Canadian premiers call on Trudeau to address complaints about carbon pricing carve-out | FULL
HTML-код
- Опубликовано: 29 сен 2024
- Canadian premiers called for a “meaningful” dialogue with the Trudeau government on the pause on carbon pricing for home heating oil, after a meeting of provincial and territorial leaders in Halifax, N.S.
Nova Scotia Premier Tim Houston, chair of the latest Council of the Federation meeting, said he is “sympathetic to the discussions” around the carbon pricing pause on home heating oil, and also said he believed the Trudeau government should do away with carbon pricing.
“I would ask that the federal government address those concerns in a meaningful way that’s fair, but ultimately I think they should just get rid of the carbon tax and work with the provinces on something that would actually help to preserve our planet,” he said, adding he doesn’t think carbon pricing is “effective.”
Saskatchewan Premier Scott Moe said Monday the premiers’ complaint isn’t with the program to switch Canadians from home heating oil to heat pumps but that it is unfair to those who heat their homes in different ways but still struggle with rising costs.
Meanwhile, Alberta Premier Danielle Smith said she didn’t believe heat pumps were a viable solution in her province as they “don’t work particularly well at below -25 degrees.”
The premiers also addressed Canada’s beleaguered health-care system and the lack of affordable housing.
For more info, please go to globalnews.ca/...
Subscribe to Global News Channel HERE: bit.ly/20fcXDc
Like Global News on Facebook HERE: bit.ly/255GMJQ
Follow Global News on Twitter HERE: bit.ly/1Toz8mt
Follow Global News on Instagram HERE: bit.ly/2QZaZIB
#GlobalNews #Canada #Politics
Anyone find it bizarre how we're all struggling to pay for heat when our country is so resource-rich?
Because they make more money selling it to the states and abroad and we pay through the nose. We should be the richest country in the world but we have the highest debt per household in the G7 countries. Thanks to the corrupt spending and money printing by the Liberals. They spent 1 billion dollars since 2019. Where’s the money?
I always find this government and country bizarre. This country is nothing but word salad .
not bizarre at all. this corrupt federal (and many provincial) leader(s) are purposefully destroying the lives of it's citizens at the cost of their own bank accounts growing. send your kids to public school for 12 years and they are indoctrinated with leftist propaganda. things are the way they are because it's all on purpose.
This was the best political discussion in Canada in years.
Wow, not a 1st ministers meeting since 2018 - that's on the Prime Minister. I know he likes to travel, but he could have at least invited them to Ottawa, so his foreign jaunts would not be compromised. I'm dissappointed that this opportunity was not acted upon. I've been dissappointed for a number of years, it seems to be style over substance. A low key affair with the premier's, but a good start. Sorry Doug Ford, but you working "collaboratively" with the municipalities, Ontario has not seen that thus far. Why no translation service ? The Quebec rep is 100% correct, it's an insult and unacceptable at this level.
Agree 100%
I was waiting to see if anyone else heard the same thing.
Can Eby answer that question on health care? 😂
It’s odd that none of them talk about the carbon tax rebate cheques being given to individual Canadians every quarter. Or how the carbon tax has made coal too expensive and that this has resulted in rapid closures of coal plants in Alberta, replacing them with lower emission solutions.
Lower emissions like LNG? Or the lower emissions that were encouraged by the federal government in the early 2000's to convert wood burning fixtures with natural gas one because of the dramatically lower polluants achieved with LNG? The same natural gas we are now being punished for using?
@@whiskybrush3219 The carbon tax is actually more impactful to large emitters than individual homeowners, that’s why you and I get a rebate check every quarter, your so-called “punishment” is balanced by the money you’re getting. The way it has reduced emissions is by making it more expensive to generate electricity from coal than from natural gas. In Alberta this accelerated the transition from coal to natural gas generation, with many coal plants closing in 2023, seven years earlier than planned. The carbon tax made coal generation unprofitable.
Only way us Canadians will ever be treated fairly is when Trudeau is gone an get someone in office with a brain an Absolutely know one involved in the WEF should ever be aloud in the government
We will all live in tents by then
Good, you can be anti trudeau and anti capitalism. Excellent.
