Military analyst: "Israel's attack of Rafah violates all laws" | LBC
HTML-код
- Опубликовано: 24 авг 2024
- At least 35 people have been killed and dozens more are injured in Israeli airstrikes on Rafah. The rockets were launched into the southern Gaza city after Hamas launched rockets towards Tel Aviv for the first time in months.
The Israeli airstrike reportedly hit a refugee camp for displaced people, per reports from Palestinian medics.
Israel insists it hit a "Hamas compound" in Rafah, taking out two senior leaders. It added that it would investigate reports that civilians had been killed.
Shelagh Fogarty is joined by defence and security expert Professor Michael Clarke to understand more.
Listen to the full show on Global Player: app.af.globalp...
#ShelaghFogarty #Israel #Gaza #Rafah #Palestine #LBC
LBC is the home of live debate around news and current affairs in the UK.
Join in the conversation and listen at www.lbc.co.uk/
Sign up to LBC’s weekly newsletter here: l-bc.co/signup
Bring back Sangeeta
supporting hamas terrorists is illegal in UK.
Exactly ✅
We have a Knesset Lawyer masquerading as a Journalist at LBC😂
You've deleted Sangeeta as if she never existed. Shame on you, LBC.
Shame on you LBC you deleted Sanjeeta! You’re not a free media
Sangeeta who.😊😊😊😊😊😊
And it's very annoying, do the callers not deserve the reason???
@@INCREASE.THE.PEACE. apparently it was due to audience figures according to j.o.b
And it was her who didn't want to say why..
She could of said if was underhanded.
Lbc is run by elitists who only use it to gauge public reaction to the days headlines.. people should not engage..
@INCREASE.THE.PEACE. James O'Brien provided you with the reason: plummeting ratings. All that anti-Israel hysteria became tiresome and listeners went elsewhere.
We stand with sangeeta. Shame on LBC. Disgraceful.
You stand with her yet can't even spell her name correctly. I see.
@@jasongray4517 Because YT hides her name if you spell it correctly. You're not very bright, are you?
I hope she joins Mehdi Hassan's new media company Zeteo. They have been doing a great job starting out and having her would only improve them
@@jasongray4517
Haven't you ever heard of algorithmic censorship??
@@brianferguson7840 Censorship? And yet here you are spouting drivel.
Sanjeeta was sacked for holding an IDF war criminal to account.
Why does Sheelagh always feel the need to speak for Israel?
She's despicable - as if Israeli suffering even compares to Palestinian suffering.
It's because when she looks at Israel all she sees is pizza and doughnuts.
Evil 😈
@@Moonwalker379 ...and pies!
Shelagh.... 😴😴😴😴😴
Oh Shelagh still defending the indefensible.
Your right she is full on hating Putin but not netenyahooo
She's on the right side of history. For goodness sake, what is Hamas. Have you ever done some research on Hamas, Palestine, or Arab league. Or do you just go on emotional outrage
What were the Ingrun what were the Stern gang killed hundreds of British soldiers do some research
@@Bootsystem66and yet Israel funded them instead of the PLO 🤔
@Bootsystem66 No she's not.
Shelagh has heen waiting for moments to defend Israel, she's been bored for days
Two people who are trying their best to give Israel the benefit of the doubt, but Israel being so indefensible that you can see the disappointment in their voices.
It's a pretty shocking conversation considering the context of the Rafah atrocity, devoid of empathy
You lot make me sick , you go on about misguided missiles and they are still firing rockets randomly.
@@Paragon62 how sure are we that it wasn't some rogue IDF unit that fired those rockets and directed the jets to the camp?
Well first comes Saturday and then Sunday 🤷🏽
We see you !
@@eugenemurtagh2085 i have no empathy for terrorists or their supporters.
What BS, this Western media is actually sickening at this point....
Explain!!!
Because they criticize Israel in this segment???
Ba Carful about the west, 🇺🇸
They never mentioned that all the terrorists attecked Israel after the ICJ ruling. Stop defending terrorists.
Don't waste effort replying to this comment. it will either be some A.I. automated post, or, some mentally disturbed individual who's only satisfaction in life is imagining that he is provoking emotional responses.
Shelagh is a pathetic excuse of a journalist. Get off air bring back Sangeeta
Fogarty is so off so lacking in any moral fibre at all. Another dwarf chamberlain.
🏆🏆🏆🏆🏆🏆🏆
Your verdict. What qualifies you to make that judgement?
