Agreed. The hand drawn version has so much more soul in it because it was HANDS ON. And each cell made was so pristine and detailed. I miss Macross and I applaud the induction of 3D animation. At least they didn't change the storyline and added a few new scenes and has a modern look to it. I love it because it's Macross but I still prefer the good-old hand drawn classic. Frontier and Delta was awesome in their own right, though.
A better example of more fluid hand drawn animation would be the Macross movie “Do You Remember Love” (1984) The old graphics were stunning. Good enough for today’s standards of detail.
How good or bad the hand drawn depends on how much money the studio has. Also depends on what studio that working on the anime, sometimes it isn't consistent. Sometimes, you'll get Max vs Millia knife fight scene if you gave them to wrong studio, sometimes you'll get scaling wrong, sometimes perspective screw up. Upsized the budget by 3 or 4 times, you'll get DYRL or Patlabor movie. Nowadays, CGI saved those money spent on hand drawn animation for same effect and more. The crazy transformation details (like VF-0 transformation in Macross Zero) that deemed almost impossible in hand drawn are easily made in CGI.
KoeSeer Hand drawn animation augmented with cgi is the way to go for me at least. That way money is saved on crazy details like the vf-0 but it doesn't look as out of place since it's not a whole giant robot
The sequence where Hikaru does that roll while blasting battlepods is one of my favorite bits of animation. Someone got to re-do it and they made it look like a toilet paper roll rolling on the floor.
The hand-drawn felt more atmospheric, it made you feel like you were actually getting ready to head into space for battle. Meanwhile the CGI made it feel like your usual generic mecha.
both versions are awesome, the old hand work without computers and cg effects was awesome for that times. think how hard was animate these details, beside some perspective errors, still was a good work, mainly for that year. for a 80s, that was innovation, the angles, the scenes, the idea. but this CGi, is still impressive, most animes or movies made in japan not explore the CGi correctly, but it was the most well done work that I already saw, some differences was not that good, but other changes made it better, anyway, they respected the opening in a way that is a example of what every studio have to follow. basically this new version is a dream coming true, who made the old version, watching this full frame animated 3D, would be happy to see what they thought but could not accomplish yet in that times
sin dudas la version original se lleva los laureles...definitivamente el talento no se hace, se nace. aun a casi 35 años de su creacion me deja asombrado con su originaidadl. sin desmerecer la nueva version, pero aun sin haber contado con los recursos que este nuevo proyecto, la calidad es indiscutidamente superior. pero quiero agradecer el que hayas subido este video. muchisimas gracias
Just brings memories flooding. Anime style I love and miss so much. Just under 2 min of anime and yet there’s hours of work involved in this opening soundtrack reel. Man ❤😢❤️🔥🔥🔥🔥
Hand-made one has "soul"... CGI-painted one has more "technical precision"... Both are good. And in my mind, being an old geezer that was a kid when the original came out, I have enough fantasy to paint my "perfect version". In my mind, if I want, I cant count each hair Risa is shaking on SDF-1 Bridge... it's more than 30 years I'm imagining it. My Fantasy best version ever. Thank you, to any author involved in Macross that made my fantasies True. Even as old gezeer now ;
@@CapitanoAraym actually, CGI can be made with passion... it is just that we don't see it. Good CGI is like good special effects, you never really notice it unless you actually search for it. The real fun with CGI is that you can literally make all the details you want and 'paint it' onto the models. That's how quite a bit of GitS: Stand Alone Complex got its Tachikomas to be so good. ;) Also, CGI is more than just 3D models, it is also 2D. There is an SFW Jollyjack strip of the struggles of using traditional 2D drawing compared to the power of computer aided 2D drawing. ;)
We didn't have an alien Battleship crash land on our planet in 1988. That means we missed 10 years of unification wars and technology jumping forward by at least 600 years. Not to mention a few hundred million casualties.
OK, I got the date wrong. We're still missing the crashed alien Battleship, the 10 or so years of unification wars, few hundred million casualties and the technology jump...
agree with you, I like them both, Delta is actually good series if you ignore the idol stuff thowing around, I just dont understand why people hate delta the heroine of delta is by far better than Minmay in original macross not the one in "do you remember love" she such a bitch in the original that it make me feel really depress.
I like both version and I hope to see more advanced versions as the technology grows, it show how far we grow from the original dream from the macross anime. I remember watching a digital photo frame in this anime closing song, and it was in the 80's. I would love to watch a 3d cgi or maybe a live action version of this opening song
+Do You Remember MACROSS? What are the fonts you use for "The Super Dimension Fortress MACROSS" at the top of the video and "Original Opening" & "Blu-ray BOX Complete Edition" at the bottom of the video?