No WEF Mark Carney. Look at how he destroyed UK.
I think I'll have left Canada by then.
No the only way is to separate,nothing ever really changes!
Nice to listen to politicians who are reasonable and mature in their thinking.
Speaking as a unit that are looking for solutions to CANADIAN problems.
Something Trudeau should try.
It’s sad they have to come together because the feds are so broken..
SO TRUE @@Cafeallday222
Scott Moe is a boss ! ,👍
This is so much better then anything Trudeau could put together.
It’s also nice to see that no matter the political stripe each premier is standing strong against unfairness by the PM
So in other words the Premiers are saying, "Canadians have an affordability problem, and the only way we can think off to help ease this crisis is to allow people to pollute and spew more fossil fuel into the environment with greater ease and at a lesser expense. Never mind that Climate Change is already costing our country BILLIONS of tax paying dollars EVERY YEAR to deal with its destruction to our environment, lives, property, and jobs and our children's futures"
Maybe it’s time for Alberta to stop making payments to Quebec
❤❤❤❤❤❤❤ payments to Quebec is from Alberta is out right wrong
That was in Max Berniers platform.
Could all the Premiers just run our country together instead?
If each province voted and made decisions for themselves, Canada would be a lot better.
Who knows better about what each province needs than those living within it, paying taxes and voting on local issues.
That's what's supposed to happen. Trudeau likes to run everything though
Nice to see leadership coming together to fill the federal void.
This was well presented, love to hear the premiers present together instead lf the feds.
It was so positive
Quebec gets to decide.....the bloc sealed our fate today ....pathetic not even a national party...disgusting!!
Typical behaviour from Quebec…when can we have a referendum to get rid of that province once and for all…..
I will leave if they ever separate this province is a joke
Honestly I can't believe what they did
I hate the term “carve out” it’s our money these crooks have stolen They should be reducing more taxes and apologize for the money they have stolen
Nice to see Danielle and Scott Moe rallying the other Premiers to take a stand against Trudope and Frefall
I'm from Ontario and I think Danielle Smith is a top of the class Politician. She has a prime minister vibe about her. Love me Polliverier but Danielle Smith hits the thoughts of most common sense Canadians.
I'm from mb and I say same...
Get rid of the mandates. You shouldn't have to take an experimental drug to work.
This was such a nice change from the division of the Trudeau government I wish I could hear positive positions on the country as as a whole instead of the negative positions brought forward by the liberal government!
What deal did Trudeau make with the Bloc to avoid a non confidence vote?
He promised Blanchett a reach around after every question period for the next 2 years.
Rented out Sophie one more time
Some bloc sauce.
I thought that was a brilliant, mature, intelligent and very productive and hopeful press conference that gives canadians encouragement that there is hope for our country to work in unity to address the current problems
Wow! I can't believe the feds are going around the premieres. That is absolutely not acceptable!
The BC Premier David Eby is dilutional if he thinks carbon Tax his helping to prevent climate change. BC ( Bring Cash)
BC ( Beside Canada )
Unity and a voice of the people. Trudeau should take note.
His ego won't let him. Doesn't matter if everyone is against him. He's a little child who will just hold his breath...
When u have a clown for a PM, premiers have to step up
Thank you for speaking out for all Canadians!
Lets not forget that the BOC said the carbon tax is adding to the affordability issue.
Not extending this to all Canadians is ridiculous! I’m a family of 3 (2 adults and a 4 month old) and my heating bill is $244 this month, i dont get much from maternity leave as it barely covers my rent. Inflation and carbon tax is literally killing me
My god what the flip is wrong with that BC premier…he is absolutely unrealistic and is mocking Canadians who are suffering from these ridiculous carbon taxes….
It so nice to see you all work together.
Get this carbon tax off the table.
The private sector is about to crash. Without the Private sector,,,,THERE IS NO TAX REVENUE!!!!!!
Would that mean that all those MPs pensions could be at risk ? Perish the thought
Wow Quebec rep... not everyone is bilingual in your province never mind the entire nation. And we cannot expect new Canadians to learn both in addition to their native language. Good way to keep the separation issues strong. Barf.
