" according to the u.s.
despite i agree with world's hypocrisy in terrorism matter, in this situation it is understandable, PKK commonly known with civillian bombings for decades and their terrorist identity is undisputed. But Terrorism claims of HTS have more political tendencies like ''they are fighting agains a government which is our ally, so they must be terrrorists''. Basically they are more like'' Mandela class'' terrorists. And they gonna be removed from these lists because they won the war and gonna become new government (and new ally to U.S. in that matter).
Как можно не видеть разницы между HTS и RKK? Первые воевали против диктатора асада, который их убивал, пытал в тюрьмах, грабил, занимался изготовлением и торговлей наркотиками, а вторые занимается тем, что совершают набеги на турецких военных в Турции и совершает теракты против гражданского населения, пытаюсь такими методами отделить курдские территории и создать отдельное государство. Сирийские курды--- это ответвление RKK. Если кто-то выступает за расчленение Сирии или Турции, то пусть начнёт со своей страны, например, Даст свободу техасу и флориде, Шотландия, Ирландии, во Франции есть много чего отделить, Каталонии и так далее
@@liliyanahmetova4853 hts is an offshoot of al-qaeda and ideologically close to isis. the ypg fought hard against isis' brutal regime, known for their strict enforcement of ancient barabaric customs, use of drugs, rape of women and numerous beheadings, and the ypg defeated them. they also aren't authoritarian in any way; they organise their society based on human rights and grassroots democracy. the rojava does not want to have a seperate kurdish state, but wants autonomy within syria. that could actually be a role model for kurdish autonomy with turkey that ends violence of the turkish state against its citizens and violence of the PKK against the turkish military. i do support independece of all regions that want independence, be it scotland, catalonia, texas or whereever. they should have a referendum and decide democratically. ireland is already independent. do you want to bring it back under british rule? i'm sure the irish wouldn't be too happy for that. you'd probably see violent "terrorist" groups fighting for independence if britain annexed ireland again.
No country has done more to the Syrian people than Turkey. Saving the lives of 4 ml Syrians from certain death by the regime and has been taken care of them for the last 14 years costing the Turkish taxpayers over 40 bn $ yet you don't hear that in the Western media. and Turkey is not fighting the Kurds but fighting a designated Kurdish terrorist organization pkk that happens to be the Kurdish majority
The US just doesn’t want terrorist groups to be able to sell that oil on the black market or the Assad regime. The US has been producing more oil than the middle eastern countries since 2018 after we reupped production. Europe receives more oil from the Mideast than the US and that’s been true for quite a long time. I’d say now that Assad is gone the US troops will be pulled out after Trump is inagurated
This is so biased video. Becuase you talk like these territory only belongs to the Kurds. Actually Kurds are minority most of the places they invaded during the civil war. If your biased point of wiev correct there must be at least 20 more new independent country just in EU borders. If you like these seperatists so much, why don't you share your own ?country
As an Arab, if israel have the rights to defend itself by attacking everyone, then Turks and us Arabs have the rights to defend ourselves too, don't you think so? It would be fair like that.
@@Proud_Hadrami Yea that's alright, but I dont like how the turkish govt is always first in the line to condemn other states when they do the same shit.
@@iftyhargil8359 israel has been doing the same thing for 75 years to Palestinians and now to Syrians, there is no Western and European country that dare to talk with them, they have been doing genocide to Palestinians, and whenever we Arabs talk about it they say they have the rights to defend themselves, why is it us Arabs and Muslims the one at the blame when we do the same thing? If they are allowed to do genocide then we are also allowed, if the Western world decided that it is self defence then it would be for us all, that previlige is not only for israel.
"Israel Occupies Syria" (your title) with its own military BUT turkey backs syrian anti goverment (goverment that already fell btw) rebels "Turkey About to Invade Syria" Great journalism bud 👏👏👏
Turkey should focus on addressing its inflation, poverty, and infrastructure issues, as well as legalizing gay marriage , before turning its attention to concerns about Syria.
Erdogen is not really popular anymore. People know that he sucks and he thinks big of himself And that's exactly why erdogen wants syria. He will use it to boost his own chance of winning elections
Well, you are right we surely have to address those issues though wtf US is doing in the Middle East while they have %130 debt to gdp ratio, increasing income inequality, stagnant real wages for years and huge political and cultural polarization??
Kurdish area is fiction of Brit mcgurk and the neocon . There is no Kurdish area in Syria . The Kurds are barely majority on some border town with turkey . the area SDF control now is 80% Arab land not Kurdish
@@samiman5606 if Amazigh want to have their own country then be it, and if Kurds want to have their own country then be it, but do it outside of our land, do it in places where Kurds are the majority, because in the so called SDF, Arabs are protesting massivley for their rights, SDF is just a Kurdish land, but Syria is for all, there are Assyrians, Turkmen, Kurds, Arabs, Armenians etc...
Thats actually true. Theres so many arabic tribes in the PYD control zone that they can literally elect their own leaders if they wanted. They also riot in cities where conflict is happening to stop the PYD from showing resistance
20m Kurds. This guy really thinks the entire eastern part of Turkey is made up of Kurds... More than half the population is Turkish there, get your facts checked The entire population of the area shown in the map as "20m" kurds doesn't exceed 15m, that's counting every ethnicity, majority is which Turkish. That area has a lower population than Istanbul.
There are 10 million people total living in that area including Turks and other ethnic groups, but sure lets make up 20 million kurds out of our asses, people will believe in us anyways because we are so "independent".
@@JojoBojobIndependent journalism? A channel that didnt mention that United Nations and all nato allies defines Pkk as a terrorist organisation, that rojava contains said terrorist groups fighters, that turkey has friendly relations with Iraqi kurdistan for decades, that 4 current turkish ministers has kurdish origin, that turkey had a kurdish president in the past, that out of 600 delegates in assembly 200 are actually kurdish, that %40 of kurdish people in Turkey voted for Erdoğan in last election? You call this independent?
Kurds have fought against IS we have lost more than 30,000 fighters women and men who sacrificed their lives for us and now this is our thanks ??? and Kobane is known worldwide as a symbol of resistance; such a city should not be occupied by Turkey. Erdogan Should leave Kurds alone!!!!
Wait . What I. The guy in Europe have to care that you beated the enemy In YOUR region which atacked you first so YOU where forced to fight him for your life. And America helped you because of their interest
@@kulrul9180 because the Kurds were the only group in the region that actively fought against ISIS. look at what the others in the region did, especially Turkey
The YPG/SDF is a root of the PKK and they have bloods of our children on them. You think it is that easy? Why are we the genocider piece of shits when there is a terrorist group right freakin' next to us?
At the very begging of the video you named "rebels" instead of "terrorists" to the new regime. You lost me right there. It's like watching cnn, what's the point?
@@MagicSecretsandMysteries quite sad how people can lie am i right there is a reason its a stereotype just like us the turks being fat you guys dont have straight teeth
@@MagicSecretsandMysteries The cost of medical recourses in Turkey is quite affordable compared to Western European countries. Have you ever heard of Medical Tourism and how many people comes to Turkey just for this?
They do have a life i am from diyarbakir and i see kurds every day it not like we are trying to do genocide no we are just not letting them learn their own language which get it right if they only spoke kurdish the country wouldnt understand eachother
I don't mind Turkey here💚 I'm Syrian and I have some Turkish in me the ottomans were here for 400 years and if we didn't like them they wont make it that far 😂 remember before that we also ruled them and they liked it too so it was a unification but look for Israel they won't complete their 100 anniversary 😌
As a Turkish citizen, I believe our country's actions in Syria are aimed at protecting national security and combating terrorism. The presence of terrorist groups along our borders poses a significant threat to our safety. Additionally, creating safe zones for displaced Syrians is a humanitarian effort to provide them with shelter and security. Turkey's involvement is crucial for regional stability and ensuring a peaceful future for both Syrians and Turks.
your government has openly funded and armed terrorist groups inside syria. so your claim that it's about combatting terrorism is a clear lie. turkey's actions and invasions are in clear violation of international law, just like what israel has done in syria.
Would it not be to the benefit of everyone to strike a peace deal that creates Rojava, let's Tuyrkie have a buffer zone, and gives a 3 part security guarantee that neither part will attack the other in the future?
Thats what Turkey has asked since years ! There has to be a 30 km buffer zone outside the border ! If that border is not being respected Turkey has all the rights to take actions. Just be far away from the Turkish border !
So you’re telling me that Turkey, a NATO member with a vast arsenal, airplanes, drones and hosting nuclear weapons, is afraid of being invaded by a few Kurds in Syria who just want their rights and therefore has to invade them? Lol
this is 2025 you think world let that happen? who will fight for some none sense shit? you cant trick people with false idea, it will end up isis and rest is history. wake up.
