*Hello A'Tin...* If you see this... please *control your emotion.* Yes the last thing we need is for Sejun to be discredited but for now don't throw hate since we really don't know the translation with the little subtitles provided. Please please... Lets put some allowance that *ENGLISH* is not his 1st languange and maybe he doesnt intent it to be the wrong way *ALWAYS CHOOSE TO BE KIND.* *A'TIN PLEASE.*
Showbt should clear this since they're the one who posted this in social media so ATIN lets calm down and waiting for their right translation or explanation. Don't forget to be nice still coz we are ATIN a role model to others as what our boys SB19 does.
In my opinion 1. The lyrics of GO UP was written by SB19's leader Sejun. 2. The melody/beat came from Real Bros. They own it. 3rd. The song GO UP was copyrighted and released by SONY and SBT So technically, this unreleased "Beautiful Love" is NOT recreated. So, GO UP is an original song of SB19.
im sorry to say this but what we've known SB19 o Sejun doesn't recreated the song, yes the same melody but Sejun wrote the lyrics himself. Yours is more on love story while SB19 one is about their journey from the very start of their training days when they almost give up, maybe because you have the same company thats why i guess.. Thank you.. God bless We stan #SB19 No hate just love SPREADLOVE
@@johntubillo1465 yes i knew i think he's the leader of the bnf 👉? But anyway it shouldn't be recreated instead it his version of Go Up... I respect and try to understand him nlng coz language barrier maybe the subtitles are not accurate somehow ..Gb
That's the demo, remember how they sang a song about a girl being pretty even with make up with same melody as Go Up in their live I think it's same as this
No. I beg to disagree. There's absolutely something happening here. First, this video was posted saying that SB19 "RECREATED" your unreleased song with the same tune as Go Up. And then now, someone from showbt's staff tweeted on SB19 official twitter account saying that this is a "Korean Version" of Go Up????? Do you even understand what you're trying to imply here??? First, they did not "recreate YOUR song" because yours is an unreleased, unofficial one. It would sound proper if you'll say that "YOU recreate their song". Second, (FOR THE COMPANY) this is not even considered a "Korean Version". The title, the lyrics, and the meaning behind the song "Go Up" is way too different from this song. I do appreciate your hardwork for your song, but please, give credit where the credit is due. And its not yours to claim it.
@@Adikotaku No. Sejun did not use it. It was given to them by their company. And for the fact that "Beautiful Love" is an unreleased song, they can't claim it as theirs cause technically, it doesn't exist. He makes it look like SB19 should have a debt of gratitude to them because they were the originals, and SB19 got their limelight by "RECREATING" their song. Which in any ways, is not true.
@@rhonalynflores8802 Sejun wrote the lyrics of go up and use the melody of beautiful love. That former BNF member wrote the lyrics of beautiful love and the melody was provided by their company but the song beautiful love was never release and the melody was given to SB19 thats why they use it for go-up.
rhonalyn flores darling, you’re in denial. SB19 made the lyrics for go up. True. No doubt about that. But the melody used is “beautiful love”. You’re also wrong to say that the song “beautiful love” was not released so it doesn’t exist. Hypothetical, if their group really made the melody but sb19 “stole” it then released that as their song, are you still going to say that they, who worked hard for the melody, has no rights for it? Again, that is a hypothetical scenario which is very far from the truth. Sb19 obviously didn’t stole the melody. They were given permission to use the melody. And just to hammer it down for you. If SB19 really has full rights to the song “go up” (lyrics and melody), why don’t you ask ShowBT or SB19 themselves to sue this person for using the melody of their song? 🙃 or claiming the melody of their song, for that matter? Oops I bet they can’t, right?
@@DDD-qm1nj Hello! Please get your facts straight, first 🙂 The melody of "Go Up" and "Beautiful Love" doesn't belong to Daewon or his group. It was composed and produced by the music producer group RealBros led by Oh Won Lee, which was made for ShowBT. The demo was given to BNF first, and then to SB19. BNF did not have the chance to release their song "Beautiful Love" because some of their members had to undergo military training. While SB19, had the chance to release their song "Go Up". As I said, only the demo music was given to both group. Sejun himself said in an interview that during the recording, the producer even let them to be free and creative to add some flavor to the song (which makes it distinctively theirs). I acknowledge BNF as seniors of SB19, but that's just it. Give credit to where credit is due. The lyrics of "Beautiful love", I'll give it to them.
I think it is a wrong pronoucement on BNFs leader that SB19 recreated that song since it is a unreleased song. So technically Go Up even the melody is a SB19 original, and the BNF leader is just recreating SB19’s song... It should be this way and not the other way around...
@@saint9981 he maybe didn't mean it that way. But the subtitle was there already. Imagine this video pop out of casuals or haters' reco, then concluded already that sb19 is 'recreating' the songs?? You cannot force them to understand the whole plot of the story, they will only believe in what they saw/heard.. The reason why they should take this down already or Sony will be the one making a move.. It's up to them
Are you serious?? Beautiful Love is originally a demo song for BNF. Do you have any receipts that "technically" this song was originally for SB19? Showbt just gave this melody to SB19 and thankfully Sejun was given the chance to rewrite its lyrics. This was supposed to be BNF's single. So don't go around telling everyone he has no right.
We love go up is it because of the lyrics that move our heart and inspire us that all thank you Choose to be kind that what pinuno said thank you again
Mga Kapatid chill lang HAHAHAHAH....baka wrong lang yung translation kasi di niya first language ang english compared saten (pero sana ganun nga kasi kung hindi...ABA! TARA SA KOREA HUNTINGIN NATEN TO)
It's not a korean version tho. Same melody but not the same lyrics. Go up and beautiful love IS DIFFERENT. the title and lyrics is DIFFERENT. If you want to hear the demo of GO UP KOREAN version try to search other korean fans do the TRUE KOREAN VERSION OF GO UP.
Thanks for this sunbae! You were already disbanded before I discovered SB19 and BNF. But thank you very much sunbae! We haven't forgotten your group. Hope you are happy where you are now. Fighting! ✊
@@Adikotaku @Won't Grow Up You keep repeating things with malice against Sejun, 😑when things is about "company supplied" music composition. The company has 2 groups one was disbanded then the company reused or used unreleased composition intended for their disbanded boy group to their new boy group which is Sb19, so Sejun a talented songwriter (yes he can compose a melody/music as well as write lyrics) conceptualized the story wrote the lyrics its not merely a translation from a korean lyrics.
Well people who know SB19 knows that they write their own songs. Maybe same in melody, but to make it clear since you said that "SB19 recreated the beautiful love", sejun the leader of SB19 writes their own songs. Go up is inspired in their story not in any song. Thank you😉
I'm a simple fan of SB19 I'm mostly calm when it comes to issues that involve SB19 and ShowBT because of respect that I have. So I'm asking nicely to ShowBT company to please enlightened us. This issue has a possibility to ruin SB19 reputation as a group and as a Artist. We want to protect SB19 that's why we are still waiting for all the statements that you need to tell us. To all my co-A'tin please approach ShowBT company in a nice way not in a sarcastically way it might not help that situation to get better if y'all let your anger eat you.
