Agreed. I've looked at a number of different Agent packages. VRSEN's work is the only project I've seen which contains code that I felt like I had a real chance of actually understanding and using, and doesn't look exclusively like a pitch for investment money.
I think other RUclipsrs are bored and post all these other codes, thank you for actually improving and building for production and not all these snake games everyone loves 😂
The quality and quantity of your kick ass videos are a demonstration that Agency Swarm works… how on earth would you have time for all that otherwise? Thanks for these high quality videos! ❤👏
dude you are the original, so happy to have such experienced expert as part of the community, lately seems a lot of bullshit is happening with those AI models, so happy to have you again for opening our eyes :)
Thinking between gpt pilot and this which to adopt. Love that open source is taking over and there is so much choice now. Will test your solution over the weekend!
I wonder what the biggest project is that has been written entirely by agents. So far I've only seen small projects like a snake clone or game of life like in this video. But I'm really curious how these agents scale to bigger projects, stuff that you would normally build with a team over the course of a year or more. Anyone know of someone who's working on this?
Since vison is available on the assistants API now when do you think you'll have an update? There are some interesting approaches here. I only wish the gradio UI wasn't required to interact with the agent. solid work!
Have you evaluated using some of the most recent open source models to power your agentic framework? Mixtral 8x7B or Mixtral 8x22B, DBRX or similar models? Thanks for sharing your project with the world!
I love it. This is why I subscribe! You pointed out that Devin lacks the "fully" agentic ability -- with their continued prompts and lengthy time to build, per time stamp! Nice! But what was the issue with OpenAI API for retrieval? The laziness sucks. I get it. What about using Claude instead?
One of the best channel for ai learning, so much value in your videos thanks for the quality content. Question : why arent you using Crew Ai as your agents framework ? Their tools are quite good and oss ?
He did address the limitations of CrewAI, as well as AutoGen, in the video about his framework. It was only a couple of videos ago if you want to look for it.
As Andrew Ng said LDB+Reflexion brought gpt3.5 from 48% to 95%, what kind are you implementing here? I hope you'll continue developing this even for local LLM, llama3 will be available at the end of May, and in conjunction with this, it would be like almost a real engineer.
Hey, I was able to get it to work, my question is what is the difference between Agency-Swarm-Lab, and your other Agency-Swarm ? Also, where can I learn more to build my own ai agents swarm?
I see the file thing but does this mean chat with docs like csv files or just files it provides you with? Can never find one that can actually use the spreadsheet you give them and fix the errors by trying the sample document you gave them? It always thinks it complete and you have to repeat the errors making it no better then gpt
Very cool. Thanks for posting! Any plans to add multiple LLM support? Including local LLM and Claude/Gemini specifically. Btw, looks like the latest model and api update from OpenAI allows vision, I haven’t tested yet. Cheers!
It seems heavily dependent on the Assistants API and its tools for file retrieval. But if I had to guess, his abstractions here probably leave room for future implementation of RAG without OpenAI dependencies.
@@avi7278 True, we could use LLAMAIndex or Langchain for RAG and then use it with them with Devid as Tools. Using Python's automated Prefect library would be magically
@@TheGenerationGapPodcast i got my system to read files interpret whats there relevant to a prompt and then continue writing in a completely new session till finished! This is fine as is as long as it works similar to his system on an open llm its done
congrats on continued work to give control to devs on implementing these projects that dont rely on langchain/lama - both of which which are a pain in production tbh
any plans to support local llms using something like lm-studio with their api? they now support embeddings endpoint so can handle retrieval and everything all locally
Brilliant! Sysreq? And can it be taught a different language? Fit example, if I give Devid a url to the instruction page(s) for hyperapp js (a strange one, I know) will it learn the language's methods?
i wish i understood what you was doing cause i installed docker but idk how to get the agent swarm lab to run on it and the program you using don't look like either github or docker so now im really confused.
Designing products like this, stop relying on OpenAI API, start using open-source models. I appreciate you open sourcing it though so it can be easily updated to use open source models.
@@TheRealUsername Correction, use the best open source model. Stop relying on these big corporations. They harvest your data. I would never use OpenAi/Anthropic/Groq api in a production environment as your putting that companies data at risk.
