Stop saying Indian CEO. Start saying Indian Hindu CEO. Because all the CEO you see in USA are Hindus (under Article 25 of Constitution of India, definition of Hindu - includes Hindu, Sikh, Jain and Buddhist). You will not find even one Muslim Indian CEO in USA. Why? Because Muslims in India are also just like Muslims in Pakistan and Bangladesh. Islam and education and peace and sanity and progress do not go together.
in Malaysia top five ultra rich are not of the country 's religion, the curse of the country is army and are comfortable in their control add over the years religious bigots over the years have got control with monies coming for outstanding they do work
Uncle, forget a city.... let me give you a finer truth. FIVE Nobel Laureates who had some association with a single college, "Presidency College Calcutta". (1) Rabindranath Tagore (Nobel Prize in Literature, 1913) (2) C. V. Raman (Nobel Prize in Physics, 1930) (3) Amartya Sen (Nobel Prize in Economic Sciences, 1998) (4) Subrahmanyan Chandrasekhar (Nobel Prize in Physics, 1983) (5) Abhijit Banerjee (Nobel Prize in Economic Sciences, 2019)
@@harpreetgill4735 then why do they have to establish false equivalence to placate extremists. All religions are not equal. There are fundamental differences between different religions. You don't have pull yourself down to criticize others.
@@harpreetgill4735 गिल साहब आपके दिमाग में अब नफरत भर चुकी है गुरु नानक जी की शिक्षा से आप कोशो दूर हो चुके है, इस लिए आपको कमेंट समझ नही आ रहा है, गुरुकुल से पढ़े लोग आईएएस पीसीएस बनते है कहिएगा तो आपको नाम बता दूंगा मदरसा में कोई एक बताओ, क्यू की गुरु कुल में जो पढ़ाया उसमे वैदिक मैथ होता है, उसमे फिलोसोफी होती है उसमे शास्त्रार्थ करने के लिए लोगो को तैयार किया जाता है मदरसा की तरह मारने को नही
How gurukul and madarsa bhi compare ...UN me ek bhi Hindu terrorist nahi Hai, ek bhi Hindu organization....Dr. ho stats and data to dekh lo ....pakistaniyo ke sath reh kr unka assar pad raha hai
Nobel means USA Deep state association to discreadit that govt, that country,... Look at Bangladezhi nobel , Russian. Person who got nobel, or Pakistani Malala, aur other next from pakistan will be..Boloch girl.... all they are USA deep state association or Agent...even in india story are nearly same
Chander Sharma is lying when he compares Gurukul education with Madrassa education. I felt he spoke it with lot of hesitation as he did not have the courage to outrightly criticise the madrassa education before two Pakistanis whom I hold in high esteem specially Shakeel Chaudhry. My own mother studied in Gurukul Kangri and never never she taught us anything against any religion. Dr Sharma has done injustice by comparing Gurukul with Madrassa.
Gurukul kangri is not a religious school. It is 100% normal school, where nobody teaching religion. It is an type of boarding school where all work have been done by students, like cooking, jhadu, pocha etc. That's why children are afraid.
Aaliya Ji...It's not only education but radicalisation of youth which should be cause of concern for Pakistan...If people don't have the skills of critical thinking then how creativity is possible. Without critical thinking it is not possible for any science to flourish...🙂🙂
Today Pakistan is in Social, Economical & Political Crisis. Most of the Pakistanis believe Islam is the solution to their Social problems, and they should be more religious. Most of the Pakistanis believe Military is the solution for their Political problems, and they should have Army Rule. Most of the Pakistanis believe USA/Arab Aid is the solution for their Economic problems, and they should expect more Aid. In reality, what they believe as Solutions, are the REAL Reasons of their current crisis.
Sanatan religion is not like Abrahamic religion sanatani religious person becomes cool and calm when they study their religious books in sanskrit and it has been found that sanskrit makes makes human sensible and calm.
To Chander Sharma... Religion does not block an individual's thinking. I urge you to see a shrink and clear your head. Mr. Somnath = Chairman ISRO, is a deeply religious Hindu. It is confused people like who are responsible for making Punjab a basket case in India.
Fact Sheet ---The overall India's literacy rate in 2024 is 85.95%. The state with highest literacy rate is Kerala(99.31%). -The state with lowest literacy rate is Andhra Pradesh(70.66%). Youth literacy rate (15-24 years) in India--96%
Mr. Sharma, i think you just got carried away in your comparison of Gurukul and Madarsa. Gurukuls has been and still is the most scientific style of education where kids are groomed in updated academics alongside discipline and values of being a good human being. The teachings of Sanatan can never be completed with Islamic teaching because Sanatan teaches to unite and respect for all creatures of the God, unlike Islamic teaching.
