Studio Pivote REALLY did their research and was extremely successful in carrying emotions in that mv. What broke me the most was when the whale, whalien 52 who could not be heard just like early bangtan, carried them up and then bursted into the many purple stars who formed into ARMYs at a stadium. Knowing that we are among those stars, and that's how they view us during concerts......yep nope wait im tearing up again
Yep, we are eachother's spring. I just love the BTS/ARMY logo meaning. An opening door from both sides pov. They are opening the doors, and we are there, waiting to meet them
MV theory we are Bulletproof: the Eternal part 1 From the beginning of the MV We are Bulletproof: the Eternal, this is a combination of the previous BTS MV, this MV describes the pararels that exist in each MV BTS, Yes we are like throwing them away. Their journey for 7 years, at the beginning there was a picture of MV No More Dream, there was a scene where V with glasses released from his eyes. The glasses, lead us to see how the BTS journey for 7 years in this MV. There was a black shadow behind the genie, then passed through the genie shop, the shadow represented a storm or bad insults. Why is there a Boy In Luv era? Because in that era they were initially accused of "plagiarism". Because of wearing the uniform concept, even then, on TV Show BTS was once asked about the issue of "plagiarism". there was a scene where Jungkook was walking and then there was a piece of paper, that was their memory, in 2014. BTS had been to America for American Hustle Life, they held a free concert and distributed their own brochures, or concert tickets. In the JK MV Part MV N.O where in the mv it tells the Bangtan who drank a capsule to control the mind, there JK instead rebelled, followed by the others, because they want to be free, not "controlled" by anything and everything Their beginnings showed the courage to start something more than they (others) thought. Imagine it's free "We are Korean singer, KPop, it's free, free concert," said the BTS member while on the road. The scene of Suga wearing the clothes worn during the performance of I Need U and some flying glass shards then, as if accusing or aiming at him, This illustrates, where during the era of I Need U, blows, storms and accusations returned to BTS. In this era they were again accused of the issue of "Plagiarism" even this time Sajaegi which was completely untrue. Part 2 Part 2 The broken glass in the current RM scene shows how they have never forgotten all the past. Because that's what they are successful as now and is getting stronger. There is a scene where there are black waves. This is a picture of the Black Ocean, Black Ocean is when the idol appears but the state of the audience is dark or only a few that turn on the light stick. In 2016, BTS performed at the GDA (Golden Disc Awards) when they performed there was a dark audience, after this Black Ocean, I think the waves, also illustrated the events they had experienced in 2016. Where they performed at one of the festivals which also aired. Here the BTS appearance is cut and not broadcast live stream. BTS should appear last and go live But for some reason suddenly the live stream said that the festival was over, but what was BTS doing? They continue to perform for the sake of ARMY. BTS performed, with a state full of confetti that indicated the show was over In MV We are Bulletproof: the Eternal, there is a whale and BTS has a song called "WHALIEN 52". So Whale 52 is true. Whale 52 is the most lonely whale in the world. Used to be a doctor This doctor named Dr. Watkins, suddenly caught the sound frequency of a male whale that was different from the others. In the song Whalien 52, BTS seems to describe them as Whalien 52 which is without anyone. Part 3. Part 3 In the lyrics of Whalien 52, it reads "Mom said that the ocean is blue, with all my strength to reach farther, But what should I do? This place is too dark and full of other whales that speak other languague, I just can't hold it mom ". And in this MV there is a scene where the RM that once sank in the dark ocean, in this MV there is also a whale that turns into a lot of purple grains, it's like a picture of an army. The relationship of all this 1. MV We are Bulletproof: the Eternal, BTS ran past the parallel of some of their previous MVs, AND THIS PLACE, BTS DO NOT CHANGE AT ALL. This indicates that during their 7-year journey, they remained the same, namely 7 men who debuted 7 years ago, under the name Bangtan Sonyeondan. Continuation no. 1 they never change, 7 years we've been through, they are still our boys. 2. The fact that BTS portrays whale as Army and BTS portrays themselves as Whale 52 in their song, unless there is a whale or Whale 52 which means they will understand each other. Because they felt the same way, this also seemed to be conveyed by BTS, they gave a picture of whale 52 which means "Army can understand, hear and reply to BTS, and vice versa. The last part In the end the picture of the whale is BTS and ARMY who understand, listen to, and respond to one another. So from there the scene of RM used to be in the dark bighit training room and now in the bright bighit training room. And there is a whale or whale, which accompanies BTS, until the scene ends where BTS wears all-pink clothes at MV BWL, with a beautiful atmosphere or scene and fits the lyrics "yeah, we are not seven with you". That's a picture where we, described as purple light and whales, accompany BTS from the past until now. The time when everything has become bright, where they managed to show that they have succeeded in achieving their dreams. Heaven in this MV means BTS now. Successful BTS, happy only with the army, BTS and Army understand each other, listen to each other because we experience the same thing. Until the end of the journey, stay together, remember, eternal: eternal. I didn't get the time to do it, what kind of program did BTS not get, the artist's room was really not given gtw, how was it that it was difficult to practice until finally they practiced in public toilets that were on the show, imagined there were many who passed through other idols, it was still difficult for BTS to practice polite with other idols but there are still people who don't like it. in the MV We are Bulletproof: the Enternal there are previous MV, namely No More Dream, NO, We Are Bulletproof pt.2, Boy In luv, I Need U, Young Forever, Spring Day, RUN, Outro: Wings, Blood, Sweet and Tears, Not Today, Mikrokosmos, perform song Born Singer and Boy With Luv 💜
@40 - Sonali.M A black ocean is basically when a fandom agrees simultaneously to turn off their light sticks when a certain artist or group performs. BTS themselves got a black ocean but I don't exactly remember which award show it was.
