I strongly disagree that one should follow "American logic and thinking" because it is a big stronge country, or because you received American education. What it means to be a scholar is to have one's own thinking and train of thought based on facts and reason. I received my Ph. D in America, but 9 out of 10 times I disagree with their way of thinking either because it is irrational or immoral or both. Just because your are trained there does not mean you automatically follow their logic or point of view.
My friend, One is thinking alike can be due to many factors. Someone is assimilated to American logic and reasoning might be just a matter of subconsciousness, where American thinking is widely available in mainstream media, education, cultural activities etc. If you were studying your Bachelor, Master, PhD all the way in States, and watching/reading all the movies, TV series, Comedies, stories books, literatures from the States, PLUS, eating all the fast foods since you were a teenager, it's not easy to be an "independent thinker" all the time. French teenagers love McD too!!!
Anglo-Saxon wins in many way because they have conquered the world, spreading the culture, language, philosophy, influences. Many learned people would not be able to look from other angle as they have been led to think in "one way". Many would not find it easy if one have to reverse their thought, more over if ones have been arrogant of their absolute truth.
This is a terrific program incomparable to any of of other mediocre Taiwanese YT political commentaries. An elite background like Pro. Young is not able to get an entry into local legislatures representative is an absurd for this nation. Too many meager fluffy filled in this representatives legislators.
Exceptionalism 不存粹是例外论, 它还有以下的意思:独特论 much greater than usual, especially in skill, intelligence, quality, etc. (尤指在技能、才智、品质等方面)卓越的,杰出的,不同凡响的 American exceptionalism is the belief that the United States is either distinctive, unique, or exemplary compared to other nations.
马凯硕这样的清醒者还是太少了
天哪天哪~真希望馬凱碩能到廣角演講一場!!(◍•ᴗ•◍)❤
观看了马凯硕的几个短片,不随波逐流,立场不偏不倚,温吞吞的讲述见解却一针见血。
温吞吞?平合理性,勉强可以成为温和,但温和和温吞吞是一个意思吗?
迫不及待看馬凱碩演講
馬凱碩能現身在台灣的政治論壇講話,實在是太好了。多謝楊博士的精警報導!希望往後能看到更多相關報導😊
但去听他讲话的估计都会被抹红吧,我期待四叉猫之流会裸体去闹场。
@@edwardhochwand9063 四插貓沒那種水準敢去聽演講
謝謝楊教授. 世界有人說真話太激勵了
杨教授棒棒棒💪👍👏👏👏
楊教授好~謝謝🙏您;加油!go go
太棒了!希望能陸續介紹此論壇中不同的聲音,幫助我們全方位了解事情各層面。
支持廣角智庫!💞
有興趣的好朋友,馬教授的每一本著作都很好都非常的淺顯易懂!
感謝教授分享、講評,東西方學者對現下國際時事的論點,更教導我們必需用更寬廣的心態、視野去觀察、體會對事情的層次與角度。
今天杨老师讲得很好
中华民族的崛起依然漫长曲折,但隐隐看到了远处的那束光亮,加油华人同胞~
楊永明教授的節目 非常棒👍🙏🏻👍🙏🏻🌹
我看過馬凱碩教授的演說,真是一位智者,令人佩服!
支持教授!
太棒了,替我們增大國際視野和深度。
謝謝楊教授。👍👍👍💪💪💪👏👏👏🙏🙏🙏✌️✌️✌️
杨教授在分享学者的论见是非常的有水平,非常到位。❤
都是有大智慧的人。
谢谢杨教授的分享❤
廣角加油❤!
意猶未盡,請下次再播更詳細的內容
謝謝永明和亮哥。Joseph Nye仍沉浸在馬凱碩所說的美國例外論(American Exceptionalism)的信仰中,看不到大陸對美的挑戰是多領域的,不像蘇聯1950-1960年只在一個領域(太空)挑戰美國。
nye 老了,思维闭塞,不过也应该不久于人世,没有影响力
盼望又期待~
兴奋又渴望~❤
非常及时的点评❤
很開心看到台灣的精英和世界的精英在一起!
