벌써 몇년 전에 연주된 악곡이지만, 이제 들어도 클라라의 차분하고 오버되지 않은 청명하고 부드러운 연주는 아름답다. 공연자도 과욕하지 않고, 협주 악단들도 결코 지나친 과시를 하지 않고 안정된 연주를 계속하는 것이 매우 좋다. 클라라의 부족할 것 없는 연주가 청중들에게도 잘 전달된 것 같다. 클라라가 더욱 자랑스럽다.
I became a fan of her after listening to her performance of Valse Sentimental. I was attracted because without exaggeration she could express explosive and intense emotions.
What I love most about this video, is that it shows Varvara Kutozova and Alexander Malofeev at tender ages along with Kang and Spivakov, with Dennis Matsuev pumped up for the show. Lovely. The conductor seemed a little too amped in the 1st movement, but rebounds and plays an absolutely brilliant 2nd movement with such finesse and control. Kang is just Kang. Plays every note perfectly. I don't really care for the 3rd movement. Bach Concerto for 2 violins is pretty much the first 2 movements for me. 3rd movement is well played though by both. Real COOL video
This is a baroque dance-like piece. The most important part is to keep a strong rhythm which you can feel with the body. This is also called dancing, so I feel a more "choppy" expression as you call it is more suited.
I’ve never played it choppy, nor has anyone else I know. I’m not saying chippy is wrong it’s all down to individual preference as is all music. It’s often good to listen to different interpretations of conductors and musician’s interpretations. Watch Von Karajan conducting Beethovens 7th. It’s very different to most renditions and it’s so beautiful. Same with the Divan conducted by Barenboim in the 6th, by the brook movement. Faster than other renditions but more fitting imo 😊
@@isabellllee I agree, it is like another dimension. Could be a bit darker but still beautiful. That is how I think a musical piece's immortality is based on; the conveyance can be slow or fast or in between.
The second movement was exquisite. You are to be pitied for your lack of appreciation. As a concession, the third movement isn't the best interpretation, lacking in the requisite clarity as it does.
While the entire piece is a marvel, I must state that the 2nd movement is absolutely sublime, with perfect tempo and synchrony between the 2 violins. Yehudi Menuhin would be truly impressed! Well done!
Can't believe my eye, Spivakov my Bach expert so old and seemed to shrink, much shorter than Clara. I still have his young and handsome photo with my Bach CD, time flies.
The difficulty of slow is what most don't understand. Like doing a push up slowly while maintaining perfect form (In music it's more difficult to maintain steadiness and tone).
nice Performing but I do not have the emotional feeling which I have listening to David Oistrach and Yehudi Menuhem . Maybe it has to do with the time. Menuhem and Oistrach concerto was during the cold war and one of my first experience with (classical) music.
It's clear that this tempo was chosen to clarify the intertwining of the two violins. It's very beautifully played. It's interesting to hear a baroque piece played in a romantic manner. I suspect that Bach would have been fascinated and moved to hear his music this way.
벌써 몇년 전에 연주된 악곡이지만,
이제 들어도 클라라의 차분하고 오버되지 않은
청명하고 부드러운 연주는 아름답다.
공연자도 과욕하지 않고, 협주 악단들도 결코
지나친 과시를 하지 않고 안정된 연주를
계속하는 것이 매우 좋다.
클라라의 부족할 것 없는 연주가
청중들에게도 잘 전달된 것 같다.
클라라가 더욱 자랑스럽다.
