The presentation suffers from a failure to recognise that 'subaltern' is a loose term and needs to be defined - especially in this case where it should be problematised.
hey Bob! the entire presentation addresses the issue you raise -- were you sleeping? Just some examples: 7:00 "subaltern - borrowed from Gramsci's idea of subalternity" 8:00 "critique of subaltern history" 8:40 "subaltern" or oppressed subject" -- term subsumes hierarchies and complexities unfamiliar to 'subaltern' Western discourses Recommendation: listen again and study the references. Bonus prize: abahlali.org/files/Can_the_subaltern_speak.pdf
@@martimartini8400 None of those relate in any way to the point I raised - I assume your link goes to an essay by Spivak which is worthless for the point I raised (and is such a well known piece it shows a lack of familiarity on your part that you would think it would be news to anyone commenting on a video like this).
This Has to be one of the best reviews of Spivaks Work. You are an excellent,excellent,excellent teacher. Excellent.
The ending quote is a disservice to Spivak and misplaced.
Hey your description is very nice . Can you help me by giving an eg that how and in what ways western thinkers are essentialising subalterns ?
An exhaustive interpretation on Spivak's theory.
Brilliant, so helpful!
Ma'am you are amazing with knowledge, but if you slow down bit that will be glitter to what you effort for...
really helpful ❤️
fantastic video
Great Video!
Content is good, but speaking too fast. If you can just slow up the speed will be great.
Reading newspaper
How feminism is too male identified ?
Paper reading makes it monotonous
The presentation suffers from a failure to recognise that 'subaltern' is a loose term and needs to be defined - especially in this case where it should be problematised.
hey Bob! the entire presentation addresses the issue you raise -- were you sleeping?
Just some examples:
7:00 "subaltern - borrowed from Gramsci's idea of subalternity"
8:00 "critique of subaltern history"
8:40 "subaltern" or oppressed subject" -- term subsumes hierarchies and complexities unfamiliar to 'subaltern' Western discourses
Recommendation: listen again and study the references.
Bonus prize: abahlali.org/files/Can_the_subaltern_speak.pdf
@@martimartini8400 None of those relate in any way to the point I raised - I assume your link goes to an essay by Spivak which is worthless for the point I raised (and is such a well known piece it shows a lack of familiarity on your part that you would think it would be news to anyone commenting on a video like this).
If only you could reduce the speed of reading. You speak too fast!
0.75 speed
I think she is speaking, not reading!
@@user-ho1vt8vz2l No she is not! I am the one who edited this video. I am amused with your claim though!
Dileep Menon if you edited, then you can't 'think' she was speaking.
This video was made for Robot.
Your fast reading makes this video very awaful... Looks as if someone is making popcorn. Kindly slow your speed ma'am.