In US, UK, EU & other Western countries don't believe Ummah states to outsource the work, you may get some freelance work but corporates will not outsource.
C P Sharma ji you are learned and respected person but I am surprised that you are equalising the Madarsa with the Sanatani Gurukul, the Gurukul teaches the all the aspects of the once life.Please Try to search meaning of both the Dharma and the Religion.No Gurukul produced a single terrorist.
"Gurukul" is normally associated with good quality education -- and a balanced curriculum. However, if Sharmaji as a child felt uncomfortable at the thought of "being sent to gurukul", it might have been that he felt he'd be sent away to a boarding school. Not all young children like being away from home from their parents. Madrasas, on the other hand, are GENERALLY, not always, vile, evil, unproductive places for the delivery of education for the 21st century: Madrasas usually deliver fake curricula, employ medieval teaching methods, dirty, inadequate facilities and extracurricular activities. Madrasas are thus grievously short changing -- most cruelly and unforgivably -- (a) the students themselves (b) parents, most of whom are misguided or uneducated and (c) society & a nation (be it India or Pakistan or anywhere else). Madrasas are generally a blatant insult to a progressive educational provision to which all children are -- should be -- entitled. I say this (as a specialist educationist and) without referring to various reported nefarious, criminal activities Madrasas tend to engage in -- from ill treatment of boys and girls, Jihad education and to operating factories for fake, counterfeit R100 notes, as reported.
You cannot equate Hindu philosophy and Gurukul teachings with Madarsa and church teachings, Hinduism doesn't teach hatred towards other religions on thr contrary Abrahamic religions sow seeds of hatred about other religions.
Kalma and Jajba that are the your achievements and assets, so there are no need for the educational , developmental, and financial aspects to bother about.
Excellent commentary by these two illustrious men. Thanks Aaliya for hosting them. I am an eighty year old Indian Hindu, I read, in school, about freedom fighters, historical figures like Akbar, Rani Laxmibai , Rana pratap, Sher shah and Lodhi, sant Kabir but I feel , still, challenged by very little knowledge of Gita and Ramayana leave alone Upanishads.
What do you expect from him when he is hosting Pakistani jihadis everyday at his home in the hope of reviving Aman ki asha... Shakil sir is far more rational pragmatic and logical than this jihadi lover Sharma and the shameless Rakesh Vaid...
Very sorry to say Mr Chandra Pal Sharma was not correct while comparing Gurukul Kangri to any Madarsa of Pakistan! Gurukul has not produced any kind of terrorism & hatred against any religion while Madarsa can't run without hatred against non believers of Islam & so on !
What an analysis!!! My kudos to you I recall distinctly Dr Hargovind Khorana was invited to deliver a lecture at McGill , that was early in 1971. Mr Khosla from California , ceo of Sun system donated millions of dollars to IIT Bombay to improve the education in IT There are umpteenth examples of Dr Sharma’ narrative
Shakil Sahib discusses any matter as a human being and not as a Muslim. As such ,he falls in the rarest of rare category of Muslims. Incisive, penetrative and very clear in his thinking. As regards Madarsa and Gurukul, can anybody cite any single person who had studied in Gurukul becoming a terrorist.Note down carefully Gurukul is akin to wisdom.Love and good wishes.
India mein only Sanatani Dharma cannot be taught in Schools. The minorities can teach their religion, indeed. A Hindu infact cannot even legally preach. The " Sri Ramakrishna Mission, hence call themselves as non Hindus. They call themselves "Sri Ramakrishna Missionites". Nehruji ki qartoot hai ye.
