This isnt anything to do with trans though, banda was born female, is female, just because she has a high testosterone doesnt make her not a woman, she passed FIFA, the olympic committee and every league she has played ins rules and regulations. Afcon notoriously has much stricter regulations on this than the rest of the world, so theres nothing wrong with her winning.
Barbra is a woman. Please stop this. An error in the understanding of the rules led to her missing the women's afcon, but she played at the World Cup and Olympics. This is inhumane treatment to Barbra and should stop. Avoid talking about things you don't fully understand
The wokist you had on from Talk Sport complaining that if HE was classified as male then HIS feelings may be hurt - well, what about the feelings of the real girls who trained hard but lost against HIM?
Labour got just short of 33% of the vote! A mandate should only ever be mentioned or Spoken of when it's over 50% of populace vote therfore we need a referendum on #1 winter fuel allowance #2 inheritance tax on farmers #3 the tax on business raising NI for employers.
I've listened to the World Service for a while after deserting Radio Four's wokeness. Now I'm leaving it. They seem to bring a climate change angle to almost any subject. Plus it's nearly all racism, gender issues or slavery. Enough. Today they were banging on about this footballer. Can't stand any more.
This is very unfair to babra Banda ,she just talented.This trouble came about because caf president Mr Patrice motsepe who is south african who wanted his country women national team to win tournament that 2022 and Zambia was biggest threat with brilliant babra Banda in it ,south Africa was no match.this was an attempt to block a good player and allow s.a women and Patrice motsepe could not even answer questions concerning babra.
I think, it is safe to say that they are being "sourced" by coaches and teams. It looks as though the 46 XY DSD is fairly common in Africa. You have the athletes - Caster Semenya, Francine Niyonsaba, Margaret Wambui, Christine Mboma Beatrice Masilini and I dare say dozens more who have been born with this condition, which used to be known as "intersex". To give you an idea of what a difference it makes, Francine Niyonsaba of Burundi holds every national women's track record from 400m to 10,000m.
@keithmorris-i9o it wasn't even a proper ratified test, she has since played in a number of FIFA-affiliated competitions. Since you're such a huge supporter of women's rights in football, what is your take on the head coach of the Zambia women's national team?
Just go ahead and do the tests to prove your allegations. Otherwise, Barbara Banda is an amazing player and deserves this amazing recognition.. congratulations my girl🎉. We are behind u🎉
Have you seen the power of the media? Banda played in the Olympics and also in the world cup of Nations but these media houses deliberately decide to avoid that and concentrate on the AFCON. This is the reason why Africa must have her own voice where media is concerned
Testosterone and X/Y chromosomes are two related but distinct concepts in biology. *X/Y Chromosomes:* - X and Y are the two sex chromosomes in humans. - Females typically have two X chromosomes (XX), while males typically have one X and one Y chromosome (XY). - The presence of the Y chromosome determines male sex characteristics, while the absence of the Y chromosome (or presence of a second X) determines female sex characteristics. *Testosterone:* - Testosterone is a hormone produced by the testes in males and the ovaries in females, although at much lower levels in females. - Testosterone plays a crucial role in the development of male sex characteristics, such as: - Masculinization of the fetus during pregnancy - Development of male genitalia - Growth and maintenance of facial and body hair - Deepening of the voice - Increased muscle mass and bone density - Testosterone also influences behavior, libido, and overall health in both males and females. Key differences: 1. *Chromosomes determine sex*, while *testosterone influences sex characteristics*. 2. *X/Y chromosomes are present from conception*, while *testosterone levels fluctuate throughout life*. 3. *Chromosomes are a genetic blueprint*, while *testosterone is a hormone that affects gene expression*. Do you have any follow-up questions or would you like me to elaborate on any of these points?
Im absolutely disappointed with these sexiest talks being advanced by these media institution, Barbara Banda was born with a female (vivi) and shes fully capable of being pregnant. Is. She supposed to undress herself in public to show that she's female? Why would you discriminate against her just because she presumably has high testosterone level? I guess most of our women in Africa then will be disadvantaged in many sports because of what you presume as high testosterone. I think its not even the issue of testosterone here, its just purely sexism and being racist here.