Sad, the blue ray edition should have been more faithful to the cool 70's styling of the animation. Allot of the choices seem to be arbitrary and random such as the random character inserts. I do like the updated definition and frame rate. I honestly don't remember the old frame rate being anywhere near as bad.
+Fenris30 This is the only thing the new one has going for it. I'd like to prefer it for that reason too, but it falls way short in every other department. Except for the SDF-1 ascending through the cloud cover, every single scene looks worse and all around soulless. Heck, even the hand-drawn cockpits look more modern than the CGI ones, that's how bad it is.
Wtf? Robotech is the same as Macross, just different title name. Macross is the first japanese release and changed it to Robotech for copyright reasons when released with dubbed.
Well, here is the issue with that. Yes, Robotech is basically SDF Macross dubbed, but there are some major differences. For example: the term 'Veritech' is used in Robotech, but it is never used in Macross - ever. Also in the Robotech timeline the world was already at war prior to the SDF arrival, while in Macross the Anti-U.N war didn't begin until AFTER the SDF crashed into earth. Also, look closer and you'll realize that everything else holding the Robotech title is NOT related to Macross - and are really just a bunch of other unrelated franchises strung together. For example: Robotech the Movie is basically footage spliced together from "Megazone 23" and "Super Dimension Cavalry Southern Cross", maintaining a nearly non-existant link to the original series. And the entirety of Robotech's third generation was basically "Genesis Climber MOSPEADA" only dubbed so that it SEEMS that its connected to the rest of the Robotech, when in actuallity it doesn't. Robotech makes no mention of any of the events of the rest of the Macross series - no Macross 7, Macross Frontier, Delta, Plus, or Zero. Therefore I consider the Macross series superior, because its continuity makes sense, and its not built by splicing together various other unrelated series into one clustered mess.
I like both, good to see they didn't really stray from the original and added in a few little nice titbits, Macross and Robotech we're part of my childhood so I didn't even know this was a thing till I nostalgia dove into some youtube haha each to there own
I like the original better, the editing and camera angles were a lot better. If they'd not had 120 frames per second on the CG in the new one it wouldn't look so jarring and out of place.
Its funny you say that because the framerate on the original is MUCH lower. It was common to capture each drawing twice in a row, at 24 frames a second for 35mm film, which brings the effective framerate of the handrawn animation to 12 fps! The problem with the motion on the 3D version is they are showing to much of it. The lower number of images your eye is seeing in the original forces your brain to fill in the missing pieces. You can still use these techniques with 3D, but its cheaper to have the computer do it.
Cada uma das apresentações tem seu charme. A original com a trabalho e esforço em realizar tudo de forma manual e o visual e ângulo q realizaram suas cenas é muito especial. Já o moderno tem inclusão de elementos e imagens tornando de forma mais dinâmica por apresentar muitos dos personagens principais.
In fairness a lot of time went into a remastered version I think we have to thank the folks who did the work and burned time and effort to complete it. But I still like to original one even if it has badly drawn sequences the story that goes into producing that well it has it s own set of circumstances and well its own merit towards the Japanese animators who did the best that they could to meet the deadline. This is also the reason why Do you remember love has its own significance when I rewatch it since well all the bad stuff got corrected there and the score is also different.
Did you know that BOTH VERSIONS belong to the 2012 bluray disc, right? The video should be titled original remastered version, vs remake Macross Fever for pachinko version.
Schnake Eyes The new animation comes from a game. The remade opening is also a feature in the blu-ray box set. They didn't reanimate the entire series.
There are areas where the new version did touched up on, but mostly on the effects (realistic area on the staroff, TOP GUN intro, more smokes and bokeh effect) but other than that the CGI simply just sucks. But isnt that kinda Japanese thing all these years? their CGI on movies or anime, it looks super B or C list movies. Just take terra formars and Attack on Titans... the CGI is just *facepalmed*
1:00 that hair flip. one is real animation with an arc motion. the other is 3 poses with drawings in between to forcefully string them together. thats the difference.
Nothing against CGi, but those handdrawn animations look much more impressive.
Agreed. The hand drawn version has so much more soul in it because it was HANDS ON. And each cell made was so pristine and detailed. I miss Macross and I applaud the induction of 3D animation. At least they didn't change the storyline and added a few new scenes and has a modern look to it. I love it because it's Macross but I still prefer the good-old hand drawn classic. Frontier and Delta was awesome in their own right, though.