아닌데
할아버지가
눈긴ㅅ이
이게바흐
같은데
진짜재미있다
지금문자가
당신실시간이냐
ㅔㅔㅔㅔㅔㅖㅔㅖㅔㅖㅔㅔㅔㅔㅐㅔㅔㅔㅔㅔㅔㅔㅔㅔ0ㅔㅔㅔㅔ000ㅔㅔㅔㅔㅔㅔㅔㅔㅔ0ㅔㅔㅐㅔㅔㅔㅔㅔㅔㅔㅔㅔ0ㅔㅔ0ㅔㅔㅔㅔㅔ0ㅔㅔㅔㅔㅔ0ㅔㅔㅔㅔㅖㅔㅔㅔㅖㅔㅖㅔㅔ0ㅔㅔㅔㅔㅔㅖㅔㅔㅔㅔㅔ0ㅖ0ㅔㅔㅔㅔㅔㅔㅔㅔㅔㅖㅔㅔㅔㅔㅔㅔㅔㅔㅔㅔㅔㅔㅐㅔㅔㅔㅔㅔㅔㅔㅔㅔㅔㅔㅔㅔㅔㅔㅔㅔㅔㅔㅔㅔㅔㅔㅔㅔㅔㅔㅔㅔㅔㅔㅔㅔㅔㅔㅔㅔㅔㅔㅔㅔㅔㅔㅔㅔㅔㅔㅔㅔㅔㅔㅔㅔㅔㅔㅔㅔㅔㅔㅔㅔㅔㅔㅔㅔㅔㅔㅔㅔㅔㅔㅔㅔㅔㅔㅔㅔㅔㅔㅔㅔㅔㅔㅔㅔㅔㅔㅔㅔㅔㅔㅔㅔㅔㅖㅔㅔㅔㅔㅔㅔㅔㅔㅔㅔㅔㅔㅔㅔㅔㅔㅔㅔㅔㅔㅔㅔㅔㅔㅔㅔㅔㅔㅔㅔㅔㅔㅔㅔㅔㅔㅔㅔㅔㅔㅔㅔㅔㅔㅔㅔㅔㅔㅔㅔㅔㅔㅔㅔㅔㅔㅔㅔㅔㅔㅔㅔㅔㅔㅔㅔㅔㅔㅔㅔㅔㅔㅔㅔㅔㅔㅔㅔㅔㅔㅔㅔㅔㅔㅔㅔㅔㅔㅔ
ㅔㅔ0ㅔ0ㅔㅔㅔㅔㅖㅔㅔㅔㅔㅔㅔㅔㅔㅔ
주미강님이 함께하면 너무나 아름다운 소리로 들려요. 음악은 없어지지 않고 영원해 좋습니다. 놀랍습니다.
스산한 날씨에 주저함없이 담백한 대가들의 연주에 나도모르게 눈물을 흘리고 있습니다
처연하게 아름다운 연주 감사합니다.🙏
강주미님에게 점점 스며들고있어요♡
대박...진짜 멋있네요..이렇게 연주를 잘하다니....스타일도 멋있고...클라라 강의 팬이 되었네요...great!!
Excelente, brillante interpretación de un bello concierto
Gorgeous !!!
So beautiful performance .!..!...!.......
Great sound quality...u know it when u can hear the triplets in the third movement clearly.
음악들으면서 눈물나보긴 처음이네..2악장 너무 아름답다.
Excellent rendition of this double concerto by Bach. It is fascinating to hear how the composer intertwins the two soloist voices.
My best compliments to Maestro V. Spivakov !!!
Indeed he plays with flawless clarity.
What a treasure! Divina Clara 🌟
Csodálatos elöadás, koncert. Gratulálok! Üdvözlö tisztelettel és köszönettel, György Tibrea.
계정이 잠시 비활성화 돼서 너무 슬펐어요.
이 곡의 이 버젼을 앞으로 못듣게 되는구나 싶었어요.
I've been searching for this video so long. I am very glad I finally got to see this again
Thank you for sharing good music!
I became a fan of her after listening to her performance of Valse Sentimental. I was attracted because without exaggeration she could express explosive and intense emotions.
Beautiful music - beautifully played. Thank you!
Very beautiful. 2nd movement is really gorgeous 😍👏👏
Thanks for re uploading! the previous uploader deleted their account and the video was lost, been searching a lot since then
So beautiful 😍 performance !! Great awesome 👏 like it
이렇게 느리고 일반적인 바흐를 강주미님과 콜라보 해주시니 참 좋은 것 같아요 ㅎㅎ
the entire flow sounds like the gentle cloud...
정말 아름다운 연주네요! 감사합니다^^
un chemin de lumière qui mène vers le ciel
2:46 start
Excellent Excellent .
17:53 lol Concerto for 2 violins and percussion :)
This is the best recording of J.S. Bach 's 2 concerto d minor available on RUclips by the way.
Theory on motivation? Didn't note it in the score....
The best ? Have you ever listened to recordings with baroque instruments ? They sound more baroque than this one that sounds more romantic.
Великолепно!!!
She makes beautiful music
Clara Jumi Kang was 4th prize winner weak Tchaikovsky competition! Kang is not that Great! You must be joking! Are you kidding me!!!
Great rendition
Wonderful and the greatest performance !
언제쯤 지겨워질까요...♥️
Wonderful music!
02:45 1악장
06:57 2악장
14:15 3악장
What I love most about this video, is that it shows Varvara Kutozova and Alexander Malofeev at tender ages along with Kang and Spivakov, with Dennis Matsuev pumped up for the show. Lovely.
