@@Mooslerherzog Das ist mir auch bekannt. Ich dachte, Sie wüssten etwas, warum Monsieur Dufour den Philharmonikern schon wieder den Rücken kehrt. Er war ja noch gar nicht so lange im Orchester...
Wow! This performance has made me look at this piece completely afresh. The way the woodwinds played, it was almost as if the music was floating above everybody in that hall, quite ethereal honestly. Oh, and the bass players too! Completely shredding into those notes, I was like “wait this has always been in this piece and i’ve never noticed until now!” Pretty amazing talent here ✨
So beautiful! I easily fall into the fantasy of Berlioz without any resistance. I hope this wonderful performance will be released on CD & vinyl record soon. Thank you for the music!
una grandissima edizione, che emozione. Direzione magnifica (grande Salonen), orchestra (sempre) eccezionale, ottima regia e immagini. E quelle campane del Sabba ! un degno coronamento e ottima conclusione. Bravissimi !
Magnífica obra romántica del genial compositor Héctor Berlioz.Es una obra cargada de suspense romántico.Es una obra preciosa en sus cinco movimientos.Estupenda dirección,y la orquesta inmejorable.Bravo por NDR.Sinceras gracias.Sigan ofreciéndonos felicidad.
As I have heard many times before, the acoustics in this hall is just super! Together with clever sound engineers this makes my listening so enjoyable. Thank you so much.
The cherry blossoms in full bloom is a good match for Berlioz‘s gorgeousness and wonderfulness Now in Tokyo the cherry blossoms are in full bloom everywhere The scenery is out of this world I am listening to this masterpiece while watching the cherry blossoms in full bloom This is a blissful time for me
At 38:33 we see the timpanist uses alternating strokes with his left and right hands. Being a timpanist myself ,the composer intended for this passage to be played with only one hand . However, at this fast tempo it is extremely difficult to do that . Just my observation
Was ein Spektakel, wäre ich sehr gerne dabei gewesen. Ist ein anderer Tonmeister als sonst am Werk? Insbesondere das Blech hört sich anders an und auch der Saal selber scheint nicht so tückisch wie sonst. Vielen Dank für den Genuss.
Vielen Dank, das freut uns sehr :) Wie kein Konzert dem anderen gleicht, so gleicht auch keine Aufnahme der anderen. Wer beteiligt war, sehen Sie im Abspann. Viel Vergnügen weiterhin mit unseren Konzertmitschnitten.
The Oboe player is often is an alcove offstage. The beginning of the 3rd movement is meant to echo Berlioz’s childhood near the French alps. This specific bit with the English Horn and the Oboe is meant to mimic two shepherds playing their “Ranz des Vaches” on alpenhorns. Hope this clears up the understanding
Todo bien, menos las campanas del último movimiento. ¿Es que no pueden conseguir unas con un timbre más siniestro y un tono bastante más grave? ¡Es una fantasmagoría romántica y demoníaca, no un cuento de hadas!
Salonen is just a pretty robot...not much imaginative....nothing like Karajan or Abbado....just a little modern robot...and a terrible composer....completely overrated.
...the music just doesn't breathe...it's just set to a modern, robotic metronome...like Salonen himself.... a little robot....nothing more. terrible conductor and composer...the worst.
I adore La Symphonie Fantastique and this is one of the most beautiful interpretations I've heard. Thank you so much!
Happy to share, happy to read your comment! Thank you! 😊
Grand orchestre!
The bass trombone at 39:54!! So sinister! I love it
love to see Andreas Blau, the great ex flutist of the Berlin Phil here :)
Er kann ja auch in Berlin "aushelfen", wenn die Stelle von Mathieu Dufour nicht sofort besetzt werden kann.
@@Mooslerherzog Warum verlässt der denn schon wieder die Berliner Philharmoniker? Wissen Sie da was?
@con brio ja die Stelle von M. Dufour ist offiziell von den Berliner Philharmonikern ausgeschrieben, das Probespiel soll Ende Mai stattfinden.
@@Mooslerherzog Das ist mir auch bekannt. Ich dachte, Sie wüssten etwas, warum Monsieur Dufour den Philharmonikern schon wieder den Rücken kehrt. Er war ja noch gar nicht so lange im Orchester...
