‘This Is NO GENOCIDE!’ | Controversial Israel-Gaza Tweet Makes SNP Withdraw Whip from Politician
HTML-код
- Опубликовано: 11 сен 2024
- Chair of the National Jewish Assembly Gary Mond joins Peter Cardwell to respond to the SNP MSP John Mason having the whip removed following his comments on social media about the Israel-Hamas conflict.
Mason tweeted “If Israel wanted to commit genocide, they would have killed ten times as many.”
#gaza #israel #hamas #terrorism #war #conflict #genocide #politics #palestine #israelgaza #israelhamas #israelpalestine #talk #snp
Click here for more from Talk talk.tv
If you need any help visit: talk.tv/helplines
John Mason needs to review his membership of the SNP. They don't deserve him!. Look at Reform John.
This is Britain not Gaza. Our politicians should be working on behalf of the British public not Palestine
They literally take money from Israel
Hear, hear. Rather shockingly they are not!!
No but Our politicians are working on behalf of Israel.
@@calmingcrist4515 Exactly so.... Why are they working for Israel and not the UK and it's people.
@@calmingcrist4515 At least they are civilised and intelligent and don't commit terrible terrorist crimes.
Palistine isn't our problem its our country this government should worry about
Given Britain created the Palestine problem it's a bit rich to say it's nothing to do with us!
You don't get a say.... you cast your vote now your done, your opinion is the opinion of a losing side
@@user-xn1qf7fx6r
britain did not create the 'palestine problem'...
Well they shouldn’t support it then
@@Hemma-mm Why would our government support Palestine, Starmers wife and kids are Jewish!
I think there is something much bigger going on here, than we are being made privvy to...
Genocide is happening in Syria not Israel
Genocide is happening right now in nigeria 🇳🇬 not Gaza
@paulbernard3477 well the world courts disagree with your expert opinion
@@msto1987 Yep, because the world court is corrupted and have sold out to one group of religion.
@@msto1987 courts don't have a case.
@@msto1987 are you talking about the UN run "world courts" that are controlled by wonderful dictatorships like Iran, Turkey, Iraq, Russia, China, Lebanon and all the other Muslim run countries? Yes, paradigms of human rights.
They were out on the streets chanting genocide when Israel hadn’t even responded to Oct 7
Where exactly is Gaza in Scotland??
Thank you!
We're living in a world where logic and truth is increasingly disappearing..
Thank you for saying it as it is
You won’t find anything more than propaganda here 😂
@@gbrown9694 you mean like your comment?
Your living in a country Run by the friends of israel. The Zionist labour party bought and paid for by Netanyahu.
Didn't see that coming did you...???
Of course it's tragic when civilians become victims in war but don't forget, this war was started by Hamas murdering innocent civilians in Israel. You don't fight a war with one hand tied behind your back either so a thought for the future to Hamas. Never start what you cannot finish.
Let's stop talking about the Holocaust because they were just victims of war.
I'm more than happy with never mentioning it again.
True, Palestine/Hamas willingly and very knowingly broke a peace agreement on October 7th, that fact seems to be hard to understand for a lot of people. An attack of *that* magnitude, that Savagery, is as unvarnished an act of War as it is possible to mark.
They *knew* what the effects would be. It doesn't matter whether it was Israel, Egypt, or Syria attacked - the results would be the same - an act of War. With no apologies from Hamas/Palestine.
@davidmullen6011
How many Israeli settler terrorists broke international laws for years?
It would not be so bad if the people in the land were genetically Israelites and not converts from Europe.
WRONG analogy
Jews were not victims of a WAR they brutally started but hamas and the gazans are.
Read the comments correctly
@@waynesimon2425
@@davidmullen6011 Firstly get your facts right, the week before the 7th there was three air strikes on Gaza so apparently no peace agreement, there was a report released in September that confirmed that within the west bank in the previous 12 months there was the equivalent of three attacks per DAY on the Palestinian communities there, they had also killed 234 in the west bank prior to the 7th and there is no Hamas there!!. So were is your condemnation of that , it still continues today, because the Israelis know that the west will do nothing, they have been braking International law for decades and only get support. There seems little appetite to condemn gang rape or torture , why is that, as there were debating what the fuss was all about in the Knesset and they should continue to torture random Palestinian they lift off the street with no charges or prosecutions??
Why would anyone take information from Hamas or any other supporter of the attack on the 7th October, makes it even more sick when you look further back to the 5th September 1972, why would the Olympics agree to allow Palestinians to enter, sick and disgusting display of support for a terror organisation
@@Raginglion88 couldn't agree more.
