I think what Karen was confused about who was Proof portraying since someone had passed away. Proof is portraying D12 member "Bugz" on the video who got shot around '99. Then the crazy part is Proof ended up gettin shot at a club aswell, and what makes it even more crazier Proof had a line on one of his songs "im in the club to beef u gotta m*rder me here". Em said he hasnt watched this music video since Proofs passing cause he blames himself. He didnt even perform this song for over a decade, but i think lately hes been performing it again.
Although what you said is true that’s not what he’s portraying at all, that had nothing to do with this.. He was simply saying that he didn’t want to throw anymore fuel on a rap beef to get it to the point where someone close to him gets killed… there have been a lot of rap beefs where someone ends up dying or getting seriously hurt and most times it’s not the main rapper himself they tend to ride with enough security to avoid that
What's crazy to me is I'm Egyptian and I know all of this songs. That's why Em will never be cancelled. He opened his heart to us and we have his back. Stan forever 😈😈😈
I love how every Em video you make a comment referring to another song and discover she hasn’t heard that either… “Oh God well we will check that out another time”😂😂 you two are adorable together and I really enjoy watching you too on this Eminem journey
This song not only being one of my top favorite Eminem tracks but will forever still hold up for its powerful message, relevancy, even a real tearjerker that hits. 🤍 RIP to Proof & Debbie Mathers 🙏💜
Also a fufact, Em said in this song they talked 50 out beefing with Ya and he did. But Ja came with big talk and did said Em's daughter would be a hore so now not only 50 but also Em did join the beef. Ja did end his own career.
I love the chemistry you both have and love how u keep showing her ur music , i think itll be fun and you should have karen Introuducd some of her music to you
You know if you think about it, you have the sslp, mmlp, and then the Eminem show, which is about Marshall. Maybe Encore could be considered a more grown slim shady show or something. Idk. Just my thoughts. Love encore. Don't care what nobody says. It's a classic. Keep it up guys. Loving the recent videos with KAREENNNN. ☺️
One thing I never noticed until I think it was Knox mentioned that all of the syllables in the song hit on each (i think) snare drum hit. Masterful writing skills.
Well yes, there is a heavy snare drum snare that’s a part of the instrumental. Eminem uses his voice as the percussion all the time. Especially on MMLP and TES. So yes he’s right, but it’s that way for nearly every song he makes. That’s also Eminem’s masterful production.
as a 90's kid, this song is one of my canon events. i don't listen to it often, as when i got older into my 20's i became more of a metal head, but it is definitely one of those songs that sticks with you, as the person you are. if that makes sense. edit: showing my age here, but when i was a kid, i remember i had a tape recorder, and tried to make a cover with this song in my room. had about a hundred takes until i was able to get it perfect. and i STILL remember all the words. for reference, i don't think i've listened to this song since like 2010 at the latest, and haven't actively listened to it regurally since like 2007.
10:22 What happen with Proof's cause of death was an argument over a game of Billiards at the Triple C nightclub. It was Proof and Keith L. Bender Jr., and Mario Etheridge. Etheridge wasn't only Proof's (rest in peace) murderer but also a bouncer at that same nightclub. Apparently, Bender Jr. served in the Military before his death. . . Actual story: Proof and Bender Jr. were playing Billiards until they started arguing. Mario Etheridge sent a warning shot, the 2 kept going, then Proof popped Bender Jr. in the head. Then that's when Mario Etheridge killed Proof (rest in peace) out of "defense" for his cousin Bender Jr., shooting Proof 3 or 4 times in the head and chest. Proof passed away at the Triple C nightclub. Bender Jr. died a week later at St. John Hospital and Medical Center. . . Google copy-&-paste: Etheridge was found guilty of carrying a concealed weapon and discharging a firearm inside a building. He was sentenced to time served for the concealed weapon charge and a $2,000 fine for firing the gun in a building. . . And Karen, Idk if Cliff knows this but Billiards is a form of 8 ball pool
This has to be one of the cruelest cases of unintentional foreshadowing in music history. It’s more accurate that most people would even pick up on. Listen to Castle and Arise, how he talks about “that image burned in my brain of you on that table” “That image burned in my brain of you on that table Me falling across your body, not able to stand to save you” It’s soul crushing.