Hindi mo na kailangan mag lagay ng make up yeah iyong ganda ay nakakasilaw na yeah!! Remember the real story behind the Go Up na kinuwento ni sejun ayan yun binago lang ni sejun ang kwento ginawa nilang kwento about sa real life story nila kasi nga baka daw hindi tangkilikin ng pinoy kaya ginawa nila nag sulat sila about sa pinagdaanan nila at yun na ang naging Go Up
ahhhhhhhhhhhh...... eto pala yung original n lyrics, according sa mga interview nila yung nung pinadala sa knila yung sounds / tugtug nung Go Up nung Composer sa Korea.. Lagi cnsabi ni Pinuno yon sa interview nila he Write the lyrics,not composed the songs / sounds khit sa post dba nakalagay Lyricist dba po?... Anyway thank you po... Itsura namang legal ang pagkaka pasa ng sounds sa #SB19 kaya nman may #thank you cya dba? ....Godbless and Keepsafe always
A'tin calm down first because we even don't know if the translation is correct or not, english is not his first language like us, korean is not our language so we are not sure what he saying
No need to translate GO UP since this is the original lyrics of BEAUTIFUL LOVE before it became GO UP. Apparently this demo song was rewritten by SEJUN.
@@honeyglaze975 Go Up was first released, Beautiful Love was NEVER released. Go Up has been registered with COPYRIGHT by Sony and ShowBTPH. Saying, "recreated INTO Go Up" is entirely wrong. Melody was given to both groups, they wrote their own different lyrics. Difference is, GO UP was RELEASED.
I believe that whoever sang it with most impact owns the song.Thank you for singing this but SB19 owns the song.It is our flag song, it lifts our spirits, we face life with its ups and downs with this song.Together ,SB19 and A'Tin we say this is PPOP song.Thanks BNF and I wish you luck in you next endeavors in life. SB19 is PPOP Kings.
Excuse me sir I think your misleading. GO UP is already released and originally wrote by Sejun the pinuno and helped by the group. Stan Talent, Stand SB19. Thank you.
From my own understanding, basing from the music k-drama's I've watched. The melody was one of the demo songs that BNF has had to choose from but it wasn't their or their companies choice tis why the melody was kept and luckily it was given to SB19 tis why Go Up was created.
Kalma lang mga kapatid... BNF ba sya? Under showbt rin sila, yaan nyo sya magkaiba sila ng message.. and baka mali lang ng translate or nagamit na word sa subtitle... but I think the beat of the music fits an inspirational song than a love song or whatsoever... glad that SB19 and tatang robin released this song... the message is really inspiring and the beat
@@Adikotaku Still wrong way to put it, Sejun conceptualized and wrote the lyrics on a music composition supplied by their company just to be clear. Its not Sb19 has taken something from Bnf nor does Bnf composed their own music and was taken by SB19, its their company's
Wooow good to know 🤗🤗🤗 It is the same with Become petals of BNF and HSH of SB19 Now, Beautiful Love of BNF and Go Up of SB19. Thank you for supporting SB19 💙
Sorry to say this sr. But technically sb19 released the song first tho different lyrics but all the royalties belongs to them and to the company/music labels and that includes the melodies.. It's safe to say you're the one recreating the song 😊.
@@Adikotaku You keep repeating things with malice against Sejun, 😑when things is about "company supplied" music composition. The company has 2 groups one was disbanded then the company reused or used unreleased composition intended for their disbanded boy group to their new boy group which is Sb19, so Sejun a talented songwriter (yes he can compose a melody/music as well as write lyrics) conceptualized the story wrote the lyrics its not merely a translation from a korean lyrics.
Poncho Pilato darling, you’re in denial. SB19 made the lyrics for go up. True. No doubt about that. But the melody used is “beautiful love”. You’re also wrong to say that the song “beautiful love” was not released so it doesn’t exist. Hypothetical, if their group really made the melody but sb19 “stole” it then released that as their song, are you still going to say that they, who worked hard for the melody, has no rights for it? Again, that is a hypothetical scenario which is very far from the truth. Sb19 obviously didn’t stole the melody. They were given permission to use the melody. And just to hammer it down for you. If SB19 really has full rights to the song “go up” (lyrics and melody), why don’t you ask ShowBT or SB19 themselves to sue this person for using the melody of their song? 🙃 or claiming the melody of their song, for that matter? Oops I bet they can’t, right?
@@DDD-qm1nj @DwN Napaka low comprehension mo. Wag moko akusahan sa putapete mong perspective/comprehension! BASA!!! when things is about "company supplied" music composition. The company has 2 groups one was disbanded then the company reused (kundi ka low comprehension indirectly meant ko na diyan from whole sentence thought with reused ay "released") or used unreleased composition intended for their disbanded boy group to their new boy group which is Sb19, so Sejun a talented songwriter (yes he can compose a melody/music as well as write lyrics) conceptualized the story wrote the lyrics its not merely a translation from a korean lyrics. (Hindi translation ng korean lyrics nor story na sinulat ng BNF) Poncho Pilato darling, you’re in denial. SB19 made the lyrics for go up. True. No doubt about that. But the melody used is “beautiful love”. (sinabi ko bang hindi? sabi ko nga yung kumpanya reused released at unreleased sa other boy group nila which is SB19) You’re also wrong to say that the song “beautiful love” was not released so it doesn’t exist. (obab 2 ginamit ko na term released at unreleased dahil HSH melody ay released na under BNF while yung Go up melody hindi na released dahil nadisband na ang BNF. Infact yung HSH tuwing kinakanta ng SB19 pinapakita yung MV ng BNF) Hypothetical, if their group really made the melody but sb19 “stole” it then released that as their song, are you still going to say that they, who worked hard for the melody, has no rights for it? (fyi hindi BNF ang gumawa ng melody kundi Realbros ang kumpanya na Showbt bumili para ipagamit sa boygroups nila) Again, that is a hypothetical scenario which is very far from the truth. Sb19 obviously didn’t stole the melody. (Ako ba nag akusa? Etong BNF member nagsabi nirecreate ng Sb19 yung song nila, iyan nga ang misplaced mistulang tinatanggalan ng kredito ang Sb19 kaya ang opinyon ko di dapat ganyan palabasin kung may issue man eto ay dahil sa desisyon ng kumpanya na gamitin muli yung melody/music composition when assigned at naka buo na pala sila ng released at finished ready to be released under sa una nilang boy group kaya ngayon eto nag claim na nirecreate yung kanilang kanta) They were given permission to use the melody (Ayan nga eh ikaw lang din naman nagsabi na kinuha nila pag aari ng BNF dahil low confused comprehension mo ) And just to hammer it down for you. If SB19 really has full rights to the song “go up” (lyrics and melody), why don’t you ask ShowBT or SB19 themselves to sue this person for using the melody of their song? 🙃 (Yung kumpanya may full rights sila naghire ng music composer/writer, sila bumili sa komposisyon kanila yun sila nagbigay sa talented boy groups nila na ininvolve nila sa paggawa pagsulat ng istorya ng kanta/lyrics, aniya ng iba yung BNF din sumusulat ng lyrics nila same sa Sb19' ang sa Sb19 ay lyrics at choreo given na pahintulot dahil empleyado under sila ng kumpanya ikaw lang naman low comprehension na tingin mo may iniissue o issue pa iyan) or claiming the melody of their song, for that matter? Oops I bet they can’t, right Ooops Ang sakit sa ulo ng kaepalan mo mi basic fact about sa topic hindi mo alam comprehended, sakin mo pinamukha sa pag akusa sisihin mo ko ng bagay na hindi ko pinaka-hulugan. Ayan ang totoong hammer o minaso talaga 🔨 baka ikaw pa mag indenial at patuloy pumutak magpapampam dahil nahurt ka ng binalik sayo, mahiya ka naman.
