애들 완전 애기잖앜ㅋㅠㅠㅠㅠㅠㅋㅋㅋ 민석이 모자 뺏는것도 귀엽고ㅠㅠ 애들 볼살도 귀엽고 완전 늑대 멋있다 생각했는데 지금 보니까 완전 애기 늑대ㅜㅋㅋㅋ 경수 카메라 쳐다보는것도 원래 저렇게 쳐다봤었구나 싶고 저때는 다 처음이고 덕질하는것도 모르는거 많고 다 새로웠는데 지금은 커뮤만 해도 몇개나 하고있고 어쩌다 이렇게 됐나 진짜 신기하다ㅋㅋㅋㅋ 한때 어딜가든 들려오고 스밍까지 진짜 많이 질릴것같이 들었던 노래라 콘서트 말고는 따로 찾아 듣지 않았는데 지금 들으니까 질리는 느낌도 없고 되게 새로워서 신기하다 애들도 나도 나이가 좀 들긴 했구나 새삼 실감나고ㅎ 생각이 많아지고 일부러 ㅌㅇㅌ나 커뮤니티를 잘 안들어갔던 요즘인데 지금 이 영상 보니까 그래도 내가 아직 엑소를 많이 좋아하구나 싶네 지금은 그냥 딱히 바라는거 없고 그냥 오래 봤으면 좋겠다 모두가 엑소를 소중히 생각했으면..!
I Love LIVE performances, even if they sound tired it's the fact they are dancing while needing to sing AND breath. Great Job EXO I would enjoy more performances like this. HWAITING!
Luhan's cuteness and voice literally turns me to jelly. Kai just wrecks by bias by one look (not including his voice and dance moves). Kris and Tao looks so coooool >.< They must have a lot of trouble with singing and dancing at the same time, but their still awesome XD
G Kin Ahn brcc yes muscally Mars murloc Lynn MA yes okay mui NGO gai what but also see yes must go anymore so maybe also set up I'm more green ran MGM Cleveland yes Super Buffet look away yes yeah yeah yeah yes cook up about Facebook I'm not talked to Karen retriever Norman mom Mass hello mine mahalo she will pick you up Mass Mazda I'll be okay okay
When i started to watch and knew EXO by their names few months ago. D.O remains as my top bias since then until now. Followed by Xiu and Suho. But the member at the bottom of my Bias list is climbing up and starting to become my bias wrecker. Why o Why Chen!! From # 12, you're number 4 now in my list
I think I prefer if they lip-sync. The boys can sing, of course they can! They wouldn't been accepted in SM if they couldn't. but its the fact that they are DANCING! and will constantly run out of breath, which is why it is in fact so hard to sing live for them when they have dance numbers. They have to focus on their voice while dancing? that's really difficult and often leads to mistakes, like when their mind focuses on one part and forgets about the other one. So for EXO's sake let them relax and lip-sync, look just how tired they seem.
But it's a LIVE performance . It's not meant to be a perfect performance with no crack in voices , no off pitch . If it's live , then it must be performed at THAT point of time and not use pre-recorded . Because that'll be deceiving the audience . I prefer this live over the others that i've seen because they're so true and .. i just feel different when i compare this with other live that are pre-recorded .
But the problem is all boy groups have to dance so you can't say that it's hard for exo to sing live because it's hard for all the groups that sing live. That's what their training is for. If groups like infinite can nail it exo can do it if they want to. You could even argue that okay let's let them lip sync for music programs but for them to only sing 5 of their songs live at their concert was just rude
You're right obviously Exo is talented but they need to be able to sing and dance live. There are other groups like Shinee, Infinite, Beast and so on that manage to sing live really good although they have a difficult choreos. It's part of the kpop business.
now it's 2017 but when I look these old shows it's like omg I wonder how they shocked people from the beginning, like "they're all visual af, can sing and dance really good"
Am I the only one that prefer THIS?! NO LIP-SYNC?? Finally found one that sounds like no lip-sync AT ALL. I love to hear something different from the recording. I love to hear how their voice doesn't sound perfect when they need to dance at the same time. This proves they can still sing really well when they're dancing. But I agree it's reasonable for them to lip-sync sometimes since they really seem tired. I also want to see more natural smiles. I'm too greedy haha.
I used to be an EXO L but not anymore. Today I came across this video and it reminded so much about those old days that I used to love EXO so much and watched every Growl performances lol, the feeling is the same and I still remember when the fandom didn't have a name so we called ourselves EXOtics haha. Kinda got surprised that I could still sing along while watching. Anyways everyone changed, the members did, old fans still stay but some left and new fans are joining all the time. But I still treasure the time when I binge watched them and stuff. For those who want to know why I quit, it's because whenever I watch these old videos, I think that I only like the old EXO, not the present EXO anymore.