i think “for sale” is a reference to how they were accused of being sellouts :( or maybe it was just on their shirts in the nmd mv in the first place jskdhd
I think it could be both those things but also maybe a reference to how they had to earn their keep by being back up dancers etc... they were literally for sale, to make money to keep going.
it actually refers to when their company was so low in budget that their clothes was from a store with the logo "For Sale", i'm not good in english but i hope i could help w/ this information
xCeleste 7:43 was the moment at 2018 MAMA when Jin confessed about their disbandment that almost happened that year. Jhope is holding the award ,and you can see J-Hope crying and everyone cries with him later.
9:58 no remember their shirts that had all sorts of writing on them and For Sale was one 10:53 the insect thing was for me like the ANTIS, the mirror breaking with Joon was like when they said he was ugly, the floor falling was kinda like Tae losing his confidence when they called him weird, the black ocean was reminiscent of MAMA 2016, the box for Hobi was like how people tried to put them in a box. The red I think was like the accusations that tried to smear them, same shade even in the VCR. 11:38 Yoongi's broken shoulder. 13:00 did you notice their formation and entrace was like how they did it in the Speak Yourself concert series before Boy With Luv? 15:00 aw you didn't notice the callback to MAMA 2018 when they got the AOTY award.
agree with you Karla.. so much meaning in this MV..yep, the red is when antis accused them for plagiarism...sad that they went thru so much but look at where they are today and antis still trying to smear their names and tried and still try their darness to break us apart...
the black waves actually a lot of people thinking represents “the black ocean” that bts had to experience a lot during the earlier years.. it’s when people in the audience at award shows or their concerts would go but turn their light sticks off and not move to make it seem like no one was there for them.. some known ones for bts was melon music awards 2016 and golden disc awards.. and no hate because i’m a exo fan but both artists performed there and that’s when bts was getting bigger and exo was the big group at the time but it was said their fans turned off their light sticks for bts’s performances and there are pictures.. that’s why we think the black wave represents the black ocean they experienced in 2016 (these are not my words, i just copid to let you know more)
Tbh the black ocean seemed more like the black oceans they faced before 2016, such as the Golden Disk Awards or MAMA 2015. Not sure about Melon Music awards 2016, bc there were still many Army bombs waving in the crowd compared to before.
Honestly I associated it with the heartbeat whale aswell because that was the only physical from we saw of it. But the whale was a reference to Whalien 52 in that MV aswell. It was also a song in the game so ye
It is both. The whale in heartbeat represents whalien 52. The whale, which could only be heard by another one of his kind, stands for BTS. He was lonely and alone until Army heard him sing. So the whale represents BTS and Army who found each other.
Purple hearts (ARMY) saved them from their feelings of pain (Yoongi-his hurt shoulder and anxiety and depression) drowning (RM-in your video actually, the hardship one, he talks about feeling like they were drowning in all the negativity).
On BTS's "hip-hop" Era, they barely had any recognisations. People were criticising them for what they presented. Calling with names and down looking to there work. But as soon as there "WINGS" Era started, A.R.M.Y. started supporting them more and more. Then came the "LOVE YOURSELF" Era, which just swept all charts, bringing BTS to only top of all music and closer to A.R.M.Y.'s hearts. Proving that BTS and A.R.M.Y. are just made for each other. BTS and ARMY are just the best amongst all musical artists and there fanbase. BTS not only touches ARMY's heart and influence them to love themselves but also to love others and the surrounding. I'm really really proud of myself, being a part of this big family. I PURPLE BTS and also ARMY 💜💜💜💜💜💜💜. Thank you all
I think the black wave that was attacking was a reference to the "black ocean" they dealt with early on. The scene where they were crying is a reference to when they revealed they almost broke up, since Hobi is holding an award. Everything else I caught. Also was wondering if I missed a reference to the Fire MV somewhere, but I still can't find it...
The part near the end when they were crying, it made me think of Hobi’s speech in which he cried and the other members cried in 2018 MAMAs, even though they are wearing their Wings era outfits/hair. If you look in Hobi’s hands, he’s holding a MAMA award. So I think that is exactly the moment, but just wearing the same outfits when they did their ending ment for Wings tour The Final, which was also an emotional moment.