@@DDD-qm1nj you know what? Ang dami mong sinabi? Ang point lng naman eh, give credit where credit is due.. The subtitle was obviously mean them owning the entire song (including melody) which is btw created by real bros. Then labelling sb19 as the one who recreate the song? A song includes melody and lyrics, but melody is the only part of the song that was given to Sb19 which is uulitin ko created by real bros not them. So basically sb19 didn't recreate anything from them. They created their original song using a unreleased melody owned by the company not BNF. If sbt let them upload this video then why they will sue him? Wala naman akong problem dun.. The subtitle was my only problem since it will cause misunderstanding from the casual viewers.
maybe what he meant by "recreated the song" yes sejun wrote the lyrics but the instrumental used is for beautiful love? like the one in hanggang sa huli and become petals has the same instrumental but different lyrics right? please A'tin do not spread hate! only love! ❤❤
Well, it was mentioned by Esbi in one of their videos kamakailan lang na may cheesy Tagalog lyrics na sana yung Go Up but then they decided to change it and write their story instead. In this sense, recreated na nga ang Go Up.
But technically speaking it is not. Sb19 Go up released first and was already licensed by SONY. So recreated will never be the word. BNF version should be the term used.
@@engr.j2261 You didn't get what I meant. "Recreated" as in "SB19 recreated their (SB19's) own song from a pop love song to an inspirational love song". The point being SB19 already started the tagalog love song lyrics but scrapped it/recreated it into an inspiring song instead. Regardless I really don't get why we have to nitpick this and make it grow into an issue. BNF and SB19 are sibling groups under the same company and it's the company that gave the same instrumentals for both groups to work with, same with Kkonipidwaeyo and HSH. What's the point of making this chaotic? A'TIN will just become a toxic fandom instead of an understanding fandom at this rate. If we're really trying yo nitpick here, I'm pretty sure it all boils down to grammar and diction in which case the use of the word "recreated" again becomes valid due to how I described it earlier. It's all just a problem of context. I really don't see the issue. Sejun is OFFICIALLY credited for the lyrics so ano pang pinaglalaban natin dito? Anong gusto nating mangyari? Can't we just appreciate sunbae for remembering SB19? Sa mga old videos ng BNF, supportive pa ang A'TIN, bakit ganito ngayon? Is this because maraming new A'TIN who aren't properly informed? Or has the A'TIN fandom grown too toxic?
I'll give you the benefit of the doubt. I understand English is not your first language. I would say VERSION instead of recreating. The music was given to them but the lyrics were written by the members. So it is safe to say, you have your own version of that song, SB19 has its own version of the song .
Hoy A'TIN.. tama na.. same company naman.. be open minded naman.. #ProtectSB19atAllCost.. ahhaha.. sge lang.. hintayin nalang natin yung statement ng SBT 😇😇💙
We'll for me, it doesn't really matter. SB19 have proven themselves already that's why they have A'tin, they really dont have to explain anything to those who believe in them. Other people might say something about this but they are the ones who are just waiting for SB19 to mess up and this is the perfect opportunity for them. A'tin I know you are all affected but we should focus more on SB19, they need us now more than ever. By keep digging on things like this, it will only have a negative effect on SB19 as well as A'tin. This is already a slap on the face for our boys, this is their redemption song and there's no better meaning or lyrics for it. Periodt! Now close the door and don't let negativity enter!
Eto siguro yung kinukwento ni sejun na go up tapos about sa ganda nung girl na hindi na kailangan maglagay pa ng make up yeah hahahhaa A'tin calm down remember yung kwento about Go Up na dapat love song for a girl pero ginawa na lng nila about their hardwork at pinagdaanan nila sana naalala nio okay
Naalala ko din to kapatid. Sadyang mali lang yung ginamit niya na term kaya nahahype ang *A'tin* misleading rin kasi yung sinabi niya or baka yung translation niya.
A'tin kalma muna tayooo baka mistranslated lang, baka di talaga ganon yung gusto niyang sabihin kaya pls di matutuwa ang boys pag nalaman nila na ganto tayo makitungo. Just saying lang po. Pls no hate, just spread love saka sabi ni pinuno diba "always choose to be kind" Alab you alll co-a'tin💙
It’s been a few months when this was uploaded on YT, but I’m still wondering on what this guy’s ulterior motives are in uploading this shelved version of his defunct group’s song.
I was excited when SB19 official posted that BNF Daewon will have his cover of go up but then here's what I saw, him saying that the boys recreated the song. Sejun wrote it by himself maybe the company gave them the same melody that's why pareho sila. But it's not recreated they just received the same melody from the company. ShowBT should give clear explanation abt this statement. #SB19HanggangSaHuli💙 #ProtectTheBoysAtAllCost
If sejun recreated this why would he claims that he wrote the song? And if he recreated this song why would he make "Go Up" and this " beautiful love" very the same beat? It's very impossible! SB19 ARE TALENTED THEY WROTE GO UP..!!
@@Adikotaku @Won't Grow Up You keep repeating things with malice against Sejun, 😑when things is about "company supplied" music composition. The company has 2 groups one was disbanded then the company reused or used unreleased composition intended for their disbanded boy group to their new boy group which is Sb19, so Sejun a talented songwriter (yes he can compose a melody/music as well as write lyrics) conceptualized the story wrote the lyrics its not merely a translation from a korean lyrics and story.
@@davidkrappenschitz4753 lol! I said Sejun use the melody of beautiful love and yes sujun wrote the lyrics. OMG! Lyrics and melody is tow different thing. lol!
@@Adikotaku I already highlighted about this, we don't have any confirmation yet to Showbt. But, if sejun recreated the melody not the "whole song!" I think there is nothing to worry about, sejun made and other members their own lyrics and made sence that they completely composed the lyrics not the song(melody/beats.. Lol) .
@@davidkrappenschitz4753 we shouldn't argue about this issue, we better support them instead. Let's just wait for the confirmation of the company itself if this video is fake. SPREAD LOVE ONLY A'TIN.
Hi we just need clarification, did you really mean that SB19 recreated this song? Kindly clarify, because from what we've kwnown the lyrics of SB19's Go Up is wrote by their leader Sejun and their song Go Up is all about their journey as a group. They just have the same melody (maybe because you're from the same company) No hate, I just noticed that "recreated" thingy.
The song was composed by Lee Oh Won. SB19 did Go Up lyrics while BNF did Beatiful Love lyrics. Another song was composed by a Korean composer - SB19 did Hanggang sa Huli lyrics while BNF did Become Petals lyrics...BNF had already disbanded since early 2019.
Sir, next time be careful using the RIGHT WORD or words. Filipinos are everywhere, most of them are perfectionist when it comes to English. They are mostly sensitive when they think it was inappropriate. Somehow, because of that single word (they misundertood it perhaps). But, also an eye opener for everyone. No one is perfect but we can fix this or need some clarification about this. We know what's the real score about #SB19 and we believed in them. God bless us all 💙❤️😍
Bernadette Caseñas yes I hope he clarifies this one because this is very misleading. Hopefully it's just bc of the language barrier but still doesn't change the fact that he should've been extra careful because it is posted online for everyone to see. It's his responsibility. :( I just hope this is being taken care of because I see a lot of Koreans commenting na baka ma-mislead sla if ever yun talaga yung ibig sabihin nya. :(( I think Sony can sue him din if ever na yun yung ibig nya talaga sabihin kasi ni "claim" nya eh kaya sana ma-clarify nya agad. 😐
I beg to differ. This isnt simple identification of mistaken translation. pinuno’s and SB19’s reputation is on the line here. This is good that we draw the line of whats right and wrong. And josh in a recent twitter post but now deleted is questioning this as well.
