Neuroscientist Answers Illusion Questions From Twitter | Tech Support | WIRED
HTML-код
- Опубликовано: 9 май 2024
- Pascal Wallisch, NYU Professor of Psychology and Data Science, answers the internet's burning questions about illusions. What is motion-induced blindness? How do mirages happen? What's the explanation for "The Dress"? How did they make the Tupac hologram? Pascal answers all these questions and much more!
For more on these illusions: www.foxlabnyu.com/techsupport...
Director: Justin Wolfson
Director of Photography: Brad Wickham
Editor: Joshua Pullar
Expert: Pascal Wallisch
Line Producer: Joseph Buscemi
Producer: Justin Wolfson
Associate Producer: Paul Gulyas
Production Manager: Eric Martinez
Production Coordinator: Fernando Davila
Camera Operator: Claudio Corredor
Sound: Brett Van Deusen
Production Assistant: Ralphy Vasquez
Post Production Supervisor: Alexa Deutsch
Post Production Coordinator: Ian Bryant
Supervising Editor: Doug Larsen
Assistant Editor: Paul Tael
Still haven’t subscribed to WIRED on RUclips? ►► wrd.cm/15fP7B7
Listen to the Get WIRED podcast ►► link.chtbl.com/wired-ytc-desc
Want more WIRED? Get the magazine ►► subscribe.wired.com/subscribe...
Follow WIRED:
Instagram ►► / wired
Twitter ►► / wired
Facebook ►► / wired
Get more incredible stories on science and tech with our daily newsletter: wrd.cm/DailyYT
Also, check out the free WIRED channel on Roku, Apple TV, Amazon Fire TV, and Android TV.
ABOUT WIRED
WIRED is where tomorrow is realized. Through thought-provoking stories and videos, WIRED explores the future of business, innovation, and culture. 
Хобби
Thanks for having me on the show. Hopefully, it was sufficiently interesting/helpful.
Very well done. You have a lot of fans in the comments, including many former students; that says a lot! They should have you back.
It was extremely so! Thank you for all the insights!!
It was really fun, thanks dude.
You are amazing! Thank you. I hope you do a second video!
Your segment was fascinating. I’ve always been curious about the illusions you discussed but now I have an understanding. You did a wonderful job at explaining scientific topics in such an easy-to-understand manner. And your humor was a bonus!
This guy is so good at this, he's actually wearing a red plaid shirt.
I was going to reply on the other comment but it got deleted. Those are bots. They go through comment section and copy a comment so they look like like a real person, in hopes you go to their profile and follow links to scam pages. Also, your comment was hilarious!
Hahaha
It's not red, it's actually blue and black😂 or is it white and gold🙄🥴
Is it really a plaid shirt?? I mean there's no pattern 🤷 I'm really not sure on the terminology
looks like corduroy to me
My guy treated it like a speedrun while still being incredibly informative and concise. Thanks so much!
“Our brains are immodest” is a great phrase
Pascal!! The best professor I had at NYU! Can’t express in words how happy I am to see him in-front of more eyes. The best of the best
This man strikes me as one of the most intelligent I have ever seen in any context. And i have personally met a number of the most important theoretical physicists alive
haha in front of more eyes u say
@@quarkraven Well his answer to the Moon question was wrong. I'm sure he knows more about the brain than astronomy though.
@@HeroesBossesit is not wrong. He states that the reasons are not entirely known or agreed upon, and he states his favorite explanation. That is as correct an answer as you could give as far as I am aware.
I was just going to say his students must feel lucky.
"I'm taking psych next semester because Pascal's class is full."
I like how he said he was going to ruin ducks for everyone and then made them 10x better.
Hmmm I've tried like 4 times and I can't quite figure out what he means by 'dog masks'. I'm not seeing it. Interesting to think that some of you out there could immediately see the 'dog mask' once he pointed it out
You have to look at the duck's bill. The tip looks like a dog nose, the two points furthest back look like dog ears, and the nostrils look like the dog's eyes. It kind of reminds me of a corgi.
