Trump says Canadians 'want' to become the 51st US state. Is this even possible? • FRANCE 24

Поделиться
HTML-код
  • Опубликовано: 19 дек 2024

Комментарии • 112

  • @kenkubesh3516
    @kenkubesh3516 21 час назад +22

    13% of Canadians, Right now, I bet more Americans would like to be a province.

    • @oceanwave4502
      @oceanwave4502 11 часов назад

      Think about it. If Canadia is part of the US, there will be no need for "cross-border trade". 😏

  • @ceebee8897
    @ceebee8897 22 часа назад +24

    Not in a million years. Canadians are living in closer quarters to the US than any other country and witnessing far more of 45's behaviour; we are more sick of him than the rest of the world rolled in together. Why would we give up our health care system, with all its faults; our CPP, vacation time, EI, and can you imagine Quebec joining the US? Canada is laughing while the rest of the world is wasting its time analyzing. We are more likely to give up the monarch as Head of State. The idiosyncrasies', racial divides & political infighting of the US can remain south of the border! We have enough to cope with with our own politicians!

    • @briancann7158
      @briancann7158 22 часа назад

      Canada has a different culture than the US and the differences in healthcare alone would keep most intelligent Canadians from supporting this idea. The rest of the World should be preparing for the insanity the new US administration has planned for them. We (thought) we were close friends: buckle Up!

    • @nunuabiznus
      @nunuabiznus 20 часов назад +1

      Quebec has repeatedly threatened to join the US in the past. Generally to get consolations from the Canadian government but they still threatened it.

    • @hepcat4202
      @hepcat4202 19 часов назад +3

      @@nunuabiznus Well, that's a lie. Did you intentionally lie - or did someone lie to you? Please point me to the proof of this. Otherwise, stop spreading lies.

    • @nunuabiznus
      @nunuabiznus 19 часов назад

      @@hepcat4202 If I am wrong it's because I was fed bad information. Declaring something to be a lie implies you somehow know my intent. Why not sound less ignorant and say that it is incorrect or you are ignorant of the history and ask for citations? The vitriol is unbecoming. My understanding was that it has been used as negotiating tactic by Quebec with the Canadian federal government, not a serious desire of the people of Quebec. I'll give you specific examples of serious discussions rather than the threat of it as a bargaining tactic, as that is what you asked for. When The Reciprocity Treaty of 1854 ended the Eastern townships had a movement, then in the 1860s Quebec and several other provinces whose confederation was lead by Joseph Howe had serious discussions about it, more recently in the 1980 Parti 51 (a party in Quebec who didn't do very well in the election) were a proponent of it. Those are slightly more concrete movements than I was originally suggesting but I think it shows that your "lie" statement is undeniably incorrect, while if you had disagreed with me in a more reasonable way or provided anything but accusations you might not have been provably wrong.

    • @JOYVEMIE
      @JOYVEMIE 17 часов назад

      Just a question who would protect Canada from China, India, Russia or the United States if they decide to come and take it ??

  • @HeBeDrGB
    @HeBeDrGB 22 часа назад +13

    This would all go away if you stopped paying attention to it... Trump believes that he can thrive within the chaos and it's better to not give it to him.

    • @garydare2238
      @garydare2238 19 часов назад

      Agreed. Donald Jr.'s new romance was stillborn in the gossips when this Canada thing first blew up, but banishing ex-fiancee Kim Guilfoyle as US Ambassador to Greece did make it onto the real news.

    • @sean367
      @sean367 18 часов назад

      As a Canadian, I welcome it. Trudeau's ruined Canada

  • @johnlangevin708
    @johnlangevin708 22 часа назад +17

    Felon Baby has it backwards . MN. is working on becoming Canada's southernmost province.

    • @JeffEbe-te2xs
      @JeffEbe-te2xs 21 час назад

      You can have it

    • @theloniousm4337
      @theloniousm4337 20 часов назад +1

      Ontario is further south than MN.

    • @johnlangevin708
      @johnlangevin708 20 часов назад

      @@theloniousm4337 My bad

    • @sean367
      @sean367 18 часов назад

      Gimme a break

    • @mabhodlelajj1195
      @mabhodlelajj1195 16 часов назад

      ​@@johnlangevin708if islamists can openly talk about taking over Canada, definitely US can Annex it. Most conservatives in Canada wouldn't mind that. Trudeau have destroyed Canada and is currently handing it over to outsiders. You leftists lunatics would have to migrate some where else if you don't like that🤷‍♂️

  • @62Cristoforo
    @62Cristoforo 6 часов назад +2

    Canada must immediately impose a 25% tariff on all imported goods from the USA. And there’s nothing he can do to stop it since he’s not even in office for another month.