I saw a post on IG saying that they stop on BWL era on this MV because BTS were not able to share the stage with us ARMY for ON era. Now let's cry together. 😭
12:30 those flower petals are also in the SAVE ME webtoon in the last episode. In the last slide of the episode, 7 of these petals fall and TOGETHER WITH YOU is written in the end and since this song is actually about ARMY and BTS being together and the petals appear when the little purple ARMY lifts RM up, maybe those petals represent TOGETHERNESS!!
The outfits from the last Wings Tour concert, the Born Singer rotating formation, and then they are standing in the exact same order as at MAMA 2018, Hobi holding the daesang and all of them crying because of everything that happened that year.. I'm still sobbing 😭
What I also understand is that they rose to international fame after spring day, hence the podium being raised after said depiction. That was the time when they were nominated for the first time for BBMAs. Interesting how I started following them when Spring day was released. Just before their ultimate fame 👏
I just can't stop crying no matter how I repeat it.. You know how dark and painful, the transitions from their old MVs are and it started to get purple and colorful after the I Need U part, which is when they won their 1st award😭💜
No matter how many times I watch the video and listen to this song, I always literally shed tears out of LOVE and PRIDE with what BTS have become... Thank you, XCeleste for your passionate vids. Lots of love for you too 💜🇵🇭
crying all day, erday from this song! BTS, youve come a long and hard way but you did it with flying colors! hoping you’ll go on for more joyful years, we will be there to cheer you on. #AFBF 💜🐋
If you notice when the guys touch the purple light (that represents Army's) it opens up into the purple ocean when previously they were crushed by a black wave, it shows that BTS are no longer alone. The way they got up to the pedestal to perform was on a whale which in the song "Whailen 52" represents loneliness. It shows that they felt alone while trying to succeed, but are no longer alone because they have army's. But, that light I think also represents that army are no longer alone. As soon as BTS touches the light it opens up into what looks like a concert showing that all in all army's are not alone because they have other army's and BTS themselves to lean on and take comfort from. In the end, #WeNeverWalkAlone
When they were at the top , you can see that they are wearing their concert clothes from the final wings tour (you can see yoongi's blonde hair, hobie's red hair , tae's bandana, RM's hat etc.) and that they were standing like how they were singing Born singer , and the scene after that when they were holding the MAMA award(suppossedly since its in 2018) and crying together. But during their ending ment for the wings tour video, you can see the similarities of their clothes and their hair in this MV. Studio Pivote really did such an amazing job in getting the feelings and msg across that im crying over animation now. Thanks for the reaction Rosan! And who said you're a fake fan LOL WHO WAS IT?!!? We're really happy that you're in the family! :D
The Young Forever scene is reminiscent of the SY concert when the guys walk from small stage to main stage to perform BWL. Two at a time they join RM in the catwalk. I love that symbolism.
I took the whale for Whalen 52 ......and BTS " Riding the wave of success" type thing........So many ways to interpret this video. Amazing and Beautiful!!!!
I remember hearing that, the reason why they didn’t add ON at the end, is because we didn’t get to experience that comeback with them all together because of the pandemic and I was just so close to crying
dude literally bts loves army so much, I wanna cry... like literally imma be crying abt not havin' a boyfriend but then I remember that one time JK said that he'll be all of army's boyfriend and i'm happy again; these boys don't even know the magnitude of joy that they give to all of us-
Couple of other points I read people noticed - when Jk walks down the NMD street, as well as For Sale, on the pillar is "BTS" & "solo", ref to when Bang PD gave Joonie the choice of whether to stay in BTS or go solo; and when we see them on the whale, Tae raises his arms, then Jk sees that & raises his (it's v quick, the commenter had slowed the mv right down), ref to when Tae was more extrovert at the beginning & helped shy Jk come out of his shell :)
What if the campfire scene represents them talking about disbandment (it's night, and it represents the darkness right before the dawn when things are the hardest) and they ask themselves why they are still doing this and then the purple bubble represents ARMY and it gives them the answer and so they decide to continue.
The campfire scene represents they are happy when they are with each other (ie: V putting his head on Jimin's shoulder)...similar to them in the on stage: Prologue mv.
Her: "Prrrrrrrr I'm not ready for this" Me in the future: "Oh ur going to die after you watch this of tears. Be ready. Because I almost shed a tear. I'm a new ARMY (legit a mOnTh) but I love them so much. I know when I become an older ARMY I will cry to this song."
I love this so much!! The animation of the past BTS and the present BTS. Is so lovely and meaningful. It included all their music videos, and show their journey through it.