No joke, a few days ago I actually heard on the radio the Toy Soldiers song that Em sampled for this. I had NEVER heard it before (well, apart from the sample). Was really surprised.
cliff beats man I love all these reactions to Encore so far but Ima just say it Im just waiting to for Just lose it song with the music video I love all the songs on the Encore Album but Just Lose It is my all time favorite song on the album
the saddest part is proofs coffin ended up being the biggest coffin to rest on his shoulders, probably still is to this day, i often wonder if em realises how many lives his music has actually saved
I'm totally with Cliffe when he says "Karen most beautiful woman in the world". Love to my man Cliffe. Shout out to Marshal Marthers and my condolences for his mother is passing, along with Proof
The more I listen to EM, he’s a genius 👍🏽👍🏽👏👏. I would never have bothered to listen to him if it weren’t for you Mijo, so THANK YOU, THANK YOU, THANK YOU ❤️❤️❤️👵🏼 Gmaw
I love your guys reactions. Re listening to the verse, you hear him talking bout the suge diss and Dre telling him to stay out? Well the suge diss just recently got leaked its called Smack You. Yall should react to it
This is about the real sixth original of D12 Bugz cuz Em was cool with them but he was in the dup Bad Meets Evil with Royce da 5'9" so Em became the 6th memeber after Bugz death and kept his promise of putting them on regardless
“The tongue has the power of life or death and those Who love it eat its fruit.” Proverbs 18:21 we’re all guilty of it and if we understood we create our lives based on the words we speak; we affect the lives of those in our lives by how we speak about them too… it’s crazy to think about but it is so true what you think and speak of is usually what you get in life so speak what you want not what you feel like, give power to your dreams and speak on things that aren’t as though they are (somewhere in Roman’s 4 I believe) this is how we live an abundant life… be blessed and live healthily and full of wealth of all kinds!!! 💚📣🗣️
Hi I'm a new subscriber love your break downs and Karen's reactions to Eminem do me a favor React to Eminem and biggie Dead wrong please I want Karen to tell us who won who had the better verse please 🙏
Man it's so surreal that this video literally predicted the future with Proof being taken. Crazy how much things spiraled after that, and how we almost lost Em.
This helps people and educates. Eminem was never a member of D12. It was Bugz. Apprently he was anamzing MC. Detroit was owning the underground at that time Royce out there to.
Guys his friend Bugs died recently (then) and proof was supposedly impersonating him in the video clip. That's why he said another's coffin rest on my conscience
Each day we grow closer and closer to Karen hearing the masterpiece that is Fack.
It’s coming soon. Late this week or early next week 🙏
@@CliffBeatsOfficialyessssss, Karen is joining the Fack cult soonnnn 😂😂
lol ohhh no
Stay Wide Awake
@@CliffBeatsOfficialshe’s either gonna love it or hate it 😂
The "someone else's coffin" is referencing former D12 member Bugz who was killed in a driveby RIGHT BEFORE D12 and Eminem made it big.
RIP Big Proof
And Bugz
@@thundacracka77and Nate
I think what Karen was confused about who was Proof portraying since someone had passed away. Proof is portraying D12 member "Bugz" on the video who got shot around '99.
Then the crazy part is Proof ended up gettin shot at a club aswell, and what makes it even more crazier Proof had a line on one of his songs "im in the club to beef u gotta m*rder me here".
Em said he hasnt watched this music video since Proofs passing cause he blames himself. He didnt even perform this song for over a decade, but i think lately hes been performing it again.
Damn. 😞
Although what you said is true that’s not what he’s portraying at all, that had nothing to do with this..