A better example of more fluid hand drawn animation would be the Macross movie “Do You Remember Love” (1984) The old graphics were stunning. Good enough for today’s standards of detail.
Amen, brother. Computer animation can be done right but it's got a LONG way to go before it hits that level of artistry and depth.
How good or bad the hand drawn depends on how much money the studio has. Also depends on what studio that working on the anime, sometimes it isn't consistent. Sometimes, you'll get Max vs Millia knife fight scene if you gave them to wrong studio, sometimes you'll get scaling wrong, sometimes perspective screw up.
Upsized the budget by 3 or 4 times, you'll get DYRL or Patlabor movie. Nowadays, CGI saved those money spent on hand drawn animation for same effect and more. The crazy transformation details (like VF-0 transformation in Macross Zero) that deemed almost impossible in hand drawn are easily made in CGI.
KoeSeer Hand drawn animation augmented with cgi is the way to go for me at least. That way money is saved on crazy details like the vf-0 but it doesn't look as out of place since it's not a whole giant robot
Both are great, however the old school just has that look we love.
Em só saber e entender o grande esforço que tiveram em animar cada frame e fazer a diagramação toda de forma analógica...
Must have been a very big pain in the ass, drawing all the fight scenes and transformation frame by frame.
RESPECT
Pain in hands wkkwkwkwk
The sequence where Hikaru does that roll while blasting battlepods is one of my favorite bits of animation. Someone got to re-do it and they made it look like a toilet paper roll rolling on the floor.
Facts, one of the best anime/cartoon sequences. CGI for this looks like 🗑
@@isrealgolden1913it doesn't, but continue to lie to yourself and your boyfriend here.
@@paulheap1982 hey a recent comment :D
🎉🎉🎉ดูสมัยตอนเด็ก1984..ชอบมากๆเป็นอนิเมะในดวงใจ.อีกเรื่อง..อันดับ1คินิคุแมน..รุ่นแรก🎉🎉🎉🎉🎉🎉❤❤❤❤❤
@@paulheap1982oh come on, they're allowed to have an opinion
without doubt.. hands down to the original !!!
This is NOT the blu-ray edition.
It's from a pachinko game.
Archer's Back Indeed it's an extra in the blu-ray box altough it's originally from the pachinko.
Yeah lol. My jimmies got rustled by people thinking there would be an anime reanimation.
Ah, a man of culture
What pachinko game
GALL4RD0 Casino
nothing beats the highly skilled artwork of the originals!
バイザー下ろした直後の光の流れ。ヴァルキリー離陸直後の機体の震え。
これを手書きでやってた凄さ。
I got into macross from building the model kits when I was a kid (I'm almost 50 now)and it blew my mind to know they had an anime 🤯
Same here. 🍻 🍻 👍
The hand-drawn felt more atmospheric, it made you feel like you were actually getting ready to head into space for battle.
Meanwhile the CGI made it feel like your usual generic mecha.
So much more brooding the original. Excellent work they did for sure. Good times to be alive
オリジナルは30年以上前の作品ですけど綺麗ですね。
むしろオリジナルに驚愕！
ahsakasa7 ブルーレイの綺麗さより30年前にセルで大差無い映像が作れてることに驚愕する。
The moment when you love the Original Animation over the CG new age animation >.>
best anime 4ever (Macross por siempre!!!)
The Blu-ray version looks like a modern remake. I think it still looks good.
both versions are awesome, the old hand work without computers and cg effects was awesome for that times. think how hard was animate these details, beside some perspective errors, still was a good work, mainly for that year. for a 80s, that was innovation, the angles, the scenes, the idea.
but this CGi, is still impressive, most animes or movies made in japan not explore the CGi correctly, but it was the most well done work that I already saw, some differences was not that good, but other changes made it better, anyway, they respected the opening in a way that is a example of what every studio have to follow.
basically this new version is a dream coming true, who made the old version, watching this full frame animated 3D, would be happy to see what they thought but could not accomplish yet in that times
Man...look at that animation on the left...so much better than that computer game on the right...
WE NEED THIS BLU-RAY RELEASED IN THE WEST! US version NOW!
sin dudas la version original se lleva los laureles...definitivamente el talento no se hace, se nace. aun a casi 35 años de su creacion me deja asombrado con su originaidadl. sin desmerecer la nueva version, pero aun sin haber contado con los recursos que este nuevo proyecto, la calidad es indiscutidamente superior. pero quiero agradecer el que hayas subido este video. muchisimas gracias
Just brings memories flooding. Anime style I love and miss so much. Just under 2 min of anime and yet there’s hours of work involved in this opening soundtrack reel. Man ❤😢❤️🔥🔥🔥🔥
オリジナルの圧勝。
when he board the plane & the cockpit start to display thats when the coolness of the entire movie begun..