谢谢杨永明教授分享你在那论壇得到的讯息和个人看点,非常喜欢!我也是Professor Mahbubani 的支持者,李光耀资政是我最崇拜的国家领导人;原因是我在ASEAN国家生长,从小在新马穿梭,后来到了美国升学,毕业后也继续在美国发展事业且定居下来,一恍也在这里三十年了。近十年來,看到美国的改变,很让人为它失望和失去信心!美国的政府、政治人物、大多数人民和某些政治学者,除了缺乏对外国的认知和囯际常识之外,往往还以自己自以为是的傲慢和霸道的自私态度来强硬主导和插手事情,其实自家的事都搞得一团糟,还要去理别人的事或去整别人,这将是美国对自己将来最大的败笔。我对美国的前景真不抱希望,几年前萌起候鸟归巢的想法了,更时不时对在上着大学的孩子建议考虑毕业后往新马、香港或大陆发展工作事业。
Agree. I have a similar observations,
解析非常棒!赞👍!!等待下期!!!
支持我们华人的智慧星,杨教授。
杨教授好
支持🎉
杨老师真厉害!加油
楊老師今天真棒!
马凯硕对米尔海斯莫,这太有趣了。两位都是极有名望的政治学者,但刚好是对中国的意见是相反的!
楊教授加油❤❤❤
感謝楊教授專業分析!
👍👍
天啊, 這些都是天王級的大師啊!
张学友不在吧?
當一個國家缺乏自我檢討的能力時就註定衰敗的命運,It's all just history repeating itself.
❤️👍
谢谢杨教授❤❤
非常感谢永明教授的分享,这期干货爆表。
很好,有字幕,謝謝。👍👍👍👍👍
👍👍👍
👍👍👍👍👍👏👏👏👏
支持
猛人雲集
Admire your team's devotion to providing a different voice!
感谢杨教授分享
楊老師好,美國教授想法像是化石(Fossils),中國威脅論和中國崩潰論沒有改變,馬教授是少數的智者
,👍👍👍
👍🏼👍🏼👍🏼👍🏼❤❤
Thanks!
👍🙏
好希望可以看到會議的公開內容,楊教授有沒有影片
求影片
很好奇Prof Kishore 如何”面对”其他美国学者的意见和言论。
新加坡虽小,但有清晰政见与智慧的能人还真多。非常欣赏马凯硕过人的见解。
Very precious photo
分析到位,不盲目跟西方走
Thank for sharing sir👍🙏
I strongly disagree that one should follow "American logic and thinking" because it is a big stronge country, or because you received American education. What it means to be a scholar is to have one's own thinking and train of thought based on facts and reason. I received my Ph. D in America, but 9 out of 10 times I disagree with their way of thinking either because it is irrational or immoral or both. Just because your are trained there does not mean you automatically follow their logic or point of view.
My friend, One is thinking alike can be due to many factors. Someone is assimilated to American logic and reasoning might be just a matter of subconsciousness, where American thinking is widely available in mainstream media, education, cultural activities etc. If you were studying your Bachelor, Master, PhD all the way in States, and watching/reading all the movies, TV series, Comedies, stories books, literatures from the States, PLUS, eating all the fast foods since you were a teenager, it's not easy to be an "independent thinker" all the time. French teenagers love McD too!!!
Anglo-Saxon wins in many way because they have conquered the world, spreading the culture, language, philosophy, influences. Many learned people would not be able to look from other angle as they have been led to think in "one way". Many would not find it easy if one have to reverse their thought, more over if ones have been arrogant of their absolute truth.
:一切只是(無知,偏見,貪婪,傲慢,自私。)
希望講得深入些
請"廣角"能迅速的將全埸的錄影翻譯上傳!
楊教授好~謝謝
長年的養尊處優
缺少了一些對他人的尊重與包容
Thanks
謝謝支持!
楊sir,英文加強點!
严格说,马凯硕是巴基斯坦裔新加坡人。
好希望能看到这个会议的全部记录!
Yahoo.....👍👍💖💕
很遗憾美国名校学者们,同样也是为认知所局限,无论这些认知源自研究,或文化,或个人傲慢。像马凯硕这样的学者很少,而且他的言论(说了那么多年)终究也无法启发或改变这些西方学者。如杨教授的比喻,盲人摸象,如果执意于自己所摸的部分就是最真实的真相,别人说什么都听不进,也不进一步思考的话,就永远看不见全貌。大国相斗,世界和平,难矣,最后大家都是输家😢
这一期做的好捧👍
This is a terrific program incomparable to any of of other mediocre Taiwanese YT political commentaries. An elite background like Pro. Young is not able to get an entry into local legislatures representative is an absurd for this nation. Too many meager fluffy filled in this representatives legislators.
