Amazing podcast! Please keep these coming. Another intellectual you should invite is Dr Zeeshan Ahmed (xLums, xKSBL, xAl-Qadir University) currently the VC of Al-Ghazali University.
Personalities like Dr Zaman should lead our education system. But unfortunately we have all the bums ruling the education system. I wish some day he can be the Chair of higher education and be involved in key policy making related to curriculum otherwise our children will have to pay the price.
I've seen many columns of Sir but honnestly this was one of the best podocast, I've ever seen. The more you got all these lavishes and man-made successes the more your soul are detached.
Muzamil you are doing an outstanding work by bringing intellectuals to your podcasts and showing the nation what we should be doing. Hats off to you. Stay blessed.
I've the honor of being his student at #PIDE from 2016-2019. One of the best person & humble Economist too !! One & only Dr #AsadZaman !! When I got #USA admission & i got the chance 2 see him & taken his advice.... Man this is a gem & a hallmark of a person !! #AsadZaman
@Muzamil I think you should have a whole complete series with Sir. OMG, the last 5 mins where impactful, I could see how deeply you were moved by his response as well. Dr Shb appears to have a youtube channel, please encourage him to revive it now. Its time for him to revamp it. Most of his videos are 8 years old in that channel.
In spite of having lived in the US from the ripe young age of 16 years with the desire to assimilate into the American culture, he did not affect an American accent. Amazing init!
The part where he mentioned solution for PAKISTAN Economy should be converted into a clip and go viral. What a simple way to put it. Well explained, great episode
Masha Allah Dr. Asad Zaman Sir, What a beautiful share. Life is not all about self centered life. Excellent job Muzamil Hasan Masha Allah, you will get better if you let your guests to do most of the talking and ask shorter questions.
this was a fantastic session , Dr.Asad is a fascinating , erudite , thoughtful gentleman . It is obvious he would be a great teacher , by the way he explains things in this interview. Keep it up Muzammil , great questions and interactivity which was thoughtful and showed you were well prepared.
Mumzamil, as you are planning to move to UAE, and even otherwise, this podcast needs to be uploaded with different subtitles e.g., english, chineese, russian, arabic etc Please consider asking your team to invest some time in creating such copies of this podcast. It will be great to see Mr. Asad Hasan sitting with you in discussion with English, Chinese, Russian and Islamic Scholars in series of podcasts.
Well thought out, nuanced and layered questions. Deep, logical and objective responses. Such an impressive interview, I thoroughly enjoyed it. Hats off to both gentlemen.
Very insightful discussion, Dr. Zaman was very erudite in explaining some complex topics, would love to hear more from him. Only suggestion, please keep the questions concise and to the point, sometimes the context you build for the question is too long and makes the podcast unnecessarily long.
May Allah SWT bless you for your effort to introduce such an icon to many like me who can benefit tremendously from Dr Sahibs wisdom, experience, ilm and aspirations for the Ummah! Ameen. Please invite him over and over to help us deepen our understanding on varied threads that were uncovered in this session.
This session was way to short for the level of detail every concept required and even as a whole. So, I would suggest ka you invite him again, and talk to him on a relatively important topic and conversate on it in greater detail... I am not sure if it is best but I am sure something related to this suggestion will be helpful for everyone.
A much needed conversation, what an investment of time I made, watched it on a recommendation of my favourite professor and now I am glad I did despite some evil forces stopping me
Excellent episode.. loved the conversation and views of Dr sb.. gave me alot of clarity and perspective on few things. Would like to listen more about islamic system countrring capitalism and socialism.
What an amazing podcast. Explained the soul of Islam in 5 mins never heard any mullah do it. That's why exposure is important because our mullah has no idea.
Watched the whole episode , massive respect fot the leanred guest and his journey is marvellous. Nonetheless , there are many insufficiently answered queries. There could have been no other bettwr peeosn to reapond to the questions of islamic exonomic system but the answers were cursory and hypothetical. Especially the response to crypto question was a lot shallow and conspirational in nature. When we mix religion a lot with mudnane knowledge such amalgamtion occurs. But still it was good learning lsitening to the talk and go through diverse concepts and ideas covered in fhd talk.
