New memoir digs into the daunting impact of the 'model minority' myth

Поделиться
HTML-код
  • Опубликовано: 29 дек 2024

Комментарии • 69

  • @hummersd
    @hummersd Год назад +13

    I used to feel that pressure being Asian, and living up to that notion I'm good at math. But the sketch on MadTV "Average Asian" helped break that stereotype in a funny way. I'm not saying that's what changed my perspective, but when it comes down to it, we're humans, all ranges of intelligence, heights, weights, baggage, unknown futures, etc. So all we are doing on this planet is to live, help one another, and try to leave it a bit better, not worse. I find it so interesting Vivek is even running -- doesn't he realize that the others on that stage/in the field of candidates don't actually believe he or his parents should be in the country (even if he was born here)? HOW can he have the same values as tRump? It's astounding.

    • @christinacody8653
      @christinacody8653 Год назад +1

      I definitely believe their attempts to shut him down come from a place of fear of a second authoritarian without governing experience outside of a marketing (i.e. social business and theoretically a bit narcissistic) background. It probably also doesn't help that he doesn't fit their model of religion as well. Nikki Haley at least conforms to their expectations of a successful woman and has made her way in the governing sphere by passing as "white American." These two individuals starkly show the difference in responses. While Pence was trying to mansplain on Women's Healthcare, he and others at least gave deference to her SC governorship and UN Ambassadorship. Both gave her credentials that Ramaswany doesn't.

  • @ciskaverster6979
    @ciskaverster6979 Год назад +10

    Very interesting segment, thank you

  • @Nonas_a_Blerd
    @Nonas_a_Blerd Год назад +11

    Her brother's pain makes me weep. Will definitely read "They Called Us Exceptional".

  • @laavanya9584
    @laavanya9584 Год назад +1

    I really commend Prachi Gupta for being courageous enough to make her family's story public and in the process debunk the fallacy of the model minority myth that many South Asian American immigrants cling to for dear life. There is such a burden of shame and silence so many live under and we do not have safe spaces in our community to speak of such things. My Indian immigrant parents lived a life of total honesty and authenticity, almost to a fault. There was no such thing as being one way to desis and another way at home. I naturally imbibed this my whole life and I have had difficulty connecting to our community for that. If that is the price I have to pay for being 100% authentic, so be it. My life has been richer for it.

  • @mitersangeeta2576
    @mitersangeeta2576 Год назад +8

    Thank you for giving a voice to minorities who are trying their best to be seen as ‘the good ones’

  • @ebfisher4942
    @ebfisher4942 Год назад +4

    That’s sad

  • @hushpuckena126
    @hushpuckena126 Год назад +6

    In the 1980s, I was well acquainted with a fellow chess player, of Indian descent, who was terribly bright and talented. The pressure he endured from his parents drove him out of university and to take solace in the bottle. He dropped out of chess and largely from life.

  • @evie964
    @evie964 Год назад +9

    Vivek is all "my side" and "my side that" when he talks about Republicans while prominent right-wing media personalities make fun of his religion is too perfect.

    • @lostboy3080
      @lostboy3080 Год назад +4

      Someone should ask him which God he believes in during the debate stage and the response of the Republican crowd will tell everything that needs to be told.

    • @christinacody8653
      @christinacody8653 Год назад +2

      @@lostboy3080 I don't approve of religion shaming as a rule and do believe that Christian Exclusivism is a concern to me, but I do expect an interviewer to dig into his faith (possibly 60 Minutes as that's where that kind of thing often comes up as it's the sort of question that will come up in a deep dive) at some point. How he responds to it will be interesting. He did go to a Catholic High school (according to wiki) but his family was also actively religious in his own (US side) Hindu temple. it would show a complexity in religion that I'm interested in hearing (please note, this interest is separate from whether or not I would vote for him, the answer on that for me is NO).

    • @beast6029
      @beast6029 Год назад

      Democrats and the left wing have done the same. For example Tulsi Gabbard was shamed for being a proud hindu in her own party.

  • @1VetsVision
    @1VetsVision 9 месяцев назад

    Prachi is very intelligent and gorgeous. Great interview ❤

  • @ramkumarigupta20458
    @ramkumarigupta20458 Год назад

    Love the parachi! Heart and work.

  • @eapensonia
    @eapensonia 11 месяцев назад

    Great book! Loved it.

  • @amygrande1416
    @amygrande1416 Год назад +2

    Leg lengthening surgery who has $ for that? Monthly healthcare premiums/deductibles are skyrocketing.

    • @NopeUghUghAbsolutelyNot
      @NopeUghUghAbsolutelyNot Год назад

      It's not as expensive as you'd think. This surgery has been around for decades. I have cousin who did it in the early 90s

  • @truegrit7697
    @truegrit7697 Год назад +1

    I have read a lot of articles of middle eastern men getting leg-lengthening surgery because they were embarrassed with their shortness. I didn't know this desire extended to Indian men. This is an insane and brutal procedure.

    • @thomasdequincey5811
      @thomasdequincey5811 Год назад

      Humans are vain. Getting plastic surgery has nothing to do with being a minority.

  • @soonpohtay4794
    @soonpohtay4794 Год назад +2

    Caste....

  • @elram2649
    @elram2649 Год назад +22

    Vivek's the type of person who closes the door behind him once he himself gets through the door. 👈👀 Fair warning for those supporting him.