Canada is broken… it makes no sense any more… the only benefit to being in Canada was access to the largest trading network at the time the British Empire. We don’t even trade province to province we all trade more with America then ourselves. The only reason to stay is if you are getting a hand out. Quebec will always rule Canada as they now can’t loose seats in the house as their population shrinks and no political party will ever say no to Quebec or it’s political suicide via seat count. We are essentially governed by a foreign country given Quebec is a nation and they haven’t even signed our constitution.
The only way to stop that tyrant is to refuse to collect the tax or remove him from office.
United We Stand, Divided we fall..
The French translation isn’t working. This is a bilingual country. I’m not repeating myself. Why do we keep Quebec in this country? Let them separate. See how well they fend for themselves.
There should be these kinds of press meetings on serious topics every month. Far more informative and useful than House of Commons federal meetings. We get to have a feel of what each province is going through too.
🇨🇦🔥🇨🇦 why don't you start up a power pipeline that's powered by air compression and vacuum turning turbines going down a pipeline and back up the other side
Why we need a federal government at all…..😮
Great conversation at the table today, was great to see and hear all different perspectives coming from the premiers of each province and what they’re going through in their own parts of the country. Funny how the separatist was there and then gone.
Unelected Eby pushing heat pumps. 15k+ Gst to buy one for my house and rebate is not applicable
Well, you would still need to run a furnace even with a heat pump so really, all it wpuld do is cost you more in electricity. So you're just as well.
Im from Ontario, born 2004. Is it okay if I don't like Quebec - like I didn't understand a single thing that guy said. Not Quebecs fault, I think the people who teach french in english provinces are super lazy and know they probably won't get fired. I would have been completely fine if he had just finished what he said in french and the centre of attention just moved on. But of course I have to hear once again that Canada is a bilingual country. Usually I would just read up on Quebecs stance through some article, but this guy proves to you that he can speak english easily if he wants to, but chooses not to. It's always the Quebecer's talking about bilingualism but yet they can't reciprocate. It's a common theme in French history too separated from French-Canadian history.
LOL this is the most symbolic representation of Quebec, nothing to be gained from speaking English. If you can't understand me then too bad I'm out 😂
Love that affordability housing.
Sure tax Canadians who are barely getting by to build a bunch of housing for drug addicts and welfare scammers.
Causing hard working Canadian taxpayers taxes to go up even further.
I'm a 51 year old Vancouverite and I've been waiting for 2 years for disc replacement surgery. When do I get the care I need/require?!?!
Hey back of the bus. After all the illegals, refuges, and others. Then they might get to you
If you pay cash for it, you could go to another province and have it done next week.
@@jeffhedrich3551 Only the wealthy can afford the private clinics. Im part of the 99% club that can't afford it.
You probably have to go to another country to get the surgery.
Hop the border
Quebec will be Quebec the Bloc Québécois needs to go Francois couldn’t even show face what a clown
Who is the arrogant gentleman that is representing Quebec in Premier Legault's place?
He is right
Great unity among the premiers. Sadly, BC's Eby stands out supporting his version of the carbon tax.
Regarding Federal taxation on nurses pay cheque: It shoud take into consideration the amount of hours one works yo make the salary they make because, it is hard to work overtime just to pay taxes to the government. Thanks
That Quebec premiere is a prick. Goes and speaks French whole time and then runs off. No where to be seen in the rest of the meeting not even in his chair to discuss his plans for the other topics.
THEY PLAY ALL TOUGH IN THE CAMERA VIEW ! BUT NEXT TO NONE OF THEM TOOK STEPS TO STOP THE CARBON TAX , OR WAS WILLING TO DROP PROVINCIAL TAXES TO HELP THEIR CITIZENS !!! ALL OUT FOR THEMSELVES !
Yup watch it all happen then try to make Canadians feel like they should be lucky they give back a tiny tiny percentage of the 50% of our pay check they steal.