At the end some idea came up. You update the manifesto in the end to adjust. But if you add an extra agent, which will update the manifesto so the next time it will auto adjust. Must be possible right? Seems pretty cool, if an error occurs because of not detailed enough prompting it will add the fix to to prompt so it teaches itself.
You need to make this much easier to install, you are making a code assistant for many people who don't understand code. the process is confusing and tedious
This better work. I just watched that dude (Internet of Bugs) debunk that Devin program.🙄😆 Scott Wu needs to get jumped in the parking LOL. He up here acting like he's a genius
Hey VRSEN, massive fan of your content. Really appreciationg what you do. When trying to replicate the project on my local machine i got the problem, that the agency.py file can't find the agency_swarm file to import Agency from it. Since i've seen the open issues with no comments and no status on them i thought i'll ask here to find out how i could fix it. I tried pip install agency-swarm from my agency folder but to no avail. Hope you keep up the good work and again thank you for the golden content and projects you provide us with.
@@vrsen Yes please, I love agency SWARM, but I can't base an architecture on Openai's Assistants'Agents, Openai specially is lazy at coding, but nobody wants to do that for more reasons, their quality is lowering, their prices are high and nobody knows what they do with the data, did I mentioned it's hyper-woke?.
Indian engineer two weeks from now: “Hey everyone, today we are releasing Devender” Korean engineer next month: “Annyeong everyone, today we have released Daeyoon”
Has anyone used it with frameworks like Refine JS? It would be great to know that it can stick to a certain framework and have content awareness of the entire protect built with it.
Thanks for showing what you are doing. No need to bash Devin though. It causes a weird vibe and does not generate any value for your viewers, at least for me.
Word of advice. Don’t shit on other tools. Just focus on what makes yours great. It sends a message that your ego drives development which sends a message of instability and lack of respect for devs. Which all of us are. You gotta be careful about the tone of your messaging when you’re actually launching products.
@@arteast8146 The beginning of the video 0:00 to 0:35 and 3:30 to 5:10. What he said might be completely valid, and he has the right to say that. But project launch showcase, should showcase your project, and not consist of disrespecting project from another team that is still being developed.
He didn't lie. Devin has already been debunked and proven to not be as reliable or "disruptive" as it was presented. I don't think it's bad to talk smack on a developer that intentionally used misleading and misrepresented marketing materials to build up hype to squeeze more money from investors. I also don't think I trust a closed platform from a developer that chooses such a shady way to conduct business. At least this guy was super transparent and walked us through a true demo.
@@laycookie-f6i I know bro, the original comment said it's not good form or proper to talk smack on projects being developed by other companies. However, my point is, if the other developer is being intentionally misleading in their product demo for hype, then they're unethical and it's open season on criticism. The dev of Devin straight up lied about the capabilities of his product. So I see nothing wrong with bashing the product because it is what it is.
Hi All, be careful. My API usage suddenly shot up beyond $150. The account was recharged multiple times. *****Now sure what happened here but I was not running the script as it was being recharged*****. I ran a single query. There is no way that a single query should cost $150!
4:45 You mention how long devin takes. Devin doesn't take 2 hours to complete the task. It only took about 30 minutes to set up the training and complete the initial 30 epochs. Then the user checks back later and the training is on epoch 404. I love that you're doing all this open source for the community, but if your going criticize others work please try to be accurate.
![Kumamoto Masters Japan 2024 | Gregoria Mariska Tunjung (INA) [5] vs. Akane Yamaguchi (JPN) [2] | F](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/EIjZybhsWqA/mqdefault.jpg)
VRSEN is the most exciting project in this space
Watch me automate myself out of the job
@@vrsen God
Agreed. I've looked at a number of different Agent packages. VRSEN's work is the only project I've seen which contains code that I felt like I had a real chance of actually understanding and using, and doesn't look exclusively like a pitch for investment money.
@@petrus4 bingo!! That time stamp callout was classic 🤣
@@vrsen epic answer :)))
I think other RUclipsrs are bored and post all these other codes, thank you for actually improving and building for production and not all these snake games everyone loves 😂
Thanks 😎
The quality and quantity of your kick ass videos are a demonstration that Agency Swarm works… how on earth would you have time for all that otherwise? Thanks for these high quality videos! ❤👏
dude you are the original, so happy to have such experienced expert as part of the community, lately seems a lot of bullshit is happening with those AI models, so happy to have you again for opening our eyes :)
People are sleeping on this channel and from what I can tell you are the real deal. Devid is awesome!