He was simply saying that he didn’t want to throw anymore fuel on a rap beef to get it to the point where someone close to him gets killed… there have been a lot of rap beefs where someone ends up dying or getting seriously hurt and most times it’s not the main rapper himself they tend to ride with enough security to avoid that
Its crazy still having proof act that out knowing that's how he actually got killed
Whats crazier is Proof has a line in one of his songs "im in the club to beef u gotta m*rder me here" and thats what ended up happening
He was the second member from the group to die
What even crazier he got killed almost exactly that way
What's crazy to me is I'm Egyptian and I know all of this songs. That's why Em will never be cancelled. He opened his heart to us and we have his back. Stan forever 😈😈😈
We appreciate finding the explicit version 😅
This is one of my top 5 songs from Eminem. Absolutely insane❤
I cant wait til she hears fack and insane, the 2 best songs, ever.
Fack
and then all of those emojis people add to signify a banger
Love Your Energy , great Reactions , Thx
I think I love you both and Eminem too!
Love the respect you just had there when you crossed your heart at the one bit in the song❤
RIP Proof!!!🙏🏻
This song came out Dec 2004 and Proof died April 2006. Less than 18 months later. RIP Proof! ❤
I love how every Em video you make a comment referring to another song and discover she hasn’t heard that either… “Oh God well we will check that out another time”😂😂 you two are adorable together and I really enjoy watching you too on this Eminem journey
Like toy soldiers is one of my all time favorites out there. I'm still waiting for Leaving heaven 🔥🔥🔥
This song not only being one of my top favorite Eminem tracks but will forever still hold up for its powerful message, relevancy, even a real tearjerker that hits. 🤍
RIP to Proof & Debbie Mathers 🙏💜
I'm enjoying these reactions so much.I'm learning alot about Eminem I didn't know.as I said before,I wasn't a hip hop fan til I heard his stuff.
Keep the reactions coming tho. Love it.
Also a fufact, Em said in this song they talked 50 out beefing with Ya and he did. But Ja came with big talk and did said Em's daughter would be a hore so now not only 50 but also Em did join the beef. Ja did end his own career.
I love the chemistry you both have and love how u keep showing her ur music , i think itll be fun and you should have karen
Introuducd some of her music to you
This is dope it takes me back since I haven’t heard this cd in awhile
You know if you think about it, you have the sslp, mmlp, and then the Eminem show, which is about Marshall. Maybe Encore could be considered a more grown slim shady show or something. Idk. Just my thoughts.
Love encore. Don't care what nobody says. It's a classic.
Keep it up guys. Loving the recent videos with KAREENNNN. ☺️
This was the one I was waiting on! Always loved this song.
This is one of my fave Em songs, When you hear that marching band drum beat come in I get goosebumps everytime ❤
I was looking forward to this one❤
One thing I never noticed until I think it was Knox mentioned that all of the syllables in the song hit on each (i think) snare drum hit. Masterful writing skills.
Well yes, there is a heavy snare drum snare that’s a part of the instrumental. Eminem uses his voice as the percussion all the time. Especially on MMLP and TES.
So yes he’s right, but it’s that way for nearly every song he makes. That’s also Eminem’s masterful production.
as a 90's kid, this song is one of my canon events. i don't listen to it often, as when i got older into my 20's i became more of a metal head, but it is definitely one of those songs that sticks with you, as the person you are. if that makes sense.
edit: showing my age here, but when i was a kid, i remember i had a tape recorder, and tried to make a cover with this song in my room. had about a hundred takes until i was able to get it perfect. and i STILL remember all the words. for reference, i don't think i've listened to this song since like 2010 at the latest, and haven't actively listened to it regurally since like 2007.
10:22 What happen with Proof's cause of death was an argument over a game of Billiards at the Triple C nightclub. It was Proof and Keith L. Bender Jr., and Mario Etheridge. Etheridge wasn't only Proof's (rest in peace) murderer but also a bouncer at that same nightclub. Apparently, Bender Jr. served in the Military before his death.