By definition, a woman is an adult human being with female reproductive organs. Biologically, Barbra Banda is female, and that's not the issue. The concern is that she has higher testosterone levels compared to her fellow female footballers, which may give her an unfair advantage. We should consider her background and childhood, which have shaped her into the person she is today. It's hurtful to hear people question her status. It's essential to recognize that distinguishing between male and female is not confusing, it's based on biological characteristics. Let's avoid dramatizing the issue and playing on people's emotions, as this can be damaging.Instead,lets focus on having a respectful conversation.
Come on, is anyone (normal people) surprised? It's all so mundane and predictable. It's a shame for the other women, but this is life these days. Incredibly sad.
THIS MESSAGE IS FOR PEOPLE IN 2124.. Hello people! hope you are keeping the world a safe place to live in.. I just wanted to let you know that a century ago, there was a female soccer player from Zambia 🇿🇲 by the name of Barbra Banda who was sooo good at the sport that she had people thinking that she is a man.. all efforts to frustrate her in the name of advocating for women failed. She kept going and continued to put her country on the map.. what a blessing it was to watch her play🥹🥹 BB11🇿🇲🇿🇲
Actually not. Intersex conditions specifically appear in male fetuses and certain conditions appear in female fetuses. So even when you can’t tell by looking genes will tell.
Why are you lemons still paying the tv licence fee. If you just watch netflix or RUclips you dont need to pay for the TV licence. Cancel your tv licence today. Defund the bbc.
@ethandalton6480 I chose to heat my home for a month rather than watch bbc for a year. BBC should be funded from advertising or by subscription by choice.
Sex matters are also very wrong as well because there are plenty of women with PCOS which actually produces more testosterone. That’s why women get hairy chin so there are women with more testosterone.
Barbra Banda is female. The whole idea of an award is to celebrate exceptional talent and hard work. When you take a look at her statistics, it is clear that she is exceptional. This is British propaganda, because you did not want her to win. She is one of the very best female footballers in the world, and that is a fact.
The BBC are just swinging to the right, abandoning all the woke nonsense, and acknowledging that MEN are the best football players regardless of what team they play for, don't you think?
Barbara is not Trans! To be clear!! Just because she's born with an advantage (testestoron)....same as any super tall female basketball players (an advantage) ! It's sooo upsetting!!
This one ticks two boxes! The BBC are beyond woke now.
South Park is becoming real life every day.
So glad I cancelled my TV licence. Not that I would've been watching any of this shite anyway.
The BBC essentially admitting men found a way to be better than women at female football. Pretty based.
I know right? We’ve come full fricking circle 😂 I’m chuffed… another win for the boys
Im sick of this trans crap with sports its just beyond a joke
This isnt anything to do with trans though, banda was born female, is female, just because she has a high testosterone doesnt make her not a woman, she passed FIFA, the olympic committee and every league she has played ins rules and regulations. Afcon notoriously has much stricter regulations on this than the rest of the world, so theres nothing wrong with her winning.
Colour had absolutely nothing to do with this 😂😂😂😂😂
Come on guys, it's the BBC. What on Earth do you expect??
Congratulations Barbra Banda. You surpassed them all 🎉🎉🎉🎉
Did you listen to the video at all?
🇿🇲 🙌🏾🙌🏾
Barbra is a woman. Please stop this. An error in the understanding of the rules led to her missing the women's afcon, but she played at the World Cup and Olympics. This is inhumane treatment to Barbra and should stop. Avoid talking about things you don't fully understand
She's got some balls accepting that award...
YEAH 2 I THINK ,LOL
Typical BBC!🇬🇧
The wokist you had on from Talk Sport complaining that if HE was classified as male then HIS feelings may be hurt - well, what about the feelings of the real girls who trained hard but lost against HIM?
Strange how Trump gets in campaigning on this very issue yet our country is going all in on the madness!
I'm british and seriously embarrassed by the british people who voted this shower of socialists into power.