Love this song. So touching. I cried the 1st time i heard it knowing it was about army and i know so much more now. But i still cry hearing it. Just Beautiful. The blood represents the death threats they got. The black wave was the other group fans going quit with lights on their concert. -baby army Brklyn, NY
@@amairaaaryan3791 --- I read somewhere this happened during the GDA in 2016? I've looked at a couple of videos from this on RUclips, but there is no sign of the Black Ocean there. On the whole, BTS seemed to be received with quite a lot of enthusiasm by the audience. Maybe it was deliberately edited out. Is there any way to see this as it happened? Or did it happen elsewhere, elsewhen? . ###
You also see the way the stage seem to go longer towards the ARMY logo.. kind of reminded me of RM's part in BOY WITH LUV.. "towards you.. let me fly" I'm whale 🐋
I'll probably go unnoticed but the red part of N.O. reminded me of the red pills they were told to swallow in that MV. Like to control them, so that's why Hobi ends up being caged, because they were chasing them and wanted to control them.
You missed the black ocean reference at the beginning (the black wave) which represents when haters turned off their Light sticks at awards shows n how they end with the purple ocean of ARMY light sticks when their on top
![Seungmin "그렇게, 천천히, 우리(As we are)" | [Stray Kids : SKZ-PLAYER]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/kAzmhLHePqU/mqdefault.jpg)
Studio Pivote REALLY did their research and was extremely successful in carrying emotions in that mv. What broke me the most was when the whale, whalien 52 who could not be heard just like early bangtan, carried them up and then bursted into the many purple stars who formed into ARMYs at a stadium. Knowing that we are among those stars, and that's how they view us during concerts......yep nope wait im tearing up again
A'jah Lawrence I bawled!
The whale from whalien 52 is also featured in heartbeat
We are the gates to their heaven
They are the heaven indeed💜💜💜💜
Yep, we are eachother's spring. I just love the BTS/ARMY logo meaning. An opening door from both sides pov. They are opening the doors, and we are there, waiting to meet them
OH GOD NOW IM CRYING
MV theory we are Bulletproof: the Eternal part 1
From the beginning of the MV We are Bulletproof: the Eternal, this is a combination of the previous BTS MV, this MV describes the pararels that exist in each MV BTS, Yes we are like throwing them away.
Their journey for 7 years, at the beginning there was a picture of MV No More Dream, there was a scene where V with glasses released from his eyes. The glasses, lead us to see how the BTS journey for 7 years in this MV.
There was a black shadow behind the genie, then passed through the genie shop, the shadow represented a storm or bad insults. Why is there a Boy In Luv era? Because in that era they were initially accused of "plagiarism". Because of wearing the uniform concept, even then, on TV Show BTS was once asked about the issue of "plagiarism".
there was a scene where Jungkook was walking and then there was a piece of paper, that was their memory, in 2014. BTS had been to America for American Hustle Life, they held a free concert and distributed their own brochures, or concert tickets.
In the JK MV Part MV N.O where in the mv it tells the Bangtan who drank a capsule to control the mind, there JK instead rebelled, followed by the others, because they want to be free, not "controlled" by anything and everything
Their beginnings showed the courage to start something more than they (others) thought.
Imagine it's free "We are Korean singer, KPop, it's free, free concert," said the BTS member while on the road.
The scene of Suga wearing the clothes worn during the performance of I Need U and some flying glass shards then, as if accusing or aiming at him,
This illustrates, where during the era of I Need U, blows, storms and accusations returned to BTS. In this era they were again accused of the issue of "Plagiarism" even this time Sajaegi which was completely untrue.
Part 2
Part 2
The broken glass in the current RM scene shows how they have never forgotten all the past. Because that's what they are successful as now and is getting stronger.
There is a scene where there are black waves. This is a picture of the Black Ocean, Black Ocean is when the idol appears but the state of the audience is dark or only a few that turn on the light stick. In 2016, BTS performed at the GDA (Golden Disc Awards) when they performed there was a dark audience, after this Black Ocean, I think the waves, also illustrated the events they had experienced in 2016.
Where they performed at one of the festivals which also aired. Here the BTS appearance is cut and not broadcast live stream. BTS should appear last and go live
But for some reason suddenly the live stream said that the festival was over, but what was BTS doing? They continue to perform for the sake of ARMY. BTS performed, with a state full of confetti that indicated the show was over
In MV We are Bulletproof: the Eternal, there is a whale and BTS has a song called "WHALIEN 52".
So Whale 52 is true. Whale 52 is the most lonely whale in the world. Used to be a doctor This doctor named Dr. Watkins, suddenly caught the sound frequency of a male whale that was different from the others.
In the song Whalien 52, BTS seems to describe them as Whalien 52 which is without anyone.
Part 3.
Part 3
In the lyrics of Whalien 52, it reads "Mom said that the ocean is blue, with all my strength to reach farther, But what should I do? This place is too dark and full of other whales that speak other languague, I just can't hold it mom ". And in this MV there is a scene where the RM that once sank in the dark ocean, in this MV there is also a whale that turns into a lot of purple grains, it's like a picture of an army.
The relationship of all this
1. MV We are Bulletproof: the Eternal, BTS ran past the parallel of some of their previous MVs, AND THIS PLACE, BTS DO NOT CHANGE AT ALL. This indicates that during their 7-year journey, they remained the same, namely 7 men who debuted 7 years ago, under the name Bangtan Sonyeondan.