It's really interesting to hear Aaliya Shah that religion (i.e. study of the holy Quran) is "compulsory" in Pakistan!! In the UK, for example, "religious education" is compulsory at earlier stages of schooling -- but UK "religious study" curriculum is not about "Bible bashing": it's about multi-faith, multi-traditions, multi-rituals and cultures, festivals. -- so that pupils develop a mature appreciation of the modern Britain with its rich population profile. I have just become aware of the "Mutalia Pakistan" deeply embedded in the curriculum too! With my developing awareness, I'm now able to explain why the Chief of Pakistan Army starts his "Independence Day" speech with a mantra from the Quran (or another religious text, I'm not sure which). Have you ever seen or heard a British, a Ukrainian, a French, or an American General starting his speech by saying -- "Holy Mother of God, in the Name of Jesus Christ".. etc. Neither will you hear an Indian General starting his speech by chanting a mantra or a part of it ( Jai Siya Ram, Maata Gayatri, Om Sita Maiyya). Presumably in Pakistan it's common practice to start a meaningful conversation, a speech, an address with a mantra from the holy quran (or Hadith?). What I have found even more puzzling is that some educated participants in a RUclips video start their commentaries with --- Bismillahir Rahmanir Raheem" (بِسْمِ ٱللَّٰهِ ٱلرَّحْمَٰنِ ٱلرَّحِيمِ), which translates to "In the name of Allah, the Most Gracious, the Most Merciful" . I'm sure someone will enlighten me in due course as to what Allah, Jesus Christ or Bhagwan Ram has got to do with the start of a conversation about US politics, for example? Nor have I ever heard anyone in India & UK or US -- In the course of a discussion on, say, the fluctuations in the exchange rates -- starting with ..".In the name of the Father, the Son and the Holy Spirit"" .... Pakistani scholars and commentators, not all thankfully, often do, Bismillahir Rahmanir Raheem” (بِسْمِ ٱللَّٰهِ ٱلرَّحْمَٰنِ ٱلرَّحِيمِ). Confused? I am, very.🙃🙃
@aaliyaji excellent discussion,n over view about very interesting topic, about education, brain drain etc by two amazing guests, Sharmaji & Shakil saab . Jk South India
Pl avoid comparing India with Pakistan,as both are completely different countries.Pak was created purely on the basis of religion n after creation it either converted the minorities or drove out of country.On the other hand india,though having the opportunity of creating a Hindu state, opted for a secular state.Since the first day pak became a radical islami state,factually governed by army.Now it has converted into a garrison state and most of the people mujahidins.Untill the mindset of people is changed, sorry to say,pak will not progress.
Six Nobel Prize winners have been associated with the city of Kolkata (Calcutta): Sir Ronald Ross (1857-1932) - medicine, 1902 Rabindranath Tagore (1861-1941) - literature, 1913; first Asian to win the Nobel Prize CV Raman (1888-1970) - physics, 1930 Mother Teresa (1910-1997) - peace, 1979 Amartya Sen (b. 1933) - economics, 1998 Abhijit Banerjee (b. 1961) - economics, 2019
Sharma ji This is very often with that generation I do agree with you sir I also remeber my father and whenever he fired he said the same thing to me@Rakesh Sharma
where im living two Bhartiyas receiced country's highst civil award,one of them came here only 1000 US Dollar in his pocket and now he is one of the richest of coutry.while pakistanis spending their entire day setting in pakistani mosque and talking pakistani politics,enjoying government well-fare policies.
India produces extra trained professionals hence export them to USA and west. They return lot of foreign currency to India. About 20 percent students come back to India with technologies and establish new companies or join Indian companies. So beneficial for India.
In India there are many Saraswati Vidya Mandir that cater education up to 12 th standard. Though these schools are guided by Hindu ethos, the students pass out from these schools excel in Math and Science so much that no convent educated English medium school student can match . There can be no comparison between Madrasas and Saraswati Vidya Mandir.
Jaise main Hindu😮 Hamare school mein Hindu ke bare mein Kuchh Nahin padhaayaa Jata😮 Koi Puja paath karen to theek na karen to theek Sabko Khuli chhut hai
Yahi toh farak hai tumhe aur Musalmanon mein.... they are very strong in their faith and will do anything to spread it... that's why Hindu girls easily fall for them because Hindus make fun of their own religion...phir cheekte raho love jihad, forced conversion....
Is it logical to say “brain drain” when the citizens who get themselves educated in country with fees and loans but do not get suitable or any employment? One could say such departure to find position abroad is a service to those who may have similar background but have no job or prospects. Brain drain alleviates employment. Education provided or supported by state is human right and the state or local citizens should not view the pursuit of employment as “drain”
Nafrat se phursat milegi tab hi to education ke liye time milega na. Current education system has to be discarded as it has delivered jahalat and jihadi mindset only.
I think India is being helped by bigger base effect too, btw. More population means more successful people, more successful people support more less successful people.. It's a cycle.
Education is not the only reason, it's one of the multiple reasons. The Real Education is those values that you give to your children at home, in the environment where they are brought up. When you teach them that all kinds of Wrongs done to the Kafirs are Halal in the eyes of Allah, the real problem starts with This Education.
Aapne sab se pehle ghabrana Nahin hai. Paxstan ki bhi 40 Billion Daalars ki Begging Industry hai. Yeh bhi koi chhoti moti baat Nahin hai. Quite an achievement. I've heard Paxstani schools mein "How to Beg" ek subject hota hai? Sab ko bachpan mein Class 1 se padhana shuru kar dete hain? That's why they are very good at it. And the top ones become PM, President, Chief Justice and of course Chief Jarnail.