@@paulchristiepureblood146 have we had another General Election since Labour won the last one?
You get what you vote for. Or in our case, what 80% of the electorate didn’t vote for.
Labour won a third of the vote mate. Not a fifth.
Labour got just short of 33% of the vote! A mandate should only ever be mentioned or Spoken of when it's over 50% of populace vote therfore we need a referendum on #1 winter fuel allowance #2 inheritance tax on farmers #3 the tax on business raising NI for employers.
You are not even ashamed of yourselfs...
Congratulations BB, Zambia as country is proud of you....
Oops! I must've landed on the wrong planet...
Voted by the people-BBC prove it
In fairness “ He” was probably voted for, if you take the disinterest in the BBC it would only take 4 votes to win
What do expect from the BBC! This organisation is out of control. Has been for a long time.
I've listened to the World Service for a while after deserting Radio Four's wokeness. Now I'm leaving it. They seem to bring a climate change angle to almost any subject. Plus it's nearly all racism, gender issues or slavery. Enough. Today they were banging on about this footballer. Can't stand any more.
Same here stopped all mainstream media near two years ago now, don’t pay the license fee’s
This is very unfair to babra Banda ,she just talented.This trouble came about because caf president Mr Patrice motsepe who is south african who wanted his country women national team to win tournament that 2022 and Zambia was biggest threat with brilliant babra Banda in it ,south Africa was no match.this was an attempt to block a good player and allow s.a women and Patrice motsepe could not even answer questions concerning babra.
Three players in one team to have this issue 😮🤔
I think, it is safe to say that they are being "sourced" by coaches and teams. It looks as though the 46 XY DSD is fairly common in Africa. You have the athletes - Caster Semenya, Francine Niyonsaba, Margaret Wambui, Christine Mboma Beatrice Masilini and I dare say dozens more who have been born with this condition, which used to be known as "intersex". To give you an idea of what a difference it makes, Francine Niyonsaba of Burundi holds every national women's track record from 400m to 10,000m.
Every source I can find says Banda was born female. Has anyone seen otherwise?
No one will have done.
Tested in 2022 failed and kicked out of a competition
@keithmorris-i9o it wasn't even a proper ratified test, she has since played in a number of FIFA-affiliated competitions. Since you're such a huge supporter of women's rights in football, what is your take on the head coach of the Zambia women's national team?
Just go ahead and do the tests to prove your allegations. Otherwise, Barbara Banda is an amazing player and deserves this amazing recognition.. congratulations my girl🎉. We are behind u🎉
Was the price given by the BBC or for the BBC?
Have you seen the power of the media? Banda played in the Olympics and also in the world cup of Nations but these media houses deliberately decide to avoid that and concentrate on the AFCON. This is the reason why Africa must have her own voice where media is concerned
Please do not forget without women none of us would be here
Come on, the dude says his name is Barbra and he identifies as a woman. Surely he’s a worthy winner as BBC’s woman footballer of the year? 😂
Testosterone and X/Y chromosomes are two related but distinct concepts in biology.
*X/Y Chromosomes:*
- X and Y are the two sex chromosomes in humans.
- Females typically have two X chromosomes (XX), while males typically have one X and one Y chromosome (XY).
- The presence of the Y chromosome determines male sex characteristics, while the absence of the Y chromosome (or presence of a second X) determines female sex characteristics.
*Testosterone:*
- Testosterone is a hormone produced by the testes in males and the ovaries in females, although at much lower levels in females.
- Testosterone plays a crucial role in the development of male sex characteristics, such as:
- Masculinization of the fetus during pregnancy
- Development of male genitalia
- Growth and maintenance of facial and body hair
- Deepening of the voice
- Increased muscle mass and bone density
- Testosterone also influences behavior, libido, and overall health in both males and females.
Key differences:
1. *Chromosomes determine sex*, while *testosterone influences sex characteristics*.
2. *X/Y chromosomes are present from conception*, while *testosterone levels fluctuate throughout life*.
3. *Chromosomes are a genetic blueprint*, while *testosterone is a hormone that affects gene expression*.
