Understand the Sequester (Spoiler: It's Bananas.)

Поделиться
HTML-код
  • Опубликовано: 16 янв 2025

Комментарии • 3,5 тыс.

  • @EnyawInc
    @EnyawInc 10 лет назад +107

    "Presidents do not set tax rates and they do not decide the budget"
    Something Americans should know, but don't.

    • @nathanspencer1238
      @nathanspencer1238 7 лет назад +2

      Yes it's true but the president decides how to spend the budget in several ways.

    • @gilmarianimer4926
      @gilmarianimer4926 6 лет назад +2

      But he just said they propose it. Didn't he?

    • @enchantedplays7860
      @enchantedplays7860 3 года назад +1

      @@gilmarianimer4926 House of Reps. can also. The real power is veto

  • @AndrewPorwitzky
    @AndrewPorwitzky 12 лет назад +3

    I am an Army research physicist facing 22 days without pay this year because of the Sequester. Thank you for helping to explain this to people.

  • @MasonGelosotech
    @MasonGelosotech 9 лет назад +62

    Why doesn't our schools have a "life preparedness" class?
    They could teach things like:
    -Buy a house
    -Open an IRA
    -Buying a car
    -Bouncing Checks
    -How Credit Cards work
    -Balancing your funds
    -Simple Stocks
    -etc
    That would solve so many problem in the long term.

    • @amelie842
      @amelie842 9 лет назад +1

      ***** That would be so helpful! Also a girl in Germay twittered that with her 19 years she has no idea how to continue with her life after school. That tweet got very very famous and ended up in every newspaper in Germany.

    • @a.m.ramblings5746
      @a.m.ramblings5746 9 лет назад +1

      ***** generally that's called Business Class.

    • @MasonGelosotech
      @MasonGelosotech 9 лет назад +1

      worldfullofbooks Most High Schools don't have a "Business Class", that's the problem that I am stating.

    • @tobitoes1052
      @tobitoes1052 9 лет назад +1

      +Mason Geloso not even when you do GCSEs/BTECs?

    • @a.m.ramblings5746
      @a.m.ramblings5746 9 лет назад

      ***** really? That's surprising.

  • @PandoraDaFoxx
    @PandoraDaFoxx 8 лет назад +21

    I learn more about the government from John in a series of four to six minute videos than I did in four years of high school.

    • @rktsnail
      @rktsnail 2 года назад

      No you just aren’t aware of what little you would know if you didn’t attend high school.

  • @andrewxc1335
    @andrewxc1335 8 лет назад +26

    John Green 2020!
    Green / Green ? That would make my day. Hank would be in charge of our energy policy...

  • @LukeBroadbent
    @LukeBroadbent 12 лет назад +1

    Living in Australia, we hear a fair bit about what is going on in America. But because I live in Australia what I don't hear is all the context to know why things are the way they are.
    As the kids say, mad props to you guys for clarifying many things for me about what's happening in the US and why. So thanks from a non-US fan for clearing all that stuff up :)

  • @taravanova
    @taravanova 10 лет назад +9

    Biggest mind fuck of this video was learning that John wrote The Fault in Our Stars.

    • @Tigermond1
      @Tigermond1 10 лет назад +12

      How can you a) know John well enough to be perplexed that you didn't know semething important about him and b) know the Fault in Our Stars, but c) don't know that John Green wrote The Fault in Our Stars??? :D That's like...watching a video of Obama and then write in the comments "Biggest mind fuck of this video was learning that Barack is the president of the USA." ^-^ (Just kidding, it just amused me.)

  • @Ariel-ps8je
    @Ariel-ps8je 10 лет назад +19

    so im procrastinating by learning about the economy of a country I don't live in. The thing is, America's debt is a lot more interesting than Canada in the 20th century, which is what I'm supposed to be writing a paper on.

    • @greg.sym.4115
      @greg.sym.4115 9 лет назад +9

      Sitting in South Africa trying to write three essays. I feel you man.

  • @TheHideCheck
    @TheHideCheck 12 лет назад +1

    As a US airman and a fellow nerdfighter, I'm really glad you made this video. The cuts are hitting deep around here, my office of four is now an office of two with the same obligations. My tuition assistance has been cut. Our pensions and even our salaries are at risk.
    ...
    but I'm willing to speak for a good portion of us that we will sooner take these personal sacrifices rather than lose our effectiveness as a military whole(such as some comments suggest). Our mission is much to important.