Aliya mam you criticize major saahab for foul language.Why not make a reaction video for that particular episode of major saahab.so we can understand yor point of view.
Why does everything in Pakistan revolve around religion ? Do you not believe it's a personal matter to be practiced inside the confines of your house ?
Ideology of islam prepares people for the life after death ,this is called as "arzi zindagi' asal zindagi to "baad me " hai...this is common amongst indian muslims ,mark my words evej highly educated muslims also fall in thjs category only ...😂😂 How on earth will the change come at all ? Given the situation
People who do not return normally remit money back home for about 10 to 25 yrs normally, say 20 yrs max till their parents are alive. Many Indian parents in India have other sources of income & hence foreign remittances are not necessary not there always. "Brain drain" of the able who migrated is a huge loss.
Education has no significance in anyone's life. Only following the great holy book, which talks abt 2 moons, everything is bcos of Ola. Following the book, will make everyone great n biggest genius of the world.
Shakil ji kuch kijiye aap log apne desh ke bacho ke liye bhagwan kashmam me jabse wo video dekha hai mujhe abhi bhi uss age ke bache dekh ke ye lgta hai ki pakistan ke aane wale time me kitna khrank hone wala hia Aalia ji please ye bhut bara dar hai suppose kal uss bache ko indian boder ke ander nhi aa paya tho wo kal ko pakistan me bom forega kyuki usko abhi se yhi mindset me aa gya hai ki bom hi forna hai
Stop saying Indian CEO. Start saying Indian Hindu CEO. Because all the CEO you see in USA are Hindus (under Article 25 of Constitution of India, definition of Hindu - includes Hindu, Sikh, Jain and Buddhist). You will not find even one Muslim Indian CEO in USA. Why? Because Muslims in India are also just like Muslims in Pakistan and Bangladesh. Islam and education and peace and sanity and progress do not go together.
Absolutely correct
Rightly said. They are becoming debt to india
It will fall into place when you identify all European CEOs as Christians and most Chinese or Russian CEOs as atheists. Don’t be selective...
Axum Premji - CEO of WIPRO
in Malaysia top five ultra rich are not of the country 's religion, the curse of the country is army and are comfortable in their control add over the years religious bigots over the years have got control with monies coming for outstanding they do work
Madresas teaches hatred towards non Muslims and gurukul teaches love to all, and spirituality, so there's no comparison between gurukul and madresa
Uncle, forget a city.... let me give you a finer truth. FIVE Nobel Laureates who had some association with a single college, "Presidency College Calcutta". (1) Rabindranath Tagore (Nobel Prize in Literature, 1913) (2) C. V. Raman (Nobel Prize in Physics, 1930) (3) Amartya Sen (Nobel Prize in Economic Sciences, 1998) (4) Subrahmanyan Chandrasekhar (Nobel Prize in Physics, 1983) (5) Abhijit Banerjee (Nobel Prize in Economic Sciences, 2019)
Don't you dare compare Gurukul with Madrassa. Heaven and hell are opposite poles. Madrassa sey compare karke insult mat karo hamari.
Tumhara andaz hi tumhari insult kar raha... arrogance can only bring a person down
@@harpreetgill4735 then why do they have to establish false equivalence to placate extremists.
All religions are not equal. There are fundamental differences between different religions.
You don't have pull yourself down to criticize others.
💯 agree , these people just want to demean the gurukul by comparing jih@di manufacturing madarsa.
राइट
@@harpreetgill4735 गिल साहब आपके दिमाग में अब नफरत भर चुकी है गुरु नानक जी की शिक्षा से आप कोशो दूर हो चुके है, इस लिए आपको कमेंट समझ नही आ रहा है, गुरुकुल से पढ़े लोग आईएएस पीसीएस बनते है कहिएगा तो आपको नाम बता दूंगा
मदरसा में कोई एक बताओ, क्यू की गुरु कुल में जो पढ़ाया उसमे वैदिक मैथ होता है, उसमे फिलोसोफी होती है उसमे शास्त्रार्थ करने के लिए लोगो को तैयार किया जाता है मदरसा की तरह मारने को नही
How gurukul and madarsa bhi compare ...UN me ek bhi Hindu terrorist nahi Hai, ek bhi Hindu organization....Dr. ho stats and data to dekh lo ....pakistaniyo ke sath reh kr unka assar pad raha hai
Nobel means USA Deep state association to discreadit that govt, that country,... Look at Bangladezhi nobel , Russian. Person who got nobel, or Pakistani Malala, aur other next from pakistan will be..Boloch girl.... all they are USA deep state association or Agent...even in india story are nearly same
Wokeness ka Zukam hai uncle ko...