ITs funny how Israel and the IDF accepted figures coming from Hamas and the Health Ministry etc before Oct 7th but after Oct 7th all of a sudden the figures are all considered BS....Its funny how independent western journalists are not allowed to enter Gaza to give the real story of whats happening and when they are allowed they have to be accompanied by the IDF and only allowed to go where the Israeli want them to go....If a journalist wants to go and there is a danger of him or her getting killed etc thats their choice...Thats how real news comes to us and has come to us since the beginning of time...Thankfully we have western doctors who are in Gaza working for western based charities like the Red Cross and the likes who come back to tell us the real story of what is happening...They are the real heroes of this sick war
None of them were Palestinians - it was a fake team- how could it be anything else when there is no such Country as Palestine- all the "team" were identified along with the countries they came from
The Olympics wanted us to believe Gaza is under attack yet got time to train a team 😂
Of course they were all fake team members
Last I checked the Brit’s got kicked out india 1948, went straight to steal pelestina land 1948 nakbar! Ever since is genocide in Gaza and West Bank every day! Facts! Is unbelievable how them Palestinians will make it out alive to 2025🙏🏿🙏🏿🙏🏿
Hamas started this war on October 7th 2023. They are responsible for everything that happens in Gaza. They could've let their citizens flee the country before Israel took action but instead they chose to keep their citizens in Gaza and use them as human shields.
Hamas has allegiances with jihadi Islamist terror organisations like Hezbollah and now Israel is being forced to fight to fight this war on 4 different fronts. Hamas in Gaza, houthi rebels in the red sea, Iran who are now allied with hamas, and Hezbollah.
Israel didn't start this war and yet they are the ones who are getting all the hate.
Yes, and just to clarify to those who cannot comprehend this - yes, the Israeli-Arab/Palestine conflict started decades ago (when and how is up for discussion) but this specific war started in the early hours of October 7th 2023.
💯 accurate ✅
Well said
@@benjaminbehan4411 well said
Yes. Have not jews always got the hate? Just read european history. The msm is false and ridiculous, using Hamas and PA as the source of truth. And still a lot of people believe it. Lisbeth
It would seem that voting Hamas wasn't such a good idea.
Bibi and Israel funded it to counter the PLO
dont pick a fight with the hands that feed you simple
Totally 💯 ✅
those hands are getting chopped off even by their own admission..plenty of articles in the Israeli based Haretz NewsPaper
The hand that feeds you should be yours.
America feeds Israel with out them there nothing
Britain has lost its mind 😂 the number of people killed has nothing to do with the definition of genocide.
Mason is a perfect example of what happens to any member of any socialist party/authoritarian system after they've listened to their conscience just long enough for telling the truth vs. towing the party line to become a personal, moral imperative. While I'm sure this is difficult for him, his life will be better for it in the end. Truth has a tendency to free the Soul, after all. Stay strong, UK.
So attacked again for telling the and John on his way out
I don’t know if he’s a ‘hero’ for saying it but he’s right!
Gotta cut Hamas out or it’ll never end.
I’m very sorry about the civilians, I truly am but it is war and people die.
I don’t believe the death figures given are correct in that they include the Hamas fighters with civilians. I do believe there should be more ways out for children, elderly and those with chronic pre-existing conditions
yes it was just 'war' when the holocaust happened
@@ModernPict I was just going to say the same thing...
Israel is defending itself.
By invading someone else's country.
🇮🇱👊🇮🇱
@@serene5986 what country have they invaded
💯💙🇮🇱💙
@@serene5986What drug are you on...please tell🤣🤣🤣
This war was not started by Hamas
You can trust Peter and Gary here folks, only one thing can be true at one time.
Please correct me but at the start of this current war Hamas did target Israeli civilians.
And I believe it was fact-checked.
Fact checked .. 😂 you’re funny!
That’s about as reliable as Wikipedia isn’t it? 🧐
Yeah, if u poke the tiger … he’s gonna get ya. 👏👏✅✅🇮🇱
I believe H*mas did their own press coverage.
Which works out as pretty indisputable..❤.
What a lot of nonsense
Last I checked ✅
The Palestinians owned the land Israel 🇮🇱 occupied forcefully.
I guess Palestinians have the right to resist and deport invaders
@@awadjr3662they did not own that land.
That is not the full truth ...look up the Hannibal directive.
It says 40k but it does include enemy combatants in that
Disagree. The combatants are in that, but they don't distinguish. I do wonder if that's because they don't know themselves who is who. And that would illustrate IDF difficulty fighting cowards who chose to wear the uniform of the civilians.
It's the truth! But these days, no one speaks the truth. If you do, the police are called!!!
💯🇳🇿
We already know what holocaust denial is and now we have genocide denial
@JN-om6rw well H and their brethren know all about denying that.
Armenia 1915.