  • @gardenrug4073
    @gardenrug4073 11 лет назад +31

    John Green for President!

  • @dasschwarzeschwein
    @dasschwarzeschwein 10 лет назад +28

    John Green for President? Everyone would know when and where our pressure is needed to be applied to our representatives!

    • @daandekker6115
      @daandekker6115 10 лет назад +1

      I will not vote for a candidate who hates unicorns!

    • @SinHurr
      @SinHurr 10 лет назад

      Daan Dekker That is actually a deal breaker. Unicorn master race!

    • @TheFireflyGrave
      @TheFireflyGrave 10 лет назад +9

      John Green was pulling his hair out by the end of this 6 minute video just talking about the dysfunction of congress. If he had to deal with them personally he'd probably go insane within 6 minutes.

  • @ChrisMarabate14
    @ChrisMarabate14 12 лет назад +1

    I want to personally thanks both of you for all the hard work you put into making these videos to make the world more educated! But mostly for making me more educated = ) Thanks again! You guys rock!

  • @kurmandhaliwal218
    @kurmandhaliwal218 8 лет назад +7

    This literally blew my mind: scraping off 8 percent less bird poop

  • @MankarCamoran8799
    @MankarCamoran8799 8 лет назад +9

    'and Greece' the best part of the video.....

  • @Hedbik
    @Hedbik 12 лет назад +1

    Hi, John! I just got your book today, and I can't wait to read it! Never before have I read a book knowing the face of it's author BEFORE reading it. I feel like I "know" you, and I am in a way proud that I "know" the writer of the book I'm reading. It's quite an interesting feeling.

  • @Persnikity-yv3nh
    @Persnikity-yv3nh 8 лет назад +8

    Your government frustrates me.

    • @jayylad38
      @jayylad38 5 лет назад +1

      The Jenna Pearl it frustrates all of us too

  • @whitesparrowchild
    @whitesparrowchild 11 лет назад +1

    I couldn't agree more! As a Head Start teacher, someone directly affected by this and still being affected by this, it irritates me that the government went this route. It not only affects jobs, it's affecting the children I teach and the parents I work with.

  • @SMFortissimo
    @SMFortissimo 12 лет назад

    I'm so sick of news people playing the blame game! Why don't they actually like inform me of facts instead of their opinions!
    A lot of what I hear from those around me is "The government is spending too much money!" and then the speaker cannot elaborate at all because they have no idea what they're talking about! You're the only sane person I've heard talk about this, John. Thank you for putting this in plain English.

  • @orangepeel45
    @orangepeel45 12 лет назад +1

    I love how he takes the time to explain things for us because, let's face it, I probably wouldn't get someone else to tell me how this works in such an understandable way, you know?

  • @wizikitheguru
    @wizikitheguru 11 лет назад

    John Green is a great beacon of light and knowledge. You teach me so much.

  • @Toshichica
    @Toshichica 11 лет назад +2

    That was incredibly informational and entertaining at the same time. Subscribed!

  • @DGray3007
    @DGray3007 11 лет назад

    there's a lot of things I don't understand in this video, but your voice makes me happy.

  • @fantasticfoil92
    @fantasticfoil92 12 лет назад +1

    Crash course economics would be an amazing thing to see. Love your videos!

  • @Astartes1000
    @Astartes1000 12 лет назад

    John, I love to hear your rants about the government and how poorly it does. Helps me to understand who to be disappointed in...

  • @coconutnacho
    @coconutnacho 11 лет назад

    hey John, thank you so much for coming to england. I got to meet you and Hank and my life is now complete.
    Thank you

  • @bearycutecg
    @bearycutecg 12 лет назад

    Thanks for this video! You were able to explain in a few minutes what no else could explain with all the time in the world. NOW I understand why everyone is angry with congress. Thanks again!

  • @bethebestofhumanity
    @bethebestofhumanity 12 лет назад

    this is actually very educational. it completely does include john's opinion. this does not mean it is not educational. he tells you everything you need to know about the sequester and also what he thinks about the sequester. just listen to what he is saying and you will "gather information from it". also, what do you have against john's opinion it makes perfect sense.