Thank you for addressing such a complex topic, but I noticed significant gaps in your analysis. Referring to Turkey’s actions as an ‘invasion’ fails to consider Turkey’s legitimate security concerns. The PKK, a recognized terrorist organization by Turkey, the EU, and the US, has been responsible for decades of violence, claiming over 40,000 lives. The PYD/YPG, which controls much of northeastern Syria, has well-documented links to the PKK and poses a direct threat to Turkey’s borders, much like ISIS. Would the US or UK tolerate such a threat on their borders without taking action? Additionally, your focus on the Kurdish population in Syria overlooks the region’s ethnic diversity, including Turkmens and Arabs, who also face displacement and conflict. The recruitment of child soldiers by the PYD/YPG, documented by the UN, is another critical issue you omitted. Furthermore, the extensive tunnel networks in the region raise serious security concerns that are not addressed in your analysis. By selectively framing Turkey’s actions as aggressive and ignoring these broader dynamics, the video risks presenting a one-sided narrative. A balanced perspective would acknowledge Turkey’s legitimate concerns while critically examining all actors in the conflict, including the PKK/PYD/YPG.
Turkey, Syria, and Iraq really need to settle down and just let the Kurds have their own state. It can't be easy to be constantly at odds with 45million people inside your own borders.
Bro, they can’t communicate together because they speaking a dialect that can’t speak with each other. Why a country, when they don’t can speak with all Kurds?
Turkey nor the new Syrian state want any separatist armed group holding any turf in the country. The country needs to be unified under one authority and one ruler.
You are already free in Turkey. You are talking about terrorists who killed thousands in Turkiye. Around 16 million Kurds are living in Turkey. The vast majority of the Kurdish population is concentrated in large cities such as Istanbul, Ankara, and Izmir. Their lives are the same as the rest of the Turkish people. They already have equal citizenship rights. They can speak their own mother tongue, but since the dominant language in Turkey is Turkish, they speak Turkish. People all live in Turkey as equals, we have no differences from each other. Kurds have their own business, or they are educated at the same university. They are getting married to each other as Turks and Kurds, in the same country with the same citizenship under the same law. Nobody asks “What's your ethnicity?” No difference is being a Turkish or Kurdish or Cherkez or Laz or Arab or any other ethnicity.
@@DOzkay OK, but and the Syrian Kurds? They have offered to split from the PKK as part of the permanent ceasefire deal yet they don't budge. And I don't think the Kurds inside the supposed Turkish buffer zone would be that free.
Turkey wants an arab populated belt, a buffer zone, between its' borders and the kurdish controlled region. While they are not fond of an autonomous kurdish region, they mainly just dont want their own kurdish populated regions to neighbor it. If Turkey gets that buffer zone, may be convinced to leave the kurds alone. On the other hand, syrian kurds dream of a united kurdish land and they are very ambitious about it. They do not want a buffer zone, as an arab populated buffer region will not allow a united kurdish state they are dreaming of. Turkey is justified to stop that. In my opinion, for US and its' allies, making that buffer zone a reality is the only peaceful solution though.
Turkey is not justified to do anything. Invading a country and relocatting people in a certain area to remove the Kurdish residents and make them a minority is genocide all over again. But Turks have always done such actions, thats their history.
Placement of manbij is off on the map at 2:41 also as of time of writing this comment 2 hours after this video was uploaded manbij hasn't been in sdf hands for a week
0:19 Respecting the rights of kurds is not the same as giving them independence. For example: Alijah Izetbegovic didn't want Srpska to split from Bosnia but that doesn't mean he disrespected serbian rights. 2 different things here.
This only shows how ignorant you are and know nothing about Turkish army. Turkish soldiers call combat as a wedding. If you believe so let’s see the consequences. 😂
0:22 "Ceasefire between Turkish proxies and Kurdish forces"... no, they are not "Turkish-proxies"... they are local people of Syria. Please use also "US-proxies" instead of Kurds as well!
I think they will. The opportunity is too good for them not to. The Kurds control many areas that are arab majority that Turkey could switch leadership on. Additionally, turkey has a good relationship with kurdish autonomous region in Iraq so I believe they W il try to switch the leadership of Syrian kurdish areas
For the Newbie if you are actually trading in the crypto space and you don't have a sound mentor. Then you are certainly going to get liquidated in 90% of your trades. Yeah that's sad truth. I remember when i just got into crypto back in 2019 but later in 2020 i ended up selling it because i have lost alot trading all by myself without a guide. Got back into crypto early in 2024 with $20k and I'm up with $232k in a short period of time
I've tried investing in the stock market several times but always got discouraged by fluctuations of stock value. I would be happy if you could advise me based on how you went about yours, as I am ready to go the passive income path.!!
Yes true, I have been in touch with a brokerage Advisor. With an initial starting reserve of $75k, my advisor chooses the entry and exit commands for my portfolio, which has grown to approximately $550k.
Tracy Britt Cool Consulting... has always been at the top of my list.. She is regarded as a genius in her area and well knowledgeable about financial markets. I highly recommend you look her up if you want excellent collaboration.
Some facts many people seem to not know or not understand: - In Syria only less than 10% of the population is Kurds however they occupy 40% of the land thanks to US arming PKK spin-off YPG and ruling the occupying regions by force. Arab Syrians don't want YPG rule but they had no power as Assad didn't support them. Now they resist agains YPG rule because that's their land and they want to be part of new Syrian government. - Even majority of the Syrian Kurds don't want YPG rule. They also want to be part of Syria. Only US and some people living in Europe want a separate state for YPG in Syria (in the name of Kurds, in reality it is the opposite). - Kurds are not a threat to Turkey, only US armed proxy YPG/PKK is. - In a democratic new Syrian state Kurds can have their rights and live in peace. Turkey supports this idea. - Turkey is the only country who supports a unitarian secular rule in Syria, all the other countries have other interests. They would rather want to divide the country or have endless civil war. - Turkey's interests align with Europe's. Only Turkey wants to help to stop refugee influx to Europe by making Syria a safe country again. This the only way to prevent a new potential refugee influx and bring refugees from Turkey and Europe back to Syria who escaped Assad. - Turkey's occupation was planned to be temporary and it had two goals: create a secure area in NE Syria to accommodate refugees and create a buffer zone agains YPG/PKK terrorists to protect Turkish citizens. Unfortunately US and Russia/Assad didn't allow any other solution as they supported YPG/PKK terrorists to use against Turkey. As soon as YPG/PKK risk is eliminated, Turkey will end the buffer zone. - US backed YPG/PKK rule is stealing oil from Syrians, they are a narco terrorist organization. So they even don't intend to become a part of Syrian society by leaving their weapons. I am interested in constructive arguments. Let me know what you think or ask me if you have any questions.
@@Vulcan_111The name " Kurdistan" was first used in Ottoman documents in the 15th century, no earlier historical sources mentions that. In Ottoman documents, the word "Kurd, ekrad" is used for "nomads, wandering people", which actually means "yürük/yörük, Türük/Türk. In the documents it is used as an adjective not a name for a people. It is used as "ekrad-ı Türkmen " which means "wandering Türkmen. It is not used for a tribe, people. In Türkiye there are Zaza and Kurmanc people, and Mitterrand's children who have been designed and labeled as Kurds by the West. The West kept the exiled Armenians in the mountains and those people married to two or three women and they were told to have as many children as they can because the West would establish a country for them in the future. Girls of 12/13 years of age were abducted and married older men by force ( I knew one of them who went through such a situation and had run away leaving two kids behind). One man had three wives and more than twenty kids. They were all fed by the West in the mountains. The West did not let Türkiye to invest in the area so the people had migrated to big cities. Those designed and labeled as Kurds were placed in the area. Today, in Türkiye when someone says "I'm a Kurd" he/she is the Kurdoid produced in the Zagros laboratries .
not all the land they have is inhabitable yet you conflated this extra land as theirs anyways when there is proportionately the same land to the rest of syria
@@Vulcan_111 thats not true at all? Kurds wouldnt want to be a part of a shity country that doesnt have the bare neccesities and literally an open estate for US
Personally I’m from Aleppo. It’s heartbreaking that all these countries have their beliefs and their eyes on my country. Syria is rich with natural resources. From oil and gas to Agricultural land in the east and the west. In the north east of Syria the USA existing . Russia’s eyes in the-sea side. Turkey’s eyes in the north. Israel and Iran in the south. Lord bless and bring peace to everyone.