This is a no BS channel. Great content every single time 🙏🏿🙏🏿🙏🏿
I would really love to see a pre-defined vendor and model selector like selecting to use Groq or ollama and the respective models of them
Cant wait for the addition of being able to use a local llm. Open ai gets enough money lol.
That would require an open source llm to reach chatgtp levels of capability and efficiency, it's what enables the agents to be... well... agents.
You're not getting enough respect my man. Love watching your videos
Thinking between gpt pilot and this which to adopt. Love that open source is taking over and there is so much choice now. Will test your solution over the weekend!
This is very impressive. Original ideas, excellent execution.
Arsen can you give us the AI enthusiasts the luxury of having you in an interview with David Ondrejf or his podcast?
Sure if he’s down
Slavic roots say hello ! I shake your hand firmly ! your research is great ! we are waiting for new videos !
I wonder what the biggest project is that has been written entirely by agents. So far I've only seen small projects like a snake clone or game of life like in this video. But I'm really curious how these agents scale to bigger projects, stuff that you would normally build with a team over the course of a year or more. Anyone know of someone who's working on this?
Brazil here. Fantástico. Gratidão eterna por essa ferramenta maravilhosa. Desejo todo sucesso do mundo meu amigo.
Conseguiu fazer rodar? Abs
Deu boa pra rodar man?
Since vison is available on the assistants API now when do you think you'll have an update? There are some interesting approaches here. I only wish the gradio UI wasn't required to interact with the agent. solid work!
Have you evaluated using some of the most recent open source models to power your agentic framework? Mixtral 8x7B or Mixtral 8x22B, DBRX or similar models? Thanks for sharing your project with the world!
Implement RAG functionality as an independent module then add it as a Tool. In that way, microservices architecture can be implemented.
additionally having the RAG capability on curated documents and examples would have been wonderful!
I love it. This is why I subscribe! You pointed out that Devin lacks the "fully" agentic ability -- with their continued prompts and lengthy time to build, per time stamp! Nice! But what was the issue with OpenAI API for retrieval? The laziness sucks. I get it. What about using Claude instead?
Thanks so much for that amazing walkthrough, can't wait to try Devid!
Very cool! Looking forward to rewatching, following the steps, and trying it out for myself. Great!!!
One of the best channel for ai learning, so much value in your videos thanks for the quality content.
Question : why arent you using Crew Ai as your agents framework ? Their tools are quite good and oss ?
He did address the limitations of CrewAI, as well as AutoGen, in the video about his framework. It was only a couple of videos ago if you want to look for it.
@@brianWreaves Thank Brian, i'll definnitely look fort it
I can't tell you how much I appreciate this, thank you very much!
Great abstractions and even better explanations!
The thumbnail cover image is gangster tho 😎🤣 I see what you did there 😂
Awesome again. Now if we can only get this to work without relying on open ai nonsense it'd be great. Would love to see the ability to use local llms
As Andrew Ng said LDB+Reflexion brought gpt3.5 from 48% to 95%, what kind are you implementing here?
I hope you'll continue developing this even for local LLM, llama3 will be available at the end of May, and in conjunction with this, it would be like almost a real engineer.
thanks man for you fantastic work, from now i will follow you ...thanks again .sharing is caring
Hey, I was able to get it to work, my question is what is the difference between Agency-Swarm-Lab, and your other Agency-Swarm ? Also, where can I learn more to build my own ai agents swarm?
I see the file thing but does this mean chat with docs like csv files or just files it provides you with?
Can never find one that can actually use the spreadsheet you give them and fix the errors by trying the sample document you gave them? It always thinks it complete and you have to repeat the errors making it no better then gpt
Very cool. Thanks for posting!
Any plans to add multiple LLM support? Including local LLM and Claude/Gemini specifically.
Btw, looks like the latest model and api update from OpenAI allows vision, I haven’t tested yet. Cheers!
It seems heavily dependent on the Assistants API and its tools for file retrieval. But if I had to guess, his abstractions here probably leave room for future implementation of RAG without OpenAI dependencies.