Bago mag talk and talk make sure alam po ang story behind that song. Love Song ang original Go Up... binago "nirecreate " nila ginawang inspirational nirelate sa buhay nila ng SB19 kaya naging Go Up. Alam ito ng mga totoong A'tin kasi napanood mismo nila kong ano ang sinabi ni Sejun about sa story ng Go Up.
Recreated (Merriam-Webster) 1. Past Tense of Recreate 2. To give NEW life or freshness to 3. To create AGAIN So now Sir, with all due respect, was Beautiful Love officially realeased before SB19? To have the License just like how SB19 and Sony have right now which is very much evident in you video? So, I don't think the word RECREATED is the proper one for this. If you said that word to Hanggang sa Huli (Becoming Petals) I may not argue with you since you released it first. But give credit to these people. It may have given to your group before hand but the fact that it was not released, then I don't think you can claim as the originator of it... Just my opinion. I do make poems, and i do have to register my poem in order to have the copyright to it. And if any case, my poem was registered by somebody else (for any other reason and situation) before me I will lose the ownership of it... #RespectBegetsRespect #JustSaying #MyOpinion
LarrianLarrios1447 darling, you’re in denial. SB19 made the lyrics for go up. True. No doubt about that. But the melody used is “beautiful love”. You’re also wrong to say that the song “beautiful love” was not released so it doesn’t exist. Hypothetical, if their group really made the melody but sb19 “stole” it then released that as their song, are you still going to say that they, who worked hard for the melody, has no rights for it? Again, that is a hypothetical scenario which is very far from the truth. Sb19 obviously didn’t stole the melody. They were given permission to use the melody. And just to hammer it down for you. If SB19 really has full rights to the song “go up” (lyrics and melody), why don’t you ask ShowBT or SB19 themselves to sue this person for using the melody of their song? 🙃 or claiming the melody of their song, for that matter? Oops I bet they can’t, right?
@@DDD-qm1nj thank you for your opinion. You have yours, I have mine. I respect yours. I won't impose you to respect mine, but that is solely your decision. Have a nice and fruitful day(s). God Bless!
![경연때 부르려고 했었던 반키올린 [이대원 - 우산이 없어요/김호중] #trotclass #k_music](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/wNq7dNZWb4g/mqdefault.jpg)
![경연때 부르려고 했었던 반키올린 [이대원 - 우산이 없어요/김호중] #trotclass #k_music](/img/tr.png)
넘 사랑스런 이대원~~
*Hello A'Tin...*
If you see this... please *control your emotion.* Yes the last thing we need is for Sejun to be discredited but for now don't throw hate since we really don't know the translation with the little subtitles provided. Please please...
Lets put some allowance that *ENGLISH* is not his 1st languange and maybe he doesnt intent it to be the wrong way
*ALWAYS CHOOSE TO BE KIND.*
*A'TIN PLEASE.*
Please like this guys so others can see
Up
Up up
choose to be kind ba?
@@atetitatitashanm4632 for now
That is one beautiful boy who can sing too!!😍🔥
아웅~~봐도봐도 너무~너~으~~무~~므쪄므쪄~~💜💜
Showbt should clear this since they're the one who posted this in social media so ATIN lets calm down and waiting for their right translation or explanation. Don't forget to be nice still coz we are ATIN a role model to others as what our boys SB19 does.
The translation is correct. A full-blooded Korean A'Tin named jaySuson on twitter confirmed this.
In my opinion
1. The lyrics of GO UP was written by SB19's leader Sejun.
2. The melody/beat came from Real Bros. They own it.
3rd. The song GO UP was copyrighted and released by SONY and SBT
So technically, this unreleased "Beautiful Love" is NOT recreated. So, GO UP is an original song of SB19.
TRUE.
true
Trueeeee
AGREE
Agree
굿
im sorry to say this but what we've known SB19 o Sejun doesn't recreated the song, yes the same melody but Sejun wrote the lyrics himself. Yours is more on love story while SB19 one is about their journey from the very start of their training days when they almost give up, maybe because you have the same company thats why i guess.. Thank you.. God bless
We stan #SB19
No hate just love
SPREADLOVE
Uhm... he's a member of a former group of ShowBT
Yan original demo . Binili ng sb19 yung masters copyright. Sila original demo
@@johntubillo1465 yes i knew i think he's the leader of the bnf 👉?
But anyway it shouldn't be recreated instead it his version of Go Up... I respect and try to understand him nlng coz language barrier maybe the subtitles are not accurate somehow ..Gb
That's the demo, remember how they sang a song about a girl being pretty even with make up with same melody as Go Up in their live I think it's same as this
@@johnpatrickoraya8964 don't say that po.. Respect is key po tayo.
No. I beg to disagree. There's absolutely something happening here. First, this video was posted saying that SB19 "RECREATED" your unreleased song with the same tune as Go Up. And then now, someone from showbt's staff tweeted on SB19 official twitter account saying that this is a "Korean Version" of Go Up????? Do you even understand what you're trying to imply here???
First, they did not "recreate YOUR song" because yours is an unreleased, unofficial one. It would sound proper if you'll say that "YOU recreate their song".
Second, (FOR THE COMPANY) this is not even considered a "Korean Version". The title, the lyrics, and the meaning behind the song "Go Up" is way too different from this song.
I do appreciate your hardwork for your song, but please, give credit where the credit is due. And its not yours to claim it.
Yes you are correct Sejun wrote the lyrics. he just use the melody or music of Beautiful Love.
@@Adikotaku No. Sejun did not use it. It was given to them by their company. And for the fact that "Beautiful Love" is an unreleased song, they can't claim it as theirs cause technically, it doesn't exist.
He makes it look like SB19 should have a debt of gratitude to them because they were the originals, and SB19 got their limelight by "RECREATING" their song. Which in any ways, is not true.
@@rhonalynflores8802 Sejun wrote the lyrics of go up and use the melody of beautiful love. That former BNF member wrote the lyrics of beautiful love and the melody was provided by their company but the song beautiful love was never release and the melody was given to SB19 thats why they use it for go-up.
rhonalyn flores darling, you’re in denial. SB19 made the lyrics for go up. True. No doubt about that. But the melody used is “beautiful love”. You’re also wrong to say that the song “beautiful love” was not released so it doesn’t exist. Hypothetical, if their group really made the melody but sb19 “stole” it then released that as their song, are you still going to say that they, who worked hard for the melody, has no rights for it? Again, that is a hypothetical scenario which is very far from the truth. Sb19 obviously didn’t stole the melody. They were given permission to use the melody. And just to hammer it down for you. If SB19 really has full rights to the song “go up” (lyrics and melody), why don’t you ask ShowBT or SB19 themselves to sue this person for using the melody of their song? 🙃 or claiming the melody of their song, for that matter? Oops I bet they can’t, right?
@@DDD-qm1nj Hello! Please get your facts straight, first 🙂
The melody of "Go Up" and "Beautiful Love" doesn't belong to Daewon or his group. It was composed and produced by the music producer group RealBros led by Oh Won Lee, which was made for ShowBT. The demo was given to BNF first, and then to SB19. BNF did not have the chance to release their song "Beautiful Love" because some of their members had to undergo military training.
While SB19, had the chance to release their song "Go Up". As I said, only the demo music was given to both group. Sejun himself said in an interview that during the recording, the producer even let them to be free and creative to add some flavor to the song (which makes it distinctively theirs). I acknowledge BNF as seniors of SB19, but that's just it.
Give credit to where credit is due. The lyrics of "Beautiful love", I'll give it to them.
He must be envious what they are now thats only I know...malayo n ang narating ng mga boys ngayon lng nila post ito .. unbelievable!!!!!