@@Bootsystem66and many other listeners
@@BruceWayne-he6hb
Listeners who keep on listening?
@@Bootsystem66 common sense
shocking journalist !..couldnt listen to her a minute longer
lol not what you wanted to hear was it? lol lol.. pathetic..
I literally turned her off at 2.18.
Where is Sangeeta?
Where did sangeeta go?
You got there before me.
she got sacked
@@harryhairo7272 Contract not renewed.
She was censored 🤬 because she talks the truth and asks them logic questions
She defends Israel like her job depends on it
It probably does…
She's probably paid by AIPAC.
Where is Sangeeta? The only ethical and moral voice at LBC.
Pure western hypocrisy
Put your house in order and leave the west alone. I'm sure you cone ftom a badly ruled country?
Lol
@@ajshaikh3213 it’s “ Bred “ buddy 😅 You know about “ emigration is obligatory for you “ ? Surah 4:97 ?
This is why you shouldn’t have Abdools serving in the Armed Forces 🤷🏽🇬🇧🇮🇳🇮🇱
What else did you expect from them???
Keep defending the devil!
💣💣💣💣🦤🦤
The devil? Israel then?
@@Prof.JeymensonCamposyes israhell
@@r0conscious
Israel is the best place for a normal person that’s a Muslim in the Middle East to live. Please don’t confuse Israel with the disputed territories of the West Bank,Golan Heights or East Jerusalem.
@@eddiecalderone Say Eddi the Expert 🤣🤣🤣
Shelagh "I must always defend Israel" .. even war has rules for civilised countries. Israel has no right to target civilians as revenge.
I don;t believe they targetted civilians. Hamas deliberately use civilian buildings, this isn't a secret. Hamas, on the other hand, started all this by obviously and willfully targetting women and children.
Does Hamas have a right to target civilians as revenge?
@@neilmarshall3071 No. We’re consistent in our arguments and morality, don’t worry about that. Killing innocent people, regardless of faith or race, is wrong, ALWAYS. Still can’t believe we have to explain that..🤦🏼♀️
@@lailahwcusansdbdb Israel did target Hamas, and most analysts say so. You just have to dig out some obscure pro-hamas apologetist that will parrot the same victim-story.
If you dont like war, thats ok, but a defensive war is not wrong.
Female soldiers are not hostages, its called POW
They better not say that word.
Don't want 'em researching what the occupiers do to POWs...
Is Shelagh being paid for by the Israeli state because it’s incredibly gaslighty!
Truth be told she she is a perfect representation of the lower\working middle class.
Poorly informed unable to hold an independent thought
Probably just trying to avoid the P45.
Gaslighty isn't a word.
@@stephenmurray8559it is now & you know what it means
@@alanhat5252 no it isn't and I don't. I suppose you can say I'm sort of don't knowy
I think we can all see right through this woman now. 😫
Through all that blubber???
7:00 . What a disgusting comment. Neglecting 75 years of oppression and apartheid and saying that it all started on the 7th of October. Ignorance at its finest.
I'm half way down the page.. not one single comment supports these liars.. it's not working, legacy media is dead.. long live the king!
Shame on you. Where is Sangeeta.
This anchor is very apologetic towards 🇮🇱
Shame on LBC
If the IDF does not want to be called barbaric they should not commit acts of barbarism.
They don't
At this point it's radical Judaeic terrorism. Using the Torah to justify massacres of children.
@@danielsgames8810lol. Delusional much?
They're still being given the arms to do it. They only complain about being called barbaric because they need to be the victim.
@KahinaKhando46 I live in what's called "reality," try it sometimes
As Josep Borrell recently stated: choice - stand with Israel OR uphold the Rule of Law.
Isn't it funny how these laws never seem to be applied to Muslim terrorist groups, like Hamas, Al Shabaab and ISIS?
👏
What laws were adhered to by Hamas and the Palestinian people on October 7th?
@@MrFoggy13and before the October the 7th? Wake up.
The world didn’t start on 7of October
does that rule of law apply to Hamas?
Sangeeta was the main person trying to stop this, and you destroyed her. LBC is a joke.
Frogarty trying to still make excuses for pissrahel lol
Israhell
IsNOTreal
Defending war crimes. Shame on you guys.
War crimes by whom?
1. Target compound was approx 200m outside safe area
2. Secondary explosions show there was ammunition stored there
Warcrime?