Continuation no. 1 they never change, 7 years we've been through, they are still our boys.
2. The fact that BTS portrays whale as Army and BTS portrays themselves as Whale 52 in their song, unless there is a whale or Whale 52 which means they will understand each other.
Because they felt the same way, this also seemed to be conveyed by BTS, they gave a picture of whale 52 which means "Army can understand, hear and reply to BTS, and vice versa.
The last part
In the end the picture of the whale is BTS and ARMY who understand, listen to, and respond to one another.
So from there the scene of RM used to be in the dark bighit training room and now in the bright bighit training room.
And there is a whale or whale, which accompanies BTS, until the scene ends where BTS wears all-pink clothes at MV BWL, with a beautiful atmosphere or scene and fits the lyrics "yeah, we are not seven with you". That's a picture where we, described as purple light and whales, accompany BTS from the past until now.
The time when everything has become bright, where they managed to show that they have succeeded in achieving their dreams.
Heaven in this MV means BTS now. Successful BTS, happy only with the army, BTS and Army understand each other, listen to each other because we experience the same thing. Until the end of the journey, stay together, remember, eternal: eternal.
I didn't get the time to do it, what kind of program did BTS not get, the artist's room was really not given gtw, how was it that it was difficult to practice until finally they practiced in public toilets that were on the show, imagined there were many who passed through other idols, it was still difficult for BTS to practice polite with other idols but there are still people who don't like it.
in the MV We are Bulletproof: the Enternal there are previous MV, namely No More Dream, NO, We Are Bulletproof pt.2, Boy In luv, I Need U, Young Forever, Spring Day, RUN, Outro: Wings, Blood, Sweet and Tears, Not Today, Mikrokosmos, perform song Born Singer and Boy With Luv 💜
Wow
Wow, very well explained!
Thank you! Borahae!
Omg thank you so much.🥺💜
@Mrs Tentacles you're Welcome
@@sh00ki3xylene9 you're Welcome 💜💜💜💜
The black wave is representing the "Black Ocean" they used to get from those who shall not be named.
I don't know if I will laugh or what 🤣🤣🤣
Yeah. That me cry...after I found the meaning of the black wave. A Black Ocean from an audience is just devastating (no matter who you stan).
@40 - Sonali.M A black ocean is basically when a fandom agrees simultaneously to turn off their light sticks when a certain artist or group performs. BTS themselves got a black ocean but I don't exactly remember which award show it was.
@@kassie-stuff i think it was the 2016 MMA
@@ridhimagohiya1662 that's terrible and hurtful
i think “for sale” is a reference to how they were accused of being sellouts :( or maybe it was just on their shirts in the nmd mv in the first place jskdhd
Yes, it was on their shirts!
I think it could be both those things but also maybe a reference to how they had to earn their keep by being back up dancers etc... they were literally for sale, to make money to keep going.
it also could've been because in their rookie years, they were made fun of and harassed for not being able to buy and wear brand clothes? maybe
if you go back to their debut stage, the "For Sale" logo was actually on their sleeves...
it actually refers to when their company was so low in budget that their clothes was from a store with the logo "For Sale", i'm not good in english but i hope i could help w/ this information
4:35 his arm is hurt there and I only noticed now
stOpppp omG his shoulder injury😭😭
Omg.. the time he messed up his shoulder! 😭😭
Wow,I didn’t notice that
Finally not just me noticed his arm
xCeleste 7:43 was the moment at 2018 MAMA when Jin confessed about their disbandment that almost happened that year. Jhope is holding the award ,and you can see J-Hope crying and everyone cries with him later.
9:58 no remember their shirts that had all sorts of writing on them and For Sale was one
10:53 the insect thing was for me like the ANTIS, the mirror breaking with Joon was like when they said he was ugly, the floor falling was kinda like Tae losing his confidence when they called him weird, the black ocean was reminiscent of MAMA 2016, the box for Hobi was like how people tried to put them in a box. The red I think was like the accusations that tried to smear them, same shade even in the VCR.
11:38 Yoongi's broken shoulder.
13:00 did you notice their formation and entrace was like how they did it in the Speak Yourself concert series before Boy With Luv?
15:00 aw you didn't notice the callback to MAMA 2018 when they got the AOTY award.
agree with you Karla.. so much meaning in this MV..yep, the red is when antis accused them for plagiarism...sad that they went thru so much but look at where they are today and antis still trying to smear their names and tried and still try their darness to break us apart...
I was naming all the era's while they were running and then I started crying so proud 😭 of them
the black waves actually a lot of people thinking represents “the black ocean” that bts had to experience a lot during the earlier years.. it’s when people in the audience at award shows or their concerts would go but turn their light sticks off and not move to make it seem like no one was there for them.. some known ones for bts was melon music awards 2016 and golden disc awards.. and no hate because i’m a exo fan but both artists performed there and that’s when bts was getting bigger and exo was the big group at the time but it was said their fans turned off their light sticks for bts’s performances and there are pictures.. that’s why we think the black wave represents the black ocean they experienced in 2016
(these are not my words, i just copid to let you know more)
😥
Oh so sad
Tbh the black ocean seemed more like the black oceans they faced before 2016, such as the Golden Disk Awards or MAMA 2015. Not sure about Melon Music awards 2016, bc there were still many Army bombs waving in the crowd compared to before.
well well well.. how the turned tabled lol
I saw someone say that the end is the flower path talked about in i believe 2!3!