@@CryptoBroke I know you are misinformed due to your media and overlords, but sdf is a militant group linked with t3r0r orgs, which did countless t3r0r attacks. They should not be named alongside the word kurds. they don't represent kurds.
0:32 Can’t believe the Wall Street Journal is invading Syria next
If a tea company can invade a country, why not WSJ
Based?
Only a secular Kurdish state is guarantee that Christians and Alwites and other minorities will not be prosecuted. Everything else is just more bloodshed and head chopping. History has shown that the worst gen0cides against Christians because of their faith were committed in Anatolia by the same people invading Syria now
😂😂😂😂😂
This is no laughing matter, the last time the WSJ invaded a country, they committed mass human rights violations
Turkey: "we condemn Israel for entering the buffer zone in Syria"
Also Turkey: invades Syria.
When Turkey already holds thousands of square kilometers of Syria.
kudus belongs to TÜRKİYE..........
Turkey overthrows Syria and installs a puppet state*
@@blacklight4720 They want to have a good bargaining position for the Istanbul Conference which will deal with the Syrian question.
Erdogan has no morals or alliance, he just says things for his personal gains.
If you could all just stop invading each other for like, five minutes, that would be GREAT.
Welcome to the middle east, where everyone is swearing over the destruction of the next guy.
It would be super funny to see how many invasions would take place and how many genocides if the US would pull out from all their bases in the middle east.
That's not how humanity works
That's not how the middle east works 💀
But it could lead to further stability in the long run if the country wasn't split
Meh boring.
Turkiye and Israel pee in the same pool yet blames the other when the water starts turning yellow.
😂
Erdogan and Netanyahu are cut from the cloth
idiot. the sdf isnt the same thing as syria. we arent hurting the syrian government. we are hurting the sdf.
@@LiF-y3c They're both Aberhamics?
not the same kurd occupie syrian ground turkey just wants a fully syrian border and no kurds
Would everyone leave Syria alone
For fuck sake
maybe after the SDF is disbanded
kurds started it first xD
@@koseku3nga theyre hopping over more borders than africans tf u mean
@@koseku3how? By fucking existing? That's their homeland.
Kurds live in Syria...
Sometimes you accidentally invade Poland, others Syria, it is a mistake everyone can make.
I invaded mexico the other day, stuff happens ya know
@linusmlgtips2123 ah, you missed Cuba too! Easy mistake to make.
Just don’t make that mistake in Afghanistan, knew a few guys who did that.
Always hate it when countries pretend they have never talked to their enemies before therefore have no choice but military action.
Please give clay
No
>.
Since most of the Syrians who had stake in Syria in the north become refugees in Turkey some are even sent from Europe to Turkey, it is kind of within their rights to intervene by extension of the stakes of refugees. Turkey wants them return, it is not possible if YPG snatches up that land.
Except the Democratic forces are a healthy mix of Arabs and Kurds.
@ sure, they are not even just Kurds, diverse groups join for common interest is fishy, supports Turkey's thesis them being opportunist mercenaries supported by minority.
Your information is incorrect, Kurds are unhappy and revolting against SDF. SDF has killed civilians in the last week.
Ottoman empire comeback before gta 6 ??? 😮
50 trillion billions dollars of debt.
people need to stop comment about gta 6
fuck no
GTA 6 before Half-Life 3?!
Debt is saying hi😂
i dont see anyone protesting for kurdish civillians
Of course not, the Turks aren't Jewish
I see them a lot in Germany. Many people from the Palestine movement and Kurdistan movement collaborate
Cause it's not trendy to stand against Muslims. Hating Jews on the other hand...
Now you do.
They can stop being terrorists
Maybe he wants to recreate the Ottoman Empire 🤷🏻♀️
Feel like we can add the rebirth of the Ottoman Empire to the Biden-Harris bingo card of disasters.
Not really more like limiting kurdish groups
Good. The Ottoman Empire was more powerful more ethnically diverse more economically stable than most of the Middle East and Eastern Europe combined
And to do this. They want to destroy all Kurds. This is sad😢😢
@@patrickkirby6580until the Polish Hussars entered.
Remember no matter how far Turkey goes in there'll always be more Syrians in Turkey than Turks in Syria.
How many times they have done this again?
its none of your business really.
Depends if you have been watching anti Turkish racist western media that not only ignores israhel occupation of Syrian land and actively bringing european khazars to colonise Syrian land
Ask your father netanysu milokowski
@@homer1273 who? Like literally?
@@cryptofinancex thank you for your input cryptofinancex
Can't we just leave the Syrians alone?
No because it will be a failed state leading to another migrant crises in Europe. Stop your populist isolationist nonsense.
Nope. You neocons demanded Assad go. Enjoy chaos
If this sort of thing happened in Mexico the US would definitely be getting involved. Ignoring a power vacuum on your border is extremely risky.
Syrian people need Turkish people to help them build Syria democratic and get rid of the invaders the past regime let them in.
@taj but it sounds like the Turkish people aren’t too interested in that
There is no “de facto kurdish state” they don’t even imply it themselves.
Turkey says otherwise.
Definitely Ain't gonna see much protest in US universities regarding this 😅
"Is Syria some kind of new sea food dish?"
Because the Turks don’t want to genocide the Kurds they want to destroy their government.
What is Aleppo?
No because apparently invading a country isn’t a problem as long as the invading power isn’t western
@Randomchannel2005 I disagree, but you don't think it's a problem at all or are similar to your bankrupt caricature.
I love how people condem israel for taking control of the buffer zone (for the high mountain points) but ignore turkey literally land grabbing from syria, turkey just wants to continue to oppress kurds and other minority but the world ignores it.
There are thousands of kurds proudly serving in the turkish army. There are 2 minister and a vice president of kurdish origin in erdoğan's cabinet. Kurds are not oppressed in turkiye. We are targetting terrorists not kurds. SDF is a terrorist organization consists of not only kurds.
Erm, the fact we're here commenting on this video proves we're not ignoring Turkish aggression. But it is appropriate to pay more attention to foreign aggression that our own governments are enabling. Especially when there is so much disinformation being spread about the aggression, such as that it's "only a buffer zone", despite the fact that there are at least 20,000 Israeli non-military citizens settled on Syrian territory in the Golan Heights. This is clearly territorial expansion.
@kicorse Golan heights itself is something different, when I say people I mean in general not necessary people here on the video
Israel is settling in the buffer zone
Both goverments are shit
In a world of hypocrites, Türkiye is the most hypocritical of all. Turks in Cyprus and Palestinians have right to self determination (fair enough) but Kurds (or Uyghurs) no?
Boycott Türkiye.
Boycott djfnjfjfjf nope u can't
When it comes to delusional countries it is by far the worst, able to be even worse than Serbia and Russia.
Uyghurs????? What about them?
We do not mistreat the kurds if they want to learn their own language they can learn it outside of school
Turkey* an oppressor state won't get to be called wha they wantt
As usual, the Western media is still trying to separate the Kurdish minorities from their Arab surroundings. In Syria specifically, the Kurdish minority does not exceed 10% of the population, and they are spread and integrated throughout northern Syria, and are not concentrated in northeastern Syria only. Also, the lands east and north of the Euphrates River are full of Arabs, and therefore more than half of the population of the new state will be Arabs in any independence.
They in fact not only exceed 10% of the population, they are the 3rd largest ethnic group in Syria (if not 2nd), and the Kurds make up about half of the population of Rojava. Rojava itself as a group isn't even stated to be run by Kurds on its entirely, but made up of both Kurds and Arabs.
@@supb1848There are not even 2 million Kurds in Syria. There are 15 million Arabs and 5 million Turkmens. But you are occupying half of the country. The terrorist PKK, the servant of imperialism, will be expelled from Syrian lands!
if they made up only 10% how are they able to rule??????? they would massive fucking manpower issues bro.
Have you ever been in Syria? According to last Syrian census Kurds were 10% of Syria. But half of Arabs left Syria and consequently Kurds constitute nearly 20% of Syria and 65% of SDF-controlled region.
Wow, while the Kurds were fighting ISIS and the barbaric Assad, the Arabs were just running away. That's why Türkiye and all of Europe were filled with huge migrations of refugees. And now the Arabs have that land
The US has 2000 troops in Syria. didn't you hear? Pentagon spokesman said "Ooops! We had 1100 more troops in the region. I am sorry we have just been told!" We don't want to Invade Syria. We are not either Israel or Russia. We want however a secure zone along our southern border. If the US has a right to create a zone between the US and Mexico. If Israel had this between them an Syria, Lebanon and Egypt, if Greece has a right to build walls to stop refugees so we Turks has this right too.