Where on earth is Sangeeta? We need her honest and fair reporting LBC
Palestinians have a right to defend themselves.
When injustice becomes law, then RESISTANCE becomes DUTY.
When it comes to standing up for international law, or standing up for Israel, the West will always stand against standing up for international law.
Hamas fired 8 of long range missles into tel aviv indiscriminately yesterday...israel fires one and kills two hamas top. The man is talking on hear say, what if the vehicle was carrying explosives or inflammable gases they use for their terror act. why is hamas leaders amongs the civilians or why are the civilians protecting hamas fighters?
@@emguy449 where is the proof that 2 Hamas leaders were amongst the homeless civillians? Please excuse me if I don't take Israel's word for it. Why does Israel refuse to let reputable international press agencies to report from Gaza? What do they have to hide?
@@emguy449 you understand that this whole "human shields" excuse for killing civilians doesn't make any sense, right? not only it's morally abhorrent, it's also just plain dumb - Israel bombs civilians all the time, so they don't even work as shields
Israel has iron dome. Everyone knows those rockets won’t hurt a fly because of that. This is the equivalent of a 17 year old gang member fighting a two year old and claiming he is defending himself.
@@emguy449Why shouldn't people under occupation react? Why don't you blame illegal occupation, illegal settlements or apartheid? Or right, you don't think those exist eventhough the world says it does.
Shelagh is stooge of IDF
Exactly. A warmonger and a consummate liar
Evidence.
Anyone still thinking this is ok, or defending it in any way is pure evil!!!!
Even if the two Hamas commanders were there, does that justify killing 40 or more civilians while they’re sleeping many of them children?
Can Shelagh have a permanent break and can we have Sangeeta back please?
Why are you so pro Israeli Sheelagh
Shill Fogarty still speaking for the Likud.
War crimes
Hamas war crimes.
Shelagh still trying to spin war crimes and play down atrocities.
This woman could be an IDF spokesperson
This did not begin on Oct 7th ..
🤮
Exactly.
But it didn’t start on October 7th why do you keep lying? 🇵🇸🏴
Sorry can't listen to fogherty.
😂😂😂😂
@@karlwilliams2703😂😂😂😂😂😂
Yet you clicked this video 😂 hope you had your volume turned down
*Bombherty
Don't you see the civilians had to become pink mist
Israel: "we have the most moral army. We have investigated ourselves and we have found that we have done nothing wrong."
Let's let criminals and fraudsters investigate themselves too. I'm sure they'll find nothing wrong.
Hamas fired 8 of long range missles into tel aviv indiscriminately yesterday...israel fires one and kills two hamas top. The man is talking on hear say, what if the vehicle was carrying explosives or inflammable gases they use for their terror act. why is hamas leaders amongs the civilians or why are the civilians protecting hamas fighters?
@@emguy449More lies congratulations
@emguy449 how can civilians resist to an armed group please explain
@@emguy449more to come. What did you expect?m
I agree ,and people who want true truth know too ❤,I stand with Israel,,
Shelagh. I'm done listening to you and your biased views.
No, this did not "start on October 7th"
Sheelagh seems not to be the brightest tool in the shed. 🍉😭😭 shame on LBC. Disgusting!
Smash Mouth approves this comment!
LBC can't take the L
Shocking , horrible .. that's where they told the civilians to go claiming it to be a "safe" area , pure evil
It's an active War zone.
Free palestine 🇵🇸 from the river to the sea
The colonised have the legal rights to arm resist the colonisers.
Nice try but we all know how many times Palestinian leaders have walked away from getting a Palestinian state so they can keep up their attempted annihilation of all the Jews in the Middle East
Even Quoran says - this is a land of Israel.
Many archeological discoveries confirming that .
It is Israel’s land that has been occupied.
READ AND RESPECT QUORAN !!!!!
Allah loves Israel 🇮🇱💕🇮🇱💕
Stop defending Israel
Why?
Because pure evil!!!!!!!!!! Beyond evil
@@denizozmen4840, hamas is evil!!!
@@deanrogers8381 Where have you been? on mars!
This is insanity.
I dont know what's worse -this woman or a worm? 🤦♂️
To compare her to a worm is an insult to worms.🪱
Worms are hamless lil creatures!
What is wrong with you!
It didnt begin on OCT 7TH, it escalated on OCT 7TH!