The conductor seemed a little too amped in the 1st movement, but rebounds and plays an absolutely brilliant 2nd movement with such finesse and control. Kang is just Kang. Plays every note perfectly. I don't really care for the 3rd movement. Bach Concerto for 2 violins is pretty much the first 2 movements for me. 3rd movement is well played though by both. Real COOL video
Lovely.
Clara-Jumi gets more gorgeous with age. Wow!!!
Vladimir has probably been playing this thing since he was 8 years old.
This is the best and the best-known double concerto ever written and one can savor every phrase with this nice tempo. Bravo!
There is a shortage of music stands in Russia. This is a great business opportunity for (American) music stand manufacturers, no?
He’s more choppy, she flows. Both brilliant but she has more feeling
This is a baroque dance-like piece. The most important part is to keep a strong rhythm which you can feel with the body. This is also called dancing, so I feel a more "choppy" expression as you call it is more suited.
I’ve never played it choppy, nor has anyone else I know. I’m not saying chippy is wrong it’s all down to individual preference as is all music. It’s often good to listen to different interpretations of conductors and musician’s interpretations. Watch Von Karajan conducting Beethovens 7th. It’s very different to most renditions and it’s so beautiful. Same with the Divan conducted by Barenboim in the 6th, by the brook movement. Faster than other renditions but more fitting imo 😊
Perfect tempi. Too many performances try to make it match Paganini. Really enjoyable thrughout.
Oh she is killing me!
so beautiful she is and plays :)
강주니 최고
백스테이지에서의 저 긴장감...초초초 프로분들도 어쩔 수 없구나...하면서 ^^
Good night
Clara is more dynamic.
More everything.
Spivakov is an all-time great.
she's 40 years younger! no wonder they are different :)
바흐 바이협 참 좋아. 클라롸가 연주하니 더욱 좋다. 바이얼린 여신 중에서 넘버어 1 비쥬얼.
🌻
👏👏👏👏
BOJESTVENNIY B A H - NEVOZMOJNO NAYTI SLOVO, 4TOBI PEREDAT, KAK VOZDEYSTVUET G E N I A L N A Y A MUZIKA GENIYA - B A H A
저는 이곡 지금 배워요.
Vladimir has a more beautiful sound, and Clara more dinamics
현이 살아 이따
돈포겟 리멤버 클라라 강
Spivakov is a master with a wonderful focus. Kang may get there.
Pensé que lo tocarían más rápido 😨
Ils debutent ensemble ? pourquoi pas....
7:00
2:45
They clap in 6/8 😆
Maybe a little bit too slow a tempo?
Exactly what I thought. Listen to Oistrakh and Menukhin playing this piece or Jansen and Kavakos
Slower makes the audiences listen more carefully to each note.
@@isabellllee I agree, it is like another dimension. Could be a bit darker but still beautiful. That is how I think a musical piece's immortality is based on; the conveyance can be slow or fast or in between.
Hahn's third movement is so fast, there isn't time to think of anything, which is a pity as Bach inspires reflective thought.
I have
This is not Bach... Too greasy
The second movement was exquisite.
You are to be pitied for your lack of appreciation.
As a concession, the third movement isn't the best interpretation, lacking in the requisite clarity as it does.
제가 들은 두 대의 바이올린을 위한 협주곡 연주 중에 최고입니다. 2악장 부분은 보통 구슬프게만 들리는데 구슬프면서도 뭔가 희망적으로 들려요. . 감사합니다.
세상에, 이 아카이브를 왜 이제야 알았단 말인가? ㅠㅠ 하늘이 인간에게 내린 선물, CJK!
While the entire piece is a marvel, I must state that the 2nd movement is absolutely sublime, with perfect tempo and synchrony between the 2 violins. Yehudi Menuhin would be truly impressed! Well done!
대학생때 파리여행하던중 루브르쪽에서 어떤분이 연주하시는걸 듣고 처음 알게되어 그 후로 푹 빠졌던 곡이에요. 예전엔 1악장만 좋아해서 1악장만 주구장창들었는데 이젠 다 좋아요. 1악장에서 2악장으로 연결되는 느낌도 부드럽고, 3악장도 조화롭구요. 잘 감상했습니다 :)
전 2악장이 더 좋던데요. 어쨌든 명곡임에는 틀림없죠.
02:45 1 Часть - Виваче
06:57 2 Часть - Ларго, Ма Нон Танто
14:15 3 Часть - Аллегро
Спасибо, добрый человек! 👏
So beautiful performance, thank you!