I watched the whole video and don’t remember anything about ducks, despite waiting for it. Anybody have the time stamp?
@@BrainyCrafter He attempts to ruin our lives at 18:57
@@gelatinguyomg AHAHAHA I love it
I could never see the dress as black and blue until this video. I guess him holding up the dress first fixed my brain for a couple seconds and I could see the image as black and blue. Then half a second later I remembered what the white and gold "version" in my head looked like and it changed back to white and gold immediately. But now I can kinda trick my brain into seeing it as black and blue and it's the coolest thing I've ever seen.
I saw 1) light blue and 2) dark gold 😩
I think one time I was able to trick my brain into seeing white and gold, but only for a brief second, and I haven't been able to get that version back.
I think it starts with convincing my brain that the top of the dress's black part is actually gold, in a sepia-like filter or something. But I just can't do it again apparently lol
I have never and do not see white and gold. It makes zero sense to me. All this time I also believed that anyone who said they saw white and gold were just saying that to be artificially different and seem interesting.
i am a black/blue person and a night owl (so that makes sense!) and i always was reminded of the way white and blue can change with bad lighting and bad cameras, so i assumed it was some case of automatic brain color correction for the white/gold people. and it seems like it was and i wish he would have explained the morning/night person thing a bit more in detail. but it makes sense that the white/gold people with the help of this video can see the black/blue, but the black/blue people cannot see the white/gold. because why would they color correct a picture, if they already see the correct version! i am wondering now in what other situations the morning/night people see differently.
@@o0Donuts0o In other words, you not only instantly disregarded other people's experiences because they were different than your own, but chose to demonize those with different experiences than you?
What a delight you must be.
Came for the dress, stayed for the knowledge. This was awesome 🙌🏾
Same
One of my favorite instructors of all time. When I was a student at NYU, I took his sensation and perception class and it altered my entire life trajectory. Watching this was a fantastic reminder of how efficiently he communicates these sometimes dense concepts merely by exuding his palpable passion about how insightful these illusions can be with regards to the way the brain is creating models of external inputs.
I took his perception class and advanced psych stats. Man is a polymath. He taught coding and a course on psychopathy as well. I tried twice to get into the psychopathy course but was snubbed both times!
really? i thought he was actually terrible at explaining multiple times throughout this vid. where what he said was a complete abstract with no context, that you couldn't possibly understand unless you already know about it
@@R0DSTER This may be a bigger indictment of your abilities than his... but I concede that he may come off as a bit flight-of-thought-ish in his explanations.
@@R0DSTER he was quite intelligible to me. seems like a you problem
@@R0DSTER I know nothing about this stuff and thought he explained everything wonderfully.
Love how he is willing to admit that there are things we still don't know. Definitely am important thing to communicate: there are always more things to discover
Psychology in general is still an extremely new field of science when compared to every other field of science.
Agreed! All proper scientists will, and should!
The most beloved Psychology Professor at NYU. WE STAN PASCAL
I came for the dress question but found myself engrossed in this ENTIRE video! I loved this way of explaining it so it’s easy to understand.
This should be a series... like the one with the body language guy. The man knows his stuff.
it is lol . its one of their biggest series that makes the channell famous
the one with a hacker is great
these guys in the videos are all professionals, they all know their stuff
@@polanski2399 OK, Mr. Obvious.
Joe Navarro
I wish these episodes were an hour long of these experts sharing their knowledge, I can never get enough of them!
This particular guest reminds of watching the show Brain Games back in the day.
May I recommend the podcast Ologies? Similar concept, longer format. I recommend the episode about bats
This was the best episode ever. This professor was the best at breaking it down and not making me feel like I either NEED a PHD to understand nor need a nappy time afterwards.
20:40 this is why some stores have bigger shopping carts, people tend to buy more when they don't think they're buying that much.
well... there's also the obvious reason, which is that you can fit more stuff in there.
I have ALWAYS seen the dress as black & blue. Never understood how anyone could see different. To find out only night owls see black & blue is really interesting because I am an EXTREME night owl with a severe circadian rhythm sleep disorder.