Went here because they apparently played this on chap 111 of tensei slime out of curiosity lmao
LOL same
Memorable anime this song still in my head bring me back to my childhood
おおおおお、こんなに作り直されてるんだ！
知らなかった！
かっこいいｗ
エーリッヒハルトマン さん
あ、そうなんですね。
ガチもんかと喜んでしまいました笑
教えてくれてありがとうございます。
Searched this because of slime manga latest chap lel.
Same 😂
SAME
I love the Old version, sorry, this is Old but Gold
元の方が動きとか爆発の表現とか絶対に良い。新しい方はＣＧ使いこなせていないし、無用にキャラ入ってくるのが構成の仕方わかってないなあと思う。
I actually like both versions, personally. Just sayin'
Finally! Someone who can see both sides.
True. Mostly everyone in the comment section is blinded by nostalgia
Hand-made one has "soul"...
CGI-painted one has more "technical precision"...
Both are good.
And in my mind, being an old geezer that was a kid when the original came out, I have enough fantasy to paint my "perfect version".
In my mind, if I want, I cant count each hair Risa is shaking on SDF-1 Bridge... it's more than 30 years I'm imagining it.
My Fantasy best version ever.
Thank you, to any author involved in Macross that made my fantasies True.
Even as old gezeer now ;
@@CapitanoAraym actually, CGI can be made with passion... it is just that we don't see it. Good CGI is like good special effects, you never really notice it unless you actually search for it.
The real fun with CGI is that you can literally make all the details you want and 'paint it' onto the models. That's how quite a bit of GitS: Stand Alone Complex got its Tachikomas to be so good. ;)
Also, CGI is more than just 3D models, it is also 2D. There is an SFW Jollyjack strip of the struggles of using traditional 2D drawing compared to the power of computer aided 2D drawing. ;)
オリジナルの勝ち
おいらはブルーレイのがいいな
EOS0329 SDバージョン(1990年代再放送)
作画パートはリメイクもかなりレベル高い
BD版は良い所もあるが、無駄にキャラが出てきてテンポが悪いし初代マクロスOPの重厚さが無くなってる。
構図やパースのセンスはオリジナルの方が上ですね。
リメイクは綺麗でいいのですが・・・なんか違う。
Ohhhh!! This is what Macross NES game is all about! I didn't know that
I love how they added a few scenes in like the character intros instead of just casually showing off macross from a distance…..but maaaan that CGI 😂
やっぱオリジナルがいいですね
重さって大事
According to Macross, why aren't we in space yet?
We didn't have an alien Battleship crash land on our planet in 1988. That means we missed 10 years of unification wars and technology jumping forward by at least 600 years. Not to mention a few hundred million casualties.
Jekub Fimbulwing 1999 actually
OK, I got the date wrong. We're still missing the crashed alien Battleship, the 10 or so years of unification wars, few hundred million casualties and the technology jump...
I like the intro :)
Flop Flip waste of resources in astronomic quantities in useless warfare conflicts ?
どっちもすき
Looking great for sure
1:02 still loving this part
The original is still better nothing can beat it. The new Delta is pretty good to though if gotta say.
naah its suck thanks to the cgi
delta is alright. Macross 7 is still bad, had good songs though.
+HazyLazyJazy have u seen macross 7?? that shit 10x worse than delta
agree with you, I like them both, Delta is actually good series if you ignore the idol stuff thowing around, I just dont understand why people hate delta the heroine of delta is by far better than Minmay in original macross not the one in "do you remember love" she such a bitch in the original that it make me feel really depress.
I like Delta don't get me wrong I just don't like the fact that the character development is so slow
0:38 i love this song. Love to morrow 😌😌😌
オリジナルOPすげぇ…
i love the packinko animation. Keep posting videos dude!
9 years after this originally was posted and I want this video so bad, you have no idea.