About the Kurds. A state is not given. It is in no one's right to do so. British and France tried this after the WWI with Sykes and Picot agreements and bloodshed never stopped. If you deserved a state, you have a state already. If you don't that means you do not have a state culture. Kurds never had one. They have a right to live free and in peace like any other people. But Kurdish people do not want a state like other people does. Other people unite to have their own state and fight against whatever strength they muster as a strong fist. However, these terrorist organizations come from Kurdish communities cannot care less about having a nation. They do not fight for a nation. They fight for a base so they can handle their drug, human and arms trafficking easier. What? Did you think these people were innocent freedom fighters? 80% of the crime run through PKK and YPG in Europe. Just ask Sweeden and they will give you all the information.
Russians used Kurdish terrorist groups before the US taken over them. They went from one country to another for support ever since. Well, after decades later they can't find anyone to sit on their lap. These terrorist organisations will become worm food very soon. Our civilian Kurdish brothers and sisters are welcome to live amongst us as they had. But anyone take up arms against to Turkish or Syrian forces will simply die. This is not a treat. This is eventuality.
Trump on their way to put in service exactly 0 men in Syria the second stepping into power:
@@supb1848 Everyone calls Trump a businessman and do not respect his patriotic side. The US in the middle east for two reasons. One petrol, Two Israel. Jewish media and businessman in the US never liked or cared about Trump (or any other American than themselves for that matter), and two all the petrol in the region is not wort losing the entire east to China. Trump knows math. So, he doesn't want to spend too much hard power in the Middle East while there was more powerful foe rising in the East. He will try to use soft power against Türkiye like he did before with the embargos and such, but he cares less about Israel nor the Middle East anymore.
As long as Türkiye doesn't push Trump, Trump won't push back.
The kurdish people do want independance, but they were literally split between 4 nations (divide and conquer style)
For a people who are a minority in every state they inhabit, guerrilla warfare (+ terrorism) seems like a logical outcome. I am not justifying terrorism, but the PKK did not appear on a vacuum....
@@I_am_somebody_1234 No! Kurdish people weren't divided and conquered. They were like pre-colonised African people living in small groups without caring whatever flags flew above them.
People from Europe doesn't realize this or realize but don't care because they profit a lot from the chaos in the region but this much division in the Middle East not healthy for the people. Middle East isn't like Europe. Let's talk about Finland. It has 5.6 million population and 5 million of them is Christian Finnish. Syria isn't like that, there are Turkmens, Arabs, Durzis, Kurds, Jews, Christians etc. etc. etc You cannot divide a demographics like that since the biggest country would be the size of a town in London. A lot of Arabic tribes are actually rebelling against to SDF in the areas they are controlling right now. So, what about those people?
Divide and conquer is not a Middle Eastern concept. Born in the East and embraced by the West. Answer this question. Why would the EU and the UNITED States would push this nationalist right-wing agenda in the Middle East but when it came to themselves, they keep uniting? Everyone else but Middle east is getting united. EU, BRICS, OTS etc. etc.
Turkish supported HTS is establishing order, opening reinstating municipalities, schools, hospitals, trade etc. They came to power 12 days ago. What did the US supported SDF do in last 12 years other than stealing petrol? As soon as they realized their days numbered in the region, the US killed the ISIS leader. And started to say ISIS is a treat again.
Anyway. Long story short There are some Kurdish terrorist organisations trying to pump people with these nationalistic ideas, but people don't care less. Otherwise with this many weapons and money coming from the US they could have overthrown Essad themselves, but these terrorist organisations actually terrorize Kurdish civilians first. As long as they were able to sell petrol to the US, traffic Essad's drugs and align their pockets with money, they were happy the things as they were.
So effing true, the sdf kidnapped my dad one time, i keep saying it over and over dang it! THE SDF SHOULDN'T EXIST.
Correction: there are currently 2000 US troops on Rojava. I understand you it's hard to keep up with all the info. I hope this does not come off as an attack.
We literally fought IS1$ away and made Europe safe, and this is our thanks..?!?!?????? You can sleep without IS1$ attacks, and this is how you thanks the Kurds for defending you??!?!?!?
See what you did made me and u break my Kurdish heart …
I want to have a place to belong to, I want to have a home, a motherland I can call for mine, and not get bullied by everyone in school for not having a counti can call mine, I am no one, I belong to nowhere
Terrorists fighting other terrorists, SDF is no different than ISIS
Turkey would do that but americans choose kurdish group that want to have control over syria anyways.
No one owes a single dime to sdf/pkk.
We, the Ards, fought too, not just the Kurds, but you should not do this. Also, these organizations you are talking about are organizations of American manufacture, and they placed them among us anyway
لقد حذرناكم نحن العرب ، المتغطي بأمريكا و الغرب عريان ، و بالوقت المناسب سوف يقومون ببيعكم حسب المصلحه.
@@baraabekkur US didn't create anything, it was supporting other groups while the Kurds emerged. The US supported them later.
When Israel invades Syria, Israel has right to defend itself.
When turkey invades Syria, turkey wants to recreate Ottoman Empire.
So would you justice both?
Exactly, last time I checked Israel isn't in the genocide business, unlike Turkey.
@@seankane8628 wow they occupiers man.
Israel is deploying troops to the demilitarised zone, not "seizing Syrian territory." And if one reads the 1974 disengagement of forces agreement, one would know that according to that agreement, all of the territory east of the purple line (the de facto border between Israel and Syria) was to be administered by Syria, and all of the territory west of the purple line, was to be administered by Israel, pending a final settlement on the Arab Israeli Conflict. That's s binding international law. The dmz was placed strictly west of the Purple line, in Israeli territory. When the Syrian government and military collapsed, Israel was within its right to deploy troops on its side of the Purple Line. So please stop with the lies and hypocrisy. 🕎
@@seankane8628lmao did you just say turkey is not a genocidal state
Let's add the rest of the information you deliberately left out in this video:
- Turkey has just shy of 5 Million Syrian refugees, more than the entire sum of entire Syrian refugees in the world if you leave Lebanon out.
- Turkey is 3rd most affected country after Syria and Lebanon because of the war, including mass migration, mass terrorism, border insecurity, artillery shelling...
- The so-called SDF, Syrian Democratic Forces, are neither Syrian nor Democratic. They are an autocratic armed militia who are oppressing anyone who are not Kurdish, such as Sunni Arabs. The Kurdish superminority is ruling over vast swathes of land that have nothing to do with Kurds or Kurdish history or culture.
- Turkey has stellar relationship with the Kurdish State in Iraq. Iraqi Kurds are also on bad terms with this so-called SDF.
- Kurds in Turkey are not some "oppressed minority", but enjoy high living standards for around 80-90% of the Kurdish population. Kurds "enjoy" free gas, electricity and amenities because it is impossible to regulate the area. Any Kurd can set up shop anywhere in Turkey, but a Turk setting up shop in a Kurdish region would result in arson or murrder and that is an objective fact.
- SDF is the #1 arms, drugs, and counterfeit money supplier into Turkey, including acting as a staging ground or an escape route for virtually all terror operations in Turkey.
- Despite the US failure to support the 2nd most powerful NATO country, and despite their trusting of the so-called SDF in the fight against ISIS, and despite cancelling all arms deals, Turkey is fighting NATO enemies all over the place, including beating Russia 3 times in Libya, Armenia-Azerbaijan Conflict, and Syria. Turkey literally toppled the "butcher" and "dictator" Assad regime within a week, so I don't understand what is wrong from the perspective of so-called liberal, democratic Western views.
Last but not least: The relations between Lebanon, Syria and Turkey are rooted beyond the Ottoman Empire. The humanitarian aid provided to the region is virtually unparalleled by any other nation for earth. For more than a decade, literal millions and millions of Syrians have worked and went to school in Turkey. They have started families, they have had children and grand children. So before some random Brit or American says anything about the situation, such as "muh ottomans" or "muh lesbian Kurdish freedom fighters", stop listening to mainstream slop and try to get an idea of what it means to be actually involved in real world affairs.
Average westerner response: ... but they have "democratic" in their name, Turkey against democracy!
lol, nice try. We know for a fact that Turkey is moving Syrian refugees illegally to Europe, Frontex has caught countless Turkish traffikers. also, NATO's second most powerful country is either France or Britain, so keep dreaming. and lastly, every human rights organization has condemned the treatment of Kurds by Turkey. Turkey is a totalitarian regime with no respect of basic human rights, that's why every attempt to join the EU has been denied. stop lying
Turkey is still a dictatorship and they're still constantly too shifty for the West OR Russia. Opinion fake and disregarded.
Finally! The truth!
Exactly! I can not believe people think Turks are invading Syria, although we are the ones who literally brought the peace and help demolish a dictatorship. It feels like global media shows racism towards us Turks. Also no, SDF have no right to have land in Turkey.