Evrytime I hear israel has the right to defend itself and international law says no occupying power has the right to defend mayb I'm ignorant to the facts can someone enlighten me please
It's because Israel aren't an occupying power.
Happy to help.
@Peter-zi4bpPalestine and hamas are the occupying power and they just so perhaps to be terrorists
@Peter-zi4bpthis is not defending. These are war crimes and crimes against humanity. Netanyahu would had a nice chair next to Von Ribbentrop
@Peter-zi4bp I'm not sure but I thought I heard that argument before so I'm just seeking clarification
Catastrophe
4:42 Israel have been in an offensive posture as an illegal occupier for decades. So how can you start this conversation on a premise that they have the right to defend themselves? If you want to call what hmas did as trrism, the you should also say what israel have been doing for decades is hundred times bigger trrism.
Nice try but we all know how many times Palestinian leaders have walked away from getting a Palestinian state so they can keep up their attempted annihilation of all the Jews in the Middle East
Israel is not occupying anything because there’s no such thing as a Palestinian State
Based
AND Everything Israel has done since October 8
nope. YHWH gave ALL the middle east lands to His Chosen People.
Your confusion is because you fail to Obey YHWH. So, repent from your apostasy, apologize to YHWH for your lack of faith, and Obey Him. Israel is Eternal.
does she still believe Netanyahu cares about the hostages. LOL.
i hate the media
Government should investigate these journalists why they are so into Israel 🇮🇱 and check their finances
We the people need to check the government and ALL mp’s to check why they too are so into ‘them’ particular the so called friends of ‘them!’
The UK Government is deeper into it than the journalists.
Conservative Friends of Israel, Labour Friends of Israel. The main defender of Palestine was smeared (Jeremy Corbyn).
It has been the same here for over a century with Waddesdon Manor.
They are and so far they only found islamists in public media.
Allah loves Israel 🇮🇱 💕
Yes , we will see how many islamists is there .
... Oh it's a mess.......this woman is vile.
This did NOT start on Oct 7. 😡😡😡
You’re right. Palestinian leaders have been walking away from getting a Palestinian state for decades just so they can keep up their attempted annihilation of all the Jews in the Middle East
Shelaugh is behaving as if Palestinians magically appeared in Middle East on October 7th 2024
It’s shocking,,help these poor people,,THE WORLD NEEDS TO STOP THIS NOW
Poor people 😂😂😂
Hamas fired 8 of long range missles into tel aviv indiscriminately yesterday...israel fires one and kills two hamas top. The man is talking on hear say, what if the vehicle was carrying explosives or inflammable gases they use for their terror act. why is hamas leaders amongs the civilians or why are the civilians protecting hamas fighters?
Hamas are firing rockets in to Israel like they have been doing for a decade israel had enough of hamas there getting wiped out
Photos of murdered babies have been going viral, all day. No, she hasn't seen the 'images coming out of Rafah'.
She is a disgrace
Dreadful woman
@@moosehakAgreed she should be sacked.☮️🇵🇸🇵🇸🇵🇸
Palestinians who is not Hamas -left .
Only Hamas and Hamas supporters stayed.
IDF spread leaflets and called to warn of upcoming military escalation.
ONLY HAMAS STAYED .
There should be independent international investigators in Palestine and Israel must allow that....
But there is no place call Palestine, maybe you mean Gaza. Palestine never exist
The world has not be on gudground to do such..
the ICJ ordered that a couple of days ago
With zero jurisdiction
Or enforcement power. Get over it
@@alanhat5252
There has to be a military presence in Israel keeping them under observation.
In 2018 Israeli soldiers shot over 6,000 Palestinians. In many cases they were shot with illegal expanding ammunition. So, did the present iteration of this problem begin on 7th October 2023 (1,200 casualties) or March/Dec 2018 (6,000 casualties) Discus ??
Kudos to the analyst for pointing out about Israelii investigation which never has an outcome
Shelagh fogerty you are such a great spokesperson for the IDF. What a great person you are 😊
Them equivocating the tens of thousands of murdered children, women and men in Gaza over the last 8 months with the 1200 from October 7th is gross. How many more kids need to die before it’s even? Another 20000? 30000? Horrid people.
“It was a tragic mistake”.
The world’s most sophisticated army tends to make very strategic “tragic mistakes”!
It wouldn't surprise me if the Israelis fired the rockets or there was no rocket attack
Got 1 minute in and decided I can't bear LBC any longer. Disgraceful station.