MashaAllah! Please also invite Prof. Imran Ihsan Khan Nyazee whose career is superb like above and his writings are game-changer in Islamic Economics. Very impressive personality at a late age.
Wonderful guest .. he would have lot to share if host would not take too much time to ask questions , some time I get confused who is taking interview and who is giving
Muzamil, you are doing great job. Really making impact. Plz invite Dr. Tariq Binouri b/c we need to know his views about education, IT exports and much more.
Best explanation i have heard as to why crypto etc . is not suitable for a nation or world currency and best answer to " Where would be Pakistan in future".
I am glad the our honourable guest could go and attend these elite educational institutes which have enabled him to think independently and critically and then come back to teach us in a local university that all that system is doomed and condemned.
That is not what happened lol. U cant expect someone to ideologically assimilate oneself to a people just because he gained something from them. If anything what u suggested is itself contradictory as what u suggest is itself against independent and critical thought
@@burhanahmad2825 I agree, I may have mis communicated myself. My point was that everybody should have the independence to experiment with different cultures and school of thoughts and then one can settle done with some belief system. Moreover, in our country, there are too much biases and strong opinions and room for independent thought and expression is missing. A good example I think would be Jinnah and Iqbal who had seen that done that and then their belief system and thought process was so firm that they self actualised their personalities. Our respectable guest is also one of those people who have finally chosen their final path. Nevertheless, intolerance and bigotry in our society is so rampant and common that it’s a huge uphill battle to have a contrarian thought.
57:00 What most people also don't probably know that countries like South Korea, Taiwan(assuming it's a country) and Singapore which are today considered "free democracies" experienced their highest growth when they weren't democracies. And that's because the authoritarian government could implement reforms very fast. Only after growing at fairly high rates for 30 years or so, the change from Authoritarian governments to democracy happened because the growth had slowed down to fairly low percentages. Many people don't understand that "Democracy" is a luxury. It's usually unaffordable by poorer countries. So, the lectures from the West and all the "indexes" that they publish are tools to control countries like India and Pakistan. If India does grow and achieve the status of a high-income country, it will be the first full democracy to do so.
Pakistan isn't a democracy. Its a hybrid regime of sorts where politicians have very little space to work. You could have authoritarian regimes back in the 1960s with the cold war going on and new media being much smaller than today. Democracies or not, what sets progress is one word.... trade. Countries with liberalized economies tend to progress. India got it right when it abandoned the Nehru model of economics. Let the people engage in trade and commerce and you will find your equilibrium and then progress from there. That is India. That is Bangladesh. It has to do with competence which is non existent in a place like Pakistan. Pakistan has had authroirtian rulers and democracies and the economic progress is roughly the same. The only thing that keeps Pakistan afloat is US aid. When $ flow in, things look better as in the 1960s, 1980s and then in the 2000s. When the US turns off the tap, all hell breaks loose. The basic fallacy here is the expectation that the govt. is the solution to the ills. Govt. is the problem. Functioning govts. empower people to make their decisions and don't try to control the economy. Free movement of goods and labor and capital is what is required. This is what India did, this is what Bangladesh is doing. This is what China is. Authoritarian or not, till the govt. decides to empower it's people and not try to control the economy, such crisis will continue happening. There is a severe lack of competence and long term planning. The establishment is about here and now and so is the entire society.
@@JW-be8wf You seem to miss the point. I meant to say that Authoritarian govts have been the necessary but insufficient condition for countries to be able to bring radical reform required to grow by taking advantage of trade.