Saskatchewan will “illegally” stop collecting carbon tax on Jan. 1. They can do it because SasEnergy is a Crown corporation owned by Saskatchewan government, but Alberta’s electricity is provided by private-own companies so our premier would not encourage private companies to violate federal law. Btw, there is NO provincial tax in Alberta. We pay the 5% federal tax only.
Good to see ya Mr Kinew! It's true we are already freezing and definitely on the brink of not having enough money to cover everything as a debt free but the house responsible family with a low middle class income (60k) I'm happy to hear you advocating for Manitobans. We are trying our best to pay and rewslly don't think this tax would be the most efficient way to resolve the issues as we simply cannot control that our fruit is trucked in from all over the world, can't not heat our home , and already are driving as minimally as possible because we can't afford more than $120/month in gas in our budget
There are numerous people in my community that have the heat pump and they are saying it is only good as a source of heat till -5 C. So when you live in the north, this isn't even close to practical as the only source of heat. And I live in BC. Very disappointed that Eby only thinking of the lower mainland where a heat pump may be a practical choice. There is a huge area of BC where heat pumps will only be a supporting source of heat.
Daniel smith❤
BC very dumb answer. heat pumps only benifit the south corner. hes not for the middle or lower class. KNOWN as province breakers.
the carbon tax is not a silver bullet .... well said ... finally . And to the pro Trudeau BC premier ... Try a heat pump in northern Ontario Pal ..
You can't tell a nurse she is not allowed to move. We have the freedom to live anywhere in Canada.
What the Quebec premier fails to consider is that while the federal government is bilingual, provincial governments really aren't.
Quebec just being Quebec. His response to translation not working or not being available comes off as extremely smug and the perfect representation on why people get annoyed at the province
Est-ce les autres provinces on parler en français pour que les canadiens français puissent eux aussi comprendre ? Non
Deux poids deux mesures.
Si le Québec doit répondre en anglais aussi, alors les autres provinces devront répondre en français aussi.
I just like to point out the empty chair at 22:49... bathroom break? Or pissed off he had to speak English?
It's so annoying lol
Our political system effectively permits a minority to dictate to the majority. A majority of Canadians, as evidenced by every election statistic publicly available on the governments own websites, did not vote Liberal, do not agree with the carbon price, and would prefer if they weren’t being imposed on by the Liberals, whom they did not vote for and do not support. Particularly because these impositions have direct, immediate, and even drastic consequences on your ability to provide for your family. You don’t address climate change through punitive tax measures that merely increase costs and decrease quality of life for your citizens. You address climate change through education, technology, and innovation. Cut wasteful spending in other areas, which there are ample, and use that to fund innovation. We don’t need a carbon tax. We are suffering and this government which formed a back-door coalition government which neither of their constituents voted on at the time of election are causing hardship for all of us who didn’t even vote for this, which is a majority.
I loved my visit to P.E.I. The land/seascape is beautiful and I was made to feel well at home by the residents…I’d love to see cheaper, cleaner burning natural gas being developed in my province pipelined to the east coast to benefit my fellow Canadians there. sincerely, a proud
Albertan/Canadian
In PEI single moms are suffering. Things are to expensive. My nerves are gone from worrying if I will have enough food for the kids. I can't afford nothing and I go without to give to my kids. Two winters in a row I wear shoes with holes because I cant afford to buy a pair when the money is needed elsewhere. I have no car so I cant drive around looking for bargains. It's no life. It's not living, it's surviving and I see no end to it. It going to get worse. Its depressing. Must be nice not having to worry, most Canadians do not know how that feels.
Honestly that is a tactic of governments to keep their population docile. When a people is too busy trying to figure out how to survive, they have no energy to revolt. Straight out of the Soviet and North Korea playbook.
Any politicians can not be trusted,offer them something under the table and surely they will double cross anyone…trust a politician
like a “ cobra “..
As a RN who no longer works as one the number one reason I left was being constantly verbally abused and having no ability to put an end to it. AHS puts up signs saying that abuse towards staff will not be tolerated but they do absolutely nothing about it. IMO if you are verbally abusive (and/or physically abusive which happens more than you would think) to staff and you are not at risk of imminent death then any staff member should be able to discharge you immediately. This is the reason most nurses burnout and leave the profession.