Free Palestine 🇵🇸
No such place.
With every box of cornflakes!
Shelagh how much did they paid
If I have to hear the phrase, 'This began on October 7th,' one more time I will lose my mind 😐
Why is Israel not allowing journalists into Gaza? The answer is obvious
Bring Sangeeta back!!
She's a great spoke person for IDF...😢
They need to stop.
Never
They need to be made to stop.
@Khalkara there's nothing on earth that can make us stop now
Hamas Shouldn't have taken the hostages and massacred those innocent civilians in Nova Festival. Hamas Shouldn't have fired from Rafah into Tel Aviv. Hamas Shouldn't be near that camp. See a pattern? Blame Hamas
Who cares
To even attempt to compare the suffering of these two peoples is abhorrent!
They are the Occupier. What do you mean they have a right to defend themselves against civilians?!
Occupier of whom? Really, I don't know why I even bother. You guys live in some other reality, apparently.
Stop defending a country breaking the law.
She is the worst
imagine a mother speaking on behalf of devils around those are shameful devils
Sangeeta was removed because the colour of her face
The people of Gaza also have the right to revolt against their own oppression. The defense guy should know that. He should also know that this mess did not begin in 2023. Only westerners seem to not know this very important fact.
Also, there will not be peace for as long as apartheid exists and these people’s children and relatives remain in prisons indefinitely. Ask South Africans. If serious about progress and an end to the mess, demand the release of both, not just one side.
No human should be expected to live under such conditions.
Israel pulled out of Gaza in 2005.
@@sabine1470but exerts a complete stranglehold on crossings and movement into and out of Gaza. They’ve treated the Palestinians with disdain for decades including the sheer inhumanity of deciding what goes into that territory and who may leave it, even for emergency care. Illegal occupiers in every respect and utterly callous.
Israel only enacted a blockade after Hamas started firing rockets into Israeli territory . Egypt also have a blockade.
Nice try but we all know how many times Palestinian leaders have walked away from getting a Palestinian state so they can keep up their attempted annihilation of all the Jews in the Middle East
@@sabine1470did they really tho Sabine ??
Isreal will never stop ,they still have European leaders and usa sipport ,peoples needs to stop bying isrealies products as well and stand for pelestenions
Nice try but we all know how many times Palestinian leaders have walked away from getting a Palestinian state so they can keep up their attempted annihilation of all the Jews in the Middle East
Shelagh is complicit!
They told the whole world what they were going to do..........and they all let it happen........disgusting
I mean pretty much the whole world has repeatedly voted at the UN for resolutions to put an immediate stop to the fighting, but the US has used its veto power every single time. America has single-handedly just overridden the votes of 95% of the world - effectively declaring that the collective will of all humanity is irrelevant & meaningless, and that a tiny cabal of people occupying positions of power in two countries gets to dictate to the entire world whether they have any say in anything at all.
When Benjamin Netanyahu held up that map showing no Gaza two weeks before October 7 th I told my elderly father that something was going to kick off by Israel.
At this point, I believe almost nothing that the media reports about this conflict
Could it be the IDF firing fireworks from Rafah, and then blaming Hamas, so to then use it for more of an excuse to invade more of Rafah?
Yes,yes.100%.
See mossad motto.
"By deception we rule"
Exactly.
Ffs 🤣🤣
Wouldnt surprise me with the amount of lies israel comes out with.
Nah, qassam took credit (quotes from telegram - only emotes and hashtags removed for brevity):
“Martyr Izz El-Din Al-Qassam Brigades:
-
Al-Qassam Brigades bombard “Tel Aviv” with a large barrage of rockets in response to the zionist massacres against civilians.
-
Note: The statement was sent one minute before the sirens began ringing.”
“The IOF army admits that the barrage of rockets fired towards the heart of the zionist entity was fired from Rafah, southern”
Why is the host trying to defend Israel and make this a 'two-sides' thing?
Did everything start on the 7th of October?? Are we kidding ourselves??
"This" didn't start on Oct 7th... A bit of perspective, please.
Shame on you call yourself journalist.... Sangyta was a honorable journalist honest, she lost her job for it lbc 🤢🤢🤢🤮🤮🤮
Shelagh Fogarty. What an utter disappointment
Hope you get issued an arrest warrant Shelagh….it could happen…
keep defending the devil
What can we expect from an evil, wicked nation?