I think Lucas or Wren are Charles. I do not own any images, clips, or songs in this video. All rights go to abcfamily and all other rightful owners. No copyright intended.
Am I the only one who doesn't think Charles and Jason are brothers at all? Why Would Jessica say "Do you want to say good night to your sister?" to just one of them and not both? Charles could just be a friend/cousin or something
MAYBE ONE OF THE DRESSES WERE FOR SPENCER!!!! Theory: some of us know that MRs Dilaurentis had an affair with Mr Hastings therefore that other dress could be Spencer's and when Mrs D said to Alison "don't tell daddy you saw two dresses because he'll leave us!" She meant if he found out about the dress then he'd find out about the affair! Of course Mr D would leave them!
in 5x25 -A give Alison/Mona the gas mask stating she was his favourite. If -A was Lucas wouldn't Hanna be his favourite??? just saying, all other thoughts were good!
Just something I've caught, but haven't people noticed that everything is old school, back in the day? Even the crib? Why is that? And even the Music A listens too as well....I feel this is a big clue to it all but I just can't figure it out. Also, on s.1 To Kill A Mocking Bird seems to be a clue, and in the book there is "Boo Radley" , Radley the insane asylum in Rosewood && the ice cream shop later on in the series where Spencer & Emily & I don't remember who else is called boo boo ice cream no? Read To Kill A Mocking Bird & Catch Up on the episodes, I think these are HUGE CLUES!!
Stephanie... I like all that your saying. It all helps in some way or another to figure out What's going on in Rosewood. I like your theory about Wren and Ashley, I also feel Ashley is a big part of PLL. I can't wait til the season premiere. Hope we get more answers than questions!
Oh my god, this is the first time I see a theory that is so well tied up. Seriously, you've done a great job, you could be so right I really believe it ! Thank you ! x
It's possible...don't let the age stuff trip you up. People can look younger and also older then they are. I get it all the time people think I'm much younger then I am. I was mid-late 20s and people thought I was 18. Lucas is one of the few character that I would feel sorry for. He's smart and could pull this off with no problem.
Good theory but remember Lucas had an insane crush on Hannah so maybe he didn't wanna be a girl ? I'm honestly going to be so shocked when I finally find out who a is . We've been waiting years !
the age doesn't match . locas is alison's age(same class at high school) . jason is older than him like seven years. the boys in the video look like they were four to five years old not more and between them not more than one year. so they can't be jason and locas
I know it's confusing, but it's possible. Lucas could be two years younger than Jason and missed two or three years of school because he was in radley. So he repeated classes at high school and was in Alison's class. With this show everything is possible.
iLoveSushi90x But how do we explain hair color. yes i know he could dye his hair but i don't think that's possible. all the DiLaurentis family have either blonde or dark blonde to brown hair.
Alice Malfoy he could have dyed it been wearing a wig brown contacts it says Charles took a lot of time to disguys himself so Charles doesn't need to have blond hair and blue eyes anymore maybe only when he was younger than changed idk not saying your wrong just an idea
Just noticed.....the mom said kiss your little sister ...but the blanket is yellow. commonly people use yellow or green when they did not want to know the sex of the baby .....
Lucas is the one who décides when he wants to play and the signal four game is four. So then I realize a thing in the place of the A letter in the names of the Dilaurentis family. Alison 1st place, Jason 2nd place, Charles 3rd place and Lucas 4th place. The serie just makes me crazy but I think hère the number 4 is pretty much important. Well I'd love to have your advices xoxo
You have some really good points (like the anagram!) but i don't think Lucas is big A. If charles was lucas, at the fake prom it only makes sense that he would've put hanna as the prom queen.. Not to mention wouldnt he have given hanna the gas mask?(Whatever was the mask for cause they didn't end up using it) Also, although Lucas is smart, I don't think he's on the same level as spencer and mona, but with that one i guess its possible he wanted to stay under the radar and held back... who knows with this show!
ok so I think chalres is either sean,wren,toby,noel amd lucas. red coat maya to protect Emily and f there is a second red coat I think jenna or cece. black veil is Melissa to protect spencer and something to do with wren. and black widow maybe aria
I dont think Lucas is Charles but i have to say, great Anagram thing at the end, so creepy and its highly likely that that means something as on some of the season 6 spoiler vids it says Lucas will have a main part in the season so...