👏👏👏🇬🇧🏴🏴Well said
The SNP are becoming totally irrelevant anyway
SNP 😂😂😂😂😂
why do we keep getting involved with our tax money when our once great kingdom is on its knees 😢
"some" civilians have been caught up in this??
Only because Hamas uses schools, hospitals & refugee camps as human shields
It's a war what u expect happend in Germany happend in England and guess what it's happening now in Russia
"Hamastinians"?
@@catherine2522 like all civilians being m......d in Nigeria, Bangladesh, Yemen etc.
Some citizens of Gaza have been caught up in the events caused by their evil government.
Yes he is right ! Spot on
Still waiting for Cardwell to interview a Palestinian !!
No such thing !
That's what israel is doing though the international court has deemed it so
THE AUDACITY “Some civilianz caught up” yeah some over 40 THOUSAND just some people over half being children 😡😡😡
TalkTV!
Well done John Mason for stating the truth.
😂😂😂😂 you are nuts
@@patriot2372why you not there helping patriot...
@@wor53lg50 I do what i can. But a billion dollar army vs a few trucks. What a joke.
@@patriot2372 yeah I'll bet you do help hamas.
@@Roatanlova68fmp71lliiiak Better than Jews
The Genocide is not instantaneous it's incrimental-saying that the ovvupiers could commit genocide if they wanted to, is tantamount to denying that it's happening right now, albeit slowly....
@@D-E-S_8559 true, because the Arabs are the real occupiers of this land.
@D-E-S_8559 plus, you need intent to commit G which clearly Israel do not, and never have had. Hence the 8 - 9 peace offers.
H on the other hand, make this intention extremely clear and extremely public.
@@Roatanlova68fmp71lliiiak No, the ovvupiers dispute thst what motivates them is Genocide-but they categorically acknowledge that they aspire to Ethnically Cleanse the natives. Problem is Ethnic Cleansing is the intent to commit a genocide...
@@D-E-S_8559
What makes this "genocide"?
Bullshit let the independent journalists in ….
Yes, lets bring in Aljazeera. They will give the correct number of casualties🤣🤣🤣🤣
@@vispillay1365 ya them too and Reuters, the Associated Press, and CNN,The Jerusalem Post,Israel Hayom The Times of Israel Fox News, The Wall Street Journal
@@vispillay1365 if Isreal have nothing to hide it would strengthen the case to the world
Feelings over facts…
Oh, eff off with policing words.
Fight with ideas, not with these games.
It was easy for them to take out millions of Syrians and push them through Turkey to European countries as refugees as a cover for the settlement process in other places without fear of emptying the cities of the population, but in the case of Gaza, they do not allow the population to leave because of the war despite the proximity of the border with the Arabic countries for fear of leaving the city to Israel .
Absolutely!
Far be it from me to defend an SNP politician, but essentially he's right. Furthermore, it's always worth remembering one important fact: the population of the lands we now call "Gaza" is higher today than it has ever been. Whatever your definition of "genocide", it clearly cannot have anything to do with any reduction in the number of inhabitants. Stand With Israel 🇮🇱
Cut Hamas out or it will never end? That’s such childlike naivety on the complex matter - that’s like saying cut out the French Resistance in Nazi occupied France during WW2
That's BS, M...d!
@@mbroitt u can spin it however u like but that’s the basic reality of this dire situation - ask yourself what would u do if u we’re in their shoes?
ANALYSIS IS DONE BY ASKING RELATIVES WHOSE MISSING? DUH
😮khamas=civilians
I have a fear, well founded, of fast moving cars.
So i look both left and right.
This man is fantastic and telling the truth
As what accepted generally in un
Genocide is defined by effort to erase/erode certain culture n ideology
Tell us what the wokes do to every conservative idea n critical perception
If it isnt legitimate culture of humanity
Still theres no genocide in gaza
Theres no sign of any cultural war
But security operation to bring justice to criminal organization that attack israel civilian
Israel isnt legalize mini skirt n homosexual there
Yet
To say that something isn't genocide because it isn't as severe as other genocides is a poor argument. The fact is, many bombed locations didn't have hamas fighters. Hamas is most likely down in the tunnels. To fight monsters we need not become monsters. Morality is best path to security. Arms embargo if Israel doesn't show standards of warfare. No weapons from my country. Israel should know better after suffering the holocaust
Given the actions of HAMAS and the "Palestinians" on Oct 7th and their vow to repeat such action over and over again what exactly should Israel do to protect their own people? Do HAMAS get a free pass?
@@rickgrear8270 that's seriously twisted and irrational thinking.
@@rickgrear8270 they do know better, which is why they say never again, and mean it. Look up H covenant to see why.
Without lies Islam dies
So icj are just.. wrong then. Cool 👍
They rather believe isreal lies.