He has a very nice voice 👏👏👏
You did well oppa 💕
Let us calm down,,,, well it was meant for SB19. He even congratulates. SB19 is SB19 let us just be proud
I think it is a wrong pronoucement on BNFs leader that SB19 recreated that song since it is a unreleased song. So technically Go Up even the melody is a SB19 original, and the BNF leader is just recreating SB19’s song... It should be this way and not the other way around...
Lets give allowance for hin that english is not his first languange so maybe he doesnt meant it the wrong way
The english translation is as clear as water honey!
@@saint9981 he maybe didn't mean it that way. But the subtitle was there already. Imagine this video pop out of casuals or haters' reco, then concluded already that sb19 is 'recreating' the songs?? You cannot force them to understand the whole plot of the story, they will only believe in what they saw/heard..
The reason why they should take this down already or Sony will be the one making a move.. It's up to them
Recreated the released song "INTO" go up
Are you serious?? Beautiful Love is originally a demo song for BNF. Do you have any receipts that "technically" this song was originally for SB19? Showbt just gave this melody to SB19 and thankfully Sejun was given the chance to rewrite its lyrics. This was supposed to be BNF's single. So don't go around telling everyone he has no right.
We love go up is it because of the lyrics that move our heart and inspire us that all thank you
Choose to be kind that what pinuno said thank you again
Nang gigigil ako! Pigilan nyo ako!
Di va kapatid.. Nakakgigil??!!! Sana mag salita sya NG maayos. Tumataas kilay ko hahaha 😂😂
Mga Kapatid chill lang HAHAHAHAH....baka wrong lang yung translation kasi di niya first language ang english compared saten (pero sana ganun nga kasi kung hindi...ABA! TARA SA KOREA HUNTINGIN NATEN TO)
A'TIN calm down.We need to inform this matter first to ShowBT and Sony Music Philippines.
Hello co - ATIN ano po bang dapat ikagigil niyo? May I ask lang po. Hindi po natin alam yung buong kaganapan. So iwas po tayo sa issue.
@@joshua4785 hahaahah sama ako kapatid
이제 글로벌 스타로 쭉쭉~~-조아~조아 👍👍👍💜💜
It is good to hear the demo version of Go Up in Korean! Thank you for this. It is nice to see you back.
It's not a korean version tho. Same melody but not the same lyrics. Go up and beautiful love IS DIFFERENT. the title and lyrics is DIFFERENT. If you want to hear the demo of GO UP KOREAN version try to search other korean fans do the TRUE KOREAN VERSION OF GO UP.
Thank you for your good wishes and being a good Senior to SB19. Hope you will have a reunion performance in the future🌿
울 워니 맘도 최고
I'm allergic to the "recreated" word in this. Kbye. SpreadLOVE💟
Yeah, it’s just a mild case of wrong choice of words. That “recreated” thing sounded a tad bit on the negative side.
Thanks for this sunbae! You were already disbanded before I discovered SB19 and BNF. But thank you very much sunbae! We haven't forgotten your group. Hope you are happy where you are now. Fighting! ✊
Nakakainit ng dugo to ha... Wag kang mang-angkin ng hindi sayo, pinuri mo p ang SB19 kiniclaim mo nmn sayo ang orig!
Well we like go up of SB19 because of the lyrics written by their leader our pinuno💙💙💙
Yes you are correct Sejun wrote the lyrics. he just use the melody or music of Beautiful Love.
@@Adikotaku @Won't Grow Up You keep repeating things with malice against Sejun, 😑when things is about "company supplied" music composition. The company has 2 groups one was disbanded then the company reused or used unreleased composition intended for their disbanded boy group to their new boy group which is Sb19, so Sejun a talented songwriter (yes he can compose a melody/music as well as write lyrics) conceptualized the story wrote the lyrics its not merely a translation from a korean lyrics.
ANUNAAA SHOWBTTTTT BAAKAAA GUSTOOO NYONG KUMILOS🙂
hindi kikilos yun pinapa-hype nga yung disbanded na niyang banda e. hindi alam kung sino talaga focus nila dapat.
#SB19 💙💙💙💙💙💙🇵🇭
비주얼 미쳤다 진짜~ 노래도 너무잘해 하아~~
Well people who know SB19 knows that they write their own songs. Maybe same in melody, but to make it clear since you said that "SB19 recreated the beautiful love", sejun the leader of SB19 writes their own songs. Go up is inspired in their story not in any song. Thank you😉
뭐야? 노래 좋고~ 너무 잘부르고~🤣
진짜 장르불문하고 다 잘하네요👍
새로운 모습에 오늘도 또 반했어요^^😍
안녕! 이거 에스비19는 노래 Go Up 들어봐요 ^^,
I'm a simple fan of SB19 I'm mostly calm when it comes to issues that involve SB19 and ShowBT because of respect that I have. So I'm asking nicely to ShowBT company to please enlightened us. This issue has a possibility to ruin SB19 reputation as a group and as a Artist. We want to protect SB19 that's why we are still waiting for all the statements that you need to tell us. To all my co-A'tin please approach ShowBT company in a nice way not in a sarcastically way it might not help that situation to get better if y'all let your anger eat you.
이 커버곡도 겁나좋네요.굿~~♡
hey, as far as i know, sejun or the whole SB19 didnt recreate the song Go Up. RealBros produced it and the lyrics was originally wrote by SEJUN.
Hindi mo na kailangan mag lagay ng make up yeah iyong ganda ay nakakasilaw na yeah!!
Remember the real story behind the Go Up na kinuwento ni sejun ayan yun binago lang ni sejun ang kwento ginawa nilang kwento about sa real life story nila kasi nga baka daw hindi tangkilikin ng pinoy kaya ginawa nila nag sulat sila about sa pinagdaanan nila at yun na ang naging Go Up
Yes you are correct Sejun wrote the lyrics. he just use the melody or music of Beautiful Love.
ahhhhhhhhhhhh...... eto pala yung original n lyrics, according sa mga interview nila yung nung pinadala sa knila yung sounds / tugtug nung Go Up nung Composer sa Korea.. Lagi cnsabi ni Pinuno yon sa interview nila he Write the lyrics,not composed the songs / sounds khit sa post dba nakalagay Lyricist dba po?... Anyway thank you po... Itsura namang legal ang pagkaka pasa ng sounds sa #SB19 kaya nman may #thank you cya dba? ....Godbless and Keepsafe always
Hi! Thanks for the congratulations to sb19. Im sure that there will be more songs to come your way. Goodluck on your career sir!!!
A'tin calm down first because we even don't know if the translation is correct or not, english is not his first language like us, korean is not our language so we are not sure what he saying
Pero bakit po may mga 'baby'?
The translation is correct. A full-blooded Korean A'Tin named jaySuson on twitter confirmed this.
No need to translate GO UP since this is the original lyrics of BEAUTIFUL LOVE before it became GO UP. Apparently this demo song was rewritten by SEJUN.
@@patriciarivero7606 yung message ng story iba sa Go Up, Yung sakanya story about love sya.
@@honeyglaze975 Go Up was first released, Beautiful Love was NEVER released. Go Up has been registered with COPYRIGHT by Sony and ShowBTPH. Saying, "recreated INTO Go Up" is entirely wrong. Melody was given to both groups, they wrote their own different lyrics. Difference is, GO UP was RELEASED.
It’s better to have SB19’S version of KOREAN and make it’s first debut in korea....THAT WOULD BE AWESOMEE💙🇵🇭💙🇵🇭💙🇰🇷💙🇰🇷
I love this thank you for supporting sb19 🙏💕
oh my god daewon oh my god o my god oh my god oh my god why are you making me cry like this what the heck
I believe that whoever sang it with most impact owns the song.Thank you for singing this but SB19 owns the song.It is our flag song, it lifts our spirits, we face life with its ups and downs with this song.Together ,SB19 and A'Tin we say this is PPOP song.Thanks BNF and I wish you luck in you next endeavors in life. SB19 is PPOP Kings.