@@avi7278 True, we could use LLAMAIndex or Langchain for RAG and then use it with them with Devid as Tools. Using Python's automated Prefect library would be magically
@@TheGenerationGapPodcast i got my system to read files interpret whats there relevant to a prompt and then continue writing in a completely new session till finished! This is fine as is as long as it works similar to his system on an open llm its done
congrats on continued work to give control to devs on implementing these projects that dont rely on langchain/lama - both of which which are a pain in production tbh
any plans to support local llms using something like lm-studio with their api? they now support embeddings endpoint so can handle retrieval and everything all locally
@vrsen Please let us know your plans for local llm
What code editor are you using?
Where is the Set-up tutorial so I can get this on my Local Host?
did you solve that? I have trouble to run this on my local host.
do I need to rebuild the docker container again the next time I enter? Or do I just run python agency.py straight away?
yeah buddy! addicted to slanina and ai agents. subscribed
Such a cool project! Love it ❤️❤️❤️
Brilliant! Sysreq? And can it be taught a different language? Fit example, if I give Devid a url to the instruction page(s) for hyperapp js (a strange one, I know) will it learn the language's methods?
This is so sick. Thanks!
Nice I will use this to perfect my coding skills.
i wish i understood what you was doing cause i installed docker but idk how to get the agent swarm lab to run on it and the program you using don't look like either github or docker so now im really confused.
Designing products like this, stop relying on OpenAI API, start using open-source models. I appreciate you open sourcing it though so it can be easily updated to use open source models.
No, Claude 3 API instead, you should use the best model available.
@@TheRealUsername Correction, use the best open source model. Stop relying on these big corporations. They harvest your data. I would never use OpenAi/Anthropic/Groq api in a production environment as your putting that companies data at risk.
At the end some idea came up. You update the manifesto in the end to adjust. But if you add an extra agent, which will update the manifesto so the next time it will auto adjust. Must be possible right?
Seems pretty cool, if an error occurs because of not detailed enough prompting it will add the fix to to prompt so it teaches itself.
So everytime you run it, it will improve itself. Feels so cool 😊
Thanks for your contribution to the knowledge of this earth!
@vrsen did you consider adding a web GUI or any GUI to Agency Swarm Lab it could sky rocket the project
what about genesis i put agency-swarm genesis it say may be want open ai key or something because it give me error
Keep it going, a lot of improvements can be done. Manual steps are not an option, as you understand.
you my friend will be a co author, thank you so much
if someone is able to make this thing works with llama locally without relying on any API thats going to be a game changer .
Hey man, pretty cool channel. Just subscribed!
You need to make this much easier to install, you are making a code assistant for many people who don't understand code. the process is confusing and tedious
This better work.
I just watched that dude (Internet of Bugs) debunk that Devin program.🙄😆
Scott Wu needs to get jumped in the parking LOL.
He up here acting like he's a genius
Hey VRSEN, massive fan of your content. Really appreciationg what you do.
When trying to replicate the project on my local machine i got the problem, that the agency.py file can't find the agency_swarm file to import Agency from it. Since i've seen the open issues with no comments and no status on them i thought i'll ask here to find out how i could fix it. I tried pip install agency-swarm from my agency folder but to no avail.
Hope you keep up the good work and again thank you for the golden content and projects you provide us with.
Devin, Devika, now Devid 😢 I think it's time we find this folks wives. Watch out for Devisha
Calling out git, shots fired
Great content was wondering if we can replace open ai key with other providers or giving a endpoint from ollama. Is this possible?
Claude streaming for Sonnet & Opus seems to be something that can be used, I found it is mire intelligent than OpenAI
While it might not be necessary to view the browser window It could be very useful when trouble shooting.
Installed Devika and it sucks. Is this better?
For sure. You can customize it in all ways
VRSEN is goat ❤️. If you happen to launch a company please I’m not rich but I want to buy some shares 😂
Could it handle dataset of node.js and react.js application?
Can we get a groq mistral/mixtral api to run this?
Datastax recently released open source assistants api implementation, I will be testing it next week
@@vrsen Yes please, I love agency SWARM, but I can't base an architecture on Openai's Assistants'Agents, Openai specially is lazy at coding, but nobody wants to do that for more reasons, their quality is lowering, their prices are high and nobody knows what they do with the data, did I mentioned it's hyper-woke?.