TO HATERS .you didn't want them to lipsynic and sing while dancing and here it is they sound great without lipsync of course not like the mv and all kpop groups don't sing perfectly live . so if u didn't like their singing live you r just hating on them cause probably they r more famous than your bias group. to us exo L just seeing them healthy is enough for us
hahahaha this performance is so funny, im supposed to be daunted coz all of them looked so tired... but i find it cute and adorable!!! hahaha xiumin's sweat!!! and grrrr suho is just a good-hot mess!! hahahaha and d.o's part was like he was more on shouting than hitting the high notes hahaha really funny!!! #exofighting
Развлечения![(ENGsub)[쇼! 챔피언] EXO - Growl, 엑소 - 으르렁, Show Champion 20130904](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/GoOyYcwvdPQ/mqdefault.jpg)
![(ENGsub)[쇼! 챔피언] EXO - Growl, 엑소 - 으르렁, Show Champion 20130904](/img/tr.png)
![(ENGsub)[쇼!음악중심] EXO - Growl, 엑소 - 으르렁, Music core 20130831](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/DQSfUWJb5XI/mqdefault.jpg)
변백현 썸네일 뭔데ㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋ 아 진짜 애기엑소... 정말 사랑했어... 지금도ㅎ
i miss how the stage looked too small for them ;-;
Luhan and Kris are damn handsome 😍😍😍
But they're not in EXO again ;((
+Meisyca Tjong They aren't wait what
+toast Both of them left during Overdose ERA.
나 혹시 몰라경고하는데 잘들어~! 같ㅇㅣ 외치던 학생에리가 나혹시 몰라경고하는데 잔들어~! 를 외치는 직딩에리가 되었읍니다,,,, 세월아,,,,
썸넬 졸귀야 진짜아ㅠㅠㅠㅠㅠㅠ
SM Entertainment get your shit together & bring back Exo 12.
Can we all agree that Lay is the Hyoyeon of EXO? So underrated.
bendehoyos18 I fucking agree
yesss
@@piacassandraparra6562 a
What is hyoyeon mean?
kim hany She’s in SNSD/Girls Generation
Watching this on 2019. Oh my god exo fetus
애들 완전 애기잖앜ㅋㅠㅠㅠㅠㅠㅋㅋㅋ 민석이 모자 뺏는것도 귀엽고ㅠㅠ 애들 볼살도 귀엽고 완전 늑대 멋있다 생각했는데 지금 보니까 완전 애기 늑대ㅜㅋㅋㅋ 경수 카메라 쳐다보는것도 원래 저렇게 쳐다봤었구나 싶고 저때는 다 처음이고 덕질하는것도 모르는거 많고 다 새로웠는데 지금은 커뮤만 해도 몇개나 하고있고 어쩌다 이렇게 됐나 진짜 신기하다ㅋㅋㅋㅋ 한때 어딜가든 들려오고 스밍까지 진짜 많이 질릴것같이 들었던 노래라 콘서트 말고는 따로 찾아 듣지 않았는데 지금 들으니까 질리는 느낌도 없고 되게 새로워서 신기하다 애들도 나도 나이가 좀 들긴 했구나 새삼 실감나고ㅎ 생각이 많아지고 일부러 ㅌㅇㅌ나 커뮤니티를 잘 안들어갔던 요즘인데 지금 이 영상 보니까 그래도 내가 아직 엑소를 많이 좋아하구나 싶네 지금은 그냥 딱히 바라는거 없고 그냥 오래 봤으면 좋겠다 모두가 엑소를 소중히 생각했으면..!
March 2016.
I miss Luhan and Kris so much :((
Me too just Luhan
+Mai Nguyen y a tao tmb:c awwww!
+BigBang Lover Los extraño a todos :,(
igual yo:c
Mai Nguyen Now It's Tao :(
Omg Minseok is more cute than maknae line, he's look like a baby
I feel like Sehun looks pissed in all performances lol
I choked 😂
Distribution
Exo-K =40%
Exo-M =7%
Baekhyun= 53%
😂😂😂
3명의 둘기들 모자이크 안되나... 엑소 다 아가다ㅋㅋㅋ 졸귀야
내가 지금 저때 엑소멤버들 나이라니....ㅠㅠ
They sang 100% live beautifully and they were still rookies what a kings
I Love LIVE performances, even if they sound tired it's the fact they are dancing while needing to sing AND breath. Great Job EXO I would enjoy more performances like this. HWAITING!
luhan had the cutest top! suit him!
Baekhyun has the same shirt. >.< Who suits the shirt more?
Annie AnHong Wu luhan ... for me :)
lol, i think so too
Annie AnHong Wu hahahahaha yea .. !