中國帶領其它願意參加的國家一起挑戰「美國例外論」,有何不可!
美國太驕傲自大。霸權,霸道。
我們樂見未來更多只說中文的學者們能提出更有影響力的觀點來爭取話語權,如同孫子兵法一般,各國來主動翻譯我們學者的文章和著作及演說,事實上這也是西方長期讀不懂中國的原因之一,他們只關注英文或親西方的論述,更進一步的加深彼此的鴻溝。
没敢请哥伦比亚大学教授Jeffery Sachs
上课来了,因为忙,都迟到了我
說了你們可能會不高興,但是你們這些評論員其實也只有兩位有真的在做功課就是亮哥還有賴哥. 在很多的領域你們都算是精英,也是我們這些聽眾的領頭羊,真的希望你們可以多用點心多努力點,連我這個門外漢都可以看得出來你們用心的程度!
這個是您的觀點,值得尊重,而別人的觀點可能和您的未必一樣。
@@caca9522 謝謝您
@@caca9522 我只是希望他能更用心點,剛好他提到的professor Kishore我從2003年就開始追蹤他.
您說的也對 @@obimethakawin6633
红点😊😊😊😊😊
很多基本介绍错误,马凯硕不是印度裔,他父亲是巴基斯坦人,所以是巴基斯坦裔,是和印度对立的。最高职位曾做到过半年多的联合国安理会主席,虽然是加拿大的硕士,主要是著作多出名
Dr. Kishore Mahbubani’s analysis is too one-sided, and will NOT help China grow!
中國是一個極具經濟潛的國家|加油 👏
马凯硕这次分享的观点和前阵子在大陆的演讲差不多。他在大陆还讲到一件事,就是亚洲这几十年的发展是建立在和平之上的。而现在最大的挑战也是维系和平。我觉得这是很站在ASEAN立场上的观点了。但感觉上即便是他,对中美关系的前景也越来越悲观了。
地緣政治學
只是個土產政治學,易造矛盾
且不擅解決問題
有天緣政治學,較地緣寬擴的多
天地兩緣政治學,被包括在。
區域政治學的範圍內
就公平公正的角度而言「中國公開的數據」基本上可信度高於美日等許多國家是真的嗎?事實如何~是否真該到中國去實際考察兩年以上才能表態?沒去過中國的任何人確實不宜發表任何評論(尤其是各國政要與媒體)不管認同或反對中國的人都一樣,不是嗎?
中国其实有意压低gdp总量的,,为的是缓和美中竞争时间的到来,,你愿做老大,,你就继续做好了,,反正你不得不全球驻军,全球吸血。最后玩不玩的转,,开你本事。
新加坡学术界蛮多是持西方的理论思维的,像马凯硕这样的学者以研究未来趋势而结合成亚洲世纪的并不常见。从他的客观理智的逻辑思维和论点可以看到LKY的传承。
老人家的特點是固執、多疑、相信讒言,但是力不從心。所以應該理解米國
中國數據我不知道,但是最近很多人討論美國上半年經濟成長但用電量卻下滑,這是怎麼回事??
把通貨膨脹變成經濟成長。🤭
感謝! 我發現馬凱碩先生的著作 亞洲的21世紀 在YT這裡有新書發表會 雖然全英文但是可以選擇英文字幕自動翻譯中文(簡體中文) 要選簡中喔繁體中文無法顯示
ruclips.net/video/Y2_pLNrCxYA/видео.html
呀米尔海默,去年刚看了他的书
Exceptionalism 不存粹是例外论, 它还有以下的意思:独特论
much greater than usual, especially in skill, intelligence, quality, etc.
(尤指在技能、才智、品质等方面)卓越的,杰出的,不同凡响的
American exceptionalism is the belief that the United States is either distinctive, unique, or exemplary compared to other nations.
居然能請到馬凱碩到台灣演講,而且還發他護照,難道某人腦洞開了嗎?
美國例外論 what's exceptional about America is that there's nothing exceptional about it.
No! What American gov. has been doing is for the American interests including American hegemony in the world --- not for this world interests at all!
請問下面的觀眾都是什麼代表是公開邀請任何人?
新加坡码头转账停泊维修注册中心水汽油买卖抽取得到金庸盈利 新加坡很小没有什么特殊的发展只是代工生活费压力很高 80岁还在做工洗碗碟扫地板
奈伊教授有什么著名的理论或书籍?