    • @kenkubesh3516
      @kenkubesh3516 3 часа назад

      How does that hurt the US? We pay that...

  • @filipe5722
    @filipe5722 22 часа назад +5

    Canada has a state would mean a generation of Democratic rule in the US.

    • @GreeneLampsy
      @GreeneLampsy 21 час назад

      The Yanks would have to go beg the Vietcong and the Taliban for their abandoned Military gear back lol not to mention the US economy would totally collapse if Canada stopped allowing the US to trade guns and drugs

  • @randstahl4869
    @randstahl4869 22 часа назад +4

    Have yet to meet a Canadian willingly abandon his\her Canuck spirit even when working in the US. Seems unlikely each prefers stars and stripes over a beautiful maple leaf.

  • @bennetnelson6189
    @bennetnelson6189 16 часов назад +1

    That this can even be a point of discussion shows you how poorly Trudeau has governed

  • @sunny2355
    @sunny2355 4 часа назад +2

    As a CANADIAN 🇨🇦 I would rather die defending CANADA 🇨🇦 Then make it an American 🇺🇸

  • @MySpace662
    @MySpace662 22 часа назад +13

    This is a false, Canada will never give up their indipendence.

    • @SaltyBollocks1
      @SaltyBollocks1 22 часа назад +6

      What independence?

    • @MySpace662
      @MySpace662 22 часа назад +2

      @@SaltyBollocks1 Independence as a country, It's not a state.

    • @rz9017
      @rz9017 22 часа назад +1

      🤣

    • @Eli-pj8xm
      @Eli-pj8xm 22 часа назад

      lol. Is that why even if it is only a joke 13% of Canadians surveyed actually support the idea of joining the US as the 51st state?

    • @TruthTeller8888
      @TruthTeller8888 22 часа назад +1

      What independence .? 😂

  • @thearchit21
    @thearchit21 22 часа назад +9

    Let's Make Canada Great Again!

    • @62Cristoforo
      @62Cristoforo 6 часов назад +3

      Let’s have you move to the USA since you love their slogans so much. Canada never stopped being great

  • @marclawson2536
    @marclawson2536 22 часа назад +5

    Austria again.

    • @ruin1619
      @ruin1619 19 часов назад

      Canada has a lot of empty living space…

  • @jocknuke
    @jocknuke 4 часа назад

    Can’t believe this is taken seriously by Canadians and the media 😂😂😂

  • @natashaj6611
    @natashaj6611 20 часов назад +1

    should we hold a vote to see if US citizens want to become part of canada and Trudeau could organize our nationalized health care.

  • @kenhunt5153
    @kenhunt5153 6 часов назад

    He's just mad that Melania thirsts over Justin when she sees him.
    Der Leader is emotionally weak.

  • @tinkerbell1120
    @tinkerbell1120 17 часов назад

    Give me a break! Although Canada is not the one country I know anymore, supporting war in Ukraine and ethnic cleansing in Gaza, really Canadians are appalled by the US government. Democrats and Republicans.

  • @TheNationalist-v5q
    @TheNationalist-v5q 8 часов назад

    Canada ought to have been taken over by the US like yesterday. The question should just be how to integrate it into the US. Maybe the US president should automatically become the head of state in Canada but they retain their PM

  • @lesliesanger4255
    @lesliesanger4255 Час назад

    Wjy would we want to be the 51st state? So that guns will be the number one cause of death for our children and youth? Have our taxes go to the medical industry and then asked to pay again once services are needed? Or so we can pave our country and poisen our watershed? Why again?

  • @iany2448
    @iany2448 20 часов назад

    Upper Canada was settled by loyalist who maintained allegiance to the Crown during the American independence war and had to flee 13 colonies.

  • @sunny2355
    @sunny2355 4 часа назад

    There are AMERICANS who want to join Canada 🇨🇦 then vice-versa 😂

  • @beynar3087
    @beynar3087 7 часов назад

    First US must be split on Mississipi river. Then US may annex Ontario and Quebec maybe.

  • @adamyoung9132
    @adamyoung9132 21 час назад +1

    People dont have a sense of humor.

    • @justinleon3509
      @justinleon3509 14 часов назад

      trump is leader of US. you shouldnt make jokes like this as a head of state

  • @hepcat4202
    @hepcat4202 19 часов назад

    I'm sorry that your network bothered to even dignify this bs with a response. As a Canadian, I get that other countries may not understand that Canada is not a puppet of the US, but it riles me to no end that the orange buffoon gets this much press over his stupid childish taunts. I guess I would prefer you to give it as much intelligent thought as the originator of the insult. Just say Canada is independent, has no desire to be a part of the US, and only an adolescent jackass president-in-waiting would say such a thing.