.
.
Actual story:
Proof and Bender Jr. were playing Billiards until they started arguing. Mario Etheridge sent a warning shot, the 2 kept going, then Proof popped Bender Jr. in the head. Then that's when Mario Etheridge killed Proof (rest in peace) out of "defense" for his cousin Bender Jr., shooting Proof 3 or 4 times in the head and chest. Proof passed away at the Triple C nightclub. Bender Jr. died a week later at St. John Hospital and Medical Center.
.
.
Google copy-&-paste:
Etheridge was found guilty of carrying a concealed weapon and discharging a firearm inside a building. He was sentenced to time served for the concealed weapon charge and a $2,000 fine for firing the gun in a building.
.
.
And Karen, Idk if Cliff knows this but Billiards is a form of 8 ball pool
etheridge now lives in panama and changed his name.
gotta love an em song. any em song. love 'em all.
Heartbreaking how this song affects Em now
One of my favorite Eminem songs of all time........
This has to be one of the cruelest cases of unintentional foreshadowing in music history.
It’s more accurate that most people would even pick up on.
Listen to Castle and Arise, how he talks about “that image burned in my brain of you on that table”
“That image burned in my brain of you on that table
Me falling across your body, not able to stand to save you”
It’s soul crushing.
Love you guys!!’
at 4:20 the word Suge Knight was removed from all versions of the song
He does perform it in recent times. And when the music comes on he tells the crowd to say Big Proof.
RIP Proof
Also RIP Debbie
I love you both so much 💗 I love Karen's reactions❤
One of the best videos the goat 🐐 Eminem has ever delivered
No joke, a few days ago I actually heard on the radio the Toy Soldiers song that Em sampled for this. I had NEVER heard it before (well, apart from the sample). Was really surprised.
Song is still great. The video of course hits way different now.
Thanks guy’s 😊 really enjoy these reactions.
cliff beats man I love all these reactions to Encore so far but Ima just say it Im just waiting to for Just lose it song with the music video I love all the songs on the Encore Album but Just Lose It is my all time favorite song on the album
Another great reaction as always! RIP Proof! Such a shame honestly to lose a life over something so pety
Let's go Cliff!!! Go down swinging with 2 strikes!!!
This is such a haunting song and video. A prime example of life imitating art.
R.I.P. Big proof, a.k.a. Derty Harry, a.k.a. DeShaun Holton.
I love how in every video, Cliff mentions another song, Karen says she has nt heard it and Cliff adds another song to the ever growing list.
It's barely possibly to pick but this has to be one of my favorite songs from Em.
Bro someday I’m taking you fishing. You get the music I’ll blow your mind In the outdoors 😊
the saddest part is proofs coffin ended up being the biggest coffin to rest on his shoulders, probably still is to this day, i often wonder if em realises how many lives his music has actually saved
I'm totally with Cliffe when he says "Karen most beautiful woman in the world". Love to my man Cliffe. Shout out to Marshal Marthers and my condolences for his mother is passing, along with Proof
The bin laden track is wild as well!
The more I listen to EM, he’s a genius 👍🏽👍🏽👏👏. I would never have bothered to listen to him if it weren’t for you Mijo, so THANK YOU, THANK YOU, THANK YOU ❤️❤️❤️👵🏼 Gmaw
i was always conflicted when i was younger. im one of those rare people who preferred ja rule over 50 cent, but also loved eminem.
How you gonna make me watch this video again? Watching it hurts so much. 😭
Ether's gonna be a wild video. 😅 23 years later and there still hasn't been a diss track to top it.