It's sept/10/2024
The new opening has a better composition and storyboard, but the CG animation irks me a bit too much. Still a cool as hell homage
I like both version and I hope to see more advanced versions as the technology grows, it show how far we grow from the original dream from the macross anime. I remember watching a digital photo frame in this anime closing song, and it was in the 80's. I would love to watch a 3d cgi or maybe a live action version of this opening song
The music is spot on, the orchestra arrangement is so wide and grandioso
浮遊感、立体感、人物の表情、仕草、どう観てもオリジナルの方が勝っているんだが。
はい、そうですね。
どう見ても８０年代の手書きが勝ってますね。
nostalgia 🥰 anime terhebat ditayangkan di rtm malaysia zaman 80 an
Original is the best , because all hand made, you can feel the soul of professionals
これってＣＲパチンコのムービーだったのでは？ sankyo pachinko macross
だよね。パチンコムービーだったはず。勝手にBDエディションとか言っちゃってるから困惑したわｗ
Thank you, I thought there is a new BD release that I am not aware of.
エーリッヒハルトマン
アニメは今も手描きだよ、デジタル処理してるだけで
この動画のメカはCGだけど
while i appreciate the more fluid animation of the blue ray version there's a charm to the original i really like so..gotta say the original wins out.
+Do You Remember MACROSS? What are the fonts you use for "The Super Dimension Fortress MACROSS" at the top of the video and "Original Opening" & "Blu-ray BOX Complete Edition" at the bottom of the video?
Sad, the blue ray edition should have been more faithful to the cool 70's styling of the animation. Allot of the choices seem to be arbitrary and random such as the random character inserts. I do like the updated definition and frame rate. I honestly don't remember the old frame rate being anywhere near as bad.
一瞬にして記憶がフラッシュバック
I came here because demon lord rimuru mention this song in the manga.
Well shit lmao
Same
I prefer the newer one. Has shots if Minmay unlike the old version. I unlike some don't mind change. Hell, I need constant change just to feel happy.
Minmay is a no talent bitch
+Fenris30 This is the only thing the new one has going for it. I'd like to prefer it for that reason too, but it falls way short in every other department. Except for the SDF-1 ascending through the cloud cover, every single scene looks worse and all around soulless. Heck, even the hand-drawn cockpits look more modern than the CGI ones, that's how bad it is.
but don't foget that the ending theme is all about Minmay
minmay and roy. the helmet belongs to roy fokker.
One thing is for certain... both are better than Robotech :D
Wtf? Robotech is the same as Macross, just different title name. Macross is the first japanese release and changed it to Robotech for copyright reasons when released with dubbed.
Even though Macross and Robotech are the same but the latter is dubbed, they changed the soundtrack/music, there Robotech's was better.
Well, here is the issue with that. Yes, Robotech is basically SDF Macross dubbed, but there are some major differences. For example: the term 'Veritech' is used in Robotech, but it is never used in Macross - ever. Also in the Robotech timeline the world was already at war prior to the SDF arrival, while in Macross the Anti-U.N war didn't begin until AFTER the SDF crashed into earth. Also, look closer and you'll realize that everything else holding the Robotech title is NOT related to Macross - and are really just a bunch of other unrelated franchises strung together. For example: Robotech the Movie is basically footage spliced together from "Megazone 23" and "Super Dimension Cavalry Southern Cross", maintaining a nearly non-existant link to the original series. And the entirety of Robotech's third generation was basically "Genesis Climber MOSPEADA" only dubbed so that it SEEMS that its connected to the rest of the Robotech, when in actuallity it doesn't. Robotech makes no mention of any of the events of the rest of the Macross series - no Macross 7, Macross Frontier, Delta, Plus, or Zero. Therefore I consider the Macross series superior, because its continuity makes sense, and its not built by splicing together various other unrelated series into one clustered mess.
+117Jorn I see. Good point. Though I still feel the soundtrack was better in Robotech.
Sorry but, Robotech is crap.
This might be the first time I liked a cgi version, it’s more fast-paced and Min may gets more screen time.
Wow now i need to rewatch this
0:25
Notice how the control panels on the left is a little skewed?
That's gonna destroy a lot of people with OCD.
I like both, good to see they didn't really stray from the original and added in a few little nice titbits, Macross and Robotech we're part of my childhood so I didn't even know this was a thing till I nostalgia dove into some youtube haha each to there own
かっこいい！
Yes, what an interesting song, I think I will play it right after Beethoven
Slime righr?
@@rubylahlouabid1171 Can you think of anywhere else someone would come up with Macross after Beethoven?
i knew that robotech was a marvel of animation in the 80's but it really shows how great it really was when you see the shit that is the re-release.
Where can watch this again 😢
This made my day
I want to start this series. Which is better to watch? (in terms of story, completeness, etc... I actually like those hand drawn animation)
I like the original better, the editing and camera angles were a lot better. If they'd not had 120 frames per second on the CG in the new one it wouldn't look so jarring and out of place.