This channel slowly became more and more political, from an entertaining hannel that aims to be objective, to a fairly obviously political news filter channel, oh well, time to look for something else 😢
bro wtf
I don't understand why people think Turkey is invading Syria. The Turks are in Syria because the Syrian people want the Turks, because Syria is still not completely safe and they are not afraid of the Turkish army. If the Turks were not on the side of the Syrian people, the regime would be standing. Turkey has a large share in the collapse of the regime. More than 5 million Syrians lived in Turkey. Don't comment on topics you don't know about.
"I don't understand why people think Russia is invading Ukraine. The Russians are in Ukraine because the Ukrainin\an people want the Russians, because Ukraine is still not completely safe and they are not afraid of the Russian army. If the Russians were not on the side of the Ukrainian people the Maidan regime would still be standing. Russia has a large share in the collapse of the regime. More than 2 million Ukrainians lived in Russia. *Don't comment on topics you don't know about* "
/s
Syria is home to many ethnic and religiously diverse people. No geographical area is homogeneous Dividing Syria into many states or administrations based on ethnic and religious grounds willead to endless wars. Is this war environment deliberately desired to continue? Who will benefit from it? The Middle East has suffered greatly from ethnic and religious micro-nationalisms. Instead, wouldn't it be a better approach to build a unitary state where every individual in Syria benefits from equal citizenship rights? Previously, Kurds did not have citizenship rights or official identities. However, now the central government is calling on everyone to be represented in the administration. Contrary to your claim, Professor, laying down arms and electing and sending civilian deputies to the Syrian parliament seems like a more civilized and peaceful approach Why do you find it so difficult to focus on the common interests of Syrians instead of using ethnic and religious differences to feed micro-
?nationalisms
If there was an armed terrorist organization in your neighboring country that wanted to divide and destroy your country, would your country remain silent about this? That's what I thought too.
Me when the Rojavan government offered as part of the ceasefire deal cut ties with the PPK, agreement supported by the transitional syrian government but rejected by the Turks.
what government?
@@supb1848Very interesting claims, source?
Me when I argue for greater Israel.
@@supb1848 you mean the Rojavan """government""" whose political and military leadership consists of PKK members? Very honest offer lol
O haritaya İsrail in işgal ettiği topraklarıda gösterin.
bencede ve teröristlerin ypg ile beraber çalıştığınıda göstermeliler. Türkiye o bölgede özgür suriye kurması normal bir şey , ypg nin orada ayrı bir yönetim kurmasından daha normal çünkü o bölgede teröristler var.
Only the turkish Sultan knows 🤷🏻♀️
But he really doesn't like the kurds and I wouldn't be surprised...
Turkiye foreign minister is a Kurdish. So there is no problem with kurds.
@@yusufbulbul7100yup no Armenian genocide only imaginary turkish genocide
😂😂😂😂😂😂@@yusufbulbul7100
@@yusufbulbul7100 the finance minister and many others too are Kurdish. People have no idea but still speaking as if Turkey is massacring its people.
😂🫵@@yusufbulbul7100
Reminder that Turkiye has killed hundreds of thousands of Kurds for no good reason, but condemns Israel for defending itself.
Go on proof
Same shit different country
Turkey also committed genocide on the Armenians and Greek.
Hahaha nice joke
Where is the proof? Theres a majority of kurds in the east Turkey. How tf Turkey killed them?
Maybe if turkey stopped trying to get rid of and suppress its ethnic minorities there wouldn't be such separatism in the Kurdish regions.
They will never admit to that. Hell, not only did they screw over the Kurds with the treaty of Lausanne, they banned all their shit, language, even changed their city names 😂 and forced them to join the shitty ass state turkey. How can you be a separatist when you were forced to join in the first place?? They even killed the ppl. In dersim for protesting against this oppression. So either be killed or forced to speak turkish and live under their rules and everyone that speaks up is a separatist trying to devide this so called "brotherhood". Brotherhood my ass you aren't even allowed to display a single kurdish word out there bc they get a stroke from seeing one.
Which also is funny bc you can see it in these comments here as well. It's always the same excuse they try and yet some ppl. still fall for it. They claim everyone is treated so good in turkey why would you be scared of a movment if the syrian kurds have autonomy??? What is it now? Do you treat them so good that they want to live with you or do you treat them like garbage and that's why you can't have kurds close to you with autonomy??? The PKK said it doesn't operate in syria anymore, the sdf offered multiple solutions to a ceasefire, they just now even offered to have no military near the border and US Troops would control the area. Even that offer is something turkey doesn't want, if they really cared about "national security" it wouldn"t be an issue but everyone that knows history damn well knows what turkey wants.
Kurds fight with each other as well. Do you really think they are a united front and Turks are the only problem here?
you know syria and turkey different countries right american ?
Turkey is not trying to suppress Kurdish minorities and NEVER tried to get rid of kurdish minorities. Turkey's main concern is security. Rojava has direct connection with another terorist organization (PKK). Any nation will do their best to eliminate open threat like this
@@kizgintosbagayou know Kurdish populations live in more places then Rojava?
Where are the arab bots criticizing Israel for creating a buffer zone at?
👆👇
I think the main difference between the Turkish zone and the Israelis is that the Turks have zero plans to settle and annex the area, unlike Israel which has an interest in annexing territory, populating it with settlers and then annexing more territory to defend said settlers
@@nizam5568that’s BS even turkey has been settling the buffer zone
@@erketyrettile4734 well yeah where else they could s3nd back thousands of Syrians
Nop not true @@erketyrettile4734
Is Turkey really occupying? There is a group on their borders armed against their country, my friend. If the same situation had happened to any EU country or the USA, there would be no such thing as Syria. Why did you find it so offensive to create a safe haven along the border to keep their own territory safe? Moreover, the terrorist incidents and civilian deaths in Turkey over the years were caused by the SDF.
They are not occupying if you want to know what invasion and occupation means look at iraq2003 and Palestine right now
Same excuses as israel
@ryboi1337 Isreal: came without invite take places to cut the water electricity and bombing force people to leave their homes, they weave their flag on someone else is country saying it is their territory now.
Turkeya: hold Syrian refugees that called Turkeya to help them fix the problem that make them refugees in the first place with goal to let them go back and live in peace in their homeland, and hold that country flag saying it is Syrian country they only came to help.
If this was occupation then i am iraqi i wished the 2003 was like that i will not call it invasion if it was like what Turkeya doing in Syria
@ryboi1337 no isreal came by itself and call ot their land now and force people to leave but Turkeya is helping Syrian to return to their home by cleaning the land from invader
@@taj3968 ... I won't bother communicating with Turkish bots
syrian kurds have no choice but to be under the new rulers in damascus with limited autonomy to prevent turkey from ousting them.
you cant' spell the correct pronounce of the name of head of the turkish republic who is in charge nearly 2 decades and yet trying to educate ppl on politics of turkey and its neighbours.
he pronounced it better than last time
Dictators should have their name said wrong on purpose.
@@Seth9809 🤓
You made a few factual errors at 2:53 About 15 million Kurds live in Turkey. And at 5:27 2000 American soldiers are in Syria now according to the Pentagon.
Not only errors but many deliberatly false western propganda claims
The majority of US Troops are on the Iraq/Syria border in the south occupying oil fields not in Rojava
There are more than 20mil in turkey
Yes its because turkey occupy kurdish land, self inflicted
40M kurds live in turkey most of them think they are turkish until a dna test
that's another example of bias: calling the PKK terrorists, while calling the HTS rebels. both are on various lists of terrorist oranisations. if you want to be impartial you could call both of them rebels, or both of them terrorist groups, but calling one of them rebels and the others terrorists is not impartial. the first would definitely be preferable, since even nelson mandela was part of a "terroist organisation" according to the u.s.
despite i agree with world's hypocrisy in terrorism matter, in this situation it is understandable, PKK commonly known with civillian bombings for decades and their terrorist identity is undisputed. But Terrorism claims of HTS have more political tendencies like ''they are fighting agains a government which is our ally, so they must be terrrorists''. Basically they are more like'' Mandela class'' terrorists. And they gonna be removed from these lists because they won the war and gonna become new government (and new ally to U.S. in that matter).