@@mrumarGTA how can it be lies when there is so much factual evidence?
You guys are either deluded or you know what you are saying stay out of Scottish politics, some of us are biased and not even aware of it
There is nothing called Israel in the map
@@extra222love unwra educated huh?
Crap tv
@@colin7832 debatable.
The satellite imagery does not lie…. approximately 80% of Gaza has been levelled. If a country is rendered uninhabitable by another foreign state, what would be the correct word to use? Just curious 🤔
20% to go.
@@philipgibbs5751
✅👏👏🤣
What you might consider uninhabitable from your perspective is quite normal for the Palestinians…
that’s how they live…
Believe me I’ve spent time there!
Have you?
if it wasn’t for Israel they’d have no infrastructure, no water, electricity, hospitals.. nothing, so you know who’s financed all that?
@@petewood3493 war
@@BingbongBangewrong
15tah 311
Stole their land and their resources
This word play is part of their game. Call it what it is. A hall a cost. From now on use that word instead.
None are "innocent".
This is how criminals think and justify their crimes, shame on you!
Not even the little children? (On both sides). Steady on
@@profaneangel0842
The Muslim children have been infected with hate.
😢😢😢😢😢😢😢😢😢
Answer me this question: the year is 1985 in Apartheid South Africa. 50 uMkhonto weSizwe (ANC Armed resistance fighters)are hiding in the basement of Soweto hospital
Does the South African Defense force have the right to bomb the hospital to get to the 'terrorists'?
Prob yes, if its war condition. But I guess they would try infantry storming.
It's OFFFENSIVE!
Don't use a Word that is OFFENSIVE!
THOUSANDS OF FAMILES HAVE BEEN KILLED NIT JUST A FEW…..
Yes by the Hamas monsters.
@@gavinlevy1693Wrong by Israel
@@alexlyndhurstfreesuge5532 Do you support Hamas?
@@alexlyndhurstfreesuge5532 D0 you support Hamas, Alex?
@@gavinlevy1693 Do you support Genocide Gavin ?
Almighty God gave Israel 10 commandments, simple to understand. These rules are very specific to children of Israel, and the 10 commandments make Israel accountable. Guidelines for how to treat others! The nearest people to Israel are Palestinians. Israel failed to respect their commitments to almighty God, and they will be judged for that on the last judgment day for the abuse, destruction and death they did in Palestine and Lebanon and others countries. As a believer, it hurts me all the destruction and suffering Israel did...
Yes. Israel invaded itself on October 7th.....You really are misguided.
@FlytoColombia no, they did not. Hamas don't deny it.
@@Roatanlova68fmp71lliiiak I was being sarcastic to the above hysterical comment.
@@FlytoColombia Trying to change the subject from it meaning is one of your bad habits! Very bad behavior! ... Almighty God told us in Coran about some of your behaviors. Fortunately, you also have believers, but many of you are harsh towards others... Now it is visible ...
That word is highly offensive, except when used to our advantage. This fellow is highly offensive. Khalushes. Farshteyst?
It's offensive when it is misapplied!
@@You.are.boring.me.now2024
Indeed it is. Like comparing Oct 7 to the Holocaust. 1200 Israelis is Shoah, but 40,000 Palestinians is normal wear and tear. That's offensive.
@@danielreiss-cy4zr
Genocide requires intent and a very special level of intent, HAMAS have expressed their genuine genocidal intent time and time again, they acted on that intent on Oct 7th and vowed to repeat those action over and over again, what exactly should Israel do to protect their own? What did on one Mr M ibn Abdullah say about women and children being killed in his raids?
@You.are.boring.me.now2024 spot on, 100% right. 👍
@danielreiss-cy4zr it's not like they haven't done that before. Armenia 1915.
You just have to ask yourself, what has Israel on these genocide deniers 😂
I can imagine what they might have on the commentator, HIGHLY suspect
Its Genocide
👍👍👍
Yes against Israel
@@BingbongBange Troll
U just can’t handle the truth.
I’d advise you stop watching msm!
You’ve been over there have you?
@alexlyndhurstfreesuge5532 funny genocide when your opponent supplies aid and safe zones, warnings, hospital facilities and a clear way to finish the war - which they don't seem to want!.
Bullshit.
"THIS AIN'T ROCK N ROLL!... THIS IS... GENOCIIIIDE!!!!" 😝🎸🎸🎸 "AS THEY PULLED YOU OUT OF THE OXYGEN TENT, YOU ASKED FOR THE LATEST PARTY!! "
Committed by Hamas? CORRECT
There's Gonna be Sorrow... Try n Wake Up Tomorrow! 🎸🎸🎸 💎🐶
Cool vid
👄👄
It's only offensive because he knows it's true, this fella should go look at the definition