Chicken Little says the sky is falling, he says if we can give him money and sacrifice todays poor and middle class, he can make it stop.
Make it free for schooling in Canada to become a doctor and nurse.
Why is it only rich people get to go become these positions?
Canadians want to help, Canadians want to work! Give them the opportunity and stop putting up a paywall!
No way!!! I don't want to pay for another person's university. Get a student loan.
Yes, provided there's a contract to work in the nation for a set number of hours or years.
Also, we need to actually get them in. I know someone training in Ireland because there’s no room in the schools now 🤦🏻♀️ we have NO spots available. Also, many careers are too $. To be a piolet costs 100k to train (just the schooling). I know someone who wanted to be a vet but it was too much money.
So you want the rich people to also get a free medical education? Or do you want to charge students based on their family savings?
I had a student loan forgiveness program: $4k forgiven for each year worked in a rural area, up to a maximum of $20k. This amount could be increased and applied to more areas in need.
The reason nurses don't work full-time is childcare- lack of capacity? I propose childcare facilities attached to hospitals with 24/7 capacity-i speak from the perspective of an acute care RN
Excellent!
Oh, and school busses too, right?
Nurses are not seen as people anymore. There's a lack of regard for our family lives and the many roles we play. We are treated as task-machines legally responsible to meet unrealistic expectations in appalling conditions. Treat us humanely, stop sexist structures toward a predominantly female profession!
I know quite a few that didn't want the so called vaccine as well!
The earth's climate had been changing since inseption.
We have to adapt
Because government sucks at mitigation
Where did the French premier go?
Once he found out that at a 1st ministers meeting, there was NO translation service, he was FORCED to leave because of this insult. Like the tone, but it looks like they are a bunch of clowns, this was unacceptable at this level. Nova Scotia was the host, should have known better. Don't talk about provincial collaboration if you don't respect one quarter of the population.
To pout in the corner acting like a baby
@raymondfranke154 Quebec has been getting special treatment from the federal government for years, that's where the animosity comes from all the other citizens of Canada. Like how the hell is a provincial interests party allowed to act as a federal political party making decisions that affect the entire country, for example.
Love how the premier of Quebec leaves the table, very class act, but to the issues discussed, the Premiers are right, one size does not fit everyone. When you force fuel taxes on people that have no choice but to buy the fuel for necessary transport to and from work and there is no viable option for them it is a forced tax that is a basic punishment for living where you do. The Federal government thinks everyone has access to public transit or is rich enough to buy a hybrid or EV. At least the majority of the Premiers have some common sense and realize there needs to be a more sophisticated answer to carbon emissions - not just a tax. The vote today in parliament on the carbon tax is proof that Liberal MP's do not vote for their constituents - they just vote the way Trudeau tells them too.
I thought he left before everyone else they weren’t showing his absence! Not surprised tho no unity there
BC primier is such a ding-dong
This is honestly a breath of fresh air. Id like to be proud of my country again, this is a good start
funny that's exactly what I've been thinking lately . I want my country back ...
Our jobs arevto get out and tell everyone ya can, get out and vote. VOTE TRUDEAU OUT!!. PASS IT ON
Love Danielle Smith
The premier of Manitoba is a DADDY.
Sugar daddy???
How is the Federal Government going to tax us on the wood we burn to heat our homes here on South Vancouver Island ? We harvest the wood from our own properties. Burning wood produces carbon emissions, maybe more than Natural Gas. I guess if you purchase wood by the cord, the Federal Government could try to have the supplier collect the Carbon Tax for them.
You would self declare right ? And send your local LIberal office your personal cheque ?
No if you buy you wood from NDPs or Liberals, than it doesn’t effect global warming???
bahaha exackly,,never will they collect a tax on wood..and good luck stopping me from burning it!
Wood is massively worse than natural gas. The carbon offset is not only immense but the particulate matter released is much worse. But that's what you get when you hurt people to this extent. They start harvesting their environment.