Как можно не видеть разницы между HTS и RKK? Первые воевали против диктатора асада, который их убивал, пытал в тюрьмах, грабил, занимался изготовлением и торговлей наркотиками, а вторые занимается тем, что совершают набеги на турецких военных в Турции и совершает теракты против гражданского населения, пытаюсь такими методами отделить курдские территории и создать отдельное государство. Сирийские курды--- это ответвление RKK. Если кто-то выступает за расчленение Сирии или Турции, то пусть начнёт со своей страны, например, Даст свободу техасу и флориде, Шотландия, Ирландии, во Франции есть много чего отделить, Каталонии и так далее
maybe if the PKK didnt kill teachers, doctors, children, kidnap women, etc. they wouldnt be considered terrorists
@@liliyanahmetova4853 hts is an offshoot of al-qaeda and ideologically close to isis. the ypg fought hard against isis' brutal regime, known for their strict enforcement of ancient barabaric customs, use of drugs, rape of women and numerous beheadings, and the ypg defeated them. they also aren't authoritarian in any way; they organise their society based on human rights and grassroots democracy.
the rojava does not want to have a seperate kurdish state, but wants autonomy within syria. that could actually be a role model for kurdish autonomy with turkey that ends violence of the turkish state against its citizens and violence of the PKK against the turkish military.
i do support independece of all regions that want independence, be it scotland, catalonia, texas or whereever. they should have a referendum and decide democratically.
ireland is already independent. do you want to bring it back under british rule? i'm sure the irish wouldn't be too happy for that. you'd probably see violent "terrorist" groups fighting for independence if britain annexed ireland again.
no
No country has done more to the Syrian people than Turkey. Saving the lives of 4 ml Syrians from certain death by the regime and has been taken care of them for the last 14 years costing the Turkish taxpayers over 40 bn $ yet you don't hear that in the Western media. and Turkey is not fighting the Kurds but fighting a designated Kurdish terrorist organization pkk that happens to be the Kurdish majority
Kurds deserve their own nation!
nope
@@ScythianMassagets tell me you're a turk without telling me you are one lol
@@ScythianMassagetsfree Kurdistan
Do you go around yelling free palestine?
@@sasansafar bla bla cry it turks against kurds in syria like in assad..
Not on Turkish soil or near Turkey's border. Anywhere else they can do whatever they want
No Kurdish seperatist state. They cannot allow that to happen.
You are not in this position take care your ass😂😂😂
good
How interesting it is that somehow Kurdish lands coincides with where Syrian Oil reserves are and USA is supporting it.
Must be the thousands of year old Kurdish society conveniently living there to steal oil for the Oil exporting USA 😂
How interesting Turkey is trying to take the region from the Kurds by genocide?
The US just doesn’t want terrorist groups to be able to sell that oil on the black market or the Assad regime.
The US has been producing more oil than the middle eastern countries since 2018 after we reupped production. Europe receives more oil from the Mideast than the US and that’s been true for quite a long time.
I’d say now that Assad is gone the US troops will be pulled out after Trump is inagurated
This is so biased video. Becuase you talk like these territory only belongs to the Kurds. Actually Kurds are minority most of the places they invaded during the civil war. If your biased point of wiev correct there must be at least 20 more new independent country just in EU borders. If you like these seperatists so much, why don't you share your own ?country
That's not what the locals say, they say they're about half the population.
Isreal having a bufferzon: 👎🤬🔥🧯
Meanwhile Turkey does the same:☺️🙈🙄😅
As an Arab, if israel have the rights to defend itself by attacking everyone, then Turks and us Arabs have the rights to defend ourselves too, don't you think so? It would be fair like that.
@@Proud_Hadrami so now doing something wrong is OK because Israeli did it but when Israel does it then it's not ok.
Cool.
both are devils servants
@@Proud_Hadrami Yea that's alright, but I dont like how the turkish govt is always first in the line to condemn other states when they do the same shit.
@@iftyhargil8359 israel has been doing the same thing for 75 years to Palestinians and now to Syrians, there is no Western and European country that dare to talk with them, they have been doing genocide to Palestinians, and whenever we Arabs talk about it they say they have the rights to defend themselves, why is it us Arabs and Muslims the one at the blame when we do the same thing? If they are allowed to do genocide then we are also allowed, if the Western world decided that it is self defence then it would be for us all, that previlige is not only for israel.
Invasion you say?
The CIA just entered the chat...
"Israel Occupies Syria" (your title) with its own military BUT turkey backs syrian anti goverment (goverment that already fell btw) rebels "Turkey About to Invade Syria" Great journalism bud 👏👏👏
TLDR are really disappointing sometimes
100% accurate
And who overthrew Syria? Who planned and funded the operation? Proxies magically funded themselves?
Does it matter whether its them or a proxy doing it? If anything, acting like the SNA has nothing to do with Turks is deceitful.
It is an invasion however.
you ll see no demonstration in london against “colonialism occupation “”that’s for sure😂
Wow, rare example of avoiding Betteridge's law of headlines, kudos to TLDR for this one.
Very well explained conflict 🙏🏾 thanks was way better tu understand than usual
Turkey should focus on addressing its inflation, poverty, and infrastructure issues, as well as legalizing gay marriage , before turning its attention to concerns about Syria.
exactly
Erdogen is not really popular anymore. People know that he sucks and he thinks big of himself
And that's exactly why erdogen wants syria. He will use it to boost his own chance of winning elections
Well, you are right we surely have to address those issues though wtf US is doing in the Middle East while they have %130 debt to gdp ratio, increasing income inequality, stagnant real wages for years and huge political and cultural polarization??
They should focus on actual important things like the first 3. No need to waste resources going against their population like the western "democracy"
Tell that to Hungary first
Kurdish area is fiction of Brit mcgurk and the neocon . There is no Kurdish area in Syria . The Kurds are barely majority on some border town with turkey . the area SDF control now is 80% Arab land not Kurdish
@ahmedhumoud5760
There is no Arabs invaders in north Africa tamazgha there's only majority Imazighen people
Arab colonizers. Kurds are native there
Arab colonizers of Kurdish lands.
@@samiman5606 if Amazigh want to have their own country then be it, and if Kurds want to have their own country then be it, but do it outside of our land, do it in places where Kurds are the majority, because in the so called SDF, Arabs are protesting massivley for their rights, SDF is just a Kurdish land, but Syria is for all, there are Assyrians, Turkmen, Kurds, Arabs, Armenians etc...
Thats actually true. Theres so many arabic tribes in the PYD control zone that they can literally elect their own leaders if they wanted.
They also riot in cities where conflict is happening to stop the PYD from showing resistance
20m Kurds. This guy really thinks the entire eastern part of Turkey is made up of Kurds... More than half the population is Turkish there, get your facts checked
The entire population of the area shown in the map as "20m" kurds doesn't exceed 15m, that's counting every ethnicity, majority is which Turkish. That area has a lower population than Istanbul.
lol, ya lets just believe the Turk in the comments and disregard independent journalism
There are 10 million people total living in that area including Turks and other ethnic groups, but sure lets make up 20 million kurds out of our asses, people will believe in us anyways because we are so "independent".
@@erbilyakskan8637 There are close to 20m including Kurds in the Western Turkey. Infact more Kurds live in Western Turkey than Eastern Turkey.
ohh look at all the mad turkeys in comments😂
@@JojoBojobIndependent journalism? A channel that didnt mention that United Nations and all nato allies defines Pkk as a terrorist organisation, that rojava contains said terrorist groups fighters, that turkey has friendly relations with Iraqi kurdistan for decades, that 4 current turkish ministers has kurdish origin, that turkey had a kurdish president in the past, that out of 600 delegates in assembly 200 are actually kurdish, that %40 of kurdish people in Turkey voted for Erdoğan in last election? You call this independent?
Syria is becoming like a playground for all its neighbors..
Wtf question is this...this is like to ask if Rusia invade in Crimea or Donbas...
If Turkey do this they need to be removed from NATO, they do not act like a proper member of the alliance.
And rest of the NATO does ?
turkey doesnt care . Nato need Turkey , not he need them
Nobody can do that. Nato needs Turkey more than ever for its security. Who will counter Russia in Europe when US is dealing with China in pacific?
Define a proper member please.
Nato needs Turkey more than Turkey needs nato
Free Kurdistan
No such thing.
@amykpop1 Then what's the PKK for?
Free them of what
@ER0G Just give them a f independence.
@@BurnBird1PKK is literally known for having done genocides against local armenian and kurdish groups in their area lmaooo
Kurds have fought against IS we have lost more than 30,000 fighters women and men who sacrificed their lives for us and now this is our thanks ???
and Kobane is known worldwide as a symbol of resistance; such a city should not be occupied by Turkey.
Erdogan Should leave Kurds alone!!!!
Kurdish armed forces: SDF/YPG/PKK which are all the same shit should LEAVE TURKEY ALONE, if they want to be left alone.