  • @jesusVSsanta
    @jesusVSsanta 12 лет назад

    Thank you for a good description, the news just spouts the babble and catch phrases, nobody explained it as a whole better than you have. Shared this on my facebook for all my non-nerdfighter friends.

  • @Waltham1892
    @Waltham1892 12 лет назад

    Dear John,
    We've had a vote and we've decided that you are the one to lead the Revolution.
    We are behind you 100%
    Signed,
    The John Green Revolutionary Committe.

  • @TinyBreakfastTable
    @TinyBreakfastTable 12 лет назад

    Just a fun fact: Government nonprofit contractors which fall into that 36% are being hit with sequestration and MOST are actually cutting and shrinking as many contracts as possible then giving any excess money to the more important contracts. However, like John said, actual government agencies are just cutting back ten percent over all. Which from what I hear tends to fall towards the contractor budgets. So honestly I think it's a start at cleaning house.

  • @HerVeryLowness
    @HerVeryLowness 12 лет назад

    Why can I only vote this comment up once? This deserves extra points, as does your science teacher.

  • @JuliaTheNinja
    @JuliaTheNinja 12 лет назад

    I like educational videos because I get to hear you talk at my face for longer.

  • @SamGoodburn
    @SamGoodburn 12 лет назад

    I'm impressed at how interesting and engaging you made this sound, even though I do not not live in American and it will not affect me. You made me wish I did so I could be outraged with you!

  • @catatoniccrimson
    @catatoniccrimson 12 лет назад

    John, can you explain the news more often? Hearing all the context explained from an informed, unbiased perspective is surprisingly helpful. I think a lot of nerdfighters appreciate the clarity. :)

  • @buckeyfan131
    @buckeyfan131 12 лет назад

    John, can you just teach everyone? The world needs your knowledge!

  • @msafder
    @msafder 12 лет назад

    Great explanation John! But to quote the great Milton Friedman "I am in favor of cutting taxes under any circumstances and for any excuse, for any reason, whenever it's possible."

  • @zrahim94
    @zrahim94 12 лет назад

    First off as a Brit studying US politics this was fascinating. Also, the retired lobby in the US is so powerful that there is no way medicare is ever being cut. Washington's problem (erm apart from the gridlock/ rhetoric) are the special interest groups that basically write your legislation.

  • @EeveelynLPs
    @EeveelynLPs 12 лет назад

    This is one of the best explanations of the actual root of the problem with sequester.

  • @AlaskaFinal
    @AlaskaFinal 12 лет назад

    "scenario is way to complex to make a sweeping statement like that."
    Greece is an example of what would happen here if we didn't require states to balance their budgets. By having a common currency with no restrictions on debt obligations, Greece was incentived to borrow money and reap all the benefits of having the same currency value as Germany, before another nation did so, and raised prices on all Europeans just the same.
    Fact: most goods are more expensive Europe, that's no coincidence.

  • @bilbobaggins9246
    @bilbobaggins9246 12 лет назад

    ONE credit agency downrated our debt one level. And it was because it had concerns that we might not raise the debt ceiling in the future, not any concern about long term spending. That act also had the paradoxical effect of spurring people to buy up US bonds, since they are still the safest place to put your money.

  • @sniper6081
    @sniper6081 12 лет назад +1

    Actually, we've defaulted on our debt like five times already, but people keep lending the government money. Strange, I know.

  • @whatsonwednesday
    @whatsonwednesday 12 лет назад

    i was coming home from an international flight and i noticed while going through immigration that there were many lines for people to get their papers stamped but only about 10 were being used. There were about 1,000 people in line and only about 10 booths open. I guess it was because it meant there were less people to work at those closed lines, because of job cuts. i just felt like acknowledging that this helped me understand a little bit more about what is going on.

  • @FaeriesAndWitches
    @FaeriesAndWitches 12 лет назад

    john you're one of my favorite people

  • @iKhanKing
    @iKhanKing 11 лет назад

    When medicare was first introduced, it payed care providers in the 70th percentile of what doctors in the area charged, in otherwords, above average. This resulted in healthcare costs skyrocketing, as Medicare was paying above the average cost. This was later changed, but we still live in a system where healthcare costs are pretty much set by Medicare, rather than being set by the market of consumers and insurance providers.