이런느낌 또 새롭네요~~~ ^^ 므슨 색깔이든 척척소화👌🏻👌🏻 멋지당
국❤대🧡트🧡롯💛맨💚 이대원 💜화이팅!!
Great voice! 💙 Great performance
저는 이 노래를 좋아해요.
저도 에스비19을 지지해요. 파이팅!
Excuse me sir I think your misleading. GO UP is already released and originally wrote by Sejun the pinuno and helped by the group. Stan Talent, Stand SB19. Thank you.
Am i the only one na nageenjoy hahahaha so cute ,siguro nasanay lng ako sa go up kaya habang nakikinig ako bigla akong nagpapago up hahahaha 💙💙💙💙💙💙💙
Nabobo ako sa Galawan ng Showbt! Pwede ko ba kayo murahin with all of my heart?
From my own understanding, basing from the music k-drama's I've watched. The melody was one of the demo songs that BNF has had to choose from but it wasn't their or their companies choice tis why the melody was kept and luckily it was given to SB19 tis why Go Up was created.
Yes you are correct Sejun wrote the lyrics. he just use the melody or music of Beautiful Love.
와 갑자기 아이돌 같애 아이돌같으니깐 해외사람들 개많이오네 ㅋㅋㅋㅋ
와 노래 시작할 때 너무 예뻐서 소리질렀어요😍 초커라니 완전 아이돌미 뿜뿜💜 노래는 뭐 말할 것도 없이 잘 부르는 우리 오빠, 오늘 무슨일이에요 진짜 브이로그에 노래영상까지 완전 행복쓰💕
Idk what to say.😱 I just love the sb19 true version more
Kalma lang mga kapatid... BNF ba sya? Under showbt rin sila, yaan nyo sya magkaiba sila ng message.. and baka mali lang ng translate or nagamit na word sa subtitle... but I think the beat of the music fits an inspirational song than a love song or whatsoever... glad that SB19 and tatang robin released this song... the message is really inspiring and the beat
Yes you are correct Sejun wrote the lyrics. he just use the melody or music of Beautiful Love.
Sejun made his own lyrics and yours is unreleased so technically it is SB19's song
Up
Yes you are correct Sejun wrote the lyrics. he just use the melody or music of Beautiful Love.
먹방에 이어 노래까지🥰 영상 고마워요ㅎㅎ 오빠 진짜 너무 멋있어요 💜💘 노래도 쵝오쵝오💜💜
SB19 did not recreate the song, sejun wrote the lyrics
Yes you are correct Sejun wrote the lyrics. he just use the melody or music of Beautiful Love.
Won't Grow Up Yup like most of their songs, same beat/melody
@@Adikotaku Still wrong way to put it, Sejun conceptualized and wrote the lyrics on a music composition supplied by their company just to be clear. Its not Sb19 has taken something from Bnf nor does Bnf composed their own music and was taken by SB19, its their company's
Wooow good to know 🤗🤗🤗
It is the same with Become petals of BNF and HSH of SB19
Now, Beautiful Love of BNF and Go Up of SB19.
Thank you for supporting SB19 💙
역시 대워니! 멋지다!
GO UP IS SB19...SB19 IS GO UP...THAT'S THE COMMENT!!!
Hi Lee!! Dont mind the upset fans. Me as sb19 fan understands. Im so excited for your career. Mahal ko kayo!
와우 오빠 너무 예쁘다❤️💜 노래도 역시 너무 잘 부른당!! 오빠 쵝오👍🏻👍🏻
thank u for appreciating our boys! such a wonderful sunbae! 💕캄사합니다!
Sorry to say this sr. But technically sb19 released the song first tho different lyrics but all the royalties belongs to them and to the company/music labels and that includes the melodies.. It's safe to say you're the one recreating the song 😊.
Yes you are correct Sejun wrote the lyrics. he just use the melody or music of Beautiful Love.
@@Adikotaku You keep repeating things with malice against Sejun, 😑when things is about "company supplied" music composition. The company has 2 groups one was disbanded then the company reused or used unreleased composition intended for their disbanded boy group to their new boy group which is Sb19, so Sejun a talented songwriter (yes he can compose a melody/music as well as write lyrics) conceptualized the story wrote the lyrics its not merely a translation from a korean lyrics.
Poncho Pilato darling, you’re in denial. SB19 made the lyrics for go up. True. No doubt about that. But the melody used is “beautiful love”. You’re also wrong to say that the song “beautiful love” was not released so it doesn’t exist. Hypothetical, if their group really made the melody but sb19 “stole” it then released that as their song, are you still going to say that they, who worked hard for the melody, has no rights for it? Again, that is a hypothetical scenario which is very far from the truth. Sb19 obviously didn’t stole the melody. They were given permission to use the melody. And just to hammer it down for you. If SB19 really has full rights to the song “go up” (lyrics and melody), why don’t you ask ShowBT or SB19 themselves to sue this person for using the melody of their song? 🙃 or claiming the melody of their song, for that matter? Oops I bet they can’t, right?
@@DDD-qm1nj @DwN Napaka low comprehension mo. Wag moko akusahan sa putapete mong perspective/comprehension!
BASA!!!
when things is about "company supplied" music composition. The company has 2 groups one was disbanded then the company reused (kundi ka low comprehension indirectly meant ko na diyan from whole sentence thought with reused ay "released") or used unreleased composition intended for their disbanded boy group to their new boy group which is Sb19, so Sejun a talented songwriter (yes he can compose a melody/music as well as write lyrics) conceptualized the story wrote the lyrics its not merely a translation from a korean lyrics. (Hindi translation ng korean lyrics nor story na sinulat ng BNF)
Poncho Pilato darling, you’re in denial. SB19 made the lyrics for go up. True. No doubt about that. But the melody used is “beautiful love”. (sinabi ko bang hindi? sabi ko nga yung kumpanya reused released at unreleased sa other boy group nila which is SB19) You’re also wrong to say that the song “beautiful love” was not released so it doesn’t exist. (obab 2 ginamit ko na term released at unreleased dahil HSH melody ay released na under BNF while yung Go up melody hindi na released dahil nadisband na ang BNF. Infact yung HSH tuwing kinakanta ng SB19 pinapakita yung MV ng BNF) Hypothetical, if their group really made the melody but sb19 “stole” it then released that as their song, are you still going to say that they, who worked hard for the melody, has no rights for it? (fyi hindi BNF ang gumawa ng melody kundi Realbros ang kumpanya na Showbt bumili para ipagamit sa boygroups nila) Again, that is a hypothetical scenario which is very far from the truth. Sb19 obviously didn’t stole the melody. (Ako ba nag akusa? Etong BNF member nagsabi nirecreate ng Sb19 yung song nila, iyan nga ang misplaced mistulang tinatanggalan ng kredito ang Sb19 kaya ang opinyon ko di dapat ganyan palabasin kung may issue man eto ay dahil sa desisyon ng kumpanya na gamitin muli yung melody/music composition when assigned at naka buo na pala sila ng released at finished ready to be released under sa una nilang boy group kaya ngayon eto nag claim na nirecreate yung kanilang kanta) They were given permission to use the melody (Ayan nga eh ikaw lang din naman nagsabi na kinuha nila pag aari ng BNF dahil low confused comprehension mo ) And just to hammer it down for you. If SB19 really has full rights to the song “go up” (lyrics and melody), why don’t you ask ShowBT or SB19 themselves to sue this person for using the melody of their song? 🙃 (Yung kumpanya may full rights sila naghire ng music composer/writer, sila bumili sa komposisyon kanila yun sila nagbigay sa talented boy groups nila na ininvolve nila sa paggawa pagsulat ng istorya ng kanta/lyrics, aniya ng iba yung BNF din sumusulat ng lyrics nila same sa Sb19' ang sa Sb19 ay lyrics at choreo given na pahintulot dahil empleyado under sila ng kumpanya ikaw lang naman low comprehension na tingin mo may iniissue o issue pa iyan) or claiming the melody of their song, for that matter? Oops I bet they can’t, right
Ooops Ang sakit sa ulo ng kaepalan mo mi basic fact about sa topic hindi mo alam comprehended, sakin mo pinamukha sa pag akusa sisihin mo ko ng bagay na hindi ko pinaka-hulugan. Ayan ang totoong hammer o minaso talaga 🔨 baka ikaw pa mag indenial at patuloy pumutak magpapampam dahil nahurt ka ng binalik sayo, mahiya ka naman.