Okay i wasnt convinced all the way but then i watched some spoilers that might be true 2 of them made me believe that your theory is correct the 2 spoilers were 1.charles is transgender 2. Lucas will be a big part of the story line
What I don't get is how Spencer could dream about the letters at the boxes. I mean she did just look at them for a few seconds how could she remember those letters?
Pretty Little Liars but it was like he escaped the night and wwe don't know if he was getting out to be lucas idk but that does make sense what u are saying
Um start to think i don't quite remember seasome street well but wasn't there a puppet or character called hermie, and it looks like the puppets that are hanging in the wall there's two of them, maybe it is Lucas who is A idk just had a thought lol
Lucas is not Charles. but i do think andrew is. (im on season 5 so don't blame if you're on season 6) I mean i feel like Andrew got really close to aria to use her. and in that video there's 2 boys right? maybe andrew was one and cece was the other. oh yeah! cece's a girl. my theory is that cece is trans. and that one of the boys is cece and the other is andrew. i mean when you look at andrew sure he could be 18 but then again what if he's lying about his age? so idk that's my theory i might be way off who knows.
what if Spencer is pretending to be Charles but she really dose know she sit everything up and having a mental break down because and what if she was the second A- but spenser was there when charles was there but he's in her head some how
i think that this theory is really good and definitely going along the right lines but if lucas is alli's age so how would he be older in the film clip?
Ok.....so he hit Aly that night........who hit bethany?......We know melissa buried her, but who hit her?...she was in Radley also, but how does she come into all of this?...
May contain spoilers! It could be Charles DiLaurentis/A because he could be the forgotten child and he threatened to tell perhaps Mr D about the affair she had with Spencer's dad songs D had to keep that secret that's why she never reported it to the police!
Go to facebook search pretty little liars they post a picture like the one on this video at the end it can be Charles dilurantis and the word in this video that lucas is the liar but in facebook its actually charles dilurantis
For me Jenna is -A-. But Lucas is perhaps "Charles" as an episode in a process observes Jason Lucas. And coincidentally when Aria is in the box, Lucas placed his camera Jenna looks. Lucas and Jason are something in common. Personally I would like it be a Lover connection, but it is probably Charles. Pour moi Jenna est -A-. Mais Lucas est peut être "Charles", car dans un épisode, dans un train Jason observe Lucas. Et comme par hasard quand Aria est dans la boite, Lucas à posé son appareil photo que Jenna regarde. Lucas et Jason on quelque chose en commun. Personnellement j'aimerais que ce sois une liaison Amoureuse, mais il est surement Charles.
even though this was 2 months ago i just now saw it and i love that someone thinks lucas is Charles also =D. But this whole lucas wanting to be a girl thing is kind of cheesey.. im not trying to be mean im just giving my theory on this. haha!
Just realize Spencer was first to know Mona was A and now Charles / hope this is not all her crazy imagination in she has always been in Radley
flora Ward omg that is the best point anyone has ever made!!
That would literally kill me
Am I the only one who doesn't think Charles and Jason are brothers at all? Why Would Jessica say "Do you want to say good night to your sister?" to just one of them and not both? Charles could just be a friend/cousin or something
I actually saw a great theory of how he was the cousin of Jason and Bethany was his sister who were meant to be protected my Mrs D or something
I also think they aren't brothers
JosieWalters no, they're absolutely not brothers :D:D
Adri anna yes they are
Adri anna Dude, check when the freakin comment was made instead of trying to sound like a smart ass
I give you props this theory is great
Thank you.
Good but, wrong
MAYBE ONE OF THE DRESSES WERE FOR SPENCER!!!!
Theory: some of us know that MRs Dilaurentis had an affair with Mr Hastings therefore that other dress could be Spencer's and when Mrs D said to Alison "don't tell daddy you saw two dresses because he'll leave us!" She meant if he found out about the dress then he'd find out about the affair! Of course Mr D would leave them!
Good idea
The Reese and Romany Show But Jason was already the result of the affair and plus I think Spencer would have found out by now
The Reese and Romany Show But i thought Jason and Spencer were related because of there father not mother...
in 5x25 -A give Alison/Mona the gas mask stating she was his favourite. If -A was Lucas wouldn't Hanna be his favourite??? just saying, all other thoughts were good!
great point. I honestly wish he had given the mask to Hanna so this theory would be even more cannon. still doesnt feel right that Cece is A
Just something I've caught, but haven't people noticed that everything is old school, back in the day? Even the crib? Why is that? And even the Music A listens too as well....I feel this is a big clue to it all but I just can't figure it out. Also, on s.1 To Kill A Mocking Bird seems to be a clue, and in the book there is "Boo Radley" , Radley the insane asylum in Rosewood && the ice cream shop later on in the series where Spencer & Emily & I don't remember who else is called boo boo ice cream no? Read To Kill A Mocking Bird & Catch Up on the episodes, I think these are HUGE CLUES!!