    • @judithsmith9582
      @judithsmith9582 Год назад +13

      Just like Justice Thomas...

    • @Sunisbrighterandgrassisg-si1mg
      @Sunisbrighterandgrassisg-si1mg Год назад +1

      Why do you want to be in the same room with him? Serves you right to shut the door to your face

    • @elram2649
      @elram2649 Год назад

      @Sunisbrighterandgrassisg-si1mg
      Why, hello there, troll who's only had an account for 9 hrs because your previous accounts have been terminated by RUclips for stochastic terrorism!
      Hi!
      How's it going, buddy? 🤗
      Do pay closer attention next time, if you will. 🤗 You might learn something: 🌟
      The warning is explicitly "for those supporting him" - hence, not for me.
      It would serve you right to learn basic English and take a basic English comprehension class or two so the door (you clearly being one of his supporters) does not get shut to your face. 👈🫢
      Bye, Putler troll! 👋
      God bless. 🤗

    • @valevisa8429
      @valevisa8429 Год назад

      You have to be blind not to see the monster under that skin.He is worse than Trump.

    • @NopeUghUghAbsolutelyNot
      @NopeUghUghAbsolutelyNot Год назад +1

      ​@@Sunisbrighterandgrassisg-si1mgHaving to the same opportunities is not the same as standing in the same room. Vivek wants to change the voting age to 25. Why does he accept he was able to vote at 18 yet its not ok for others? This is closing the door behind him. Wanting to vote at 18 is not trying to stand in a room with him

  • @DistractedDaisy
    @DistractedDaisy Год назад

    Good topic. Never knew this point of view. Now I know.

  • @SS-hz4jo
    @SS-hz4jo Год назад +1

    I wonder how tall her brother was before the surgery.

  • @PaperRaines
    @PaperRaines Год назад

    I think I missed the entire point of her book and this interview

    • @NopeUghUghAbsolutelyNot
      @NopeUghUghAbsolutelyNot Год назад +2

      Basically her brother died trying to live up to standards that arent real. Or at least thats how I'm understanding it

  • @jaysong5500
    @jaysong5500 Год назад +3

    I wonder is she still a feminist tho sounds like that drove a wedge more then the minority thing

  • @TamponTimWalz
    @TamponTimWalz Год назад +7

    Any updates on the Nashville trans mass murderer manifesto??.?

    • @julesmasseffectmusic
      @julesmasseffectmusic Год назад

      So 1 trans person proves they are all the same.
      Now explain why 90 percent of mass shootings being white males has no bearing on white males.

  • @thisisanewusername4662
    @thisisanewusername4662 Год назад +3

    this was horrible

  • @TamponTimWalz
    @TamponTimWalz Год назад +4

    President Trump was described as an athlete..6’3’’ 215 pounds with "blonde or strawberry" hair and blue eyes

    • @kusheran
      @kusheran Год назад +2

      The Aryan stereotype.

  • @Publicistvideos
    @Publicistvideos Год назад +7

    Of course she completely misses the possibility that men in general regardless of race might be dealing with issues.

    • @19EHF
      @19EHF Год назад +9

      Stop. We all acknowledge that all men of all races deal with all issues when it comes to body image and perception. She is specifically talking about how it impacts black and brown men more especially in her own family she is talking about her own experience.

    • @neeldani7450
      @neeldani7450 Год назад +6

      @@19EHF She is not talking about "black and brown" men. She is talking about "Indian" men. Hence the reference "Model Minority".

    • @DJcyberslash
      @DJcyberslash Год назад +3

      ​@@19EHFshe's not talking about black people

  • @swimminginthoughts
    @swimminginthoughts Год назад +4

    How is this Trump's fault?

  • @X2LR8
    @X2LR8 Год назад +3

    Is this an Identity Politics memoir?

  • @richyp64
    @richyp64 Год назад +3

    Such a stunning and brave birthing person. Thank you for taking a stand. 👏👏👏

    • @lintoppthomas
      @lintoppthomas Год назад +4

      WOW Birthing person 😂😂😂.. Ok tell what is a women??

    • @bellepierre24
      @bellepierre24 Год назад +4

      "Birthing person"? That sounds utterly ridiculous!

    • @NopeUghUghAbsolutelyNot
      @NopeUghUghAbsolutelyNot Год назад +1

      Not the proper use of that phrase. Leave it to the scientific professionals please... women is just fine

  • @mga2899
    @mga2899 Год назад +2

    Those mini watermelons are pretty good. Get the organic ones though.

  • @Sunisbrighterandgrassisg-si1mg

    Exceptions make the rule... Can't let someone's cathartic writing turn into a tyranny of tears

  • @aurora_occidentalis2248
    @aurora_occidentalis2248 Год назад +1

    Congratulations, SpaceX, on another successful crewed mission to the International Space Station and for ending US dependency on Russian spacecraft.
    Boeing failed, Musk prevailed.

  • @TheMagicJIZZ
    @TheMagicJIZZ Год назад

    Why do people think they are owed something?

    • @kusheran
      @kusheran Год назад

      Its called a contract. In this case, its called a social contract. That is why white people believe they are owed privilege, and black people believe they are owed equal Justice under the law, and youth believe they are owed a life better than their parents... Get it?

  • @josephsonora3787
    @josephsonora3787 Год назад +1

    Im sure the door will always be open for her in Bali World? Love those musicals! ❤