Honestly it reminds me of those Japanese SEGA remasters they put out on the PS2.
Its funny you say that because the framerate on the original is MUCH lower. It was common to capture each drawing twice in a row, at 24 frames a second for 35mm film, which brings the effective framerate of the handrawn animation to 12 fps! The problem with the motion on the 3D version is they are showing to much of it. The lower number of images your eye is seeing in the original forces your brain to fill in the missing pieces. You can still use these techniques with 3D, but its cheaper to have the computer do it.
Cada uma das apresentações tem seu charme. A original com a trabalho e esforço em realizar tudo de forma manual e o visual e ângulo q realizaram suas cenas é muito especial. Já o moderno tem inclusão de elementos e imagens tornando de forma mais dinâmica por apresentar muitos dos personagens principais.
In fairness a lot of time went into a remastered version I think we have to thank the folks who did the work and burned time and effort to complete it. But I still like to original one even if it has badly drawn sequences the story that goes into producing that well it has it s own set of circumstances and well its own merit towards the Japanese animators who did the best that they could to meet the deadline. This is also the reason why Do you remember love has its own significance when I rewatch it since well all the bad stuff got corrected there and the score is also different.
They tried to digitally recreate the original cell animation. They failed miserably.
Hicieron una adaptación a blue-ray? Con esa animación?
Thats the version that was in the Pichinko game in japan i believe, its not the 4k version of SDF-Macross...
Looks very similar anyway
オリジナルのほーがいいやん
Both are great, but you feel real love for art in the originals.
Blu-ray普及は失敗のようですが、新しく書き下ろしなんですね。
分かりやすい比較ありがとうございました
Misa with the hair flip.
余計な演出過ぎる…
美樹本氏、板野氏に作監させてよ。
非常經典
The blueray edition is the full series? Where can I find it? Would love to watch that...
This is so awesome!
anyone know where we can buy the blue ray? just want to add it in to my collection!
余分なエフェクトが無い分オリジナルの勝ちですね
んーオリジナルのほうがなんだか温かみを感じますね。ＢＬのほうもかっこいいし見やすいんだけど何か違う感じがする。
オリジナルのほうをよく見ていたというひいき目もあるのかな
Is this that $400 box set they sell on Amazon? Anyone have any info on which Blu-Ray Box Complete edition this is?
Good job!
They original is much much much better.
What a voice
Did you know that BOTH VERSIONS belong to the 2012 bluray disc, right?
The video should be titled original remastered version, vs remake Macross Fever for pachinko version.
左は格好いい。
右はシャープで綺麗。
個人的にはオリジナルが好きだけど、右は柿崎が格好いいからこれはこれで良い(適当)
エーリッヒハルトマン リメイクにしちゃ断片すぎるし違和感はあるなと思ってたらパチンコだったの？
When are they going to show theses episodes or dub them?
Blu-rayバージョンは綺麗ですが、シックリくるのは」やはりoriginalですね。
I like the blue -ray version but prefer the original. Makes me feel nostalgic.
Wow, the CG version just sucks all the soul out of it. What a terrible idea.
still other than the CG, blue ray looks more lively than the older one.
it's for a game not a TV series
Schnake Eyes The new animation comes from a game. The remade opening is also a feature in the blu-ray box set. They didn't reanimate the entire series.
There are areas where the new version did touched up on, but mostly on the effects (realistic area on the staroff, TOP GUN intro, more smokes and bokeh effect) but other than that the CGI simply just sucks. But isnt that kinda Japanese thing all these years? their CGI on movies or anime, it looks super B or C list movies. Just take terra formars and Attack on Titans... the CGI is just *facepalmed*
i hear ya
オープニングにミンメイとかいらんなぁ…
構成的にも動き的にもオリジナルの勝ち
Yes! very clear image smoothest motion and clearest song
BD版というより、たんにBD－BOXの映像特典用にパチンコ・パチスロのマクロスの映像を編集した物だね。
映像特典だと、この後に「私の彼はパイロット」「ドッグファイター」「小白竜」「アクション総攻撃」「シルバームーン・レッドムーン」「愛は流れる」が続きます。
1:00 that hair flip.
one is real animation with an arc motion. the other is 3 poses with drawings in between to forcefully string them together.
thats the difference.
CGアニメに新たなるオリジナル映像が多少入ったものの、セル画アニメをほぼ再現してくれてるのはイイネ。