=.= yay for luhan
D.O.I missing you so I watching you.
i love sehun beakhyun and luhan
no lipsync 😁😁😁 their vioce are really good
Love the live performance, but the boys seem terribly tired.
It's ok they all the best for me
But the 3 main vocals is still legit tho, still managed to sound direct from CD
2016 still watching，I miss Kris Luhan and Tao.
D.O (Kyungsoo)
Tao and Sehun's hair
i miss how many they were in stage
Kai's smile and Xiumin's eyes are poison to me.
luhan oppa, i miss you so much
0:03 My Bias TAO was so handsome so much.I like his hair so very colorful..
WE ARE EXO WE ARE ONE!!
EXOTICS FOREVER... SARANGHAEYO EXO ♥♥♥
kai looked so fuckin good here omg
***** ikr omg
of cause kai always being perfect in all his songs
其實每次看到tao的綠髮都有點心疼
他年紀還這麼輕就一直這樣染髮
Tao不染頭髮你還是一樣帥的
在我們心中你永遠都是那個最棒最讚最帥的澡澡貓
I love u tao
It's been the end of 2020 and I'm stucking in OT12
Baekhyun so cute!!!
Kai at the beginning tho.. *flips the universe*
그래 이게 찐이지 말 더 필요 없다 내 학창시절의 전부라면 전부 일단 저 엑소케이/엑소엠 응원법 모르는 사람이 이상한거였자나 ㅎㅎ
Luhan's cuteness and voice literally turns me to jelly.
Kai just wrecks by bias by one look (not including his voice and dance moves).
Kris and Tao looks so coooool >.<
They must have a lot of trouble with singing and dancing at the same time, but their still awesome XD
2016 who's still watching this? aarghh I'm so miss them (ot12) Luhan , Kris , Tao
love u yixing!!
G Kin Ahn brcc yes muscally Mars murloc Lynn MA yes okay mui NGO gai what but also see yes must go anymore so maybe also set up I'm more green ran MGM Cleveland yes Super Buffet look away yes yeah yeah yeah yes cook up about Facebook I'm not talked to Karen retriever Norman mom Mass hello mine mahalo she will pick you up Mass Mazda I'll be okay okay
Huiyan Tham wut
2018
2019!
2021
Ugh Kai....
Sehun's hair are amazing!
Xiumin is sweating all the sweat for the rest of 11 members.
여기까지 온 에리들 있을까
When i started to watch and knew EXO by their names few months ago. D.O remains as my top bias since then until now. Followed by Xiu and Suho. But the member at the bottom of my Bias list is climbing up and starting to become my bias wrecker. Why o Why Chen!! From
# 12, you're number 4 now in my list
Baekhyun oppa looks like a baby here...soooo cute
Luhan and Kai and Sehun 😭👬💞👌
I AM SO ATTRACTED TO KAI WHEN HE SINGS HIS PART IN GROWL WTF
와 나 지금 35살인데 이게 11년 전이라니 진짜 시간 너무 빠르다진따
*1:10** Kyungsoo with red hair will always be my favorite Kyungsoo's hair color. D.O. with red hair= death of me* 😍😍😍
I just love noticing Baekhyun trying to fix his hair every time Xiumin takes the hat off him, it's literally the cutest thing :)
MY GOLDWN DAYS 😭😭😭😭
baekhyun and luhan always cute even when they're singing.
BWCW!!!!
BWCW - KRIS
growl era teaser - CHANYEOL
MUSIC CORE - CHEN
OMO!!! soooo legit
sehun's poker face makes me alive till this day
VOCAL KINGS SINCE DAY 1
1st time I see this live perf w/o the school uniforms... great, better with live. Luhanie so cute, Kai, I prefer u with black hair
I miis you Baekhyun,chanyeol,d.o,and Suho 😘😘💓💕
Xiumin: *gets baekhyuns cap*
Baekhyun:Wtf wheres my cap
0:44
1:46 it sounded like Chanyeol just said "fuck it" 😂😂😜
Divya Tulsi Omg True
Divya Tulsi OMG
Divya Tulsi True！
lol😂
Trueeeee
I think I prefer if they lip-sync. The boys can sing, of course they can! They wouldn't been accepted in SM if they couldn't. but its the fact that they are DANCING! and will constantly run out of breath, which is why it is in fact so hard to sing live for them when they have dance numbers.
They have to focus on their voice while dancing? that's really difficult and often leads to mistakes, like when their mind focuses on one part and forgets about the other one.
So for EXO's sake let them relax and lip-sync, look just how tired they seem.
But it's a LIVE performance . It's not meant to be a perfect performance with no crack in voices , no off pitch . If it's live , then it must be performed at THAT point of time and not use pre-recorded . Because that'll be deceiving the audience . I prefer this live over the others that i've seen because they're so true and .. i just feel different when i compare this with other live that are pre-recorded .