***** that is very interesting
Stephanie... I like all that your saying. It all helps in some way or another to figure out What's going on in Rosewood. I like your theory about Wren and Ashley, I also feel Ashley is a big part of PLL. I can't wait til the season premiere. Hope we get more answers than questions!
***** who was A in the book
Oh my god, this is the first time I see a theory that is so well tied up. Seriously, you've done a great job, you could be so right I really believe it ! Thank you ! x
Wow! I live in Australia and PLL is fast tracked to Foxtel via FOX 8 - We never saw that scene with Alison throwing the orange to her lawyer.
It's possible...don't let the age stuff trip you up. People can look younger and also older then they are. I get it all the time people think I'm much younger then I am. I was mid-late 20s and people thought I was 18. Lucas is one of the few character that I would feel sorry for. He's smart and could pull this off with no problem.
I think Lucas is Charles too.he is the only person I can feel bad for
Good theory but remember Lucas had an insane crush on Hannah so maybe he didn't wanna be a girl ? I'm honestly going to be so shocked when I finally find out who a is . We've been waiting years !
ShantelKarisma Who says "girls" can't have insane crushes on other girls?
the age doesn't match . locas is alison's age(same class at high school) . jason is older than him like seven years. the boys in the video look like they were four to five years old not more and between them not more than one year. so they can't be jason and locas
I know it's confusing, but it's possible. Lucas could be two years younger than Jason and missed two or three years of school because he was in radley. So he repeated classes at high school and was in Alison's class. With this show everything is possible.
He could still be older and have a younger looking face. Alot of people think I'm alot younger then I am so anything is possible.
iLoveSushi90x But how do we explain hair color. yes i know he could dye his hair but i don't think that's possible. all the DiLaurentis family have either blonde or dark blonde to brown hair.
samar alobaidy Age is everything XD a 24
Alice Malfoy he could have dyed it been wearing a wig brown contacts it says Charles took a lot of time to disguys himself so Charles doesn't need to have blond hair and blue eyes anymore maybe only when he was younger than changed idk not saying your wrong just an idea
Just noticed.....the mom said kiss your little sister ...but the blanket is yellow. commonly people use yellow or green when they did not want to know the sex of the baby .....
Ali could be the baby because the night Ali went missing she was wearing yellow??!! Could be a clue!
finally someone did a theory about him i am thinking about him since day one
Great theory. I now think Lucas is Charles.
Lucas is the one who décides when he wants to play and the signal four game is four. So then I realize a thing in the place of the A letter in the names of the Dilaurentis family. Alison 1st place, Jason 2nd place, Charles 3rd place and Lucas 4th place. The serie just makes me crazy but I think hère the number 4 is pretty much important. Well I'd love to have your advices xoxo
@jami carter no Mona would remember when he and Mona were working together right before she "died"
this theory is great makes so much sense
that makes alot of sens, you know since charles loved dolls
On 5x25 A gave a gas mask to mona right? And said she was his favourite. And mona is dressed like alison...
One problem with your theory, Lucas and Ali are about the same age and this little boy is only 4-5 years older. Lucas isn't nearly that old.
You have some really good points (like the anagram!) but i don't think Lucas is big A. If charles was lucas, at the fake prom it only makes sense that he would've put hanna as the prom queen.. Not to mention wouldnt he have given hanna the gas mask?(Whatever was the mask for cause they didn't end up using it) Also, although Lucas is smart, I don't think he's on the same level as spencer and mona, but with that one i guess its possible he wanted to stay under the radar and held back... who knows with this show!
And the process of Halloween? Lucas and Jason are in the eye!
ok so I think chalres is either sean,wren,toby,noel amd lucas. red coat maya to protect Emily and f there is a second red coat I think jenna or cece. black veil is Melissa to protect spencer and something to do with wren. and black widow maybe aria
Very convincing. Has anyone thought Aria was uber A?
I also think that the "he, she, it, bitch" thing is a clue for the hermie thing and that Lucas can't seem to figure out his gender.