Chander Sharma is lying when he compares Gurukul education with Madrassa education. I felt he spoke it with lot of hesitation as he did not have the courage to outrightly criticise the madrassa education before two Pakistanis whom I hold in high esteem specially Shakeel Chaudhry. My own mother studied in Gurukul Kangri and never never she taught us anything against any religion. Dr Sharma has done injustice by comparing Gurukul with Madrassa.
Gurukul kangri is not a religious school. It is 100% normal school, where nobody teaching religion.
It is an type of boarding school where all work have been done by students, like cooking, jhadu, pocha etc. That's why children are afraid.
True
123 billions dollars NRI have sent into India , last year.
Aaliya Ji...It's not only education but radicalisation of youth which should be cause of concern for Pakistan...If people don't have the skills of critical thinking then how creativity is possible. Without critical thinking it is not possible for any science to flourish...🙂🙂
Sakil...There is nothing called Hyderabad Dakkhan it's Hyderabad in Telangana.
Shakil Chaudhary ISI Ka Aadmi hai.
Today Pakistan is in Social, Economical & Political Crisis.
Most of the Pakistanis believe Islam is the solution to their Social problems, and they should be more religious.
Most of the Pakistanis believe Military is the solution for their Political problems, and they should have Army Rule.
Most of the Pakistanis believe USA/Arab Aid is the solution for their Economic problems, and they should expect more Aid.
In reality, what they believe as Solutions, are the REAL Reasons of their current crisis.
Sanatan religion is not like Abrahamic religion sanatani religious person becomes cool and calm when they study their religious books in sanskrit and it has been found that sanskrit makes makes human sensible and calm.
I am a fan of Dr Shakeel Saab. A great Asset to your show.Keep it up Beti Aaliya!! Dr ChanderPal is a big Scientist but so simple !!. Lovable indeed!!
To Chander Sharma... Religion does not block an individual's thinking. I urge you to see a shrink and clear your head. Mr. Somnath = Chairman ISRO, is a deeply religious Hindu.
It is confused people like who are responsible for making Punjab a basket case in India.
India would have been more beautiful and prosperous much before without democracy nd so called secularism.
And without Muslims.
Fact Sheet ---The overall India's literacy rate in 2024 is 85.95%. The state with highest literacy rate is Kerala(99.31%). -The state with lowest literacy rate is Andhra Pradesh(70.66%).
Youth literacy rate (15-24 years) in India--96%
Yes.. Kerala has most muslims but still..nothing to show in tech ceo, etc...
Mr. Sharma, i think you just got carried away in your comparison of Gurukul and Madarsa. Gurukuls has been and still is the most scientific style of education where kids are groomed in updated academics alongside discipline and values of being a good human being. The teachings of Sanatan can never be completed with Islamic teaching because Sanatan teaches to unite and respect for all creatures of the God, unlike Islamic teaching.
What do you expect from him when he is hosting Pakistani jihadis everyday at his home in the hope of reviving Aman ki asha...
Evolution of brain stops the day a momin start reciting kalma.
In US, UK, EU & other Western countries don't believe Ummah states to outsource the work, you may get some freelance work but corporates will not outsource.
Jai Chaudhry,is from my home state ,Himachal pradesh❤❤❤❤❤
C P Sharma ji you are learned and respected person but I am surprised that you are equalising the Madarsa with the Sanatani Gurukul, the Gurukul teaches the all the aspects of the once life.Please Try to search meaning of both the Dharma and the Religion.No Gurukul produced a single terrorist.
What do you expect from him, when he is hosting Pakistani jihadis everyday at his home in the hope of reviving Aman ki asha...
"Gurukul" is normally associated with good quality education -- and a balanced curriculum. However, if Sharmaji as a child felt uncomfortable at the thought of "being sent to gurukul", it might have been that he felt he'd be sent away to a boarding school. Not all young children like being away from home from their parents. Madrasas, on the other hand, are GENERALLY, not always, vile, evil, unproductive places for the delivery of education for the 21st century: Madrasas usually deliver fake curricula, employ medieval teaching methods, dirty, inadequate facilities and extracurricular activities. Madrasas are thus grievously short changing -- most cruelly and unforgivably -- (a) the students themselves (b) parents, most of whom are misguided or uneducated and (c) society & a nation (be it India or Pakistan or anywhere else). Madrasas are generally a blatant insult to a progressive educational provision to which all children are -- should be -- entitled. I say this (as a specialist educationist and) without referring to various reported nefarious, criminal activities Madrasas tend to engage in -- from ill treatment of boys and girls, Jihad education and to operating factories for fake, counterfeit R100 notes, as reported.
