At t = 00:45, presenting an improved example with an hour range of from 1 to 24, when using a 24H hour option ... And for extra irony, referring to R33 about _appropriate_ range *sigh*
Agree in real life this requirement would not be needed. Sarah's point was to use it as an example for appropriate range within the 7 examples so had to stretch things a little.
@@incoserwg891 It's toy examples, I understand, but I think there's a risk that inexperienced requirement authors look at such examples and try to emulate them. And to top it off, the example is incorrect (1 ... 24 instead of 0 .. 23). :-( I think there's a real need for good (and bad) examples of requirements, beyond the toy level...
At t = 00:45, presenting an improved example with an hour range of from 1 to 24, when using a 24H hour option ... And for extra irony, referring to R33 about _appropriate_ range *sigh*
Agree in real life this requirement would not be needed. Sarah's point was to use it as an example for appropriate range within the 7 examples so had to stretch things a little.
@@incoserwg891 It's toy examples, I understand, but I think there's a risk that inexperienced requirement authors look at such examples and try to emulate them. And to top it off, the example is incorrect (1 ... 24 instead of 0 .. 23). :-(
I think there's a real need for good (and bad) examples of requirements, beyond the toy level...