Thank you for such a fascinating vid. I'd like to see more like this.
My 5 yr old daughter saw that dress as white and yellow, while me i saw it black and blue ,too and yes i am a night owl🤣🤣
I’m a night owl and see it yellow and white but I used to see it as black and blue so I was confused when I saw it again and changed colours
OMG I JUST SAW IT AGAIN AND SWITCHED AGIAN WTF IS BRAIN
i also thought that it might have related to the exterior lighting, i.e. daylight/nightlight, which would influence the brightness of the phonescreen, which could affect the result
This blew my mind too bc I have never seen gold and white too!!!
had him as my prof last sem for my data science class. hands down, he is one of the best at NYU. his passion for teaching and learning shines through in every second.
On the blue dress part: Interesting that when the actual dress was in the shot, I saw the dress as black and blue, but when it cut to a close up it flipped to white and gold. So cool. And I love that fact about morning or night people! That explains so much.
Fascinating video! Thanks so much for all this really cool information.
Wait, for real? When it cut to a closeup as he was holding the actual dress, or of the infamous photo? Thanks!
I can tell this guy has a lot of information in his head because he talks really fast AND slow because he knows it all but has to actually explain it slow enough for us to take the information in. I could listen to him for hours
My eyes lit up seeing Pascal in this video. I took two classes with him at NYU and they were delightful. He somehow made advanced statistics interesting and had such a bright and vibrant personality! His research on psychopaths and music is fascinating. Love seeing you doing well, Pascal! 😊
i love how deliberate scientists are with word choices . they use the best possible word for the context and its verry satisfying as a person with aspergers. no misscomunications for once .
Science people got us!! Great choice of words and always happy to answer questions if something isn't clear, it's like a dream come true
Speaking as a research engineer, I'm glad they are precise. Definitions matter (and can be difficult) and finding the boundary between two different things is part of what they do. I got an English degree so my instincts are for hyperbole. It helps my writing be relatable but I have to have that precision to keep me in line so that I can communicate well.
this was one of the more engaging "expert" sessions I've seen. Our brains are freaky!
I always asked my Physics teachers and adults in general as to why things like fidget spinners and tops spin in reverse at times and they were dismissive of my questions and said that it was not true. I thought the "wagon wheel illusion" as I know now, was something that happened exclusively to me. Finally got the answer to one of the most intriguing of my childhood queries.
P.S. I loved watching tops spin, and fans and in general anything in rotational motion for this very reason, I still do.
It makes me really happy that people in the comments had a good time in his class 🥺
I had him for three classes! He really is a gifted lecturer. He always made himself available to anyone
@@dfxgdg you guys have to stop. Making me jealous that I will never meet or be taught by what seems to be a fantastic teacher.
I really like that this episode wasn't as 'dumbed down' as some of the other ones. I understand there is real value in making a show like this accessible, but in that process there is often a loss of actual information, which wasn't true to the same extent for this one
Yeah! He managed to explain everything in a simple way that doesn't feel like he's dumbing down!
💯
exactly. there are ways to explain concepts to people who arent specialized in a field without just taking out the smart. simplifying shouldnt laways be dumbing it down
Agreed! (Sorry if this is Karen-ish, but awareness is important...let's try not to use the word dumb, even in quotes, as it is a slur against those who cannot speak...and although we don't mean it maliciously, it is a shot against ❤)
One interesting illusion I've experienced first hand was sitting in a room with dark green curtains on a sunny day and suddenly noticing everything outside that room looked kind of pink. So probably what happened there was my brain subconsciously adjusted to see colors "normally" in a room strongly lit by green light and also applied that adaptation to things that were not in the same green light environment, instead lit by white lamp light.
that dress picture still blows my mind. if i squint hard enough, i can see the black and blue, but not if i'm looking regularly. i've had insomnia since i was 16 so i don't sleep very well and usually end up awake all night and i never saw black and blue
I would like to spend my life being surrounded by people like this. I swear no subject or topic would ever be boring.