Love you both teachers
Shri Shakil speaks very crystal clear and logical reasoning
Yeah...Shakil sir is far more rational, pragmatic, and logical than this jihadi lover Sharma and the shameless Rakesh Vaid...
You cannot equate Hindu philosophy and Gurukul teachings with Madarsa and church teachings, Hinduism doesn't teach hatred towards other religions on thr contrary Abrahamic religions sow seeds of hatred about other religions.
Kalma and Jajba that are the your achievements and assets, so there are no need for the educational , developmental, and financial aspects to bother about.
Excellent commentary by these two illustrious men. Thanks Aaliya for hosting them.
I am an eighty year old Indian Hindu, I read, in school, about freedom fighters, historical figures like Akbar, Rani Laxmibai , Rana pratap, Sher shah and Lodhi, sant Kabir but I feel , still, challenged by very little knowledge of Gita and Ramayana leave alone Upanishads.
धर्म या रिलीजन यदि मानव को इंसान बनाता है तो वो बुरी नही है क्योंकि इंसान बम बांधकर फटते नही है👌👌👌👌
How dare you compare gurugul with madrasa. Do you knew that madrasa is making a barbaric mob. Gurugul give wisdom.
What do you expect from him when he is hosting Pakistani jihadis everyday at his home in the hope of reviving Aman ki asha....
How dare you compare Gurukul To Madarasa.
Gurukul system was best system.
😅 Just one quick question, would you send your children to Gurukul for education with no modern education.
@@amitasharma8339 Madam , do you know that modern Gurukul system covers all aspects of life including imparting science education.
@@amitasharma8339 hamare idhar to nahi hai warna bhejte ham to
What do you expect from him when he is hosting Pakistani jihadis everyday at his home in the hope of reviving Aman ki asha... Shakil sir is far more rational pragmatic and logical than this jihadi lover Sharma and the shameless Rakesh Vaid...
@@amitasharma8339 I am actually sad that there was no proper Gurukuls during my childhood.
Very sorry to say Mr Chandra Pal Sharma was not correct while comparing Gurukul Kangri to any Madarsa of Pakistan!
Gurukul has not produced any kind of terrorism & hatred against any religion while Madarsa can't run without hatred against non believers of Islam & so on !
Very good discussion Aaliya ji
Gurukul has not sent a single terrorist. Can you say the same for a Madrassa ?
I think Costa Rica is now going to become Riyasat-e-Madina !
Enjoyed the show. Please continue with shows like this.
Simply literacy may not improve a country. Quality of education is very important
What an analysis!!!
My kudos to you
I recall distinctly Dr Hargovind Khorana was invited to deliver a lecture at McGill , that was early in 1971.
Mr Khosla from California , ceo of Sun system donated millions of dollars to IIT Bombay to improve the education in IT
There are umpteenth examples of Dr Sharma’ narrative
Pakistan was the first love of Nehru & Gandhi.
Great debate by very knowledgeable people….
Sakil shahab either keep religion or education both can't go together. Brain drain is better than brain in drain.
When public is poor...they become communist or Muslim..makes them equal n b4 most Islam countries hv free food etc...mostly poor public get converted
Shakil Sahib discusses any matter as a human being and not as a Muslim. As such ,he falls in the rarest of rare category of Muslims. Incisive, penetrative and very clear in his thinking. As regards Madarsa and Gurukul, can anybody cite any single person who had studied in Gurukul becoming a terrorist.Note down carefully Gurukul is akin to wisdom.Love and good wishes.
Thank you Aalia for bringing in these two gentlemen on the show
India mein only Sanatani Dharma cannot be taught in Schools. The minorities can teach their religion, indeed.
A Hindu infact cannot even legally preach.
The " Sri Ramakrishna Mission, hence call themselves as non Hindus. They call themselves "Sri Ramakrishna Missionites".
Nehruji ki qartoot hai ye.
Most educating episode I have seen regarding India and Pakistan.
Pl don’t mind majority of Muslims only use to go in madarasa. Religion in every sector of Islamic countries. That’s the main reason of backwardness
Very imformative.keep coming up with such videos.