But the problem is all boy groups have to dance so you can't say that it's hard for exo to sing live because it's hard for all the groups that sing live. That's what their training is for. If groups like infinite can nail it exo can do it if they want to. You could even argue that okay let's let them lip sync for music programs but for them to only sing 5 of their songs live at their concert was just rude
You're right obviously Exo is talented but they need to be able to sing and dance live. There are other groups like Shinee, Infinite, Beast and so on that manage to sing live really good although they have a difficult choreos. It's part of the kpop business.
Have you seen SHINee performing live? lol
Anyways; Not trying to be offensive but maybe they wanted to try singing live. xD
Ya shinee's performances are just as intense and they still sing live! And remember dbsk? They rarley lip-synced
woah chen singing the high notes and adlibs even while dancing!
june 2016 and still can't move on from growl :'(
Baekhyun ♥️♥️
now it's 2017 but when I look these old shows it's like omg I wonder how they shocked people from the beginning, like "they're all visual af, can sing and dance really good"
I feel like watching street boy perfomance while kris being the rich heir that hanging out with them(based on their outfit)
Watching this again and again makes me cry..
baekhyun is so cute😙😙
Kaiiiiiiii
Growl is unforgettable... It's always queen.
Sehun does the "shh" sign better than the pretty little liars ladies :)))
썸넬 너뮤 귀엽고 ...
Luhaaaaaaen!!!😝
Luhan + koala shirt
Bless the soul of the stylist
I love Tao's energy in these performances
Am I the only one that prefer THIS?! NO LIP-SYNC?? Finally found one that sounds like no lip-sync AT ALL. I love to hear something different from the recording. I love to hear how their voice doesn't sound perfect when they need to dance at the same time. This proves they can still sing really well when they're dancing. But I agree it's reasonable for them to lip-sync sometimes since they really seem tired. I also want to see more natural smiles. I'm too greedy haha.
Baekhyun is very handsome and cute
엑소사랑해♥♥
Growl이라는 노래를 너무 좋아해서 방금 이 노래 뮤직비디오를 봤는데 단원들이 서로 모자를 가지고 쓰고 있어서 너무 귀여워요.😁😁😁😁😁
Baekhyun looked so cute
d.o and kai is Very handsome and cute
와 라이브네..
This song is still so catchy even after so many months *.* but Haiz Krissss
Kai know thats he so cute and hot when he smirk.. aooouuuccchhhh my heart
수호 너무 사랑해용!
Fetus EXO make me wanna cry 😢
I used to be an EXO L but not anymore. Today I came across this video and it reminded so much about those old days that I used to love EXO so much and watched every Growl performances lol, the feeling is the same and I still remember when the fandom didn't have a name so we called ourselves EXOtics haha. Kinda got surprised that I could still sing along while watching. Anyways everyone changed, the members did, old fans still stay but some left and new fans are joining all the time. But I still treasure the time when I binge watched them and stuff. For those who want to know why I quit, it's because whenever I watch these old videos, I think that I only like the old EXO, not the present EXO anymore.
Miss you Kris and Luhan..
2016, still watching! Hahahaha 😍😍😍😂❤️ Wow! Sehun is so hot! Tho. his hair! Btw, i really miss Tao, Kris, and Luhan 😭😭😔😢
i want luhans sweater its f cute
miss u luhan and kris
Baekhyun and Luhan couple wear 😂😂💙💙
shhhh...quiet,you will hurt chanyeol's feelings..
M Seo ha ha couple
TO HATERS .you didn't want them to lipsynic and sing while dancing and here it is they sound great without lipsync of course not like the mv and all kpop groups don't sing perfectly live . so if u didn't like their singing live you r just hating on them cause probably they r more famous than your bias group. to us exo L just seeing them healthy is enough for us
Chen is definitely the biggest fan of BWCW
Luhan and suhun look handsome 😍😍😍 I'm in 2018
Omg I love their hairstyles and Luhan your just too perfect that hair that shirt omg FAB
Funny how in the beginning when I started listening to them, I thought Luhan and Sehun were brothers or were the other person.
my favourite stage for growl promotions this far because i can hear their voices clearly
엑소 으르렁!
hahahaha this performance is so funny, im supposed to be daunted coz all of them looked so tired... but i find it cute and adorable!!! hahaha xiumin's sweat!!! and grrrr suho is just a good-hot mess!! hahahaha and d.o's part was like he was more on shouting than hitting the high notes hahaha really funny!!! #exofighting
Those fan girls are no joke!
I love Luhan's face
potangina sa last part inamo kai!!! 😍😍
HOW I MISS THAT RAINBOW-HAIR GUY OVER THAT STAGE! UGGHH! SARANGHAJA EXO!