  • @lovemeloveu3572
    @lovemeloveu3572 14 часов назад

    This is jook this wuold never ever happen ever f Donald Trump

  • @flavianparis4843
    @flavianparis4843 Час назад

    Trump says many stupid things! Stop wasting time talking about this.

  • @Phillip_Reese
    @Phillip_Reese 22 часа назад +2

    Stupid click-bait.

  • @TruthTeller8888
    @TruthTeller8888 22 часа назад +1

    One turbonator is keeping Canada hostage for his pension 😂

  • @YellowGun114
    @YellowGun114 15 часов назад

    Make North America great again!😊

  • @XrsN
    @XrsN 4 часа назад

    Trump we have but for a short time, Canada you have forever after

  • @georgetaylor3978
    @georgetaylor3978 15 часов назад

    No, the fifty-first position is saved for France. Their paycheck deduction for health care will guarantee medical care as long as they keep working.

  • @benjamindover4337
    @benjamindover4337 22 часа назад +1

    You know what they say... Many a truth are spoken in jest..

  • @herrbenrath2819
    @herrbenrath2819 14 часов назад

    What a dumb analysis. I cannot believe France 24 would even do such a ridiculous hypothetical run down.

  • @importantname
    @importantname 12 часов назад

    hahaah, a ha, hahahahah, ah, oh please stop, i cant breathe, ahahah, hah, ahahahahahahahah

  • @nunuabiznus
    @nunuabiznus 20 часов назад +3

    I bet each province will get to be its own state. All of Canada becoming one state is a bit silly. But state 51-60 sounds reasonable.

  • @AS-np3yq
    @AS-np3yq 22 часа назад +3

    It was a joke. My God Jesus Christ! A joke! He does that often.

    • @herlandercarvalho
      @herlandercarvalho 20 часов назад

      No, it's not a joke, he's always saying dumb sh*t, like that time he asked at a WH press conference, if COVID patients could be injected with disinfectant or be exposed to a really strong UV light to kill the virus. Or if Murica could buy Greenland. It's the same man, who looked right at the Sun during the eclipse, which can be dangerous and cause visual impairment if prolonged exposure, and had to be warned not to look. I guess that was a joke too, uh?

    • @PS-ej2xn
      @PS-ej2xn 18 часов назад

      But isn't it just wonderful to see all the libs having a collective meltdown? 😂

  • @RickRichard-s6t
    @RickRichard-s6t 22 часа назад +2

    United North America is a true destiny

    • @ruin1619
      @ruin1619 19 часов назад

      I thought you guys hated Mexicans?

    • @ruin1619
      @ruin1619 19 часов назад

      I thought you guys disliked Mexicans?

  • @robynmurray7421
    @robynmurray7421 13 часов назад +1

    Would Canadians be willing to give up their health care?

  • @homeplanet365
    @homeplanet365 16 часов назад

    52 is much more balanced.

  • @danailangelov283
    @danailangelov283 22 часа назад

    Disgrace!

  • @revagreen2303
    @revagreen2303 8 часов назад

    Old news!

  • @JeffEbe-te2xs
    @JeffEbe-te2xs 21 час назад +1

    Don’t want another welfare state

    • @kenkubesh3516
      @kenkubesh3516 21 час назад

      Ok are your talking about the US or Can.

  • @marksias6764
    @marksias6764 15 часов назад

    Do it!

  • @sheshe0806
    @sheshe0806 21 час назад +1

    Great report Bravo !!

  • @ruin1619
    @ruin1619 19 часов назад

    Free Quebec at least

  • @JT.Pilgrim
    @JT.Pilgrim 18 часов назад

    Maple Leaf Forever 🍁

  • @Camilla_Kudrin
    @Camilla_Kudrin 22 часа назад

    Canadian painter 🎨🖼

  • @Howiex-is8gq
    @Howiex-is8gq 21 час назад +1

    Id say 60 to 70% do....

  • @Wildhorse66
    @Wildhorse66 20 часов назад +1

    Canada doesn't mind the 100 billion it gets from the US. I hope that doesn't happen again

    • @RonMalleck-mb8vy
      @RonMalleck-mb8vy 18 часов назад

      That’s absolutely not true at all !
      US baloney

  • @sparky1145
    @sparky1145 22 часа назад +1

    Governor Trudeau he can't even do that properly 😂🤣

  • @ryanf2501
    @ryanf2501 7 часов назад

    As a Canadian , why not