@@arunsar7893 The radical reform that is the prerequisite to economic progress lies in having rule of law aka an independent and functional judiciary and secure property rights. That problem of authoritarianism it tends to become a self sustaining mechanism where more authority leads to even more authority and it tends to interfere with the rule of law and property rights most of the time. Once you establish these 2 conditions, authoritarian or democratic becomes irrelevant. The radical reforms that tend to work is empower people and reduce the size of government when it comes to trade, movement of goods, labor and capital. Pakistan is a quasi authoritarian state. Govt. is too involved in the business of business. For every successful authoritarian leader, there are 10 authoritarian leaders who have brought ruin to their people. Africa is the poster child of it.
Good content. My tip would be to ask short crisp and meaningful questions from the worthy guests. Make peace with the fact that no one is interested in your worldview.
I think Muzamil should have added the idea of continuation of policies. A powerful regime with time on its hands to bring stability and continuity. Anything else will end up like us.
A humble suggestion for Mr. Hasan. Please let the guest speak. Dr. Zaman does not have a personality like some of your other guests where you just sat in aw and let the guests speak. Mr. Hasan normally is good about letting guests speak but with Dr. Zaman- he was out there.
Growing sun seeds require long term investment of hard work in educating farmers to make them do what is in interest of country, here everyone is free to do what he like to. Everyone wants to live in his own comfort zone.
Who is giving value to the Gold? The people? Who is giving value to the Bitcoin. Of course, the people. Gold is Gold because people have given the value to it.
Really thought-provoking. Both the host and the guests were on the money. Thank you I wonder if the host ever thought about getting together the best of his guests in one program for resolutions to issues of Pakistan. Excellent program MashALLAH congrats.
Thought provoking. A little sad too, a lot of very learned people understand the need to have a system made for us. But no one seems to know what that is. I agree with Muzammil on that opinion that maybe the factor behind is the polarized view of religion and science/economics/etc.
i feel proud to be a student of Dr Asad Zaman sab when he was Dean at International Islamic university Islamabad ❤
Amazing podcast! Please keep these coming. Another intellectual you should invite is Dr Zeeshan Ahmed (xLums, xKSBL, xAl-Qadir University) currently the VC of Al-Ghazali University.
Please more Dr Asad Zaman, so much to listen and learn, kudos to TBT team for creating such a wonderful thought space
Personalities like Dr Zaman should lead our education system. But unfortunately we have all the bums ruling the education system. I wish some day he can be the Chair of higher education and be involved in key policy making related to curriculum otherwise our children will have to pay the price.
I've seen many columns of Sir but honnestly this was one of the best podocast, I've ever seen.
The more you got all these lavishes and man-made successes the more your soul are detached.
Muzamil you are doing an outstanding work by bringing intellectuals to your podcasts and showing the nation what we should be doing. Hats off to you. Stay blessed.
I've the honor of being his student at #PIDE from 2016-2019. One of the best person & humble Economist too !!
One & only Dr #AsadZaman !!
When I got #USA admission & i got the chance 2 see him & taken his advice....
Man this is a gem & a hallmark of a person !!
#AsadZaman
Dr Asad zaman was my teacher in international Islamic university islamabad.
Dr Asad is a very humble teacher economist and my Ex neighbor. He is very talented
He's my teacher ❤, having a great coverage over economics, world history and many more. Very pleased to see them here.
pidean
Dr. Asad Zaman is one of the humble and intelligent men on the universe.
@Muzamil I think you should have a whole complete series with Sir. OMG, the last 5 mins where impactful, I could see how deeply you were moved by his response as well. Dr Shb appears to have a youtube channel, please encourage him to revive it now. Its time for him to revamp it. Most of his videos are 8 years old in that channel.
Great great idea.. someone should lead this idea to him..
In spite of having lived in the US from the ripe young age of 16 years with the desire to assimilate into the American culture, he did not affect an American accent. Amazing init!
The part where he mentioned solution for PAKISTAN Economy should be converted into a clip and go viral. What a simple way to put it. Well explained, great episode
Yes pks make shorts...
Pls*
Masha Allah Dr. Asad Zaman Sir, What a beautiful share. Life is not all about self centered life. Excellent job Muzamil Hasan Masha Allah, you will get better if you let your guests to do most of the talking and ask shorter questions.
a scholar about whom humanity can be proud of
Thank you Muzammil for introducing us to such people and being the best at what you do.