@@conbrio825 den eigentlichen Grund kenne ich nicht, haben Sie einen Tipp wer der oder die Nachfolger/in wird;)?
I have to say, this is trade-mark Esa Pekka Salonen sound. He likes resonance that resonance.
I’ve listened to perhaps 250 recordings of Symphonie Fantastique, but none of them come close to the NDR Elbphilharmonie Orchester. Flawless! 你們太棒了！
We feel honored - thank you for the compliment!
Époustouflant...tout Berlioz est là. Merci ❤
Wunderschöne english horn solo!
Ja! Das ist unsere Englischhornistin Beate Aanderud! :)
So happy to have Salonen here as MD of the San Francisco Symphony
Yes, we can imagine! :)
And they say conductors don’t make a difference. Never heard the NDR better. And that hall. Magnificent! And Herr. Blau on flute. Wonderful.
Thank you for listening! We are glad to have you with us.
Huge musical wonder of a version. To relish & treasure.
Thanks 😊 . from south Korea
You are very welcome! Greetings from Hamburg to South Korea!!
Best ever Finish conductor of all time !!!
A great big thank you to all the woodwinds, a brilliant performance
Thank you (in the name of our woodwinds section)!!
Love Maestro Salonen's tempi. Music just flows naturally like the notes write themselves!
A wonderful thought, the one about the notes writing themselves during the consert! And I agree about the tempi.
They were certainly very nimble witches
Bravo!! Das Orchester wird immer besser! Klingt einfach fantastisch!!!
Danke für die netten Worte!
I like the guest principle flutist. I've seen him elsewhere before? Lol.
Always lovely to see and hear Andreas Blau!
Bravi!! zwei Tuben:)
perfect, bravissimo
Danke für das Musikstück
Gern geschehen! :) Danke fürs Kommentieren!
Très bon orchestre, très bon chef. Bravo Maestro !
Merci. très gentil! :)
L'enregistrement est excellent.
Ein sehr gutes video das
Vielen Dank! :)
Fantastic performance, I always enjoy watching you.
Thank you so much! We are happy to hear that. :)
Großartiges Orchester und Dirigent !!!!!
Vielen herzlichen Dank! :))
Fantastic performance! love the use of sort of ancient instruments and the use of the cornet in the second movement! great Conductor and Orchestra!
Thank you! Much appreciated. :)
Symphonie Magnifique!
E vero berlioz queria 500 músicos para esta sinfonia bravo Brasil
Ah!! Soo beautiful! Thank you so much for sharing it with us!! :)
Our pleasure! Thank you for joining us!
Amazing harps. 00:14:10
this performance is exceptional! I hope NDR will release a recording of this
Thank you, much appreciated! Love the idea!!
Wunderschön !
Wow! This performance has made me look at this piece completely afresh. The way the woodwinds played, it was almost as if the music was floating above everybody in that hall, quite ethereal honestly. Oh, and the bass players too! Completely shredding into those notes, I was like “wait this has always been in this piece and i’ve never noticed until now!” Pretty amazing talent here ✨
So happy to hear this, thank you so much!! 🤩🤩🤩
Such wonderful symphony with it's beautiful waltz movement and it's conducting is perfection. Love it
Yay!! Thank you for commenting!
Sono arrivato alla fine senza fiato. Esecuzione incredibile!
Grazie mille!! :))
I was streaming the concert on tv. Exquisite! Thank you.
Awesome! The pleasure is ours!
So beautiful! I easily fall into the fantasy of Berlioz without any resistance. I hope this wonderful performance will be released on CD & vinyl record soon. Thank you for the music!
You can download it on your own...
This interpretation is wider, deeper and higher than all I have heard before. Thank you, Esa-Pekka Salonen and NDR Elbphilharmonie Orchester.
Tack så mycket!! We are happy to hear that. :))
@@NDRKlassik Svar på svenska! Jo jag tackar jag!
una grandissima edizione, che emozione. Direzione magnifica (grande Salonen), orchestra (sempre) eccezionale, ottima regia e immagini. E quelle campane del Sabba ! un degno coronamento e ottima conclusione. Bravissimi !
Really fantastic!!!
Yay!! Thank you!