  • @duncanlovesscifi360
    @duncanlovesscifi360 12 лет назад

    Too much money being spent in the near future on things that you guys don't need. I agree wholly with this video! Keep on doing your work vlog brothers! May your messages get out soon hopefully!

  • @3redwoodsgirl
    @3redwoodsgirl 11 лет назад

    seriously, this guy's channel is awesome. you need to check it out.

  • @jocelynchoi4939
    @jocelynchoi4939 12 лет назад

    Paper towns is awesome, just awesome. I love your books John!!!

  • @Samiiraee
    @Samiiraee 11 лет назад

    I could just listen to him talk all day.

  • @lindsayrose2728
    @lindsayrose2728 11 лет назад

    I learn more watching a 6 minute video by john green than i ever have in history class

  • @fuhleeshuhfilluhbomb2534
    @fuhleeshuhfilluhbomb2534 12 лет назад

    as soon as i saw the time, i was kinda excited for a punishment. alas, educational video. so bittersweet.

  • @Virginiafox21
    @Virginiafox21 12 лет назад

    I kinda take back what I said. I had a very informative guest lecturer in Political Science today, and while there is no actual money changing hands, there is plenty of appointments and IOUs and other stuff changing hands for a better place, and that's just in Congress.
    Also, I totally agree with you.

  • @SlashTheWolf101
    @SlashTheWolf101 11 лет назад +1

    the debt ceiling is pretty much a governmental "stop hitting yourself"

  • @otmrs
    @otmrs 12 лет назад

    I'm not sure where you tailed off to at the end there... but my point was that current market systems tend to privatize the profits but socialize the costs. From 1977 - 2007, the US military spent ~$244B per year securing Persian Gulf oil tankers (Stern, 2010) which comes out of the public's pockets in the form of taxes. Considering the US only imported $337B worth of oil in 2010 (Pickens, 2011), it's fairly safe to say you're only paying directly for half the cost of the gas you use.

  • @VioletEdgar
    @VioletEdgar 12 лет назад

    I work at a us army library overseas. We work to serve our military community, providing entertainment and education and promoting literacy to the service members stationed here.
    After three years, what do I get as a thank you for my hard work? A 20% reduction in work hours and pay for almost 6 months.
    The sequestration is not just bananas, it is actively destroying lives of those who have actively worked towards the betterment of their communities.

  • @ejmaso05
    @ejmaso05 11 лет назад

    The biggest financial problem facing the country is the aging population and the cost of their future medical care. One of the most expensive illnesses to treat is dementia, which is also one of the most prominent illnesses in adults over 65. Finding a treatment for dementia would remove a TREMENDOUS amount of financial strain from the government. I am a scientist that studies dementia HOWEVER because of the sequester I just lost a significant portion of money for my research. That makes sense.

  • @MikeTheMasterfulMage
    @MikeTheMasterfulMage 11 лет назад

    I didn't think it was possible, but you have made me ACTUALLY care about history and polotics ^^

  • @augflaw
    @augflaw 12 лет назад

    this should be mandatory viewing for all news anchors

  • @Tartar
    @Tartar 12 лет назад

    There are few nations currently with the economic growth that rivaled those before the crisis. But that is quite normal.

  • @molelimer
    @molelimer 12 лет назад +1

    I think you might be confused about how social security works... Also, the baby boom. But okay.

  • @molelimer
    @molelimer 12 лет назад

    This should not be boring. It is important to understand. If no one were to care to understand what's happening in our country, we would end up with a bunch of deadweight, poorly informed, parasitic citizens. Well. More of them than we already have.
    Sorry, I'm very passionate about this.

  • @andrsdtz
    @andrsdtz 12 лет назад

    as a german I always find it very interesting when u explain these things to us outsiders

  • @MCPaddyB
    @MCPaddyB 11 лет назад

    Though I slightly disagree with you I felt obliged to come here and say I appreciate your views and opinions. Too often on RUclips people just throw profanities around and do not explain/understand the situation. Rather they blindly follow irrational nationalism, 'MERICA!' and so forth. So thank you AlaskaFinal, You have shown that not everyone on RUclips is completely ignorant. Nice argument, well put.