Got it
can we integrate groq? instead of openai
Did you try?
@@TheGenerationGapPodcast yep and it’s working, it’s similar to openai endpoint
What have you made with this agents stuff
Indian engineer two weeks from now: “Hey everyone, today we are releasing Devender”
Korean engineer next month: “Annyeong everyone, today we have released Daeyoon”
Silicon Valley spends millions to create Devin, Vren creates something 10x better with his bare hands. I'm here for this
Has anyone used it with frameworks like Refine JS? It would be great to know that it can stick to a certain framework and have content awareness of the entire protect built with it.
Devid dude I love it. Totally agree, way to stick it to them. Devin is such a d ..... Bag.
Is it like
Is it free?Is it open source?Is it linked to specific countries, such as? ديفينوب
How does it perform in SWE-Bench?
Can you use Wizard LLM instead?
As always, amazing, thanks.
Add support google germini pro 1.5 for increased context of the whole project files
You got one subscriber sir!
Does it work in Linux?
which editor do you use?
IntelliJ Idea?
Hey man, how can I apply for a job with your agency?
In discord!
@@vrsen just joined!
Why do you share such gold all the time :O
Same question here haha
I wouldn't want to do anything else in the world instead. I appreciate you guys being on this journey with me.
Bro came with receipts
Dibs on Devine.
I got dibs on Devine.
Thanks for showing what you are doing. No need to bash Devin though. It causes a weird vibe and does not generate any value for your viewers, at least for me.
Devin sucks though. I dont know anyone who would use it for real prod code.
OUTSTANDING(!)
cold sniper killer.
Hi VRSEN ❤ I'm also an ai developer, let me know if you like to collab! All the best!
I must be dumb -- what would you actually use this for?
Word of advice. Don’t shit on other tools. Just focus on what makes yours great. It sends a message that your ego drives development which sends a message of instability and lack of respect for devs. Which all of us are. You gotta be careful about the tone of your messaging when you’re actually launching products.
Could u give example/timestamp of criticism towards devs community in this video?
@@arteast8146 The beginning of the video 0:00 to 0:35 and 3:30 to 5:10.
What he said might be completely valid, and he has the right to say that. But project launch showcase, should showcase your project, and not consist of disrespecting project from another team that is still being developed.
He didn't lie. Devin has already been debunked and proven to not be as reliable or "disruptive" as it was presented.
I don't think it's bad to talk smack on a developer that intentionally used misleading and misrepresented marketing materials to build up hype to squeeze more money from investors. I also don't think I trust a closed platform from a developer that chooses such a shady way to conduct business.
At least this guy was super transparent and walked us through a true demo.
@@NoCodeFilmmaker No one ever said that he lied you are missing the point
@@laycookie-f6i I know bro, the original comment said it's not good form or proper to talk smack on projects being developed by other companies. However, my point is, if the other developer is being intentionally misleading in their product demo for hype, then they're unethical and it's open season on criticism. The dev of Devin straight up lied about the capabilities of his product. So I see nothing wrong with bashing the product because it is what it is.
Hi,
Please create a vscode plugin.
And, it would be great if it can scan / Index folders and files and optimize databases.
👍
Thanks.
Devin is cooked here.
Hi All, be careful. My API usage suddenly shot up beyond $150. The account was recharged multiple times. *****Now sure what happened here but I was not running the script as it was being recharged*****. I ran a single query. There is no way that a single query should cost $150!
Phenomenal
do it again in LLAMA 3
Cheekii bureekie
4:45 You mention how long devin takes. Devin doesn't take 2 hours to complete the task. It only took about 30 minutes to set up the training and complete the initial 30 epochs. Then the user checks back later and the training is on epoch 404.
I love that you're doing all this open source for the community, but if your going criticize others work please try to be accurate.
AWESOME
nice. just sub. will be trying it out asap
This is really amazing stuff, but I burned almost 50€ in one day of openai fees without success;(
That is the reason for this sales pitch of a program. This is just OpenAI trying to lure more users in to their failing company.
Thought this guy is AI avatar
Красава!
nice job