Do you have any follow-up questions or would you like me to elaborate on any of these points?
Funded by your license fee
So predictable,who cares what bbc think.
She earned it. Stop trying to defame our girl!
Im absolutely disappointed with these sexiest talks being advanced by these media institution, Barbara Banda was born with a female (vivi) and shes fully capable of being pregnant. Is. She supposed to undress herself in public to show that she's female? Why would you discriminate against her just because she presumably has high testosterone level? I guess most of our women in Africa then will be disadvantaged in many sports because of what you presume as high testosterone. I think its not even the issue of testosterone here, its just purely sexism and being racist here.
This is one of the least controversial things the BBC have done.
By definition, a woman is an adult human being with female reproductive organs. Biologically, Barbra Banda is female, and that's not the issue. The concern is that she has higher testosterone levels compared to her fellow female footballers, which may give her an unfair advantage.
We should consider her background and childhood, which have shaped her into the person she is today. It's hurtful to hear people question her status. It's essential to recognize that distinguishing between male and female is not confusing, it's based on biological characteristics.
Let's avoid dramatizing the issue and playing on people's emotions, as this can be damaging.Instead,lets focus on having a respectful conversation.
Nonsense Babra Banda is the best she's the best ❤
Come on, is anyone (normal people) surprised? It's all so mundane and predictable. It's a shame for the other women, but this is life these days. Incredibly sad.
THIS MESSAGE IS FOR PEOPLE IN 2124..
Hello people! hope you are keeping the world a safe place to live in.. I just wanted to let you know that a century ago, there was a female soccer player from Zambia 🇿🇲 by the name of Barbra Banda who was sooo good at the sport that she had people thinking that she is a man.. all efforts to frustrate her in the name of advocating for women failed. She kept going and continued to put her country on the map.. what a blessing it was to watch her play🥹🥹
BB11🇿🇲🇿🇲
There are males, females and Its.
Actually not. Intersex conditions specifically appear in male fetuses and certain conditions appear in female fetuses. So even when you can’t tell by looking genes will tell.
Shims
Why are you lemons still paying the tv licence fee. If you just watch netflix or RUclips you dont need to pay for the TV licence. Cancel your tv licence today. Defund the bbc.
It was a public vote
@ethandalton6480 I chose to heat my home for a month rather than watch bbc for a year. BBC should be funded from advertising or by subscription by choice.
@@rbir2653 OK, but it doesn't change the fact that the BBC didn't decide the winner, it was a public vote
@@ethandalton6480 if you want to watch men play football just watch the premier league
“WE DON’T KNOW”
full stop, everything after that is y’all’s BS.
“We can read what we like into that”
Facts over Feelings!
Oh dear 😢😢
Sex matters are also very wrong as well because there are plenty of women with PCOS which actually produces more testosterone. That’s why women get hairy chin so there are women with more testosterone.
Why can't they have their own compitions ?😮
Of course the bbc had to pick the most controversial person they possibly could to show their dei credentials. Its insane.
Barbra Banda is female. The whole idea of an award is to celebrate exceptional talent and hard work. When you take a look at her statistics, it is clear that she is exceptional. This is British propaganda, because you did not want her to win. She is one of the very best female footballers in the world, and that is a fact.
The BBC are just swinging to the right, abandoning all the woke nonsense, and acknowledging that MEN are the best football players regardless of what team they play for, don't you think?
Barbara is not Trans! To be clear!! Just because she's born with an advantage (testestoron)....same as any super tall female basketball players (an advantage) ! It's sooo upsetting!!
From what I've read she had high testosterone and there is no evidence released (that I know of) proving she definitely has XY chromosomes
Cancel the properganda get your news of independent sources it one big Hive Mind.
You are Either Arthur or Martha.
End of.
What what
Congra Mister Banda.
Wait that is so bad. The BBC forgot to pick someone who is no part of alphabet soup brigade...
Yes vegetable soup 😂
It was a public vote
@@ethandalton6480 Like a Panorama audience is just "The public"🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