In college, I worked in a vision psychology labs which dealt with all the stuff in this vid and more. Many people I met would find it interesting but also annoying for "ruining it" or "taking the fun out of it" lol especially when I told them the answer for the blue or gold dress when pic came out
Get a job at a uni!
There was a saying, forget who, said, if you think you are the smartest person in the room, you're in the wrong room. Or something to that effect. Surrounding yourself with intellectual and intelligent people is always a good idea
WIRED really finds the absolute best people to do these videos. I always enjoy all of them.
I'm glad that you mentioned artists in the line illusion because when I first saw the illusion years ago I was quick to figure out that all the lines are the same length and I assumed it was because I'm a professional graphic designer
He is such a professor professor like if someone told me to imagine a professor I'd have conjured him before I ever saw him.
love this guy already - this is one of the more informative tech support episodes.
Oh great, one of these *ssh*l*s who educates the Derren Brown/David Blaine/Chris Angel non-Catholic involuntary lobotomy and induced narcolepsy club. F*ck this *ssh*l* and his f*ck*ng Imaginary degree!
seems like a wholesome character that Fred Armisen could play
yeah! very wholesome + instant crush
This guy confidence and how he KNOWS about what he's talking about is astonishing. Even he prepare the controversial dress and matrix glasses, lmao. Great man.
Easily one of the most interesting episodes of tech support, Professor Wallisch also seems super interesting
I really surprisingly enjoyed this. So many of the things covered here, I've always wondered about. Great video.
More neuroscientists/neuropsychologist pleaseee! Just freaking fascinating
Edit: can we stop with the red plaid shirt joke 😒
why is it a joke it looks nice.
Yeah I love red, it's fine
Oh my god this guy is a gifted teacher. What a pleasure that was to watch. Please please please bring him back for more videos.
I love the way he talks. As a psychology student i rarely have lecturers who i enjoy listening to. But I'd love to go to his lectures
Thank you, Professor! I'm still trying to learn more about my brain AND you gave me six facts that I had never heard or known before. Clearly there's a reason why Socrates never wrote anything down AND why Plato wrote in dialogues & dialectics. You also helped enrich my understanding of Plato's Allegory of the Cave - the foundation of the MATRIX film franchise.
This guy is amazing, you can tell he has soo much to say just by him talking soo fast and trying to fit his thoughts in the words. Great episode!
Pascal is very good at this. Fantastic instructor. I especially like that he didn't try to over explain and take the joy out of it. He didn't say "It's not trippy because..." He says "It IS trippy, and here is WHY...". Well done.
i could tell right away how quickly Pascal blinks, as if in his mind he's trying to recall info so quickly while explaining stuff, kinda like an instant buffering, don't mean it in a bad way tho, but it's quite fascinating 'cause i tend to do the same as well
This was genuinely one of the most interesting videos I've seen in a very long time.
Pascal is amazing! Let's just appreciate his effort of bringing props which made the comprehension easier. Would love to see him in more videos!
The face detection bias isn't only about enemies. We also crucially need others for connection, interaction, cooperation, protection. So, detecting faces, even at the risk of sometimes of sometimes "overdetecting" is also essential in a supportive way, not only a defensive.
It's also one of the first complex tricks we learn. We've been doing it all day every day since we were just weeks old.
it is ol' reliable
@@elkikex I saw on a vsauce short that there's evidence we do it Before being born.
You can actually see this man visualize things in his head and it's amazing to watch!
this is officially my favourite video on yt
I could listen to this fantastic man all day long! We need more of him, if he'd be so kind to want to show up again.
i dropped a Sensation and Perception course last fall bc i didn’t realize that meant it would be neuroscience (they didn’t have many prerequisites yet as it was a new class), so this is a nice casual coverage of the neuroscience behind optical & visual illusions! i’m glad i saw this video & thanks to the professor!
I would love to hear an explanation on how aphantasia works, since I have it. I heard most people can imagine visual images, and I can't at all, so I would love to know why my brain doesn't do that.