Mr sharma is wrong ....jo log paisa bhejte hai india mai o urab country se bhejte hai ,jo ki labour class hota hai .... just for information
Kerela 100%
It's really interesting to hear Aaliya Shah that religion (i.e. study of the holy Quran) is "compulsory" in Pakistan!! In the UK, for example, "religious education" is compulsory at earlier stages of schooling -- but UK "religious study" curriculum is not about "Bible bashing": it's about multi-faith, multi-traditions, multi-rituals and cultures, festivals. -- so that pupils develop a mature appreciation of the modern Britain with its rich population profile. I have just become aware of the "Mutalia Pakistan" deeply embedded in the curriculum too! With my developing awareness, I'm now able to explain why the Chief of Pakistan Army starts his "Independence Day" speech with a mantra from the Quran (or another religious text, I'm not sure which). Have you ever seen or heard a British, a Ukrainian, a French, or an American General starting his speech by saying -- "Holy Mother of God, in the Name of Jesus Christ".. etc. Neither will you hear an Indian General starting his speech by chanting a mantra or a part of it ( Jai Siya Ram, Maata Gayatri, Om Sita Maiyya). Presumably in Pakistan it's common practice to start a meaningful conversation, a speech, an address with a mantra from the holy quran (or Hadith?). What I have found even more puzzling is that some educated participants in a RUclips video start their commentaries with --- Bismillahir Rahmanir Raheem" (بِسْمِ ٱللَّٰهِ ٱلرَّحْمَٰنِ ٱلرَّحِيمِ), which translates to "In the name of Allah, the Most Gracious, the Most Merciful" . I'm sure someone will enlighten me in due course as to what Allah, Jesus Christ or Bhagwan Ram has got to do with the start of a conversation about US politics, for example? Nor have I ever heard anyone in India & UK or US -- In the course of a discussion on, say, the fluctuations in the exchange rates -- starting with ..".In the name of the Father, the Son and the Holy Spirit"" .... Pakistani scholars and commentators, not all thankfully, often do, Bismillahir Rahmanir Raheem” (بِسْمِ ٱللَّٰهِ ٱلرَّحْمَٰنِ ٱلرَّحِيمِ). Confused? I am, very.🙃🙃
Chandra sahab pranaam. A lil correction with respect, gurukul not equal to madarsa🙏
@aaliyaji excellent discussion,n over view about very interesting topic, about education, brain drain etc by two amazing guests, Sharmaji & Shakil saab .
Jk
South India
Pl avoid comparing India with Pakistan,as both are completely different countries.Pak was created purely on the basis of religion n after creation it either converted the minorities or drove out of country.On the other hand india,though having the opportunity of creating a Hindu state, opted for a secular state.Since the first day pak became a radical islami state,factually governed by army.Now it has converted into a garrison state and most of the people mujahidins.Untill the mindset of people is changed, sorry to say,pak will not progress.
Six Nobel Prize winners have been associated with the city of Kolkata (Calcutta):
Sir Ronald Ross (1857-1932) - medicine, 1902
Rabindranath Tagore (1861-1941) - literature, 1913; first Asian to win the Nobel Prize
CV Raman (1888-1970) - physics, 1930
Mother Teresa (1910-1997) - peace, 1979
Amartya Sen (b. 1933) - economics, 1998
Abhijit Banerjee (b. 1961) - economics, 2019
Amartya sen to western puppet hai bhai 😊
@@mayankindian3750, nevertheless, the fact remains that he is a noble laureate and is associated with the city of Kolkata.
Sharma ji This is very often with that generation I do agree with you sir I also remeber my father and whenever he fired he said the same thing to me@Rakesh Sharma
Now a days, concern for brain drain have gone, everyone can migrate anywhere on earth for progress
Good wise discussion.keep it up
Literacy in Kerala is 99.8% and all India is 86%, which also should be 100%.
Woke Mr Sharma Comparing Gurukul with Madrasa 😂😂
Those left Pak for foreign countries are begging entrepreneurs who are CEOs of vast begging enterprises in foreign land😂😂
Most Indians, very well know dr Shakil, sir.
Almost every pakistani thinks their problem is because of "Deen se doori" but fact is pakiatan problem is their over obsession for "Deen"
where im living two Bhartiyas receiced country's highst civil award,one of them came here only 1000 US Dollar in his pocket and now he is one of the richest of coutry.while pakistanis spending their entire day setting in pakistani mosque and talking pakistani politics,enjoying government well-fare policies.
India produces extra trained professionals hence export them to USA and west. They return lot of foreign currency to India. About 20 percent students come back to India with technologies and establish new companies or join Indian companies. So beneficial for India.
This is so today...not 20 yrs b4..
Pakistan ko Sabse jyada philosophy or secular ethics padhne ki jarurat hai......
Tabhi baaki subject ko theek se pedh paoge.....🙄
In India there are many Saraswati Vidya Mandir that cater education up to 12 th standard. Though these schools are guided by Hindu ethos, the students pass out from these schools excel in Math and Science so much that no convent educated English medium school student can match . There can be no comparison between Madrasas and Saraswati Vidya Mandir.
Both guest are brilliant 🎉🎉🎉
Respect to Chander ji in india you can speak whatever you want about only Hindu religion it's shame.