Remember when it was not safe for Higgs to be same room houston cause of covid😅😅😅😅😅😅I 😅😅 houston go buy another hotel to help health care 😅😅😅😅😅😅
I am blocked from watching this unless I accept the force of RUclips to try RUclips Prime. Why don't I have the right to say no without constant harassing from RUclips?
I hEaRt HeAt PuMpS 😂😂😂 what a dope , the jet he flew private to get to this meeting burned more fuel and gosh knows how many houses hahaha
According to 2022 Adult Literacy Report : Literacy is more than the ability to read and write. It’s the ability to
understand and use a wide range of materials to engage fully in activities
and opportunities at home, at work, and in the community. Literacy
enables people to meet their goals and succeed in today’s world.
According to Statistics Canada, 49% of the adult population scored below high-school literacy
levels; 17% scored in the lowest level. [1] Newcomer, Indigenous, and low-income populations
are disproportionately challenged by low literacy. These groups have also been more
impacted by the learning, employment, and financial crises that resulted from the pandemic. THIS IS an ANSWER for CANADIAN GOVERNMENT performance and why CANADA become BANANA REPUBLIC !!!!
Change the Nurses, being stuck in the hallways on computer, back to clip boards at foot of every hospital bed. Then you get a netter bang fir the buck because, nurses then see the patients throughout their shifts
We had a much better healthcare system in the 1960’s , 70’s by far , than we do now. We need to rethink why healthcare was much better, in the past..
People need to realize , not one of these premiers talk about solid property rights being protected in Canada., we need a charter of rights, that means something , for the people of Canada, not just for government control, which is never addressed, why???? There are so many, many problems besides the carbon tax, like heating by itself, being far to expensive in our resource rich country.
This seems like more of a distraction from everything else that needs to be addressed in this country. We haven’t evolved with natural climate change. Not enough explanation on heat pumps, this its just word salad.
boo to the bc priemier! as a bcer his comments are a suck up comment to justine t..yes we have had disaster in bc but heat pumps are only effective down to minus 5 which only helps lower mainland peoples..
The premiers can have a discussion as adults. It's when Mr.Dressup Enters the drama starts.
When a good higher up in the government will push for Trudeau to have no choice of stepping down to really help Canadians of their nightmare
Why Truedo’s terrorists threatening india on bombing plane in india ??? What is this man doing against terrorism
dang yep. Thanks for turning on comments by the way!
That just shows what Quebec is all about! Speaks french lol what a joke!
We are in a co2 drought why such hate for fossil fuels?
Where is Quebec?
Said something in French, then the women said we don't have have an translators and left. 19:35
@@billjohn1152😂 Canada's weird bilingualism!
They are shutting down the vote in parliament on a home heating pause for the rest of canada.....quebec is deciding for canada. What did Trudeau give them for this support??
In my opinion, they should have had translators provided. It looked rather rude that they missed on this opportunity. Btw, if you notice, each premier has their province written in both English and French in front of them, as it should. Btw, we are still an official bilingual country and many French Canadians live outside of Quebec.
@@OwlieOwltoinette Quebequers who live outside Quebec 100% speak English so what's your point?
Yeah I think its time for the west to quit sending money down east
the collaborative of premiers far outweigh the uselessness of the federal government
11 BSers chasing a Tyrone
We do not want private healthcare Danielle
So why does this sound so good and not so good when we hear it on the news?
Love the lack of captions
*
They all think $20 a month will change people's lives? Then they drive their SUVs to the burger joint a couple blocks over to get those two extra cheeseburgers a month. I saw a few minutes of the live feed from the House of Commons vote on this, it was so annoying with the MPs acting like a bunch of 5 year olds that I couldn't take more than that. You pay people $200K a year and that's what they do, yell and thump their hands on the thing in front of them. The Speaker tells them to shut tf up and they immediately do it again. All they gotta do is start fining them for making noise, $1000 a pop, see how much noise the vastly overpaid children make then. But no, that would be too logical, better to just waste as much time as possible making horrendous noise so they don't have to actually do anything productive, because that would be crazy. What a joke we have for a Parliament.
Quebec is so ignorant. I understand though, if this was a unified rally of provinces; it ought to represent Canada ; bilingual as well.