  • @thegoodcyborg
    @thegoodcyborg 12 лет назад

    "It's like the doctor told you you had a slow growing tumor in your fingernail and you responded by saying 'Quick! Remove my gall bladder!'"
    Lovely! That quote comes between Liz Lemons "women are allowed to get angrier than men about double standards" and Jane Austens "There are few people whom I really love, and still fewer of whom I think well."
    (Not because there are any realtions between those quotes, just because I think they are awesome...)

  • @SJPace1776
    @SJPace1776 12 лет назад

    John,
    I truly hope you do a video on why health care cost what it does in the United States. See where the money goes and ask if the more we spend really equals better care? Considering how much we spend every year, I think it is worth while to ask why.

  • @Rockthezeppelin
    @Rockthezeppelin 12 лет назад

    these econ videos are some of my faves, they so damn good

  • @nicolemarino9523
    @nicolemarino9523 11 лет назад

    You are so smart, I love watching these videos!

  • @SheilaMartinezpsychobable11130
    @SheilaMartinezpsychobable11130 12 лет назад

    No it don't. The uploader was the best economist in their state at the age of 17 so I assume he did not misunderstood the tax structure of your country. And he is the best novelist EVER.

  • @ParagonBeaumont
    @ParagonBeaumont 12 лет назад

    John Green, how do you feel about the machines that smash pennies for souvenirs? My parents wouldn't let me do it when I was little because it "cost too much". But now I never use change and it makes perfect sense.

  • @TelaranRogue
    @TelaranRogue 12 лет назад

    That's what I thought! I think they have a special clause exempting or extending the maximum duration for videos of an educational nature, since some important topics can only be compressed so much before they lose meaning or accuracy.

  • @ThatRyanD
    @ThatRyanD 11 лет назад

    That's really nice of you to say, thanks!

  • @pppvideos
    @pppvideos 11 лет назад

    every person in america should watch this video.
    I am officially a subscriber to the nerdfighters (I'm late to the party, I know). DFTBA!

  • @lizbub34
    @lizbub34 12 лет назад +1

    'And Greece.' made my day :D

  • @Tartar
    @Tartar 12 лет назад

    I can understand that people in America are probably living less healthy, smoke more, are obese and thus get cancer and heart diseases more often. But still you've got to admit that considering France offers universal healthcare for all, and America is just giving a discount to elderly, it's rather inefficient use of the money.

  • @atypicalamericangirl
    @atypicalamericangirl 11 лет назад

    ^_^ I love that you attacked this problem...or well, talked about it. You said it much better than I've ever been able to as well!

  • @ThatPoshGirl
    @ThatPoshGirl 12 лет назад

    You're my favorite explainer.

  • @NaviDoodlez
    @NaviDoodlez 11 лет назад

    "Politics is the art of looking for trouble, finding it everywhere, diagnosing it incorrectly, and applying the wrong remedies" -Groucho Marx

  • @therealdrag0
    @therealdrag0 12 лет назад

    More of these videos. Love it.

  • @ImYourGeek
    @ImYourGeek 11 лет назад

    John's awesomeness would be wasted in Congress.
    Not to mention, he wouldn't have time to make delightful vlogs for us.

  • @CaitieLou
    @CaitieLou 11 лет назад

    John: Sometimes I have to pause your videos for various reasons while watching them, but I feel bad about pausing because I'll often land on an unsavory still and I don't want some creepy distorted John face staring at me when I come back to the video. But sometimes when I find a decent freeze frame, but it's fuzzy because you move around so much. That bothers the animator/graphic designer in me so I can't tolerate those either.
    There isn't much you can do about that, I just thought I'd share.

  • @awatts1971
    @awatts1971 12 лет назад

    Nice job and thank you for clearing a lot of that up. Kudos!

  • @SuperiorStergeon
    @SuperiorStergeon 12 лет назад

    "Quick! Remove my gallbladder!" is going to be my new response to any small problem that I can't help with, but people come to me with anyway.

  • @lindsayrose2728
    @lindsayrose2728 11 лет назад

    my teacher tried to explain this to my class a few weeks ago, i had no idea what she was talking aobut even after an half hour..watching 6 minutes of this and its all clear

  • @michelegarrison3760
    @michelegarrison3760 12 лет назад

    He works in maintenance at a military building. He is a vet, with health problems and his wife is also a disabled vet who cannot work. this is literally taking food off of the table for them.