Wait . What I. The guy in Europe have to care that you beated the enemy In YOUR region which atacked you first so YOU where forced to fight him for your life. And America helped you because of their interest
@@kulrul9180 because the Kurds were the only group in the region that actively fought against ISIS. look at what the others in the region did, especially Turkey
The YPG/SDF is a root of the PKK and they have bloods of our children on them. You think it is that easy? Why are we the genocider piece of shits when there is a terrorist group right freakin' next to us?
America left you 😂 Russia left you 😂 don't worry you still have Israel 😂
At the very begging of the video you named "rebels" instead of "terrorists" to the new regime. You lost me right there. It's like watching cnn, what's the point?
Serbia is having its biggest protests since independance and this channel doesent give a shit lol
Turks am I right
Aynen
Hahahaha dont worry we atleast have straighter teeth
@ER0G Actually, on average, you don't.
@@MagicSecretsandMysteries quite sad how people can lie am i right there is a reason its a stereotype just like us the turks being fat you guys dont have straight teeth
@@MagicSecretsandMysteries The cost of medical recourses in Turkey is quite affordable compared to Western European countries. Have you ever heard of Medical Tourism and how many people comes to Turkey just for this?
turkey: invade
israel: extend its rightful lands
Two different ways to say the same thing
Turkey just doesn't want the kurds to have a life.
They do have a life i am from diyarbakir and i see kurds every day it not like we are trying to do genocide no we are just not letting them learn their own language which get it right if they only spoke kurdish the country wouldnt understand eachother
@ER0G erdogan? Is that you buddy?
@ER0G Even Israeli Arabs are allowed to learn Arabic in their schools. Turkey is much worse than Israel apparently.
Theres literally no oppresion on Kurds? Fym?
@@RobyHirsh firstly i cannot vote i am 16 secondly my family is against him
I don't mind Turkey here💚 I'm Syrian and I have some Turkish in me the ottomans were here for 400 years and if we didn't like them they wont make it that far 😂 remember before that we also ruled them and they liked it too so it was a unification but look for Israel they won't complete their 100 anniversary 😌
Islam is the key 💚✌️
As a Turkish citizen, I believe our country's actions in Syria are aimed at protecting national security and combating terrorism. The presence of terrorist groups along our borders poses a significant threat to our safety. Additionally, creating safe zones for displaced Syrians is a humanitarian effort to provide them with shelter and security. Turkey's involvement is crucial for regional stability and ensuring a peaceful future for both Syrians and Turks.
your government has openly funded and armed terrorist groups inside syria. so your claim that it's about combatting terrorism is a clear lie.
turkey's actions and invasions are in clear violation of international law, just like what israel has done in syria.
Turkey needs to take the opportunity to stop those separatists.
Lol
But you guys don't support Israel when it acts for its national security
@@Inferred17 Rules for thee, not for me.
Would it not be to the benefit of everyone to strike a peace deal that creates Rojava, let's Tuyrkie have a buffer zone, and gives a 3 part security guarantee that neither part will attack the other in the future?
No. You cannot trust a terrorist state, they would agree to not attacking but still act as a safe house for the PKK terrorists.
Peace doesn't benefit the stronger power, in this case Turkey
Turkey wants all of it. Getting it now? The fascist erdogan is trying to bring back the dead Ottoman Empire
Thats what Turkey has asked since years ! There has to be a 30 km buffer zone outside the border ! If that border is not being respected Turkey has all the rights to take actions. Just be far away from the Turkish border !
Turkey wants it all for itself.
So you’re telling me that Turkey, a NATO member with a vast arsenal, airplanes, drones and hosting nuclear weapons, is afraid of being invaded by a few Kurds in Syria who just want their rights and therefore has to invade them? Lol
2000 US troops actually, not 900.
They want to separate Syria, refusing to live equally with the rest of the Syrian nation!
2:52 Turkey has about 14-15 Million Kurds not 20!
and not all live in that said area, they live in every city.
Erdogan trying to get back some of that old Ottoman land.
he will pay in the worst way.
Come and make us pay c'mon. Don't just talk show some action c'mon u poppets@@CryptoBroke
@@BunyaminEkinci-xq1hr haha nice try turkish bot :D
@@CryptoBrokesure hahaha
this is 2025 you think world let that happen? who will fight for some none sense shit? you cant trick people with false idea, it will end up isis and rest is history. wake up.
Leave the Kurds in Syria alone Turkey.
Ok 👍 😂
Erdogan isn't gonna see this lil bro
Thank you for addressing such a complex topic, but I noticed significant gaps in your analysis. Referring to Turkey’s actions as an ‘invasion’ fails to consider Turkey’s legitimate security concerns. The PKK, a recognized terrorist organization by Turkey, the EU, and the US, has been responsible for decades of violence, claiming over 40,000 lives. The PYD/YPG, which controls much of northeastern Syria, has well-documented links to the PKK and poses a direct threat to Turkey’s borders, much like ISIS. Would the US or UK tolerate such a threat on their borders without taking action?
Additionally, your focus on the Kurdish population in Syria overlooks the region’s ethnic diversity, including Turkmens and Arabs, who also face displacement and conflict. The recruitment of child soldiers by the PYD/YPG, documented by the UN, is another critical issue you omitted. Furthermore, the extensive tunnel networks in the region raise serious security concerns that are not addressed in your analysis.
By selectively framing Turkey’s actions as aggressive and ignoring these broader dynamics, the video risks presenting a one-sided narrative. A balanced perspective would acknowledge Turkey’s legitimate concerns while critically examining all actors in the conflict, including the PKK/PYD/YPG.
Turkey, Syria, and Iraq really need to settle down and just let the Kurds have their own state. It can't be easy to be constantly at odds with 45million people inside your own borders.
Bro, they can’t communicate together because they speaking a dialect that can’t speak with each other. Why a country, when they don’t can speak with all Kurds?
@@xe6zewhat are you talking about i understand all accents its like British english and American english dont be uneducated
@ no
Turkey nor the new Syrian state want any separatist armed group holding any turf in the country. The country needs to be unified under one authority and one ruler.
I hope Trump will sanction Turkey at this point
BRUH
He already did… look at the list of nations he sanctioned the first go around.
sanction ? who is America ? 🤣
Whyyy tho
Trump our friend 😂😂😂 cry about it!!!
FREE KURDISTAN ✌✌✌
LOVE KURDISTAN 💛💛💛
REST KURDISTAN 🙃🙃🙃
You are already free in Turkey. You are talking about terrorists who killed thousands in Turkiye. Around 16 million Kurds are living in Turkey. The vast majority of the Kurdish population is concentrated in large cities such as Istanbul, Ankara, and Izmir. Their lives are the same as the rest of the Turkish people. They already have equal citizenship rights. They can speak their own mother tongue, but since the dominant language in Turkey is Turkish, they speak Turkish. People all live in Turkey as equals, we have no differences from each other. Kurds have their own business, or they are educated at the same university. They are getting married to each other as Turks and Kurds, in the same country with the same citizenship under the same law. Nobody asks “What's your ethnicity?” No difference is being a Turkish or Kurdish or Cherkez or Laz or Arab or any other ethnicity.
@@DOzkayTake your nonsense somewhere else
@@DOzkay OK, but and the Syrian Kurds? They have offered to split from the PKK as part of the permanent ceasefire deal yet they don't budge. And I don't think the Kurds inside the supposed Turkish buffer zone would be that free.
@@supb1848 Yes they will be free and they should be free.🙏
@@supb1848 I don't think that would realistically happen, they could've done that way way earlier if they could do it too.
Enough, as a Turk, I'm tired of you using Turkey in all your videos.
Free Independent Syria without Rojava. One Country One Nation.
00:21 Should be: Syrian groups vs US proxies or PKK
You can't be a proxy if your state as a proxy is limited on a 4 year long presidency.
or more accurately US proxies vs. US proxies. the americans have supported basically everyone who was not assad.
çünkü sana her kürt PKK
Turkish proxies, because they only fight Kurds.
Respecting minority rights doesn't mean letting them form a country in their territory.
turkey is not talking to even discuses the situation so what are you saying
@@CryptoBrokeIm talking about 5:02
@@CryptoBroke 5:01
@@mertince2310 1:55
And who are you to make decision instead of them?
Turkey wants an arab populated belt, a buffer zone, between its' borders and the kurdish controlled region. While they are not fond of an autonomous kurdish region, they mainly just dont want their own kurdish populated regions to neighbor it. If Turkey gets that buffer zone, may be convinced to leave the kurds alone. On the other hand, syrian kurds dream of a united kurdish land and they are very ambitious about it. They do not want a buffer zone, as an arab populated buffer region will not allow a united kurdish state they are dreaming of. Turkey is justified to stop that. In my opinion, for US and its' allies, making that buffer zone a reality is the only peaceful solution though.