Amazing guest MA, very knowledgeable, and has solutions to problems. Why is our government not listening to these suggestions!!!!
I am highly demanding to tbt to invite Dr. Asad Zaman as soon as possible for detailed conversation on Economics and Social sciences
this was a fantastic session , Dr.Asad is a fascinating , erudite , thoughtful gentleman . It is obvious he would be a great teacher , by the way he explains things in this interview. Keep it up Muzammil , great questions and interactivity which was thoughtful and showed you were well prepared.
What a man. Muzammil had to dig deep to surface the wisdom. Arguably one of the best by tbt
What a lovely podcast Muzamil! THIS is what a good conversation is!
This gives more value than a whole course in university.
Brilliant. Please call him again ❤
As a student who is in the midst of college applications etc. He is a great source of admiration
Mumzamil, as you are planning to move to UAE, and even otherwise, this podcast needs to be uploaded with different subtitles e.g., english, chineese, russian, arabic etc Please consider asking your team to invest some time in creating such copies of this podcast. It will be great to see Mr. Asad Hasan sitting with you in discussion with English, Chinese, Russian and Islamic Scholars in series of podcasts.
It is really appealing to see Dr Zaman, tbh is setting new heights, more power to u muzammil
Towards the end Dr. Zaman provided elegant solutions to Pakistan economic problems.
Yes he also visited different universities for awarenesss
Kindly muzamil do something about your thumbnails They really are becoming scary day by day 😭😂😂
😂😂
True
😂😂100% scary and cartoonish😅
🤣🤣😂😂 exactly😂😂🤣🤣
Lol yeah
What an insightful discussion with doctor sahab. Really looking forward to meet him in person.
Dr. Asad seems to be such a humble personality. Good, informative session.
One of THE BEST episodes of thought behind things... thank you for having him and thank you to dr sb for such simple breakdown of many complex issues
This is the first time I've heard views on economics and social responsibility in view of Islam with clarity.
Jazak ALLAH. Would love to hear again. Such a humble personality
Mashaallah. It is very fruitful discussion ❤❤
A brilliant interview, please call him again as well on economy.
Well thought out, nuanced and layered questions. Deep, logical and objective responses. Such an impressive interview, I thoroughly enjoyed it. Hats off to both gentlemen.
Such a great personality thanks for inviting him
Very insightful discussion, Dr. Zaman was very erudite in explaining some complex topics, would love to hear more from him. Only suggestion, please keep the questions concise and to the point, sometimes the context you build for the question is too long and makes the podcast unnecessarily long.
This is the best tbt. I have watched!
May Allah SWT bless you for your effort to introduce such an icon to many like me who can benefit tremendously from Dr Sahibs wisdom, experience, ilm and aspirations for the Ummah! Ameen. Please invite him over and over to help us deepen our understanding on varied threads that were uncovered in this session.
Really enjoyed the session. Thank you muzammal for having intellectuals like dr asad on the show.
Thank you muzammil .. such a wonderful episode
This session was way to short for the level of detail every concept required and even as a whole.
So, I would suggest ka you invite him again, and talk to him on a relatively important topic and conversate on it in greater detail...
I am not sure if it is best but I am sure something related to this suggestion will be helpful for everyone.
Dr. Asad Zaman such a great person❤
A much needed conversation, what an investment of time I made, watched it on a recommendation of my favourite professor and now I am glad I did despite some evil forces stopping me
k.
Excellent episode.. loved the conversation and views of Dr sb.. gave me alot of clarity and perspective on few things. Would like to listen more about islamic system countrring capitalism and socialism.
25:00 minutes ..
Eurocentric narrative
27:25 👍👍
Mcaulay's Minutes on education 28:48
What an amazing podcast. Explained the soul of Islam in 5 mins never heard any mullah do it. That's why exposure is important because our mullah has no idea.