RIP Bugz and Proof still love you.... You need listening Eminem & 50 cent - Patietly Waiting
One of the best Eminem songs ever. How about you have her listen to Bone Thugs N Harmony Crossroads official video. She might love it
Shout out Proof RIP
It was Like Toy Soldier that make me love hiphop
cliff whats up with them pullin your videos, good luck bro
You explained this well Cliff. 💯💯💯👍🏿🫡
The fact it was proof in this video made this song way more deeper
I like how clif treat's her like he should big upp my G
She deserves the world
@CliffBeatsOfficial no doubt about dat
you should do Security by Royce it's his perspective on Proof's loss from the outside because him and Em weren't getting along at the time
I love your guys reactions. Re listening to the verse, you hear him talking bout the suge diss and Dre telling him to stay out? Well the suge diss just recently got leaked its called Smack You. Yall should react to it
Savage soldier baby😘😘😘😘
This is about the real sixth original of D12 Bugz cuz Em was cool with them but he was in the dup Bad Meets Evil with Royce da 5'9" so Em became the 6th memeber after Bugz death and kept his promise of putting them on regardless
This hit different now
Morning Karen and Cliff. I've got fresh coffee. Let's Goo.
“The tongue has the power of life or death and those
Who love it eat its fruit.” Proverbs 18:21 we’re all guilty of it and if we understood we create our lives based on the words we speak; we affect the lives of those in our lives by how we speak about them too… it’s crazy to think about but it is so true what you think and speak of is usually what you get in life so speak what you want not what you feel like, give power to your dreams and speak on things that aren’t as though they are (somewhere in Roman’s 4 I believe) this is how we live an abundant life… be blessed and live healthily and full of wealth of all kinds!!! 💚📣🗣️
What a great man
Let Karen her Hail Mary with Em ND 50. But for this reason and song. It was 🔥🔥🔥🔥
But remember we constantly get told Em never says anything, he just rhymes words and raps fast.
Let's go. Love this song.
this classic hits hard i love it.. rip proof
He wasn't talking about Suge. It was about Jarule and Murder Inc.
He was talking about suge as well
#FreeCliffBeats
Ya'll forgot Not Afraid and Business 🙏❤
Cliff you've got to show Karen "kurt cobain" by proof
Rest in peace Debbie Mathers
Eminem to this day Cant handle this video he was talking in some interview or magazine 😢 imagine how he fell it
Eminem 1998 XL Show Freestyle
Too many people have lost their lives and it needs to stop and I don’t think it will ever happen because people let words control their lives
Proof was portrayed Eminem’s other group member who else passed before that it was bugz
I agree with you Mijo, she’s, beautiful inside and out. And so are you❤️❤️❤️. Now I’ll listen to song😜😜😜👵🏼
We miss you PROOF! RIP big homie❣️❤️🩹💯
Hi I'm a new subscriber love your break downs and Karen's reactions to Eminem do me a favor
React to Eminem and biggie
Dead wrong please I want Karen to tell us who won who had the better verse please 🙏
Harry Mack just done an Edinburgh video it’s unreal
Man it's so surreal that this video literally predicted the future with Proof being taken. Crazy how much things spiraled after that, and how we almost lost Em.
Hopefully you guys do 8 mile such an underrated song
I hope youtube can get their stuff together... i wanna get into streaming, but i keep seeing youtube wanting to change their rules every 30 seconds.
fun fact: the video was about Bugz and that’s who Proof was playing
Sleep Easy King Proof
This helps people and educates. Eminem was never a member of D12. It was Bugz. Apprently he was anamzing MC.
Detroit was owning the underground at that time Royce out there to.
the shady tour bus with obie Trice, in it shot up too on the highway around the same time proof murder to
They wanna play hard ball??? We’re game!!!!! 😘❤️🧲
Next song needs to be “difficult” and should show Karen Proof’s “Kurt Kobane”
Great song. . I like Martika's song that he sampled. I don't watch the video often cause it's almost too rough to get through
Hey Karen 👋 👋 👋 👋 👋 👋
Guys his friend Bugs died recently (then) and proof was supposedly impersonating him in the video clip. That's why he said another's coffin rest on my conscience
You Should show her when i am gone and mockingbird