@@DDD-qm1nj you know what? Ang dami mong sinabi? Ang point lng naman eh, give credit where credit is due.. The subtitle was obviously mean them owning the entire song (including melody) which is btw created by real bros. Then labelling sb19 as the one who recreate the song? A song includes melody and lyrics, but melody is the only part of the song that was given to Sb19 which is uulitin ko created by real bros not them. So basically sb19 didn't recreate anything from them. They created their original song using a unreleased melody owned by the company not BNF.
If sbt let them upload this video then why they will sue him? Wala naman akong problem dun.. The subtitle was my only problem since it will cause misunderstanding from the casual viewers.
Hindi namin kailangan ng korean version nyan...Go Up at SB19 lang sapat na samin sobra sobra pa nga...
SB19 fans! Lee Dae-won posted a video to cheer for junior singers, so I hope you enjoy it.😊😊
Don't get mad at him.. He might not translate the words thoroughly. He looks so happy and genuine for SB19 success. 💙💙💙
#SpreadLove
#Nohate
노래 너무 좋아요~ 오늘은 아이돌 느낌이네요🥰 어떤 장르도 다 어울리고 너무 멋지다구요~😘 오늘도 응원합니다💜❤
A'TIN, PLEASE CALM DOWN, OKEY?, LET'S JUST WAIT FOR THE ANSWER FROM SONY OR SHOWBT 💙
maybe what he meant by "recreated the song" yes sejun wrote the lyrics but the instrumental used is for beautiful love? like the one in hanggang sa huli and become petals has the same instrumental but different lyrics right? please A'tin do not spread hate! only love! ❤❤
Well, it was mentioned by Esbi in one of their videos kamakailan lang na may cheesy Tagalog lyrics na sana yung Go Up but then they decided to change it and write their story instead. In this sense, recreated na nga ang Go Up.
But technically speaking it is not. Sb19 Go up released first and was already licensed by SONY. So recreated will never be the word. BNF version should be the term used.
Their version using the tune of Go Up is not even realeased. So it is not official, and it will never be.
@@engr.j2261 You didn't get what I meant. "Recreated" as in "SB19 recreated their (SB19's) own song from a pop love song to an inspirational love song". The point being SB19 already started the tagalog love song lyrics but scrapped it/recreated it into an inspiring song instead.
Regardless I really don't get why we have to nitpick this and make it grow into an issue. BNF and SB19 are sibling groups under the same company and it's the company that gave the same instrumentals for both groups to work with, same with Kkonipidwaeyo and HSH. What's the point of making this chaotic? A'TIN will just become a toxic fandom instead of an understanding fandom at this rate. If we're really trying yo nitpick here, I'm pretty sure it all boils down to grammar and diction in which case the use of the word "recreated" again becomes valid due to how I described it earlier. It's all just a problem of context.
I really don't see the issue. Sejun is OFFICIALLY credited for the lyrics so ano pang pinaglalaban natin dito? Anong gusto nating mangyari? Can't we just appreciate sunbae for remembering SB19? Sa mga old videos ng BNF, supportive pa ang A'TIN, bakit ganito ngayon? Is this because maraming new A'TIN who aren't properly informed? Or has the A'TIN fandom grown too toxic?
@@engr.j2261 yah recreated was not the right term for me, esbi released Go Up under SONY's license so recreated was a triggering part
Hello senior hahaha thanks for singing go up
although i didn't know the lyrics its make me dance and sing along hehehehe
I'll give you the benefit of the doubt. I understand English is not your first language. I would say VERSION instead of recreating. The music was given to them but the lyrics were written by the members. So it is safe to say, you have your own version of that song, SB19 has its own version of the song .
Hoy A'TIN.. tama na.. same company naman.. be open minded naman.. #ProtectSB19atAllCost.. ahhaha.. sge lang.. hintayin nalang natin yung statement ng SBT 😇😇💙
이렇게 다 잘하면 어똫게해요! 완전 아이돌이에요. 아이돌!! 정~~~말 멋있어요 💜💜💜💜
Aytsss Sana hndi na Ito pinost para hndi Sana nag magulo😣
We'll for me, it doesn't really matter. SB19 have proven themselves already that's why they have A'tin, they really dont have to explain anything to those who believe in them. Other people might say something about this but they are the ones who are just waiting for SB19 to mess up and this is the perfect opportunity for them. A'tin I know you are all affected but we should focus more on SB19, they need us now more than ever. By keep digging on things like this, it will only have a negative effect on SB19 as well as A'tin. This is already a slap on the face for our boys, this is their redemption song and there's no better meaning or lyrics for it. Periodt!
Now close the door and don't let negativity enter!
💜 대원님~!! 랩까지 잘하시면 .... 너무 멋있어요~ 💜 우째 대원님은 날이 갈수로 나이가 거꾸로 가는 듯? 💜
완전 아이돌!!뭐든 다 잘어울리는 대원님 짱👍
항상 응원합니댕댕💜 오늘은 행복day!!!
Calm down A'TIN.💙💙💙
Eto siguro yung kinukwento ni sejun na go up tapos about sa ganda nung girl na hindi na kailangan maglagay pa ng make up yeah hahahhaa
A'tin calm down remember yung kwento about Go Up na dapat love song for a girl pero ginawa na lng nila about their hardwork at pinagdaanan nila sana naalala nio okay
Naalala ko yun💙💙💙
Naalala ko din to kapatid. Sadyang mali lang yung ginamit niya na term kaya nahahype ang *A'tin* misleading rin kasi yung sinabi niya or baka yung translation niya.
nakakabastos sa nag compose haha. it's their story. please do respect :)
A'tin kalma muna tayooo baka mistranslated lang, baka di talaga ganon yung gusto niyang sabihin kaya pls di matutuwa ang boys pag nalaman nila na ganto tayo makitungo. Just saying lang po. Pls no hate, just spread love saka sabi ni pinuno diba "always choose to be kind" Alab you alll co-a'tin💙
역시 짱이네요 밥먹다 깜짝놀래서요 멋진대원씨 항상 응원합니다 👏👏👏👏👏
please have subtitle of lyrics~ thank you BNF leader for sharing another version of Go Up!
It’s been a few months when this was uploaded on YT, but I’m still wondering on what this guy’s ulterior motives are in uploading this shelved version of his defunct group’s song.