Oh yeah! I didn't even think of that
The part where Jk is the box it like they were trying to box them into one genre. And he fought it
It’s actually J Hope in the box
Thats jhope
7:42 Hoseok in the middle holding the daesang while they were all crying, it is the scene from MAMA 2018, same position of members. 😭💜
The whale and stage was heartbeat mv ref
Honestly I associated it with the heartbeat whale aswell because that was the only physical from we saw of it. But the whale was a reference to Whalien 52 in that MV aswell. It was also a song in the game so ye
It is both. The whale in heartbeat represents whalien 52.
The whale, which could only be heard by another one of his kind, stands for BTS. He was lonely and alone until Army heard him sing. So the whale represents BTS and Army who found each other.
Purple hearts (ARMY) saved them from their feelings of pain (Yoongi-his hurt shoulder and anxiety and depression) drowning (RM-in your video actually, the hardship one, he talks about feeling like they were drowning in all the negativity).
ARMY's representative animal should be a whale
I wish! 💜🐳
koreee
Yaaasss
100th like 😭😭💜
I know I wasn't the only one crying at this 💜❤
I really wonder if someone in the fandom didn't cry
i remember seeing 'the for sale' on the sleeve is on the shirts they wore in their debut teaser photos but have no idea the meaning behind it
the scene with jungkook getting engulfed by the black wave reminded me of the black ocean back in 2016
V just mentioned on a concert what a beautiful colour purple is and now it has become such a big colour for Army.
That's amazing.
When they were in New York the Empire State Building was lit up purple for them.
@@ILmylife108 omg, I googled it, it's beutiful💜.
Those hearts in the water...the first K ARMY..and at campfire International ARMY comes and lifts them to the sky
Yassss Queennnnnnn!!!!! I've been looking forward for your reaction to this gift from bangtan...luv you luv you💜💜💜...we cry together in this family 😭
This was a beautiful gift and I'm not ready for bang bang con!
On BTS's "hip-hop" Era, they barely had any recognisations. People were criticising them for what they presented. Calling with names and down looking to there work. But as soon as there "WINGS" Era started, A.R.M.Y. started supporting them more and more. Then came the "LOVE YOURSELF" Era, which just swept all charts, bringing BTS to only top of all music and closer to A.R.M.Y.'s hearts. Proving that BTS and A.R.M.Y. are just made for each other.
BTS and ARMY are just the best amongst all musical artists and there fanbase. BTS not only touches ARMY's heart and influence them to love themselves but also to love others and the surrounding.
I'm really really proud of myself, being a part of this big family. I PURPLE BTS and also ARMY 💜💜💜💜💜💜💜. Thank you all
I think the black wave that was attacking was a reference to the "black ocean" they dealt with early on. The scene where they were crying is a reference to when they revealed they almost broke up, since Hobi is holding an award. Everything else I caught. Also was wondering if I missed a reference to the Fire MV somewhere, but I still can't find it...
The way there is flowers everywhere is no one else reminded of 2,3! And how they are in a flower garden, makes me think we are the flowers you know.
BTS is a Family!
Army is a Family!
Together we are a World Wide Family!
I purple my World Wide Family!
the look in your eyes and the sound of your voice when you're talking about BTS. this. this is what made me cry. borahae ARMY :( 💜💜
The part near the end when they were crying, it made me think of Hobi’s speech in which he cried and the other members cried in 2018 MAMAs, even though they are wearing their Wings era outfits/hair. If you look in Hobi’s hands, he’s holding a MAMA award. So I think that is exactly the moment, but just wearing the same outfits when they did their ending ment for Wings tour The Final, which was also an emotional moment.
Wow you managed to keep most of ur tears in RESPECK
YAAAAASSSSS GIRL!!!
NO OTHER REACTORS NOTICE BORN SINGER BUT YOY DID!!!! I WAS HOPPING THAT YOU NOTICE IT AND YOU DID!!
THANK YOY SO MUCH!!!💜🌌💜🌌💜🌌💜
She was also the only one that noted in the end the army logo turning to bts logo
@@alexandrapereira4051 I saw that
I saw a post on IG saying that they stop on BWL era on this MV because BTS were not able to share the stage with us ARMY for ON era. Now let's cry together. 😭
Girl, I cried so intensely on my 1st watch. I still cry with each watch 😅 They love us so much. I feel like we can never love them enough! 💜
I know this might sound too common but The Eternal really is a love letter to army 💜🐋
12:30 those flower petals are also in the SAVE ME webtoon in the last episode. In the last slide of the episode, 7 of these petals fall and TOGETHER WITH YOU is written in the end and since this song is actually about ARMY and BTS being together and the petals appear when the little purple ARMY lifts RM up, maybe those petals represent TOGETHERNESS!!