Best of best among music pieces composed by human beings!
Can't believe my eye, Spivakov my Bach expert so old and seemed to shrink, much shorter than Clara. I still have his young and handsome photo with my Bach CD, time flies.
The difficulty of slow is what most don't understand. Like doing a push up slowly while maintaining perfect form (In music it's more difficult to maintain steadiness and tone).
exactly same tempo my 8 y/o daughter practices her part
何度もくり返し聴いてしまう!!
素晴らしいバッハをありがとう!!
There is too much ego in his playing and she is far too deferential
He does not need to stab or slap the music to make it make love with him
This performance is the best ever I've heard.💐 It's a great consolation to me all the time.
Nice rendition indeed. Try the one played by Oistrakh and Menuhin, 2 giants!
특히 2악장 계속 반복 듣기 중입니다.
두분연주 호흡이 정말 환상이시고
너무나 감정어린 연주입니다.
들을때마다 가슴이 뭉클하네요.
감동 입니다♡♡♡
I've been searching for it again, again and again. Finally it comes back. Bravo!
Another great performance of this wonderful piece! Thank you.
모든 것이 아름다워서 좋다.
태클거는게 아니고 클래식은 정확히몰라서그런데 왜지휘자없이 한거에요?? 남자분 솔로박자는 일부러조금씩 밀리게? 연주하시는건가용?? 부분적으로 아주조금씩 위태롭게들리는건 기분탓인가 어째뜬 너무아름다워요ㅜㅜ
밀린다라ㅋㅋ 그걸 캐치하시다니 대단하시네요
저거는 오케스트라 라기보다는 앙상블 형태에 더 가까워서 지휘자가 없는것 같아요.
앙상블은 지휘자 없이 연주하거든요.
아니면 저 남자솔로분이 지휘자일수도 있어용
베토벤 이전 시대는 특히 바흐는 원래 악기수도 적었기때문에 지휘자가 궂이 필요가 없었습니다.
그리고 블라지미르 스피바코프는 러시아의 상징적인 바이올리스트입니다.
스피바코프가 주미강 나이때 연주영상을 보시면 이해가 가실겁니다.
스피바코프는바이올리니스트이기도 하지만 지휘자여서 개인 오케스트라도 갖고있습니다
원래 협연은 지휘가 없는경우도 있어요~ 그리고 이 무대는 Two violin concerto라서 두명의 연주자가 연주했구용! 아마 박자가 밀리는것처럼 들으신건 두 연주자를 위한 곡인만큼 화음과 서로 주고받는 부분이 생기기때문이 아닌가 싶네요
nice Performing but I do not have the emotional feeling which I have listening to David Oistrach and Yehudi Menuhem . Maybe it has to do with the time. Menuhem and Oistrach concerto was during the cold war and one of my first experience with (classical) music.
Thank you for uploading!
Два великолепных музыканта, и каждый играет своего Баха
전 2악장이너무 아름다워요
Clara so humble and beautiful, thank you ❤
Какая же она красивая...
Thank you for re-uploading!
Clara-Jumi Kang & Vladimir Spivakov すばらしー！
Nieśmiertalna muzyka a II część jak w niebie. D.Ojstrach i J. Menuhin w nowym wydaniu !
주미강 어깨받침 없이도 잘하시네요ㄷㄷ
저는 이곡 배워요
나도그리하고싶어요
나이60
Lovely duet
아름 답고 조으다 ㅎ
멋진연주입니다 클라라 주미강님 너무 존경스럽습니다
JS Bach; one ring to rule them all ...
Nádhera, výtečné provedení. J.S.Bach je geniální skladatel, velká poklona interpretům.
Exquisite Largo Second Movement
You two sound so beautiful💗 thank you💕아름다운 연주입니다 응원합니다! 두 분 모두 아름다워요💗
It's clear that this tempo was chosen to clarify the intertwining of the two violins. It's very beautifully played. It's interesting to hear a baroque piece played in a romantic manner. I suspect that Bach would have been fascinated and moved to hear his music this way.
exactly same tempo my 8 y/o daughter practices her part
yes.....one simply cannot rush Bach, and so many fine violinists do; simply because they can
이 곡 빠르기를 알 수 있게 유려하게 주미강을 비롯 2개의 바이올린을 위한 협주곡 잘 들었습니다
클라라만의 정교하고도 차분함이 좋아요
Qué sublime! Qué belleza!...