Great playing!
Thank you!!
A musical fantasy . So beautiful and spell binding. Every note is magically played to perfection. Thank you all. Bravo...
Thank you so much! :)) We are happy to hear that you enjoyed it!
Magnífica obra romántica del genial compositor Héctor Berlioz.Es una obra cargada de suspense romántico.Es una obra preciosa en sus cinco movimientos.Estupenda dirección,y la orquesta inmejorable.Bravo por NDR.Sinceras gracias.Sigan ofreciéndonos felicidad.
Muchas gracias!!
As I have heard many times before, the acoustics in this hall is just super! Together with clever sound engineers this makes my listening so enjoyable. Thank you so much.
Our pleasure!! Thank you for joining!
length of the notes, he holds it just a tad longer when needed. very appropriate.
멋진 연주 감사합니다 ^^
Thank you!! Much appreciated!
The cherry blossoms in full bloom is a good match for Berlioz‘s gorgeousness and wonderfulness
Now in Tokyo
the cherry blossoms are in full bloom everywhere
The scenery is out of this world
I am listening to this masterpiece while watching the cherry blossoms in full bloom
This is a blissful time for me
Thank you, dear friend!
@@NDRKlassik
You are welcome
I hope you are well
ｗｏｎｄｅｒｆｕｌ
Thank you!!
Perfect!
Thank you!!
これは名演だ！さすがはサロネン。フランス音楽のベルリオーズをドイツのオーケストラが見事に表現！ワルプルギスの夜、良い鐘の音。
Much appreciated, thank you so much!
Terrific performance! Does anyone know the name of the lady that plays the oboe "solo"? I really enjoyed her playing.
If you mean the big cor anglais solo, that is Beate Aanderud.
@@alkanista That's her. Thank you.
At 38:33 we see the timpanist uses alternating strokes with his left and right hands. Being a timpanist myself ,the composer intended for this passage to be played with only one hand . However, at this fast tempo it is extremely difficult to do that . Just my observation
Is there anyone more mesmerizing than Maestro Salonen? No.
We are big fans too! :)
Thank God for Bass Trombones!
💖
Was ein Spektakel, wäre ich sehr gerne dabei gewesen. Ist ein anderer Tonmeister als sonst am Werk? Insbesondere das Blech hört sich anders an und auch der Saal selber scheint nicht so tückisch wie sonst. Vielen Dank für den Genuss.
Vielen Dank, das freut uns sehr :) Wie kein Konzert dem anderen gleicht, so gleicht auch keine Aufnahme der anderen. Wer beteiligt war, sehen Sie im Abspann. Viel Vergnügen weiterhin mit unseren Konzertmitschnitten.
interesting Dudamel came from France Paris, while Salonen went to Germany.
21:35 Why does he face the audience?
Because the oboe player plays off-stage! So he is actually turning to face him - not so much the audience. ;)
The Oboe player is often is an alcove offstage. The beginning of the 3rd movement is meant to echo Berlioz’s childhood near the French alps. This specific bit with the English Horn and the Oboe is meant to mimic two shepherds playing their “Ranz des Vaches” on alpenhorns. Hope this clears up the understanding
you would have to ask players of the LA Philharmonic how they regard him. Philadelphia Orchestra days, like Mutti, Ormandy ...
Todo bien, menos las campanas del último movimiento. ¿Es que no pueden conseguir unas con un timbre más siniestro y un tono bastante más grave? ¡Es una fantasmagoría romántica y demoníaca, no un cuento de hadas!
Interesting thought!
幻想交響曲のトップクラスの演奏。幻想交響曲を聴く人はこれを標準とすべきだろう。
Salonen is just a pretty robot...not much imaginative....nothing like Karajan or Abbado....just a little modern robot...and a terrible composer....completely overrated.
...the music just doesn't breathe...it's just set to a modern, robotic metronome...like Salonen himself.... a little robot....nothing more. terrible conductor and composer...the worst.
Not an excellent symphony. Sounds disjointed.
Interesting comment. Disjointed ? That's exactly the intent !
@@tortysoft There seems to be no connection between movements. That's why I dislike it.
@@changeamerica What do you mean by no connection between movements? Care to explain what you mean?