The outfits from the last Wings Tour concert, the Born Singer rotating formation, and then they are standing in the exact same order as at MAMA 2018, Hobi holding the daesang and all of them crying because of everything that happened that year.. I'm still sobbing 😭
The characters onscreen correlate with whoever's singing, especially in the beginning - makes it easier to tell who they are 😆
Its a delight to watch reaction of an older army... the difference between a buffet and gourmet is so intelligible..
I think we’re the flowers!!!!!!! We’re part of their spring as much as they are a part of ours
What I also understand is that they rose to international fame after spring day, hence the podium being raised after said depiction. That was the time when they were nominated for the first time for BBMAs.
Interesting how I started following them when Spring day was released. Just before their ultimate fame 👏
I watched this mv a lot of times already but I always get goosebumps all over my body. And sobs uncontrollably 😭
At the 12:25 it is leaves falling down as the reference to the song itself which SUGA aka MinPD produced
I just can't stop crying no matter how I repeat it.. You know how dark and painful, the transitions from their old MVs are and it started to get purple and colorful after the I Need U part, which is when they won their 1st award😭💜
No matter how many times I watch the video and listen to this song, I always literally shed tears out of LOVE and PRIDE with what BTS have become... Thank you, XCeleste for your passionate vids. Lots of love for you too 💜🇵🇭
I love how you caught everything
That feeling where you label yourself a fake army for not recognizing/mixing up a few referrences in the MV hahaha
crying all day, erday from this song! BTS, youve come a long and hard way but you did it with flying colors! hoping you’ll go on for more joyful years, we will be there to cheer you on. #AFBF 💜🐋
If you notice when the guys touch the purple light (that represents Army's) it opens up into the purple ocean when previously they were crushed by a black wave, it shows that BTS are no longer alone. The way they got up to the pedestal to perform was on a whale which in the song "Whailen 52" represents loneliness. It shows that they felt alone while trying to succeed, but are no longer alone because they have army's. But, that light I think also represents that army are no longer alone. As soon as BTS touches the light it opens up into what looks like a concert showing that all in all army's are not alone because they have other army's and BTS themselves to lean on and take comfort from. In the end, #WeNeverWalkAlone
When they were at the top , you can see that they are wearing their concert clothes from the final wings tour (you can see yoongi's blonde hair, hobie's red hair , tae's bandana, RM's hat etc.) and that they were standing like how they were singing Born singer , and the scene after that when they were holding the MAMA award(suppossedly since its in 2018) and crying together. But during their ending ment for the wings tour video, you can see the similarities of their clothes and their hair in this MV. Studio Pivote really did such an amazing job in getting the feelings and msg across that im crying over animation now. Thanks for the reaction Rosan! And who said you're a fake fan LOL WHO WAS IT?!!? We're really happy that you're in the family! :D
I figured the star whale was a call back to the Heartbeat mv for BTS World OST...
(calling it a star whale because I'm also a Whovian 😄)
@sam white right?! I've always described the BTU exactly that way 😄
The whale was a reference to Whalien 52 in that MV as well. The song was also in the game.
The Young Forever scene is reminiscent of the SY concert when the guys walk from small stage to main stage to perform BWL. Two at a time they join RM in the catwalk. I love that symbolism.
Oh also! 5:25 they are assembling together like how they did in one of their concerts!!
I love RM old hairstyle. There's nothing to be ashamed of.
I took the whale for Whalen 52 ......and BTS " Riding the wave of success" type thing........So many ways to interpret this video. Amazing and Beautiful!!!!
the petals that surrounded yoongi looks like the butterfly wings on the cover of the album for the most beautiful moment in life part 1 and 2
I remember hearing that, the reason why they didn’t add ON at the end, is because we didn’t get to experience that comeback with them all together because of the pandemic and I was just so close to crying
I cry every time I watch it. It is so awesome
IT hits you in the feels
Suga was holding his hurt shoulder in the I Need U outfit 💜
Girrrrllll, I don’t know how you weren’t crying the whole time!! I was bawling 😭 the moment it started!! Love you and your channel!!
Of course at the end, they put Bow With Luv. Because we are the ones that gave them love. Now, they have love, because of us ARMYs.