This was one of the best of these Wired Support videos.
Loved this guy.
You can definitely tell that he’s a true expert in his field.
This is amazing and I love the detail for explaining what's happening in each instance. The simplest overview I've heard about some of these is "your brain is smart, your eyes are dumb".
This AP Psych teacher is thrilled to see this video being put out there! Hooray for Sensation and Perception!
An interesting effect of the motion blindess one I noticed. I got the described effect when looking at the moving image, but also, after it left the screen, I was still seeing afterimages of the 3 dots for a few seconds. Even though I was never looking directly at them.
I have NEVER been able to see white and gold in my life. When he was moving the printed picture around, I feel like I could for split-seconds at a time. Also, I am a night owl, like he says. Neat!
What about the thumbnail for the video? In that, I saw it as very light blue and bronze. But in the video itself, the actual dress on his desk looked clearly dark blue and black, whereas the images he showed were more like a sky blue and brown. (At least, that how I saw it.) Admittedly, when this phenomenon was all the craze a decade ago, I saw it as blue and black sometimes, and at other times, a very, very pale (almost white) blue and gold or light brown. Sometimes I was looking at the exact same image, but in one instance, it would appear one way and on another instance, it would appear as the other. The funny thing was that once I looked, looked away, and looked back at it, it's appearance always remained the same. It was only if I completely went on to something else and stopped thinking about it, but then saw it again, it would look the other way.
I never saw the white and gold and thought it was a joke. I feel so satisfied knowing I’ve been right this entire time the dress actually is black and blue. I believe using technology my entire life allows me to see what’s real vs fake
I recently came across the dress photo. I saw it twice in the same day but the color changed. I noticed my blue light filter was on when I re-viewed the photo. Turning on/off the blue light night mode made the dress change between black/blue to gold/silver at a push of the button. This likely factored in on people viewing the dress when it went viral.
It's just massively over exposed photo with 2700k lights... I put it on photoshop, make some minor tweaks and it looks just like the dress he has in the studio. Perhaps the white/gold people don't have the ability to process color like that... hence the "night vision" my brain just tells me... it's too light, so in the dark it's blue & black.
I'm completely the opposite. I still cannot see the picture as anything other than a white and gold dress even after years of knowing the actual dress is blue and black
Really good video! Would love a part two
more with him please! i love this
One of my favourite episodes ever, go so hooked on that those 20 minutes just flied. Illusion of time as well...
Love these in general, but this one in particular has to be the most interesting I've seen. Fascinating subject, thank you wired and Prof. Wallisch!
That was amazing and Mr. Wallisch has such a pleasant and friendly way to explain things. :D I knew a lot about illusions already but some things were new and with others I didn't know the brain workings behind them!
Yes!! I loved that presentation! I am an artist and I do see some of those illusions differently. I also love the illusion of a light or dark background in a painting changing the overall image color impression. Something I learned in color theory in college 30 years ago... 🤔😁
what a brilliant video, Pascal you are the goat of explaining things well enough for me to understand
I've experienced the frame rate thing myself in real life. I've woken up, really tired, on a flight and noticed the propellers spinning slowly backwards. I thought everyone experienced this.
Don’t believe I ever have, weird now I’m curious
I’ve experience it too-used to spend a lot of time staring at my ceiling fan
This was an amazing reminder of why I love this field of study so much. Life is so much more than what is face value, how incredible is that?!
I really enjoyed your insight on these questions! Thank you for answering in such an informative and interesting way. Great job!
It's great that he debunked the "myth" about the dancing lady. I just love it when experts and professionals put out counterinformation to educate the masses, which is vital when there's just so much fake news and misleading information out there. Great video!
Love this dude. Bring him back.
“You might die” is just amazing.
"user name checks out" 11:17 lmao
This was the best WIRED TS I've ever seen. Please more.
That was absolutely great video!!!
Really want to know more about this theme!
1:40 For me, the image is always spinning counterclockwise. I can watch it ten times and it still appears to go counterclockwise.