Hope Govt in Pakistan, policy makers listens to Shakil saab.
आज मालूम पड़ गया कि शर्मा जी को इंग्लिश आती है ।
We can speak in india still. I am a hindu and I will not like religion in school and politics.
Jaise main Hindu😮 Hamare school mein Hindu ke bare mein Kuchh Nahin padhaayaa Jata😮 Koi Puja paath karen to theek na karen to theek Sabko Khuli chhut hai
Yahi toh farak hai tumhe aur Musalmanon mein.... they are very strong in their faith and will do anything to spread it... that's why Hindu girls easily fall for them because Hindus make fun of their own religion...phir cheekte raho love jihad, forced conversion....
Is it logical to say “brain drain” when the citizens who get themselves educated in country with fees and loans but do not get suitable or any employment? One could say such departure to find position abroad is a service to those who may have similar background but have no job or prospects. Brain drain alleviates employment. Education provided or supported by state is human right and the state or local citizens should not view the pursuit of employment as “drain”
महोदय,कई दशकों से भारत के गुरुकुल में आधुनिक शिक्षा का प्रसार हो चुका है ।
Nafrat se phursat milegi tab hi to education ke liye time milega na. Current education system has to be discarded as it has delivered jahalat and jihadi mindset only.
Only one aasmani book no other books 😢
I think India is being helped by bigger base effect too, btw. More population means more successful people, more successful people support more less successful people.. It's a cycle.
Education is not the only reason, it's one of the multiple reasons. The Real Education is those values that you give to your children at home, in the environment where they are brought up. When you teach them that all kinds of Wrongs done to the Kafirs are Halal in the eyes of Allah, the real problem starts with This Education.
Aapne sab se pehle ghabrana Nahin hai. Paxstan ki bhi 40 Billion Daalars ki Begging Industry hai. Yeh bhi koi chhoti moti baat Nahin hai. Quite an achievement. I've heard Paxstani schools mein "How to Beg" ek subject hota hai? Sab ko bachpan mein Class 1 se padhana shuru kar dete hain? That's why they are very good at it. And the top ones become PM, President, Chief Justice and of course Chief Jarnail.
Aliya mam you criticize major saahab for foul language.Why not make a reaction video for that particular episode of major saahab.so we can understand yor point of view.
Biggest question is why she invited gaurav Arya in her show if he is foul mouth
Namaskar Aliya ji 🙏👍
Yah log literacy rate mein madrasa ki dini talim bhi jodte honge🤣🤣
Everything is devoured by Mazhab.
Jay Choudhary's net worth = 11 billion dollars
Jab tak pakistan k log philosophy nahi pedhenge tab tak unko peta nahi legega ki sab religion man made hai....🚩🙏
Increase the number of population who are religious asset. By that you can rule the world.
95% Indian Hindus are educated,
Very nice cmant
Kolkata city gave us 6 novel laureates
Hinduism koi kitab nahi jo padhaya jay. Ye ek way of life hai
Dr .shahab west ki tension lo ,jahan reh Rahe ho ???aap ki theory Europe and uk me fail ho gai ???
Why does everything in Pakistan revolve around religion ? Do you not believe it's a personal matter to be practiced inside the confines of your house ?
Educated but leftist minded ?
Aaliya ji Aaj live nahin aana hai kya 😀😀
Ideology of islam prepares people for the life after death ,this is called as "arzi zindagi' asal zindagi to "baad me " hai...this is common amongst indian muslims ,mark my words evej highly educated muslims also fall in thjs category only ...😂😂 How on earth will the change come at all ? Given the situation
Religion can not earn you bread and butter
Actually it does so.. everywhere
How come Pakistan was able to make Nuclear Bomb?
Stolen technology by a ahmadia working in Europe n rest by USA..
Hare Krishna
People who do not return normally remit money back home for about 10 to 25 yrs normally, say 20 yrs max till their parents are alive. Many Indian parents in India have other sources of income & hence foreign remittances are not necessary not there always.
"Brain drain" of the able who migrated is a huge loss.
Education has no significance in anyone's life. Only following the great holy book, which talks abt 2 moons, everything is bcos of Ola. Following the book, will make everyone great n biggest genius of the world.
Shakil ji kuch kijiye aap log apne desh ke bacho ke liye bhagwan kashmam me jabse wo video dekha hai mujhe abhi bhi uss age ke bache dekh ke ye lgta hai ki pakistan ke aane wale time me kitna khrank hone wala hia Aalia ji please ye bhut bara dar hai suppose kal uss bache ko indian boder ke ander nhi aa paya tho wo kal ko pakistan me bom forega kyuki usko abhi se yhi mindset me aa gya hai ki bom hi forna hai