I dont think Lucas is Charles but i have to say, great Anagram thing at the end, so creepy and its highly likely that that means something as on some of the season 6 spoiler vids it says Lucas will have a main part in the season so...
Wow, smart theory!
Okay i wasnt convinced all the way but then i watched some spoilers that might be true 2 of them made me believe that your theory is correct the 2 spoilers were 1.charles is transgender 2. Lucas will be a big part of the story line
We don't know Charles Is Big A we just assumed that. I would love for That to Work out in that way
What I don't get is how Spencer could dream about the letters at the boxes. I mean she did just look at them for a few seconds how could she remember those letters?
Lucas cant be Charles because Charles escaped "That Night" and Lucas has been around at school way before that
Pretty Little Liars but it was like he escaped the night and wwe don't know if he was getting out to be lucas idk but that does make sense what u are saying
In like season 2 or 3 omg i felt so sorry for him
This hole theory is bogus XD
I like the idea but the anagram doesn't actually work out when you change it to the one about Lucas because it's leaves out the 'H'
The H is most likely a clue
Um start to think i don't quite remember seasome street well but wasn't there a puppet or character called hermie, and it looks like the puppets that are hanging in the wall there's two of them, maybe it is Lucas who is A idk just had a thought lol
Lucas is not Charles. but i do think andrew is. (im on season 5 so don't blame if you're on season 6) I mean i feel like Andrew got really close to aria to use her. and in that video there's 2 boys right? maybe andrew was one and cece was the other. oh yeah! cece's a girl. my theory is that cece is trans. and that one of the boys is cece and the other is andrew. i mean when you look at andrew sure he could be 18 but then again what if he's lying about his age? so idk that's my theory i might be way off who knows.
I now believe Lucas Is the Big -A
What's the deal with Ali and yellow? Yellow blanket yellow dresses and yellow top the night she went missing
I agree with you i think it might be lucas too haha
what if Spencer is pretending to be Charles but she really dose know she sit everything up and having a mental break down because and what if she was the second A- but spenser was there when charles was there but he's in her head some how
Lucas is the Same age as the girls so it doesn't make sense plus, that doesn't explain Bethany and Sara
i think that this theory is really good and definitely going along the right lines but if lucas is alli's age so how would he be older in the film clip?
He could've gotten help back just a couple years for spending time in Radley
I hope that is him , I mean I bet on Him
I swear Big A isn't Charles though?
Ok.....so he hit Aly that night........who hit bethany?......We know melissa buried her, but who hit her?...she was in Radley also, but how does she come into all of this?...
JacesunS If i am right with this theory, i think it could be Jason or Mrs. Dilaurentis.
May contain spoilers!
It could be Charles DiLaurentis/A because he could be the forgotten child and he threatened to tell perhaps Mr D about the affair she had with Spencer's dad songs D had to keep that secret that's why she never reported it to the police!
Go to facebook search pretty little liars they post a picture like the one on this video at the end it can be Charles dilurantis and the word in this video that lucas is the liar but in facebook its actually charles dilurantis
Lucas or Jenna for me !
Ouuu I never even considered Jenna ! Isn't she blind again though ?
For me Jenna is -A-. But Lucas is perhaps "Charles" as an episode in a process observes Jason Lucas. And coincidentally when Aria is in the box, Lucas placed his camera Jenna looks. Lucas and Jason are something in common. Personally I would like it be a Lover connection, but it is probably Charles.
Pour moi Jenna est -A-. Mais Lucas est peut être "Charles", car dans un épisode, dans un train Jason observe Lucas. Et comme par hasard quand Aria est dans la boite, Lucas à posé son appareil photo que Jenna regarde. Lucas et Jason on quelque chose en commun. Personnellement j'aimerais que ce sois une liaison Amoureuse, mais il est surement Charles.
cece is charles
or maybe wilden
charless is collin
even though this was 2 months ago i just now saw it and i love that someone thinks lucas is Charles also =D. But this whole lucas wanting to be a girl thing is kind of cheesey.. im not trying to be mean im just giving my theory on this. haha!
You do have a lot of evidence saying Lucas is A bit there is a lot of evidence saying he's not A bit I'm not gonna go through it now.🙂
jason tiene un gemelo y la dede en drazo puede ser ali
el que golpio a ali puede que lucas lo hizo por venganzq
In the video Charles is the taller one there twins 😠
It's ABC family! They wouldn't make it like a transgender thing would they
But they did