Watched the whole episode , massive respect fot the leanred guest and his journey is marvellous.
Nonetheless , there are many insufficiently answered queries. There could have been no other bettwr peeosn to reapond to the questions of islamic exonomic system but the answers were cursory and hypothetical.
Especially the response to crypto question was a lot shallow and conspirational in nature.
When we mix religion a lot with mudnane knowledge such amalgamtion occurs.
But still it was good learning lsitening to the talk and go through diverse concepts and ideas covered in fhd talk.
MashaAllah! Please also invite Prof. Imran Ihsan Khan Nyazee whose career is superb like above and his writings are game-changer in Islamic Economics. Very impressive personality at a late age.
Best guest till now
Wonderful guest .. he would have lot to share if host would not take too much time to ask questions , some time I get confused who is taking interview and who is giving
Just WoW....incredible discussion, fabulous
Excellent conversation 👌
Muzamil, you are doing great job. Really making impact. Plz invite Dr. Tariq Binouri b/c we need to know his views about education, IT exports and much more.
this is my favourite episode, period
Living gem my teacher ❤
Best explanation i have heard as to why crypto etc . is not suitable for a nation or world currency and best answer to " Where would be Pakistan in future".
excellent podcast. Keep it up Muzammil. I think expansion of human capital through creative thought processes is the way forward.
I am glad the our honourable guest could go and attend these elite educational institutes which have enabled him to think independently and critically and then come back to teach us in a local university that all that system is doomed and condemned.
That is not what happened lol. U cant expect someone to ideologically assimilate oneself to a people just because he gained something from them. If anything what u suggested is itself contradictory as what u suggest is itself against independent and critical thought
@@burhanahmad2825 I agree, I may have mis communicated myself. My point was that everybody should have the independence to experiment with different cultures and school of thoughts and then one can settle done with some belief system. Moreover, in our country, there are too much biases and strong opinions and room for independent thought and expression is missing. A good example I think would be Jinnah and Iqbal who had seen that done that and then their belief system and thought process was so firm that they self actualised their personalities.
Our respectable guest is also one of those people who have finally chosen their final path. Nevertheless, intolerance and bigotry in our society is so rampant and common that it’s a huge uphill battle to have a contrarian thought.
@@burhanahmad2825 Anyway, thanks for your input
I would say Dr. asad had a privilege from childhood.
57:00 What most people also don't probably know that countries like South Korea, Taiwan(assuming it's a country) and Singapore which are today considered "free democracies" experienced their highest growth when they weren't democracies. And that's because the authoritarian government could implement reforms very fast. Only after growing at fairly high rates for 30 years or so, the change from Authoritarian governments to democracy happened because the growth had slowed down to fairly low percentages.
Many people don't understand that "Democracy" is a luxury. It's usually unaffordable by poorer countries. So, the lectures from the West and all the "indexes" that they publish are tools to control countries like India and Pakistan.
If India does grow and achieve the status of a high-income country, it will be the first full democracy to do so.
Pakistan isn't a democracy. Its a hybrid regime of sorts where politicians have very little space to work. You could have authoritarian regimes back in the 1960s with the cold war going on and new media being much smaller than today. Democracies or not, what sets progress is one word.... trade. Countries with liberalized economies tend to progress. India got it right when it abandoned the Nehru model of economics. Let the people engage in trade and commerce and you will find your equilibrium and then progress from there. That is India. That is Bangladesh. It has to do with competence which is non existent in a place like Pakistan. Pakistan has had authroirtian rulers and democracies and the economic progress is roughly the same. The only thing that keeps Pakistan afloat is US aid. When $ flow in, things look better as in the 1960s, 1980s and then in the 2000s. When the US turns off the tap, all hell breaks loose.
The basic fallacy here is the expectation that the govt. is the solution to the ills. Govt. is the problem. Functioning govts. empower people to make their decisions and don't try to control the economy. Free movement of goods and labor and capital is what is required. This is what India did, this is what Bangladesh is doing. This is what China is. Authoritarian or not, till the govt. decides to empower it's people and not try to control the economy, such crisis will continue happening.