That ballerina illusion is soooooo frustrating! I make myself insane trying to switch direction and it seems to happen randomly and then I can't change it back.
To me it always looks counter-clockwise (guess i'm left brain, jk). Ive never seen it switch.
if you're looking to see the switch, the frame happens exactly at 1:37 when he says "changes" you can see her arm positions switch and her lifted leg is now on the opposite side
I found out how to easily switch. Instead of looking at her arms, looks at her legs. Pause when she’s facing a side and tell yourself that the legs are switched. Unpause and your brain will tell you she’s spinning the other way.
@@dccaleb5529 😯 NICE
To me is the oposite, to me it never changes randomly, but I do not have a hard time switching direction at will
Wow this was amazing ❤ thank you for this ❤ I love the way you speak and how you clarified everything ❤ I am also amazed by the amounts of props you came with
i love that as he's holding the photo of the dress and the light is reflecting over the photo when it's titled, the image actually does look black and blue.
You know someone is a great teacher when you are fully engaged in every moment. That's how I felt here. This man must be a brilliant professor.
I agree, he had me hooked. Lots of practical demos to keep me engaged and technical stuff my friend beside me was loving too
I didn not realise this video was as long as it is. I can listen to this guy for hours
This guy is so cool. I learned so much. Favourite Wired video yet. I loved it.
tbh, its much better than i expected. this guy is fun and very knowledgeable
Pascal isn't my favorite Fred Armisen character, but I do appreciate him none the less. He really makes me feel like he knows all that science
LMFAO
I didn't expect that this episode will be this informative and interesting 😱..
I love the way he describes our brain evolution as "debugging"
Best Wired video yet. You are brilliant and I am fascinated by this subject ❤
Love to see my friend Pascal on WIRED! Such a great teacher!
10:00 Wagon-wheel effect; Street Lamps are 60Hz. Thus can induce the Wagon-wheel.
It happens to me at daylight
@@huawafabeditto with trucks
This is so cool! I really hope WIRED has him back. I'd be curious to know why I see both versions of The Dress.
Wow this was the best one yet, interesting subject with a cool and knowledgeable expert
"I'm going to ruin ducks for you" is a sentence I never thought I'd hear anyone say to me
I just wanna say I love the name Pascal. Blaise Pascal is probably one of the coolest sounding names out of science imo.
This guy is fantastic! I'm jealous of people that had him as a Prof! Good stuff!!
I could listen to this guy speak for hours. Fascinating stuff.
Love the way he explains things. He keeps it joyful and entertaining and doesn’t make you feel dumb about things which helps you understand and grasp what he’s talking about better. You can tell he’s not only intelligent but charismatic in a way and has a passion for what he’s talking about. Kinda makes him really hot ngl. 😭😭
You forever destroyed the dress picture for me by showing the actual one. I always wondered why people said that it is blue and black. I was so sure it’s gold and white. Now I can’t unsee
it has ALWAYS been black and blue. Wtf is wrong with people for seeing something different?
@@tfulookinatm8 same i could never force myself to see it white and gold
I couldn’t believe it when he said 2/3rds of people see gold and white! I thought the vast majority were like me - seeing black and blue is just so obvious that it must be true. Laughed when I realised I’m a night owl too… 🦉
I never could see it as the gold and white. Black and blue here, and I am a night owl. I can also see the car wheels spinning backwards and never thought until now that it was not something everyone could see.
@@tfulookinatm8 the guy literally explains how or why ppl might see it differently 😅
i love this dude!!! made this video really interesting and was spitting facts🔥
That was soooo much information.
What an awesome and smart guy!
3:50 okay, only issue I got with this is that this video is at 30fps. So that 60fps example won't do anything because the video isn't at 60 😅
This!!
(the video is actually 24fps, but it changes nothing)
This one should get a sequel
Came for the dress, stayed for the knowledge. This was awesome . Thanks for having me on the show. Hopefully, it was sufficiently interesting/helpful..
This was so interesting and insightful. Tysm for sharing!