Fun fact: There should be atleast 5 billion more purple orbs if they represent us. 💜
6:56 Me: almost going to cry
Her: readying her brain for a fountain
The flower petals remind me of the petals at the end of Save me book
Te estaba extrañando necesitó tu reacción. Tengo 72 años y te sigo desde hace mucho tiempo al igual que a BTS.
dude literally bts loves army so much, I wanna cry... like literally imma be crying abt not havin' a boyfriend but then I remember that one time JK said that he'll be all of army's boyfriend and i'm happy again; these boys don't even know the magnitude of joy that they give to all of us-
Couple of other points I read people noticed - when Jk walks down the NMD street, as well as For Sale, on the pillar is "BTS" & "solo", ref to when Bang PD gave Joonie the choice of whether to stay in BTS or go solo; and when we see them on the whale, Tae raises his arms, then Jk sees that & raises his (it's v quick, the commenter had slowed the mv right down), ref to when Tae was more extrovert at the beginning & helped shy Jk come out of his shell :)
Been waiting for this reaction. Sobbing ocean tears til now. 😭💜
Ye no I'm not crying my eyes are sweating
10:47 thats the black ocean, RM biggest fear, when the army bombs turn off 🥺💔💔
noooo😭 i hope they know we'll never leave them
Let's always try to keep our army bombs on for our boy so they never feel alone!
What if the campfire scene represents them talking about disbandment (it's night, and it represents the darkness right before the dawn when things are the hardest) and they ask themselves why they are still doing this and then the purple bubble represents ARMY and it gives them the answer and so they decide to continue.
The campfire scene represents they are happy when they are with each other (ie: V putting his head on Jimin's shoulder)...similar to them in the on stage: Prologue mv.
I think petals here are like the flower petals road we were walking on during The Most Beautiful Moment in Life
The for sale sign represents BTS members pre - debut working as backing dancers for other groups .
Her: "Prrrrrrrr I'm not ready for this"
Me in the future: "Oh ur going to die after you watch this of tears. Be ready. Because I almost shed a tear. I'm a new ARMY (legit a mOnTh) but I love them so much. I know when I become an older ARMY I will cry to this song."
I love this so much!! The animation of the past BTS and the present BTS. Is so lovely and meaningful. It included all their music videos, and show their journey through it.
I've waited for thissss💜
Just found this💜
Love your reaction!
Always and forever an Army💜
I was waiting for this!!!! Btw borahae💜💜💜💜💜😁😁
Wait.... am I first?
Wow you are first lol thank you
Omg thank you for replying. I love your theory vids. Borahae fellow army😁💜
I just watched the video and i cried from begining till end. It was so beautiful and true.🥺🥺
Bts really touch me where nobody could never touch :’)
U understood it completely and also helped me to understand.
Army💜
the only reaction that I am waiting for💜💜
I appreciate your love and patience 💜
This mv was literally so perfect. So emotional and nostalgic. Quick question tho... what happened with the love yourself eras??
Love this song. So touching. I cried the 1st time i heard it knowing it was about army and i know so much more now. But i still cry hearing it. Just Beautiful. The blood represents the death threats they got. The black wave was the other group fans going quit with lights on their concert. -baby army Brklyn, NY
love you! you're so beautiful inside and outside!
your video about BTS is very helpful! thank you Army!
we're bulletproof. purple you xCeleste💜
Uwu i just found you and I'm already inlove with your channel gurl! BORAHAE 💜
This was a awesome video I literally started tearing up when I I saw the beginning but the end is what really got me. I wasn’t prepared for this. :)
OMG I WAS WAITING FOR YOUR REACTION!!! 😂😂
The flower petals may signify the arrival of the HYYH era.
The "shadow wave" - is that the dark ocean?
###
It is black shadow that BTS got. Damn it hurts like hell seeing it again.
@@amairaaaryan3791 --- I read somewhere this happened during the GDA in 2016? I've looked at a couple of videos from this on RUclips, but there is no sign of the Black Ocean there. On the whole, BTS seemed to be received with quite a lot of enthusiasm by the audience. Maybe it was deliberately edited out. Is there any way to see this as it happened? Or did it happen elsewhere, elsewhen?
.
###
Eupetros Arktou it happened in some events in their earlier years. All I can mainly think of is the Golden Disk awards 2016.
Love your reaction and explanation 💜
at the beginning, that school bus is from 'no more dreams' their 1st mv 🥺
I love how you explain the video. Thank you as always. Borahae
We are the reason why they reach the top😭😭😭
I love how u explain the whole thing of the video. I love it
this is by far the best reaction and explanation of WAB ETERNAL MV!!! 💜
Very beautiful and emotional!!! 😭😭😭😩😩😩💜💜💜
Look at that !!Suga's left arm !
Thank you for the great breakdown of the song. I learned some new things from this reaction. I love your videos and share them often to new ARMY. 💜
You also see the way the stage seem to go longer towards the ARMY logo.. kind of reminded me of RM's part in BOY WITH LUV.. "towards you.. let me fly"
I'm whale 🐋
wait! was that a centipede ?
that got me HAHAHAH
You actually got more references than anyone else I watched. (Except, I guess the Wings tour outfits)
I'll probably go unnoticed but the red part of N.O. reminded me of the red pills they were told to swallow in that MV. Like to control them, so that's why Hobi ends up being caged, because they were chasing them and wanted to control them.
You missed the black ocean reference at the beginning (the black wave) which represents when haters turned off their Light sticks at awards shows n how they end with the purple ocean of ARMY light sticks when their on top