잘보고갑니당~~ 노래잘부르세용~~!!항상 코로나조심하세용~~
항상 응원해용💜💜 멋진 활동 하길 바래욘💜💙💜
I was excited when SB19 official posted that BNF Daewon will have his cover of go up but then here's what I saw, him saying that the boys recreated the song. Sejun wrote it by himself maybe the company gave them the same melody that's why pareho sila. But it's not recreated they just received the same melody from the company. ShowBT should give clear explanation abt this statement.
#SB19HanggangSaHuli💙
#ProtectTheBoysAtAllCost
울가수님 못하는게 뭐지~안 어울리는게 뭐지 모든 노래 소화력 짱~꼭 있어야할 가수님 ~눈호강 합니다~이대원 매력속으로~^-^
Sino A'tin dito.. Naalala nyu ba yung Go up na Love song Sana Yun..
Di mo na kailangan mag make up pa yeah 🎶🎶.. Dba Yun Sabi pinuno.m
True! Yan din naisip ko
If sejun recreated this why would he claims that he wrote the song? And if he recreated this song why would he make "Go Up" and this " beautiful love" very the same beat?
It's very impossible! SB19 ARE TALENTED THEY WROTE GO UP..!!
Yes you are correct Sejun wrote the lyrics. he just use the melody or music of Beautiful Love.
@@Adikotaku @Won't Grow Up You keep repeating things with malice against Sejun, 😑when things is about "company supplied" music composition. The company has 2 groups one was disbanded then the company reused or used unreleased composition intended for their disbanded boy group to their new boy group which is Sb19, so Sejun a talented songwriter (yes he can compose a melody/music as well as write lyrics) conceptualized the story wrote the lyrics its not merely a translation from a korean lyrics and story.
@@davidkrappenschitz4753 lol! I said Sejun use the melody of beautiful love and yes sujun wrote the lyrics. OMG! Lyrics and melody is tow different thing. lol!
@@Adikotaku I already highlighted about this, we don't have any confirmation yet to Showbt. But, if sejun recreated the melody not the "whole song!" I think there is nothing to worry about, sejun made and other members their own lyrics and made sence that they completely composed the lyrics not the song(melody/beats.. Lol) .
@@davidkrappenschitz4753 we shouldn't argue about this issue, we better support them instead. Let's just wait for the confirmation of the company itself if this video is fake. SPREAD LOVE ONLY A'TIN.
오늘 무슨일이에요...인스타 앨범 자켓사진에 심쿵하고 왔는데 이런 아이돌 비주얼로 노래를 하다닝...진심 너무너무 멋지다요!! 진짜루 You're my beautiful love ~💕💕💕
Nag search ako ng beatiful love na kanta pero wala namng lumabas na kaparehas ng kinanta nya yan lang baka sb talaga nauna🤔
Hi we just need clarification, did you really mean that SB19 recreated this song? Kindly clarify, because from what we've kwnown the lyrics of SB19's Go Up is wrote by their leader Sejun and their song Go Up is all about their journey as a group. They just have the same melody (maybe because you're from the same company)
No hate, I just noticed that "recreated" thingy.
The song was composed by Lee Oh Won. SB19 did Go Up lyrics while BNF did Beatiful Love lyrics. Another song was composed by a Korean composer - SB19 did Hanggang sa Huli lyrics while BNF did Become Petals lyrics...BNF had already disbanded since early 2019.
Yes you are correct Sejun wrote the lyrics. he just use the melody or music of Beautiful Love.
Guys kalma lang tayo. Wag tayo padalos dalos sa sasabihin natin kasi mostly ang maaapektuhan sa issue ay ang boys natin.
DROP NYO NA DIN KUNG PATI ALAB!
LUBUSIN NYO NA SHOWBT, 6MAL
Sir, next time be careful using the RIGHT WORD or words. Filipinos are everywhere, most of them are perfectionist when it comes to English. They are mostly sensitive when they think it was inappropriate. Somehow, because of that single word (they misundertood it perhaps). But, also an eye opener for everyone. No one is perfect but we can fix this or need some clarification about this. We know what's the real score about #SB19 and we believed in them. God bless us all 💙❤️😍
Bernadette Caseñas yes I hope he clarifies this one because this is very misleading. Hopefully it's just bc of the language barrier but still doesn't change the fact that he should've been extra careful because it is posted online for everyone to see. It's his responsibility. :( I just hope this is being taken care of because I see a lot of Koreans commenting na baka ma-mislead sla if ever yun talaga yung ibig sabihin nya. :(( I think Sony can sue him din if ever na yun yung ibig nya talaga sabihin kasi ni "claim" nya eh kaya sana ma-clarify nya agad. 😐
I beg to differ. This isnt simple identification of mistaken translation. pinuno’s and SB19’s reputation is on the line here. This is good that we draw the line of whats right and wrong.
And josh in a recent twitter post but now deleted is questioning this as well.
오마나 울 댕댕이 깜짝이야 😃
정말 잘한당
신선 했어요💜✊👍
우와 bnf곡으로 리메이크라니요 ㅠㅠㅠ
이런곡이 왜 안나왓을까요 ㅠㅠㅠ 노래 너무 좋아요!!! 💕💕
Guyssss!! Stream ikako!!
Road to 1M!!!!
Bago mag talk and talk make sure alam po ang story behind that song. Love Song ang original Go Up... binago "nirecreate " nila ginawang inspirational nirelate sa buhay nila ng SB19 kaya naging Go Up. Alam ito ng mga totoong A'tin kasi napanood mismo nila kong ano ang sinabi ni Sejun about sa story ng Go Up.
Totoo po kuya, medyo nakakahiya rin sa artist na 'to huhu andaming nagkalat😣
역쉬~울아이돌 이대원
넘멋있옹~💜😍👍🏻
넘이뿌댕~
오늘도잘자고 챔밤😍
🥰🥰🥰😘💙💙💙💙💙
ShowBT and Sony waiting for your Official Statement about this. I'm not demanding but I guess A'TIN really wants to know the whole story bout this.
Recreated (Merriam-Webster)
1. Past Tense of Recreate
2. To give NEW life or freshness to
3. To create AGAIN
So now Sir, with all due respect, was Beautiful Love officially realeased before SB19? To have the License just like how SB19 and Sony have right now which is very much evident in you video?
So, I don't think the word RECREATED is the proper one for this.
If you said that word to Hanggang sa Huli (Becoming Petals) I may not argue with you since you released it first.
But give credit to these people. It may have given to your group before hand but the fact that it was not released, then I don't think you can claim as the originator of it...
Just my opinion. I do make poems, and i do have to register my poem in order to have the copyright to it. And if any case, my poem was registered by somebody else (for any other reason and situation) before me I will lose the ownership of it...
#RespectBegetsRespect
#JustSaying
#MyOpinion
LarrianLarrios1447 darling, you’re in denial. SB19 made the lyrics for go up. True. No doubt about that. But the melody used is “beautiful love”. You’re also wrong to say that the song “beautiful love” was not released so it doesn’t exist. Hypothetical, if their group really made the melody but sb19 “stole” it then released that as their song, are you still going to say that they, who worked hard for the melody, has no rights for it? Again, that is a hypothetical scenario which is very far from the truth. Sb19 obviously didn’t stole the melody. They were given permission to use the melody. And just to hammer it down for you. If SB19 really has full rights to the song “go up” (lyrics and melody), why don’t you ask ShowBT or SB19 themselves to sue this person for using the melody of their song? 🙃 or claiming the melody of their song, for that matter? Oops I bet they can’t, right?
@@DDD-qm1nj thank you for your opinion. You have yours, I have mine. I respect yours. I won't impose you to respect mine, but that is solely your decision. Have a nice and fruitful day(s). God Bless!