There is a severe lack of competence and long term planning. The establishment is about here and now and so is the entire society.
@@JW-be8wf You seem to miss the point. I meant to say that Authoritarian govts have been the necessary but insufficient condition for countries to be able to bring radical reform required to grow by taking advantage of trade.
@@arunsar7893 The radical reform that is the prerequisite to economic progress lies in having rule of law aka an independent and functional judiciary and secure property rights. That problem of authoritarianism it tends to become a self sustaining mechanism where more authority leads to even more authority and it tends to interfere with the rule of law and property rights most of the time.
Once you establish these 2 conditions, authoritarian or democratic becomes irrelevant. The radical reforms that tend to work is empower people and reduce the size of government when it comes to trade, movement of goods, labor and capital.
Pakistan is a quasi authoritarian state. Govt. is too involved in the business of business. For every successful authoritarian leader, there are 10 authoritarian leaders who have brought ruin to their people. Africa is the poster child of it.
Brilliant 👍 interview
Thanks for podcasts. Humble request kindly speak simple urdu language, because it hard to translate 1 hour + podcast ❤
Really insightful conversation!
Great conversation! specially about debt and trade trap.
Very rich discussion.
Amazing...
Good content. My tip would be to ask short crisp and meaningful questions from the worthy guests. Make peace with the fact that no one is interested in your worldview.
I think Muzamil should have added the idea of continuation of policies. A powerful regime with time on its hands to bring stability and continuity. Anything else will end up like us.
A humble suggestion for Mr. Hasan. Please let the guest speak. Dr. Zaman does not have a personality like some of your other guests where you just sat in aw and let the guests speak. Mr. Hasan normally is good about letting guests speak but with Dr. Zaman- he was out there.
Glad to be here and eager to know more about Dr.Asad's Opinion 👏
Wonderful personality 💯
Great,
very knowledgeable podcast.
Excellent podcast!
Ñeed Dr Asad Zaman round 2 mainly focused on Islamic economic system
Muzamil bhai mehman lag rahay thay zyada time to onhon nay hi lay liya. Doctor sab was like honn , honn😍😆
We all should be united and work for prosperity of Pakistan 🇵🇰❤️
He is a true muslim. He only felt his children when came to an Islamic University else he never felt attached with students.
Excellent
What an amazing talk
Don't worry muzzamil, India will lead the way
Best podcast ever 👍🏻
Growing sun seeds require long term investment of hard work in educating farmers to make them do what is in interest of country, here everyone is free to do what he like to. Everyone wants to live in his own comfort zone.
Want more podcasts with Dr. Asad Zaman.
Amazing podcast,
Last Question is superb, nice answer is very amazing.
Pls invite his genius brother , Dr Arif Zaman too
Dr Asad Zaman..the Legend
Great podcast. Learned a lot from it :)
Who is giving value to the Gold? The people?
Who is giving value to the Bitcoin. Of course, the people.
Gold is Gold because people have given the value to it.
Great infomation
Very relatable. Large contingent is white washed. 26 mins in and I know I'll love this podcast.
ps
read super imperalism by micheal hudson.
Very informative and interesting podcast ❤
Muzammil bhai please invite Syed Aamir Ali, CEO of BankIslami. He is very nice and competent guy behind success of the bank.
Muzamil, Good to see that you are into Salt water aqurium... do a small episode on this. It is an exciting hobby
Oh my god, so much to learn
Really thought-provoking. Both the host and the guests were on the money.
Thank you
I wonder if the host ever thought about getting together the best of his guests in one program for resolutions to issues of Pakistan.
Excellent program MashALLAH congrats.
excellent work boy keep it up
Thought provoking. A little sad too, a lot of very learned people understand the need to have a system made for us. But no one seems to know what that is. I agree with Muzammil on that opinion that maybe the factor behind is the polarized view of religion and science/economics/etc.