  • @perrymoorej
    @perrymoorej 12 лет назад

    'Sequester' the catch phrase of the year.

  • @Pegasusthewyze
    @Pegasusthewyze 12 лет назад

    The title definitely tricked me into thinking there was some specific provision in the sequester about the import/export of bananas.

  • @emilyylimethe
    @emilyylimethe 12 лет назад

    You should do videos like this about other countries too because it's getting to the point where I know more about american systems than my own country's! :)

  • @nachtEule19
    @nachtEule19 12 лет назад

    Yeah this is unfortunate. I'm about to graduate from college and go into the military, and it's looking like because of sequestration and budget cuts I'm either not going to go active duty for a year (having to get a meaningless in-between job in the meantime) or when I do go active duty I'll be trying to do the workload of 20 people with only 13 because we can't afford to hire more.... fabulous timing.

  • @Spraggette
    @Spraggette 12 лет назад

    As a non-American I think it would be great if John made a video explaining how the American government works. If the President doesn't have much (if at all) say in the creation of legislation, what do they actually do?

  • @recklesstenacity
    @recklesstenacity 12 лет назад

    LOL my mother had to learn to use the internet when I went away to college. One day, she called me up and went, "do i have email?" and i went, "no, i didn't send you anything." "no, but do i have an email? so i can send things?" "uh... yes. it comes with your internet services." "i don't think i have that." "mom, go click the little button that looks like an envelope." "oh hey! i have email!"

  • @joshmnky
    @joshmnky 11 лет назад

    NASA had an internal memo saying they're suspending all outreach and education activities. Naturally, the site is down now from traffic since it was on Reddit, and I can't read into it.
    I hope this doesn't effect the USLI competition I've been working on... FOR A YEAR.

  • @Nixillustrations
    @Nixillustrations 12 лет назад

    Ahh! That makes sense. I don't think that having less kids should be seen as a problem seeing as there are already too many people on this planet in relation to our wasteful lifestyles, but that really is a dilemma. Maybe instead of pushing up the retirement age or encouraging people to have more children, the cost of living needs to come down so that the budgets don't need to be as high.

  • @Qster1584
    @Qster1584 12 лет назад

    Missing the old Vlogbrothers set up where we got videos every other day. :( Wondering if the punishments are still in effect? Waiting for my Tuesday video. :)

  • @AlaskaFinal
    @AlaskaFinal 12 лет назад

    "Capital Gains are not taxed twice"
    I took a tax class for my accounting minor, yes they are.
    People invest in Corporations, and corporation's money is taxed at the corporate rate (38%). At that point, the investor's expected return on their investment, is lower than if the Government was not taxing said corporation.
    The money is then taxed AGAIN as they receive their return, in the form of Dividends (capital gains). So, their return on investment is not simply 14% lower, it's over 30% lower.

  • @Kitty2042
    @Kitty2042 12 лет назад

    I know you only just mentioned it, but either in Vlogbrothers or one of your many other channels, could you do a video summary on why Greece is in the economic situation it is. I have various discussions/debates on why Greece is in the position it is in right now with my family and friends and it would be interesting to hear your reasons.

  • @HabeebaHusain
    @HabeebaHusain 12 лет назад

    Wow, I actually understood that. Thank you, John!

  • @rbmcgillicuddy
    @rbmcgillicuddy 12 лет назад

    I was lectured by my father (who is a government employee) about this literally 12 hours ago and how it's illegal for them to strike. They are being force to take one day off a week without pay for 22 weeks. And they can't strike. Damn you Congress!

  • @LPersFromNowhere
    @LPersFromNowhere 12 лет назад

    He's the older brother. He's allowed to rewrite the rules to ensure his victory.
    -Rinion

  • @MacroAggressor
    @MacroAggressor 8 лет назад +1

    I didn't make the connection that you wrote The Fault In Our Stars. Fine work sir, thank you.

  • @chocolatecigar1
    @chocolatecigar1 12 лет назад

    "It's over Rock. Nothing on Earth is going to save you now" "Nothins over, just give me sometin to drink."

  • @georgias2125
    @georgias2125 12 лет назад

    omfg just finished the fault in our stars and you emotionally scarred me