Forge Battle! Gas Forge vs. Coal Forge - Which is better?

Поделиться
HTML-код
  • Опубликовано: 24 дек 2024

Комментарии •

  • @jodydille8612
    @jodydille8612 6 месяцев назад +2

    You have some great insight into both the pros and cons of each. This was a very informative video.

  • @SchysCraftCo.
    @SchysCraftCo. Год назад +1

    Thanks so much Drew. This video was very informative and helpful video this week. Can't wait to see more videos soon. Keep up the great craftsmanship and hard work my friend. Forge On. Fab On. Weld On. Keep forge lit. Keep Making. God bless.

  • @jonandersen3347
    @jonandersen3347 Год назад +2

    watched all your videos. hope there is more to come.

  • @lazerfrazer5918
    @lazerfrazer5918 Год назад +1

    Great video! Very informative

  • @Skyhors3
    @Skyhors3 Год назад +2

    Coal creates a deeper heat at the same color, where gas seems to create a more superficial heat.
    You can feel it.
    Other blacksmiths agree.

  • @waveman0
    @waveman0 Год назад +3

    gas forges offer a level of consistency and even heat that I enjoy, you can put your work in a gas forge and leave it in there for an hour if you wish and it will never burn. I also like how they do not emit a lot of fumes or require much in the way of fire maintenance.
    If you run the right gas forge you can easily do anything you can do in a coal forge and for me, the gas forge is the only choice.

    • @drew.alexander
      @drew.alexander  Год назад

      Thanks for watching 👀

    • @CChan11
      @CChan11 Год назад +1

      Agree, if a gas forge is set up even halfway right, you can use them to forge-weld easily. I've even been able to forge weld wrought iron with mine.

  • @9black9mark9
    @9black9mark9 Год назад +1

    My gas forges are forced air, work on propane or house pressure natural gas, and easily hit welding temperatures. Aside from that, pretty good information. 👍🏼

  • @BurntMushroomBlacksmithing
    @BurntMushroomBlacksmithing Год назад +2

    Its all in the details, I agree. Skill, the project, ect. I've been using coal/char for my entire venture so far. But I'm currently finishing up putting together my first gas forge. I got the Mr volcano hero #2. It was a great price and the option of being portable. That and the length it has.
    I just made a sale to my neighbor( a pair of sheppards hooks) and now he wants a cooking tripod. With my coal forge, I was able to do the hooks just fine, but I would have liked to use the length of the gas.(I can get around 10 to almost 15 inches hot at a time depending on the stock)Same goes for the tripod. I did a small test piece to see if he still wanted one, and I bet it would have taken half the time using the gas one. Plus currently I'm not using a fire pot. (I dont have welding equipment) so i made "sort of" a small trench forge with pipe and big fire brick. Works great, but i need a pot asap lol. I was fortunate and found a homemade steel box grill that someone threw out. Looks just like a classic square coal forge without the hole for a pot. Did some modifications and bam!
    But enough ranting, looking forward to your video on pricing work and such. 🍻

  • @therondodds4588
    @therondodds4588 Год назад

    Where do you get your coal from in the USA

  • @theluth9046
    @theluth9046 Год назад +1

    I like coal becuz that's what I got.😊I take mine outside so heat is not a problem especially when it's 30deg out! Oh yeah, mine is potable. I'm a shade tree blacksmith, ya know kinda like a shade tree mechanic.
    I just came onto your channel and subscribed,
    Can't believe you don't have more subscribers,
    I got to past the word on my end, enjoyed your video!

  • @SunriseSideIronworks
    @SunriseSideIronworks 9 месяцев назад

    Love the old time feel of of a coal forge. I also admire the convenience of a gas forge. Unfortunately, I can only use a gas forge in city limits. Coal forge is only used for demonstrations and reenactment. Makes me sad honestly.

  • @steveparker8723
    @steveparker8723 11 месяцев назад

    It depends on what kind of work you're doing.

  • @jasonscott7803
    @jasonscott7803 Год назад

    👍✌️

  • @TheGibberingGoblin
    @TheGibberingGoblin Месяц назад

    bump