"Sultun" Erdogan won't be satisfied until Everything that used to be part of the Ottoman Empire belongs to him.
Turkey is not justified to do anything. Invading a country and relocatting people in a certain area to remove the Kurdish residents and make them a minority is genocide all over again. But Turks have always done such actions, thats their history.
Except their are Kurdish areas within their nation, so they need a buffer within their own nation
DUDE WHAT KURDISH STATE???
THAT IS RIGHTFUL ARAB LAND, NO ONE NATIVE THERE WANTS KURDS, Screw them!
They do not and will NOT have a free 'state'
Placement of manbij is off on the map at 2:41 also as of time of writing this comment 2 hours after this video was uploaded manbij hasn't been in sdf hands for a week
0:19 Respecting the rights of kurds is not the same as giving them independence. For example: Alijah Izetbegovic didn't want Srpska to split from Bosnia but that doesn't mean he disrespected serbian rights. 2 different things here.
Turkey also illegally occupies northern Cyprus and threatens Greece on the daily. It's an imperialist country.
Great 🎉
Bi akıllı sensin.
turkey soldiers fight for money vs Kurdish soldiers fight for their own land and honor
This only shows how ignorant you are and know nothing about Turkish army. Turkish soldiers call combat as a wedding. If you believe so let’s see the consequences. 😂
we defeated isis with our women soldiers while turkey backed them.
hahahaha what a moron avrage pyd sdf militant get 300 usd from usa so no one living free in this world
@@CryptoBrokeKurds would have nothing if they didn’t have daddy America
First you should ask question why USA support kurds, why a communist marksist party accepting USA military help
0:22 "Ceasefire between Turkish proxies and Kurdish forces"...
no, they are not "Turkish-proxies"... they are local people of Syria.
Please use also "US-proxies" instead of Kurds as well!
You can be a Turkish proxy and a citizen of Syria.. that's sort why the word "proxy" is there and not just "Turkish"
A proxy cannot be a native. Kurds are native to the region and for that reason they don't need any incentive to fight for their own freedom
@@davianoinglesias5030 ah I see, syrians are not native to syria, got it.
They are backed by Turkey and have risen because of Turkey that to sounds like a Puppet state of Syria
Local people of syria supplied with a infinite amount of Turkish men, shells, and weaponry. At that point can you be called yourself a syrian?
2025 is looking very spicy.
I think they will. The opportunity is too good for them not to. The Kurds control many areas that are arab majority that Turkey could switch leadership on. Additionally, turkey has a good relationship with kurdish autonomous region in Iraq so I believe they W il try to switch the leadership of Syrian kurdish areas
Syria was invaded by USA, and Turkey will help people of Syria to rescue from USA.
There's some comment in your Propaganda.
There's no difference between American spreading democracy and Turkey Rescuing Syria😂
@@Itisjustasaganowwe would rather have turkey.
Such beniegn and relaxed analysis of such a worrying imminent danger...
For the Newbie if you are actually trading in the crypto space and you don't have a sound mentor. Then you are certainly going to get liquidated in 90% of your trades. Yeah that's sad truth. I remember when i just got into crypto back in 2019 but later in 2020 i ended up selling it because i have lost alot trading all by myself without a guide. Got back into crypto early in 2024 with $20k and I'm up with $232k in a short period of time
Investing in stocks is planting a tree for your future; with patience, it will bear fruit
I've tried investing in the stock market several times but always got discouraged by fluctuations of stock value. I would be happy if you could advise me based on how you went about yours, as I am ready to go the passive income path.!!
Yes true, I have been in touch with a brokerage Advisor. With an initial starting reserve of $75k, my advisor chooses the entry and exit commands for my portfolio, which has grown to approximately $550k.
Please can you leave the info of your Investment advisor here? I'm in dire need for one
Tracy Britt Cool Consulting... has always been at the top of my list.. She is regarded as a genius in her area and well knowledgeable about financial markets. I highly recommend you look her up if you want excellent collaboration.
Turkey is invading Syria and everyone is silent. Thanks for lighting this issue up
Ooooo,Turkey better not invade the Kurds.😮
NATO's indifference to the Kurds and their right to have their own country is glaring evidence that were no better than the Russians.
Up to 50% of the Rojava civil government are non-Kurds
Erdogan: "WE'RE RESTORING THE TURKISH EMPIRE WITH THIS ONE!!!" 🗣🗣🗣🔥🔥🔥
Some facts many people seem to not know or not understand:
- In Syria only less than 10% of the population is Kurds however they occupy 40% of the land thanks to US arming PKK spin-off YPG and ruling the occupying regions by force. Arab Syrians don't want YPG rule but they had no power as Assad didn't support them. Now they resist agains YPG rule because that's their land and they want to be part of new Syrian government.
- Even majority of the Syrian Kurds don't want YPG rule. They also want to be part of Syria. Only US and some people living in Europe want a separate state for YPG in Syria (in the name of Kurds, in reality it is the opposite).
- Kurds are not a threat to Turkey, only US armed proxy YPG/PKK is.
- In a democratic new Syrian state Kurds can have their rights and live in peace. Turkey supports this idea.
- Turkey is the only country who supports a unitarian secular rule in Syria, all the other countries have other interests. They would rather want to divide the country or have endless civil war.
- Turkey's interests align with Europe's. Only Turkey wants to help to stop refugee influx to Europe by making Syria a safe country again. This the only way to prevent a new potential refugee influx and bring refugees from Turkey and Europe back to Syria who escaped Assad.
- Turkey's occupation was planned to be temporary and it had two goals: create a secure area in NE Syria to accommodate refugees and create a buffer zone agains YPG/PKK terrorists to protect Turkish citizens. Unfortunately US and Russia/Assad didn't allow any other solution as they supported YPG/PKK terrorists to use against Turkey. As soon as YPG/PKK risk is eliminated, Turkey will end the buffer zone.
- US backed YPG/PKK rule is stealing oil from Syrians, they are a narco terrorist organization. So they even don't intend to become a part of Syrian society by leaving their weapons.
I am interested in constructive arguments. Let me know what you think or ask me if you have any questions.
Majority of Kurds in Turkey dont want to be part of Turkey what are we gonna do about that?
@@Vulcan_111The name " Kurdistan" was first used in Ottoman documents in the 15th century, no earlier historical sources mentions that. In Ottoman documents, the word "Kurd, ekrad" is used for "nomads, wandering people", which actually means "yürük/yörük, Türük/Türk. In the documents it is used as an adjective not a name for a people. It is used as "ekrad-ı Türkmen " which means "wandering Türkmen. It is not used for a tribe, people.
In Türkiye there are Zaza and Kurmanc people, and Mitterrand's children who have been designed and labeled as Kurds by the West. The West kept the exiled Armenians in the mountains and those people married to two or three women and they were told to have as many children as they can because the West would establish a country for them in the future. Girls of 12/13 years of age were abducted and married older men by force ( I knew one of them who went through such a situation and had run away leaving two kids behind). One man had three wives and more than twenty kids. They were all fed by the West in the mountains. The West did not let Türkiye to invest in the area so the people had migrated to big cities. Those designed and labeled as Kurds were placed in the area. Today, in Türkiye when someone says "I'm a Kurd" he/she is the Kurdoid produced in the Zagros laboratries .
@@Vulcan_111 That's not true but also irrelevant topic for Syria.
So this basically means you have nothing to challenge the points I shared.
not all the land they have is inhabitable yet you conflated this extra land as theirs anyways when there is proportionately the same land to the rest of syria
@@Vulcan_111 thats not true at all? Kurds wouldnt want to be a part of a shity country that doesnt have the bare neccesities and literally an open estate for US
Personally I’m from Aleppo. It’s heartbreaking that all these countries have their beliefs and their eyes on my country. Syria is rich with natural resources. From oil and gas to Agricultural land in the east and the west. In the north east of Syria the USA existing . Russia’s eyes in the-sea side. Turkey’s eyes in the north. Israel and Iran in the south. Lord bless and bring peace to everyone.
Better Turkey than the Polish Netanyahu
SDF is not kurds. Local kurds hates SDF do some research
which local? those who sold his soul to turkey and money?
@@CryptoBroke I know you are misinformed due to your media and overlords, but sdf is a militant group linked with t3r0r orgs, which did countless t3r0r attacks. They should not be named alongside the word kurds. they don't represent kurds.
FREE KURDISTAN ✌✌✌
LOVE KURDISTAN 💛💛💛
REST KURDISTAN 🙃🙃🙃
@@CryptoBroke no those who not sold their souls to us and israel
@@adamfarmer7665 you know who did countless massacres against the Kurdish population